31/10/22, 20:01 Nostalgia and Radicalization - European Eye on Radicalization

   ‫عربي‬ Fr Es 

Home About Us  Analysis Opinion Pieces  Reports Reading Radicalization Events 

Interviews Videos Contact

Home

Opinion Pieces

Contributors’ Opinions

Nostalgia and Radicalization

12 November 2018
in
Contributors’ Opinions, Opinion Pieces

348  Share on Facebook  Share on Twitter  

VIEWS

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie
Jan Wójcik Policy. I Agree

https://eeradicalization.com/nostalgia-and-radicalization/ 1/6
31/10/22, 20:01 Nostalgia and Radicalization - European Eye on Radicalization

Empowered Nostalgia

After losing territorial control in Syria and Iraq, Islamic State (IS) will use the nostalgia narrative as a tool for
recruitment and sustaining morale and inspiration among its supporters.

The nostalgia narrative is actually nothing new in terrorists’ communication. However, this time counter-radicalization
experts predict that it will be distinguished from other nostalgic narratives and empowered by reminding followers
that “once we had the caliphate”.

This raises two questions. First, is the narrative an essential factor to be considered in countering radicalization?
Second, or is it quite the reverse? Will focusing on it create the risk of losing clear sight of the broader picture?

Nostalgia as a Motivator

To begin with, we should remember that nostalgia is an element of every revolutionary movement, whether it refers
to some golden age in the past or a bright future, imagined in dreams. The latter is important. As movements focus
on bringing about change, even they are nostalgic for the past and hope to recreate it in the future.

Generally, jihadists’ nostalgia is broadly the same as non-violent Salafists’ and Islamists’. It is an attempt to
implement rules and a way of life described in the Qur’an and the sunnah (the teachings, sayings and actions of the
prophet of Islam, seen as a guide to life) in modern times. In this worldview, recreation of the social, ethical,
religious and political principles from the times of Muhammad and the Four Righteous Caliphs of Islam’s earliest
decades should bring glory and success to the ummah (community of believers). This kind of nostalgia, unlike “IS
nostalgia”, is common in the wider spectrum of society exposed to radicalization.

Muslims who perceive the quasi-state IS built as a fulfillment of the caliphate promise constitute a narrower group
than those who support Islam as a legal basis for the state. Thus, the appeal of “IS nostalgia” will touch fewer
potential recruits. Nonetheless, it could become an agent activating people who are already on the radicalization path.

“Every returnee from jihad brings a number of stories of fighting and glory”, writes PhD Kacper Rękawek, Head of
Defence and Security at Globsec, in his book “Man With a Small Bomb” (published only in Polish “Człowiek z małą
bombą”). This can be inspiring, as the tales come from jihad in the cause of Allah from Afghanistan, Bosnia,
Chechnya, and Somalia to Iraq and Syria.

Here we should stress the distinction between radicalization in the sphere of ideas and radicalization in the sphere of
actions. “IS nostalgia” will have more effect on radicalizing actions of people sharing extremist ideas.

Victimization and Nostalgia – Twin Sisters

The nostalgia narrative has a twin sister – victimization. The motivation to undertake any action is based on
perceptions of one’s current state and prospects for achieving improvements. Here victimization creates the negative
perception of oneself or one’s wider group as victims while nostalgia forms the view of a desired state. So, the
This website
activity, uses cookies.
dynamics and By continuing
energy to use this website
are generated not as you are giving
a result consent
of state A toorcookies
state being
B, butused.
as Visit our Privacy
a result of theand Cookie
distance
between A and B. Policy. I Agree

https://eeradicalization.com/nostalgia-and-radicalization/ 2/6
31/10/22, 20:01 Nostalgia and Radicalization - European Eye on Radicalization

This means we should not limit ourselves to combating the nostalgia narrative with various counter-narratives alone.
Instead, there is an opportunity to work with victimization as well. Twofold solutions can be proposed: changing
perceptions of the current and desired states, reducing the distance between A and B, or finding other, non-violent and
positive ways to improve the perceived situation, moving from A to B.

Some may find this debatable: do we really want to find other ways to move towards a caliphate? However, if we
think of a caliphate not as an end but as a means to realize other goals, such as justice, equality, freedom of religion,
gaining status, and so on, then this can be a partial solution. This can be implemented if we focus on social factors
such as education, social status, employment, discrimination, or crime.

But does it work when it comes to an individual’s religious perceptions? If A is one’s own perception of life and it is
miserable, sinful, or just not in line with the true meaning of the religion, B offers prospects for redemption and
paradise. In this case, the distance between these points can be reduced by religious or psychological counselling.
Other ways to repent for sins and achieve paradise should be strongly advised and propagated. That can only be done
with the cooperation and dedication of religious people.

The Limited Gains From Exposing Islamic State

If we are speaking of countering “IS nostalgia”, the question is how to challenge its charm? One might think it can
be done by exposing the truth about Islamic State, starting with its failure to deliver the promise of a caliphate.

There are two factors that make these expectations excessive. First, Islamic State did not govern long enough to
discredit itself in eyes of its sympathizers. All the mistakes and shortcomings during that brief project can be
explained away by being in a state of war – the caliphate was besieged by the world powers. Second, as with other
utopian ideologies, new generations of Islamists will simply think that they will do it better.

Consider socialism and communism – they have proven that they are not viable and profitable long-term models for
communities, yet still new groups appear, claiming that they can do it properly. They “know” how to avoid the
mistakes of their predecessors and deliver the promise without forsaking communism’s “genuine idea”.

In this case, even if we manage to expose the inabilities and failures of IS, we cannot be sure that al-Qaeda or other
new groups will not promise better results. Moreover, and unfortunately, IS has already demonstrated that the idea of
creating a territorial Islamic State can be realized.

Perspective is needed. While we should not neglect the danger of this new narrative, the nostalgia for what was
achieved by IS in 2014-17 is probably a temporary factor rather than long-standing. In the short term, though, major
efforts should be focused on perceptions of victimhood and finding other legitimate ways to achieve improvements.

European Eye on Radicalization aims to publish a diversity of perspectives and as such does not endorse the
opinions expressed by contributors. The views expressed in this article represent the author alone.

Related
This Posts
website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie
Policy. I Agree

https://eeradicalization.com/nostalgia-and-radicalization/ 3/6
31/10/22, 20:01 Nostalgia and Radicalization - European Eye on Radicalization

CONTRIBUTORS’ OPINIONS EER EDITORIALS

Barriers to the Successful Canada Sanctions Iran’s Criminal

Implementation of P/CVE Programs in Leaders, Provides a Model for Others
Africa  24 OCTOBER 2022

 31 OCTOBER 2022

CONTRIBUTORS’ OPINIONS EER EDITORIALS

A New Approach is Needed to Deal With The Expatriation of Foreign Fighters’

Islamist Terrorist Prisoners Families: Between Security Risks and the
 20 OCTOBER 2022 Necessity to Bring Them Home
 18 OCTOBER 2022

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent
EER EDITORIALS
to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie
CONTRIBUTORS’ OPINIONS
Policy. I Agree
The Use of Drones by Terrorist The Extremism Market and Salad Bar
https://eeradicalization.com/nostalgia-and-radicalization/ 4/6
31/10/22, 20:01 Nostalgia and Radicalization - European Eye on Radicalization
Organizations: A Constant Challenge to Ideology
Counter-Terrorism Policies  11 OCTOBER 2022

 14 OCTOBER 2022

Latest from Twitter

Tweets from @EuroEyeRad Follow on Twitter

European Eye on Radicalization @EuroEyeRad · 13h

"Barriers to the Successful Implementation of P/CVE Programs in Africa", by @Strong_Cities'
@IselZyl.

Popular

Taliban: Structure, Strategy, Agenda, and the International Terrorism Threat

 7 OCTOBER 2022

How a Swedish Agency Stopped Funding the Muslim Brotherhood

 5 SEPTEMBER 2022

This website uses cookies. Muslim Brotherhood

By continuing and Khomeinism
to use this website you are givinginconsent
Italy: to
The Toldbeing
cookies and the
used.Untold
Visit our Privacy and Cookie
 6 MAY 2022 Policy. I Agree

https://eeradicalization.com/nostalgia-and-radicalization/ 5/6
31/10/22, 20:01 Nostalgia and Radicalization - European Eye on Radicalization

Islamist Organizations in the United Kingdom: From the Rushdie Affair to Present Day
 17 JANUARY 2022

Remote Controlled Terror: Houthi Suicide Boats

 27 SEPTEMBER 2018

Islamist Extremism and Jihadism in Latin America: A Longstanding and Underestimated

Phenomenon (Part 2)
 17 JUNE 2022

© 2018 EER - Copyright © European Eye on Radicalization.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie
Policy. I Agree

https://eeradicalization.com/nostalgia-and-radicalization/ 6/6