Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Zhang 2001 - Engg Geological Prop of Red Mud in Comprehensive Way
Zhang 2001 - Engg Geological Prop of Red Mud in Comprehensive Way
Table 1
Physical and hydrophilic properties of red mud from an aluminium factory in Shanxi province, China
Sample Water Natural Dry Special Void Degree Water- Water- Re- Liquid Plastic Plasticity Liquid Ratio of Speci®c
number content density density gravity ratio of bearing bearing leased limit limit index index natural surface
(%) (kN m±3) (kN m±3) saturation capacity capacity water (%) (%) water area
(%) (%) after during content (m2 g±1)
shaken shaking /plastic
(%) (%) limit
1627 89.97 14.97 7.96 2.87 2.61 99.1 93.32 81.34 11.98 76.0 50.6 25.4 1.47 1.16 74.24
1628 85.79 15.06 8.11 2.80 2.45 97.9 86.99 72.08 14.91 71.0 44.5 26.5 1.56 1.21 70.99
1629 87.22 14.81 7.91 2.85 2.60 95.5 90.31 74.97 5.34 75.0 51.0 24.0 1.51 1.16 73.20
1630 86.01 14.73 7.92 2.85 2.60 94.4 79.03 74.66 4.37 78.0 52.0 26.0 1.31 1.10 78.65
1635 89.41 14.96 7.90 2.84 2.60 97.9 85.52 75.76 9.76 76.0 46.0 30.0 1.45 1.18 64.09
2.61. The high water content and low density were mainly index of 24 to 30, and the characteristic of clayey soils
caused by the high porosity of red mud (Fig. 1). by the engineering classi®cation of plasticity index. The
high liquid index (1.31±1.56) and high ratio of water
High consistency content to liquid limit (1.10±1.15) indicate that red mud
Consistency is a measure of the hardness of clayey soil. belongs to an industrial waste that is liable to plastic
The red mud has a liquid limit that ranges from 71.0 to ¯ow.
78.0%, and a plastic limit of 44.5±51.0%, with both being
relatively high; but it has a comparatively low plasticity Properties of water-bearing and liquefaction of red mud
Experiments by the authors have shown that fresh red
mud samples can release free water by shock to cause
liquefaction. The water-bearing capacity of red mud was
measured with fresh powdered samples under gravity to be
79.03±93.32%, which is very close to the natural water
content (85.79±89.97%). The released water during shak-
ing ranged from 4.37±14.91%, depending on the water-
bearing capacity. This suggests that fresh red mud stocked
as tailing dams could undergo liquefaction by mechanical
vibration and result in failure of soil mass, known as
shallow or surface dam failure.
Table 2
Gross analysis results of red mud wastes
Sample Sample SiO2 TiO2 Al2O3 Fe2O3 FeO CaO MgO K2O Na2O H2O CO2 Total CaCO3
number type (%)
1627 Original 16.40 2.50 6.84 6.91 0.73 33.07 1.67 0.17 3.00 3.05 26.58 100.92 60.35
1628 Original 14.10 2.50 6.94 6.78 0.66 33.59 1.29 0.17 3.25 3.42 27.81 100.51 63.17
1629 Original 12.80 2.75 7.74 6.54 0.82 34.16 1.11 0.19 3.00 3.48 27.01 99.60 61.35
1630 Original 12.43 2.25 7.40 7.04 0.66 34.11 1.15 0.17 3.00 3.27 28.14 99.62 63.92
1635 Original 13.70 2.25 7.51 6.97 0.59 34.37 1.52 0.15 1.42 3.38 26.35 99.11 59.85
1627-1 <2 lm 24.20 1.25 14.23 10.88 0.66 18.01 1.49 0.27 2.95 5.41 15.45 94.80 35.09
1628-1 <2 lm 21.10 1.50 15.36 10.46 0.44 20.05 1.30 0.27 3.07 5.10 17.03 95.58 38.68
1635-1 <2 lm 21.30 1.25 16.51 11.00 0.52 17.44 1.30 0.26 2.45 5.71 15.25 92.99 34.40
1627-2 >2 lm 16.30 2.50 6.83 6.60 0.66 33.59 1.49 0.16 1.35 2.58 27.44 99.50 62.33
1628-2 >2 lm 16.95 2.50 7.06 6.75 0.69 34.40 1.52 0.15 1.38 2.91 25.22 99.52 57.28
1635-2 >2 lm 15.00 2.25 7.17 6.91 0.62 34.52 1.67 0.15 1.42 2.94 26.92 99.57 61.15
Chemical composition of original red mud increasing to 60%, Al2O3 to 110.7% and Fe2O3 to 57.4%,
1. The main composition of original red mud includes whereas CaCO3 decreased by 41% compared with the
CaO and CO2: its content ranges from 33.07 to 34.37% original sample.
and 26.35 to 28.14%, respectively, with a corresponding
mineral composition of aragonite (CaCO3) or calcite Chemical composition of easily soluble salt
(CaCO3). The content of CaCO3 ranged from 59.85 to in red mud
63.92%, which accounts for more than one-half of the Determination of the permeating solution in the perme-
red mud. The deposition and crystallization of CaCO3 is ation test showed that large amounts of easily soluble salts
produced by the addition of quicklime (CaO) and car- were present in red mud as a result of the addition of
bon dioxide (CO2) during aluminium production, and NaOH, CO2 and CaO in alumina production. The results
constitutes the coarse components (skeleton) and show that the main chemical composition of easily soluble
cementing materials. salt was Na2CO3, and accounted for 60% of the total
2. The content of SiO2 in red mud ranges from 12.43 to (Table 3), and the others were Na2SO4 10H2O, NaHCO3,
16.40%, which is dissociated from kaolinite [Al2Si2O3 NaAlO2. These easily soluble salts exist as pore solutions in
(OH)4] associated with bauxite during alumina pro- red mud at the initial stage of storage. Dehydration,
duction to form hydrophane (SiO2±nH2O) and sodium especially drying, will cause the formation of solid salt on
silicate (Na2SiO3), which effects irreversible cementa- the surface.
tion during red mud ageing and hardening.
3. The content of Al2O3 in red mud ranges from 6.84 to
7.74%, which usually exists in two forms, NaAlO2 and Mineral composition of red mud
Al(OH)3, in the presence of the strong alkaline media After studying the red mud by X-ray diffraction analysis,
NaOH. rock chemical analysis, differential thermal analysis
4. Fe2O3, a colloid of Fe(OH)3, formed after oxidation and (DTA), infrared absorption spectroscopy, MoÈssbauer
hydration of associated FeS2 in bauxite, ranged from spectrometry and scanning electron microscope (SEM),
6.54 to 7.04% (whereas FeO was only between 0.59 and the results were as follows:
0.82%). The colloid of Fe(OH)3 is unstable under 1. The minerals of red mud are aragonite and calcite,
strongly alkaline and heated conditions, and tends to which are both the polymorphs of CaCO3. Because of
convert into goethite (FeOOH), which may coexist with the instability of aragonite under normal temperature
the colloid Fe(OH)3 in fresh red mud, whereas FeO may and pressure, it has a tendency to convert to calcite.
exist as a form of siderite (FeCO3). Furthermore, it contains a little siderite (FeCO3).
5. Na2O in red mud was comparatively high, and generally 2. The subordinate minerals of red mud are hydrated free
ranged from 3.0 to 3.25%, and exists in pore solutions oxides such as hydrophane (SiO2 nH2O), goethite or
as Na+. Its abundance in red mud is caused by the hydrohematite (b-FeOOH) and gibbsite [Al(OH)3].
excessive addition of NaOH in aluminium production. Goethite usually exists in the form of a thin crust
In addition, a series of saline deposits or colloid coating the surface of grains and acts as a cementing
products, such as Na2CO3, NaHCO3, Na2SiO3, NaAlO2, material.
are formed during desiccation, which take part in 3. A layer of white powder was commonly formed on the
reshaping the structure of aged red mud. surface of regular test samples of red mud dried in the
6. TiO2 is also comparatively high, and ranged from 2.25 laboratory. According to X-ray diffraction analysis
to 2.75%, and was present as components of rutile and results, the layer is a mixture of trona [Na3H(CO3)2
anatase in bauxite, which was left as residues in red 2H2O] and thermonatrite (Na2CO3 2H2O), which are
mud in alumina production. salt deposits formed from pore solution by evaporation
and condensation on the surface, and of Na+, HCO3
Chemical composition of <0.002-mm red mud and CO23 ions by capillary action under drying con-
The chemical analyses of <0.002 mm ®ne red mud, as ditions. Although their total content is less than
compared with that of original red mud and >0.002 mm 2 g 100 g±1, they are seriously harmful to the environ-
coarse red mud, show that SiO2, Al2O3 and Fe2O3 exist ment because of their accumulation and the formation
mainly as colloids in the <0.002 mm fraction, with SiO2 of a white crust on the surface.
Table 3
Results of chemical analyses of easily soluble salt in red mud
Sample pH Residue Cations (mg 100 g±1) Anions (mg 100 g±1)
number value after
drying Ca2+ Mg2+ Na+ K+ Total HCO3 CO23 SO24 Cl± AlO2 OH± Total
(mg 100 g±1)
1627 11.25 1,880 1.85 35.37 607.07 13.44 657.73 187.01 547.86 305.89 29.46 72.42 ± 1,142.64
1628 11.50 1,849 0.74 9.52 720.73 16.43 747.42 119.37 675.04 271.91 34.37 85.58 1.11 1,187.38
1635 11.25 1,340 0.37 4.48 661.19 15.97 682.01 136.98 567.42 253.78 36.83 84.27 12.2 1,091.48
4. According to chemical analyses, some unstable com- loam. It needs to be pointed out that the content of ®ne
pounds, such as Na2SiO3, NaAlO2, NaOH and Fe(OH)3, sand of >0.1 mm was very high (with values between 28.91
are also included in the pore ¯uids of red mud. and 35.37%), and was generally >30%. Brown sand parti-
cles and coarse silt particles, obtained by suspension
Generally, aragonite, calcite and siderite can not only act sieving, can all be rubbed into very ®ne particles by hand,
as the skeletons of red mud, but also mutually cement which indicates that they are strongly integrated aggre-
themselves through phase transformation and recrystalli- gates with high stability.
zation under drying condition. Colloids of free oxides such However, suspensions obtained from ultrasonically
as hydrophane (SiO2±nH2O), sodium silicate (Na2SiO3), treated HCO3 ±Ca2+ type tap water was considerably
goethite (b-FeOOH) and gibbsite [Al(OH)3] will become unstable, and precipitated fast after churning. This
irreversible cement materials of dried mud when changing indicates that dispersion to promote liquefaction of red
to a solid state. mud would be considerably lowered under the effects
of a HCO3 ±Ca2+-type surface or groundwater after
Particle and aggregate constitution of red mud storage.
Excessive addition of NaOH, CaO and CO2 in alumina
production results in the presence of abundant electrolytes
(dispersants), such as NaOH and NaHCO3 in red mud,
causing red mud to be in a highly dispersive state under
natural conditions. The particle constitution is measured Engineering properties of red mud
using a liquid extract of red mud with a mud/water ratio of
1:10: suspensions of such an extract are very stable with no Permeability and leaching property
¯occulation. The results of granulometric analysis using a The incoherence and high content of ®ne sands and coarse
pipette method, are shown in Table 4. silts determine the importance of the permeability re-
The particle fraction of <0.005 mm ranged from 19.6 to search of red mud. Using a Nan-55 type lysimeter and
26.8%, the particle fraction <0.002 mm was 15.2 to 23.6%. taking tap water as a penetrating ¯uid, the authors have
The principal particle size was >0.01 mm. Thus, most studied the permeability and leaching properties of origi-
samples belonged to heavy loam, and a few to heavy silty nal red mud samples (Table 5).
Table 4
Granulometric analysis results of red mud in different dispersing media
Sample Dispersing Particle composition (mm, %) Structural
number media coef®cienta
>0.1 0.1 to 0.05 0.05 to 0.01 0.01 to 0.005 <0.005 <0.002
1627 Distilled water 35.28 11.12 26.0 8.0 19.6 15.2 5.43
Tap water 20.61 25.79 35.6 12.8 5.2 2.8
1628 Distilled water 28.91 4.29 31.2 10.0 25.6 21.2 6.63
Tap water 15.51 20.88 48.8 9.6 5.2 3.2
1629 Distilled water 35.24 3.16 26.4 8.8 26.4 23.6 2.81
Tap water 37.44 16.16 23.6 9.2 13.6 8.4
1630 Distilled water 30.23 5.77 26.0 11.2 26.8 22.4 6.22
Tap water 57.2 12.18 20.8 6.0 4.0 3.6
1635 Distilled water 35.37 6.63 22.8 10.0 25.2 19.6 12.30
Tap water 45.92 4.03 38.0 7.6 4.4 1.6
a
Structural coef®cient is the ratio of the content of <0.002 mm particle fraction measured by distilled water to that measured by tap water
Table 5
Test results of permeability and leaching property of red mud. The results of chemical analysis for tag water: pH=7.62, degree of mineral-
ization=240.9 mg/l, the type of water quality belongs to HCO3 ±Ca2+
Sample Duration Filtration pH Na+ K+ Salt Natural Dry Water
number of time coef®cient value (mg l±1) (mg l±1) content density density content
(h) (´10±5 cm s±1) (mg l±1) (kN m±3) (kN m±3) (%)
1632-1 2.00 2.36 12.6 2,500.0 116.2 9,848 15.3 76.7 8.7
1632-2 3.40 3.40 12.3 857.0 60.0 2,732
1632-3 4.50 3.62 11.96 340.0 21.1 1,192
1632-4 5.75 3.48 11.87 290.0 15.0 956
1633-1 2.20 1.86 12.56 2,307.7 80.0 7,980 14.9 74.6 8.5
1633-2 3.50 2.36 12.22 660.0 31.0 2,048
1633-3 4.70 2.59 12.08 469.9 25.7 1,456
1633-4 5.92 2.57 11.85 285.0 4.3 868
1. Red mud is weakly permeable with a ®ltration coef®- water content (w>80%), which may arise from the
cient between 2.57´10±5 cm s±1 and 3.62´10±5 cm s±1, recrystallization of carbonates.
which is close to that of loess.
2. The ®ltration coef®cient of red mud affected by pene- Strength of red mud
trating water tends to increase gradually because An undrained shear test (direct shear test) with four
leaching of easily soluble salts and the ¯occulation of original samples was performed (Table 7). Despite the
Ca2+ lead to a rapid decrease of salts. The original high water content and low density, the shear strength was
content of salts within 6 h decreased by about ten times not low, with an internal friction angle (u) of 29±31°
from 8±10 g l±1 to 0.87±0.96 g l±1. Therefore, alkaliza- (higher than that of loess), and not a low cohesion(c). The
tion of groundwater and soil will inevitably occur after high shear strength is attributed to the high content of
storage of red mud. >0.01-mm coarse silt particles and ®ne sand particles
(>60%), and the recrystallization and cementation as
It should be pointed out that the strong alkalinity (with a discussed above. Furthermore, draining of samples during
pH value of >12.5, and a pH value of the leaching solution the test may also be responsible.
of up to11.7 after leaching for 6 h), is harmful to the Red mud exhibits a similar behaviour to saturated clay
ecological environment. when deformed, and the shear strain rate varies rapidly
with the increase in shear stress. Long conserved samples
Compressibility of red mud have a remarkably higher cohesion than that of the un-
The highly porous, wet red mud will become gradually conserved samples. Therefore, discontinuous ®lling of red
consolidated and compacted with increased dumping in mud waste may help improve the stability of the dam.
the tailings dam. Its compressibility will be lowered with
the duration of its storage as a result of the crystallization Contraction and disintegration durability of red
of the soluble salts from the pore solutions by desiccation mud
and the cementation caused by hydrophane (SiO2±nH2O), Red mud does not undergo volumetric shrinkage by
goethite (FeOOH), gibbsite [Al(OH)3] and sodium silicate exposure, but hardens with progressive drying. Hardened
(Na2SiO3), so that it becomes a less compressible non- red mud test pieces experience no disintegration when
metallic material. soaked, and neither expansion nor disintegration when a
The compressibility test results of original red mud sam- redried sample is immersed in water for some time, this is
ples from an aluminium factory in Shanxi province are because of recrystallization of CaCO3 and the diagenetic
given in Table 6, with a subsidence rate that ranges from cementation of red mud.
6.0 to 19.0 mm m±1 under a load of 0.1 MPa, and from
12.5 to 30.5 mm m±1 under a load of 0.2 MPa, and a Corrosion of red mud
compressibility factor (a1±2) of 0.218 to 0.433 MPa±1. Such Being of high water content, industrial waste contains
values show a medium compressibility that is not quite large amounts of strong alkaline materials such as NaOH,
compatible with their high porosity (e>2.0) and a high NaHCO3, Na2CO3, Na2SiO3, NaAlO2, so that red mud
Table 6
Results of compressibility test of red mud
Sample Water Natural Dry Void Subsidence rate (mm m±1) Modulus of Compression
number content density density ratio compressibility coef®cient
(%) (kN m±3) (kN m±3) 0.1 MPa 0.2 MPa (MPa) (MPa±1)
Table 7
Results of quick shear test of red mud
Sample Water Natural Dry Cohesion Angle of Remarks
number content density density (MPa) internal
(%) (kN m±3) (kN m±3) friction
(°)
1627 88.1 15.0 8.0 0.0125 30 The results of no. 1636 are obtained by
the sample conserved for 100 days
1629 87.2 14.9 7.9 0.04 29
1635 89.4 15.0 7.9 0.005 31
1636 84.3 14.8 8.1 0.075 29
wastes possess several kinds of corrosion. Some examples internal friction angle to approximately that of a soft rock
that appeared during the experimentation were (1) the (Table 8).
boxes for measuring water content were subjected to
considerable corrosion, which was caused by the reaction Reinforcement mechanisms
of aluminium with NaOH to form NaAlO2. (2) Quartz and The above augmentation in strength is thought to arise
glass are extraordinarily stable when put in neutral or from the following mechanisms:
acidic media; however, there appears to be extensive dis-
1. Heating effect. The reaction of quicklime with red mud
solution when the pH value of water exceeds 11. In dis-
leads to the formation of Ca(OH)2 with extensive
integration tests, the white salt deposits separated out,
emission of heat to cause vapourization of interstitial
distilled water changed into a strongly alkaline solution,
water to create enormous cavities (Fig. 2). Loss of water
and the inner wall of the beaker changed into a semi-
will thereby increase the strength of red mud waste. The
transparent rough surface. (3) Touching the red mud di-
rectly for a short period of time brought about pain, and
the skin became tender because of the alkaline conditions.
Because of the above, the drainage of red mud will cause a
series of environmental problems, such as threatening the
growth of crops and trees, and the safety of humans and
animals.
Table 8
Test results of red mud reinforcement by quicklime
Test Method of Duration Water Natural Dry Special Shear strength
order reinforcement of time content density density gravity
(day) (%) (kN m±3) (kN m±3) (c/MPa) u (°)
Table 9
Measurement results of pore size distribution in red mud and consolidated red mud by quicklime
Sample Quicklime Bulk Skeleton Total Total Median Average Distribution of pore size/lm, %
number supplement density density volume area of of pore of pore
(%) (g ml±1 (g ml±1 of pores pores size size >200 20020 202.0 2.00.2 <0.2
(ml g±1 (m2 g±1) (lm) (lm)
2050 0.0 1.134 2.269 0.441 6.747 0.691 0.262 3.40 7.93 20.40 40.80 27.47
2054 6.0 0.995 2.382 0.585 7.365 0.957 0.318 0.86 12.47 23.42 41.88 21.37
2053 10.0 1.014 2.456 0.579 12.057 0.537 0.192 2.59 21.57 12.95 25.02 37.87
2052 15.0 0.895 2.159 0.654 9.203 1.124 0.284 3.06 30.56 10.70 30.57 25.11
2051 20.0 1.056 2.298 0.512 13.770 0.191 0.149 0.98 2.92 10.74 34.16 51.20
distribution of different pore sizes of samples mixed accelerates the transformation of aragonite to calcite to
with different proportions of quicklime is determined form a ®rm crust. Thereby, it is best to stack the waste
by hydrargyrum pumping (Table 9). The abundance of in the reservoir at intervals of time other than the rainy
cavities enhances the permeability of red mud. season. It provides the most convenient way of rein-
2. Formation and cementation of carbonates. Secondary forcement without involving any additional invest-
calcite and acicular aragonite crystals produced by the ment.
reaction of Ca(OH)2 (formed by the process as stated
above) with carbon dioxide from the air will increase
the structural strength of red mud. The more quicklime Utilization of red mud waste
added, the stronger the cementation. As a kind of composite material mainly composed of su-
3. Formation and cementation of minerals of hydrous per-®ne grains of calcium carbonate, as well as several
aluminium-silicate. Authigenic platy minerals of hy- other kinds of minerals, red mud has a broad prospect of
drous aluminium-silicates formed by the reaction of utilization, especially after solution pumping and recy-
Ca(OH)2 with free oxides such as SiO2 and Al2O3 will cling.
result in an irreversible cementation of the mud waste.
1. It can be used as roadbed material instead of lime soil
in the plain area because of its high bearing strength
and durability.
2. Silicate cement produced from red mud is strong, sul-
phate- and frost-resistant, and inexpensive.
Control and utilization of red 3. Silicate fertilizer made from red mud is very suitable to
mud waste acid red soil, yellow soil and rice soil in south China
because it contains many trace elements, and is espe-
Reinforcement countermeasures for a red mud dam cially high in potassium and phosphate.
At present, red mud wastes produced in the world are
either dumped into the sea or piled up on land. In China,
they are mainly stored in a red mud dam. With the rapidly
rising height of mud-waste accompanying the develop-
ment of the aluminium industry, unforeseen disasters may Conclusions
occur. Consequently, to ensure the safety of dams, hazard
controls and for environmental protection the following Fresh red mud is a kind of soft, loose, earthy material,
engineering countermeasures are suggested. which has undesirable engineering properties such as high
water content that are liable to deformation and lique-
1. Shaking draining. Water retained in fresh red mud is a
faction. Nevertheless, after it is conserved or desiccated for
pore solution of various salts such as Na2CO3 and
a long period, its strength can obviously be increased, and
Na2SO4, which can be removed by shaking and vacuum
it undergoes no shrinkage or disintegration because of its
pumping through transformation of capillary water to
special chemical and mineral composition, and the irre-
free water. Meanwhile, the pumped solution can be
versible structural cementation formed during ageing and
recycled.
desiccation. It has been proved by experiments that ap-
2. Consolidation by draining. Rapid consolidation by
plying quicklime to red mud consolidation is an effective
draining is fundamental to the stability of a red mud
method. Moreover, the comprehensive utilization of red
dam. Therefore, it is necessary to drill drainage wells
mud can open up a new way for turning a harmful material
and lay a sand layer as a drainage cushion at the base of
into a valuable one that is of bene®t to society.
the waste mass for this purpose. The waste can thus be
half-consolidated. Acknowledgement The authors wish to thank Professor Chen
3. Reinforcement by desiccation. Desiccation of red mud Qingxuan and members of the Chinese Academy of Sciences for
can not only result in a reduction of water content, carefully reading the manuscript and for their constructive sug-
which increases the strength of the waste, but also gestions.