Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ramon Navarro
Raul Gil-Parra
Endoscopic third ventriculostomy in children:
Aaron J. Reitman
Greg Olavarria
early and late complications
John A. Grant and their avoidance
Tadanori Tomita
Material and methods eter perforation technique had the catheter left in the lateral
ventricle, which was connected to the subgaleal Ommaya
This is a retrospective study of patients who underwent an reservoir.
endoscopic third ventriculostomy at Children’s Memorial
Hospital from January 1993 to July 2004. The study has
been approved by our Internal Review Board. Patients more Results
than 18 years old were excluded. We reviewed the medical
records, operative reports, and radiological studies [mag- Although all 129 patients were intended to complete the
netic resonance imagimg (MRI) and computed tomography ETV, the procedure was aborted in seven (6.9%) due to
(CT) scans] in all of the 129 patients in whom ETV was endoscopic findings such as presence of tumor, arachnoid-
attempted. Of these, seven procedures could not be itis, or poor anatomy which precluded the performance of
completed. The remaining 122 patients who had successful ventriculostomy in a safe manner. These seven patients
ETV were entered into this study. A subsequent need of were excluded from the analysis. Fourteen patients under-
CSF diversion procedure was considered ‘failure’ of the went more than one ETV procedure; therefore, a total of
ETV. 136 ETV were performed in 122 patients between January
Patients were divided by age, etiology of hydrocephalus, 1993 and July 2004. Thirty-eight patients (29.5%) were
period when the ETV was performed, outcome, presence of children under 1 year of age. Mean follow-up time was
complications, and whether or not an external ventricular 3.3 years.
drain (EVD) or Ommaya reservoir was inserted. Five main
groups were classified depending on the etiology:
1. Stenosis at the level of the aqueduct (congenital Early complications
aqueductal stenosis, tectal gliomas, and pineal tumors)
2. Stenosis at the posterior fossa (cerebellar and brain- There were 12 patients (9.8%) who developed complica-
stem tumors) tions following a third ventriculostomy (Table 1). The age
3. Congenital (congenital hydrocephalus, Dandy–Walker of these patients ranged from 1 month to 12 years (mean
malformation, and Chiari type I malformation) age 3.7 years). There were eight male and four female
patients. Hydrocephalus was caused by stenosis at the level
4. Secondary to IVH/meningitis of the aqueduct in ten patients and posterior fossa tumor in
5. Patients with myelomeningocele one patient while one patient was with hydrocephalus
Statistical analyses (descriptive analysis, Pearson chi- secondary to intraventricluar hemorrhage. Seventy-five
square test, and Kaplan–Meier survival analysis) were percent of the patients that had a complication underwent
conducted using a statistical software (SPSS, Chicago, IL). ETV before 1998.
We performed a total of 136 ETVs, with a total of 12
complications (8.8%). Four of these 12 complications
Surgical technique occurred after the second EVT. Repeated ETV had a
statistically significant higher risk of early complications
A right frontal burr hole is placed over the coronal suture and (p=0.009). Case 9 had an intra-operative complication at
slightly medial to the mid-pupillary line. Two methods were the second ETV: while the floor of the third ventricle was
used for ventriculostomy: one with a peel-away sheath for being perforated with the blunt head of an endoscope, the
channel neuroendoscope (outer diameter 3.5 mm), and an- patient developed severe intracranial hemorrhage (intra-
other with either an inner vision catheter or slotted catheter ventricular and posterior fossa subdural hematoma) due to
using NeuroPEN neuroendoscope (Medtronics, Minneapo- vascular injury to the interpeduncular cistern structures.
lis). An endoscope is advanced into the lateral ventricle Although this infant survived, he was severely disabled.
aiming the foramen of Monro, and the anatomy is identified. This complication occurred in the earliest period of this
Endoscopic ventriculostomy is performed between the mam- series. In the remaining 11 patients, the complication was
millary bodies and the infundibulum using either a French #3 identified in the immediate postoperative period: three CSF
Fogarty catheter or the tip of the NeuroPEN scope. The leaks without infection, two CSF leaks with subsequent
stoma was enlarged by inflating the Fogarty balloon or pas- meningitis, one meningitis and one ventriculitis without
sing the catheter over the endoscope. No or little ventricular CSF leak, one intraventricular hemorrhage, acute subdural
bleeding is expected and it is easily controlled by gentle hematomas and seizure, another with seizure, and two with
irrigation with normal saline solution at body temperature. transient diabetes insipidus. The latter patients showed
Significant arachnoid membranes in the subarachnoid space clinical symptoms of diabetes insipidus in the immediate
are perforated until structures of the interpeduncular and postoperative period, which was resolved within 10 days
prepontine cistern are visualized. In earlier patients, an EVD after transient use of DDAVP. A significant number of
was left for the postoperative purpose for a few days, and patients (8 of 12) that developed a complication also had a
removed at bedside. The most recent 32 patients with cath- third ventriculostomy failure with a statistically significant
508
value (p=0.035). More specifically, all the ones with either The success rate is better when ETV is performed after
an infectious or hemorrhagic complication required sub- 1 year of age than during the first year. A total of 36 ETVs
sequent VPS. Conversely, patients experiencing diabetes were successfully completed in infants under 12 months,
insipidus or seizures without additional complications did with a significant failure rate of 55.6% (20/36). This failure
not need a shunt (Table 2). Interestingly, most of the rate was significantly (p=0.012) higher than that of the
children with complications were under 12 months of age older age group (Fig. 1).
(8 of 12) and those complications occurred before 1998 When considering etiology of the hydrocephalus, we
(9 of 12). could also find different outcomes (Table 3). In patients
with obstruction at the posterior fossa, the success rate was
75%, followed by children with stenosis at the level of the
ETV failures aqueduct of Sylvius with a 64% of favorable outcome.
Patients with congenital hydrocephalus other than aque-
After the first ETV, the overall failure rate was 37% ductal stenosis (Chiari type I and Dandy–Walker), myelo-
(46/122). In 65% of the cases, failure occurred before
6 weeks after initial ETV with the latest one presenting
6 years after initial ETV. Mean time to failure was
age
26.7 weeks, and median time to failure was approximately 1,0
older than one
5 weeks. Nevertheless, statistical differences were ob- year
younger than
served when different variables were analyzed. one year
0,8 censored
censored
Acummulative survival
Total Failures
CSF leak 3 2
CSF leak with meningitis 2 2
0,2
Meningitis/ventriculitis 2 2
Seizure 1 0
Seizure with moderate bleeding 1 1 0,0
Severe bleeding (IVH/SDH) 1 1
12 8 0 1000 2000 3000 4000
time to failure
CSF Cerebrospinal fluid, IVH intraventricular hemorrhage, SDH
subdural hematoma Fig. 1 Ventriculostomy survival according to patients’ age
509
Acummulative survival
Pineal region 10 4 (40) 1/1
0,6
Tectal glioma 22 4 (18) 0/1
IVH 7 5 (71) 3/5
IVH/meningitis 4 2 (50) 12
0,4
Meningitis 4 1 (25) 14
MM 3 2 (66) 2/3
PF benign 7 4 (57) 0 0,2
PF malignant 16 4 (25) 1/1
Brainstem tumor 8 0 0
Chiari type I 5 3 (60) 1/1 0,0
Dandy–Walker 1 1 (100) 0
0 1000 2000 3000 4000
122 46 (37) 20 (55%) time to failure
Aq. stenosis Aqueductal stenosis, IVH intraventricular hemorrhage, Fig. 3 Ventriculostomy survival according to hydrocephalus etiol-
MM myelomeningocele, PF posterior fossa ogy (II): 1 aqueductal stenosis, tectal gliomas, pineal tumors, and
cerebellar and brainstem tumors; 2 Chiari type I, Dandy–Walker
malformation, intraventricular hemorrhage and/or meningitis,
meningocele, and IVH/meningitis fared worse with a myelomeningocle
success rate of 34, 34 and 47%, respectively. These values
were not statistically significant with p=0.087 (Fig. 2).
Nevertheless, if we combine the patients in whom there is a We also subdivided the patients in two groups depending
clear anatomical lesion causing hydrocephalus (posterior on the year that EVT was performed: from 1993 to 1997
fossa tumors, pineal region tumors, tectal glioma, and and from 1998 to 2004. The latter group of patients had a
aqueductal stenosis) vs those with other lesions (IVH, statistically significant better outcome (p=0.009) of 72.3 vs
meningitis, MM, Dandy–Walker, and Chiari), we found a 49.1% in our early experience (Fig. 4).
statistically better outcome for the first group (p=0.026) Finally, when analyzing the patients depending on
(Fig. 3). whether or not an EVD or an Ommaya reservoir was
inserted, statistically significant differences were also
found (p<0.005). CSF diversion with an EVD proved to
1,0 causes
1
2
3
0,8 4
5
ETV Date
Acummulative survival
1-censored 1,0
Before 98
2-censored
After 98
0,6 3-censored
1-censored
4-censored
0,8 2-censored
5-censored
Acummulate survival
0,4
0,6
0,2
0,4
0,0
time to failure
0,0
Fig. 2 Ventriculostomy survival according to hydrocephalus etiol-
ogy (I): 1 aqueductal stenosis, tectal gliomas and pineal tumors; 2 0 1000 2000 3000 4000
cerebellar and brainstem tumors; 3 Chiari type I and Dandy–Walker time to failure
malformation; 4 intraventricular hemorrhage and/or meningitis; 5
myelomeningocele Fig. 4 Ventriculostomy survival according to date of the ETV
510
1,0
CSF Diversion Avoidance of early complication
EVD
Ommaya
Nothing Complication avoidance starts with patient selection. ETV
EVD-censored
0,8
Ommaya-
should not be performed if CSF is already flowing
Acummulative survival
prevented by avoiding traction of the floor of the third Prevention of ventriculostomy failure
ventricle with an inflated Fogarty balloon. Using any sort
of thermal energy such as monopolar cautery or laser is We identified several groups of patients that had a higher
discouraged as it increases the chances of a vascular or failure rate than the rest. First of all, our success rate in
hypothalamic injury [32]. A careful monitoring of urinary patients younger than 1 year of age was only 44.4% with
output and electrolytes in the immediate postoperative statistical significance p=0.012 compared to their counter-
period is needed to detect diabetes insipidus. In addition, parts above that age. This finding was also noticed by
metabolic disturbance can lead to seizure disorder in the numerous authors [31, 36, 37]. This might reflect a low
following days after ETV. capacity of the subarachnoid space for CSF reabsorption—
Although no or little hemorrhage are expected during arachnoid granulations are not fully mature until fontanel
EVT, sometimes bleeding can be troublesome. Minimal closure—, tendency for formation of new arachnoid
bleeding can be easily controlled with gentle irrigation. In membranes, and need of a higher pressure difference as
the event of massive hemorrhage, profuse irrigation and some of the pressure gradient is lost in distending the
patience must be used; if a bleeding point can be identified fontanels rather than opening the arachnoid villi. However,
after irrigation, though difficult due to obscured vision, a recent report by Gorayeb et al. [38] shows better results
bipolar cautery or balloon inflation on the source of after ETV during infancy.
hemorrhage can help with hemostasis. Placement of EVD A second set of patients that had statistically higher
is a valuable option for postoperative management of ventriculostomy failure were the ones that developed
intraventricular hemorrhage. complications. Sixty six percent (8 of 12) of these patients
When irrigating during surgery, attention must be paid to required VPS placement, specifically those that had either a
the infusion rate as well as the temperature of the irrigation hemorrhagic or infectious complication. Diabetes insipi-
solution; aggressive irrigation can lead to increased ICP dus, CSF leak, or seizures alone did not increase the failure
with severe bradycardia [26], and cold saline infusion can rate. This might reflect an additional poor reabsorption
produce altered mental status after surgery. It is also component after arachnoid villi damage secondary to blood
important to make sure that there is a patent inward and debris or infection. If a second ETV was performed, we had
outward flow of the irrigation solution, as small volume less chance of success (35.7%) than the initial ETV
changes can lead to dramatic intracranial pressure changes. (64.3%) with p=0.035 on chi-square analysis. Schroeder et
This parameter can be monitored by connecting an arterial al. [13] also found a higher ETV risk in repeated ETVs. In
line transducer to both the endoscope irrigating channel contrast, Cinalli et al. [39] claims that repeated ETV has a
and the anesthesia monitor using a three-way tap. In 65% success rate and no higher complications.
addition, Van Aalst et al. [33] have demonstrated an acute Most of the failures (66%) happen within the first
distortion of the anatomy of the third ventricle after profuse 6 weeks (early failure). Early clinical response frequently
irrigation during ETV. This can also increase the rate of has a high correlation with good outcome [17]. None-
complications secondary to poor identification of the theless, there is usually a partial clinical and radiological
anatomical landmarks. response that makes evaluation of the procedure more
The last step to avoid early complications is a good challenging compared to patient evaluation after standard
wound closure. Instead of a burr hole for ETV directly shunting. Early failures after a proper ETV are usually
underneath a skin incision, we routinely use a semicircular secondary to absorption problems, while late failures might
incision that allows us to create a small pericranial flap that be due to stoma closure. In the latter cases, a repeated ETV
will be closed separately creating an additional layer. CSF can be performed, especially if the first one was successful
leak or persistent bulging under the incision is a sign of [26, 40]. In the more recent ETV cases, we have been
ventriculostomy failure, and increases the risk of menin- routinely implementing an Ommaya reservoir. With this
gitis. However, one might expect an increased ICP on the subcutaneous reservoir, we can gain access to the CSF and,
first few days because restoration of CSF absorption at the therefore, we can monitor ICP, drain CSF if necessary and,
arachnoid granulations is not immediate, and there is a so- more important, potentially expedite emergency treatment
called adaptation period [34, 35]. Lumbar punctures after in cases with acute hydrocephalus after delayed ventricu-
technically successful third ventriculostomy in the postop- lostomy failure [24, 30]. Additionally, contrast dye can be
erative period may promote flow through the stoma while injected through the reservoir to confirm stoma patency on
normal CSF absorption is restored. Identifying anatomical CT, as flow MRI and ventricular size change are not
landmarks and perforating the floor of the third ventricle is infallible to detect ventriculostomy patency [26, 41].
generally more challenging in re-operations. Wound heal- Leaving an EVD after ETV presents several disadvantages:
ing is also not as good in previously operated tissue than in it provides only transient access to the ventricular system, it
a virgin scalp. Finally, when performing an ETV on a may add risk of infection, and it may decrease the CSF flow
patient with VPS, removing all the shunt hardware can through the ventriculostomy. It is important to initially
minimize the risk of infection [21]. maintain a high-pressure gradient through the ventriculos-
tomy [17].
512
Finally, as in all surgical procedures, there is a learning copy instruments and procedures and experiencing a
curve for ETV [20]. Our results since 1998 are significantly sufficient case load is needed to maintain a good success
better than in the previous years. This learning process rate of this valuable procedure for hydrocephalic children.
includes good patient selection that usually decreases the
chance of failure, as well as some technical considerations Acknowledgement We would like to thank Susana Ochoa M.S.
that can help in avoiding early complications. Seventy-five from Hospital Sant Joan de Deu Foundation for her thoughtful
suggestions and statistical analyses.
percent of our complications occurred before 1998 and,
interestingly, the delayed failure rate was significantly
higher in that period of time. Being familiar with endos-
References
1. Choi JU, Kim DS, Kim SH (1999) 11. Hopf NJ, Grunert P, Fries G, Resch 20. Teo C, Rahman S, Boop FA, Cherny B
Endoscopic surgery for obstructive hy- KD, Perneczky A (1999) Endoscopic (1996) Complications of endoscopic
drocephalus. Yonsei Med J 40:600–607 third ventriculostomy: outcome analy- neurosurgery. Child’s Nerv Syst
2. Guiot G (1973) Ventriculo-cistern- sis of 100 consecutive procedures. 12:248–253
ostomy for stenosis of the aqueduct of Neurosurgery 44:795–806 21. Walker ML (2004) Complications of
Sylvius. Puncture of the floor of the 12. Jones RF, Kwok BC, Stening WA, third ventriculostomy. Neurosurg Clin
third ventricle with a leucotome under Vonau M (1994) The current status of N Am 15:61–66
television control. Acta Neurochir endoscopic third ventriculostomy in the 22. Saint-Rose C, Chumas P (1996) Endo-
28:275–289 management of noncommunicating scopic third ventriculostomy. Tech
3. Kelly PJ (1991) Stereotactic third hydrocephalus. Minim Invasive Neurosurg 1:176–184
ventriculostomy in patients with Neurosurg 37:28–36 23. Handler MH, Abbott R, Lee M (1994)
nontumoral adolescent/adult onset 13. Schroeder HWS, Niendorf W, Gaab A near-fatal complication of endo-
aqueductal stenosis and symptomatic MR (2002) Complications of endo- scopic third ventriculostomy: case re-
hydrocephalus. J Neurosurg 75:865– scopic third ventriculostomy. port. Neurosurgery 35:525–528
873 J Neurosurg 96:1032–1040 24. Mobbs RJ, Vonau M, Davies M (2003)
4. Teo C, Jones R (1996) Management of 14. Teo C (1998) Third ventriculostomy in Death after late failure of endoscopic
hydrocephalus by endoscopic third the treatment of hydrocephalus: expe- third ventriculostomy: a potential solu-
ventriculostomy in patients with rience with more than 120 cases. In: tion. Neurosurgery 53:384–386
myelomeningocele. Pediatr Neurosurg Hellwig D, Bauer BL (eds) Minimally 25. Abtin K, Thompson BG, Walker ML
25:57–63 invasive techniques for neurosurgery. (1998) Basilar artery perforation as a
5. Buxton N, Macarthur D, Mallucci C, Springer, Berlin Heidelberg New York, complication of endoscopic third ven-
Punt J, Vloeberghs M (1998) Neu- pp 73–76 triculostomy. Pediatr Neurosurg 28:
roendoscopy in the premature popula- 15. Beems T, Grotenhuis JA (2004) Long- 35–41
tion. Child’s Nerv Syst 14:649–652 term complications and definition of 26. El-Dawlatly AA, Murshid WR,
6. Grant JA, McLone DG (1997) Third failure of neuroendoscopic procedures. Elshimy A, Magboul MA, Samarkandi
ventriculostomy: a review. Surg Neurol Child’s Nerv Syst 20:868–877 A, Takroury MS (2000) The
47:210–212 16. Buxton N, Macarthur D, Mallucci C, incidence of bradycardia during endo-
7. McLaughlin MR, Wahlig JB, Punt J, Vloeberghs M (1998) Neu- scopic third ventriculostomy. Anesth
Kaufmann AM, Albright AL (1997) roendoscopic third ventriculostomy in Analg 91:1142–1144
Traumatic basilar aneurysm after en- patients less than 1 year old. Pediatr 27. Enya S, Masuda Y, Terui K (1997)
doscopic third ventriculostomy: case Neurosurg 29:73–76 Respiratory arrest after a ventric-
report. Neurosurgery 41:1400–1404 17. Feng H, Huang G, Liao X, Fu K, uloscopic surgery in infants: two case
8. Siomin V, Cinalli G, Grotenhuis A, Tan H, Pu H et al (2004) Endoscopic reports. Masui 46:416–420 (Japanese)
Golash A, Oi S, Kothbauer K et al third ventriculostomy in the manage- 28. Kim BS, Jallo GI, Kothbauer K, Abbott
(2002) Endoscopic third ventric- ment of obstructive hydrocephalus: an R (2004) Chronic subdural hematoma
ulostomy in patients with cerebrospinal outcome analysis. J Neurosurg as a complication of endoscopic third
fluid infection and/or hemorrhage. 100:626–633 ventriculostomy. Surg Neurol 62:64–68
J Neurosurg 97:519–524 18. Santamarta D, Onzain I, Blázquez JA, 29. Kramer U, Kanner AA, Siomin V,
9. Brockmeyer D, Abtin K, Carey L, Gomez-Moreta JA, Morales F (2004) Harel S, Constantini S (2001) No
Walker ML (1998) Endoscopic third Endoscopic third ventriculostomy: risk evidence of epilepsy following endo-
ventriculostomy: an outcome analysis. factor for failure and evolution of scopic third ventriculostomy: a short-
Pediatr Neurosurg 28:236–240 ventricular size. Neurocirugía 15: term follow-up. Pediatr Neurosurg
10. Gangemi M, Donati P, Maiuri F, 248–257 (Spanish) 34:121–123
Longatti P, Godano U, Mascari C 19. Teo C, Jones RFC, Stening WA, Kwok 30. Hader WJ, Drake J, Cochrane D,
(1999) Endoscopic third ventric- B (1991) Neuroendoscopic third ven- Sparrow O, Johnson ES, Kestle J
ulostomy for hydrocephalus. Minim triculostomy. In: Matsumoto S (ed) (2002) Death after late failure of third
Invasive Neurosurg 42:128–132 Hydrocephalus: pathogenesis and ventriculostomy in children. Report of
treatment. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg three cases. J Neurosurg 97:211–215
New York, pp 680–691
513
31. Rekate HL (2004) Selecting patients for 35. Nishiyama K, Mori H, Tanaka R (2003) 39. Cinalli G, Sainte-Rose C, Chumas P,
endoscopic third ventriculostomy. Changes in cerebrospinal fluid hydro- Zerah M, Brunelle F, Lot Guillaume,
Neurosurg Clin N Am 15:29–49 dynamics following endoscopic third Pierre-Kahn A, Renier D (1999) Failure
32. Brockmeyer D (2004) Techniques of ventriculostomy for shunt-dependent of third ventriculostomy in the treat-
endoscopic third ventriculostomy. noncommunicating hydrocephalus. ment of aqueductal stenosis in children.
Neurosurg Clin N Am 15:51–59 J Neurosurg 98:1027–1031 J Neurosurg 90:448–454
33. van Aalst J, Beuls EAM, van Nie FA, 36. Fukuhara T, Vorster SJ, Luciano MG 40. Siomin V, Weiner H, Wisoff J, Cinalli
Vles JS, Cornips EM (2002) Acute (2000) Risk factors for failure of G, Pierre-Kahn A, Saint-Rose C (2001)
distortion of the anatomy of the third endoscopic third ventriculostomy Repeat endoscopic third ventric-
ventricle during third ventriculostomy. for obstructive hydrocephalus. ulostomy: is it worth trying? Child’s
J Neurosurg 96:597–599 Neurosurgery 46:1100–1111 Nerv Syst 17:551–555
34. Bellotti A, Rapana A, Iaccarino C, 37. Koch D, Wagner W (2004) Endoscopic 41. St. George Edward, Natarajan K,
Schonauer M (2001) Intracranial pres- third ventriculostomy in infants of less Sgouros S (2004) Changes in ventric-
sure monitoring after endoscopic third than 1 year of age: which factors ular volume in hydrocephalic children
ventriculostomy: an effective method to influence the outcome? Child’s Nerv following successful endoscopic third
manage the ‘adaptation period’. Clin Syst 20:405–411 ventriculostomy. Child’s Nerv Syst
Neurol Neurosurg 103:223–227 38. Gorayeb RP, Cavalheiro S, Zymberg 20:834–838
ST (2004) Endoscopic third ventric-
ulostomy in children younger than 1
year of age. J Neurosurg (Pediatrics 5)
100:427–429