Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Astm 2149-01 Rest Antimicrobiana en Textiles
Astm 2149-01 Rest Antimicrobiana en Textiles
Krystyna Guzińska,
Antibacterial Activity of PLA Fibres
Marzena Dymel Estimated by Quantitative Methods
DOI: 10.5604/12303666.1191437
126 Kaźmierczak D, Guzińska K, Dymel M. Antibacterial Activity of PLA Fibres Estimated by Quantitative Methods.
FIBRES & TEXTILES in Eastern Europe 2016; 24, 2(116): 126-130. DOI: 10.5604/12303666.1191437
mer to confer bioactive properties. Table 1. Composition of PLA fibres put to microbiological examination.
The agent contains silver ions depos-
Fibre marking Composition of fibre
ited upon a ceramic matrix; particle size:
B PLA 6201D / Estesol PF 790
D 98% < 5 μm; D 50% = 2 μm. It was in
B/P PLA 6201D / Estesol PF 790/washed
the amount of 0.2 - 1.0 wt%, powdered B/S0.2 PLA 6201D / Estesol PF 790/0.2% Sanitized BCA 21-41
on the granulated polymer, and both B/S0.2/P PLA 6201D / Estesol PF 790/washed/0.2% Sanitized BCA 21-41
components were mixed in a tumbling B/S0.6 PLA 6201D / Estesol PF 790/0.6% Sanitized BCA 21-41
dryer. Estesol-PF-790 (poly-ethylen- B/S0.6/P PLA 6201D / Estesol PF 790/washed/0.6% Sanitized BCA 21-41
glycolester) from Bozzetto Group, Italy, B/S1.0 PLA 6201D / Estesol PF 790/1.0% Sanitized BCA 21-41
was applied on the fibre as a spinfinish in B/S1.0/P PLA 6201D / Estesol PF 790/washed/1.0% Sanitized BCA 21-41
the form of a 13% aqueous solution.
Test strains n the other from the American standard
The fibre was laundered in laboratory ASTM: E2149–01 [11].
Bacteria strains derived from the Ameri-
conditions in an ultrasonic washer at
can Type Culture Collection (ATCC)
30 °C with Persil powder, and 5-times JIS L 1902: 2002 Testing for
were used in the examination. Selected
rinsed in the same washer with distilled antibacterial activity and efficacy on
were microbes most popular in testing:
water. The action was repeated three textile products
times. One full cycle of laundering and Gram (-) Escherichia coli ATCC 11229
rinsing lasted 15 minutes. and Gram (+) Staphylococcus aureus Two samples of PLA, 0.5 g each, with
ATCC 6538. The strains were deep-fro- and without the biocidal agent and a cot-
Compositions of the fibres examined are zen stored in CrioBanks; their biochemi- ton reference fabric were used in the ex-
compiled in Table 1. cal features were regularly controlled, amination. All three materials were inoc-
and before the test they were multiplied ulated in three repetitions with a suspen-
A cotton fabric was used as a reference on nutritive agar. sion of bacteria at an adequate density at
sample in the JIS L 1902: 2002 standard a volume of 0.2 ml. The microbes were
Test methods leached from the materials by means of
[10]. It is typically applied in laboratories
as standard material devoid of microbi- Two methods were adopted for compari- standard saline with the addition of a sur-
cidal properties; 0.26 mm thick and of son of the methods to examine PLA mi- face-active substance and then planted on
97.7 g/m2 surface density. The absence crobiological activity: agar plates straight after inoculation and
of fabric activity is testament to the cor- n one from the Japanese standard JIS L after 24 hours of incubation at 37 °C.
rectness of the test. 1902: 2002 and The method is illustrated in Figure 1.
Figure 1. Scheme of method JIS L 1902: 2002. Figure 2. Scheme of the method as per ASTM: E2149 – 01.
FIBRES & TEXTILES in Eastern Europe 2016, Vol. 24, 2(116) 127
Table 2. Antibacterial activity of unwashed PLA fibres with z Sanitized estimated by stand- which means that the level of bacte-
ard JIS L 1902: 2002 against S. aureus. ria was undetectable after incubation.
Symbol of Time, Number of bacteria, Bacteriostatic Bactericidal Growth The activity against S. aureus in the fi-
sample h cfu/sample activity activity value bre tested amounted to 3.1 and 5.6, re-
reference 0 2.7 × 104
- -
- spectively, and 3.4 & 6.9 against E. coli.
reference 24 8.5 × 106 2.5 The results obtained are proof that pure
B 24
PLA exerts biocidal properties. In con-
B/S0.2 24
< 20 5.6 3.1 - tinuation of the analysis, the fibres were
B/S0.6 24
laundered three times. Results are pre-
B/S1.0 24
sented in Tables 4 & 5.
Table 3. Antibacterial activity of unwashed PLA fibres with z Sanitized estimated by stand- Bactericidal and bacteriostatic activ-
ard JIS L 1902: 2002 against E. coli.
ity of PLA fibres with and without the
Symbol of Time, Number of bacteria, Bacteriostatic Bactericidal Growth Sanitized additive was high or very high
sample h cfu/sample activity activity value
against both strains. It was only PLA
reference 0 5.3 × 104 -
- - holding 0.2% of the additive where activ-
reference 24 1.5 × 108 3.5
ity against E. coli was down after laun-
B 24
B/S0.2 24
dering.
< 20 6.9 3.4 -
B/S0.6 24
B/S1.0 24 The activity of the same fibres against
the same strains was tested by another
quantitative shaking flask method ac-
Knowing the number of bacteria on the at 37 °C. 1 ml of the suspension was
cording to Standard ASTM: E2149 – 01.
reference sample before incubation and collected from each of the flasks, and
Presented are the numbers of bacteria for
that of bacteria that survived on the ref- the number of bacteria was estimated by
erence and test samples after the incuba- the method of decimal dilution on nutri- both repetitions and the arithmetic mean
tion with microbes, the bacteriostatic and ent agar. Incubation was made from ei- of logarithmic and percentage reduction.
bactericidal activity is calculated from ther dilution onto two parallel plates. The results are compiled in Tables 6 & 7.
the formulae:
S = M b - Mc The result of the analysis is presented as Unwashed PLA fibres containing
L = Ma - Mc a reduction in the number of bacteria cal- the bactericidal agent showed antibacte-
where: S – value of bacteriostatic ac- culated from the formula: rial activity, which was highest for a 1%
tivity, L - value of bactericidal activity, B−A and lowest for a 0.2% content of Sani-
Reduction,%,
Reduction, %,CFU /m
CFU/mll == × 100
Ma – common logarithm of the bacteria B tized. Pure PLA used as reference did not
number on the sample without the ac- or reveal activity when tested by the Shak-
tive agent straight after inoculation, Reduction, log = (log B - log A)
ing Flask Method. The average number
Mb - common logarithm of the bacteria where:
of E. coli cells after 1 hour of incubation
number on the sample without the active A = cfu of 1 ml in the tested sample af-
was close to that in the buffer without
agent after 24-hours of incubation, Mc - ter 1 hour, B = cfu of 1 ml estimated in
the sample i.e. in the inoculum.
common logarithm of the bacteria num- the starting suspension before the addi-
ber on the sample with the active agent tion of the sample (time 0).
Fibres with the bactericidal agent washed
after 24-hours of incubation three times were much less antibacterial
Standard ASTM: E2149 – 01 does not
quote any criteria to define the level of than those unwashed.
According to standard JIS L 1902:2002,
a value of bactericidal activity (L) higher antibacterial properties in the textiles
tested. A scheme of the method is pre- A higher content of Sanitized produced
than zero is an indication of bactericidal
sented in Figure 2 (see page 127). higher antibacterial activity.
activity, while bacteriostatic properties
begin with (S) values exceeding 2,
The highest reduction in activity was
n Results of investigation after laundering with fibres containing
ASTM: E2149 – 01 ”Standard
Test Method for Determining the Tables 2 & 3 present results of the ex- 0.2% of the bactericidal agent. Activity
Antimicrobial Activity of Immobilized amination of unwashed PLA fibres tested against S. aureus dropped from 98.94%
Antimicrobial Agents Under Dynamic according to JIS L 1902: 2002 against to 8.49% reduction, and against E. coli
Contact Conditions”- Shaking Flask E. coli and S. aureus. from 99.51% to 2.64%. The order of
Method magnitude of the number of units making
A sample of 1 g of fibres was put into The PLA fibres tested revealed high an- the colony is thus decreased by two or-
a 250 ml conical flask and flooded with tibacterial activity. With three concentra- ders. The decrease was lower in the sam-
buffer 0.3 mM KH2PO4 with bacteria at tions of the bactericidal agent: 0.2, 0.6, ple with 0.6% content of Sanitized in
a density of 3.0 × 105 cfu/ml. Samples 1.0% as well as with the PLA sample the case of S. aureus. The sample with
in two repetitions and a reference with- without Sanitized, maximal bactericidal 1% Sanitized attained, in spite of laun-
out a sample were incubated for 1 hour and bacteriostatic activity was achieved, dering, a high percentage of reduction
128 FIBRES & TEXTILES in Eastern Europe 2016, Vol. 24, 2(116)
n Discussion Table 4. Antibacterial activity of washed PLA fibres with Sanitized estimated by standard
JIS L 1902: 2002 against S. aureus.
Differing results were attained in the
Symbol of Number of bacteria, Bacteriostatic Bactericidal Growth
examination by different methods for sample
Time, h
cfu/sample activity activity value
the same PLA samples with a low con- reference 0 4.60 × 104 -
- -
tent of the antibacterial additive Sanitized reference 4.30 × 106 1.9
and without it. Only fibres with the high- B/P
est content of Sanitized showed in both B/S0.2/P 24
< 20 5.3 3.4 -
tests the same high antibacterial activity. B/S0.6/P
B/S1.0/P
The divergence ensues from the different
methods in both standards, which provide Tabela 5. Antibacterial activity of washed PLA fibres with Sanitized estimated by standard
for dissimilar contact of bacteria with JIS L 1902: 2002 against E. coli.
the sample. As per ASTM: E2149 – 01,
Symbol of Number of bacteria, Bacteriostatic
the samples tested are immersed for sample
Time, h
cfu/sample activity
Bactericidal activity Growth value
1 hour in a voluminous buffer with a sus- reference 0 1.0 × 105 -
- -
pension of microbes, while according to reference 1.1 × 108 3.0
Standard JIS L 1902:2002, the textiles B/P 2.9 × 103 4.5 1.5
are incubated for 24 hours with a small B/S0.2/P 24 1.1 ×103 5.0 2.0
-
amount of bacteria suspension. B/S0.6/P
< 20 6.7 3.7
B/S1.0/P
Longer incubation time and a higher
amount of the active substance in propor- Table 6. Bactericidal activity against S. aureus of unwashed and washed PLA fibres con-
tion to the number of cells and volume taining Sanitized estimated according to Standard ASTM: E2149 – 01.
of the bacteria suspension are the reasons
Unwashed fibre Washed fibre
for a stronger impact of the active sub- Symbol of Average Average
stance upon the microorganisms. The ac- sample cfu/ml
Average
reduction, cfu/ml
Average
reduction,
reduction, % reduction, %
tivity of pure PLA against bacteria, re- log log
vealed particularly in the test according Inoculum 1.78 × 105 - - 1.09 × 105 - -
to JIS L 1902:2002, probably results from B 6.87 × 104 61.40 0.52 1.39 × 105 -27.52 -0.11
the migration of lactide from the fibre to B/S0.2 1.83 × 103 98.94 2.00 9.98 × 104 8.49 0.04
B/S0.6 5.25 × 100 100.00 4.53 2.75 × 102 99.75 2.60
the medium. It is known that lactide ex-
B/S1.0 <1 100.00 5.25 9.25 × 100 99.99 4.07
erts a strong antibacterial and antifungal
activity [3, 12]
Table 7. Bactericidal activity against E. coli of unwashed and washed PLA fibres contain-
All PLA samples were also tested af- ing Sanitized estimated according to Standard ASTM: E2149 – 01.
ter laundering, which was to remove Unwashed fibre Washed fibre
the lactide and examine the durability of Symbol of Average Average Average Average
the Sanitized application. sample cfu/ml reduction reduction cfu/ml reduction reduction
% log % log
Inoculum 2.01 × 105 - - 2.27 × 105 - -
In method JIS L 1902:2002, a decrease
B 1.77 × 105 12.19 0.06 2.21 × 105 2.86 0.01
in activity in the washed samples was
B/S0.2 9.93 × 102 99.51 2.31 2.21 × 105 2.64 0.01
observed only in the case of E. coli for
B/S0.6 1.20 × 102 99.94 3.22 4.26 × 102 99.81 2.73
samples without Santized or with its low- B/S1.0 <1 100.00 5.30 <2 100.00 5.05
est content of 0.2%, while in method
ASTM: E2149 a substantial fall of ac-
tivity in the same samples occurred both As can be seen, the antibacterial activ- particularly manifested with the Japanese
with E. coli and S. aureus. According to ity of the samples tested may stem from method, which is more sensitive due to
both methods, the washing did not affect the presence of substances that were not the longer incubation time of the bacteria
the activity of the samples with 1% of added as antibacterial agents. The pres- on the sample and the small volume of
Sanitized; it was not leached to the extent ence of such substances may be typical the suspension in proportion to the sam-
which would imply a decrease in antibac- for the sample material or they might ple mass. Such conditions are the reason
terial activity. have been generated by the process of
why PLA samples without the active ad-
fibre spinning. PLA 6201D, accord-
ditive or with its low content revealed
The drop in activity in samples without ing to the manufacturer [13], contains
up to 0.5% of unreacted lactide, which strong antibacterial activity.
Sanitized probably results from the re-
moval of lactide in the course of wash- may go up in the course of melt spin-
ing. The decrease in activity in washed ning as a result of thermal degradation of For the interpretation of test results ac-
samples with 0.2% Sanitized could have the polymer. In an aqueous medium, lac- cording to Standard JIS L 1902:2002,
been caused by the removal of both lac- tide yields lactic acid, which confers an- criteria are available that indicate
tide and the active agent. tibacterial properties upon the fibre. It is the sample is active if the value of bacte-
FIBRES & TEXTILES in Eastern Europe 2016, Vol. 24, 2(116) 129
riostatic activity S > 2 and that of bacte- for a given method ought to constitute włókienniczych, Przegląd Włókienniczy
ricidal activity L > 0. a part of all standards. – Włókno, Odzież, Skóra 2008; 11.
3. Grossman R F and Nwabunma D. Poly
Standard ASTM: E2149 does not con- (lactic acid) Synthesis, structures, prop-
erties, processing, and applications,
tain criteria for the evaluation of results n Conclusions John Wiley & Sons, INC., Publication
i.e. at which a reduction in the cell num- 2010: 445-456.
1. Results of the testing of microbio-
ber of the sample can be recognized as 4. Wiegand C, Abel M, Ruth P and Elsner
logical activity are comparable only
active. The lack of criteria may lead P. Uta-Christina Hipler, In vitro assess-
if they were derived by the use of ment of the antimicrobial activity of
toward false inferences. To give an ex-
the same examination method. wound dressings: influence of the test
ample: evaluating the reduction in S.
2. Due to the multitude of available method selected and impact of the pH.
aureus cells at a level of 61.40%, one J Mater Sci: Mater Med 2015; 26: 18.
methods, information about the meth-
may deduce that the PLA sample without 5. Wang Hongbo, Wei Qufu, Wang Xi, Gao
od applied must always be given
the Sanitized additive revealed strong Weidong and Zhao Xiaoyan. Antibacteri-
whenever test results are announced al Properties of PLA Nonwoven Medical
antibacterial activity. It must, however,
concerning biological activity. Dressings Coated with Nanostructured
be noted that the decrease in the cell num-
3. When the results of antibacterial ac- Silver. Fibres and Polymers 2008; 9, 5:
ber is rather modest, from 1.78 × 105 to 556-560.
6.87 × 104 cfu/ml on average, respond- tivity examination are construed, ex-
6. Joo Min Jung, Merkel C, Auras R and Al-
ing to the reduction at a level of 0.52 log. cept the activity factor indicated in menar E. Development and characteri-
Such a value can be recognized as the standard, the initial and final level zation of antimicrobial poly(l-lactic acid)
meaningless, since a high concentra- of bacteria (cfu) on the sample tested containing trans-2-hexenal trapped in
tion of the bacteria cell was preserved must be taken into account. It is par- cyclodextrins. International Journal of
ticularly important if no criteria exist Food Microbiology 2012; 153: 297–305.
in the medium. In the standard ASTM: 7. Kurtycz P, Karwowska E, Ciach T,
E2149, high activity is observed when to assess the results Olszyna A and Kunicki A. Biodegradable
the bacteria number drops from the 105 4. Selection of the method for a given Polylactide (PLA) Fibre Mats Contain-
level to 101 , responding to a decrease of material is crucial in the assessment of ing Al2O3-Ag Nanopowder Prepared by
4 in the logarithm scale and reduction of antibacterial activity. As was shown Electrospinning Technique - Antibacte-
with the instance of PLA fibres, test- rial Properties. Fibres and Polymers
around 99.9%. 2013; 14, 8: 1248-1253.
ing according to Standard JIS L 8. Xu Xiaoyi, Yang Qingbiao, Wang Yong-
The lack of criteria in the standard in- 1902:2002 allows the detection of zhi, Yu Haijun, Chen Xuesi and Jing Xia-
duces the adoption of own assumptions activity resulting from the presence of bin. Biodegradable electrospun poly(L-
for the interpretation of results. Pinto et lactide/lactide acid, in contrast to the lactide) fibrescontaining antibacterial
ASTM method, which did not pro- silver nanoparticles. European Polymer
al. [14] consider a drop in the cell number Journal 2006; 42:2081–2087.
by one order of magnitude in proportion duce such results. .
9. Nguyena Thuy Thi Thu, Chungb Ok Hee
to the initial value as testament of sam- 5. In the examination of PLA fibres, and Parka Jun Seo. Coaxial electrospun
ple activity. Recognition of the samples the Shake Flask Method (ASTM: poly(lactic acid)/chitosan (core/shell)
tested as active according to such criteria E2149 – 01:2010) appeared adequate composite nanofibres and their antibac-
because it allowed to reveal the im- terial activity. Carbohydrate Polymers
may not necessarily mean sufficient ef- 2011,86: 1799– 1806.
ficiency in the intended use. pact of Sanitized concentration upon
10. JIS L 1902:2002, Testing for antibacte-
the fibre activity. rial activity and efficacy on textile prod-
It is worth remembering that an infection 6. Laundering caused a partial removal ucts, Japanese Industrial Standards
may be initiated even when an insignifi- of lactide from the fibre, which was Committee.
cant cell number survives despite con- demonstrated by the decrease in ac- 11. ASTM E2149-01, Standard Test Method
tivity of the PLA fibres in the ASTM for Determining the Antimicrobial Activity
tact with the sample, for instance bioac-
method. In the Japanese method, the of Immobilized Antimicrobial Agents Un-
tive dressing. One infectious inoculum
der Dynamic Contact Conditions, ASTM
i.e. a minimal number of bacteria to start residual lactide preserved the activity
International, West Conshohocken, PA,
an infection cannot be established for all of the washed fibres. 2001.
microorganisms. According to Schmidt- 12. Mutsuga M, Kawamura Y and Tanamoto
Hempel et alii [15], various pathogens Acknowlegment K. Migration of lactic acid, lactide and
are characterised by different minimal oligomers from polylactide food-con-
The work was done within the framework of tact materials. Food Addit. 2008; Oct,
infectious doses of cells depending on 25(10): 1283-90.
the project „Biodegradable fibrous products”
the type and place where the infection 13. Patent US 6506873.
(Biogratex) – POIG.01.03.01-00-007-/08-00
develops. Some pathogens may begin 14. Pinto RJB, Marques PAAP, Neto CP,
infection from a small number of cells Trindade T, Daina S and Sadocco P.
in the start phase. Only 10 cells consti- References Antibacterial activity of nanocomposites
of silver and bacterial or vegetable cel-
tute an infectious inoculum in the case of
1. Dymel M, Gutarowska B, Więckowska- lulosic fibres. Acta Biomaterialia 2009;
the enterhemorhagic strain Escherichia Szakiel M and Ciechańska D. Me- 5, 6: 2279-2289.
coli, while others like Vibrio cholerae tody ilościowe oceny aktywności 15. Schmid-Hempel P and Frank S A.
need a lot of cells (from 103 to 108) to przeciwdrobnoustrojowej wyrobów Pathogenesis, Virulence, and Infective
effectively infect the host organism. włókienniczych, Przegląd Włókienniczy Dose. PLoS Pathog. 2007; 3(10): e147.,
– Włókno, Odzież, Skóra 2009; 3. Marianne Manchester, Editor 88u.
2. Dymel M, Gutarowska B, Więckowska-
In investigations concerned with antibac- Szakiel M and Ciechańska D. Me-
terial properties, criteria are needed to tody jakościowe oceny aktywności
evaluate the results. Such criteria unified przeciwdrobnoustrojowej wyrobów Received 13.07.2015 Reviewed 12.01.2016
130 FIBRES & TEXTILES in Eastern Europe 2016, Vol. 24, 2(116)