Professional Documents
Culture Documents
WARGAMING.NET LLP
Plaintiff,
Civil Action No. 12 CV __________
v.
(Jury Trial Demanded)
WORLDOFTANKSHOP.COM, XIAO CHEN,
SHIJIE ZHAO, and JOHN DOES
Defendants.
Xiao Chen, Shijie Zhao, and John Does 1-5 d/b/a Mr. Boss (collectively “Defendants”) states as
follows:
NATURE OF CASE
piracy, unfair competition, and false designation of origin under the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. §§
1114, 1125(a), 1125(d), and for copyright infringement under the Copyright Act, 17 U.S.C. §
THE PARTIES
Plaintiff Wargaming.net
company—is a limited liability partnership organized under the laws of the United Kingdom and
has a principle place of business at Office 415, 60 Cannon Street, London EC4N 6NP, United
Kingdom
m.
features mid-20th
m cen
ntury era fig
ghting vehiclles. Users leearn about, ddownload, annd play WO
ORLD
OF TAN
NKS® on Waargaming.nett’s web site at http://WoorldofTanks.ccom (reprodduced below)).
Deefendants
5. On in
nformation and
a belief, and
a based onn Domain N
Name Servicce (DNS) loookup
Address of 108.16.32
21.98.
6. On in
nformation and
a belief, th
he Americann Registry fo
for Internet N
Numbers (A
ARIN)
7. On in
nformation and belief, th
he headquartters for SinggleHop and its two Chiccago-
area dataa centers aree located in this judiciall district resspectively att: 621 W. R
Randolph Stt. 3rd
Floor, Ch
hicago, Illinois; 2200 Bu
usse Road, Elk
E Grove V
Village, Illinnois; and 6011 W. Polk S
Street,
hosted on
n a server with
w an IP Address
A of 108.16.321.9
1 98 in this juudicial distriict that is ow
wned
and/or op
perated by SingleHop in this judiciall district.
9. nd belief, Deefendants W
On information an WorldofTankS
Shop.com, X
Xiao Chen, S
Shijie
Zhao, an
nd John Does 1-5 d/b/a Mr. Boss arre fictitious business naame(s), owneer(s), operattor(s),
and/or ad
dministratorr(s) for the accused
a web
b site http:///WorldofTannkShop.com
m and, inter alia,
have con
ntract(s) and
d/or arrangeements(s) with
w SingleH
Hop to host the web siite on serveers in
using em
mail addressses such as
a webepay
yee@live.com
m, ecoinwaays.com@gm
mail.com, aand/or
geoepay@
@ymail.com
m; target customers in th
his judicial ddistrict throuugh the webb site in Chicago;
content on
o their web site in Chicaago.
10. The lo
ocations of Defendants are unknow
wn. Furtherr, the domaiin name reggistrar
http://wh
ho.godaddy.ccom/whois.aaspx?domain
n=worldoftannkshop.com&
&prog_id=G
GoDaddy
(reproducced below).
JURISDICT
J TION AND VENUE
transact business
b witthin this judicial districtt, and have ccommitted vviolations off the Lanham
m Act
and Copy
yright Act heere.
GENERAL
L ALLEGA
ATIONS
14
4. Wargaaming.net is
i the owneer of Uniteed States T
Trademark R
Registrationn No.
goods an
nd services recited thereiin (“Wargam
ming.net Loggo”), a true and correct copy of whiich is
attached as Exhibit A,
A and is shown below.
16. Wargaaming.net has made usee of the Warrgaming.nett Logo sincee December 1999
17. Wargaaming.net co
oined the traademark andd service maark (collectivvely “the M
Mark”)
WORLD
D OF TANKS® and mad
de use of thee mark WOR
RLD OF TA
ANKS® since at least as early
for WOR
RLD OF TAN
NKS® in In
nternational classes
c 009, 016, and 0441 for the gooods and serrvices
recited th
herein, a truee and correctt copy of wh
hich is attachhed as Exhibbit B.
Logo rep
produced bellow (WoT Logo):
association with Wargaming.net’s goods and services for WORLD OF TANKS®. Further, on
23. The Wargaming.net Logo, the Mark, and the WoT Logo have been used
extensively and continuously by Wargaming.net in association with its goods and services for the
24. The Wargaming.net Logo, the Mark, and the WoT Logo symbolize the business
25. For several years, and prior to the acts of Defendants alleged herein,
Wargaming.net has used the Wargaming.net Logo, the Mark, and the WoT Logo, alone and in
combination, on or in connection with advertising, marketing, and sales of its goods and services
26. The Wargaming.net Logo, the Mark, and the WoT Logo are famous or in the
process of becoming famous. This is exemplified by the fact that WORLD OF TANKS® has
risen quickly to become one of the most popular, massive, multiplayer, online games of all time,
having amassed over 18 million users by December 21, 2011, and earning a Guinness World
27. WORLD OF TANKS® has received numerous industry awards, including First
prize for “Best Online Client Game”, KRI (Russian Game Developer’s Conference) 2010; “Best
New Concept” award at the Electronics Entertainment Expo (E3) 2010; “Best Free MMORPG”
according to the MMORPG Center’s 2010 Player’s Choice Awards; “Most Anticipated Free
MMORPG” according to the MMORPG Center’s 2010 Player’s Choice Awards; “Most
Anticipated MMO in 2010” according to the MMOSITE’s Reader’s Choice Awards 2010;
“Favorite Strategy MMO in 2010” according to the MMOSITE’s Reader’s Choice Awards 2010;
“Gold Award” from Gamers Daily News; “Best Game” KRI 2011; “Audience Award” KRI
2011; Best “Game that Needed the Award” Award from Gamepro at E3 2011; “Rising Star”
the WoT Logo Artwork and copyright registration number TX7-524-993 for the World of Tanks
Wiki main page, each of which includes content published at WorldofTanks.com, and copies of
WorldofTanks.com; however, registrations for such content have not yet been obtained from the
U.S. Copyright Office (together with the registered copyrights in the preceding paragraph,
“Wargaming Copyrights”.
31. On information and belief, Defendants registered and are using the domain name
the letters “hop” immediately before the top level domain, thereby creating actual confusion that
the web site WorldofTankShop.com is an online shop somehow associated with Wargaming.net
and WORLD OF TANKS®. The domain name WorldofTankShop.com actually includes the
trademark registration.
34
4. ndants’ web site of WorrldofTankShhop.com reppeatedly missrepresents tto the
Defen
public that
t it is the “officcial onlinee shop” foor WORLD
D OF TA
ANKS®. (See
http://Wo
orldofTankS
Shop.com and
http://ww
ww.worldoftaankshop.com
m/index.php?route=inforrmation/conttact ) annootated
reproductions below)).
35. Defe
fendants hav
ve copied Wargaming.ne
W et’s WoT loogo and coppyrighted arttwork
on http
p://WorldofT
TankShop.co
om, as shown below:
Plaiintiff’s WoT
T Logos On Defeendants’ Hom
me Page
On Def
efendants’ ho
ome page On D
Defendants’ Home pagee, referred too as
“Featured”
”
36. Defe
fendants hav
ve copied thee Wargaminng.net Logo in an attemppt to confusse the
otherw
wise endorsed
d shop of Waargaming.neet:
Wargaming.net’s Reegistered Ma
ark Logo used on Worldoft
ftankshop.com
m
WorldofTanks.com web site, including Wargaming.net’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.
http://www.worldoftankshop.com/index.php?route=information/information&information_id=3.
http://www.worldoftankshop.com/index.php?route=information/information&information_id=5.
40. Defendants repeatedly used Wargaming.net’s name and domain name on the
Privacy Policy or Terms & Conditions, which Defendants copied from http://WorldofTanks.com,
ww.worldoftaankshop.com
http://ww m/index.php?route=inforrmation/infoormation&innformation_id=3
http://ww
ww.worldoftaankshop.com
m/index.php?route=inforrmation/infoormation&innformation_id=5
and WN’s corporate logo are trademarks or registered trademarks of WN in the United States
and other countries, and all rights, title and interests in and to any and all such marks are hereby
42. On information and belief, Defendants’ actions have caused consumers actual
confusion. For example, Defendants have used Wargaming.net’s customer support email
fraud and theft, have been confused and misdirected their emails to Wargaming.net. Myriad
such emails exist and illustrate actual consumer confusion. Representative emails received by
imitations of the Wargaming.net Logo, the Mark, and the WoT Logo, in connection with the
http://WorldofTankShop.com or in connection with the web site. Such acts are likely to cause
45. On information and belief, Defendants acts were committed with knowledge that
their imitation was intended to be used to cause confusion, or to cause mistake, or to deceive.
46. On information and belief, Defendants have used the Wargaming.net Logo, the
Mark, and the WoT Logo, with the knowledge of, and the intent to call to mind and create a
likelihood of confusion with regard to, and/or trade off of Wargaming.net’s fame and the
48. Defendants’ acts alleged above have caused, and if not enjoined will continue to
cause, irreparable and continuing harm to Wargaming.net’s trademarks, business, reputation, and
goodwill. Wargaming.net has no adequate remedy at law as monetary damages are inadequate to
suffered damages to the Wargaming.net Logo, the Mark, and the WoT Logo, and other damages
50. Defendants’ infringement of the Wargaming.net Logo, the Mark, and the WoT
Logo, is deliberate, willful, fraudulent and without any extenuating circumstances, and
constitutes a knowing use of the Wargaming.net Logo, the Mark, and the WoT Logo, and an
actual damages, enhanced profits and damages, costs, and reasonable attorneys’ fees under 15
COUNT II –
53. On information and belief, Defendants have, on or in connection with their goods
well as combinations thereof, and have made false designations of origin, false or misleading
descriptions of fact, or false or misleading representations of fact, which are likely to cause
54. On information and belief, Defendants have, on or in connection with their goods
well as combinations thereof, and have made false designations of origin, false or misleading
55. On information and belief, Defendants have and had a bad faith intent to profit
from the Wargaming.net Logo, the Mark, and the WoT Logo.
56. On information and belief, Defendants registered, trafficked in, and used a
to the Mark.
58. On information and belief, WorldofTankShop.com does not consist of the legal
name of any person or a name that is otherwise commonly used to identify any person.
59. On information and belief, Defendants have not had any prior use of their domain
name in connection with the bona fide offering of any goods or services.
60. On information and belief, Defendants have no bona fide noncommercial or fair
use of the Wargaming.net Logo, the Mark, and the WoT Logo in a site accessible under
could harm the goodwill represented by the Wargaming.net Logo, the Mark, and the WoT Logo,
information when applying for the registration of the domain name and intentionally failed to
63. On information and belief, Defendants had no reasonable grounds to believe that
the use of the http://WorldofTankShop.com domain name was a fair use or otherwise lawful.
64. Defendants’ acts alleged above have caused, and if not enjoined will continue to
cause, irreparable and continuing harm to Wargaming.net’s trademarks, business, reputation, and
goodwill. Wargaming.net has no adequate remedy at law as monetary damages are inadequate to
suffered damages to its business, its goodwill, its trade name recognition, the Wargaming.net
Logo, the Mark, and the WoT Logo, and other damages in an amount to be proved at trial.
actual damages, enhanced profits and damages, costs, and reasonable attorney fees under 15
U.S.C. §§ 1125(a), 1125(d), 1116, and 1117. Wargaming.net is further entitled to have the
68. On information and belief, Defendants have infringed and continue to infringe
Wargaming.net’s Copyrights under, inter alia, 17 U.S.C. §§ 102, 106, 501, and 602 by copying,
69. Defendants’ conduct as alleged herein has caused and will continue to cause
Wargaming.net irreparable harm for which there is no adequate remedy at law, and is also
causing damage to Wargaming.net in an amount that cannot be accurately computed at this time
JURY DEMAND
Wargaming.net Logo, the Mark, and the WoT Logo in violation of §1114 of Title 15 in the
United States Code, (ii) willfully infringed the Wargaming.net Logo, the Mark, and the WoT
Logo in violation of § 1114 of Title 15 in the United States Code, (iii) willfully used false
States Code, (iv) committed cyber piracy under § 1125(d) of Title 15 in the United States Code,
designation of origin, and unfair competition of the Wargaming.net Logo, the Mark, and the
WoT Logo by Defendants, their officers, agents, servants, employees, and attorneys, and all
attorneys, and all others in active concert or participation with any of them;
damages sustained by Wargaming.net, the costs of the action, enhanced damages, and reasonable
together with reasonable attorneys’ fees based on Defendants intentionally using a mark or
designation, knowing such mark or designation is a counterfeit in connection with the sale,
offering for sale, or distribution of goods or services, and award prejudgment interest;
amount of $2,000,000 per counterfeit mark per type of goods or services sold, offered for sale, or
U.S.C. § 501;
and
j) Grant Wargaming.net such other further relief as the Court may deem proper and
just.
Respectfully submitted,
EXHIBIT LIST