You are on page 1of 4

455023

2012
JFM141210.1177/1098612X12455023Cannon and BrettJournal of Feline Medicine and Surgery

Short Communication

Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery

Comparison of how well conscious 14(12) 906­–909


© ISFM and AAFP 2012
Reprints and permission:
cats tolerate blood pressure sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav
DOI: 10.1177/1098612X12455023

measurement from the radial and jfms.com

coccygeal arteries

Martha J Cannon and Jo Brett

Abstract
Hypertension is a common condition of older cats and acquiring clinically relevant and repeatable blood pressure
(BP) measurements in conscious cats is important in its diagnosis and management. The most common sites for
indirect BP measurement in the cat are the radial artery (RA) and the coccygeal artery (CA) but, to date, there are
no published data comparing how conscious cats tolerate BP measurements from these sites. A high-definition
oscillometric BP monitor was used to measure BP in 30 cats admitted to a cat-only veterinary clinic for reasons other
than hypertension. Systolic arterial pressure (SAP), mean arterial pressure (MAP) and diastolic arterial pressure
(DAP) were measured using the RA and CA, alternating which site was used first. The number of failed attempts
and total time to achieve six measurements was recorded. Measurement of BP using the CA was better tolerated
than the RA, resulting in fewer failures and shorter total time required. SAP measurements were slightly higher from
the CA compared with the RA, irrespective of which site was used first. There were no significant differences in MAP
and DAP. The coccygeal artery appears to be the more appropriate site to use when measuring BP in conscious
cats using this oscillometric machine. Further studies are required using alternative BP monitors, including Doppler
machines, to establish whether this is a consistent finding. When measuring BP in cats the site used should be
recorded and the same site used for all subsequent measurements from the same cat.

Accepted: 25 June 2012

Hypertension is a common problem in older cats, espe- client-owned cats of different gender, breed and age
cially those with chronic renal failure1–4 or hyperthyroid- (range: 6 months to 18 years) that were admitted to a cat-
ism.5,6 Routine monitoring of blood pressure (BP) is only veterinary clinic for reasons other than hyperten-
recommended in all cats aged 11 years and older,7 all cats sion. All cats were allowed a minimum 5-min period of
with chronic renal failure and all cats that have recently acclimatisation before BP measurements were made, as
started treatment for hyperthyroidism.8 Acquiring clini- recommended in the 2007 American College of Veterinary
cally-useful, repeatable BP measurements in a timely Internal Medicine (ACVIM) Guidelines on Systemic
way is an important requirement in clinical practice, but Hypertension.12 Each cat was then allowed to settle in a
can be challenging in conscious cats owing to the con- natural position or, if still unsettled, was gently restrained
founding effects of stress.9–11 Using an anatomic site that while systolic arterial pressure (SAP), mean arterial pres-
is better tolerated may produce more reliable results and sure (MAP) and diastolic arterial pressure (DAP) were
may shorten the time required to achieve a result, encour- measured. Measurements were made using both the RA
aging increased utilisation of routine BP monitoring in and CA, alternating which site was used first. The same
veterinary practice. investigator operated the HDO MD-15 machine in each
The recommended sites for indirect BP measurement case, using a standard procedure recommended by the
in the cat are the radial artery (RA) and coccygeal artery
(CA).8,12 To date, there are no published data comparing Oxford Cat Clinic, Oxford, UK
how conscious cats tolerate BP measurements from
Corresponding author:
these sites.
Martha Cannon BA VetMB DSAM(Fel), Oxford Cat Clinic,
A high definition oscillometric BP monitor (HDO 78A Westway, Oxford, OX2 9JU, UK
Memodiagnostic-15) was used to measure BP in 30 Email: enquiries@oxfordcatclinic.co.uk
Cannon and Brett 907

manufacturers. The cats were restrained gently by an RA versus the CA for indirect oscillometric BP measure-
experienced veterinary nurse, but it was not possible to ment in the conscious cat in day-to-day veterinary prac-
use the same veterinary nurse for all cases. All measure- tice. We followed current ACVIM guidelines regarding
ments were taken in the same consultation room to measurement of BP, but also tried to mimic the con-
reduce the number of external variables that may have straints that apply when measuring feline BP in general
affected the results. practice. Under these conditions the CA was the pre-
Six successful readings of SAP, MAP and DAP were ferred site for measurement for the majority of the cats in
recorded from each site. In each case the first reading the study. It is also interesting to note that in the six cats
was discarded and the average of the remaining five for which there was no difference in time required, and
readings was calculated in accordance with the recom- in the four cats for which RA measurements were
mendations of the 2007 ACVIM Guidelines on Systemic achieved more easily than CA measurements, the time
Hypertension.12 The number of failed attempts and total required for either set of measurements was only a maxi-
time required to achieve six measurements was recorded. mum of 6 mins, suggesting that these cats were at the
The HDO MD-15 machine comes with a single, stand- more placid or relaxed end of the temperament range.
ard-sized cuff for use in cats which measures 4.3 cm The increased number of failed readings encountered
across; the same cuff was used in all cases. For RA meas- when using the RA was largely due to movement arte-
urements the cuff was positioned on the forelimb distal fact in a weight-bearing limb and oscillometric BP moni-
to the elbow with the inflation bladder over the palmar tors are particularly susceptible to this problem. In a
mid-line. Either the right or left fore limb was used previous study, Jepson et al measured BP in the fore limb
according to how the cat settled on the examination of conscious cats using a Doppler BP monitor and a
table. For the CA measurements the cuff was placed standard (not high definition) oscillometric machine.13
around the tail base with the inflation bladder positioned In this study operators using the Doppler machine were
over the ventral mid-line. In both cuff locations the cat successful in making five BP readings within 5 mins in
was gently restrained or was allowed to rest naturally, 37.5% of cases, whereas with the oscillometric machine
keeping the cuff within a 10 cm vertical height of the this was achieved in only 5% of cases. In 55% of cases it
heart. The order in which the two cuff locations were took longer than 10 mins to achieve five readings. In our
used was alternated between each case. study using the HDO-MemoDiagnostic 15 on the RA
It was not possible to measure the BP from the RA in five readings were achieved in under 5 mins in 34.5% of
one cat — a small male Sphynx cat whose fore limb cir- cases (10/29) and more than 10 mins was required in
cumference was too small for the standard sized cuff 24.1% of cases (7/29). In comparison, when using the
provided with the HDO MD-15 machine. This cat was CA, five measurements could be made in under 5 mins
excluded from the study and results for the remaining in 69% of cases (20/29) and more than 10 mins was
29 cats were included in the subsequent analysis. A required in only 1/29 cats.
summary of all results is shown in Table 1. While weight-bearing artefacts could be reduced by
Measuring BP using the CA was better tolerated than measuring the BP with the subject in lateral or sternal
using the RA, resulting in fewer failures (see Figure 1) recumbency this cannot be achieved in a majority of con-
and shorter total time required (see Figure 2). When tak- scious feline patients so this is a limitation of the oscillo-
ing measurements from the CA 33 failed attempts metric method. Further studies are required to identify
occurred while obtaining the 174 useable measurements whether similar disparity between results would be found
(15.9%) compared with 161 failed attempts (48.1%) using a Doppler BP machine on the CA and the RA.
encountered while obtaining the required 174 measure- The difference in SAP measured in the CA compared
ments from the RA. The significantly higher failure rate to the RA is in line with findings in anaesthetised dogs14
encountered when using the RA contributed to the but in this study may also be due, in part, to positioning.
increased time required to obtain a clinically-useful BP Measured BP will be higher the greater the vertical dis-
reading from that site. Mean time required to obtain six tance of the cuff below the heart. In this study cats were
BP readings from the CA was 4.35 mins (SD 2.1, range allowed to settle in a natural position whenever possible
2–13 mins) compared with a mean time of 8.1 minutes to reduce stress to the cat. In many cases the cat settled
(SD 6.7, range 2–28 mins) for the RA. into sternal recumbency and the tailhead would have
SAP measurements were slightly higher from the CA been approximately level with the heart; however, the
compared with the RA (mean 8.7%, P = 0.002), irrespec- position adopted by the cat was not recorded in this
tive of which site was used first. There were no signifi- study and cats that settled or were gently restrained in
cant differences in MAP and DAP. an upright position would have had a relatively large
This study did not attempt to assess the accuracy, or vertical distance from heart to tailhead, and likely a
otherwise, of the BP measurements that were obtained, larger distance than when their BP was measured via a
but rather attempted to assess the practical utility of the cuff on their antebrachium. In this study a second factor
908 Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery 14(12)

Table 1  Summary of data

Case Cuff site Radial artery measurements Coccygeal artery measurements


number  used first
Timea Failuresb Av Av Av Timea Failuresb Av Av Av
SBPc MAPd DBPe SBPc MAPd DBPe

 1 Forelimb 10 0 142.8 109.6 91 6 0 138.6 100.4 79.2


 2 Tail 5 5 142 97.4 73 4 4 134 100 80.8
 3 Forelimb 3 0 169.4 115.4 86.2 4 0 161 120 97.4
 4 Tail 12 9 113.4 87 71.6 3 0 115 78.4 57.8
 5 Forelimb 3 1 145.4 107.6 86.6 2 0 186.8 122 87.6
 6 Tail 7 4 145.6 102.4 78.8 3 1 147.6 103 78.8
 7 Forelimb 23 18 147 104.8 81.6 5 2 153.8 108.2 83.8
 8 Tail 2 0 142 104.6 83.8 2 0 146.2 105.4 83
 9 Forelimb 3 2 152.4 115.4 94.8 3 1 171.8 109.2 76
10 Tail 16 19 115.4 82.8 64.8 5 2 163.8 117.8 92.8
11 Forelimb 14 6 134.4 93.4 70.8 5 1 114.2 80.6 61.8
12 Tail 20 9 110.2 81.8 65.6 13 5 170.2 119.6 92.2
13 Forelimb 5 2 111.4 81.6 64.6 4 1 126 88.6 68
14 Tail 5 1 160.4 119.6 97.4 3 0 181.4 129.6 101.6
15 Forelimb 8 7 126 94.8 77 7 4 120.2 78.8 56
16 Tail 4 5 127.2 89.6 68.8 3 1 127.2 93.6 75
17 Forelimb 14 15 131 90.4 68.2 4 2 152.4 103.8 77.4
18 Tail N/A 9 N/A N/A N/A N/R 1 119.2 86.8 68.8
19 Forelimb 5 4 110.6 84.6 69.6 3 1 104.6 74.6 58
20 Tail 3 2 158.2 116.2 93.4 3 0 164 119.6 95.4
21 Forelimb 3 1 129 95.8 77 3 0 141.4 103.8 83
22 Tail 3 0 129 97.2 79.4 4 0 139.2 89.8 62.8
23 Forelimb 8 4 142.6 107.6 88.2 3 0 144.6 100.4 76.2
24 Tail 6 3 118.8 92.2 76.8 4 0 127.2 90.6 70.6
25 Forelimb 28 29 119.2 87.6 66.6 6 1 125.2 89.6 69.6
26 Tail 5 5 127.4 96.4 78.2 6 4 134.2 98 77.8
27 Forelimb 5 2 129.2 96.4 78 5 2 156 114.2 91
28 Tail 8 7 107.8 73.4 54 4 1 129.2 92 71.4
29 Forelimb 4 0 109.2 84.4 69.8 4 0 135.2 93.6 70.8
30 Tail 3 1 123 93.4 76.8 4 0 135.2 90.8 66.4
Average 8.1 5.7 4.3 1.2  

aTime,number of minutes taken to get six blood pressure measurements


bFailure,
number of failed attempts while getting six reliable readings
cAv SBP, average of five reliable systolic blood pressure measurements in mmHg
dAv MAP, average mean arterial pressure in mmHg
eAv DBP, average of five reliable diastolic blood pressure measurements in mmHg

may also have been the requirement to use the single range that would be considered to produce ‘moderate’
cuff size supplied with the HDO-Memodiagnostic or, in two cases, ‘high’ risk of target organ damage.12
machine to measure BP at both sites. Cuff size should be However, in five of these cats (cases 5, 9, 10, 12 and 20)
approximately 40% of the circumference of the append- the SBP measured in the RA was below 160 mmHg such
age to which it is applied: if the proximal tail has a sig- that they would have been categorised as at ‘mild’ or
nificantly larger circumference than the distal fore limb ‘minimal’ risk of target organ damage. One cat (case 14)
this would tend to produce a higher reading when using was confirmed as hypertensive based on repeated BP
the same sized cuff at each site. measurement using a Doppler BP monitor 1 month later
Whatever the source of the difference in measured BP (SBP in the RA: 230 mmHg; SBP in the CA: 225 mmHg).
between the CA and the RA it is interesting to note that Long-term (range: 17–39 months) follow-up information
in this study seven cats had systolic BP (SBP) above 160 was available on five of the other six cats none of which
mmHg when it was measured in the CA (see Table 1, developed hypertensive end organ damage or chronic
cases 3, 5, 9, 10, 12, 14 and 20). These results were in a renal failure during that period.
Cannon and Brett 909

7 12.0

6 10.0
Number of Failed Aempts

5
8.0

Time (Minutes)
4
6.0
3

2 4.0

1
2.0

0
0.0
Coccygeal Artery 1st Coccygeal Artery 2nd Radial Artery 1st Radial Artery 2nd
Coccygeal Artery 1st Coccygeal Artery 2nd Radial Artery 1st Radial Artery 2nd

Figure 1  Comparison of mean number of failed attempts to Figure 2  Comparison of mean time taken to obtain six
measure blood pressure from each site measurements from each site

The difference in BP measured in the CA compared 4 Jepsen RE. Feline systemic hypertension: classification
with the RA identified in this study confirms the impor- and pathogenesis. J Feline Med Surg 2011; 13: 25–34.
tance of recording the site on which the cuff was used 5 Syme HM and Elliott J. The prevalence of hypertension in
and of using the same site each time when undertak- hyperthyroid cats at diagnosis and following treatment.
ing serial BP monitoring in the same cat. This study also J Vet Intern Med 2003; 17: 754.
highlights that it is essential to use clinical findings, 6 Morrow LD, Adams VJ, Elliott J and Syme HM. Hyperten-
sion in hyperthyroid cats: prevalence, incidence and
including retinal examination, when interpreting the
predictors of its development. J Vet Intern Med 2009;
significance of apparently raised SBP in the conscious
23: 699.
cat and that the apparent hypertension should be 7 Pittari J, Rodan I, Beekman G, et al. American Association
confirmed to be a persistent finding on more than one of Feline Practitioners Senior Care Guidelines. J Feline
occasion before a diagnosis of hypertension is reached. Med Surg 2009; 11: 763.
Further studies comparing BP measurements obtained 8 Stepien RL. Feline systemic hypertension: diagnosis and
using oscillometric and Doppler machines in con- management. J Feline Med Surg 2011; 13: 35–43.
scious hypertensive cats are also required. 9 Belew AM, Barlett T and Brown SA. Evaluation of white-
coat effects in cats. J Vet Intern Med 1999; 13: 134–142.
Funding  This research received no grant from any funding 10 Sparkes AH, Caney SMA, King MCA and Gruffydd-Jones
agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors for TJ. Inter- and intra-individual variation in Doppler ultra-
this short communication. sonic indirect blood pressure measurements in healthy
cats. J Vet Intern Med 1999; 13: 314–318.
Conflict of interest  The authors declare that there is no 11 Quimby JM, Smith ML and Lunn KF. Evaluation of the
conflict of interest. effects of hospital visit stress on physiologic parameters
in the cat. J Feline Med Surg 2011; 13: 733–737.
12 Brown S, Atkins C, Bagley R, et al. ACVIM Consensus
References Statement: Guidelines for the identification, evaluation,
1 Kobayashi DL, Peterson ME, Graves TK, et al. Hyperten- and management of systemic hypertension in dogs and
sion in cats with chronic renal failure or hyperthyroidism. cats. J Vet Intern Med 2007; 21: 542–558.
J Vet Intern Med 1990; 4: 58–62. 13 Jepson RE, Hartley V, Mendl M, et al. A comparison of
2 Syme HM, Barber PJ, Markwell PJ and Elliott J. Prevalence CAT Doppler and oscillometric Memoprint machines for
of systolic hypertension in cats with chronic renal failure at non-invasive blood pressure measurement in conscious
initial evaluation. J Am Vet Med Assoc 2002; 220: 1799–1804. cats. J Feline Med Surg 2005; 7: 147.
3 Stiles J, Polzin DJ and Bistner SI. The prevalence of reti- 14 Bodey AR, Young LE, Bartram DH, et al. A comparison of
nopathy in cats with systemic hypertension and chronic direct and indirect (oscillometric) measurements of arte-
renal failure or hyperthyroidism. J Am Anim Hosp Assoc rial blood pressure in anaesthetised dogs, using tail and
1994; 30: 564–572. limb cuffs. Res Vet Sci 1994; 57: 265–269.

You might also like