Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Healthy Occupational Culture For A Worker-Friendly
Healthy Occupational Culture For A Worker-Friendly
Institute for Occupational Medicine, University Clinic for Internal Medicine II, Medical University of Vienna, Austria1,
Department of Environmental Health and Occupational Medicine, School of Public Health “Andrija Štampar”,
School of Medicine, University of Zagreb, Croatia2
Work has numerous health and wellbeing benefits, but it also involves physical hazards and psychological exertion. Today
the scale has tipped toward psychosocial factors. Workers’ mental health affects their intellectual, emotional, and social
growth, as well as work ability, productivity, and ultimately organisational productivity and competitiveness on the market.
Even though companies may have an internal hierarchy that lowers stress at work, there are other formal and informal
social processes that can affect (positively or negatively) the cohesion within the work unit. Safety culture of an organisation
is a product of individual and group values, opinions, competences, and behavioural patterns that determine how
occupational health and safety are implemented. Organisations that nurture positive safety culture understand the importance
of health and safety and believe in prevention rather than dealing with consequences. Jobs that are stable, autonomous,
and reasonably physically and psychologically demanding are far more likely to lower work-related stress and boost
worker satisfaction. In fact, employee empowerment is one of the best ways to achieve good psychosocial health at the
workplace.
KEY WORDS: healthy organisations; mental health; organisational culture; stress; workers wellbeing
Approximately 58 % of the world population, that is, 4 deaths at the workplace, respectively (2). Furthermore,
billion people, spend one third of their adult lives at the mental health issues are among the leading causes of
workplace. Around 120 million workplace accidents and absenteeism and early retirement everywhere in Europe.
2.3 million deaths are reported every year. About 318,000 These issues are a great and long-lasting economic burden
deaths are related to injuries at work and almost 2 million for employing organisations. A UK study (6) showed that
to exposure to workplace hazards and unsafe working mental health illnesses cost employers almost 26 billion
conditions (1, 2). In 2013, Croatia saw 13,796 work-related pounds a year: 8.4 billion for sick leave payments, 15.1
injuries, of which 1,700 were severe and 17 fatal. In billion for production losses, and 2.4 billion for replacing
addition, 209 new cases of professional illness were the employees who left. In Croatia, mental health illnesses
reported (3). are the second leading cause of disability, neurosis, stress,
and somatoform disorder in particular (7).
Mental health at the workplace Due to changes in job tasks and work organisation a
One out of four people will develop one or more mental relatively low number of jobs are still physically demanding,
or behavioural difficulties during their lifetime. Psychiatric as the demands have shifted toward mental and emotional,
conditions account for 7.4 % of the total disability-adjusted which makes psychosocial risk factors at the workplace
life years (DALYs), with the highest loss in the population even more prominent. Although the strength of evidence
between 10 and 29 years. Estimates predict that their share about the relationship between psychosocial risk factors at
will reach 15 % by the year 2020 (4). Four out of ten leading the workplace varies, almost all research confirms that
reasons for disability and premature death worldwide are psychosocial health of the employees correlates with
psychiatric conditions (4, 5). In industrialised countries and occupation in all mortality cases, coronary heart diseases,
the EU mental illnesses are responsible for 4 % and 1 % of psychiatric illnesses (especially depression), and chronic
bronchitis (8).
Correspondence to: Prof Jadranka Mustajbegović, MD, PhD, Organisational culture of health and safety at work
Department of Environmental Health and Occupational Medicine,
School of Public Health Andrija Štampar, Rockefellerova 4, 10000 Ravasi and Schultz (9) define organisational culture as
Zagreb, Croatia, E-mail: jmustajb@snz.hr combined mental assumptions that determine the way of
2 Grabovac I, Mustajbegović J. Healthy occupational culture for a worker-friendly workplace
Arh Hig Rada Toksikol 2015;66:1-8
working within organisations by defining what behavioural and Sweden, legislation goes a step further than the EU
patterns are acceptable in different situations. legislation and stipulates that employers should actively
Organisational culture involves a number of psychosocial work to reduce these risk factors. In the United Kingdom
factors and mostly relies on informal aspects of work and stress management programmes are more often
its organisation. Simply put, it is what people in an recommended than obligatory, although health and safety
organisation find appropriate or not. A colloquial laws do express concern about stress (13-15).
explanation would be: “it is the way we do things here”
(10). Formal and informal organisational influences
Organisations should encourage a “healthy”
The Whitehall II Study (16, 17) showed that civil
organisational culture in order to increase productivity,
servants at the bottom of the hierarchy were six times more
economic growth, and management efficacy, and to
absent from work than others, which is related to a
discourage behavioural patterns that lower productivity and
perception of lower control over job tasks, low social
increase employee turnover (Table 1). Organisations with
support, and higher incidence of mental health issues.
an adaptive organisational culture have better economic
performance than those without it (11). Authors such as Carayon, Hoonakker, and Smith (18, 19)
While the awareness of health risks at the workplace is believe that in the centre of organisational design and
growing among the worker population, in the managerial management (ODAM) is the relationship between
structures the lack of awareness is a serious obstacle to management philosophy, satisfaction, and productivity of
developing necessary measures to protect health at work. employees; employees accept managerial decisions more
Additional obstacles may be the fear of high costs, shortage easily if they too hold them necessary, if the decisions have
of funds, work fragmentation, and new work forms such as been clearly outlined, and if the lines of responsibility are
small businesses, distance working, self-employment, and clearly set. All this lowers stress that would otherwise arise
the increasing gap between health care and economy sectors from conflicting roles. Technological innovations and
(1). education that help with job tasks also tend to actively
From the health sector ’s point of view, poor involve employees in problem solving, decision making,
organisational health and safety culture often leads to stress and encourage them to speak their minds freely (20,21).
and adverse health effects in employees. Although none of Research is now shifting focus on issues related to
the EU member states has a specific legislation for stress organisational structure and the relationships between
at the workplace, all legal frameworks do refer to superiors and subordinates. Organisational structures that
psychosocial factors as those that can cause or aggravate are based on a clear hierarchy are inexpensive, efficient,
stress at the workplace. According to the European Agency and easily maintained; this is why they are most common
for Safety and Health at Work (EU-OSHA) (12), 80 % of in the world. However, parallel to this formal structure,
the managers in the EU consider stress to be a problem in there is an informal social interaction between employees
their organisations, but only 30 % say that they have and the employers. As early as the 1920s, the Hawthorne
implemented some sort of stress management programme studies (22) have shown that people do not work for
or a programme that deals with psychosocial issues at the financial gain alone, but also because they want to belong
workplace. Half the respondents claim that psychosocial to a collective, and produce something meaningful. In other
issues at the workplace are harder to manage than the more words, they are equally influenced by intrinsic (psychological
“traditional” hazards. and social benefits) and extrinsic (payment and financial
According to the same report by EU-OSHA (12), benefits) work factors.
Croatia is one of the least likely countries to take preventive Informal social processes greatly affect the efficacy of
measures against psychosocial issues; stress management work organisations and work in teams, even where the
programmes are implemented in only 25 % of the formal organisational structure is good. They can affect the
respondent organisations, while only 23 % use psychologist cohesion within and between work units and the relationship
services. In Belgium, Denmark, Germany, the Netherlands, between workers and the organisation and can undermine
Table 1 Early signs of poor organisational culture of health and safety at work
Individual Organisation
Unusual behaviour Growing backlog, low production, more overtime hours
Poor work results Lower work quality (more production errors)
Mood swings and changes Less clients and inadequate service
Problems with co-workers Increase in sick leave
Increase in absenteeism due to illness Inefficient cooperation between employees and departments
Cannot keep one job for long Higher employee turnover
Grabovac I, Mustajbegović J. Healthy occupational culture for a worker-friendly workplace
Arh Hig Rada Toksikol 2015;66:1-8 3
the formal structure and decrease productivity. It is occupational medicine specialists and experts who research
important to know that informal processes have the same, organisational development should focus on developing
if not even greater power to change beliefs, attitudes, and interventions that encompass organisational culture through
behaviour of workers and ultimately lead to the establishment the perspectives of health of individual workers as well as
of social norms within the work unit. Usually these are the whole organisations.
mutually set social norms about the quantity of the work Increasingly important and driven by globalisation is
that is to be done and the relationship with the superiors. the diversity management at the workplace. Many
Every deviation from these norms leads to an increase in experiences are common to all minority groups and
social pressure and stress, which disrupts productivity. encompass stereotyping, discrimination, harassment,
Therefore it is necessary to match formal and informal violence, and exclusion from formal an informal exchanges
influences so that the employees can actively participate in at the workplace (32). A working environment that is more
improving productivity (23, 24). This can be achieved in receptive to diversity attracts better workers and has lower
different ways that are all based on active communication employee turnover. Employee turnover may cost up to
with workers, such as focus groups and work units that are 150 % of the regular cost of the employee who has left the
dedicated to solving a specific problem, then on education position. Therefore, successful organisations regularly
and safe working conditions, which all comes down to monitor employee turnover and report the findings every
creating a healthy work organisation. Protecting health and year as a measure of success (33).
safety at the workplace is much more than just focusing on The success of entrepreneurship depends on technology,
formal aspects of prevention of harmful effects that result tolerance, and talent (the “3T”), and developing new
from work processes, work tasks, and workplace technologies and talent depends on tolerance within an
environment. At the core of ensuring health and safety at organisation (34). Research has shown that non-heterosexual
work are people; therefore all organisations who wish to individuals who feel safe enough to come out in the
invest in and maintain human capital should pay close workplace are more efficient, more motivated, and feel
attention to behavioural, social, and cultural processes (24). better about their relationships with co-workers.
Furthermore, hiding one’s sexual orientation at the
Healthy work organisation concept: connecting workplace reduces productivity up to 30 %, while
organisational culture and health organisations that provide their workers with support
The healthy organisation concept encompasses groups, mentoring programmes, etc. have 7-16 % higher
managerial and business understanding of health in relation scores in questionnaires about satisfaction and productivity
to organisational culture. It is built on the simple premise at the workplace in comparison to those that do not (35).
that a happy, content, and calm worker is a healthy and Sense of security is crucial for establishing good
productive worker. Healthy organisations are those whose interpersonal relationships at the workplace (36).
culture, management, working environment, and business Organisations that value employee diversity and allow free
practice create an atmosphere that improves health, expression of this diversity and those that are culturally
efficiency, and quality of employee’s work (18, 25). A heterogenic have better results than those that are culturally
growing amount of data indicates that the most successful homogenous, as they encourage creativity and innovation
and competitive companies are those that have the highest (35, 36-38).
levels of health and safety and the most physically and
Work satisfaction and productivity
mentally healthy and satisfied workers (26). Crimmins and
Halberg (27) define “health culture” as a mixture of attitudes In 1975, Katzell et al. (39) showed that increasing
and beliefs of employees towards health promotion worker satisfaction did not necessarily increase productivity.
programmes at the workplace. An optimal social They saw two obstacles to this: resistance to implementing
environment is necessary in order to improve psychosocial change and focusing on just one approach instead of
and physical health of the employees. The World Health implementing system-wide changes. Therefore, they
Organization (WHO) in its new model of health and safety suggested seven principles to increase both workers’
protection at the workplace includes the “internal working satisfaction and productivity:
environment” (which encompasses both individual physical 1. Critical-Mass Principle: changes in the organisation
health and psychosocial well-being) as well the need for need to be sufficiently deep and far reaching in order to
connections between work organisations, communities, and have a lasting effect;
the environment that the workplaces are a part of (26). Such 2. Motivation Principle: development of a workforce
a broad model of understanding health and safety at work that is dedicated to the concept of high productivity through
makes it necessary that occupational medicine physicians, financial and/or psychological rewards;
ergonomics and human factors specialists consider the 3. Shared Benefits Principle: workers need to see that
wider aspects of social policies, economy and the organisational changes that increase productivity benefit
environment (28-30). Peterson and Wilson (31) suggest that them as well;
4 Grabovac I, Mustajbegović J. Healthy occupational culture for a worker-friendly workplace
Arh Hig Rada Toksikol 2015;66:1-8
4. Job Design Principle: changes need to be implemented implement the agreed changes and policies. Workers can
so that the workers see them and actively participate in their be informed about the program via internet or monthly
implementation. The implemented changes have to ensure bulletins, regular meetings of working groups, or specific,
optimal working conditions; task-oriented meetings. The importance of good
5. Pattern of Control Principle: higher autonomy and communication is paramount.
self-regulation can be key to increasing work satisfaction;
organisations in which all workers have a certain level of 2. Recognition of needs
control are more productive and motivated;
Programmes should be clear about what needs to
6. Patterns of Compensation Principle: adequately paid
address, such as promoting healthy attitudes towards health
workers generally like their job, are more satisfied, have
at work, understanding and preventing stress and health
lower absenteeism levels and more rarely leave their jobs.
risk factors, supporting employees with health problems
However, pay needs to be connected with the productivity
level; and including them back into the work environment. It is
7. System-Wide Changes Principle: changes need to also necessary to recognise the strengths and weaknesses
include the whole organisation and need to create “new” of a specific health promotion programme. This analysis
work systems) (40). needs to be done in cooperation with all employees,
Newer studies seem to support the idea of happy and regardless of their position in hierarchy. This cannot be
healthy workers as productive workers. Organisations that repeated enough times.
promote healthy and safe working conditions ensure Approaches to determining the needs differ and
economic growth through the trust that they build within complement one another (10, 44). They broadly fall into
the community (40, 41). Quick and Quick (42) suggest that three categories: academic (or anthropological), analytical
creating a happy, healthy, and productive workforce should (or psychological), and pragmatic (10). They also differ in
rely on the principles and knowledge of occupational the observed timeline (past, present or future), kind of
medicine and public health (42). This in turn calls for information that is derived (quantitative or qualitative),
preventive health programmes that seek to develop the form/features of the information (descriptive or normative),
abilities of the worker population and eliminate conditions and strategies, methods, and instruments used (44).
that lower this ability. These programmes should also plan
and implement healthy practices following the principles 3. Determining objectives
listed in Table 2. The objectives should be “measurable” using appropriate
analytical methods; for example, an objective could be to
Proposed procedures in developing a healthy reduce perceived stress caused by a determined stressor by
organisation
10 % within a year or to reduce absenteeism due to
This process requires complete cooperation and psychosocial health issues by 5 % within 2 years or to
consensus between the management and workers. One of reintegrate or hire a number of individuals who had a longer
the most important ways to protect workers’ psychosocial period of sick leave or had health issues over the last two
health is to empower the employees and include them in years.
decision making (43).
According to several authors (29, 36, 43), the seven 4. Developing specific plans and measures
steps listed below are the fundamental building blocks for
After determining the objectives and the time frame, it
any healthy organisation:
is necessary to define the means to achieve these objectives.
1. Communication, consultation, and informing They usually include informative campaigns that raise
awareness about a certain issue within the organisation,
It is necessary to obtain consent and make sure that all education and training for employees and employers,
organisational levels are devoted to protecting health of all actions aimed at reducing discrimination and violence at
employees, regardless of their status or position in hierarchy. the workplace, methods for removing stressors at the
All organisation units need to actively shape, conduct, workplace, policies aimed at helping people who develop
supervise, and evaluate adopted programmes. It is health problems, and discrimination-free employment
recommended to form a group of workers to supervise and strategies.
implement the adopted programmes in cooperation with It is necessary to adjust the strategies used in the
outside experts such as union members, psychologists, and programme to the culture and needs of the community as
occupational medicine physicians. All the employees need well as to different segments of the employee population,
to be clearly and regularly informed about the implementation as the success of new or already implemented programmes
steps and need to be given an active role in implementation. depends on it (24).
This will increase the perceived importance of the
programme and their willingness to participate and
Grabovac I, Mustajbegović J. Healthy occupational culture for a worker-friendly workplace
Arh Hig Rada Toksikol 2015;66:1-8 5
Table 2 Principles of healthy and productive organisations
Importance of trust, respect, Organisations need to implement activities and programmes that develop trust,
and decency respect, and righteousness between co-workers, supervisors, and managers
Organisations need appropriate supervision, fair benefits, safe employment, and good
Adequate work hygiene
physical and social working conditions
5. Implementation of the programme not. Evaluation should take place as previously scheduled
during programme implementation. The results should be
It is crucial to make a clearly written document about
clearly communicated to everyone in order to increase the
the implementation of the programme, measures to be taken,
and other planned changes within the organisation. This interest of the workers for the programme and introduce
document should be a joint declaration of employers and corrective measures if needed (18, 47, 48).
workers as to what is and what is not acceptable, how to
7. Ensuring sustainability
resolve possible disputes or conflicts, and what sort of
disciplinary measures workers can expect. All workers The only way to ensure the sustainable plans and
should be clearly informed and actively participate with programmes for preserving health at the workplace for long
suggestions in the making of such a document. All should is to include them in the official work policies of the
sign it and be responsible for its implementation (45-47). organisation (48).
When one considers the efficiency of the prevention Programmes that address several issues at the same
programme, special care should be taken to determine time, that increase physical, mental, and social aspects of
programme implementation standards that should be health are cost effective and usually the most appealing to
sensitive to cultural norms, financial and research employers. Such programmes can lower the risk of a variety
possibilities assuring its reimplementation on the basis of of disorders or illnesses and increase the overall health level
the written documentation. of the workers.
The shining examples are the programmes included in
6. Evaluation
the online databases made available to anyone interested
Programme evaluation has to clearly and unequivocally by the UK Evidence for Policy and Practice Information
show whether the agreed objectives have been reached or and Co-ordinating Centre, who developed the Database of
6 Grabovac I, Mustajbegović J. Healthy occupational culture for a worker-friendly workplace
Arh Hig Rada Toksikol 2015;66:1-8
Radni uvjeti, radni okoliš i sam način rada znatno utječu na zdravlje. Danas je relativno malo poslova definirano tjelesnim
zahtjevima, a puno više mentalnima i emocionalnima, pri čemu psihosocijalni rizici postaju značajni. Uz brojne pozitivne
utjecaje rada na zdravlje i blagostanje, mnogi su radnici izloženi i opasnostima, štetnostima te ergonomskim i psihološkim
naprezanjima. Stanje mentalnog zdravlja zaposlenog omogućava razvijanje u emocionalnom, intelektualnom i socijalnom
pogledu te ima odlučujuće učinke na radnu sposobnost, zahvaćajući ne samo način i ishode njegova rada nego i ishode
poslovanja tvrtke ili ustanove, određujući njenu kompetitivnost na tržištu. Unatoč dobroj organiziranosti upravnih tijela
tvrtke, što umanjuje stres na radu, neformalni društveni procesi utječu (pozitivno ili negativno) na koheziju unutar radnih
jedinica i na osjećaj povezanosti radnika i organizacije. Kultura sigurnosti neke organizacije rezultat je individualnih i
grupnih vrijednosti, stavova, kompetencija i oblika ponašanja. To, pak, određuje odlučnost i način vođenja programa za
očuvanje zdravlja i za sigurnost u organizaciji. Značajke organizacija koje imaju pozitivnu kulturu sigurnosti su zajednička
percepcija važnosti sigurnosti te pouzdanost u preventivne mjere. Rad koji omogućuje autonomiju, kontrolu nad svojim
radnim zaduženjima, razumne tjelesne i psihološke zahtjeve te sigurnost od iznenadnih otkaza dovode do većeg zadovoljstva
radnika i smanjuju stres na radnome mjestu. Danas se sve više ističe važnost različitosti na radnome mjestu. Potrebno je
istaknuti kako je upravo osnaživanje zaposlenika jedan od najvažnijih načina očuvanja psihosocijalnog zdravlja.
KLJUČNE RIJEČI: blagostanje radnika; mentalno zdravlje; organizacijska kultura; stres; zdrave organizacije
Copyright of Archives of Industrial Hygiene & Toxicology / Arhiv za Higijenu Rada I
Toksikologiju is the property of De Gruyter Open and its content may not be copied or
emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written
permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.