CASE 12
When she was nervous or felt bad,
Karen ate sweet things
THE CASE OF KAREN HENDERSON
(Karen Henderson was a French-Canadian who
came to the U.S. thirty years ago. She was fifty-eight
years old and had worked as a secretary to the
president of the Mathers Candy Company for twenty-
four years. Karen made only $5,000 a year when she
started, but she got a $1,000 raise every year, until she
she was making $29,000. On May 1, 1883, the presi-
dent of the company, Mr. Mathers, told her she was
no longer needed. He was going to replace her with a
new secretary for $10,000. Karen was very upset
because she was going to be sixty years old in two
years and could retire from the company with a
pension of $5,000 a year. Now she would get nothing
“Is this the way you repay me for twenty-four
years of service?” Karen asked.
“You have one more month: then you're fin-
ished,” said Mr. Mathers. “You don’t work as fast as
you used to, and besides, you've missed ten days due
to illness in the last five months. I need a fast and
healthy secretary. I'm sorry, Karen, but business is
business. Sooner or later age must step aside and let
youth take over. None of us is getting any younger.”
(2) Karen saw her lawyer and they decided to sue
the company. It seemed so unfair. They were going to
argue that the company was practicing illegal age
discrimination. Karen and her lawyer felt that it was
illegal to fire someone just for getting old
(3) Karen had health problems, and this bad news
made them worse. She had diabetes, a disease of the
blood. She had to take insulin every day. She was not
supposed to eat sweet things, but when she was
nervous and felt bad, she ate them anyway. She could
not stop herself. Once, after a fight with her husband,
Jack, she ate a pound of chocolates and had to to go
the hospital
(4) When the company found out that Karen was
going to sue, Mr. Mathers told her she could stay. He
gave her a new office—it used to be a closet! It had no
windows and was very small. She was there by
herself, and Mathers took away all of her respons
bilites. Now she had almost nothing to do all day.
‘Once, when she was crying, Mr. Mathers brought her
a pound of chocolates, She ate them all. She got sick
and almost died. Mathers told the other employees
that he didn’t know she was a diabetic, and he said
that he didn’t know that diabetics weren't supposed
to eat sweets.
(5)_ Karen knew that if she quit she would get no
pension and she would not be able to sue, She was
being forced to leave, but she wanted to get her
revenge before. she left. She knew that ten years ago
the company was in deep financial trouble. In 1972
Mr. Mathers changed the company’s books so that
they paid no taxes. The company was supposed to
pay $25,000. Karen told Mathers that she was going to
tell the truth to the newspapers and to the police.
She did not like doing that, and she-left Mathers's
office crying.
(6) At the same time, she was having problems with
her marriage. Her husband, Jack, also worked for the
Mathers Candy Company, and he was interested in
Mathers's new secretary, Sadie. Sadie had already
taken over many of Karen's ald responsibilities.
(7) Karen decided to delay talking to the news:
papers. Four days later, on May 10, 1983, her husband
found her dead in bed. The medical examiner said
she had died from too much sugar in her blood. By
her bed was an empty box of chocolates and an
empty half-gallon container of chocolate ice cream.
{8) The police found a typewritten suicide note.
They discovered that two pages of her diary had
been torn out. One of the pages was from May 7, 1983,
and the other was from May 3, 1972. Parts of the diary
were written in French. These parts told the truth
about Mathers not paying taxes.