Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Running Tight 4-Hour Dungeon World One-Shots
With Zero Preparation
by John Aegard
INTRODUCTION
My literary background is in short genre fiction, so when I run a one-shot of Dungeon World, I
want our game to resemble a simple, traditional fantasy adventure story -- a story in which
some characters travel somewhere, do something, and in the end are all changed by the
journey.
I also don’t want to do any preparation beforehand. I don’t want to show up with a setting or a
scenario or a situation. For one, that’s work, and I’m lazy. For two, I don’t want to be telling
my story, I want to be helping to tell our story. I want everyone to contribute ideas. I don’t
believe that players have to always squeeze their contributions through the narrow aperture
of their character. I want all the important stuff about our game to happen right there at the
table, not in my head beforehand.
I’ve evolved some techniques that help me hit this mark pretty consistently. If you want to
run tight Dungeon World one-shots, these may be helpful to you!
In my experience, these techniques work for an absolute maximum of five player characters.
At five, the spotlight time is squeezed pretty thin, especially during fights. I think 3-4 is the
optimal number.
CHARACTER CREATION
Players select their playbooks and fill out everything as usual, saving Bonds for later. Don't go
around the table and have them introduce their characters. We'll learn about the
characters by learning about their relationship to the story. See my list of common DW
character creation confusions in Appendix D.
SETTING QUESTIONS
Ask one of these questions to get the baseline of the setting down. I like to direct these
questions at playbooks that intrinsically suggest a place: the Druid, Ranger, Barbarian, or
Thief.
Here are some examples:
Druid, what is your homeland? How is it beautiful?
Ranger, what lands do you range? How are they beautiful?
Barbarian, what is this land you have traveled to? How is it strange?
Thief, what are your stomping grounds?
Anyone, what is this place you have traveled to?
You can ask other players some follow-on questions if you want to butter up the setting:
Bard, when was the last time you were here? What was the place like then? How has it
changed?
Bard, what does your <bard’s chosen expertise> say is special about this place?
Cleric, why do pilgrims of <cleric’s god> come to this place? Why is this place special to
the god of <cleric’s chosen domain>?
Fighter, what battle was fought here? Who fought it?
Thief, what have you stolen from here before?
Wizard, why is this place a place of power? What kind of rituals are held here? What
ritual would you conduct here?
PREMISE QUESTIONS
By “premise,” I mean “what are the characters doing and why?” Premise generation is the
most critical part of this setup.
HOW MANY PREMISES? In my experience, it definitely works to have multiple distinct
premises in a four-player game. Sometimes they'll tangle up in weird ways in the final scene,
which is usually pretty satisfying. Having just one premise is fine too; it’ll just make the game
simpler.
THE FINAL DESTINATION: Make sure that all premises point towards a single location on
your map. That's the location where your final scene will take place. I'm going to talk about
that location a bunch, so I'll give it a name and call it the Final Destination.
When you make the first premise, the space you assign it to becomes the Final Destination. If
you establish another premise, make sure it references that Final Destination.
Here are some basic questions that will establish premise:
Paladin, what is your quest?
Thief, what have you come here to steal?
Wizard, what magic or mystery draws you here?
Cleric, what prophecy are you trying to fulfill or thwart here?
Druid, what troubles this land, and how can these adventurers help?
Barbarian, what appetite has brought you here? How will you satisfy it?
Bard, what legend drew you here? What do you hope to see while you are here?
Anyone, why are you traveling to this place?
Once you've established premises, it's time to tangle the party in them. You'll use your GM
skills to draw triangles between two characters and the premise in classic Apocalypse World
fashion.
You can use player-premise-player triangles to place characters in tension. For example:
<GM> Paladin, what is your quest?
<Paladin> I'm here to prevent the Necromancer from completing her spell.
<GM> Thief, what do you need to steal from the Necromancer?
<GM> Wizard, are you still friends with the Necromancer? Where did you first meet her?
<GM> Fighter, who do you know who is a thrall of the Necromancer?
If you’d like a less contentious game, you can use also use triangles to make characters'
objectives complement each other. For example:
<GM> Druid, what troubles this land?
<Druid> The swamp dragon Poxtoxalis, who takes too much prey.
<GM> Fighter, why do you want to slay Poxtoxalis?
<GM> Thief, what have you stolen from Poxtoxalis?
<GM> Ranger, what happened when you tried to hunt Poxtoxalis?
BEYOND DEATH’S DOOR LIES THE PREMISES: The Last Breath move is a killer feature of
Dungeon World and in my experience players really respond to it. To showcase it, you need a
great Death bargain, so let's make one here.
Put on your evil GM cap and consider your premises. Think about what's going to happen if
the characters don't intervene -- just like if you were creating an Impending Doom for an
adventure front. If you haven't got any ideas, then just ask. "Paladin, why are you trying to
seize the Book of Elite Summonings from the archmage Doorva? Why can't he be allowed to
keep it? What is he going to do with it?"
When someone does shuffle off, have them roll Last Breath as normal. On the 7-9 result, Death
offers a bargain: if the dying character vows to help make the Impending Doom come true,
Death will let them go free! Consider treating the 2-6 result as the 7-9 result. These bargains
are hella fun.
Also, keep that Impending Doom in mind for all the usual reasons -- like when you want to
rock show signs of an approaching threat or reveal an unwelcome truth.
OPPOSITION QUESTIONS
Ask one or more of the following questions to get ideas about the opposition.
Bard or Wizard, why do you need protection when you travel here?
Cleric or Paladin, what enemies of your faith dwell here?
Druid, who troubles your land?
Fighter or Barbarian, what have you come here to slay? Why do you hate or fear them?
Thief, who controls this territory?
Ranger, what beasts hunt these lands?
Anyone, who else in the world wants to achieve <premise>?
Anyone, what is guarding <premise>?
MORE QUESTIONS!
Dungeon World warlock Tim Franzke has compiled a wonderful list of playbook-specific GM
hints that will help you be a fan of the characters. Check it out for more ideas about how to
tailor your DW game to your party.
BONDS
After you’ve got enough Q&A to establish your scenario, ask each character to write one Bond.
If they need a little prompting, here are some questions you can ask that address standard
Bonds:
Barbarian, who here nearly got you killed? How?
Bard, who here have you traveled with before?
Cleric, who here do you trust as a good and faithful person? Why?
Druid, who here have you shared a secret rite of the land with? Why did you trust them?
Fighter, who here have you sworn to protect?
Paladin, who here has stood beside you in battle?
Ranger, who here have you guided before?
Thief, who here knows incriminating details about you? <Other Player>, what do you
know?
Wizard, who here will play an important role in the events to come?
And here are some questions that could create alternate Bonds:
Barbarian, who here would fit in in your homeland? Who would you invite to come
home with you?
Bard, who here have you heard of before? What did you hear about them?
Cleric, who did you once refuse to heal? Why?
Wizard, who here are you experimenting on? What have you done to them?
THE MONSTERS
Make sure you know why the monsters are there--it should be relevant to something revealed
in Q&A. Perhaps they are pawns of the big boss sent to fight the party, or perhaps they are
competing for the same goals as the party.
If people have contributed ideas about the opposition, then definitely use those ideas to create
these monsters.
My practice is to staff the first encounter with a mob of 6-10 mildly threatening little guys,
4HP, Armor 0, d6 damage, with an attack move that makes them a bit interesting and a
mobility move that'll prevent the battlefield from becoming too static.
My go-to intro monster is something with an entangling move -- a net, a whip, a prehensile
tongue, etc. I've used toad cultists with long item-stealing toad tongues, spider cultists with
spinnerets , jackal-headed Anubites with whips. I'll usually give some of them wings or
jumping or burrowing or swimming too -- some movement power that I can use to break up
the hit point grind. (see the Appendix)
Do not use familiar boring old monsters like orcs, goblins, kobolds,etc in the first
encounter. You want the party to be curious about the things they're fighting, to be asking
questions and triggering knowledge-gathering moves like Spout, Discern, and Bardic Lore.
SCENE TWO: THE BRANCH
Okay, the first encounter is done. Now we're going to figure out how the party is going to get
to the final location. Put three location cards in a row between their current location and the
final location. Let these locations be inspired by anything from the Q&A - the Ranger may
have mentioned that she's traveled some mountains, or the Thief may mention a secret
entrance via the sewers.
Tell them that they can travel to the final location via any of those new locations.
Once they make their choice, hit them with an encounter featuring an unusual monster that's
suited to demonstrate the power of fictional positioning. My favorite here is to use a
petrification monster like a basilisk or a medusa. These are notorious foes that can't be
simply fought, they need to be outwitted and outmaneuvered.
Also, partial petrification is a fun thing to do to a player character; I start with eyes, nose, and
hair. It's even more fun when you've got a self-sacrificing Paladin in the party who's eager to
show off their moral rectitude with a Lay On Hands, or a Wizard who wants to improvise an
anti-petrification ritual.
You can do other things in Scene 2 as well. Consider hitting them with a Location move
appropriate to the path they chose -- get them lost in the woods, expose them to the elements
in the desert, and so forth. You could also show an opportunity to give them some allies or
some help in the final battle -- perhaps a rebel camp full of soldiers they can recruit, an
itinerant wizard who knows useful things, a disgruntled henchmen with a map or a password,
etc.
Chimera-Hydra
huge magical construct
Goat Heads (2): b[2d8] damage, 10 hit points each, 3 armor, forceful
● Knock them flying
Lion Heads (2): b[2d12] damage, 10 hits points each, 2 armor, messy
● Stun them with a roar
● Shake and break them
Flame Serpent Heads (2): b[2d10] damage, 10 hit points each, 2 armor, reach
● Belch a cone of fire
● Strike perfectly in the dark
● Inject venom that boils blood
Body: b[2d8] damage, 16 hit points, 1 armor
● Regenerate a head
● Trample underfoot
● Fly clumsily
Whatever monster you use, put some interesting terrain in the encounter area. Elevation is
always a winner, especially elevation that doesn’t hamper the boss monster’s attacks. Set up
water to drown in and fire to burn in. A theater / coliseum / bleacher full of spectators is a
good add too; nothing gets under a gladiator's skin like a taunt from a drunk man-frog
merchant. Maybe the spectators throw sour tomatoes or bricks, doing 1d4 / blinding damage
Even while the big battle is raging, there's probably premise stuff to be addressed -- items to
be stolen, princes to be rescued, rituals to conduct, etc. Draw the characters' eyes to these.
Use show them opportunities to get them thinking about the stuff they desire. Tempt them to
place their interests over those of the party.
Play hard enough so they'll go visit Death.
Then, once the fight's over, the party will have to resolve the tangles in their premises. In my
experience, this is the highest-energy part of the game, especially if there's contention. PvP is
not unknown to me here. Sit back and enjoy what you have wrought.
EPILOGUE
Okay, it's the end of the game and things have resolved! Go around the table, ending on the
character who had the most dramatic stuff happen to them. Ask each player in turn to narrate
a short epilogue describing their life in the wake of the adventure. I love epilogues; they're a
nice opportunity for players to solo a bit, let down their defenses, and just say pure story that
the GM can't mess with.
Also, you should describe epilogues for any of your favorite NPCs or locations as well.
That's it! Thank everyone for playing and maybe debrief a bit if there's time.
APPENDICES: VARIOUS REMARKS ON DUNGEON WORLD PLAY
APPENDIX A: DEFY DANGER ADVICE
I find the 7-9 result on Defy Danger can be very tough to adjudicate. Here's some guidance for
how to make those results fun.
LOOK TO YOUR MOVES: To make a worse outcome, look at Defy like this:
10+: PC defies danger
7-9: PC defies danger + GM makes a move.
6- : GM makes a move
Say Omar the Thief is running from the city guard and rolls a 7-9 with the Danger being that
he's caught. As the GM, I'm going to grant Omar his escape. But I can also:
● Use a monster, danger, or location move -- Omar accidentally runs into a vogue of
Necrodancers and gets hit by their Fresh Curse move.
● Deal damage -- Omar sprains his ankle while running.
● Use up their resources -- Omar drops some of his loot while getting away.
● Put them in a spot -- Omar escapes pursuit....but stumbles into the ogre pit.
● Separate them -- Omar gets lost!
WORSE OUTCOMES CAN BE SOFTENED INTO UGLY CHOICES You can turn a worse
outcome into a hard bargain by explaining the worse outcome and asking the player to choose
between eating the danger or suffering the worse outcome. I think this softens the move
somewhat; you're collaborating with the player on their fate rather than just imposing it.
PUT SOMEONE ELSE IN THE CROSSHAIRS. Is another character in a questionable position?
Can they suffer the downside of the 7-9?
Say Omar has leapt aboard a panicking wooly mammoth and is trying to calm it while
Sanguinus the Paladin battles the crocodile folk nearby. The Danger for Omar is that the
mammoth will continue rampaging and throw him. The Worse Outcome version is that Omar
calms the mammoth, but not before it has bowled over Sanguinus.
Say Omar is creeping through the quarantine districts, looting the houses of the dead. The
Danger is that he gets the plague. On a 7-9, Omar doesn't get sick ... but he becomes a carrier,
and his friend Bug picks it up some time later.
Say Omar is reading the Canticle of Sog-Yothoth aloud to close the Murder Gate (danger: the
magic melts his sanity) while Xeno the Wizard casts their Mirror Image spell to distract some
cultists. The Murder Gate is closed with no harm to Omar but the flux of freaky energy results
in Xeno's mirror image becoming a permanent, independent, reverse-alignment version of
Xeno.
Sometimes I will totally cheat at this and cut away to another character just before a Defy
Danger move is rolled so that the situation can develop some more facets before we start
messing it up with mixed successes.
CONSIDER IMPLIED DANGERS AT EVERY TIME SCALE: I usually categorize dangers as
immediate dangers, scene dangers, or campaign dangers. I group them by asking when the
pain from the danger will come down. If it will come down right away, it's an immediate
danger. If it will come down by the end of the scene, it's a scene danger. If it will come down
sometime later, it's a campaign danger.
For example, let's say that Omar the Thief is jumping from rooftop to rooftop (immediate
danger: he falls) trying to escape the guard (scene danger: he's caught) while also remaining
anonymous (campaign danger: he's identified). That's three dangers in the single action. One
of these must be the stated Danger of the Defy Danger.
Let's say that the Danger is that he falls. The complications of the mixed success can be that he
makes the leap and escapes, but he is clearly identified by his pursuers and his anonymity is
toast. Another possibility is that he makes the leaps safely but so do his pursuers and so he
has to figure out another tactic to elude them.
Alternatively, say the Danger is that he's caught. On a mixed success, he might elude pursuit --
by falling and spraining his ankle while the pursuit concentrates on the rooftops. Or he will
escape, but lose his anonymity.
THANKS TO
Gray Pawn, Morgan Stinson, Ross Cowman, Erich Lichnock, Philip LaRose, Jamie Fristrom, Jay
Loomis, Victoria Garcia, and everyone else I’ve ever played with experimented on at Games
on Demand.
FURTHER READING
● Play Unsafe by Graham Walmsley is an outstanding guide to the use of improvisational
techniques in tabletop RPGs.
● Things To Do In the First Session of Your Dungeon World Game by Tim Franzke has a
lot of terrific suggestions that will help you to be a fan of the characters.
FURTHER CONVERSATIONS
See my other game stuff at http://john.aegard.com.
If you’d like to talk about this further, you can circle me up on Google Plus, which is where I
have most of my RPG conversations these days. I welcome your comments and war stories!
REVISION HISTORY
2014-09-23: Initial publication.
2015-08-12: Added new Bonds Aid or Interfere move.
2019-08-21: softened statements to opinions