You are on page 1of 19

7 By Gabriella Minnes Brandes, Jennifer Condie and Aleah Wielinga

Using Alexander Technique


Principles with Beginning
Piano Students
A Collaborative “Duet” Between an Alexander
Technique Teacher and a Piano Teacher
(This article contains a video clip. Download

MTNA e-JOURNAL
a PDF and open in Adobe Acrobat to view.)

J
oyful music making at the piano information about how to achieve this is not
requires functional technique. “Since readily available to teachers of beginning stu-
the beginning of the twentieth century, dents. For example, it is not well understood 17
many piano approaches are based on that a collapsed spine may cause shoulder

FEBRUARY 2020
the conviction that technical mastery tension and thereby poor coordination in the
provides the key to injury-free technique, hands and arms. Seymour Bernstein explores
physical and musical freedom—and for many, this relationship between the fingers and
the guiding principle is that this is achieved movement in the whole body: “Your fingers
by avoiding excessive muscular tension.”1 are quite obviously of paramount import-
This introduction from the Journal of Arts and ance in playing the piano. Only seemingly
Biomechanics cleanly summarizes the popu- independent, they are actually influenced by
lar opinion that reducing muscular tension all the other movements in your body.”5
is necessary when playing the piano. In his Most information in these sources, and
book, What Every Pianist Needs to Know about others similar to them, is oriented toward
the Body,2 Thomas Carson Mark thoroughly pianists playing senior-level repertoire who
explores the whole body and its relation- are finding their playing limited by injuries or
ship to playing injuries. Barbara Lister-Sink’s their physical or technical abilities.6 However,
popular approach to injury-free technique in The Art of Practicing, Madeline Bruser cites
echoes this sentiment, using “Freeing the Dr. Fadi J. Beijani who alerts piano teachers
Caged Bird,”3 as a metaphor for the freedom to the importance of attending to how piano
that comes from releasing the physical and students use themselves when they play
mental entrapment of tension. The approach because, “Before the age of ten the skeleton
that tension is a major contributing factor to is still malleable and is shaped by how you
playing-related injuries and technical limita- play your instrument.”7
tions inspired Carola Grindea to found the Accurate and detailed information about
International Society for the Study of Tension piano playing and its physical challenges is
in Performance.4 readily available. This growing awareness
Despite general consensus that learning to is encouraging, but it really only “trickles
play injury-free involves balanced energies, down” into elementary piano teaching from
with muscular engagement where it is neces- the teachers who have directly participated
sary and muscular release where it is not, in these programs. The independent studio
Using Alexander Technique Principles

teacher, even one with a university degree, is The results of this study highlight the poten-
often left to piece together new understand- tial of the Alexander Technique in aiding the
ings from books, online videos and whatever relief of tension in piano playing.
pedagogical training they have been able Similarly, our study is designed to explore
to access. This often results in “telling stu- ways in which a piano teacher, in particular,
dents what to do” rather than giving them a who is studying Alexander Technique, may
new experience. Teachers are more likely to develop a whole-body approach to teach-
address the student’s hand, wrist or arm as ing young piano students. It is our intention
individual parts, without seeing the student to find and try out tools that support piano
as a whole. teachers in nurturing a functional technique
Concern still remains about the ways in for teaching a broad range of young students.
which teachers, if they have limited access
to an experiential understanding of physical Research Questions
aspects of piano playing, can use this infor- 1. In what ways can Alexander Technique
mation to support and nurture their students’ teachers provide piano teachers with
learning. Alexander Technique provides a increased access to information and
FEBRUARY 2020

unique framework that may support musi- experiential learning about the psycho-
cians as they seek efficiency to achieve full physical aspects of playing the piano,
artistic expression.8 which they can, in turn, pass on to their
In recent years there have been studies that students?
examine the application of Alexander Tech- 2. What are some effective strategies avail-
18 nique (AT) to music making. Stephen Parker able to piano teachers for incorporating
described a project whereby AT is taught in AT principles in teaching elementary level
MTNA e-JOURNAL

music institutions in Norway.9 In his project, piano?


AT was taught separately from the instrument 3. What are the necessary bridges and pos-
and students were left to integrate the two sible tensions between the goals of a
on their own. Parker’s findings show there piano teacher and those of an AT teacher,
were varied levels of collaboration between when they are collaborating and each is
the music teachers and the Alexander teach- teaching in their own specialized areas?
ers. Only on some occasions did the music
teachers continue to use the observation Alexander Technique: A Short
skills and language from Alexander Technique Introduction and Definition of Basic
as an integrated aspect of their teaching. Terms
Fung, Loo et al.10 set out to test the effect- Alexander Technique is an educational
iveness of Alexander Technique in reducing method by which a person learns to apply
tension in piano playing working with 15 the basic principles of the body’s natural
undergraduate piano students. Students coordination to improve the quality of his
received 14 weekly group AT lessons that or her own movement. The basic principles
focused on: recognition of habit, inhibition, of the coordination of the body, principles
direction and primary control (definitions which are followed unconsciously in infants
and discussion of these AT terms appear on and animals, can be learned and applied con-
pp. 5–8). Students went through pre- and sciously to improve the functioning and inte-
post- tests that identified problems of ten- gration of the individual. This coordination
sion (fingers, hands, arms, wrists, shoulders, may provide relief from stress and pain, make
back, legs and neck). “After a fourteen-week repetitious or boring tasks easy and provide
intervention of the Alexander Technique, the a new opening for excellence in performers
outcome reveals a positive effect in reducing and others who need to use their bodies for
tension in pianists. There is a significant maximum efficiency and endurance. Those
reduction in tension that was reported by the who study the Alexander Technique often
participants relative to their pre-test survey.”11 experience a sense of ease of movement, an
Using Alexander Technique Principles

increased sense of integration of their whole attend to the ways in which they use them-
selves—body and mind—and a reawakened selves as they play their instruments.
joy in making choices in daily activities, while End-gaining: End-gaining is the term
seeking awareness and efficiency. Alexander used when one is directing all the
Australian Frederick Matthias Alexander attention to the end result and not on the
(1869–1955) was embarking on a promis- process. Alexander argued that when one
ing career as an actor in the 1890s when he attends to the process, and specifically to
began to develop voice problems that failed the relationship between the head, neck and
to respond to any conventional medical treat- back, it is more likely for the person to move
ment. After a particularly important engage- with ease and efficiency while maintaining
ment where he could not use his voice well, poise. Musicians face tension between play-
he realized that it must be something he was ing music accurately while simultaneously
doing in the act of speaking that was causing paying attention to how they play so that
his difficulties. He set out to discover the root they are able to achieve and express their
cause of his voice problems and seek a meth- musical intentions. Alexander teachers often

MTNA e-JOURNAL
od of overcoming them. Through his meticu- invite students to attend to the process,
lous observations and experimentations, he the means-whereby they can achieve their
devised his technique, which is process ori- desired goal, and not to focus solely on
ented and geared toward gaining awareness end-gaining.
of and efficiency in movement. Habit: Alexander observed that he was
The following Alexander Technique terms12 constantly responding to internal or exter-
will help clarify the approach in this case nal stimuli. He noticed his initial responses 19
study. were often unconscious, automatic and

FEBRUARY 2020
Psycho-physical unity: As early as the habitual. As long as the responses were
turn of the previous century, Alexander unconscious, automatic or habitual, he could
argued that all human actions and activities not bring about any real and lasting change.
are both physical and mental. He called for an He understood that becoming aware of
integrative and holistic approach to describe habitual responses is a crucial first step in
any human activity. He asserted that learning having choice or being able to change such
new ideas or making any changes in one’s responses. Many musicians develop habits
practice involves both psychological and that pertain to music making and stem from
physical elements. Learning to play the piano the repetitive nature of musical practice. Alex-
has elements that are simultaneously physical ander teachers often encourage those who
(for example, releasing the shoulder to allow teach music to focus on developing habits
more fluid movement of the arm and appro- that will support efficiency and good use in
priate touch of the keys) and psychological their students.
(for example, noticing the emotional reac- Inhibition: Inhibition is the process of
tions to playing a challenging piece and how creating a wedge in time between a stimulus
those reactions manifest in the pianist’s ways and any response to it. That wedge allows
of playing). the response to be different from the habit,
Manner of use affects functioning: Alex- and therefore, it becomes a response that is
ander named the way one moves and func- conscious, thoughtful and with intention. It
tions “use,”as it refers to the ways in which is the process of consciously not reacting, of
the different body parts relate to others and withholding the initial reaction to stimuli and,
the ways in which one moves as a whole. thus, providing the space to respond in ever-
Alexander claimed that when people use changing ways.
themselves well, in an integrated whole-body Primary control: Alexander observed that
way, they function with efficiency. To play the way in which the head is aligned at the
well, musicians need to become aware of and top of the spine is dynamic and determines a
Using Alexander Technique Principles

person’s ease of movement and use of voice. and participated in data analysis. We also
That dynamic and conscious relationship can wanted an external review of our data from
enhance efficiency and balance in move- a piano teacher who had no Alexander Tech-
ment. Initially, Alexander lessons are directed nique background, so we invited Leslie Chen,
at having the student become aware of the an established piano teacher, to observe the
dynamic relationship between the head, neck data and comment on it.
and back, seeking length and width while the The data for this case study were collected
teacher guides the student in simple, often in two tiers: First, the data was generated
daily movements. In this way, the student is from six piano lessons of a student in Jen-
given the experience of easy, fluid motions nifer’s studio. The second tier of data was
made possible by attention to the dynamic generated from structured observations of
relationship between the head and torso. videos of the six lessons. Each video record-
Then the student learns to generate this ing was uploaded to WeVu,13 a computer
awareness and choice available to enhance platform that allows for time-specific com-
an integrated way of moving. Playing the ments. The video recorded lessons were
piano is an activity directly impacted by the subsequently viewed by the four observers:
FEBRUARY 2020

way students use themselves, move in space Gabriella, Jennifer, Aleah and Leslie.
and move their arms to connect with the Using codes14 from piano pedagogy and
piano. Alexander Technique, each observer watched
In this introduction, we have defined and and coded the videos. The time-specific
explained some basic concepts of the Alex- comments of each lesson were then coded,
20 ander Technique and provided a short review categorized and analyzed in terms of identi-
of pertinent piano technique literature. We fying key moments of teaching and learning.
MTNA e-JOURNAL

have also analyzed research exploring the We wondered in which ways each observer’s
links between piano technique and Alexander background impacted their analysis of the
technique. These two bodies of knowledge lessons and how each observer defined key
serve as the backdrop for this case study and moments of teaching and learning, specif-
support the research questions listed previ- ically exploring piano pedagogy and the
ously. experiential psycho-physical aspects of play-
ing the piano.
Methodology To provide further context for this study, we
Before detailing the data sources and will now describe Jennifer’s studio in some
research methodology, let us introduce the detail.
participants in this case study. There are
three authors of this paper, Gabriella Minnes Jennifer’s Studio
Brandes, an Alexander Technique teacher; In Jennifer’s piano lessons, she integrates
Jennifer Condie, the piano teacher who attention to both the physical aspects (how
taught the piano lessons in this case study; to sit and have the arms supported by the
and Aleah Wielinga, an Alexander Technique back) and the musical aspects of playing
and piano teacher. Gabriella had been giv- piano (rhythm, intention, flow, tempo and so
ing Jennifer Alexander Technique lessons on). Taking Alexander lessons with Gabriella
for a few years prior to the study, and these has expanded her repertoire of activities to
lessons have become the impetus for this connect these two aspects of her teaching
exploration. She suggested the structure for and also to connect these activities to Alexan-
the data collection and led the analysis pro- der Technique principles of primary control,
cess. Jennifer taught all the piano lessons in manner of use affects function, and end-gain-
this study and participated in data analysis. ing. For a number of years prior to this pro-
Aleah, who is both a piano teacher and an ject, Jennifer had been actively cultivating
Alexander Technique teacher, was invited to awareness in her students of how to sit at the
observe all the data, comment on the data piano so they gain more balance and support
Using Alexander Technique Principles

while playing. Simultaneously, Jennifer has tunities to visually connect their felt sense of
also explored balance and support in her own arm release and what they actually see in the
playing through her Alexander Technique les- mirror. It also makes explicit the connections
sons with Gabriella. between the head/neck/back and limbs, and
To teach her students an efficient rela- each student’s perception of their move-
tionship between the torso, limbs and head, ments.
Jennifer introduces an Alexander Technique The mirror also proved useful for Jennifer
procedure called active rest (often referred to in a way that she did not anticipate. Jennifer
as constructive rest or semi supine), whereby noticed that when she observed her students
students lie on the floor for 10–15 minutes in the mirror, it gave her a bit more distance,
with their knees bent and support under their making it easier to see changes or challen-
heads (see below). This procedure provides ges in how the students moved. She learned
students with an experience of support for to observe the students by watching them
the head (on the book), support for the torso in the mirror, similar to the ways in which
(on the floor) and a particular relationship Gabriella observed her during the Alexander

MTNA e-JOURNAL
between the torso, arms and shoulders. When lessons.
students get up from the floor, they are invit- Following our discussion of how Jennifer
ed to explore these relationships while stand- taught in her studio, we now turn our atten-
ing and sitting at the piano. Jennifer sees that tion to Fiona, the student in this case study.
consistent use of active rest before practicing
makes noticeable changes in students when The Student: Fiona
they play the piano. Active rest heightens stu- Fiona began studying with Jennifer at 21
dents’ awareness of the relationship between age 6, after a year of piano lessons in China,

FEBRUARY 2020
the arms and the back and often positively where she lived. She had forgotten much of
impacts their playing. what she had learned, so they began their
work with Faber Piano Adventures Book One,15
to work on building note-reading skills, tech-
nical skills and interpretive skills. During this
time, Jennifer began to systematically use
Alexander Technique concepts in Fiona’s les-
sons. Fiona worked through books One16 and
2A17 quickly, and by the end of the term had
advanced through the Royal Conservatory of
Music Level One18 for her festival and recital
repertoire, and to Faber Piano Adventures
2B19 for quick study material. She could play
two-octave scales hands separately for C, G,
Active rest position. D, A, E, A minor and E minor, and could play
triads broken, followed by a solid triad, in root
Another aspect of Jennifer’s teaching position and inversions. At the beginning of
inspired by her Alexander lessons with Gab- this study, Fiona was age 7.
riella was the dynamic use of the mirror. Jen-
nifer observed how Gabriella used the mirror Fiona’s Six Piano Lessons
as a teaching tool in their lessons. Gabriella For the six weeks of the study (see Appen-
explored with Jennifer where and how to dix 1 for Table of Progression of Lessons),
place mirror(s) in her teaching studio, and she Jennifer chose to focus on teaching the skill
made suggestions about the ways in which of continuous broken triads (not separated by
Jennifer could enhance her teaching using a solid chord) to address the common, tech-
them. Using the mirror to learn to observe nical challenge of keeping the wrist flexible as
how each arm moves gives students oppor- it follows the fingers in circular configurations
Using Alexander Technique Principles

at the keyboard. For the repertoire, she chose Similarly, Jennifer worked with Fiona stand-
“The Silent Moon,” by Nancy Telfer20 (RCM ing and releasing her arms facing the mirror
level 2) because it requires the ability to use and then when she sat on the piano bench
this skill (see Appendix 2 for other possible in a balanced way, she could glance at her
repertoire that use this skill). The left hand of reflection in the mirror to get a visual cue that
the “Silent Moon” contains triad-like patterns, helped her connect her work away from the
some just on white keys and some on black piano and at the piano.
and white keys. To play this piece, Fiona had Jennifer used “The ball exercise” to teach
to learn how her wrist movement related to the difference between releasing and hold-
the shape of the chords. She also needed to ing the arm. In this exercise, Jennifer stood
learn to maintain her wrist flexibility as she opposite Fiona with a lightweight ball slight-
moved toward and away from the fallboard. ly smaller than a soccer ball. Jennifer and
Jennifer incorporated Alexander principles Fiona each held a ball above their heads and
to support Fiona’s learning. Fiona learned to dropped the balls, leaving their arms up,
FEBRUARY 2020

observe herself, focusing on the relationship while observing what it is like to keep the
between her head, neck and back; she learn- arms in the air without lifting the shoulders.
ed to track the movement of her arm and Then, Fiona was asked to let go of the ball
fingers away from the piano using a mirror, and let her eyes and hands follow the move-
a ball and an adjustable table. Jennifer sup- ment of the ball as it was dropping. To do
22 ported Fiona in connecting these activities this well, Fiona needed to learn to have the
highlighting her physical awareness to play- neck stay connected to the back, the arm stay
MTNA e-JOURNAL

ing the piano. supported by and isolated from the torso,


Using the mirror, Fiona learned how to and to have the eyes lead the movement of
observe her arm movements to gain infor- the arms in following the ball. This activity fol-
mation about her shoulders, arms and hands. lowed Alexander’s concept that it is possible
This became the opportunity for Fiona to to change a habit when one understands
become aware of her habitual movements their habitual response, chooses to stop that
of each arm, to explore new levels of release response and approaches the possibility of
and find an integrated relationship between new movement patterns. In other words, if
the head/neck/back and arms in movement. a student tightens their arm when playing
Jennifer often placed her hand on Fiona’s the piano, it is often challenging for them
shoulder to enhance her kinaesthetic aware- to change that tightening while playing
ness. Fiona was asked to observe each arm the instrument. It may be more helpful to
separately and see the differences in the approach this difficulty moving away from
movement of each arm. Fiona learned that the habitual use of the arm, through learning
her head/neck/back and shoulders are inter- to release the shoulders following the move-
connected, and this relationship impacted ment of a ball, while enjoying the support
the quality of movement in her arms and was that standing provides. Once the ball was let
therefore relevant to piano playing. go, gravity pulled it to the floor. Fiona’s arms
Using Alexander Technique Principles

imitated that movement with release. Jen- joints while standing, where the relationship
nifer often added the verbal cue, “Follow the of the head, neck, and back is more dynam-
ball with your eyes,” as an additional indirect ic and supports efficient use of the arms.
instruction, instead of asking Fiona to pay Doing these activities away from the piano
attention to her arms. Another important followed Alexander’s principle of focusing on
aspect of this activity was Jennifer’s model- the means-whereby one reaches a goal, pay-
ling of the arm movements as the ball fell. ing attention to the way of working toward
She demonstrated to Fiona how to move the achieving a goal and not just focusing on
arms with ease. the end result. Using the adjustable table in
this way, provided Fiona with a structure to
explore the release of her arms and notice
the relationship of her forearm to wrist to fin-
gers. It also encouraged an exploration of the

MTNA e-JOURNAL
direction of circular wrist rotation and ability
to execute, notice and verbally articulate that
experience while learning to play the broken
triad pattern away from the piano, where the
height of the surface is adjustable to fit Fiona.
This movement of the arms was chosen
because it is crucial to the development of 23
fluency at the keyboard. Within the six les-

FEBRUARY 2020
sons, Fiona moved from a triad exercise con-
taining a broken pattern followed by a solid
The third activity away from the piano was chord to demonstrating her ability to play
using an adjustable table. Standing work can continuous broken triads.
be used in piano pedagogy with younger
students to bring movement into what can
be considered a sedentary activity and to
accommodate the size challenges that come
with a small person playing an instrument
better designed for a larger body. As part of
this project, Jennifer was curious to see what
a table with an adjustable height would do,
so that the forearm angle was optimal, tak-
ing into account the height of each student
to support and maintain the most efficient
relationship between the head, neck and
back. Jennifer’s goal was to increase her
students’ awareness of and freedom in the
Using Alexander Technique Principles

Data Analysis
Each of the four observers were asked to define specific moments of teaching and learning
that occurred in these lessons. The analytical process was ongoing, emergent and developing
throughout the research. We first observed the videos of the lessons and coded them. Then
we categorized the codes, focusing on moments of teaching and learning. The visual rep-
resentation below highlights the sequence of this analytical process.
FEBRUARY 2020

24
MTNA e-JOURNAL

We were curious to understand and define moments of learning and teaching. We won-
dered how teachers of piano and Alexander Technique would be shaped by their unique
backgrounds when they analyzed the lessons. Jennifer analyzed how she applied what she
learned in her Alexander lessons with Gabriella to teaching beginner pianists; Leslie noticed
moments when Fiona demonstrated that she was learning piano concepts; Aleah made
specific observations about piano teaching and used Alexander Technique concepts in her
analysis; and Gabriella paid particular attention to the translation of Alexander Technique prin-
ciples into teaching piano. All four of us analyzed the lessons in terms of: a) Jennifer’s choices
in real time, b) Jennifer’s use of questions and modelling, and c) Jennifer and Fiona making
connections, developing a shared language and creating metaphors.

Teaching: Making Choices in Real Time


Teaching is about making decisions that shape students’ learning. It is also shaped by
students’ reactions to their own learning, as teachers build bridges between what students
already know and the new material presented to them. Beyond the lesson plans, teachers
make many moment-to-moment decisions, weighing choices available to the student in real
time during the lesson. The teacher observes the student, assesses their learning process in
Using Alexander Technique Principles

relation to the goal of the lesson and, based ment. This interplay between standing and
on these observations, makes many deci- performing was an effective approach at
sions during the lesson. Experienced teachers that moment. Fiona’s curiosity came through
sometimes make such decisions in an almost with a question about how to play with a
automatic way, whereas other decisions are complete circle instead of a half, indicating
well thought out. Alexander Technique pro- that this contrast between standing away
vides a specific and particular paradigm for from the piano and performing on the piano
approaching these real-time decisions during enhanced her whole-body awareness. In
the lessons. Alexander teachers are trained to Lesson Three, using the triads in the reper-
view each lesson as a set of stimuli to which toire, Jennifer moved back to the adjustable
both teacher and student respond. They prac- table to help Fiona release her thumb more
tice noticing the student’s initial responses in the wider chord pattern that required a
and then assess these responses in terms of more open hand. Jennifer reminded Fiona
their effect on playing the piano. that, “The wrist follows the finger, the elbow
In our project, although Jennifer is not an follows wrist, and shoulder follows the

MTNA e-JOURNAL
Alexander teacher, she used Alexander Tech- elbow,” Fiona learned she did not require
nique tools to assess moments in the lesson. excessive movement. Fiona was learning
Jennifer continued to hone her observation how to connect her thinking about playing
skills, to increase her ability to assess what with the ways in which she was using herself
Fiona needed in terms of how she used her- while playing. In Lesson Four, seeing Fiona
self as she was learning to play a piece. Based tighten her shoulders while playing, Jennifer
on those observations, Jennifer decided when responded by sitting back to back with Fiona 25
and how to use the activities away from and on the piano bench. This allowed Jennifer to

FEBRUARY 2020
at the piano. support Fiona’s back, which allowed Fiona to
Jennifer continuously made pedagogical stay stable as she played the chords. In Les-
decisions in the lessons that were a result of son Five, Jennifer introduced a new variation
her assessment of Fiona’s use and how that on arm release. She asked Fiona to drop her
translated into how she moved and played. arms directly to her sides, as if a puppeteer
In Lesson One, when Jennifer saw Fiona lift- let go of the strings on a marionette. Initially
ing her head to read the score, she noticed Fiona’s shoulders were thrown about by her
Fiona shortened her back, correspondingly arms. In response, Jennifer moved to the
tightened her arms and hands, and leaned mirror, placed her hand on Fiona’s shoulder
her torso to play each chord. To address the blade, and Fiona’s trunk stayed stable as her
shortening of the back, Jennifer asked Fiona arms released. Fiona was able to maintain this
to stand and play solid chords. Though this stability, even as Jennifer removed her hand.
was still at the piano, changing from sitting Working at the adjustable table, Jennifer
to standing helped Fiona improve how she reminded Fiona to connect the use of finger
used her arms and hands while she was read- number five with her arm, and to keep an
ing and playing the notes. In Lesson Two, active thumb, rather than having the weight
Fiona played the triads, and Jennifer took her of her arm collapse on the thumb. This was
away from the piano to work on releasing transferred to broken triads on the piano and
her elbow. As a result of that activity, Fiona’s to playing the left hand of the repertoire.
kinesthetic awareness of the relationship Jennifer then invited Fiona to rest her left
between the arm and torso grew, and her hand on her knee, to become aware of all
integration of movement improved. When her finger pads in order to release her hand.
Jennifer took Fiona back to the piano, Fiona Lesson Six began with Fiona observing her
asked how she could do the “complete” arm movement using the mirror, focusing
circle she had experienced while standing. on rapid arm release. When Jennifer asked
Jennifer demonstrated with her own wrist Fiona what she observed, she responded
and Fiona found more fluency in her move- with, “good,” so Jennifer asked for clarifica-
Using Alexander Technique Principles

tion. Without prompting Fiona responded, new vocabulary. In Lesson Two, Fiona explained
“released,” and, “no wobblies.” Jennifer com- that her hand felt, “sloppy,” and “more relaxed,”
mented that Fiona’s shoulder looked quite and Jennifer commended her, saying, “That is a
released, and her arm was, “moving quite good word to use!” These positive interchanges
freely and independently.” All of these instan- fostered a nurturing environment for explor-
ces illustrate how Jennifer’s choices followed ation and learning. Jennifer enhanced Fiona’s
from her observations. She used piano peda- learning through cultivating kinesthetic experi-
gogy and tools from Alexander Technique to ences, encouraging the use of metaphors and a
enhance Fiona’s whole-body awareness while shared language to express what and how she
playing. learned at the piano.

Teaching: Using Questions and Learning: Making Connections,


Modelling to Develop a Shared Language Developing a Shared Language
When Jennifer wanted to be certain Fiona and Creating Metaphors to Express
understood what she was teaching, she mod- Experiences
eled at the piano, asked questions, then used Learning piano involves listening and being
FEBRUARY 2020

Fiona’s answers and language to support able to translate information from the score
Fiona’s specific ways of learning. Jennifer had to one’s body and to the piano, taking into
new insights into Fiona’s learning, based on her account notes, rhythm and musical intention.
growing ability to observe how Fiona was using When Fiona made connections between
herself: “When Fiona uses herself well, she is different pieces of music she played and
26 able to copy my sound much more easily.” her interpretations of their musical themes,
Jennifer continued to look for ways to she based these connections on the sound
MTNA e-JOURNAL

teach Fiona to speak about her experience and how she felt playing the pieces. Beyond
at the piano: “I am searching for questions making connections based on sound, Fiona
to help Fiona find words for her experience slowly learned to make connections between
of learning.” Jennifer became more specific how she was able to move her arms, fore-
and intentional in her own use of language arms, wrists and fingers, and the sound she
as she taught: “Released is becoming part of made on the piano. When Jennifer taught
the vocabulary by Lesson Four. I am working Fiona how to release her arm using the
to substitute relaxed with flexible or released.” support of her back, she applied Alexander
Jennifer introduced language that helped Technique principles that focus on the con-
Fiona describe her experience by supply- nections between how one uses themselves
ing terms that captured Fiona’s learning and how they function. Fiona named her
process. In Lesson Three, Jennifer used the observation of her own experience using a
term “bossy” to describe how Fiona’s thumb metaphor: “My shoulder needs to go to the
was leading the movement in her hand spa [to relax and do less] and my fingers need
and arm. As the lesson progressed, Jennifer to go to the gym and exercise [to be more
guided Fiona to remember the sensation of active while playing].” With her growing kin-
releasing her thumb and also guided Fiona aesthetic awareness, Fiona found language to
to make connections between her fingers, capture her experiences, learning to connect
wrists, elbows and shoulders. By the end of her experience to what Jennifer was teaching.
the lesson, Fiona told Jennifer that she could When Jennifer placed her hand on Fiona’s
feel her thumb “bossing” her hand around, shoulder to highlight how she was using her
providing evidence of her growing aware- arm, she asked Fiona if it is helpful to have
ness through these experiential activities and that kinesthetic reference. Fiona said: “No,
metaphors that described her movements. it [Jennifer’s suggestion to pay attention to
In addition to introducing new language, how the shoulder and arm were connect-
when Fiona described her experience with her ed] doesn’t help,” turning into, “Yes, it [the
own words, Jennifer positively affirmed her relationship between the arm and the back]
Using Alexander Technique Principles

does change.” Fiona’s “aha” moment, immedi- defined key moments of learning and teach-
ately followed Jennifer moving her hand and ing and wondered about the ways in which
putting it back again. With that kinesthetic each person’s background and expertise
support, Fiona was able to notice the shift in shaped their observations and interpretations.
how she used her arm in a new way. Jennifer
provided Fiona with the necessary contrast so Multiple Perspectives for Identifying Key
she was able to notice both her habitual and Moments of Teaching and Learning
new ways of moving the arm. Gabriella, Jennifer, Aleah and Leslie individ-
Over the span of the study, Fiona learned ually observed the videos of Fiona’s lessons,
to respond to Jennifer’s continued use of and each commented on what they saw and
Alexander terms. Introduction of language heard based on their varied backgrounds
specific to Alexander Technique also aided and areas of expertise. Each was seeking to
Jennifer in her ability to equip Fiona with identify key moments that indicated learn-
tools to address and enhance her experi- ing in each lesson. All four observers noted
ence. In Lesson Three Jennifer used the word the development of a shared language as

MTNA e-JOURNAL
“released” to explain what changed in Fiona a marker of learning. Jennifer taught Fiona
when she eased off of the excessive tension specific terms such as “release” and “thinking
in her shoulders. One of the strengths of the up” that highlighted the Alexander Tech-
Alexander Technique as a teaching and learn- nique approach to describing what Fiona was
ing paradigm, is that it takes into account that learning to notice. Jennifer also taught Fiona
learning is a mind-body process, whereby specific terms to identify her own body map-
the student learns to identify their experience ping as it pertained to her playing the piano: 27
and name it as it is happening. Jennifer con- “trunk,” “torso,” and “where the shoulder con-

FEBRUARY 2020
tinued to use the word “released” in Lessons nects to the torso.”
Four and Five, and by Lesson Six, Fiona was All four observers noted the metaphors
using this term to describe her sensations. that Fiona used to describe her experience
With Fiona’s growing awareness of herself, and what she was learning: “sloppy thumb,”
Jennifer introduced the concept of sending meaning the thumb needs to be less mus-
directions or being actively engaged in think- cularly engaged in that moment; “shoulders
ing about movement. Fiona learned to direct to the spa,” meaning the shoulders were too
her arms by “thinking up” along her torso. active with excessive muscle tension and that
She was able to sense the contrast between Fiona needed to choose to activate them less,
“thinking up” and her habitual way of being, whereas with “fingertips to the gym,” Fiona
and Fiona used new words to describe her noted that she needed to use her fingers with
experience as she noticed a change within more muscle tone to have the appropriate
herself. Her ability to notice these changes contact with the piano. All these metaphors
was evidence of her learning. also suggest that Fiona could see the connec-
Leslie Chen, the piano teacher who tions between the amount of muscular effort
observed and analyzed the videos, defined she was activating and its impact on the
Fiona’s learning through ongoing conver- sound she was making.
sations that took place between Fiona and The four observers also noticed Fiona was
Jennifer. Leslie wrote: “When a student needs making connections between her experien-
to verbalize/articulate something herself, it is ces at the adjustable table and the piano. She
an opportunity for her to digest and evaluate, noticed her thumb wanted to “lead more” at
which helps her learn.” the piano than on the table.
After discussing teaching and learning with All four of us were seeking to hear a dif-
a focus of the application of Alexander Tech- ference in Fiona’s tone, and we connected
nique, we review the multiple perspectives those changes in sound to the ways she used
of the observers who analyzed the lessons. herself. We noted how Jennifer explained
We were curious to track how each observer the way Fiona needed to move her wrist on
Using Alexander Technique Principles

the adjustable table, connecting the quality lished away from and at the piano, both Jen-
of movement to a smoother sound through nifer and Fiona hone their observation skills,
practicing broken triads on the table and then develop a shared language, use metaphors,
on the piano. Leslie summarized: “I really like and make explicit links between kinesthetic
how Jennifer used a combination of verbal awareness and its connection to use and to
instruction, physical demonstration, exercises music making.” Gabriella identified Fiona’s key
away from the piano (for example, on the moments of learning: “When Fiona asks ques-
table), having Fiona’s hand on top of Jennifer’s tions, makes connections, uses metaphors,
own and moving Fiona’s hand as Fiona played this increases her kinesthetic awareness and
(on the table and on the keys) to teach Fiona her growing ability to perform the tasks
the concept of the wrist circles.” Jennifer gives her.”
Some unique and specific comments about The four of us commented on the non-
the lessons were the manifestations of the linear process of learning. We could see that
observers’ background. With Leslie’s back- although at some moments it seemed that
ground as a piano teacher, her comments Fiona’s use was improving, the following
focused primarily on sound: “Overall, I did see week she had moments in the lesson where
that Fiona improved in the way she played her arms were tight and the sound she was
FEBRUARY 2020

the broken triads (especially left hand) and making was not as full. We all acknowledged
the way she played the LH in “Silent Moon.”21 that teaching piano and being attentive to
I was impressed when she put the two hands how one is using the arms and fingers for
together and played from beginning to end playing is complex. In addition, Leslie raised
from memory.” another pedagogical challenge, and perhaps
28 Aleah, who is both a piano teacher and an one of the limitations of this case study, when
Alexander teacher explained what she was she spoke about the hierarchical differences
MTNA e-JOURNAL

noticing in terms of Alexander principles. She between teacher and student. She wondered
discussed the work at the adjustable table as how open a student is to answer a teacher’s
a way to move away from end-gaining and questions honestly, not trying to gauge what
remove immediate response to the stimulus the teacher wants to hear: “Do you think it
of playing the piano. She saw these activities would be hard for Fiona to say to Jennifer
as, “creating another tool for integration away if something did not feel different [if she
from and at the piano.” In her comments, thought that was what Jennifer wanted to
Aleah linked piano pedagogy and Alexander hear]?” This is an important note to pay atten-
principles: “As the lessons progress, Fiona is tion to, and for any teacher to consider the
playing with more ease, and her shoulders are ways in which questions are encouraged and
more stable, but it is clear that things are very supported both verbally and non-verbally.
much in transition as her habit of tightening
comes and goes. But she is able to find free- Conclusions
dom quickly when Jennifer asks her to place Similar to learning to play the piano,
her attention in specific moments. Fiona is also learning Alexander Technique requires both
able to describe her experience and sensations conscious, cognitive understanding of prin-
much more easily than in earlier lessons.” ciples and a set of experiences that support
Jennifer’s comments on the videos highlight the learning. Each student, in both instances,
her increasing and systematic use of Alexander explores their habits and is invited to try new
terminology in teaching piano. She noted the ideas. Piano teachers seek ways to be able
use of metaphors and how she used touch to provide their students with tools to reach
as a tool to teach kinesthetic awareness and their musical goals. They are well trained in
provide feedback. She also noted the changes the musical aspects of teaching piano but
in sound that Fiona was able to produce at the have limited specific tools and language to
piano with her improved use. approach the mind-body, whole student
In Gabriella’s comments she reviewed and learning. Alexander Technique teachers
summarized the six weeks: “A routine is estab- approach learning using a psychophysical,
Using Alexander Technique Principles

kinesthetic lens. They observe and analyze We addressed these limitations through the
movement, seeking efficiency. They enhance study: first, Jennifer continued to take Alex-
awareness of and attention to one’s habits ander lessons and work on herself. Second,
and provide the means to stop undesired Gabriella and Jennifer continued to have
habits and enhance the ability to choose conversations about Jennifer’s learning and
while thinking in activity. the challenges she encountered in applying
In this case study, we demonstrate how these principles with Fiona and other stu-
collaboration between a piano teacher and dents in her studio. Third, Jennifer knew that
an Alexander teacher supports the process of the work with students on their kinesthetic
teaching piano. The piano teacher acquires awareness would support their musical prog-
new ways to observe herself and her stu- ress as they advanced. Fourth, Jennifer cre-
dents, and she learns to use specific language ated opportunities for Gabriella to work with
that captures the kinesthetic aspects of music Jennifer’s students in a master class setting
making. Using Alexander-specific tools and and in private lessons.
language consistently with students, adding Although this case study focuses only on
activities away from and at the piano, and one student, Jennifer collected data from

MTNA e-JOURNAL
learning to use a mirror in specific ways all five additional students, and in the future,
enrich the students’ understanding and may we intend to analyze and compare the data
lead to enhanced sense of joy and success between the students to enrich our findings.
playing the piano. The “duet” we propose in this case study
However, there were some limitations is not a “quick-fix.” We propose a thorough
inherent to this case study. For a piano teach- and deep exploration of how to make music
er to be able to integrate Alexander principles through the understanding of how body 29
in her studio, she needs to first understand mechanics work with efficiency. We propose

FEBRUARY 2020
and experience these principles and their a process that is exploratory in nature, similar
impact on her own use and her own playing. to the basic elements of the Alexander Tech-
This takes tremendous investment of both nique. The tensions that arise are addressed
time and money. Then the piano teacher through ongoing conversations about the
and Alexander teacher need to find specific various activities in the study, the data col-
ways to apply Alexander inspired activities lected and its analysis and significance. We
that will enhance the teaching. The role of created “bridges” that focus on a process, that
the Alexander teacher is to support the piano highlight the ability to observe preconceived
teacher, paying specific attention to the chal- notions within each discipline, work towards
lenges the piano teacher faces and finding awareness of habits and choose new ways to
ways to approach these challenges through approach teaching piano.
the application of principles of the Alexander
Technique. The major hurdle the Alexander Acknowledgments
teacher faces is finding ways to support the We would like to acknowledge the contri-
piano teacher without being able to use the butions of Alexander Technique teachers in
very specific “hands-on” work, fundamental to Vancouver who provided us with comments
AT teachers, directly, with each piano student. and suggestions for an earlier draft of this
The major hurdle for the piano teacher is the the paper. We thank Denise O’Leary for her
tension between the parents’, students’ and technical support. Fraser Brooks, who built
her own expectations of what the musical the adjustable table Jennifer envisioned,
progress “should be,” particularly in relation to and Nicholos Poullos for editing suggestions
examinations and festival performances and of an earlier draft. We would also like to
the additional content added from Alexander acknowledge the support received from the
Technique. To incorporate Alexander inspired Canadian Society of Teachers of the Alexan-
activities, the piano teacher needs to find der Technique (CANSTAT, ATC) through a
ways to insert these suggested new activities research grant for this project. 7
into the flow of the lesson.
Using Alexander Technique Principles

Appendix 1
Table of Progression of the Six Lessons

Week Piano Technique and Silent Moon Challenges


[SM] at piano
1 Fiona [F] learns LH using blocked chords F is leaning into piano as she plays chords
[SM]
At the end of the lesson F sits to play
blocked chords, she leans less than in
the beginning of the lesson

2 Triads F lifts her shoulders


F plays LH broken triads up as Thunder is raised
Jennifer [J] has F feel wrist and her circles F leans on RH when she plays LH broken
Silent Moon circles triads, left shoulder is raised
F’s elbow is ‘overworking’ as she plays the
triads

3 Triads at piano with J’s hand as a tactile F’s wrist circles are correct most of the time
FEBRUARY 2020

reminder to stay released at the table, but are not yet consistent
F performs left hand while teacher plays Thumb is ‘leading’ the
RH [SM] wrist in the chords containing minor 7ths
Less tension in thumb, and more fluency
after table activity [SM]
30

4 Triads: Hands separately, tone and fluen- F self-adjusts her sitting at piano
MTNA e-JOURNAL

cy progressing Freedom in shoulders and arms comes and


Just LH, J and F sit back to back on the goes
bench while F is playing [SM] Lower back moves with each movement
of pedal

5 Triads: LH alone triads. F copies J’s Elbow slightly tightens at times


smoother sound after a demonstration Wrist circle awareness developing
LH movement from #5 and #1 focusing consistently
on awareness rather than accuracy [SM] Stable back on hands together [SM]
Hands together with score [SM] Wrist and shoulders tighten a bit [SM]
J demonstrates RH balance, F copies LH too loud [SM]
[SM]

6 Triads: LH alone Circles correct and RH released without


prompts, some unnecessary elbow movement
Together, playing LH singing RH, listen-
ing, moving to quicker tempo (one long After tightening on ascending triads,
pulse per bar) [SM] F self-adjusts back and neck on descending
triad, no prompt with RH, small prompts LH
Using Alexander Technique Principles

Activity not seated at piano Alexander Technique concepts


(see pp. 5-8)
Playing while standing Primary control: Because F was leaning
forward her back did not support her arm
and fingers.
Force of Habit: Attending to the process by
standing at the piano allowed F to notice
her habits
‘Ball exercise’ Primary control: the relationship between
Doing this exercise, arms release and swing easily the head/neck/back impacts playing
At adjustable table: review wrist direction in broken Seeking efficiency in movement
triads Awareness of habit: recognizing habit as a
J invites F to be aware of elbow first step in change
At adjustable table: J & F
compare LH Silent Moon circles to triad circles
Mirror: F observes Thunder, J places hand on F’s shoul- Primary control

MTNA e-JOURNAL
der girdle Means-whereby: working with process
At adjustable table: basic wrist circles for direction towards change
At adjustable table: Silent Moon LH for awareness of
thumb tension

31

Ball exercise: F thinks up as she releases shoulders Primary control

FEBRUARY 2020
J’s hands on shoulders, no hands on shoulders Force of Habit: Freedom comes and goes as
At adjustable table: F sends her wrist circles in correct F recognizes her habit
direction, thinking up from finger to shoulder, F releas- Manner of use affects function: ‘Lengthen-
es her arm in relation to her shoulder ing’ foot on pedal changes, with ankle joint
Back to back on the bench: flexible and independent from calf, allows
back to stay stable, and facilitates more
Awareness of back through kinesthetic contact precise use of the foot
Ball exercise with mirror: puppet arms for faster joint Primary control awareness and stability
release, arms straight down to floor. J’s hand on shoul- while joints are released
der for stability and awareness Manner of use affects function: Fiona’s use
At adjustable table: circles with a focus on alignment, is sufficient to create change in her playing
activating pinky and thumb when she imitates J
J teaches F an exercise to enhance F’s awareness of
finger pads to open palm of hand she sits and places
her palm on her thigh
Ball exercise: ‘puppet arm’ release with trunk stability End-gaining: last lesson, J’s habit moves to
and breathing: musical intention, less to unity of sound
F makes observations and use.
At adjustable table: for circles RH, LH Manner of use affects function: F finds
F repeats the palm on thigh exercise for release on some musical ideas more difficult to realize
larger intervals than in lesson 5, when she used herself
better.
Many moments of ease appear, as habits of
integration become stronger.
Using Alexander Technique Principles

Appendix 2 6. A complete analysis of current discussion


The “Silent Moon” by Nancy Telfer (RCM 2 of injury free piano pedagogy is beyond the
Repertoire) has LH patterns based on triads, scope of this paper. Currently many post-
and transferred well from the broken triad secondary music schools (McGill in Canada,
portion of the technique used in this project. Julliard and Salem College North Carolina
Any repertoire with continuous broken chord in the US to name a few) offer programs
patterns for a few bars, including those sug- which include experiential ways of increasing
gesting 7th chords, or filled in with passing whole body awareness while playing the
notes, would also have worked. For example, piano. There are also programs (e.g. The Well
in the same book, Margaret Goldston’s “The Balanced Pianist and the Taubman Training
Sparking Brook” has triad patterns in the right program) that aim primarily at adult music
hand throughout the whole piece. In the students and seek ways of playing the piano
RCM Piano Etudes, Level 2, the Etude in F with more freedom; Teresa Dybvig, “A Few
major op. 190, no. 27 by Kohler has repeated Illustrations of Comfortable Seating at the
triad patterns in the LH, much like the “Mel- Piano,” The Well Balanced Pianist, Teresa
ody of Spring,” by Fritz Spindler, in Technic is Dybvig, last modified 2014, http://www.
FEBRUARY 2020

Fun, Elementary B, published under the Alfred wellbalancedpianist.com/bpseatingguide.


umbrella. Less obvious, but also suitable for htm#illustrations; Teresa Dybvig, “Piano Tech-
applying the wrist directions used in triads, nique: the Taubmann Approach,” The Well
is the much simpler, “Ocean Spray” in Anne Balanced Pianist, Teresa Dybvig, last modified
Crosby’s charming collection, “Fuzzy Beluga,” 2012, http://www.wellbalancedpianist.com/
32 also published by Frederick Harris Music. bptaubman.htm.
7. Madeline Bruser, The Art of Practicing: A
MTNA e-JOURNAL

Guide to Making Music from the Heart (New


Notes York, NY: Three Rivers Press, 1999), 71.
1. Michèle Wheatley-Brown, Gilles Comeau, 8. Gabriella Minnes Brandes, “Alexander
and Donald Russell, “The Role and Manage- Technique Gives Me Space to Create Musical-
ment of Tension in Pedagogical Approaches ly: Musicians Explore the Application of Alex-
to Piano Technique,” Arts BioMechanics 2, no. ander Principles,” in The Congress Papers- The
1 (2013): 2, http://www.mindbodymusic.ca/ 11th International Congress of the F.M. Alexander
wp-content/uploads/2014/11/the-role- Technique, ed. Paul Marsh (London, ENG: STAT
and-management-of-tension-in-piano- Books, 2019), 192–198.
approaches-.pdf. 9. Stephen Parker, “Integrating Teaching
2. Thomas Mark, Roberta Gary, and Thom and Learning- A New Model at the Norwe-
Miles, What Every Pianist Needs to Know About gian Music Academy,” AmSAT Journal, no. 12
the Body: With Supplementary Materials for (Fall 2017): 52–56.
Organists (Chicago, IL: GIA Publications Inc., 10. Loo Fung Ying et al, “Tension Release in
2003), 107. Piano Playing: Teaching Alexander Technique
3. “Introduction,” Freeing the Caged Bird, to Undergraduate Piano Majors,” Procedia-
directed by Barbara Lister-Sink (1996; Lewis- Social and Behavioral Sciences 174 (2015):
ville, NC: Wingsound, 1996), DVD. 2413–2417, https://doi.org/10.1016/
4. Carola Grindea, “The History of ISSTIP,” j.sbspro.2015.01.910.
The International Society for Study of Tension 11. Ying et al, “Tension Release,” 2416.
in Performance, last modified 2015, 12. “Home: The Definitive Guide to the Alex-
http://www.isstip.org/. ander Technique,” The Society of Teachers of
5. Seymour Bernstein, With Your Own Two the Alexander Technique (STAT), last modified
Hands (Portland, ME: Manduca Musica Publi- 2019, https://alexandertechnique.co.uk/; Jean
cations, 1981), 193. Fischer, “Primary Control,” A Companion to
Using Alexander Technique Principles

the Alexander Technique, last modified 2019, Bibliography


https://mouritz.org/?article=primary-control; Bernstein, Seymour. With Your Own Two
In compiling the definitions of AT terms we Hands. Portland, ME: Manduca Musica Pub-
also were inspired by yearly participation in lications, 1981.
discussions of the Competencies Group, an Brandes, Gabriella Minnes. “Alexander Tech-
international group of Alexander Technique nique Gives Me Space to Create Musically:
teachers who are working on developing an Musicians Explore the Application of Alex-
instrument to define and measure the com- ander Principles.” In The Congress Papers-
petencies of Alexander Teachers. The partici- The 11th International Congress of the F.M.
pants in that group are: Ann Rodiger, Carol Alexander Technique, edited by Paul Marsh,
Boggs, Edward Buchard, Ruth Rootberg, 192–198. London, ENG: STAT Books, 2019.
Sarah Barker, Kathleen Ballard and Gabriella Bruser, Madeline. The Art of Practicing: A Guide
Minnes Brandes. to Making Music from the Heart. New York,
13. “WeVu for Music,” WeVu, ISIT Technol- NY: Three Rivers Press, 1999.
ogy Inc., last modified 2019, Celebration Series: Piano Repertoire Level 1.

MTNA e-JOURNAL
https://wevu.video/wevu-for-music/. Toronto, ON: Frederick Harris Music Com-
14. List of codes used when watching the pany, 2015.
videos: student connects to other experi- Crosby, Anne. “Ocean Spray.” Fuzzy Beluga,
ence, teacher connects to other experience, Elementary Piano Solos, Anne Crosby Library.
teacher suggests movement, teacher’s use, Toronto, ON: Frederick Harris Music Com-
teacher observes or comments on obser- pany, 2008.
vation, student explains.AT specific codes: Dybvig, Teresa. “A Few Illustrations of Com- 33
head/neck/back, inhibition, opposition, fortable Seating at the Piano.” The Well-Bal-

FEBRUARY 2020
unreliable sensory appreciation, use affects anced Pianist. Last modified 2014. http://
function, direction and directing, habit, wellbalancedpianist.com/bpseatingguide.
teacher uses AT term, student uses AT term. htm#illustrations.
Piano pedagogy codes: teacher’s question, Dybvig, Teresa. “Piano Technique: the Taub-
student’s question, teacher models, teacher mann Approach.” The Well-Balanced Pian-
hands-on, away from the piano, technique to ist. Last modified 2012. http://www.well-
repertoire, teacher uses piano terminology. balancedpianist.com/bptaubman.htm.
15. Nancy and Randall Faber, Piano Adven- Faber, Nancy and Randall Faber. Piano Adven-
tures Lesson Book: Level One (Fort Lauderdale, tures Lesson Book: Level One. Fort Lauder-
FL: The FJH Music Company, 1997). dale, FL: The FJH Music Company, 1997.
16. Faber, Piano Adventures Lesson Book: Faber, Nancy and Randall Faber. Piano Adven-
Level One. tures Lesson Book: Level 2A. Fort Lauderdale,
17. Nancy and Randall Faber, Piano Adven- FL: The FJH Music Company, 1997.
tures Lesson Book: Level 2A (Fort Lauderdale, Faber, Nancy and Randall Faber. Piano Adven-
FL: The FJH Music Company, 1997). tures Lesson Book: Level 2B. Fort Lauderdale,
18. Celebration Series: Piano Repertoire Level FL: The FJH Music Company, 1997.
One (Toronto, ON: Frederick Harris Music Fischer, Jean. “Primary Control.” A Companion
Company, 2015). to the Alexander Technique. Last modified
19. Nancy and Randall Faber, Piano Adven- 2019. https://mouritz.org/?article=
tures Lesson Book: Level 2B (Fort Lauderdale, primary-control.
FL: The FJH Music Company, 1997). Goldston, Margaret. “The Sparkling Brook.”
20. Nancy Telfer, “Silent Moon.” Celebra- Celebration Series: Piano Repertoire Level 2.
tion Series: Piano Repertoire Level 2 (Toronto, Toronto, ON: Frederick Harris Music Com-
ON: Frederick Harris Music Company, 2015), pany, 2015.
24–25.
21. Telfer, “Silent Moon.”
Using Alexander Technique Principles

Grindea, Carola. “The History of ISSTIP.” The Kholer, Louis. “Etude in F Major,” Op. 190,
International Society for Study of Tension in No.27. Celebration Series: Piano Etudes Level
Performance. Last modified 2015. 2. Toronto, ON: Frederick Harris Music Com-
http://www.isstip.org/. pany, 2015.
“Home: The Definitive Guide to the Alexander Lister-Sink, Barbara. Freeing the Caged Bird.
Technique.” The Society of Teachers of the Directed by Barbara Lister-Sink. 1996; Lewis-
Alexander Technique (STAT). Last modified ville, NC: Wingsound, 1996. DVD.
2019. https://alexandertechnique.co.uk/ Mark, Thomas, Roberta Gary, and Thom Miles.
What Every Pianist Needs to Know About
the Body: With Supplementary Materials for
Gabriella Minnes Brandes, PhD, Organists. Chicago, IL: GIA Publications Inc.,
has been teaching the Alexander 2003.
Technique for more than 30 years. She Parker, Stephen. “Integrating Teaching and
teaches in the Theatre Department Learning- A New Model at the Norwegian
at Capilano University and at the Music Academy.” AmSAT Journal, no. 12
Alexander Technique Centre, working (Fall 2017): 52–56.
FEBRUARY 2020

extensively with musicians and music Spindler, Fritz. “Melody of Spring.” Technic
educators. is Fun, Elementary B (Preparatory), edited
by David Hirschberg. Van Nuys, CA: Bel-
win-Mills Publishing Corporation, 2000.
Telfer, Nancy. “Silent Moon.” Celebration Series:
34 Jennifer Condie, B.Mus., ARCT, RMT, Piano Repertoire Level 2. Toronto, ON: Fred-
has been teaching piano to beginners erick Harris Music Company, 2015.
MTNA e-JOURNAL

through university entrance for more “WeVu for Music.” WeVu, ISIT Technology Inc.
than 30 years. She works from her Last modified 2019.
home studio and is an avid supporter https://wevu.video/wevu-for-music/.
of local exams and festivals. Wheatley-Brown, Michèle, Gilles Comeau, and
Donald Russell. “The Role and Management
of Tension in Pedagogical Approaches to
Piano Technique.” Arts BioMechanics 2, no.
1 (2013): 2. http://www.mindbodymusic.ca/
wp-content/uploads/2014/11/the-role-
Aleah Wielinga, B.Mus., is a Van- and-management-of-tension-in-piano-
couver-based piano and Alexander approaches-.pdf.
Technique educator. Her teaching Ying, Loo Fung, Gabriel Isaac Evans, Mohd
and playing is driven by her continual Nasir Hashim, and Loo Fung Chait. “Tension
exploration of how to make music in a Release in Piano Playing: Teaching Alex-
holistic, joyful, and authentic way. ander Technique to Undergraduate Piano
Majors.” Procedia- Social and Behavioral
Sciences 174, (2015): 2413–2417.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sbspro.2015.01.910.
Reproduced with permission of copyright owner. Further reproduction
prohibited without permission.

You might also like