Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2019 Gauteng Health Annual Report
2019 Gauteng Health Annual Report
ANNUAL REPORT
2018/19
Together, Moving Gauteng City Region Forward
GAUTENG PROVINCE
HEALTH
REPUBLIC OF SOUTH AFRICA
DISTRIBUTION OF SERVICE PLATFORMS
FINANCIAL INPUTS
ACTUAL EXPENDITURE
65 821
Total Health Workforce
DENTAL DENTAL
REGISTRARS PRACTITIONERS
41 308
STUDENT PROFESSIONAL
MEDICAL DENTAL NURSES NURSES
REGISTRARS SPECIALISTS 2 437 14 897
1 215 116
9 169 11 398
LEVEL 13 LEVEL 14
73 23
JUNIOR LOWER
LOWER JUNIOR MIDDLE MANAGERS LEVELS
LEVELS MANAGERS MANAGERS (LEVELS 9-10) Management
(LEVELS 1-8) (LEVELS 9-10) (LEVELS 11-12) (LEVELS 1-8)
2 Professionals
8 478 457 234 11 396
LEVEL 15 LEVEL 16
3 1
268 008 pregnant women given 126 788 learners immunized for HPV
antenatal care services
Supported 222 115 deliveries 167 100 learners screened for potential
at our facilities learning barriers
Communicable Conditions
PR 223/2019
ISBN: 978-0-621-47565-4
PART A
GENERAL INFORMATION
1. DEPARTMENT GENERAL INFORMATION 4
2. ABBREVIATIONS AND ACRONYMS 6
3. FOREWORD BY THE MEC FOR HEALTH 8
4. REPORT OF THE ACCOUNTING OFFICER 10
5. STATEMENT OF RESPONSIBILITY AND CONFIRMATION OF
THE ACCURACY OF THE ANNUAL REPORT 15
6. STRATEGIC OVERVIEW 16
7. ORGANISATIONAL STRUCTURE 17
8. ENTITIES REPORTING TO THE MEC 18
9. LEGISLATIVE AND OTHER MANDATES 18
PART B
PERFORMANCE INFORMATION
1. AUDITOR-GENERAL’S REPORT: PREDETERMINED OBJECTIVES 20
2. OVERVIEW OF DEPARTMENTAL PERFORMANCE 20
3. STRATEGIC OUTCOME-ORIENTATED GOALS 26
4. PERFORMANCE INFORMATION BY PROGRAMME 27
5. TRANSFER PAYMENTS 81
6. DONOR FUNDS 82
7. CONDITIONAL GRANTS 83
8. CAPITAL INVESTMENT
PART C
87
GOVERNANCE
1. INTRODUCTION 99
2. RISK MANAGEMENT 99
3. MINIMISING CONFLICTS OF INTEREST 99
4. FRAUD AND CORRUPTION 100
5. CODE OF CONDUCT 100
6. HEALTH, SAFETY AND ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES 100
7. PORTFOLIO COMMITTEES 102
8. SCOPA RESOLUTIONS 108
9. PRIOR MODIFICATIONS TO AUDIT REPORTS 116
10. INTERNAL CONTROL UNIT 116
11. REPORT OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE 117
PART D
HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
1. INTRODUCTION 121
2. OVERVIEW OF HUMAN RESOURCES 121
3. HUMAN RESOURCES OVERSIGHT STATISTICS 122
PART E
FINANCIAL INFORMATION
1. REPORT OF THE AUDITOR-GENERAL 153
2. ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 162
PART F
MSD FINANCIAL INFORMATION
1. REPORT OF THE ACCOUNTING OFFICER 282
2. REPORT OF THE AUDITOR-GENERAL 294
3. ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 399
ABOUT THE
4-18
DEPARTMENT
Information about the
mandate, location and
messages from the MEC
and the accounting
officer on performance
of the Department.
ADMINISTRATIVE
OVERVIEW
A performance report
outlining quality improve-
ment, technology and
20-78
transformation agenda.
DISTRICT HEALTH
CARE SERVICES
GOVERNANCE,
HUMAN FINANCIAL
A&E Accident and Emergency DPME Department of Planning, Monitoring and Evaluation
ACLS Advanced Cardiac Life Support DPSA Department of Public Service and Administration
AGYW Adolescent Girls and Young Women ECA Emergency Care Assistant
B-BBEE Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment FCSU Family Violence, Child Protection and Sexual Offences Unit
CCMDD Centralised Chronic Medicine Dispensing and Distribution GHAC Gauteng Health Accreditation Committee
CCPGP Co-ordinating Chamber of the Public Service Co-ordinating Bargaining Council CBC for Gauteng Province GP Gauteng Province
CHBAH Chris Hani Baragwanath Academic Hospital HAST HIV, AIDS, STIs and TB
CRO Chief Risk Officer HPCSA Health Professions Council of South Africa
DGMAH Doctor George Mukhari Academic Hospital HWSETA Health & Welfare Sector Education & Training Authority
DHIS District Health Information System ICSP Internship and Community Service Programme
IMCI CC Integrated Management Of Childhood Illnesses Community Component PMTCT Prevention Of Mother-To-Child Transmission
ISHP Integrated School Health Programme PRAAD Policy On Reasonable Accommodation And Assistive Devices
LAN Local Area Network PSCBC Public Service Co-Ordinating Bargaining Council
LBC Liquid Base Cytology PSETA Public Service Education And Training Authority
LTDOT Long Term Domiciliary Oxygen Therapy PSRMF Public Sector Risk Management Framework
MPAT Management Performance Assessment Tool SABS South African Bureau Of Standards
MPET Management Performance Enhancement Tool SADC Southern African Development Community
MPSA Minister Of Public Service And Administration SAM Severe Acute Malnutrition
MSD Medical Supplies Depot SAMEC South African Malaria Elimination Committee
MSSN Management Of Small And Sick New-Borns SANC South African Nursing Council
NDPW National Department Of Public Works SETA Sector Education And Training Authority
NGO Non-Governmental Organisation SIPDM Standard For Infrastructure Procurement And Delivery Management
NIDS National Information Data System SMME Small, Medium Or Micro Enterprise
OHSC Office Of The Health Standards And Compliance TER Township Economy Revitalisation
PEPFAR President's Emergency Plan For AIDS Relief VHF Viral Haemorrhagic Fever
PFMA Public Finance Management Act VMMC Voluntary Medical Male Circumcision
PHSDSBC Public Health And Social Development Bargaining Council Wits University Of the Witwatersrand
The report reflects the milestones and difficulties that the While our focus and some of the expectations of the communities we
Department has overcome, in the face of particular pressures during serve have tended to be on curative care, it is well recognised that
the year, in ensuring that the health care needs of the people of delivery of healthcare requires a much broader approach. As part of
Gauteng are met. The effects of rapid urbanisation and increased pushing back the frontiers of ill-health, the GDoH launched a
migration are amongst the Department’s greatest challenges. The three-year Health, Wellness and Happiness programme on 16
report therefore reflects these challenges and their effects on the November 2018 with the aim of increasing health promotion and
health service. disease prevention for better health outcomes.
In developing the report and in planning for the next five years, the Despite the many challenges facing its health system, Gauteng has
Department has taken stock of government’s priorities. Gauteng is a the highest proportion of primary health facilities certified as Ideal
diverse, multi-racial and multi-class society where, in providing Clinics in South Africa; this is confirmed by the Office of Health
adequate health services, “the people must always come first”. This Standards Compliance which is responsible for guiding, monitoring
is the spirit that drives Team Gauteng Health during this new term. and enforcing health care safety and quality standards in the
Taking full account of the pressures and challenges that currently country’s health facilities. We have worked hard to introduce the Ideal
prevent our public healthcare system from meeting the standards of Hospitals Accreditation system in line with the Ideal Clinics System,
excellence to which we aspire, we must persist in our objective of and have appointed a panel of eight professionals as the Gauteng
improving the quality of healthcare for all the province’s residents. Health Accreditation Committee (GHAC) whose main purpose is to
The GDoH is the largest health service provider in South Africa, sustain and expand the province’s Ideal Clinics status and to realise
serving 14,6 million residents (25 % of the country’s population). the Ideal Hospitals system.
Over the past two and half decades, the province’s population has
doubled and the number of patient visits almost tripled. Only 25% Average life expectancy in Gauteng has increased from 56 to 67
of the population have adequate medical aid coverage (according to years, and mother-to-child transmission of HIV has been reduced over
a 2017 report by Statistics South Africa). This increases demand for the past five year term of government to 0,9% ushering in the
public healthcare services as, when medical aid scheme benefits do possibility that South Africa will be amongst the first countries in the
not exist or are exhausted, people turn to the public sector. world to do so. A decentralisation policy underlies this success, with
delegations to strengthen district management.
The Department has reduced past year accruals and irregular As we chart a way forward for the next five years, we will continue
expenditure and has progressively improved the rate of payments to to position ourselves as a leader in the country, particularly in
suppliers within 30 days. Much more remains to be done to ensure relation to the roll-out of National Health Insurance. I encourage all
that business processes become more efficient, with officials and of us to re-commit ourselves to diligence in service as we forge
management held accountable for their actions and inactions in ahead towards high quality healthcare for all. In the next five years,
areas of recurring underperformance. we will as a Department continue to implement the Recovery Road
Map strategy and to provide the people of Gauteng with a
In his State of the Province address, Gauteng Premier David Makhura transformed, responsive and effective public health service.
pointed to the profound challenges relating to service delivery in the
health system and that these have to be resolved as soon as possible.
The financial and structural challenges facing the public healthcare
system are the subject of urgent attention by the Provincial Executive
Council and National Cabinet, with President Ramaphosa
announcing measures to deal with these matters as part of the ___________________________
Economic Stimulus and Recovery Plan. This includes addressing Gauteng MEC for Health
shortages in hospitals, making funding available to buy new medical 31 May 2019
equipment and linen and filling critical medical posts.
Despite the acute challenges to the health system, the Department In this regard, we were saddened by an increasing number of attacks
continued to strive for improved quality of service, as indicated by on our staff, predominantly emergency medical services staff with
the fact that the GDoH has the highest proportion of clinics that are some isolated attacks at our health facilities. We will continue to use
Ideal Clinics in the country, at 89%. Also, 30 of its 32 Community every avenue to educate and increase the awareness of communities
Health Centres (CHCs) provide comprehensive 24 hour services. of their responsibilities to health care delivery and advocate for
Efforts to improve access to medicines saw enrolment of clients in communities that are comprised of public health activists. The
the Centralised Chronic Medicine Dispensing and Distribution Department in collaboration with the Department of Community
programme rising to 490 518. Safety, the South African Police Service and the Private Security
Industry Regulatory Authority have undertaken a process of
Notwithstanding the efforts of the Department to provide quality strengthening physical security at health facilities through insourcing
health care, it has been hampered by several instances of labour physical security using police reservists and community safety
unrest, namely those by student nurses, community health workers patrollers.
and general staff demanding payment of performance bonuses.
4.2 OVERVIEW OF THE DEPARTMENT’S FINANCIAL
RESULTS
Another significant event that unsettled the Department's
administrative operations was the fire at the Bank of Lisbon building The Department surpassed its revenue collection target by R272
on the 5th of September 2018. Although the impact on service million (54%). The notable improvement in revenue collection is a
delivery of the fire was minimal, the administrative functioning of result of increased payments received from medical schemes, the
the Department was significantly impacted particularly in that access Road Accident Fund and self-paying patients. Despite this, payment
to records was restricted, it became difficult to account fully for delays from some provinces are still encountered, with no payments
assets and employees underwent emotional trauma. In addition, received from Limpopo and Mpumalanga provinces. There will be
there was loss of administrative productivity as support staff were at continuous engagement with revenue collecting agencies regarding
home due to lack of office space, tools of their trade and operational outstanding debts.
infrastructure.
2018/19 2017/18
Sale of goods and services other than capital assets 475 648 657 -173 322 449 821 503 424 -53 603
Transfers received - - - - 1 -1
Interest, dividends and rent on land 1 422 764 658 1 344 974 370
Financial transactions in assets and liabilities 31 134 131 284 -100 150 29 427 42 470 -13 043
Total 507 949 780 803 -272 854 480 647 547 318 -66 671
The following information outlines in detail how tariffs charged by the Department were determined.
Tariff Policy
Patient Fee Tariff
The Department charges according to the Uniform Patient Fee • Free health services for pregnant women and children under the
Schedule (UPFS) tariffs for patients using public hospitals. These age of six (Notice 657 of 1994, 1 July 1994).
tariffs are determined by a steering committee consisting of the • Free primary health care services (Notice 1514 of 1996, 17
National Department of Health and the health Departments of the October 1996).
nine provinces. Tariffs are reviewed and revised annually in • Termination of pregnancy (Act 92 of 1996).
accordance with Section 7.3.1 of the Treasury Regulations. Patients • Social Pensioners (Act 81 of 1967 as amended by Act 100 of
accessing public institutions are classified into three main groups for 1998).
service fee determination. The classifications are listed below: • Medico-legal services for survivors of rape, assault and post
mortem (Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977).
Full Paying • Donors (Human Tissue Act 63 of 1965).
This category of patients is liable to pay full UPFS fees for all services • Children who are committed to the care of a children’s home,
provided. industrial school or foster parents (Child Care Act 74 of 1983,
Section 15).
Subsidised and Exempted Patients
• Persons with mental disorders (Mental Health Act 18 of 1973).
These patients are classified into six categories (PH, PG, HG, H0, H1,
• Treatment of infectious, formidable and notifiable diseases
H2 and H3) based on statutory requirements. The PG and HG
(National Health Act 61 of 2003).
categories are exempted from paying fees because of statutorily
• Services to the formally unemployed (Unemployment Insurance
determined circumstances: for example, pregnant women and
Act 63 of 2001).
children under the age of six.
• Patients receiving HIV and AIDS treatment (Notice 1 of August
2006).
The H0 category receives services free of charge only when they
provide proof of status: for example, social pensioners. The H1, H2
and H3 category pay discounted fees which are expressed as a Meals and Crèche Fees Tariffs
percentage of the fees payable by full-paying patients. The tariffs for meals and crèches are reviewed and revised annually
in accordance with Section 7.3.1 of the Treasury Regulations. Tariff
adjustments are also negotiated and agreed upon with employee
Free Services
organisations.
The following free services are provided in line with national and
Other Tariffs
provincial policies:
Other tariffs such as parking and accommodation are determined
externally with the involvment of relevant Departments.
The table below summarises the performance of the appropriated budget and expenditure per programme from 2017/18 to 2018/19.
Administration 1 361 130 1 360 786 344 1 085 267 1 085 177 90
District Health Services 15 073 917 14 516 480 557 437 13 712 101 13 683 513 28 588
Emergency Medical Services 1 423 203 1 330 508 92 695 1 268 154 1 219 274 48 880
Provincial Hospital Services 8 746 469 8 686 653 59 816 7 892 663 7 892 277 386
Central and Tertiary Hospitals 17 135 226 17 134 256 970 15 333 041 15 316 687 16 354
Health Sciences and Training 1 123 296 1 106 708 16 588 928 471 918 987 9 484
Health Care Support Services 339 156 339 048 108 289 838 289 767 71
Health Facilities Management 1 559 933 1 536 120 23 813 1 683 299 1 607 777 75 522
Total 46 762 330 46 010 559 751 771 42 192 834 42 013 459 179 375
engaged with cooperatives, small and medium enterprises (SMMEs) supply chain processes for the leasing of 45 Commissioner Street for
and Military Veterans, communicating opportunities available for staff relocated following the Bank of Lisbon fire.
Yours faithfully
_____________________________________
Accounting Officer
Gauteng Department of Health
31 May 2019
MISSION
VALUES
MEC: GAUTENG
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
Head Of Department
Head Office
DDG: Human
CD: Information and Chief of Operations Resources & CD: Corporate Chief Financial DDG: Facility
Technology (L14) (L15) OD (L15) Services (L14) Officer 9L15) Management (L15)
CD: Tuberculosisi
(TB)
CD: Health
Economics &
Financing
CD: EMS
CD: Pharmacetical
Services
Registered as ‘The Central The depot charges a levy of The MSD is responsible for the
Medical Supplies Depot (MSD)
Medical Trading Account’ 5% on stock supplied to the supply of essential medicines
since 1 April 1992 under the provincial healthcare facilities. and disposable sundry items
Exchequer Act, Act 1 of 1976 to the Gauteng provincial
healthcare facilities.
The Department’s service delivery catered for primary prevention Apart from work with households, the Department further increased
and curative and quaternary/specialised services. As regards primary access to health through its integrated school health programme.
prevention, the Department provided both educationally oriented This involved visits to 746 schools where 167 100 pupils were
and outreach programmes at health facilities, households and screened for various health-related conditions which have the
schools. potential to impact negatively on learning. In this regard, 86 015
learners were referred for speech, oral health, eye care and hearing
As a result of these programmes access to health care services was problems and suspected TB. The table below provides a breakdown
improved. For instance, the number of patients cared for at of the provision of such services.
household level through the 796-strong ward-based outreach teams
came to 3 374 445 patients, a 44 % increase from the previous year.
Of the clients seen at household level, 63097 were referred to health
facilities and/or to social workers.
A range of initiatives are being implemented to improve access to Innovative measures are also being implemented to decongest
health care services and in this regard the Department continues to health facilities and ensure that chronic medicines are provided
provide 24-hour comprehensive health care services in 30 of its 32 closer to where users live and work. As a result, 490 518 clients have
CHCs. All CHCs with Maternity Obstetric Units continue to provide access to various centres where they can collect their medicine
24-hour care services for supported deliveries. As a result 44 059 supplies conveniently.
deliveries across our primary health care facilities were supported by
a professional midwife. Complicated cases are also supported Notable improvements were also observed in rehabilitative services,
through specialist obstetricians across our regional and tertiary levels with provision of various assistive devices aimed at enhancing the
of care. By the end of the financial year under review, 222 115 quality of life of patients.
deliveries were attended to at our various health facilities, with only
7 439 born before arrival at the hospital.
The table below shows the devices issued and requested, and the issue rate for the reporting period.
Table: Assistive devices issued
Efforts to improve the immunity of children under five years Emergency transport services between health facilities also played a
continued, in addition to other interventions aimed at improving critical role in the survival of patients. The Department in the
child survival. This included immunisation of 221 437 children under financial year increased the fleet to 5 859 and helped enhance the
one year on various vaccine schedules. While the numbers capacity of emergency transport personnel to ensure that these
immunised increased, coverage of over 90% is still not being services are operated by highly technically qualified professionals. To
reached, and REACH outreach programmes are continuing to this end, 479 147 priority patients were transported to hospitals
ensure that every child is immunised. presenting with a range of conditions.
Challenges related to late presentation of children at health facilities Specialised services provided through the National Tertiary Service
by health caregivers are also being tackled directly through the grants reflect an increase in demand, with over 1.4 million patients
continued Integrated Management of Childhood Illnesses (IMCI) attending clinics whose services range from burns to oncology
community training and health education to ensure that no child services. Various hospital related services were also provided to
dies from dehydration due to diarrhoea, severe malnutrition or 5 730 255 and 887 382 patients who presented at outpatient and
pneumonia. Clinical governance to help improve these areas emergency Departments, respectively.
through the support of district clinical specialists is taking place.
It became clear from the last quarter of the 2017/18 financial year The following summary provides highlights from the recovery
that drastic measures were required to turn around the performance roadmap:
trajectory of the priority health programmes including a
LEADERSHIP, GOVERNANCE AND ACCOUNTABILITY
commitment to an iron clad policy position which required
partnership with and the consent of suppliers if the Department was i. Governance Charter developed outlines the various Executive
to fare better and exercise financial prudence. Committee system and management structures of the
Department. The assessment of the management structures is
As a result, several key engagements were convened with various intended to rationalise them and ensure that their purpose
stakeholders to help support the Department in its journey of aligns to the strategy of the Department.
recovery. By the first quarter of the year under review, the MEC and ii. SOPs focusing on performance accountability from primary
HOD had convened a two-day summit titled: "Commitment to health care facilities to Head Office are being implemented.
Quality Health Services: Accelerating Service Delivery Accountability on performance has been changed from
Improvement for Maternal, Neonatal and Child Health". The quarterly to weekly/monthly to ensure proactive dealing with
summit provided a platform for 300 nursing and medical personnel, potential glitches in service delivery while addressing the
policymakers, health systems leaders, specialists in reproductive, strategic objectives of the Department.
maternal and child health, community representatives, health iii. A Management Performance Enhancement Tool has been
information management specialists, monitoring and evaluation developed to provide a framework for assessing performance at
(M&E) specialists and advocacy groups on women and child related a glance for each hospital. This will help the organisation to
issues to engage on how to accelerate performance improvements ensure that management practices comply fully with legislation
in services for women and neonates. and frameworks for effective governance.
iv. Weekly accountability by the Big Seven hospitals is consistently
A committee comprising obstetricians, neonatologists, monitored through Microsoft teams while the other platforms
paediatricians, midwives and policymakers has been formed to (regional, district and sub-district hospitals) are being assisted to
develop a service-oriented recovery plan. This will ensure that the achieve consistent reporting.
persisting challenges pertaining to maternal and child health-related v. Loading of portfolios of evidence gained momentum during the
care are addressed in a comprehensive manner covering short to third quarter, and all hospital and district folders have been
long term interventions. created on the SharePoint and evidence can be uploaded.
ICT OPTIMISATION
Through this committee, the Department hosted a Maternal and
Neonatal Health Summit. A recovery plan was developed, and its i. Video-conferencing implemented at three main sites in the
costed implementation plan is being finalised. Through the advocacy province to help optimise management processes.
of this committee, a Clinical Governance Group comprising various ii. ICT Strategy finalised.
heads of clinical Departments was established to cover all other iii. LAN implemented across four hospitals, including broad access.
specialities. iv. Health Patient Registration System deployed in 69% of 372 PHC
facilities with 2.8 million patient registrations on the system.
Another important organisational process was the finalisation of the
Mental Health Recovery Plan following the conclusion of the
arbitration processes.
Financial and SCM business processes have been re-engineered, HEALTH, WELLNESS AND HAPPINESS
standardised and integrated. The tracking process for finance and
i. The GDoH developed a policy framework, the first of its kind in
SCM performance includes the implementation of electronic
the history of the Gauteng health system, for implementation
invoicing, improvement of demand plan processes, the introduction
over three years. The policy is benchmarked on models from
of an electronic demand management plan, workshops and
other countries, e.g. Community-oriented Primary Care (COPC)
strengthening of the DBAC’s controls by ensuring that all deviations
in the Cuban health care system.
are approved at the appropriate level.
ii. The framework was launched 16 November 2019 by the
HUMAN RESOURCES FOR HEALTH Gauteng Premier.
iii. It provides a paradigm shift, seeking to revolutionise health
i. A total of 2 056 posts were approved by the post-filling outcomes and give focus to health promotion.
committee, inclusive of sessional posts. Of these, 828 were iv. It has the potential to strengthen the health sector, reversing the
nursing posts in all categories. focus from treating to preventing disease.
ii. All SMS personnel signed their performance contracts at the v. Disease prevention and health promotion as outlined in the
beginning of the financial year. policy takes a multi-sectoral approach, with inter-Departmental
iii. Training of Human Resources (HR) managers on HR ethics has collaboration bringing all Departments together to address
been completed. Training of the trainer will ensure that all HR challenges that impact on the health of communities before
managers are trained in this area, with a focus on HR they manifest as illnesses.
professionals.
Several management structures and posts that are critical to the
CLINICAL
recovery of the Department have been prioritised. Important posts
i. The CEOs and governance structures Management Performance filled include the appointment of the two central hospital heads and
Enhancement Tool (MPET) Management Information of a Chief Risk Officer for the Department. Business continuity was
Performance Framework was completed with the support of the also implemented following the Bank of Lisbon building fire,
Department of Planning, Monitoring and Evaluation (DPME) and assisting in minimising the impact of business interruptions.
some of its components are being implemented while awaiting
its automation. Finally, the Department, as part of efforts to improve governance,
ii. Implementation of the Ideal Hospitals prrogramme commenced redefined the mandate of the hospital boards from advisory to
with the Gauteng Health Accreditation Committee oversight. This will go a long way in improving governance and
Implementation in progress. The committee was established to accountability. Key challenges relating to labour peace were also
help prepare Gauteng hospitals for external assessments by the tackled head-on and efforts are being made to strengthen the
Office of Health Care Standards and Compliance (OHSC). effectiveness of labour relations Departments, thus improving
Inspections are continuing. relations in the health sector between labour and management.
iii.A Mental Health Recovery Plan was developed and is being
implemented. Additional resources have been provided to cater
for mental health in the 2019/20 financial year
The Department has completed a Service Delivery Improvement Plan. The tables below highlight the nature of the plan and its achievements
to date.
Table: Main services and standards
Antenatal Services provided to Pregnant women attending antenatal 58.4% 70% Antenatal care was provided to
women with a first visit before 20 care with Antenatal 1st visit before 20 64.7% of pregnant women during
weeks from 58.4% to 75% weeks of gestation the first 20 weeks of pregnancy
Roll out of the pregnancy testing Women of reproductive age N/A 2500 36 153 screened for pregnancy
by WBOTs at household level (5000)
Promotion of Sexual and Teenagers and youth N/A 250 000 3500 youth and teenagers who
Reproductive Health services with received sexual reproductive health
a focus on teenagers and youth education
WBOTS promotion of early Pregnant women N/A 10% increase During household outreach visits 540
antenatal booking and post-natal (3.3%) of pregnant women were
care referred for antenatal care
1000 trained nurses and doctors Pregnant women N/A 45% of clinicians 1000 midwives, doctors, medical
on ESMOE trained on associates and paramedics were
ESMOE trained
Consultation 5 community dialogues/consultations 500 Targted Community dialogues in 3 community dialogues were
conducted at least once per year per sub-districts with low uptake of early conducted
Health District Antenatal care bookings (less than 50%)
1 Radio station and 1 Print Media 2 Radio stations and Print Media N/A
Courtesy Analysis of all MOMCONNECT complaints Implementation of the mitigation Analysis of the datasets in the
database to determine the trends linked to strategy. Provision of Antenatal Services database is still to be carried out
antenatal service and develop mitigation in a respectful manner and reduction in
strategy Antenatal related complaints by 5%
Access 30151 households visited by WBOT teams 31587 households visited by WBOT During household outreach visits 8
where pregnant women were referred to teams where pregnant women were 540 (3.3%) of pregnant women
facilities referred to facilities were referred for antenatal care
Current Current Status Desired Year Cycle 2018/19 2018/19 Progress In This
Standard Reporting Period
Information Provide information pertaining 30151 households visited by 31587 households visited by During household outreach visits
to pregnancy and child birth WBOT teams where pregnancy WBOT teams where pregnancy 8 540 (3.3%) of pregnant women
through dialogues, care was given care was given were referred for antenatal care
MOMCONNECT and SBCC
materials / media / WBOT
Openness and Sharing of the annual Distribute citizens report to Distribute citizens report to On an annual basis the
Transparency citizens report with clients focusing on antenatal clients focusing on Department prints infographics
communities based on clients antenatal clients which are distributed during
planned targets community sessions on the annual
performance of the Department.
Current Standard Current Status Desired Year Cycle 2018/19 Progress In This
Reporting Period
Redress Resolve all received complaints within 25 Resolve all received complaints within 25 95-98% of complaints are resolved
working days working days within the agreed 25 days
Resolve all received MOMCONNECT Resolve all received complaints within 10 85% of complaints were resolved
complaints within 10 working days working days within 10 days
Inform patients upon consultation should All Antenatal care patients are informed Communities are made aware of
there be changes in the staffing or service upon consultation should there be the changes
delivery patterns changes in the staffing or service
delivery patterns
Service Standards Provision of antenatal care every day five Provision of antenatal care every day 177 facilities are providing
days a week from 08h00 to 16h00, five days a week as per the maternity antenatal care 5 days a week
including extended service hours as per the guidelines
maternity guidelines
Gauteng
Goals Indicator Baseline 2018/19
Performance
2017/18
Improved health and wellbeing Under-5 mortality rate (U5MR) per 1000 live births
of all citizens, with an emphasis 6.9 6.1
on children and women
Neonatal mortality rate (<28 days) (per 1 000 live births) 13.6 13/1 000 live births
Reduced rate of new infections Mother-to-child transmission rate of HIV <2 months of age 0.99% 1.19%
and the burden of HIV & AIDS The proportion of eligible HIV positive pregnant women initiated 94.7% 96.8%
and TB
on antiretroviral treatment (ART)
Number of patients (adults and children) on ART 927 825 1 037 212
Medical male circumcisions 112 608 102 325
Proportion of TB treatment successes among all TB cases 87.5% (84%) 28 705/34 190
TB defaulter rate at the end of TB treatment among all TB cases 5.2% 5.2%
Percentage of HIV-TB co-infected patients on ART on completion 90.3% 88.2%
of TB treatment
Increased equal and timely PHC utilisation rate 1.5 visits per person 1.5 visits per person
access to efficient and quality
health care services, thereby
preparing for the roll-out of
National Health Insurance (NHI)
To provide strategic direction and leadership; guide and support the increase was the result of encouraging employees who had not
development of policy frameworks and guidelines for priority declared their disability status to do so. However, the majority of
programmes; develop policies and legislation on healthcare people with disabilities do not have Health Sciences qualifications
provision;and ensure that norms and standards are followed in the and particularly in medicine and nursing, and the Department has
course of implementation. few vacancies in Administration and Support where people with
disabilities could be placed. Ongoing prioritisation of such people
Sub-programmes will include sourcing CVs from organisations working with people
• Human Resource Management with disabilities and encouraging walk-in applications.
• Quality Assurance
• Information and Communications Technology. Efforts to improve the experience of health care services by persons
with disabilities included changes to physical infrastructure at health
Strategic objectives
facilities. Roadshows and advocacy workshops were carried out in
• Improved client satisfaction rates.
three health districts and at five hospitals to sensitise staff to the
• Improved achievement against national norms for health
need to treat colleagues with disabilities with the dignity and
professionals.
respect they deserve. Workshops on Policy on Reasonable
• Employment equity and diversity management.
Accommodation and Assistive Devices (PRAAD) took place in most
of the province’s hospitals and districts.
Significant achievements, and strategies to address areas of
underperformance
QUALITY ASSURANCE
HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT Efforts to improve the quality of care and patient safety and
experience of health services included the establishment of a
During Women’s Month, Youth Month and in August during the Gauteng Accreditation Committee which will support institutions’
Service Delivery Expos organised by the Office of the Premier, the self-assessment before external assessment by the Office of Health
Department provided a range of health promotion services Care Standards. Compared with the previous reporting year, six
including screening for diabetes, high blood pressure, cholesterol, priority areas across all hospitals showed performance
HIV/AIDS, breast and cervical cancer and dental health. improvement. However, scores and performance levels for
Cleanliness and Infection Prevention and Control still need to
During the year under review, the number of people with improve, and Positive and Caring Attitudes and Patient Safety both
disabilities employed increased from 450 in 2017/18 to 1100. This scored below 75%.
The table below shows average scores per level of care in relation to core standards
Table: National core standards comparison report
Increase diversity, verification of qualifications and equity of our workforce thus increasing the number of women in senior
management positions from adequate (41%) to good (50%) and the percentage of people with disabilities employed to 2% by
2019/20.
Percentage of women 46.5% 48% 46.2% (1.8%) Target could not be achieved because of
in senior management (53/114) (56/117) (48/104) the termination of a female SMS member
posts (117 senior in the last quarter of the year. In the new
managers) financial year, the Department will target
female candidates for SMS posts.
Percentage of newly 23.2% 100% 0% (100%) Verification of non- clinical staff continued,
appointed non-clinical staff albeit using internal mechanisms. Target
members with verified not achieved due to budgetary challenges.
qualifications The Department will prioritise procurement
of a service provider to conduct
verifications and consider policy revisions.
Enforce performance management at Senior Management Service (SMS) level thus increasing SMS signed contracts to 100% by
2019/20.
Improve the relationship between employer and employees in the workplace thus resolving grievances within 30 working days and
misconduct cases within 90 days.
Percentage of 90% 100% 87.9% (12.1%) Target not achieved due to the
grievances cases (327/372) unavailability of critical parties to finalise
resolved within 30 grievance cases. The Department has
working days developed a labour relations framework
aimed at improving case management,
including building labour relations capacity
in institutions.
[1] There was no strategic objective statement attached to this performance indicator; this has been included as part of the Strategic Plan review that the SCM branch conducted.
The results will be fully documented when the process is completed in October 2016. It includes: Maintain percentage of linen contracts awarded to women cooperatives at 100%
by 2019/20; Increase percentage of hospitals procuring/buying vegetables from local farmers to 90% by 2019/20; Increase percentage of hospitals procuring dairy products from
local farmers to 80% by 2019/20; Increase percentage of hospitals procuring bread from small/medium scale bakeries to 70% by 2019/20.
Percentage of budget # 40% 29.5% (10.5%) Target not achieved because of limited
spent on township R86.4/R292,8 marketing of business opportunities. In
enterprises against collaboration with National Empowerment
identified commodities Fund and the Gauteng Enterprise Propeller,
the Department has held supplier
workshops to boost the township
economy and will continue to strengthen
marketing and improve access.
Increase revenue collection from qualifying paying patients from R527/709 million in 2013/14 to >530 million in 2019/20.
Rand value of revenue R535m R507m R780.8m R273.8m Target exceeded due to increased
collected collection from medical aids, self-paying
patients, Correctional Services and the
Road Accident Fund as a result of
continuous engagement with collection
service providers.
Improve efficient and effective functioning and performance of hospitals and clinics and quality of patient care through functional
hospital boards; increase to 100% and clinic committees to 100% by 2019/20.
Percentage of hospitals 77% 100% 94.6% (5.4%) All hospitals had a full complement of
with functional hospital (37/37) (35/37) Board members with requisite skills.
boards Functionality for 2 of the 37 hospitals
however reduced due to resignations and
secondments. The reasons given include
lack of incentives and administrative
problems. The Department fills vacancies
when they arise. It will further explore
ways to incentivise appointed members.
Implement an integrated and interoperable eHealth architecture in 100% of hospitals and clinics by 2019/2020.
Percentage of PHC # 100% 68.5% (31.5 %) Target not achieved because of technical
facilities’ Health Patient (372/372) (255/372) integration and data synchronisation
Registration Systems challenges. These are being addressed
deployed through a comprehensive programme
planned for the new financial year.
Percentage of hospitals # 30% 40.5% 10.5% Target exceeded due to adoption of a lean
with an upgraded Local (11/37) (15/37) LAN infrastructure design. The benefit of
Area Network this design resulted in four additional
infrastructure institutions (Edenvale, Heidelberg, ODI and
Helen Joseph hospitals) being
incorporated into the LAN project scope.
Percentage of hospitals # 62% 5.4% (56.6%) Target not achieved because NDoH, the
with Health Patient (23/37) (2/37) custodian of the system only approved
Registration System rollout to additional hospitals in December
deployed 2018.
It is envisaged that the remaining 6
facilities will be incorporated in the new
financial year.
Number of hospitals # 37/37 22/37 (15) Target not achieved. The acquisition of a
implementing PACS new PACS contract faced procurement
delays and was not awarded as planned. It
is envisaged that the 100% target will be
achieved in the new financial year.
Receive unqualified audit opinion from Auditor-General by 2016/17 and a clean audit by 2019/20
Percentage of service 29% 100% 47.3% (52.7%) Payment of suppliers within 30 days of
providers’ invoices (77 357/163 655) receipt of invoices significantly improved
without dispute paid in 2018/19. However, the target could not
within 30 days be achieved due to delays in clearing of
work cycles. The Financial Reporting unit is
to be capacitated to ensure improved
payment of invoices within 30 days of
receipt, including decentralisation of SCM
processes to improve efficiencies.
Increase broadband provision in the Department so that 100% of PHC facilities and hospitals have broadband network access and
100% of total staff have email access by 2019/2020.
Percentage of fixed 48% 80% 47% (33%) Target not achieved because E-Gov did
PHC facilities with (176/369) (297/372) (175/372) not receive the promised funding for
broadband access broadband.
Management 1 064 909 1 072 828 (7 919) 1 339 549 1 350 748 (11 199)
Total 1 085 267 1 085 177 90 1 361 130 1 360 786 344
DISTRICT HOSPITALS One strategy directs staff and beds to units in need from those which
District hospitals are a key component of district health provision are under less pressure. To increase surgical skills and experience at
and of the referral system to PHCs. district hospitals, interested medical officers are encouraged to
rotate through regional hospital surgical units, and some surgical
Efficiency Measures procedures are directed to district hospitals from central hospitals.
Utilisation of district hospitals’ medical wards and maternity unit This reduces congestion at the central hospitals and improves
services is very high, reflecting the general burden of disease and the utilisation of district hospitals. Examples include redirection of the
health needs of the population, with under-utilisation in paediatric elective caesarean section list to South Rand Hospital from Chris
and surgical units. The low utilisation of the paediatric wards may Hani Baragwanath Academic Hospital and the breast clinic and
reflect the success of various child health programmes; in the case of theatre list to Bertha Gxowa Hospital from Charlotte Maxeke
surgical wards, it relates to district hospitals’ inability to attract Johannesburg Academic Hospital.
sufficiently experienced medical officers
.
To improve efficiency and the ability to cope with extreme needs
with the available resources, a number of efficiency measures have
been put in place in district hospitals.
Leadership and Governance – multi-sectoral approach at various training institutions were placed the West-Rand Health
During the financial year, the Department’s NCD Control and District (one optometrist), Sedibeng Health District (two) and
Prevention Committee, consisting of stakeholders such as academic Tshwane Health District (two). This brings the total of optometrists
institutions, NGOs, advocacy groups, development partners and in the Department’s service to 62; together with the eight
other government Departments, continued its work. It meets district-based, dedicated ophthalmic nurses, this represents a
quarterly to ensure implementation of the National capable workforce at PHC to provide comprehensive eye health care
Non-Communicable Diseases Strategy. The Tshwane and Ekurhuleni services, helping to ensure early diagnosis, treatment, management
A new web-based NMC system rolled out in all of the province’s Food safety is continuously monitored and food premises inspected,
health care facilities has provided real-time notification of infectious particularly following the public outcry about the sale of fake and
diseases, with all reported outbreaks attended to within 24 hours. unsound food stuffs. Joint investigation operations were conducted
All hospitals and clinics submit weekly surveillance reports. The with law enforcement agencies to address complaints; out of 55 586
target for submission is 80%; at 93%, the province has exceeded food premises inspected, 68.3 % were found to comply with food
this. safety legislation. Illegal operations, not compliant with zoning
regulations, contributed to the low compliance rate. Some premises
Annual Influenza vaccinations have been provided in all districts, were served with compliance notices and others were closed.
with a particular focus on vulnerable groups: people with chronic
illnesses; pregnant women; people aged 65 years and above; and During the reporting period, the premises of 530 hazardous
residents of old age homes and rehabilitation centres. In 2018, 260 substances dealers were inspected in accordance with the
000 influenza vaccine doses were distributed to such facilities, Hazardous Substance Act 15 of 1973; the compliance rate was
attaining a coverage of 97%. 94.3%, higher than the 75% of the previous financial year. The
improvement is attributed to intensified monitoring strategies.
Strategies to Address Underperformance in Communicable
Disease Control and Surveillance As part of active surveillance to reduce malaria deaths and eliminate
Training on malaria elimination strategies, targeting environmental the disease from the country, all malaria cases were investigated and
health practitioners, doctors, nurses and other healthcare in almost all cases, the patient had travelled to malaria endemic
practitioners, has been provided. malaria death audits are conducted areas.
on all patients who die from malaria; the most common cause of
fatality is patients presentating late at health facilities. A malaria Strategy to address areas of underperformance
Rapid Diagnostic Test (RDT) is availed at all health care facilities to Awareness creation about safe water storage and food safety
allow early diagnosis in the these facilities. Intravenous artesunate, measures will continue, as will workshops for environmental health
the drug of choice for complications of malaria, is now available in practitioners on food safety and water quality monitoring.
public as well as private hospitals. PHC nurses in all districts have
been trained on the use of the rapid diagnostic test and on
administering Coartem, the treatment for malaria without
complications. Doctors and environmental health practitioners have
been trained on the management and investigation of malaria.
Increase PHC facilities rendering 24 hours service provision in all CHCs; integration of mental health and rehabilitation services in
100% of PHC facilities by 2019/20
Increase the number of fully-fledged, functional Ward Based Outreach Teams from 103 to 533 by 2019/20
Reduce Outpatient Department (OPD), Accident and Emergency Department waiting times across all facilities by 60% in 2019/20
Percentage of PHC # 50% 58% 8% PHC facilities have achieved the set target
facilities with average of 100 minutes.
treatment waiting
times below agreed
benchmark of 100
minutes
Improve staff (health professionals and administration) attendance at PHC facilities and OPD and Accident and Emergency across all
health facilities by 90%
Percentage of PHC # 100% 100% 0% Target achieved
facilities with staff
attendance of 90%
and above
Increase fixed PHC clinics with Ideal Clinic status to 100%; 100% of PHC facilities and district hospitals compliant with national core
standards; and complete self assessments in 100% of hospitals and >95% of PHC facilities by 2019/20
Ideal Clinic status rate # 75% 89.2% 14.2% Target exceeded due to an additional five
(330/370) clinics (Khutsong West, Khutsong CHC,
Beverly Hills, Evaton Main and Rabie
Ridge) achieving Ideal Clinic status.
Reduce the number of primary care patient cases seen at regional, tertiary and central hospitals by 20% in 2019/20 to increase
utilisation of PHC services
PHC utilisation rate - 1.5% 1.6 1.5 (0.1) Target not achieved because of
total (210 796 58 / implementation of community-based
141 042 42) interventions aimed at decongesting clinics
which led to lower numbers presenting at
health facilities.
Complaints resolutions 95.9% 100% 96.1% (3.9%) Target not achieved due to
within 25 working days (2 080/2 165) capacity-related challenges particularly in
rate (PHCs) Ekurhuleni District
Increase % of health facilities with annual quality improvement plan based on a PHC facilities self-assessment to 100%, fixed PHC
clinics scoring above 80% on the Ideal Clinic dashboard, 90% of PHC facilities and district hospitals compliance with national core
standards and percentage of PHC facilities and district hospitals that conduct self-assessment to 100% by 2019/20
Improve the efficiency of hospitals by reducing the average length of stay to less than 5 days
Average length of stay 4.4 days 4.5 days 4.1 days 0.4 days Within target
(district hospitals) (662 745/161 050)
Increase bed utilisation to 80% and decrease expenditure per PDE in hospitals by 2019/20
Percentage of complaints resolved within 25 working days will be over 95% by 2019/20
Complaint resolution 99.4% 99.4% 99.1% 0.3% Target exceeded; the Provincial Office’s
within 25 working days (529/534) monitoring of complaints has been
rate (district hospitals) strengthened and physical visits to facilities
have started.
Reduce Outpatient Department (OPD), Accident and Emergency Department waiting times across all facilities by 60% in 2019/20
Percentage of hospitals 75% 66% 91.6% 25.6% Three more hospitals were measured, and
with OPD average (9/12) the same was an inductive exercise in
treatment waiting times preparation for an increase in 2019/20
below agreed benchmark
of 180 minutes
Improve staff attendance (health professionals and administration) at PHC facilities and OPD and Accident and Emergency across all
health facilities by 90%
Percentage of hospitals # 100% 0% (100%) Currently not reported on due to limited
with staff attendance understanding of the tool. Training will be
of 90% and above done by Quality Assurance Directorate
during 2019/20 financial year.
Increase the number of female condoms distributed annually from 1 451 696 to 5.6 million by 2019/20
Female condoms 7 289 873 5 091 314 3 760 346 (1 330 968) Target not achieved due to inability of the
distributed new contractor to meet the condom
demands, payment delays, fewer primary
distribution sites in Ekurhuleni and delays
in approval by SABS. The Department will
be increasing PDS sites and facilitate
quicker resolution of work cycles. It will
also intervene through NDOH to facilitate
fast-tracking of the assessments with SABS
management.
Increase the proportion of the HIV positive population on ART from 80% in 2013/14 to 90% by 2019/20
Total new clients # 185 700 173 923 (11 777) The target was not achieved due to poor
started on ART linkage to care. Improvement in this was
observed following the introduction of
linkage officers, whose functionality will
be strengthened.
Increase the proportion of HIV positive population on ART from 80% in 2013/14 to 90% by 2019/20
ART clients remain on 927 825 1 093 1 037 212 (56 645) The target was not achieved due to
ART end of month: total 857 declining initiation trends; these improved
in the last quarter of the year under review
due to multi-stakeholder engagement.
Strengthening the functionality of linkage
officers; initiating at multiple focal points;
and monitoring supervision of daily
capturing to continue.
TB/HIV co-infected 87.5% 90% 88.2% (1.8%) Target not achieved due to limited
clients on ART rate (17 690/20051) integration across health facilities and
incomplete capturing of data onto
ETR.net. Monitoring supervision of daily
capturing and advocate for limited
rotation of technical staff to a minimum of
1 year.
Increase the number of people tested for HIV, including pregnant women, from 3 257 478 in 2013/14 to 2 498 007 by 2019/20
HIV tests done - total 3 083 921 2 641 848 3 253 783 61 1 935 Multi-stakeholder and multisectoral
collaboration contributed to this
achievement.
Increase percentage of people treated for TB from 84% in 2013/14 to 92% of total population with HIV by 2019/20
TB clients 5 years and older 88.1% 90% 90.5% 0.5% Target exceeded due to improved contact
started on treatment - rate tracing.
Increase number of male condoms distributed annually from 69 480 738 to 176 million by 2019/20
Male condoms distributed 190 349 748 160 524 172 953 486 12 429 486 Target exceeded due to increased uptake
000 of variety of scented condoms and
increased primary distribution sites in
Tshwane district.
Increase number of men medically circumcised from 132 095 in 2013/14 to 136 752 by 2019/20
Medical male circumcisions - 112 608 124 320 102 325 (21 995) Target not achieved due to delays in the
total awarding of the General Practitioners
Tender for medical male circumcision.
The tender will be concluded and awarded
during the 2019/20 financial year.
TB client treatment 84.2% 89% 84% (5%) Target not achieved. The ETR.net
success rate (30998/36800) (28705/34190) erroneously reported fewer treatment
successes particularly in COJ, Tshwane and
Ekurhuleni. The system has since been
discontinued and replaced by a more
reliable system (TIER.NET).
Increase the percentage of people cured of TB from 83% in 2013/14 to 85% by 2019/20 by reducing lost to follow up rate from
5.1% to 5%
TB clients lost to follow 6.3% 5.5% 6.3% (0.8%) Target not achieved due to inability to
up rate (2318/36800) (2149/34190) trace patients because of provision of
incorrect addresses and highly mobile
community. Community education on the
importance of provision of correct
demographic information and strengthen
surveillance.
Decrease TB death rate from 6.1% in 2013/14 to 5.3% by 2019/20
TB client death rate 6.2% <5% 6.3% (1.3%) Target not achieved due to late
(2159/34190) presentation with advanced TB disease
and high co-infection rate. Strengthen
community awareness about TB and
importance of early presentation.
Increase percentage of patients with MDR-TB started on treatment from 45% in 2013/14 to 80% by 2019/20 and success rate from
40% in 2013/14 to 65% by 2019/20
TB-MDR treatment success 53.1% 60% 58.0% (1.9%) Target not achieved due to high death
rate (662/1246) (199/343) rates and loss to follow-up
Reduce in-facility maternal mortality ratio from 143 in 2013/14 to 85 per 100 000 live births by 2019/2020
Maternal mortality in-facility 108.5 / 100 <100 (122.8/ 100 000) 22.8/ 100 000 Target not achieved because pregnant
ratio 000 live births women book late for first visit under 20
weeks and according to Saving Mothers
Report, a high proportion of late booking
women die due to hypertensive disorders
of pregnancy. The Department will be
implementing maternal quality standards
for management of these disorders.
Reduce neonatal mortality from 15/1 000 live births in 2013/14 to 8.5/1 000 live births by 2019/20
Neonatal death in facility 13.6 <14 13/1000 live (1/1000 live Target achieved
rate births births
Increase number of mothers whose first antenatal visit is before 20 weeks from 43.7% in 2013/2014 to 70% by 2019/20
Antenatal first visit 61.4% 66% 64.7% (1.3%) Target not achieved because pregnant
before 20 weeks rate 173 316/268 008 women book late for first visit under 20
weeks. Strengthen household testing by
WBOTS in the new financial year to detect
pregnancies well before they reach 20
weeks of gestation.
Decrease number of mothers visited within 6 days of delivery of their babies from 86.5% in 2013/14 to 85% by 2019/20
Mother postnatal visit within 70.8% 80% 75.1% (4.9%) Target not achieved. Reported data
6 days rate 166 728/222 115 include only PHC facilities as hospitals did
not report on the measurement.
Orientation of nursing managers and
hospital information officers on the tool
for reporting of postnatal visits for
mothers who remain in Kangaroo Mother
Care (KMC), visiting mothers and lodger
mothers staying in with their sick babies.
Reduce mother to child transmission of HIV from 2% to <1.3% at 10 weeks after birth and from 3.1% to less than 2% at 18 weeks by
increasing antiviral coverage among pregnant women living with HIV from 81% to 98% by 2019/20
Antenatal client starts on 94.7% 97.5% 96.9% (0.6%) Target not achieved due to late
ART rate 43845/44969 28 982/29 920 presentation of pregnant women wishing
to be enrolled in the PMTCT programme.
Infant 1st PCR test positive 0.99% 1.40% 0.73% 0.67% Target exceeded due to slight
around ten weeks rate 510/36 541 294/40251 improvement in infant testing rate in
Tshwane.
Immunisation under 1 year 77% 98% 84.3% (13.7%) Target not achieved due to erratic
coverage (200139/259772) 197525/201556 (221 437/262 623) reporting by private providers who receive
state vaccines and migrant population.
Establish and strengthen partnerships with
private providers for improved reporting
and surveillance.
Measles 2nd dose 74.5% 97% 77.2% (19.8%) Target not achieved due to erratic
coverage (189446/254306) (197 844/ (202 725/ reporting by private providers who receive
203 963)
262 623) state vaccines and mobile communities.
Establish and strengthen partnerships with
private providers for improved reporting
and surveillance.
Decrease child (under 5 years) diarrhoea case fatality rate from 3% in 2013/14 to 1.56% by 2019/20
Diarrhoea case fatality rate 2.3% <1.6% 2.1% (0.5%) Late presentation of dehydrated children
(88/4205) at health facilities. The Department will be
adopting and implementing the death
review form for diarrhoea case fatalities
and continue with caregiver/community
awareness on hand washing and the
importance of oral rehydration at home.
Decrease child (under 5 years) pneumonia and severe acute malnutrition case fatality rate from 12% in 2013/14 to <6% by 2019/20
Pneumonia case fatality rate 2.6% <1.6% 2.8% (1.2%) Late presentation of sick children at health
132/4678 facilities. The Department will be adopting
and implementing the death review form
used for case fatalities and continue with
caregiver and community awareness
raising.
Severe acute malnutrition 6.2% <6% 6.8% (0.8%) Target not achieved due to various
case fatality rate (105/1544) reasons including improper
implementation of SAM treatment
protocol. Increase supervision of
compliance with treatment protocols
whilst increasing advocacy of exclusive
breastfeeding and linkages to social
services where required.
Increase coverage of Grade 1 learners’ health screening in Quintile 1 – 5 public primary schools from 20% to 60% and Grade 4, 8 and
10 learners’ health screening (annualised) in Quintile 1 -2 from 10% to 20% respectively in 2019/2020
School Grade 1 learners 83 402 74000 88 200 14 200 Target exceeded due to employment of
screened additional nurses to support the HPV
campaign and learner screening.
School Grade 8 learners 46 612 40 000 48 818 8 818 Target exceeded due to employment of
screened additional nurses to support the HPV
campaign and support learner screening.
Reduce the levels of unwanted pregnancies for 10 to 19 years from 5.7% to 4.2%
Delivery in 10 to 19 years 8.1% 4.4% 6.7% (2.3%) More teenage pregnancies are attended to
in-facility rate 14 920/222 115 at health facilities by a skilled birth
attendant.
Increase couple year protection rate from 24.9% in 2013/14 to 60% by 2019/20
Couple year protection rate 59% 55% 54.1% (0.9%) Target not achieved due to inconsistent
(int) availability of injectables nationally.
Expansion of choice of contraceptives for
users.
Increase cervical cancer screening coverage from 41.7% in 2013/14 to 65% of women by 2019/20
Cervical cancer screening 47.4% 55% 52% 3% Target not achieved due to unavailability
coverage, 30 years and of liquid-based cytology consumables.
above older Continue to monitor SLA compliance.
Increase HPV vaccine coverage rate from 87.1% for 1st dose to 80% by 2019/20
HPV 1st dose 51 352 60 000 65 543 5 543 Target exceeded due to employment of
additional nurses to support the HPV
campaign and learner screening.
Increase HPV vaccine coverage rate for 2nd dose to 80% by 2019/20
HPV 2nd dose 57 150 60 000 61 031 1 031 Target exceeded due to employment of
additional nurses to support with the HPV
campaign and learner screening.
Decrease child (under 5 years) severe acute malnutrition case fatality rate from 6.1% in 2013/14 to <6% by 2019/2020
Vitamin A 12-59 months 50% 62% 55.1% (6.9%) Vitamin A capsules were out of stock in
coverage the last quarter of the year under review.
Provide accurate estimates of required
amounts to NDOH for procurement
purposes.
Reduce cataract surgery rate from 1408 per million in 2013/14 to 1000 per million; malaria case fatality rate
reduced to <0.4% by 2019/20
Cataract surgery rate 917.1 (1000/mil) 957.3/mil (42.7) Target not achieved. The DHIS does not
operations have the uninsured population
denominator which results in false lower
surgery rates. Correct population figures
on the DHIS and improve documentation.
Malaria case fatality rate 1.5% <1% 1.4% (0.4%) Most malaria cases are imported from
(18/1280) malaria endemic countries. The reports of
the malaria death audits indicate that
patients die from complications of malaria
because of late health care seeking
behaviour.
Reduce cataract surgery rate from 1408 per million in 2013/14 to 1000 per million; malaria case fatality rate
reduced to <0.4% by 2019/20
Sexual assault prophylaxis # 100% 99% (1%) Target not achieved due to assault clients
rate refusing to be provided with ARV
treatment prophylaxis.
District Management 516 536 524 552 (8 016) 505 175 527 767 (22 592)
Community Health Clinics 2 425 500 2 416 248 9 252 2 472 905 2 382 980 89 925
Community Health Centres 1 778 040 1 792 265 (14 225) 2 001 669 1 941 214 60 455
Community Based Services 1 780 080 1 780 657 (577) 1 996 989 2 082 027 (85 038)
HIV/AIDS 3 957 203 3 890 431 66 772 4 465 616 4 096 480 369 136
Nutrition 55 583 49 557 6 026 58 548 55 993 2 555
Coroner Services 215 243 214 321 922 240 133 225 305 14 828
District Hospitals 2 983 916 3 015 482 (31 566) 3 332 882 3 204 714 128 168
Total 13 712 101 13 683 513 28 588 15 073 917 14 516 480 557 437
Improve EMS response time for P1 patients within 15 minutes for primary calls in urban areas from 77.4% to 90%
EMS P1 urban response 81.2% 75% 82.3% 7.3% Target exceeded due to improvements in
under 15 minutes rate (4983/6055) the steps of an emergency call,
incorporating proper triage by the call
taker and appropriate dispatch, with the
direct involvement of managers of these
calls in their areas. Also public information,
education and relations programmes in
communities.
Improve EMS response time for P1 rural within 40 minutes in rural areas for primary calls to 100%
Reduce utilization rate of inter-facility transfer clients from 31.2% to 15% by 2019/20
EMS inter-facility transfer 32.3% 20% 35% (15%) Target not achieved due to an increase in
rate transfers between health institutions. The
following is being done to correct the
anomaly:
1. Present statistics to Cluster Heads, for
mitigation through clinical heads of
Departments.
2. Request the Office of DDG Clinical
Services to review Referral Policy and
Diversion Policy.
Emergency transport 1 158 450 1 125 937 32 513 1 253 364 1 168 905 84 459
Planned patient transport 109 694 93 337 16 357 169 839 161 603 8 236
Total 1 268 154 1 219 274 48 880 1 423 203 1 330 508 92 695
Decrease average Outpatient Department (OPD) waiting times in all hospitals by 60% in 2019/20
Percentage of hospitals # 100% 78% 22% Two hospitals, Edenvale with an average of
prioritising P1-patients (9/9) 4 minutes and Mamelodi 16 minutes, were
requiring immediate above the 3 minute set benchmark
attention because their triaging was incorrect. A
proper triage system on patients to be
adhered to by all hospitals.
Percentage of hospitals # 77% 77% 0% The hospitals achieved the set benchmark.
adhering to average (7/9) (7/9)
waiting times of 160
minutes for P2-patients
with acute injuries and
pain
Decrease average Outpatient Department (OPD) waiting times in all hospitals by 60% in 2019/20
Percentage of hospitals # 77% 77% 0% The hospitals achieved the set benchmark
adhering to average (7/9) (7/9)
waiting times of 160
minutes for P3-patients
with acute injuries and
pain
Quality of care will be improved by increasing compliance with national core standards and self-assessment in all regional and
specialised hospitals to 100%
Hospital achieved 75% 88.9% 9/9 8/9 1/9 Thelle Mogoerane was audited by the
and more on the National (100%) (88.9%) (11.1%) Office of Health Standards Compliance
Core Standard (NCS) (OHSC) and obtained 70%. It is the only
self-assessment rate regional hospital with an NCS assessment
(regional hospital) of less than 75%. The predominant factor
which contributed to this
underperformance was infection
prevention and control. The hospital is
now implementing the new SOPs, and
there is a task team appointed to provide
over-sight and monitoring
Improve the efficiency of hospitals by reducing the average length of stay to less than 5.5 days, increasing bed utilisation to 85%
and decreasing expenditure per patient day equivalent (PDE) in hospitals by 2019/20
Average length of stay 5.1 days 5.5 days 5.4 days 0.1 days Within target
(regional hospital) (1 465 467.5
/ 270 134)
Complaint resolution 100.5% 90% 97.2% 7.2% Target exceeded due to improved
within 25 working days monitoring of complaints by the
(regional hospital) Provincial Office and support visits
to facilities which were assisted in
implementation of the SOP.
Hospital achieved 75% 50% (4/9) (4/9) 0 Four hospitals were scheduled for
and more on National 44% 44% self-assessments, and all obtained 75%
Core Standards and above. Sterkfontein – 81%, Cullinan
self-assessment rate – 81%, Wits Oral & Dental - 97%,
(specialised hospitals) Weskoppies - 93%
The percentage of complaints resolved within 25 working days to over 95% in 2019/20
Complaints resolution 98% 90% 96.4% 6.4% Target exceeded, monitoring of complaints
within 25 working days (81/84) by the Provincial Office has been
rate (Specialised hospitals) strengthened, and a checklist on
complaints has been developed to assist
facilities to comply.
Reduce Outpatient Department (OPD, Accident and Emergency and Pharmacy departments’ waiting times across all facilities by
60% in 2019/20
Percentage of hospitals 75% 100% 100% 0% Target achieved.
with OPD average (7/7) (7/7)
treatment waiting times
below the agreed
benchmark of 180 minutes
Improve the efficiency of hospitals by increasing bed utilisation to 85% and decreasing expenditure per PDE in hospitals by 2019/20
Inpatient bed utilisation # 80% 53.6% 26.4% Target not achieved because of
rate (specialised hospitals) (116 301/ 216 decentralization of multi-drug resistant
833.76) tuberculosis (MDR TB) treatment and
limited use of mental health beds at
Cullinan Hospital due to staffing
challenges. A psychiatrist has been
appointed at Cullinan Hospital.
Expenditure per PDE # R2 799 R 3 437.2 (638.2) Closer monitoring of prices paid for goods
(specialised hospitals) (411 457 and services to ensure market related
440.6/119 708) prices are paid
General (regional) hospitals 5 719 131 5 738 (18 895) 6 431 824 6 351 096 80 728
Tuberculosis hospitals 396 292 026 112 408 379 744 290 044 89 700
Psychiatric/mental hospitals 1 164 077 283 884 (74 142) 1 261 857 1 393 015 (131 158)
Dental training hospitals 535 399 1 238 219 (13 257) 581 625 560 989 20 636
Other specialised hospitals 77 764 548 656 (5 728) 91 419 91 509 (90)
Total 7 892 663 83 492 386 8 746 469 8 686 653 59 816
Purpose of the programme the ICU so that it can attract clinicians who need intensive care
To provide highly specialised health care services, platforms for training. The hospital also appointed two additional orthopaedic
training health workers and sites for research and to serve as specialists with interest in arthroplasty and this had a positive impact
specialist referral centres for regional hospitals and neighbouring on the arthroplasty backlog. Head of department posts in psychiatry
provinces. and orthopaedics were filled after they had been vacant for more
than two years.
Significant Achievements by the Tertiary and Central
Hospitals
Established the much-needed spiritual wellness for employees and
TERTIARY HOSPITALS healthy lifestyle activities attendance has improved. The hospital’s
Achievements wound clinic received a golden trophy during the Premier’s Awards.
Installation of MRI scan facilities has improved services at Helen The Khanyisa Awards was received for “Most Efficient Health Care
Joseph Hospital, Rahima Moosa Mother and Child Hospital, Facility – Tertiary Hospital”.
Leratong Hospital, Sterkfontein Hospital, Tara Hospitalz, South Rand
Hospital and Bertha Gxowa Hospital. Expansion of Mammography To improve service efficiency, the implementation of an electronic
services by installing stereotactic guided vacuum assisted core biopsy queue management system to measure patient waiting time at the
and a three dimensional breast tomosynthesis unit This contributes OPD reception area was introduced as well as an improved booking
to accuracy of diagnosis which decreases dose radiation exposure system. This operates by phoning patients to remind them about
and improves patient throughput, thereby reducing waiting times. their appointment a day prior to their visit. Patient safety has been
Installation of a fluoroscopy unit in September 2018 improved prioritised through the opening of a 24/7 enquiries department.
patient care as patients no longer have to go to Rahima Moosa OHSC external assessment also scored the hospital 100% in Patient
Mother and Child hospital for services. Transport Services and it was evaluated as one of the cleanest
hospitals in the Province.
Kalafong Hospital opened a newly renovated human milk bank in
2018/19. The hospital also achieved improved Patient Experience of
Care, to 87%, which was the highest among tertiary hospitals; and
achieved improved performance on Core Standards Self-Assessment
with a score of 91%.
Increase compliance with national core standards to 100% in 2019/20, and complete self-assessments in all hospitals
Improve efficiency of hospitals by reducing average length of stay to 6.5 days, increasing bed utilisation to 85% and decreasing
expenditure per PDE in hospitals by 2019/20
Average length of stay 5.8 days 6.5 days 6.1 days 0.4 days Within target
(tertiary hospitals) (689 409.5/ 112
865)
Expenditure per PDE R3 472 R3 676 R 4 086.7 (R410.7) Target not achieved. Due to services at
(tertiary hospitals) (3 978 400 higher cost at T3 level. Prudent
056/973 505.5) management of the fiscus to ensure that
procurement is in accordance with demand
plans.
The percentage of complaints resolved within 25 working days will be over 95% in 2019/20
Complaints resolution 100% 90% 101% 11% Target exceeded, monitoring of complaints
within 25 working days: (769/760) by the Provincial Office has been
rate (tertiary hospitals) strengthened and physical visitation to
facilities has commenced.
Reduce Outpatient Department (OPD), Accident and Emergency departments waiting times across all facilities by 60% in 2019/20
Reduce Outpatient Department (OPD), Accident and Emergency departments waiting times across all facilities by 60% in 2019/20
Percentage of hospitals 2/3 66% 100% 34% Target exceeded due to inclusion of
with OPD average (2/3) 3/3 Tembisa in the assessment of waiting
treatment waiting times times.
below agreed benchmark
of 240 minutes
Improve staff (health professionals, administration clerks, cleaners and porters) attendance at OPD and Accident and Emergency
across all health facilities by 90%
Increase compliance with national core standards to 100% in 2019/20, and complete self-assessments in all hospitals
Improve the efficiency of hospitals such that waste, expense and unnecessary effort is reduced and bed utilisation in each hospital
will not be too high or too low
Average length of stay 7.9 days 8 days 7.8 days 0.2 day Within target range.
(central hospitals) (1 804
690.0/232 063)
In-patient bed utilisation 82.6% 85% 81.1% 3.9% Within target range.
rate (central hospitals) (1 804 690/2
224 310.4)
Expenditure per PDE R4 137 R4 229 R4 563.0 (R334) Expenditure higher than expected due to
(Central Hospitals) (13 080 631 increased expenditure by some of the
181/2 866 central hospitals because of increased
674.667) accrual payments.
The percentage of complaints resolved within 25 working days over 95% in 2019/20
Complaint resolution 99.2% 90% 98.4% 8.4% Target exceeded due to improved capacity
within 25 working days: (974/990) support through clusters systems
rate (central hospitals)
Reduce Outpatient Department (OPD), Accident and Emergency departments waiting times across all facilities by 60% in 2019/20
Percentage of hospitals 75% 75% 100% 25% Target exceeded due to inclusion of
with OPD average (3/4) (3/4) (4/4) DGMAH in the assessment.
treatment waiting times
below agreed benchmark
of 240 minutes
Improve staff (health professionals, administration clerks, cleaners and porters) attendance at OPD and Accident and Emergency
across all health facilities by 90%
Percentage of central 79% 100% 100% 0% Target achieved
hospitals with staff (53%) (4/4) (4/4)
attendance of 90% and
above
Reduce Outpatient Department (OPD), Accident and Emergency departments waiting times across all facilities by 60% in 2019/20
Expenditure per PDE R4 862 R4 676 R5 477.9 (R 801.9) Expenditure high due to payment of prior
(central hospitals) (2 538 177 538/ year accruals
463 352)
Complaint resolution 98.3% 90% 96.7% 6.7% Target exceeded because the Provincial
within 25 working days: (177/183) Office has strengthened monitoring of
rate (central hospitals) complaints and physical visitation to Steve
Biko Academic Hospital (SBAH)
Average length of stay 7.8 days 8 days 7.9 days 0.1 days Within target range.
(central hospitals) (416 148/52
703)
In-patient bed utilisation 77.9% 85% 76.0% 9% Not within target range due to the
rate (central hospitals) (416 148/ 547 renovation of wards 16 and 37 which
682) resulted in the closure of the two wards.
Thus 80 beds were not available for one
full quarter during the financial year.
Expenditure per PDE R4154 R4304 R 4534.6 R230.6 Payments of outstanding accruals
(central hospitals) (2 741 865 resulting in over expenditure. Prudent
095/604 652.7) management and monitoring of
expenditure patterns to be implemented.
Complaint resolution 98.6% 90% 96.9% 6.9% Target exceeded because the Provincial
within 25 working days: (310/320) Office has strengthened the monitoring
rate (central hospitals) of complaints and physical visitation to
DRGMAH
Percentage of hospitals # Yes Yes None Target achieved. Triage system fully
prioritizing P1 patients implemented and supported by a medical
requiring immediate practitioner.
attention in A&E
Department
Percentage of hospitals No No Yes Yes Target achieved. The No in the target was
with P2-P3 patients an omission because no central hospital
attended to within 160 must be left out of assessment in any
minutes waiting time A&E given year.
Department
Average length of stay 7.5 days 8 7.4 days 0.6 Target achieved
(central hospitals) 320 720/ 43 125
In-patient bed utilisation 86.8% 85% 82.3% 2.7% Within target range
rate (central hospitals) (320 720/389 863)
Expenditure per PDE R4407 R4 429 R4 842.9 (R 413.9) Abnormal expenditure for PDE,
(central hospitals) (3 374 933 Department will be investigating further
847/696 887.7) with the hospital directly
Complaint resolution 100% 90% 100% 10% Target exceeded due to monitoring of
within 25 working days: (222/222) complaints by the Provincial Office
rate (central hospitals)
Average Length of Stay 8 days 8 Days 7.8 days 0.2 day Within target range
(803 291/103 173)
In-patient bed utilisation 82.6% 85% 82.1% 2.9% Within target
rate (803 291/978 307)
Expenditure per PDE R3 661 R3 282 R4 016.8 R734.8 Abnormal expenditure for PDE,
(4 425 654 701/1 101 Department will be investigating further
782.3) with the hospital directly
Complaint resolution 100% 90% 100% 10% Target exceeded because the Provincial
within 25 working days: (265/265) Office has strengthened the monitoring
rate of complaints
Percentage of hospitals # Yes Yes None The hospital achieved the set benchmark
prioritizing P1 patients
requiring immediate
attention in A&E
Department
Percentage of hospitals Yes No Yes None The hospital achieved the set benchmark
with OPD waiting times
below the agreed
benchmark of 240 minutes
Percentage of hospitals Yes Yes Yes None The hospital achieved the set benchmark
with P2-P3 patients
attended to within 160
minutes waiting times in
A&E Department
Central Hospitals 11 839 981 11 988 788 (146 785) 13 219 797 13 218 982 815
Provincial Tertiary Hospital 3 493 060 3 329 921 163 139 3 915 429 3 915 274 155
Services
Total 15 333 041 15 316 687 16 354 17 135 226 17 134 256 970
Programme Purpose
The Health Sciences and Training Programme is strategically Achievements
positioned to plan for, produce and manage the education, training The RTCs in collaboration with institutions of learning, NGOs,
and development needs of the GDoH. It is designed to comply with development support partners such as PEPFAR and external training
relevant legislative and policy mandates at the national, provincial providers have developed 63 training programmes which are meant
and local level and to respond to service transformation imperatives. for healthcare workers such as doctors, professional nurses, other
Priorities include support for the Service Transformation Plan, professional allied workers and Community Health Workers (CHWs).
re-engineering of PHC, expansion of the HIV and AIDS, sexually These programmes address issues such as those relating to HIV and
transmitted infection (STI) and TB programmes and implementation AIDS/STIs/TB, non-communicable diseases and maternal and
of NHI. neonatal mortality. A number of the 63 training programmes are
identified as priorities in the Annual Performance Plan (APP) of
List of Sub-Programmes 2018/2019.
The Professional Development Directorate includes:
• Regional Training Centres (RTCs)
• Professional development
• Professional service support
• Bursary Section
• Lebone College of Emergency Care
• Leadership Management and Skills Development Directorate
• Employee Health and Wellness Programme Directorate
Strategic Objectives
• Improve achievement of national norms for the supply of
health professionals
• Improve compliance with the legislative framework
• Respond to the GDoH’s staff education, training and
development needs.
All HIV, AIDS, STIs and TB (HAST) related training planned for A new training plan, which was agreed upon by Tshwane HAST
Tshwane district was put on hold. The District took a resolution unit, Tshwane Training Unit and Right to Care, has been
to focus on mentorship for those already trained. developed according to the needs of the District. Training will
commence in April 2019.
The Health Promotion Officer qualification was suspended by the NDoH will inform the RTC when the review has been completed.
National Department of Health (NDoH) as they were reviewing
the training content.
CHW training phases 1 & 2 did not happen as NDoH in The material has been developed, and CHW skills development
collaboration with I-TECHSA were developing new material that training will be conducted in 2019/20.
will be used as in-service training for CHWs already trained in
phases 1 & 2.
Shortage of staff due to vacant posts not filled. Three posts for Deputy Directors and four posts for clinical
coordinators have been advertised and are to be filled in the first
quarter of 2019/2020
The unavailability of training manuals for various training Submissions to procure manuals were made, and POs were
programmes such as NIMDR TB, Kidz Alive, Adherence finally released, though late.
Guidelines, Prevention of Mother-to-child Transmission (PMTCT),
Advanced Primary Care (APC ) etc. due to the delay caused by a Tender for training manuals to be in place and senior managers
new procurement process, procedures that are not documented to approve as soon as possible.
and delays by senior managers in approving submissions.
Some of the training was shifted or cancelled by districts and Districts and supporting partners have been consulted, and
supporting partners. This led to some targets not being training will take place in the new financial year.
achieved, for instance:
• Medical male circumcision for all categories – the District clinical specialist teams (DCSTs) will now report their
supporting partner Justice Project South Africa (JPSA ) did training to the RTC, and these will form part of the RTC reports
get funding from PEPFAR in 2019-2020.
• ART initiation management for doctors and
pharmacovigilance for professional nurses – Pulse Health
lost funding from PEPFAR
• Not enough training on Kidz Alive for enrolled nurses,
health promoters, social workers and lay counsellors as
manuals were delivered late
• Trauma containment, sexual assault for professional nurses,
are conducted from the Medico-Legal Unit. Regional
Training Centre (RTC) staff are not trained on these
programmes.
The Professional Development Sub-directorate coordinates Special programmes under Sub-directorate Professional
Continuing Professional Development (CPD) programmes that are Development
critical for all medical doctors and allied professionals in accordance 1. Pharmacist assistant training, basic and post basic course
with the requirements set by statutory bodies for professional to 2. Six months of midwifery skills training for enrolled nurses
maintain their registration status. The sub-directorate also manages 3. Emergency medical care courses, e.g. basic life support (BLS),
the development and accreditation of mid-level worker Advanced Cardiac Life Support (ACLS), Pediatric Advanced Life
qualifications and training for lower categories and mid-level Support (PALS)
workers. This is in support of task shifting and the accreditation of 4. Structured clinical in-service training including on-boarding
identified qualifications. in-service training
5. South African Cuban medical training.
Structured in-service training in all health sciences related areas in
teaching institutions is also coordinated. The sub-directorate
participates in the development of short courses and skills
programmes to bridge those skills gaps identified as critical in
minimising incidences of malpractice and in achieving the strategic
objectives of the Department. It also coordinates the South African
Cuban Medical Programme in line with the Bilateral Cooperation
Agreement between South Africa and Cuba.
Challenges Recommendations
Insufficient budget for professional development training activities including Allocate more funding. Seek sponsorship to fund
purchasing training manuals. training.
Accreditation of Lillian Ngoyi CHC as BLS training centre negatively affected. Ring fence funds for patient safety courses,
Training put on hold. especially life support programmes.
Termination of contract for the retired nurse midwives leading to most patient Allocate more funding. Seek sponsorship to fund
safety training put on hold. training. Ring fence funds for patient safety
courses, especially life support programmes.
Shortage of staff due to absenteeism following the fire at Bank of Lisbon Employ advanced midwives and neonatal nurse
building. specialists by the RTC for the training of midwives.
Approval for filling of posts to be granted
Pharmacists 61 61 0
Clinical psychologists 61 61 0
Pharmacists 85 88 3
Dentists 15 23 8
Dieticians 54 55 1
Occupational therapists 84 91 7
Pharmacists 85 88 3
Physiotherapists 94 102 8
Radiographers 95 76 19
Recommendations
We recommend that if the following can be changed and adhered
to, the above issues can be resolved:
1. ICSP placement commences earlier in the year and results are
communicated to all provinces by latest mid-October (not
December).
2. Ensure that double placements are checked by an ICSP team or
provinces are given the allocations early to check for any double
placements or bursary holders of other provinces (2 weeks prior)
before notifying all applicants of their final placement.
3. ICSP system must always be online for users and the national
desk team to be available always for provincial coordinators.
4. ICSP guidelines should include a clause on commencement
dates so that all provinces are guided lawfully as this reduces
court cases and litigation.
MBCHB 251
Pharmacy 33
Occupational therapy 27
Dietetics 16
Oral hygiene 1
Optometry 7
Clinical technology 2
Physiotherapy 22
Radiography 51
TOTAL 441
This programme was implemented as part of the Bilateral Corporation Agreement between South Africa and Cuba for training medical
students. In the 2018/2019 financial year, the following obtained:
Numbers remaining in Cuba in the 3rd and 4th quarter of 2018/2019 352
Numbers who fell ill due to mental health and were repatriated back to SA 3 1 returned to Cuba in February 2019 and will be
Costing:
Cost for the 18 months integration in SA universities 73 R 17 118 050 – paid 5 July 2018
Cost for the 438 students which was not paid in 2017/2018 as accrual 438 R 140 066 822 – paid 5 July 2018
Academic fees for 2018/2019 financial year 352 Invoice still not sent by National: estimated at R
Cost of chartered flight for 195 students 195 R 6 435 000 (to be paid in 2019/2020 financial
year).
Cost for July vacations for students on vacation 38 R 939 171.00 paid to the provider.
(EHWP)
Increase access to training opportunities for staff Including heads of institutions to 95% by 2019/20
Percentage of hospital 83% 85% 124.3% 39.3% Target exceeded due to multiple training
CEOs trained in leadership (30/36 46/37 programmes participated in by several
and management CEOs) CEOs. Nine of them attended more than
one training programme during the
reporting period.
Percentage of PHC facility 71% 75% 114.8% 39.8% Target exceeded due to multiple training
managers trained in (263/372) 427/372 programmes participated in by several
leadership and PHC managers. Fifty-five were trained in
management more than one programme during the
reporting period.
Increase awareness of ethical conduct for all staff by offering code-of-conduct training to 30% of our employees in 2019/20
Percentage of employees 33% 25% 26.2% 1.2% Target exceeded because code of
trained in code of conduct (8451) (17 259/65 821) conduct training was included in multiple
in-house training programmes
Increase the number and quality of health professionals by increasing the number of health professionals trained annually to 1 500
by 2020
Number of nursing # 1 500 1 007 (493) 1500 is a departmental target and was
students graduating not achieved. Graduate output is
dependent on student enrolment. Intake
rates vary depending on factors such as
available finances, applicants meeting the
admission criteria, etc. Actual intake was
1 205. Outcomes are impacted by
attrition rates which are affected by
course terminations, failures and deaths.
Increase the number and quality of health professionals by increasing the number trained annually to 1 500 by 2020
Increase the number of new nursing students to fulfil replacement annually to 800 by 2019/20
Number of bursaries 984 700 671 (29) Total bursaries awarded include public
awarded to first-year nursing colleges and universities. With
nursing students implementation of higher education
funding in 2018, some university
students opted for this funding which
had no contractual obligations as
opposed to the GDoH nursing bursary
funding. Terminations at the nursing
colleges also impacted on the total
number of bursaries awarded.
Nurse training colleges 738 389 747 136 (8 767) 848 937 778 971 69 966
EMS training colleges 34 981 34 953 28 37 859 27 175 10 684
Bursaries 86 548 68 676 17 872 142 498 211 282 (68 784)
Other training 68 595 68 222 373 94 002 89 280 4 722
Total 928 471 981 987 9 484 1 123 296 1 106 708 16 588
Increase % of vital medicine available and accessible from 82% in 2013/14 to 99% by 2019/20
Percentage of vital 96.8% 98% 96.3% (1.7%) Vital medicines items not awarded on
medicine availability at (406/418) contracts; poor supplier performance
health facilities exceeding the lead times. EML items not
on contract; buy out procedure lengthy
and cumbersome. Continue with the
buyout of items not on contract or not
delivered including penalties on
non-performing suppliers and close
monitoring of medicines
Increase % of essential medicine available and accessible from 82% in 2013/14 to 99% by 2019/20
Percentage of essential 97.6% 98% 96.2% (1.8%) EML items not awarded on contracts;
medicine availability at (527/538) poor supplier performance exceeding the
health facilities lead times. EML Items not on contract;
buy out procedure lengthy and
cumbersome. Continue with the buyout
of items not on contract or not delivered
including penalties on non-performing
suppliers and close monitoring of
medicines
Increase access to chronic medication for stable patients through the use of central chronic dispensing and distribution centres and
pick-up points from 0 in 2013/14 to 600 000 by 2019/20
Number of patients 410 075 350 000 490 518 140 518 Roll out of the programme beyond the
enrolled on centralised pilot district and to some hospitals.
chronic medicine
dispensing and distribution
programme (cumulative)
Improve the quality of NHLS services delivered to GDoH by increasing turn-around times for laboratory test results by 33% by 2019/20
Percentage of Gene-xpert 96.7% 90% 94.9% 4.9% Target achieved and exceeded. Periodic
results available within 48 (284 765/294 reporting and continued monitoring of
hours 463) the indicator has enabled the NHLS to
develop appropriate intervention
measures.
Improve availability of essential medical equipment needed in 100% of hospitals by 2019/20
Number of hospitals with # 100% 100% 0 Target achieved. All hospitals are
essential medical 37/37 37/37 procuring equipment based on the
equipment recommended service package
equipment list whilst awaiting finalisation
of the essential equipment policy and list.
Reduce post mortem and mortuary body release turnaround time to 4 days
Laundries 213 145 208 732 4 413 251 462 250 982 480
Food Supply Services 76 692 81 035 (4 343) 87 693 88 066 (373)
Medicine Trading Account 1 - 1 1 - 1
Total 289 838 289 767 71 339 156 339 048 108
Purpose
The purpose of the programme is to plan and deliver new health • Construction at Kekanastad New Clinic commenced in
facilities and to refurbish, upgrade and maintain existing facilities. February 2018
• Construction at the new Eersterus Clinic in Soshanguve is 25%
Strategic Objective completed
Increased efficiency of service implementation through • Upgrading of psychiatric wards at Charlotte Maxeke
infrastructure delivery, good governance practices and sustainable Johannesburg Academic Hospital is 75% completed
maintenance of moveable and immovable assets. • Construction of new Khutsong South Clinic is 88%
completed.
LIST OF SUB-PROGRAMMES
• District Health Services
• Community Health Facilities
• Provincial Hospital Services
• Central Hospital Services
• Emergency Medical Services
• Other facilities
FUNDING SOURCES
Programme 8 is funded through:
• Hospital Facility Revitalisation Grant (HFRG)
• Equitable Share (ES)
• Extended Public Works Programme (EPWP)
SIGNIFICANT ACHIEVEMENTS
Build 10 new clinics/community health centres; commence with the construction of two additional new hospitals; refurbish 21
health care facilities by 2019/20, of which 100% will comply with the gazetted norms and standards for facilities
Build 10 new clinics/community health centres by 2019/20 of which 100% will comply with the gazetted norms and standards
Build 10 new clinics/community health centres; commence with the construction of two additional new hospitals; refurbish 21 health
care facilities by 2019/20, of which 100% will comply with the gazetted norms and standards for facilities
Soshanguve Hospital:
Follow up meeting with CoT was held to
confirm bulk services and usable space in terms
of the current buffer zone on the proposed site.
Target reached.
Diepsloot Hospital:
Initially, the identified site was privately owned.
COJ identified alternative land for transfer to
GDOH. Target reached.
Jubilee Hospital:
The process of acquiring an appropriate site for
proposed new facilities is under way with GDoH
and the Gauteng Deparment of Infrastructure
Development (GDID) Town Planner discussing
options with the City of Tshwane. The initial
identified site was environmentally sensitive; the
2nd identified site is tribal land. Target reached.
Kalafong Hospital:
Identified sites belong to City of Tshwane (CoT)
and Public Works. GDID is in negotiations with
the respective owners. Target reached.
The CoT needs township establishment for all
uses to be erected on site.
Build 10 new clinics/community health centres; commence with the construction of two additional new hospitals; refurbish 21
health care facilities by 2019/20, of which 100% will comply with the gazetted norms and standards for facilities
Number of new EMS bases # 5 in 5 In planning: 0 Target exceeded, additional 5 EMS bases
revitalised planning in planning phase namely: Westonaria,
Mohlakeng, Heidelberg, Devon,
Dewagensdrift. Construction could not
commence due to the resolution taken
by Exco pertaining to Dewagensdrift
base.
Community Health Facilities R 341 042 R 317 227 R 23 815 432 134 390 045 42 089
Emergency Medical Rescue R 7 046 R 1 739 R 5 307 9 628 1 299 8 329
Services
District Hospital Services R 260 789 R 214 806 R 45 983 218 580 172 998 45 582
Provincial Hospital Services R 288 934 R 282 716 R 6 218 264 803 202 304 62 499
Central Hospital Services R 311 287 R 335 462 -R 24 175 314 344 315 650 (1 306)
Other facilities R 474 201 R 455 827 R 18 374 320 444 453 824 (133 380)
Total R 1 683 299 R 1 607 777 R 75 522 1 559 933 1 536 120 23 813
Renovations & rehabilitation R 143 500 R 173 452 R 136 017 R 37 435 R0
Upgrades and additions R 229 700 R 142 110 R 135 410 R 6 700 R0
Maintenance and repairs R 797 343 R 707 073 R 517 073 R 190 000 R0
The table below shows the infrastructure allocation per funding source. The provincial equitable share (ES) reduced by R 320 million (34%)
compared to the Mid-Year Adjustment Budget.
Health Facility Revitalisation Grant R 874 842 R 892 084 R 892 084 R0 R0
5. TRANSFER PAYMENTS
Table: Transfer payments to other public entities, 2018/19
Health Welfare and Sector Non-profit Medical Services Yes 20,962 20,962 -
A number of
Mental Health Non-profit Training of Health Yes 191,207 150,495
non-profit institutions
institutions professionals
did not meet the
Psychiatric Community
requirements
Based Services
institution Yes
institutions
Hospital institution
Increased payments of
Households Non-profit Service benefits and Yes 535,809 921,439 claims against the state
and its reclassification
institution households
from goods and services
6. DONOR FUNDS
DONOR FUND 1
Name of donor Health care waste and occupational hygiene risk management, Mamelodi Hospital
Full amount of the funding Compass Medical Waste donated Assets to the value of R494820.00
Purpose of the funding Kickabout bucket, med waste trolley small and med waste trolley large for the patient
Expected outputs Kickabout bucket, med waste trolley small and med waste trolley large for the patient
Actual outputs achieved Kickabout bucket, med waste trolley small and med waste trolley large for the patient
Amount received in the current period (R’000) R494820.00(Kickabout bucket, med waste trolley small, med trolley large)
Purpose of the funding Refrigerator, microwave used by patient at Paediatric by the Kangaroo Mother care unit.
Expected outputs Refrigerator, Microwave used by Patient at Paediatric by the Kangaroo Mother care unit.
Actual outputs achieved Refrigerator, Microwave used by Patient at Paediatric by the Kangaroo Mother care unit.
DONOR FUND 3
Amount received in the current period (R’000) R23474.83 (Dell Latitude E7470)
7. CONDITIONAL GRANTS
The table below shows the conditional grants and earmarked funds paid to the Department.
Table 7.1: Conditional Grant: Health Facility Revitalisation Grant
Department/municipality to which the grant was GDOH
transferred
Purpose of the grant The purpose of the grant, made in terms of DORA, was to:
partnerships
Monitoring mechanisms by the transferring department National Health Infrastructure Progress Reviews
Standard for Infrastructure Delivery and Procurement Management (SIPDM)
Division of Revenue Act (DORA).
Reasons for the funds unspent by the entity (R’000) This item is projected to be underspent due to the processes of sourcing
quotations and finalisation of tenders regarding MTS equipment. However, there
are commitments of R252 million as of 31 March 2019. The department is in the
process of applying a rollover of R252 million.
Monitoring mechanisms by the transferring department Monthly, quarterly and annual monitoring of expenditure and equipment progress
Table 7.3: Conditional Grant: Health Professions Training and Development Grant
Expected outputs of the grant Increased supply of trained health professionals: medical doctors, nurses and allied
health professionals
Progress made in implementing the capital, investment and asset management plan
By implementing a range of capital and maintenance infrastructure projects, the programme spent 98% of its allocated budget in the 2018/19
financial year.
Table 8.1: Infrastructure projects completed during the financial year and progress compared with what was planned at the
beginning of the year
241 Charlotte Maxeke Construction 09 November 30 June 2018 31 May 2019 Previous ward councillor influenced
Johannesburg 2015 general workers that their rate per
Academic Hospital day is supposed to be R288 instead of
Upgrading and the R150 which the contractor bid
renovation of the entailed. This led to community
existing Psychiatric unrest which was resolved by the
unit establishment of a Project Steering
Committee.
179 Dewagensdrift Clinic Construction 01 August 2016 31 March 2018 29 July 2018 All construction works completed; HT
Construction of the completed items need to be fitted and
new clinic commissioned. The official opening
took place on 26 April 2019.
129 Finetown Clinic Construction 28 September 28 February 31 January 2020 There was a contractual dispute due
Construction of new 2016 2019 to the Department’s lengthy payment
clinic procedures which eventually led to
contract cancellation in November
2018. Replacement contractor to be
appointed.
6793113 Greenspark Clinic Construction 15 February 29 March 2019 30 October 2019 Progress has been slow due to cash
New clinic 2017 flow problems by the contractor.
Scope of work changes on the
contract allowing additional
extension of time. Additional scope
to bulk earthworks and ICT had to be
added. Delays on site due to
community unrest.
291 Kekanastad Clinic Construction 27 February 14 December 31 December Construction was at 35% when the
Construction of the 2018 2018 2019 contract was terminated.
new clinic Replacement contractor had to be
appointed.
6793111 Khutsong South Ext2 Construction 12 April 2016 31 August 2018 31 July 2019 Slow progress on site due to
Clinic community unrest. Contractor off-site
New Clinic due to late payments from
Department. Community unrest.
GDID requested additional scope.
170 Mandisa Shiceka Construction 03 October 2017 14 December 14 December The land is too small for the clinic. An
Clinic 2018 2019 additional land parcel ERF 355 (a
Replace current clinic portion) was requested to
and upgrade to CDC accommodate parking for the clinic.
The requested land is owned by the
City of Tshwane, which was
requested to allocate this piece of
land or to relax the parking bylaws.
Construction commenced for a
temporary structure.
283 Tshwane District Construction 06 May 2015 09 March 2018 09 March 2018 Completion of Ward 1 has
Refurbishment completed commenced; practical completion was
Contract 4 A reached on 9 March 2018
Table 8.2: Infrastructure projects currently in progress and their expected completion dates
30309905 Atteridgeville CHC Construction of new CHC Feasibility 30 November 2018 31 August 2021
84 Bertha Gxowa Hospital Upgrading of hospital Design 01 February 2020 31 March 2021
31007931 Bheki Mlangeni Hospital New Nurses Residences Feasibility 01 December 2022 31 March 2025
143 Boikhutsong CDC Replacement of existing clinic and Construction 51% - 75% 29 May 2017 29 May 2020
6792486 Boitumelo Clinic New Clinic Construction 1% - 25% 01 April 2020 31 March 2023
6793105 Braam Fischerville Clinic New Clinic Pre-feasibility 05 March 2020 31 March 2023
445 Bronkhorstspruit FPS Mortuary New mortuary Feasibility 06 September 2020 06 January 2022
212 Carletonville Hospital Refurbishment of TB ward Design 30 October 2019 31 January 2022
241 Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg Academic Hospital Construction 76% - 99% 09 November 2015 31 May 2019
30309680 Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg Academic Hospital Design 01 June 2019 01 July 2020
Wet Services
6793027 Chiawelo Clinic Replace asbestos with brick and upgrade Feasibility 15 February 2020 24 February 2022
428 Chris Hani Baragwanath Hospital Critical repairs and Tender 01 March 2019 11 November 2021
6793012 Cosmo City Clinic New Clinic Identified 01 April 2021 31 March 2023
103 Dark City CHC Additions and Rehabilitation Design 02 November 2019 30 September 2021
6793117 Daveyton Main Clinic Construction of the new clinic Feasibility 01 April 2021 31 March 2024
30309906 Dewagensdrift EMS New EMS base Design 05 August 2019 29 September 2020
105 Dilopye Clinic Additions and rehabilitation Construction 1% - 25% 31 March 2021
319 Discoverers CHC Convert CHC into District Hospital Design 01 May 2024
30309678 Edenvale Hospital Upgrades Upgrading and new AET, Feasibility 01 September 2021
129 Evaton West clinic Construction of new clinic Tender 31 March 2022
540 Finetown Clinic Construction of new clinic Construction 26% - 50% 31 January 2020
6793113 Ga-Rankuwa Nursing College Upgrading and renovations Practical completion 05 October 2018
to college
659 Greenspark Clinic New clinic Helen Joseph Hospital Construction 51% - 75% 30 October 2019
656 Helen Joseph Hospital Renovations to Psychiatric ward and Construction 1% - 25% 30 November 2021
observation units
31006404 Hillbrow District HospitalConversion of CHC into District Construction 76% - 99% 31 May 2019
hospital
292 Kgabo CHC New CHC Construction 26% - 50% 31 December 2019
31007745 Khayalami Hospital Demolition of current empty hospital Pre-feasibility 28 June 2024
6793111 Khutsong South Ext2 Clinic New clinic Feasibility 30 April 2021
6793107 Kokosi CHC New CHC Construction 76% - 99% 31 July 2019
31008679 Lenasia District Hospital Phase1 - Gateway Clinic Tender 01 December 2024
908 Lenasia South CHC Convert CHC into District Hospital. Tender 01 April 2020 31 March 2024
30309679 Leratong Nurses Res Upgrade Feasibility 30 June 2020 30 September 2022
31006389 Lillian Ngoyi Hospital Staff accommodation Tender 01 April 2020 31 March 2025
53 Lillian Ngoyi Construct new 500 bed District Hospital Design 01 April 2020 31 March 2025
170 Mandisa Shiceka Clinic Replace current clinic and upgrade Construction 76% - 99% 03 October 2017 14 December 2019
to CDC
6793112 Mayibuye clinic Construction of new clinic Design 28 October 2019 16 January 2021
180 New Eersterus Clinic Construction of new clinic in Construction 1% - 25% 31 August 2018 31 August 2023
Soshanguve
6793120 Northmead Clinic Upgrades and additions Feasibility 01 April 2020 31 March 2022
OR Tambo MOU Upgrading and renovation of the existing Identified 11 September 2019 11 September 2021
6793122 Orange Farms Replacement of Ext 7 Clinic Tender 01 December 2022 01 December 2025
195 Phedisong 4 CHC Additions and rehabilitation Design 05 October 2019 05 October 2020
6793119 Phillip Moyo CHC Extension and refurbishment of Construction 51% - 75% 31 July 2017 01 November 2020
maternity unit
198 Pretoria North Clinic Additions and rehabilitation Design 01 April 2019 19 April 2024
202 Ramotse Clinic New clinic Design 01 July 2020 31 March 2022
6793106 Randfontein Clinic Replace small clinic and upgrade to CHC Construction 1% - 25% 31 January 2020 31 May 2022
6793149 Refentse Clinic Additions and rehabilitation. Design 01 April 2019 31 March 2021
205 Refilwe Clinic Replace small clinic and upgrade to CHC Design 30 April 2019 30 September 2021
629 S G Lourens Nursing College Construction of new training Design 01 April 2020 31 March 2021
facility
6793128 Sebokeng Zone 17 Clinic Construction of new clinic Tender 31 October 2019 31 October 2020
223 South Rand Hospital Conversion and renovation of old Design 02 February 2020 02 February 2021
compound/pharmacy
South Rand Hospital Maternity homes Identified 01 March 2020 02 June 2020
901 Tambo Memorial Hospital Revitalisation Feasibility 01 August 2020 28 May 2026
31006387 Tara Hospital Construction of new secure adolescent ward Design 01 August 2019 31 August 2020
Tembisa Hospital Encroachment and dolomite risk Feasibility 01 April 2020 31 March 2021
Tembisa Hospital New bulk store Design 01 April 2020 30 April 2022
4640 Thelle Mogoerane Hospital New staff residences Handed over 25 February 2015 31 December 2017
1006 Tshwane District HospitalExternal wet services contract Practical Completion 21 January 2016 14 December 2017
283 Tshwane District Refurbishment Contract 4 A Practical completion 06 May 2015 09 March 2018
1010 Tshwane Rehabilitation Centre Renovation and upgrading Design 30 November 2019 30 September 2023
of the facility
245 Weskoppies Hospital Condition assessment and Design 16 November 2019 01 June 2022
Winnie Mandela CHC Construction of a new CHC Design 01 April 2021 31 March 2024
Zola Clinic Construction of a new clinic Feasibility 01 April 2021 31 March 2024
Table 8.3: Procurement of medical equipment was completed by 31 March 2018 for the following three health facilities:
Kalafong Hospital
Tembisa Hospital
Maintenance category Final appropriation (R’000) Expenditure (R’000) % spent against budget (R’000)
Table 8.5: Percentage of the Department’s capital assets in good, fair or bad condition
The table below shows the condition ratings of facilities as per the User Asset Management Plan (UAMP) for 2018/19.
Condition Rating C2 9 2%
Condition Rating C1 0 0%
Table 8.6:The following major maintenance projects were undertaken during the period under review.
175 Auckland Park Medical Supply Depot Depot maintenance R 4 000 R 1 791
93 Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg Academic Hospital All maintenance activities R 36 772 R 50 809
6792275 Cullinan Care Rehabilitation Hospital All maintenance activities R 5 587 R 10 802
121 Ekurhuleni District Health Office All maintenance activities R 500 R 860
256 Far East Rand Hospital All maintenance activities R 7 275 R 11 399
260 MEDUNSA Oral Health Centre All maintenance activities R 2 159 R 1 799
268 Rahima Moosa Mother and Child Hospital All maintenance activities R 7 908 R 11 035
101 Rahima Moosa Nursing College All maintenance activities R 742 R 3 660
229 Steve Biko Academic Hospital All maintenance activities R 6 962 R 45 829
246 West Rand District CHCs All maintenance activities R 11 825 R 1 113
248 West Rand District Clinics All maintenance activities R 4 774 R 6 400
6793146 West Rand District Office All maintenance activities R 1 469 R 2 675
31008656 Chris Hani Baragwanath Laundry Laundry Electro-mechanical equipment R 22 000 R 6 046
30309840 Auckland Park Medical Supply Depot Electro-mechanical equipment R 1 000 R 185
New and replacement assets R 632 306 R 612 897 R 19 409 R 710 276 R 521 837 R 188 439
Existing infrastructure assets R 994 134 R 949 298 R 44 836 R 789 500 R 944 739 -R 155 239
Upgrades and additions R 170 617 R 137 291 R 33 326 R 136 410 R 181 549 -R 45 139
Rehabilitation, renovations R 89 648 R 65 605 R 24 043 R 136 017 R 114 324 R 21 693
and refurbishments
Maintenance and repairs R 733 869 R 746 402 -R 12 533 R 517 073 R 648 866 -R 131 793
Infrastructure transfer
Current R 733 869 R 746 402 -R 12 533 R 517 073 R 648 866 -R 131 793
Capital R 892 571 R 815 793 R 76 778 R 982 703 R 817 711 R 164 992
Total 1 626 440 1 562 195 R 64 245 R 1 499 776 R 1 466 576 R 33 200
The Gauteng Department of Health is committed to sound The following key strategic risks were identified in the 2018/2019
corporate governance in its delivery of health care services to the financial year:
public. The Department assures taxpayers that systems of internal • Inadequate access to quality health services for mental health
control are in place to enable effective, efficient and economical use patients.
of state resources. • Increase in maternal, new-born, infant and child morbidity/
mortality.
2. Risk Management • High death rate due to an increase in the number of HIV and
TB infections.
The Accounting Officer (AO) of the Department takes responsibility • Inadequate resources for the Primary Health Care
for implementing Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) in accordance reengineering programme.
with the National Treasury Public Sector Risk Management • Serious adverse events.
Framework (PSRMF). The Chief Director: Risk Management (RM) and • Poor quality of the EMS referral/call system due to incorrect
Internal Control is the Chief Risk Officer (CRO) for the Department. use of the system.
In compliance with the PSRMF and to embed risk management, the • Shortages of pharmaceutical supplies.
Department has adopted an ERM Policy Statement which sets out its • Aging infrastructure and health technology.
overall intentions with regard to ERM. • Non-adherence to prescripts.
• Lack of standardised information technology platforms to
A detailed Risk Management Strategy and Risk Management enable the provision of quality health care.
Implementation Plan were approved and implemented for the • Delays/late payments to suppliers (30-day payment period).
2018/2019 financial year. The ERM Implementation Plan gives effect • Inadequate human capital management.
to the departmental RM Policy and Strategy and outlines the roles • Inability of Supply Chain Management to support the provision
and responsibilities of management and staff in embedding risk of quality health care.
management in the Department. • Financial losses due to litigation.
• Inability to achieve revenue targets.
The Department has assessed significant risks that could have an • Fraud and corruption.
impact on its ability to achieve its strategic and operational • Fruitless and wasteful expenditure.
objectives. Risks have been prioritised based on their likelihood and • Irregular expenditure.
impact (inherently and residually), and mitigations were agreed • Inability to function in the event of a disaster (business
upon to reduce the risks to acceptable levels. Risk owners have been disruption).
identified for each risk and are responsible for monitoring risk levels • Compromised safety of patients and employees.
and the extent to which mitigating strategies are in place. • Insufficient, irrelevant, inaccurate and incomplete performance
reports.
Progress on mitigation measures is tabled at the Risk Management • Industrial action at Forensic Pathology.
Committee meeting (RMC) and the Audit Committee every quarter.
New/emerging risks are identified and assessed on an ongoing basis. Plans are in place to mitigate these risks.
The Department has an established and functional departmental
Risk Management Committee, chaired by an external chairperson, 3. Minimising Conflicts of Interest
to assist the Accounting Officer in carrying out his responsibilities
relating to risk management. The Committee operates within Terms SMS members disclose their financial interests using the eDisclosure
of Reference approved by the Head of the Department and consists system. In 2018, the Department achieved 100% (106 employees
of identified risk owners for each risk, representatives of all out of 106) disclosure by the SMS members. The Department has a
programmes and representatives of the four academic hospitals and circular on financial disclosures for other categories; 426 employees
of Gauteng Provincial Treasury. The committee meets quarterly to were trained on the circular and how to submit disclosures on the
review and assess departmental risks recorded and to evaluate the eDisclosure system.
action plan’s progress in the strategic risk register.
The table below shows the dates of the meetings of the Portfolio Committees, the matters discussed and how the Department addressed
them.
16 October 2018 Plans to ensure proper (a) The Department developed a strategy to address spending
Request for responses on House spending and achievement and the achievement of targets for Emergency Medical Services.
resolutions emanating from the of targets under The Strategy is based on the following pillars:
Health Portfolio Committee Emergency Medical • Post-filling approved for 49 Intermediate Learner Students
Oversight Report on the Annual Services and Health
(ILS) and 30 Ambulance Learner Students (ALS). Only 3 ALS
Report of the Gauteng Facilities Management
Department of Health for the and 35 ILS were appointed at 31 March 2019. Recruitment
2017/18 Financial Year process under way to fill remaining posts before the end of
the financial year to increase the quality of care of circulating
ambulances.
• Expedite the re-advertisement of CAD tender with the
involvement of the Chief Information Officer (CIO) office.
This will add a resource scheduling and management
component that will also assist in fleet and staff
management and efficiency.
• Vehicle Tracking: expedite the evaluation of an award for a
vehicle tracking solution to have the added business
intelligence component that will assist with fleet
management; it will also increase the life span of our fleet as
it will assist in curbing vehicle abuse and improve driver
behaviour.
• Fleet status to procure 200 ambulances as per
recapitalisation plan; only managed to procure 60
ambulances (R 44 358 400.00) leaving the Department with
a shortfall of 140 (R118 289 065.60) for the 2018/2019
financial year.
Security
All security contracts of the Department are on a
month-to-month basis until an alternative security arrangement
in all health facilities is found.
Nursing agencies
The current practice is that different institutions source their
nurses for Trauma, Intensive Care and Theatre Units. This has
been found to constitute a splitting of orders practice and thus
irregular as all contracts above R500k must be subjected to a
bidding process.
Plans to ensure adherence The Department is committed to complying with the provisions
of the Employment Equity of the Employment Equity Act (No.55 of 1998) and the targets
Act by appointing people set for the recruitment of PWDs. To date, the Department has
with disabilities (PWDs) achieved remarkable growth in the number of PWDs employed.
This time last year, 0.5% of GDoH employees were PWDs. By the
end of the second quarter, the number had risen to 1.61%
(1071 people).
Reasons for not achieving Coordination between the Department of Health and the
the number of health Department of Infrastructure was not as good as it should have
facilities that have been. This resulted in weaknesses in project management and
undergone major and monitoring of programmes between the two Departments.
minor refurbishments for There were also complications in terms of contract manage-
both 2016/17FY and ment, with some service providers not adhering to contractual
2017/18FY obligations. This delayed completion of some of the work.
Plans to remedy the In the previous financial year (2017/2018), the Department,
unachieved target for the jointly with the GDED, conducted two TER change manage-
percentage of budget ment workshops. The purpose was to make SCM officials and
spent on township those involved in SCM processes aware of the imperatives of the
enterprises against TER and the target set.
identified commodities
The Department will resuscitate the quarterly stakeholder
workshops as a means of linking township enterprises with
corporates.
REQUEST FOR RESPONSES ON HOUSE RESOLUTIONS EMANATING FROM SCOPA REPORT ON THE AUDITOR-GENERAL’S REPORT ON THE
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND PERFORMANCE INFORMATION OF THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 MARCH 2018
1 In terms of Rule 179 (4), 1.1 The Department will comply with the request to provide
the Accounting Officer quarterly updates to SCOPA and the Health Portfolio.
submits a quarterly update
to SCOPA and the Health
1.2 The Department has developed a litigation strategy (still in
Portfolio Committee on
intensifying performance draft form) aimed at improving the management of
and consequence medico-legal claims. The strategy is based on the following six
management processes to pillars:
mitigate instances of
findings on lawsuits and i. Prevention of harm and promotion of patient safety with the
provides the Committee
support of internal audit processes against a risk register with
with a quarterly progress
report detailing the quarterly reports.
effectiveness of measures
put in place to address ii. Staff-related risk management, including in areas of
challenges related to Performance Agreements, absenteeism, supervision and
lawsuits every quarter and disciplinary action for negligence.
continuing up until June
2019.
iii. Appointment of an external independent expert team on
Patient Safety and a Medico-legal team.
1.3 The litigation system will not only enable tracking of claims
but monitoring of disciplinary cases instituted because of
employee negligence. and civil cases instituted by the
Department to recover costs incurred because of employee
negligence.
2 The Accounting Officer ii. There is a need for a body of legal research to inform
provides the Committee investigative approaches to medical litigation
with a progress report
regarding the effectiveness
iii. Appropriate monitoring of labour by skilled birth attendants;
of measures put in place to
curb the recurrence of correct and consistent use of the partogram for all patients in
re-statement every quarter labour
and continuing up and to
the end of June 2019. iv. Where there is a potential case of cerebral palsy, investigations
must to be carried out immediately after birth to determine gas
levels and possible anaemic condition of the pregnant woman
1.4 The following are the long-term solutions intended to deal with
incidences of medical negligence:
1.6 As well as the above strategies, the Office of the Premier has
established a Specialized Litigation Unit (SLU) to deal with all
medico-legal matters. The SLU will have the following
components:
2 The Accounting Officer An audit approach is being undertaken where a full set of
provides the Committee disclosures are performed monthly. Reconciliation is performed
with a progress report between supporting schedules and data information and weak-
regarding the effectiveness
nesses are reported for corrective action to senior management
of measures put in place to
curb the recurrence of and the Accounting Officer.
re-statement every quarter
and continuing up and to Request for information letters are being sent monthly, and
the end of June 2019. management orientation takes place before year-end with regard
to the requirements of the audit to improve the response rate and
the quality of information submitted.
4 The Department provides The following measures have been put in place to address the
the Committee with a weaknesses of predetermined objectives:
progress report detailing • Since the implementation of the WEB DHIS system, the
the effectiveness of
Department can track data violations through data
measures put in place to
address weaknesses of visualisations tools built into the system; data quality indices
predetermined objectives are also being tracked monthly and feedback on violations
every quarter and provided to institutions for corrections to be effected on the
continuing up and until the data.
end of June 2019. • Through implementation of the performance accountability
sessions and establishment of service intervention units, the
Department has achieved higher levels of awareness in terms
of tracking data management outcomes; districts that used to
have poor data quality scores have consistently and
significantly improved their timely submission of data and
ensuring that datasets submitted are complete.
• Because of the above initiatives, the Department has seen an
improvement regarding the completeness of data
• Training of WEB DHIS has been continuing since the previous
financial years (2017/18). This training targets different
groups of personnel from data capturers to programme
managers at different levels. The training for data capturers
aims to achieve accuracy of data captured at source points.
Training for programme managers is in line with the vision to
improve information by ensuring that managers can access
their programme specific data to review and to analyse data
about their respective programmes. By so doing, they can
intervene quickly where performance is not according to plan
and help identify any potential errors in the reported data.
• The next sets of training were planned for the fourth quarter
with emphasis laid on building capacity to carry out rapid
data quality audits at the coalface. Additional workshops
were provided to clinical and administrative managers so that
they understand the audit requirements including the records
management process and how POE can be loaded onto
SharePoint to ensure that all performance claims submitted
can be supported by verifiable evidence.
• It is anticipated that with the roll-out of the digitised registers
following rationalisation of registers that the data quality
outputs will further improve.
• The Department currently captures data at selected PHC
facilities and plans are afoot to increase these daily data
capturing sites.
• The full effectiveness of the Monitoring and Accountability
Governance Framework is also anticipated to be felt once
compliance with the SOP expectations becomes consistent,
enabling weekly performance tracking at the coalface. With
its initial implementation, we have seen monthly sharing of
data quality status and managers requested to account.
5 The Accounting Officer provides An audit approach is being undertaken where a full set of disclosures
the Committee with a progress are performed monthly. Reconciliation is performed to supporting
report on the measures put in schedules/information and weaknesses are reported for corrective
place to ensure carrying out of
action to senior management and the Accounting Officer.
monthly reconciliations in
compliance with Section 40 (1) of
the PFMA every quarter and Request for information letters are sent monthly and management
continuing up and until the end of orientation takes place before year-end with regard to the require-
June 2019. ments of the audit to improve the response rate and the quality of
submitted information.
6 The Accounting Officer ensures that An Audit Implementation Plan was developed and is being monitored
transparent financial and to ensure that corrective action takes place and that risk areas identi-
performance management reporting
fied by the Auditor General are improved.
systems are regularly maintained
and provides the Committee with a
progress report detailing the A new approach has been adopted whereby the Executive Manage-
effectiveness of measures put in ment Committee will take direct responsibility for the resolution of
place in addressing matters related identified risks.
to annual financial statements
within 30 days of adoption hereof,
and after that every quarter
continuing up and until the end of
June 2019.
7 The MEC provides the The Department has developed a Combined Assurance Model that will
Committee with a progress strengthen monitoring of compliance, risks and internal controls. The
report on measures put in place model provides for four levels of insurance to be provided before a
to monitor the adequacy of
matter is resolved. The first level is by management, the second by the
internal controls to avoid
recurrence of non-compliance Internal Control and Risk Committee, the third by Internal Audit and
with applicable legislation every Auditor General and the fourth by the Audit Committee and the
quarter and continuing up and Legislature.
until the end of June 2019.
The Department is also in the process of developing a Compliance
Strategy and Compliance Framework that will be implemented and
monitored by the Compliance Unit.
8 In terms of GPL Rule 179(4), the Internal controls around irregular expenditure have been improved to
MEC provides the Committee curb recurring irregular expenditure. Priority amongst these are curbing
(SCOPA) and Portfolio of security, nursing agencies and Finance/HR/Governance support
Committee on Health with a
partners and consignment stock irregularities that have contributed
monthly report detailing its
adherence and compliance to significantly to the R1.7 billion incurred irregular expenditure.
the requirements of all applicable
legislation to ensure that Security
effective measures are All the Department’s security contracts are on a month-to-month basis.
implemented to prevent irregular This is irregular in terms of the Public Finance Management Act as this
expenditure as required by
practice does not constitute fairness and transparency.
Section 38(1)(c)(ii) and Treasury
Regulation 9.1.1. Every quarter The Department is in the process of insourcing security services; this
and continuing up and until the will bring an end to irregular expenditure related to security contracts.
end of June 2019.
Nursing agencies
Current practice is that different institutions source their nurses for
Trauma, Intensive Care and Theatre Units. This has been found to
constitute a splitting of orders practice and thus irregular as all
contracts above R500k must be subjected to a bidding process.
This bidding process is now being carried out through a cluster
approach.
Consignment stock
Current practice is that consignment stock is not subjected to the
manual process of Purchase Order, GRV and invoice matching. This is
because the cataloguing of such commodities has not been performed
in the past. This leads to the inability during audit to produce sufficient
appropriate audit evidence that procurement processes were followed.
During the reporting year, cataloguing of this commodity was
performed, bringing an end to irregular expenditure in this regard.
Finance/HR/Governance support partners contracts
It was the view of the Department that the current partner contracts
for Finance and Human Resources constituted sole suppliers. This view
was disputed by the Auditor General; thus these contracts constituted
irregular expenditure as a bidding process was not followed.
The contracts were stopped on 31 December 2018 and the Depart-
ment is now following a competitive bidding process.
New PFMA compliance testing will take place from February 2019 to
test and ensure compliance with the PFMA.
9 The Accounting Officer intensify The Accounting Officer is currently in the process of instituting
performance and consequence disciplinary action against senior managers responsible for allowing
management processes to irregular expenditure to take place. These managers have been served
eliminate findings on irregular
with disciplinary letters and the process is unfolding. Internal controls
expenditure and provides the
have around irregular expenditure have been improved to curb
Committee with a progress
report detailing the effectiveness recurring irregular expenditure. Priority amongst these includes curbing
of measures put in place to of security, nursing agency and Finance/HR/Governance support
address challenges relating to partners and consignment stock irregularities that contributed signifi-
irregular expenditure every cantly to the R1.7 billion incurred in irregular expenditure.
quarter and continuing up and
until the end of June 2019.
Security
All the Department’s security contracts are on a month-to-month basis.
This is irregular in terms of the Public Finance Management Act as the
practice does not constitute fairness and transparency. The Department
is in the process of insourcing security services which will then bring an
end to irregular expenditure related to security contracts.
Nursing agencies
Current practice is that different institutions source their nurses for
Trauma, Intensive Care and Theatre Units. This has been concluded to
constitute a splitting of orders practice and thus irregular as all
contracts above R500k must be subjected to a bidding process. This
bidding process is now being carried out through a cluster approach.
Consignment stock
Current practice is that consignment stock is not subjected to the
manual process of Purchase Order, GRV and invoice matching. This is
because cataloguing of such commodities has not been performed in
the past. This leads to the inability during audit to produce sufficient
appropriate audit evidence that procurement processes were followed.
During the reporting year, cataloguing of this commodity was
performed, bringing an end to irregular expenditure in this regard.
It was the view of the Department that the current partner contracts
for Finance and Human Resources constituted sole suppliers. This view
was disputed by the Auditor General; thus these contracts constituted
irregular expenditure as a bidding process was not followed.
The contracts were stopped on 31 December 2018 and the Depart-
ment is now following a competitive bidding process.
New PFMA compliance testing will take place from February 2019 to
test and ensure compliance with the PFMA.
The table below shows the steps taken to address matters in the AGSA’s report for the previous financial year ending 31 March 2018.
Nature of qualification, disclaimer, The financial year in which it first Progress made in resolving the matter
adverse opinion and matters of arose
non-compliance
None.
Non-Executive Members
Executive Members
In terms of the GPG Audit Committee Charter, officials listed hereunder are obliged to attend meetings of the Audit Committee:
The Audit Committee noted that the Accounting Officer attended all five scheduled Audit Committee meetings. The Audit Committee is
satisfied that the Department adhered to the provisions of the GPG Audit Committee Charter.
The Members of the Audit Committee met with the Accounting Officer, Senior Management of the Department, Internal Audit and the
AGSA, individually and collectively to address risks and challenges facing the Department. A number of in-committee meetings were held to
address control weaknesses and deviations within the Department.
The effectiveness of internal control and Information and Communication Technology (ICT) Governance
The Audit Committee has observed that the overall control environment of the Department has regressed during the year under review.
Significant deficiencies in the system of internal control and deviations were reported in the Internal Audit and Auditor-General Reports. The
overall opinion of Internal Audit on the internal control design at the Department is adequate but ineffective. It is recommended that
Management pay special attention to the core business processes as most findings raised are related to the core mandate of the Department.
Furthermore, it was reported that significant challenges are being experienced at the operational institutions and the Department should
design and implement strict measures to ensure proper oversight and monitoring over them.
The Audit Committee also reviewed the progress with respect to the ICT Governance in line with the ICT Framework issued by the
Department of Public Services and Administration. Controls regarding the ICT environment and system implementation require urgent
attention as many repeat findings are raised and inefficiencies experienced. Based on the unfortunate event of the Bank of Lisbon, business
continuity, disaster recovery and document management remain a high risk for the Department and significant effort must be made with the
implementation of proper document management systems, Disaster Recovery and Business Continuity plans.
The reporting on material irregularities by the AGSA is noted. The audit committee has emphasised the need to address the matters raised in
particular finalisation of irregular and fruitless and wasteful expenditure investigations. The collection of debtors also remains a matter of
great concern.
The Audit Committee advised that management should implement an overall strategy to address the findings raised by the AGSA and Internal
Audit effectively and on time.
Internal Audit
The Audit Committee is satisfied that the Internal Audit plan represents a clear alignment with the key risks, has adequate information
systems coverage, and a good balance across the different categories of audits, i.e. risk-based, mandatory, performance, computer and
follow-up audits.
The Audit Committee has noted improvement in the communication between the Executive Management, the AGSA and the Internal Audit
Function, which has strengthened the Corporate Governance initiatives within the Department, however further improvement is required if
proper effect is to be given to combined assurance.
Risk Management
Progress on the departmental risk management was reported to the Audit Committee on a quarterly basis. The Audit Committee is satisfied
that the management of risk received increased attention in the latter part of the year, although there are areas that still require improvement.
Management should take full responsibility for the entire Enterprise Risk Management Process and continue to support the Chief Risk Officer
to even further enhance the performance of the Department.
Forensic Investigations
Investigations based on the allegations of procurement irregularities, fraud, theft and negligence are being performed on matters dating back
from prior periods. Some of these investigations have been finalised and others were still in progress at the reporting date. The
recommendations of investigations should be implemented with decisiveness.
The quality of quarterly reports submitted in terms of the PFMA and the Division of Revenue Act
The Audit Committee is satisfied with the content and quality of financial and non-financial quarterly reports prepared and submitted by the
Accounting Officer of the Department during the year under review and confirms that the reports were in compliance with the statutory
reporting framework.
• Reviewed and discussed the audited Annual Financial Statements to be included in the Annual Report, with the AGSA and the
Accounting Officer;
• Reviewed the Audit Report of the AGSA;
• Reviewed the AGSA’s Management Report and Management’s response thereto;
• Reviewed the Department’s compliance with legal and regulatory provisions;
• Reviewed significant adjustments resulting from the audit; and
• Reviewed the appropriate accounting policies and relevant disclosures.
1. INTRODUCTION
The information contained in this part of the Annual Report has
been prescribed by the Minister of Public Service and Administration
for all Departments in the public service.
Over the past two years, the Department has sought to increase
accountability and compliance. In doing so, the Department has
experienced an increase in the number of labour cases, disputes,
grievances and of cases reported through Chapter 9 Institutions.
Whilst this was positive, it increased Labour Relations’ workload.
This has required the development of a cadre of internal and
external presiding officers to improve turnaround times in all
labour-related matters.
2. District health services 14,516,480 7,762,182 4,327 45,897 53.5% 416 18,656
4. Provincial hospital services 8,686,653 6,244,387 850 279,379 71.9% 295 21,132
5. Central hospital services 17,134,256 10,956,631 555 35,523 63.9% 592 18,522
6. Health sciences and training 1,106,708 762,053 11,019 - 68.9% 207 3,680
- HWSETA accounts - - - - * *
Salaries Salaries as % Overtime Overtime as % HOA HOA as % of Medical Ass. Medical Ass. as Total
Programme (R'000) of Personnel (R'000) of Personnel (R'000) Personnel Costs (R'000 % of Personnel Personnel Cost
Costs Costs Costs (R'000
Administration 382,688 1.4% 4,425 0.0% 8,404 0.0% 0.1% 15,092 410,609
District health services 6,802,656 25.3% 368,226 1.4% 232,666 0.9% 1.3% 358,633 7,762,181
Emergency medical services 476,076 1.8% 8,900 0.0% 24,254 0.1% 0.2% 43,451 552,681
Provincial hospital services 5,236,782 19.5% 562,471 2.1% 179,659 0.7% 1.0% 265,475 6,244,387
Central hospital services 9,104,579 33.8% 1,182,107 4.4% 278,684 1.0% 1.5% 391,260 10,956,630
Health sciences and training 707,634 2.6% 1,505 0.0% 22,193 0.1% 0.1% 30,722 762,054
Health care support services 136,466 0.5% 14,853 0.1% 12,015 0.0% 0.1% 18,812 182,146
Health facilities management 30,767 0.1% - 0.0% 295 0.0% 0.0% 548 31,610
HWSETA accounts -
Total 22,877,648 85.0% 2,142,487 8.0% 758,170 2.8% 4.2% 1,123,993 26,902,298
Lower Skilled (Levels 1-2) 2,307,123,594 11.3% 156,188,453 7.3% 158,538,064 20.0% 211,140,401 18.8%
Skilled (Levels 3-5) 4,257,427,901 20.8% 194,402,743 9.1% 306,625,678 38.8% 393,323,200 35.0%
Highly Skilled Production (Levels 6-8) 4,499,891,382 22.0% 133,699,851 6.3% 210,284,319 26.6% 315,069,506 28.0%
Highly Skilled Supervision (Levels 9-12) 9,305,777,826 45.5% 1,648,585,861 77.1% 114,863,506 14.5% 203,977,190 18.1%
Senior and Top Management (Levels 13-16) 102,937,697 0.5% 5,824,462 0.3% 839,907 0.1% 1,565,097 0.1%
Total
Total Number Total % of SMS % of SMS
Number
Salary Band Description of Funded Number of posts Filled posts
of SMS
SMS posts SMS posts Vacant
posts
Filled
Vacant
Table 3.3.3 Advertising and Filling of SMS Posts 1 April 2018 to 31 March 2019
Table 3.3.4 Reasons for not having complied with the filling of funded vacant SMS posts Advertised within 6 months and filled
within 12 months after becoming vacant: 1 April 2018 to 31 March 2019
Budget constraints
Unavailability of senior managers to conduct the shortlisting and interviews Cancellation of scheduled
Recruitment processes due to the Executive Management's urgent meetings
Table 3.3.5 Disciplinary steps taken for not complying with the prescribed timeframes for filling SMS posts within 12 months
Posts were
Reasons foradvertised andadvertised
vacancies not documentswithin
were six
caught in the fire at the Bank of Lisbon building. An erratum advertisement
months
was placed in national newspapers and attracted one candidate.
As above
Notes:
Some Health lower level posts are currently being co-ordinated by the DPSA and we are awaiting the results.
DPSA has also facilitated the job evaluation benchmark exercise for all Middle Managament, Supply Chain, Finance, and Risk management posts
Female 0 0 0 0 0
Male 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0 0 -
Table 3.4.3 Employees with salary levels higher than those determined by job evaluation by occupation: 1 April 2018 to 31
March 2019
0 0 0 0
Table 3.4.4 profile of employees whose salary levels are higher than those determined by Job evaluation: 1 April 2018 to 31
March 2019
Total
Gender African Asian Coloured White
0
Female 0 0 0 0
0
Male 0 0 0 0
0
Total 0 0 0 0
-
Employees with Disability - - - -
Notes:
Total number of employees whose salaries exceeded the level determined by job evaluation is ZERO
Table 3.5.1 Annual turnover rates by salary band: 1 April 2018 to 31 March 2019
Pharmacists (intern) 60 59 63 -
Table 3.5.3 Reasons why staff left the Department: 1 April 2018 to 31 March 2019
% of Total
Termination Type Number Resignations
Male Female
African Coloured Indian Total White African Coloured Indian Total White Total
Occupational Category Black Black
2. Professionals 1,774 67 420 2,261 796 1,945 84 500 2,529 993 6,579
3. Technicians and associate professionals 2,614 39 57 2,710 139 17,162 471 364 17,997 1,006 21,852
5. Service workers and shop and market sales workers 2,639 20 15 2,674 51 14,363 107 17 14,487 136 17,348
Total 13,706 236 518 14,460 1,118 45,976 889 902 47,767 2,476 65,821
Male Female
African Coloured Indian Total White African Coloured Indian Total White Total
Occupational Bands Black Black
1.Top management 2 - - 2 - 5 - - 5 - 7
2. Senior management 44 3 2 49 6 35 2 2 39 4 98
3. Professionally qualified and experienced specialists and 2,598 89 412 3,099 730 9,267 318 660 10,245 1,447 15,521
mid-management 31
4. Skilled technical and academically qualified workers, junior 2,584 37 2,652 129 12,637 274 172 13,083 72 16,593
management, supervisors
13 9
5. Semi-skilled and discretionary decision making 5,350 68 5,431 69 17,590 189 21 17,800 152 23,452
6. Unskilled and defined decision-making 3,128 39 60 3,227 184 6,442 106 47 6,595 144 10,150
Total 13,706 236 518 14,460 1,118 45,976 889 902 47,767 2,476 65,821
Male Female
1.Top management 1 - - - - - - - 1
2. Senior management 1 - - - 1 - - - 2
3. Professionally qualified and experienced specialists and 414 28 93 230 865 135 188 406 2,259
mid-management 523 20
4. Skilled technical and academically qualified workers, junior 101 3 3 18 56 196 920
management, supervisors
468 5
Male Female
African Coloured Indian Total White African Coloured Indian Total White Total
Salary Band Black Black
1.Top management - - - 0 - 1 - - 1 - 1
2. Senior management 1 - - 1 - - - - 0 - 1
3. Professionally qualified and experienced specialists and 102 3 23 128 23 369 18 31 418 42 611
mid-management 6
4. Skilled technical and academically qualified workers, junior 77 1 3 81 3 764 12 782 11 877
management, supervisors, foreman and superintendents
-
Male Female
African Coloured Indian Total White African Coloured Indian Total White Total
Salary Band Black Black
1.Top management 1 - - 1 - 5 - - 0 - 1
2. Senior management 4 1 - 5 2 1,190 - - 5 2 14
3. Professionally qualified and experienced specialists and 492 29 106 627 235 1,188 72 198 1,460 482 2,804
mid-management
4. Skilled technical and academically qualified workers, junior 261 5 6 272 18 806 49 67 1,304 282 1,876
management, supervisors, foreman and superintendents
5. Semi-skilled and discretionary decision making 292 9 4 305 9 624 21 1 828 15 1,157
Total 1,461 49 142 1,652 313 58 160 290 4,263 818 7,046
Male Female
Disciplinary action
437 4 2 12 457 5 1 12 930
Male Female
African Coloured Indian Total White African Coloured Indian Total White Total
Occupational Category Black Black
3. Technicians and associate professionals 1,606 449 206 2,261 61 2,751 692 121 3,564 37 5,923
5. Service workers and shop and market sales workers 201 12 4 217 1 701 4 3 708 2 928
Total 4,905 874 361 6,140 134 10,293 1,190 242 11,725 112 17,111
Legend
• Legislators, Senior Officials and Managers Officials responsible for determining and formulating policy and strategy, planning, directing and coordinating the policies and activities of the organisation;
for example: CEOs, Senior Managers, College Principals
• Technicians and Associate Professionals This group includes occupations whose main tasks require technical knowledge and experience such as Clinical Technologists, Industrial Technicians,
Environmental Health Officers, Professional Nurses
• Clerks This group includes occupations whose tasks require the knowledge and experience necessary to organise, store, compute and retrieve information such as
Accounting Clerks, Stores Officers, Administration Clerks
This group includes occupations whose main tasks require the knowledge and experience necessary to provide personal and protective services such as
• Service Workers and Shop and Market Sales Workers
auxiliary services officers (ward attendants), Emergency Care practitioners, firefighters, food services aides
• Craft and Related Trades Workers This group includes occupations whose main tasks require the knowledge and experience of skilled trades and handicrafts such as clinical photographers,
plumbers and electricians
• Plant and Machine Operators and Assemblers The main tasks of this occupational grouping involve the use of automated industrial machinery and equipment such as drivers and tradesmen’s aides
Table 3.7.2 Reasons for not having concluded Performance Agreements for all SMS members as on 31 March 2019
Table 3.7.3 Disciplinary steps taken against SMS members for not having concluded Performance Agreements
Reason
None
Table 3.8.1 Performance rewards by race and gender: financial year 2017/2018
Highly skilled production (Levels 6-8) 12,758 16,676 76.5% 92,876,364 7,280
Highly skilled supervision (Levels 9-12) 9,532 15,650 60.9% 69,589,654 7,301
Staff nurses and pupil nurses 6293 7600 82.8% 45,597,688 7,246
Table 3.8.4 Performance related rewards (Cash Bonus) by salary band for SMS: Financial year 2017/2018
Highly skilled supervision (Levels 9-12) 701 63.4% 651 67.9% -50 34.0%
Table 3.9.2 Foreign workers by major occupation: 1 April 2018 to 31 March 2019
Social natural technical and medical sciences + supp 1 0.1% 1 0.1% 0 0.0%
Technicians and associated professionals 166 19.9% 141 18.3% -25 39.1%
Total Days % Days with Number of % of Total Average Estimated Total Total
Medical Employees Employees Days per Cost (R'000) Number of Number of
Salary Band Certification using Sick using Sick Employee Employees Employees
Leave Leave using Sick using Sick
Leave Leave
Contract (Levels 13-16) 40.00 90.00 7.00 0.00 6.00 163.00 48,536.00 36.00
Contract (Levels 3-5) 189.00 72.50 47.00 0.10 4.00 147.00 48,536.00 137.00
Contract (Levels 6-8) 3,064.00 73.10 564.00 1.20 5.00 3,618.00 48,536.00 2,241.00
Contract (Levels 9-12) 6,358.00 73.00 1,378.00 2.80 5.00 15,190.00 48,536.00 4,644.00
Contract Other 612.00 90.40 223.00 0.50 3.00 208.00 48,536.00 553.00
Highly skilled production (Levels 6-8) 88,404.00 83.50 12,973.00 26.70 7.00 110,729.00 48,536.00 73,848.00
Highly skilled supervision (Levels 9-12) 63,812.00 83.20 9,122.00 18.80 7.00 163,812.00 48,536.00 53,117.00
Lower skilled (Levels 1-2) 39,919.00 88.10 5,657.00 11.70 7.00 20,627.00 48,536.00 35,172.00
Senior management (Levels 13-16) 420.00 82.90 67.00 0.10 6.00 1,681.00 48,536.00 348.00
Skilled (Levels 3-5) 122,146.00 84.00 18,496.00 38.10 7.00 94,365.00 48,536.00 102,644.00
Total Days % Days with Number of % of Total Average Estimated Total Total
Medical Employees Employees Days per Cost (R'000) Number of Number of
Salary Band Certification using Sick using Sick Employee Employees Employees
Leave Leave using Sick using Sick
Leave Leave
Contract (Levels 6-8) 125.00 100.00 6.00 0.20 21.00 141.00 125.00 3,599.00
Contract (Levels 9-12) 354.00 100.00 12.00 0.30 30.00 795.00 354.00 3,599.00
Highly skilled production (Levels 6-8) 19,894.00 100.00 1,086.00 30.20 18.00 25,230.00 19,894.00 3,599.00
Highly skilled supervision (Levels 9-12) 15,444.00 99.80 757.00 21.00 20.00 38,340.00 15,418.00 3,599.00
Lower skilled (Levels 1-2) 6,940.00 100.00 445.00 12.40 16.00 3,668.00 6,940.00 3,599.00
Senior management (Levels 13-16) 5.00 100.00 1.00 0.00 5.00 18.00 5.00 3,599.00
Skilled (Levels 3-5) 25,318.00 100.00 1,292.00 35.90 20.00 19,527.00 25,312.00 3,599.00
Average Number of
Total Days Employees who
Salary Band Days per
Taken took leave
Employee
Highly skilled production (Levels 6-8) 590.43 4.00 30.00 165.00 97,480.99 3,286.00
Highly skilled supervision (Levels 9-12) 741.30 5.00 33.00 154.00 100,496.40 3,053.00
Lower skilled (Levels 1-2) 5.00 5.00 22.00 1.00 770.27 35.00
Senior management (Levels 13-16) 15.00 15.00 63.00 1.00 2,500.56 40.00
Annual - discounting: unused vacation credits (work days) 105.00 3.00 35,000.00
TOTAL 94,387.00 - -
Units/categories of employees identified to be at high risk of Key steps taken to reduce the risk
contracting HIV & related diseases (if any)
Health Care Professionals (Biological Exposure through cuts, Policy, protocols & PPE
splashes, NSI, bites)
1. Has the Department designated a member of the SMS to YES Dr Sipho Senabe
implement the provisions contained in Part VI E of Chapter 1 Chief Director: HRD & EHWP
of the Public Service Regulations, 2001? If so, provide her/his
name and position.
PHC Services
- Management of Chronic Diseases
- NIMART
5. Has the Department reviewed its employment policies and National HIV, TB & STI Strategic Plan of Gauteng HIV &
practices to ensure that these do not unfairly discriminate AIDS Strategic 2017-22
against employees on the basis of their HIV status? If so, list HR Recruitment Policy
the employment policies/practices so reviewed. Medical Surveillance Policy
7. Does the Department encourage its employees to undergo Wellness Days, Peer Education Programmes, Medical
Voluntary Counselling and Testing? If so, list the results that Surveillance, Support Groups, STI & Condom Week
you have you achieved. Results are poor
1311 tested
138 males
1173 females
PHSDSBC
12 June 2018
Resolution 1 Of 2018 - Agreement on The Standardisation Of Remuneration For Community Health Workers In
The Department Of Health
PSCBC
08 June 2018
Resolution 1 of 2018: Agreement on the salary adjustments and improvements in conditions of service for the
period 2018 to 2021
Notes:
The CCPGP did not sign any resolutions during the reporting period.
Data supplied by Labour Relations Management & Development
Table 3.12.2 Misconduct and disciplinary hearings finalised: 1 April 2018 to 31 March 2019
Abscondment 23 3%
Dismissal 4 0.50%
Corrective counselling 13 2%
Withdrawn 23 3%
Closed e.g. insufficient evidence, employees resigned, key witness not available, decease etc. 49 6%
Assault 27 3%
Dereliction of duties 28 3%
Dishonesty 17 2%
Improper conduct 67 7%
Negligence 89 10%
Theft 78 8%
Others, e.g. late coming, damage to state property, misuse of state property, irregular appointment, dress code etc. 178 2%
Table 3.12.5 Disputes lodged with Council: 1 April 2018 to 31 March 2019
Withdrawn 11
In favour of the Department 15
In favour of the applicant 03
Dismissed 04
Settled 09
Occupational Categories Gender Number of Learnerships Skills Programmes Other forms of Total
Employees (1 & other short training
April 2018) courses
Male 84 - 6 - 6
5. Service Workers and Shop and Market Sales Workers Female 15,036 - 750 -- 750
Male 0 - 0 -- 0
Male 407 - 5 - 5
Notes:
a. Data provided by the Directorate Human Resource Development: Skills Development
b. Number of employees is as at the beginning of the reporting period (i.e. April 2018) as required by the reporting guideline.
c. Learnerships, Skills Programmes and other forms of training are training needs identified as per Workplace Skills Plan of 2018/2018
Occupational Categories Gender Number of Learnerships Skills Programmes Other forms of Total
Employees (1 & other short training
April 2018) courses
1. Legislators, Senior Officials and Managers Female 76 - 6 0 6
Male 84 - 10 0 10
5. Service Workers and Shop and Market Sales Workers Female 15,036 - 710 0 710
Male 0 - 3 0 3
Male 407 - 11 0 11
Notes:
a. a. Data provided by the Directorate Human Resource Development
b. Number of employees is extracted from PERSAL as at the beginning of the reporting period (i.e. April 2019) as required by the reporting guideline.
c. Learnerships, Skills Programmes and other forms of training is training provided as per Annual Training Report of 2018/2019
Table 3.16.1 Granting of employee-initiated severance packages for the period 1 April 2018 to 31 March 2019
Total 0 0 0 0
Notes:
The Department does not have the competence/mandate to approve severance packages.
The competence lies with the MDPSA.
PART E:
FINANCIAL INFORMATION
GAUTENG DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH VOTE 4
REPORT OF THE AUDITOR-GENERAL TOAPPROPRIATION
THE GAUTENG PROVINCIAL
STATEMENT LEGISLATURE
FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 MARCH 2019
ON VOTE NO. 4: GAUTENG DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
REPORT ON THE AUDIT OF THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 8. As disclosed in note 19.2 to the financial statements, payables of
Opinion R2 855 623 000 exceeded the payment term of 30 days, as
1. I have audited the financial statements of the Gauteng Depart- required by treasury regulation 8.2.3. This amount, in turn,
ment of Health set out on pages 162 to 271, which comprise the exceeded the R439 466 000 of voted funds to be surrendered by
appropriation statement, the statement of financial position as R2 416 157 000 as per the statement of financial performance.
at 31 March 2019, the statement of financial performance, The amount of R2 416 157 000 would therefore have constitut-
statement of changes in net assets and cash flow statement for ed unauthorised expenditure had the amounts due been paid in
the year then ended, as well as the notes to the financial time.
statements, including a summary of significant accounting
policies. Other matter
2. In my opinion, the financial statements present fairly, in all 9. I draw attention to the matter below. My opinion is not modified
material respects, the financial position of the Gauteng Depart- in respect of this matter.
ment of Health as at 31 March 2019, and its financial perfor-
mance and cash flows for the year then ended in accordance UNAUDITED SUPPLEMENTARY SCHEDULES
with the Modified Cash Standard (MCS) prescribed by the 10. The supplementary information set out on pages 272 to 279
National Treasury and the requirements of the Public Finance does not form part of the financial statements and is presented
Management Act of South Africa, 1999 (Act No. 1 of 1999) as additional information. I have not audited this/ these sched-
(PFMA) and the Division of Revenue Act of South Africa, 2018 ule(s) and, accordingly, I do not express an opinion on it/ them
(Act No. 1 of 2018) (Dora).
RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE ACCOUNTING OFFICER FOR
Basis for opinion THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
3. I conducted my audit in accordance with the International 11. The accounting officer is responsible for the preparation and
Standards on Auditing (ISAs). My responsibilities under those fair presentation of the financial statements in accordance with
standards are further described in the auditor-general’s respon- the MCS prescribed by the National Treasury and the require-
sibilities for the audit of the financial statements section of this ments of the PFMA and Dora, and for such internal control as
auditor’s report. the accounting officer determines is necessary to enable the
4. I am independent of the department in accordance with sections preparation of financial statements that are free from material
290 and 291 of the International Ethics Standards Board for misstatement, whether due to fraud or error.
Accountants’ Code of ethics for professional accountants (IESBA 12. In preparing the financial statements, the accounting officer is
code), parts 1 and 3 of the International Ethics Standards Board responsible for assessing the Gauteng Department of Health’s
for Accountants’ International Code of Ethics for Professional ability to continue as a going concern, disclosing, as applicable,
Accountants (including International Independence Standards) matters relating to going concern and using the going concern
and the ethical requirements that are relevant to my audit in basis of accounting unless the appropriate governance structure
South Africa. I have fulfilled my other ethical responsibilities in either intends to liquidate the department or to cease opera-
accordance with these requirements and the IESBA codes. tions, or has no realistic alternative but to do so.
5. I believe that the audit evidence I have obtained is sufficient and
appropriate to provide a basis for my opinion.
AUDITOR-GENERAL’S RESPONSIBILITIES FOR THE AUDIT
OF THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
13. My objectives are to obtain reasonable assurance about wheth-
Emphasis of matters
er the financial statements as a whole are free from material
6. I draw attention to the matters below. My opinion is not modi-
misstatement, whether due to fraud or error, and to issue an
fied in respect of these matters.
auditor’s report that includes my opinion. Reasonable assurance
is a high level of assurance, but is not a guarantee that an audit
MATERIAL UNCERTAINTIES RELATING TO LITIGATIONS
conducted in accordance with the ISAs will always detect a
7. With reference to note 17.1 to the financial statements, the
material misstatement when it exists. Misstatements can arise
department is the defendant in various lawsuits. The ultimate
from fraud or error and are considered material if, individually or
outcome of the matters cannot presently be determined and no
in aggregate, they could reasonably be expected to influence the
provision for any liability that may result has been made in the
economic decisions of users taken on the basis of these financial
financial statements.
PAYMENTS WHICH EXCEEDED VOTED FUND TO BE statements.
SURRENDERED
14. A further description of my responsibilities for the audit of the completeness and appropriateness of the performance
financial statements is included in the annexure to this auditor’s indicators included in the planning documents. My procedures
report. also did not extend to any disclosures or assertions relating to
planned performance strategies and information in respect of
REPORT ON THE AUDIT OF THE ANNUAL PERFORMANCE future periods that may be included as part of the reported
REPORT INTRODUCTION AND SCOPE performance information. Accordingly, my findings do not
15. In accordance with the Public Audit Act of South Africa, 2004 extend to these matters.
(Act No. 25 of 2004) (PAA) and the general notice issued in 17. I evaluated the usefulness and reliability of the reported perfor-
terms thereof, I have a responsibility to report material findings mance information in accordance with the criteria developed
on the reported performance information against from the performance management and reporting framework,
predetermined objectives for selected programmes presented in as defined in the general notice, for the following selected
the annual performance report. I performed procedures to programmes presented in the annual performance report of the
identify findings but not to gather evidence to express department for the year ended 31 March 2019:
assurance.
16. My procedures address the reported performance information, .
which must be based on the approved performance planning
documents of the department. I have not evaluated the
18. I performed procedures to determine whether the reported performance information was properly presented and whether perfor-
mance was consistent with the approved performance planning documents. I performed further procedures to determine whether the
indicators and related targets were measurable and relevant, and assessed the reliability of the reported performance information to
determine whether it was valid, accurate and complete.
19. The material findings in respect of the usefulness and reliability of the selected programmes are as follows:
Various indicators
21. The reasons for the variances between the planned targets and the reported achievements were not explained in the annual perfor-
mance report for the indicators listed below. Furthermore, the reported achievements in the annual performance report did not agree
to the supporting evidence provided for the indicators listed below. It was impractical to determine the audited values.
HOSPITAL ACHIEVED 75% AND MORE ON NATIONAL CORE STANDARDS SELF-ASSESSMENT RATE (DISTRICT
HOSPITALS).
23. I was unable to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence to validate the existence of systems and processes that enable reliable
reporting of actual service delivery against the indicator for the reported achievement of 91.7%. This was due to the limitation placed
on the scope of my work as the information documented in the checklists completed during the assessments could not be
re-performed as no corroborating evidence was provided to support the ratings in the checklists. I was unable to validate the existence
of systems and processes by alternative means. Consequently, I was unable to determine whether any further adjustments were
required to the reported achievement. Furthermore, the reason for the variance between the planned target of 92% and the reported
achievement of 91.7% was not reported in the annual performance report.
No Planned strategic objectives per annual performance plan Reported strategic objectives per annual performance report
1 Increase number of fully-fledged, functional Ward Based Increase the number of fully-fledged, functional Ward Based
Outreach Teams from 130 to 775 targeted wards by 2019/20 Outreach Teams from 103 to 533 by 2019/20
2 Increase number of female condoms distributed annually from 1 Increase number of female condoms distributed annually from
451 696 to 5 600 445 million and male condoms from 69 480 1 451 696 to 5.6 million by 2019/20
738 in 2013/14 to 176 576 4 by 2019/20
3 Increase number of male condoms distributed annually from: 69 Increase number of male condoms distributed annually from 69
480 000 to 176 576 400 by 2019/20 480 738 to 176 million by 2019/20
4 Decrease TB death rate from 5,2% in 2013/14 to <5% by Decrease TB death rate from 6,1% in 2013/14 to 5,3% by
2019/20 2019/20
5 Decrease child (under 5 years) severe acute malnutrition case Decrease child (under 5 years) pneumonia and severe acute
fatality rate from 6,1% in 2013/2014 to <6% by 2019/20 malnutrition case fatality rate from 12% in 2013/14 to <6% by
2019/20
6 Increase HPV vaccine coverage rate for 1st dose from 87,1% to Increase HPV vaccine coverage rate from 87,1% for 1st dose to
90% by 2019/20 80% by 2019/20
7 Increase HPV vaccine coverage rate for 2nd dose to 90% by Increase HPV vaccine coverage rate for 2nd dose to 80% by
2019/20 2019/20
8 Increase percentage of people treated for TB from 84% in Increase percentage of people treated for TB from 84% in
2013/14 to 92% by 2019/20 2013/14 to 92% of total population with HIV by 2019/20
9 Increase number of mothers whose first antenatal visit is before Increase number of mothers whose first antenatal visit is before
20 weeks from 43,7% in 2013/2014 to 65% by 2019/20 20 weeks from 43,7% in 2013/2014 to 70% by 2019/20
INCREASE NUMBER OF MEN/WOMEN AGED 15-49 TESTED FOR HIV FROM 1.8 MILLION TO 4 MILLION
26. The strategic objective approved in the annual performance plan was Increase number of men/women aged 15-49 tested for HIV from
1.8 million to 4 million. However, the strategic objective was not reported in the annual performance report.
HOSPITAL ACHIEVED 75% AND MORE ON NATIONAL CORE STANDARDS SELF-ASSESSMENT RATE (TERTIARY
HOSPITALS)
30. I was unable to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence to validate the existence of systems and processes that enable reliable
reporting of actual service delivery against the indicator for the reported achievement of 3/3. This was due to the limitation placed on the
scope of our work as the information documented in the checklists completed during the assessments could not be re-performed as no
corroborating evidence was provided to support the ratings in the checklists. I was unable to validate the existence of systems and
processes by alternative means. Consequently, I was unable to determine whether any further adjustments were required to the reported
achievement. Furthermore, reported achievement was not consistent when compared with planned target as the approved target in the
annual performance plan was 100% (3/3). However, the target achievement in the annual performance report was 3/3.
HOSPITAL ACHIEVED 75% AND MORE ON NATIONAL CORE STANDARDS SELF-ASSESSMENT RATE (CENTRAL
HOSPITALS)
31. I was unable to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence to validate the existence of systems and processes that enable reliable
reporting of actual service delivery against the indicator for the reported achivement of 100%. This was due to the limitation placed on
the scope of my work as the information documented in the checklists completed during the assessments could not be re-performed as
no corroborating evidence was provided to support the ratings in the checklists. I was unable to validate the existence of systems and
processes by alternative means. Consequently, I was unable to determine whether any further adjustments were required to the reported
achievement.
No Planned strategic objectives per annual performance plan Reported strategic objectives per annual performance report
1 Improve efficiency of hospitals by reducing average length of Improve efficiency of hospitals by reducing average length of
stay to 5.5 days increasing bed utilisation to 85% and decreasing stay to 6. 5 days, increasing bed utilisation to 85% and decreas-
expenditure per PDE in hospitals by 2019/20 (Tertiary Hospital) ing expenditure per PDE in hospitals by 2019/20
2 Reduce the number of primary care patient cases that are seen Reduce Outpatient Department (OPD), Accident and Emergen-
at regional, tertiary and central hospitals by 20% in 2019/20 cy departments waiting times across all facilities by 60% in
(Tertiary Hospital) 2019/20
3 Increase compliance to extreme and vital measures of core Increase compliance with national core standards to 100% in
standards to 100% in 2019/20, and complete self- assessments 2019/20, and complete self-assessments in all hospitals
in all hospitals by 2019/20 (Tertiary Hospital)
OTHER MATTER
33. I draw attention to the matter below.
EXPENDITURE MANAGEMENT
42. Effective and appropriate steps were not taken to prevent irregular expenditure, as required by section 38(1)(c)(ii) of the PFMA and
treasury regulation 9.1.1. The value, as disclosed in note 23 to the financial statements, may not be complete as awards to the value of
R77 510 081 could not be tested due to missing/ incomplete information. The majority of the irregular expenditure disclosed in the
financial statements was caused by non-compliance with the treasury regulations on competitive bidding.
43. Effective steps were not taken to prevent fruitless and wasteful expenditure amounting to R26 682 000, as disclosed in note 24 to the
annual financial statements, as required by section 38(1)(c)(ii) of the PFMA and treasury regulation 9.1.1. The majority of the fruitless and
wasteful expenditure was caused by interest levied on overdue accounts.
44. Payments were not made within 30 days or an agreed period after receipt of an invoice, as required by treasury regulation 8.2.3. The
non-compliance resulted in a material irregularity as reported in the section on material irregularities.
REVENUE MANAGEMENT
45. Effective and appropriate steps were not taken to collect all money due, as required by section 38(1)(c)(i) of the PFMA.
46. All reasonable steps were not taken to recover debts before writing them off, as required by treasury regulation 11.4.1.
47. Bad debt was written off contrary to the requirements of the Department of Health’s write-off policy, as required by treasury regulation
11.4.2.
48. Interest was not charged on debts as required by treasury regulation 11.5.1.
CONDITIONAL GRANT
49. The Comprehensive HIV/AIDS,National Tertiary Services and Health Professions Training and Development were not spent for the
purposes stipulated in the Schedule concerned / in accordance with the applicable framework, as required by section 17(1) of the Division
of Revenue Act (Act 1 of 2018).
CONSEQUENCE MANAGEMENT
50. Disciplinary steps were not taken against the officials who had permitted irregular expenditure, as required by section 38(1)(h)(iii) of the
PFMA.
MATERIAL IRREGULARITIES
60. In accordance with the PAA and the material irregularities regulations, I have a responsibility to report on material irregularities identified
during the audit.
61. The material irregularities identified are as follows:
MEDICAL CLAIMS NOT PAID WITHIN THE PERIOD SPECIFIED IN THE COURT JUDGEMENT
62. Payments for medical claims were not made within the period specified in the court judgement, as required by treasury regulation 8.2.3.
As a result of the late payments interest was charged, resulting in a material financial loss of R7 977 322, which forms part of the
amount disclosed as interest on litigation in note 24 of the financial statements.
63. The accounting officer has not taken appropriate action in response to being notified of the material irregularity. I recommend that the
accounting officer should take the following actions to address the material irregularity, which should be implemented by 31 January
2020:
• The accounting officer should investigate the fruitless and wasteful expenditure incurred as a result of the interest paid.
• Effective and appropriate disciplinary steps should be taken against any official that the investigation found to be responsible, as
required by section 38(1)(h) of the PFMA and in accordance with treasury regulation 9.1.3.
• Appropriate action should be taken to determine whether the responsible official is liable by law for the losses suffered by the
department for the purpose of recovery, as required by treasury regulations 9.1.4 and 12.7.1.
OTHER REPORTS
68. In addition to the investigations relating to material irregularities, I draw attention to the following engagements conducted by various
parties that had, or could have, an impact on the matters reported in the department’s financial statements, reported performance
information, compliance with applicable legislation and other related matters. These reports did not form part of my opinion on the
financial statements or my findings on the reported performance information or compliance with legislation.
INVESTIGATIONS
69. Various investigations, based on the allegations of procurement irregularities, fraud, theft and negligence, are being performed by the
department dating back from prior periods. Some of these investigations were finalised by the Special Investigation Unit and the depart-
ment whilst others were still in progress at the date of this auditor’s report
Johannesburg
31 August 2019
1. As part of an audit in accordance with the ISAs, I exercise professional judgement and maintain professional scepticism throughout my
audit of the financial statements, and the procedures performed on reported performance information for selected programmes and
on the department’s compliance with respect to the selected subject matters.
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
2. In addition to my responsibility for the audit of the financial statements as described in this auditor’s report, I also:
• identify and assess the risks of material misstatement of the financial statements whether due to fraud or error, design and
perform audit procedures responsive to those risks, and obtain audit evidence that is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis
for my opinion. The risk of not detecting a material misstatement resulting from fraud is higher than for one resulting from error,
as fraud may involve collusion, forgery, intentional omissions, misrepresentations, or the override of internal control
• obtain an understanding of internal control relevant to the audit in order to design audit procedures that are appropriate in the
circumstances, but not for the purpose of expressing an opinion on the effectiveness of the department’s internal control
• evaluate the appropriateness of accounting policies used and the reasonableness of accounting estimates and related disclosures
made by the accounting officer
• conclude on the appropriateness of the accounting officer’s use of the going concern basis of accounting in the preparation of
the financial statements. I also conclude, based on the audit evidence obtained, whether a material uncertainty exists related to
events or conditions that may cast significant doubt on the department’s ability to continue as a going concern. If I conclude that
a material uncertainty exists, I am required to draw attention in my auditor’s report to the related disclosures in the financial
statements about the material uncertainty or, if such disclosures are inadequate, to modify the opinion on the financial
statements. My conclusions are based on the information available to me at the date of this auditor’s report. However, future
events or conditions may cause a department to cease continuing as a going concern
• evaluate the overall presentation, structure and content of the financial statements, including the disclosures, and whether the
financial statements represent the underlying transactions and events in a manner that achieves fair presentation
1 Administration 1 074 130 - 287 000 1 361 130 1 360 786 344 100,0% 1 085 267 1 085 177
2 District Health Services 15 360 917 - -287 000 15 073 917 14 516 480 557 437 96,3% 13 712 101 13 683 513
3 Emergency Medical Services 1 483 203 - -60 000 1 423 203 1 330 508 92 695 93,5% 1 268 154 1 219 274
4 Provincial Hospital Services 9 030 469 - -284 000 8 746 469 8 686 653 59 816 99,3% 7 892 663 7 892 277
5 Central Hospital Services 16 818 226 - 317 000 17 135 226 17 134 257 969 100,0% 15 333 041 15 316 687
6 Health Sciences and Training 1 123 296 - - 1 123 296 1 106 708 16 588 98,5% 928 471 918 987
7 Health Care Support Services 312 156 - 27 000 339 156 339 048 108 100,0% 289 838 289 767
8 Health Facilities Management 1 559 933 - - 1 559 933 1 536 120 23 813 98,5% 1 683 299 1 607 777
Programme sub total 46 762 330 - - 46 762 330 46 010 560 751 770 98,4% 42 192 834 42 013 459
Statutory Appropriation - - - - - - - - -
" Actual amounts per Statement of Financial Performance 47 543 133 42 739 750
(Total Revenue) "
" Actual amounts per Statement of Financial Performance
Expenditure " R46 010 560 R42 013 459
Catering: Departmental activities 4 940 - - 4 940 2 332 2 608 47,2% 4 842 2 600
Communication (G&S) 101 021 - - 101 021 70 437 30 584 69,7% 92 948 74 378
Computer services 359 651 - - 359 651 64 711 294 940 18,0% 289 092 264 615
Consultants: Business and advisory services 189 526 - - 189 526 370 023 -180 497 195,2% 215 299 370 900
Laboratory services 2 513 707 - -425 000 2 088 707 2 138 382 -49 675 102,4% 1 541 789 1 535 121
Agency and support / outsourced services 223 617 - - 223 617 245 764 -22 147 109,9% 349 979 255 725
Fleet services (including government motor transport) 323 232 - -60 000 263 232 254 328 8 904 96,6% 237 224 235 509
Inventory: Food and food supplies 380 445 - - 380 445 331 714 48 731 87,2% 342 080 338 723
Inventory: Fuel, oil and gas 218 466 - 8 000 226 466 262 538 -36 072 115,9% 171 642 220 779
Inventory: Learner and teacher support material 3 402 - - 3 402 15 003 -11 601 440,9% 1 652 813
Inventory: Materials and supplies 40 650 - - 40 650 29 593 11 057 72,8% 43 162 37 564
Inventory: Medical supplies 2 767 724 - 317 000 3 084 724 3 619 141 (534 417) 117.3% 2 470 058 2 618 205
-
Inventory: Medicine 4 935 506 - 138 000 4 797 506 4 132 206 665 300 86,1% 3 895 518 3 826 095
Inventory: Other supplies 123 698 - - 123 698 121 992 1 706 98,6% 134 388 112 339
Consumable supplies 522 431 - 11 000 533 431 485 743 47 688 91,1% 457 197 452 908
Consumable: Stationery, printing and office supplies 164 545 - - 164 545 166 441 -1 896 101,2% 159 849 152 092
Transport provided: Departmental activity 8 702 - - 8 702 317 8 385 3,6% 13 075 4 875
Travel and subsistence 37 251 - - 37 251 16 518 20 733 44,3% 35 823 22 104
Training and development 58 094 - - 58 094 23 773 34 321 40,9% 48 699 23 391
Venues and facilities 22 582 - - 22 582 7 045 15 537 31,2% 4 526 1 457
Rental and hiring 811 - - 811 996 -185 122,8% 735 984
Departmental agencies and accounts 20 962 - - 20 962 20 962 - 100,0% 19 812 19 812
Departmental agencies (non-business entities) 20 962 - - 20 962 20 962 - 100,0% 19 812 19 812
Higher education institutions 13 681 - - 13 681 13 421 260 98,1% 12 061 9 786
Payments for capital assets 2 243 187 - - 2 243 187 1 572 106 671 081 70,1% 2 123 479 1 476 113
Buildings and other fixed structures 900 267 - - 900 267 785 617 114 650 87,3% 818 917 615 434
Machinery and equipment 1 342 920 - - 1 342 920 786 489 556 431 58,6% 1 304 562 860 679
Transport equipment 159 710 -5 000 - 154 710 143 970 10 740 93,1% 199 910 139 335
Other machinery and equipment 1 183 210 5 000 - 1 188 210 642 519 545 691 54,1% 1 104 652 721 344
Consumable: Stationery, printing and office supplies 4 944 - - 4 944 1 628 3 316 32,9% 7 493 3 268
Travel and subsistence 7 943 - - 7 943 3 866 4 077 48,7% 7 864 3 383
Training and development 6 194 - - 6 194 6 865 -671 110,8% 1 175 7 347
Venues and facilities 1 802 - - 1 802 839 963 46,6% 181 104
Rental and hiring 193 - - 193 358 -165 185,5% 183 334
Transfers and subsidies 2 450 - 287 000 289 450 588 392 -298 942 203,3% 2 313 165 909
Other transfers to households 1 376 - 287 000 288 376 586 021 -297 645 203,2% 1 300 164 272
Payments for capital assets 107 466 - - 107 466 4 814 102 652 4,5% 72 261 11 744
Machinery and equipment 107 466 - - 107 466 4 814 102 652 4,5% 72 261 11 744
Other machinery and equipment 102 713 - - 102 713 3 432 99 281 3,3% 67 776 8 195
Economic classification R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 % R'000 R'000
Economic classification R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 % R'000 R'000
Consumable: Stationery, printing and office supplies 506 - - 506 37 469 7,3% 477 56
Operating leases - - - - 626 -626 - - 506
Travel and subsistence 3 113 - - 3 113 240 2 873 7,7% 2 937 112
Venues and facilities 170 - - 170 13 157 7,6% 160 54
Rental and hiring 18 - - 18 - 18 - 17 -
Transfers and subsidies - - - - 76 -76 - - -
Households - - - - 76 -76 - - -
Social benefits - - - 76 -76 - - -
Payments for capital assets 663 - - 663 303 360 45,7% 626 702
Machinery and equipment 663 - - 663 303 360 45,7% 626 702
Transport equipment 513 - - 513 238 275 46,4% 485 534
Other machinery and equipment 150 - - 150 65 85 43,3% 141 168
Payment for financial assets - - - - 41 -41 - - -
Total 21 581 - - 21 581 10 038 11 543 46,5% 20 358 12 349
Economic classification R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 % R'000 R'000
Sub programme
Community Health Clinics 2 472 905 - - 2 472 905 2 382 980 89 925 96,4% 2 425 500 2 416 248
Community Health Centres 2 001 669 - - 2 001 669 1 941 214 60 455 97,0% 1 778 040 1 792 265
Community Based Services 1 996 989 - - 1 996 989 2 082 026 -85 037 104,3% 1 780 080 1 780 657
District Hospitals 3 619 882 - -287 000 3 332 882 3 204 715 128 167 96,2% 2 983 916 3 015 482
Economic classification
Current payments 14 367 406 - -287 000 14 080 406 13 566 475 513 931 96,4% 12 688 348 12 713 689
Salaries and wages 6 699 920 - - 6 699 920 6 759 196 -59 276 100,9% 6 155 015 6 219 445
Goods and services 6 571 503 - -287 000 6 284 503 5 804 293 480 210 92,4% 5 594 994 5 557 926
Catering: Departmental activities 3 930 - - 3 930 2 070 1 860 52,7% 3 630 1 807
Consultants: Business and advisory services 29 080 - - 29 080 29 397 -317 101,1% 29 324 35 217
Laboratory services 1 153 872 - -275 000 878 872 956 687 -77 815 108,9% 756 855 840 331
Economic classification R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 % R'000 R'000
Agency and support / outsourced services 61 179 - - 61 179 30 978 30 201 50,6% 60 903 43 563
Fleet services (including government motor transport) 33 295 - - 33 295 24 009 9 286 72,1% 38 571 34 116
Inventory: Food and food supplies 85 343 - - 85 343 57 754 27 589 67,7% 64 529 63 934
Inventory: Fuel, oil and gas 75 711 - - 75 711 74 673 1 038 98,6% 85 872 52 088
Inventory: Materials and supplies 15 667 - - 15 667 5 615 10 052 35,8% 17 368 12 609
Inventory: Medical supplies 536 755 - - 536 755 484 008 52 747 90,2% 525 976 463 091
Inventory: Medicine 3 158 696 -12 000 3 146 696 3 021 249 125 447 96,0% 2 785 627 2 872 048
Inventory: Other supplies 29 057 - - 29 057 21 316 7 741 73,4% 35 662 35 706
Consumable: Stationery, printing and office supplies 71 595 - - 71 595 58 349 13 246 81,5% 71 104 73 320
Transport provided: Departmental activity 1 821 - - 1 821 10 1 811 0,5% 2 145 200
Travel and subsistence 11 337 - - 11 337 7 017 4 320 61,9% 10 176 5 869
Training and development 39 696 - - 39 696 4 326 35 370 10,9% 34 671 8 428
Venues and facilities 15 830 - - 15 830 6 206 9 624 39,2% 4 345 1 235
Economic classification R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 % R'000 R'000
Transfers and subsidies 874 495 - - 874 495 825 077 49 418 94,3% 802 260 834 240
Payments for capital assets 119 016 - - 119 016 122 969 -3 953 103,3% 221 493 133 457
Machinery and equipment 118 776 - - 118 776 122 969 -4 193 103,5% 221 493 133 457
Other machinery and equipment 87 088 - - 87 088 72 396 14 692 83,1% 171 351 100 544
Payment for financial assets 15 360 917 - -287 000 15 073 917 14 516 480 557 437 96,3% 13 712 101 13 683 513
Economic classification R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 % R'000 R'000
Salaries and wages 1 103 942 - - 1 103 942 1 096 654 7 288 99,3% 1 049 989 1 017 627
Goods and services 849 425 - - 849 425 745 311 104 114 87,7% 862 559 862 469
Administrative fees - - - - 1 -1 - 20 6
Agency and support / outsourced services 3 368 - - 3 368 1 209 2 159 35,9% 2 235 1 284
Fleet services (including government motor transport) 100 - - 100 73 27 73,0% 4 656 705
Inventory: Food and food supplies 182 - - 182 23 159 12,6% 454 86
Inventory: Fuel, oil and gas 3 166 - - 3 166 1 018 2 148 32,2% 10 921 2 273
Inventory: Materials and supplies 1 578 - - 1 578 1 073 505 68,0% 2 365 1 766
Inventory: Medical supplies 50 000 - - 50 000 25 028 24 972 50,1% 93 257 36 805
Inventory: Other supplies 2 068 - - 2 068 1 157 911 55,9% 1 996 2 523
Consumable: Stationery, printing and office supplies 6 774 - - 6 774 5 529 1 245 81,6% 9 656 4 425
Economic classification R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 % R'000 R'000
Operating leases 2 989 2 989 1 720 1 269 57,5% 3 114 1 074
Property payments 153 200 153 200 135 519 17 681 88,5% 162 591 164 775
Transport provided: Departmental activity - - - - - 50 25
Travel and subsistence 435 435 94 341 21,6% 884 43
Training and development 474 474 - 474 - 451 3
Operating payments 323 323 7 316 2,2% 760 257
Rental and hiring - - 69 (69) - -
Transfers and subsidies 335 762 - - 335 762 336 893 (1 131) 100,3% 318 848 333 412
Provinces and municipalities 316 463 - - 316 463 316 463 - 100,0% 298 550 298 550
Municipalities 316 463 - - 316 463 316 463 - 100,0% 298 550 298 550
Municipal bank accounts 316 463 316 463 316 463 - 100,0% -
Municipal agencies and funds - - - - 298 550 298 550
Non-profit institutions 13 308 13 308 13 115 193 98,5% 12 578 12 578
Households 5 991 - - 5 991 7 315 (1 324) 122,1% 7 720 22 284
Social benefits 5 991 5 991 7 315 (1 324) 122,1% 7 720 4 851
Other transfers to households - - - - - 17 433
Payments for capital assets 15 000 - - 15 000 19 974 (4 974) 133,2% 38 854 26 733
Machinery and equipment 15 000 - - 15 000 19 974 (4 974) 133,2% 38 854 26 733
Transport equipment 450 450 208 242 46,2% 2 500 90
Other machinery and equipment 14 550 14 550 19 766 (5 216) 135,8% 36 354 26 643
Payment for financial assets - 536 (536) - - 410
Total 2 472 905 - - 2 472 905 2 382 980 89 925 96,4% 2 425 500 2 416 248
Economic classification R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 % R'000 R'000
Economic classification R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 % R'000 R'000
Consumable supplies 7 978 7 978 (3 870) 11 848 (48,5%) 5 960 5 281
Consumable: Stationery, printing and office supplies 3 313 3 313 2 332 981 70,4% 5 157 4 096
Operating leases 1 098 1 098 276 822 25,1% 788 319
Property payments 7 078 7 078 10 217 (3 139) 144,3% 9 900 9 888
Transport provided: Departmental activity 774 774 - 774 - 568 24
Travel and subsistence 3 903 3 903 2 531 1 372 64,8% 2 965 2 310
Training and development 3 130 3 130 1 067 2 063 34,1% 2 584 1 077
Operating payments 272 272 4 268 1,5% 361 156
Venues and facilities - - - - - 50
Rental and hiring 36 36 - 36 - -
Transfers and subsidies 315 521 - - 315 521 274 885 40 636 87,1% 260 098 261 887
Non-profit institutions 313 408 313 408 272 531 40 877 87,0% 257 338 257 151
Households 2 113 - - 2 113 2 354 (241) 111,4% 2 760 4 736
Social benefits 2 113 2 113 2 265 (152) 107,2% 2 760 2 638
Other transfers to households - - 89 (89) - - 2 098
Payments for capital assets 32 795 - - 32 795 2 239 30 556 6,8% 7 630 5 500
Machinery and equipment 32 795 - - 32 795 2 239 30 556 6,8% 7 630 5 500
Transport equipment 3 888 3 888 119 3 769 3,1% 824 28
Other machinery and equipment 28 907 28 907 2 120 26 787 7,3% 6 806 5 472
Payment for financial assets - 90 (90) - - 92
Total 1 996 989 - - 1 996 989 2 082 026 (85 037) 104,3% 1 780 080 1 780 657
Economic classification R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 % R'000 R'000
Economic classification R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 % R'000 R'000
Current payments 231 962 - - 231 962 220 210 11 752 94,9% 207 961 209 881
Compensation of employees 195 236 - - 195 236 187 316 7 920 95,9% 172 865 179 309
Salaries and wages 165 877 165 877 165 655 222 99,9% 152 715 158 206
Social contributions 29 359 29 359 21 661 7 698 73,8% 20 150 21 103
Goods and services 36 726 - - 36 726 32 894 3 832 89,6% 35 096 30 572
Administrative fees 34 34 5 29 14,7% 30 12
Advertising 90 90 - 90 - 158 24
Minor assets 567 567 77 490 13,6% 535 193
Catering: Departmental activities 116 116 53 63 45,7% 114 110
Communication (G&S) 1 661 1 661 305 1 356 18,4% 1 777 558
Consultants: Business and advisory services - - - - - 52 25
Economic classification R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 % R'000 R'000
Laboratory services 592 592 56 536 9,5% 275 211
Contractors 821 821 118 703 14,4% 775 78
Agency and support / outsourced services 2 022 2 022 855 1 167 42,3% 1 908 1 075
Fleet services (including government motor transport) 5 056 5 056 6 607 (1 551) 130,7% 4 770 5 142
Inventory: Fuel, oil and gas - - 5 (5) - 30 5
Inventory: Learner and teacher support material - - - - - - -
Inventory: Materials and supplies 282 282 72 210 25,5% 394 111
Inventory: Medical supplies 6 387 6 387 8 538 (2 151) 133,7% 6 210 7 948
Inventory: Medicine 38 38 3 35 7,9% - 16
Inventory: Other supplies 50 50 5 45 10,0% - 5
Consumable supplies 4 000 4 000 1 890 2 110 47,3% 3 842 1 537
Consumable: Stationery, printing and office supplies 1 000 1 000 1 179 (179) 117,9% 924 1 040
Operating leases - - - - - - -
Property payments 12 500 12 500 12 770 (270) 102,2% 11 827 11 813
Transport provided: Departmental activity - - - - - - -
Travel and subsistence 359 359 144 215 40,1% 338 218
Training and development 636 636 - 636 - 600 79
Operating payments 15 15 8 7 53,3% 37 9
Venues and facilities 500 500 204 296 40,8% 500 363
Transfers and subsidies 637 - - 637 391 246 61,4% 175 952
Households 637 - - 637 391 246 61,4% 175 952
Social benefits 637 637 391 246 61,4% 175 952
Other transfers to households - - - -
Payments for capital assets 7 534 - - 7 534 4 645 2 889 61,7% 7 107 3 422
Machinery and equipment 7 534 - - 7 534 4 645 2 889 61,7% 7 107 3 422
Transport equipment 4 103 4 103 3 256 847 79,4% 3 870 1 081
Other machinery and equipment 3 431 3 431 1 389 2 042 40,5% 3 237 2 341
Payment for financial assets - 59 (59) - - 66
Total 240 133 - - 240 133 225 305 14 828 93,8% 215 243 214 321
Economic classification R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 % R'000 R'000
Inventory: Medical supplies 196 044 196 044 186 563 9 481 95,2% 154 981 176 676
Inventory: Medicine 133 457 (12 000) 121 457 106 119 15 338 87,4% 146 588 146 564
Inventory: Other supplies 19 565 19 565 15 238 4 327 77,9% 24 704 22 463
Consumable supplies 74 412 74 412 55 396 19 016 74,4% 55 762 55 131
Consumable: Stationery, printing and office supplies 23 658 23 658 20 492 3 166 86,6% 20 772 19 470
Operating leases 6 299 6 299 13 227 (6 928) 210,0% 5 424 4 493
Property payments 142 500 142 500 123 963 18 537 87,0% 119 945 119 021
Transport provided: Departmental activity 947 947 10 937 1,1% 977 151
Travel and subsistence 1 206 1 206 563 643 46,7% 1 238 330
Training and development 2 558 2 558 241 2 317 9,4% 2 214 280
Operating payments 885 885 198 687 22,4% 915 126
Rental and hiring - - 445 (445) - - 437
Transfers and subsidies 7 165 - - 7 165 6 750 415 94,2% 6 760 25 862
Households 7 165 - - 7 165 6 750 415 94,2% 6 760 25 862
Social benefits 7 165 7 165 6 671 494 93,1% 6 760 7 246
Other transfers to households - 79 (79) - - 18 616
Payments for capital assets 24 588 - - 24 588 33 928 (9 340) 138,0% 61 144 38 153
Machinery and equipment 24 588 - - 24 588 33 928 (9 340) 138,0% 61 144 38 153
Transport equipment 8 285 8 285 2 915 5 370 35,2% 10 175 4 811
Other machinery and equipment 16 303 16 303 31 013 (14 710) 190,2% 50 969 33 342
Payment for financial assets - 469 (469) - - 597
Total 3 619 882 - (287 000) 3 332 882 3 204 715 128 167 96,2% 2 983 916 3 015 482
Economic classification
Current payments 996 466 - (60 000) 936 466 890 319 46 147 95,1% 759 074 745 181
Compensation of employees 589 627 - - 589 627 552 681 36 946 93,7% 487 200 484 285
Salaries and wages 491 415 - - 491 415 462 344 29 071 94,1% 402 814 402 683
Social contributions 98 212 - - 98 212 90 337 7 875 92,0% 84 386 81 602
Goods and services 406 839 - (60 000) 346 839 333 258 13 581 96,1% 271 874 260 896
Administrative fees 2 412 - - 2 412 1 608 804 66,7% 2 811 1 600
Advertising 1 500 - - 1 500 8 1 492 0,5% - -
Minor assets 8 610 - - 8 610 301 8 309 3,5% 5 010 2 074
Catering: Departmental activities 50 - - 50 16 34 32,0% 71 70
Communication (G&S) 6 934 - - 6 934 2 581 4 353 37,2% 2 434 2 342
Computer services 512 - - 512 - 512 - 504 52
Legal services 1 800 - - 1 800 110 1 690 6,1% - 146
Contractors 10 534 - - 10 534 21 250 (10 716) 201,7% 4 234 2 095
Agency and support / outsourced services 1 028 - - 1 028 412 616 40,1% 1 228 983
Fleet services (including government motor transport) 267 037 - (60 000) 207 037 213 478 (6 441) 103,1% 176 012 179 728
Inventory: Clothing material and accessories - - - - 347 (347) - - 37
Inventory: Food and food supplies 15 - - 15 4 11 26,7% 15 6
Inventory: Materials and supplies 546 - - 546 126 420 23,1% 2 212 28
Inventory: Medical supplies 20 844 - - 20 844 43 615 (22 771) 209,2% 24 526 20 911
Inventory: Medicine 1 150 - - 1 150 (8 455) 9 605 (735,2%) 588 393
Economic classification
Current payments 8 888 596 - (284 000) 8 604 596 8 578 867 25 729 99,7% 7 606 857 7 667 767
Compensation of employees 6 446 669 - (8 000) 6 438 669 6 244 388 194 281 97,0% 5 824 757 5 812 575
Salaries and wages 5 630 733 - (8 000) 5 622 733 5 512 747 109 986 98,0% 5 182 517 5 128 045
Social contributions 815 936 - - 815 936 731 641 84 295 89,7% 642 240 684 530
Goods and services 2 441 927 - (276 000) 2 165 927 2 334 479 (168 552) 107,8% 1 782 100 1 855 192
Administrative fees 152 - - 152 109 43 71,7% 172 172
Advertising 7 - - 7 10 (3) 142,9% 284 28
Minor assets 13 254 - - 13 254 3 539 9 715 26,7% 12 553 4 094
Catering: Departmental activities 160 - - 160 13 147 8,1% 158 2
Communication (G&S) 12 551 - - 12 551 5 871 6 680 46,8% 12 363 9 832
Computer services 583 - - 583 1 190 (607) 204,1% 660 144
Consultants: Business and advisory services 112 098 - - 112 098 247 967 (135 869) 221,2% 7 640 182 551
Laboratory services 376 952 - (150 000) 226 952 239 135 (12 183) 105,4% 203 107 117 559
Legal services - - - - - - - - 12 025
Economic classification
Current payments 15 815 866 - 317 000 16 132 866 16 458 011 -325 145 102.0% 14 471 001 14 633 592
Compensation of employees 10 657 379 - - 10 657 379 10 956 631 -299 252 102.8% 10 194 649 10 319 570
Salaries and wages 9 188 411 - - 9 188 411 9 798 744 -610 333 106.6% 8 931 433 9 224 717
Social contributions 1 468 968 - - 1 468 968 1 157 887 311 081 78.8% 1 263 216 1 094 853
Goods and services 5 158 487 - 317 000 5 475 487 5 498 014 -22 527 100.4% 4 276 352 4 314 022
Administrative fees 162 - - 162 68 94 42.0% 158 54
Advertising 445 - - 445 134 311 30.1% 800 558
Minor assets 49 633 - - 49 633 6 571 43 062 13.2% 50 822 10 429
Catering: Departmental activities 45 - - 45 19 26 42.2% 64 28
Communication (G&S) 16 018 - - 16 018 16 596 -578 103.6% 17 734 19 671
Computer services 10 077 - - 10 077 974 9 103 9.7% 10 097 2 881
Consultants: Business and advisory services 613 - - 613 89 524 14.5% 97 150 82 166
Laboratory services 982 830 - - 982 830 942 560 40 270 95.9% 581 769 577 214
Scientific and technological services - - - - - - - - -
Legal services - - - - 288 -288 - - 165 194
Contractors 169 411 - - 169 411 239 720 -70 309 141.5% 169 286 148 734
Agency and support / outsourced services 102 411 - - 102 411 129 999 -27 588 126.9% 139 848 118 229
Entertainment - - - - - - - - -
Fleet services (including government motor transport) 6 003 - - 6 003 6 348 -345 105.7% 6 025 6 826
Inventory: Clothing material and accessories - - - - 51 -51 - - 6
Inventory: Food and food supplies 147 304 - - 147 304 126 457 20 847 85.8% 142 863 123 287
Inventory: Fuel, oil and gas 76 248 - - 76 248 62 078 14 170 81.4% 43 494 47 046
Inventory: Learner and teacher support material - - - - - - - - 34
Inventory: Materials and supplies 13 067 - - 13 067 16 762 -3 695 128.3% 11 698 14 371
Inventory: Medical supplies 1 609 630 - 317 000 1 926 630 2 374 133 -447 503 123.2% 1 421 051 1 597 376
Inventory: Medicine 1 226 744 - - 1 226 744 799 743 427 001 65.2% 843 786 676 246
Inventory: Other supplies 59 977 - - 59 977 64 025 -4 048 106.7% 64 932 43 213
Consumable supplies 183 445 - - 183 445 231 276 -47 831 126.1% 178 062 188 469
Economic classification R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 % R'000 R'000
Consumable supplies 54 175 54 175 74 016 (19 841) 136,6% 55 771 40 428
Consumable: Stationery, printing and office supplies 25 745 25 745 34 308 (8 563) 133,3% 24 388 21 135
Operating leases 4 550 4 550 7 227 (2 677) 158,8% 2 796 3 488
Property payments 102 010 102 010 101 011 999 99,0% 106 446 107 300
Transport provided: Departmental activity 40 40 5 35 12,5% 1 060 4
Travel and subsistence 165 165 123 42 74,5% 602 101
Training and development 255 255 209 46 82,0% 1 348 1 734
Operating payments 185 185 612 (427) 330,8% 1 270 769
Transfers and subsidies 12 190 - - 12 190 8 969 3 221 73,6% 11 500 20 526
Households 12 190 - - 12 190 8 969 3 221 73,6% 11 500 20 526
Social benefits 12 190 12 190 8 969 3 221 73,6% 11 500 9 071
Other transfers to households - - - - 11 455
Payments for capital assets 152 834 - - 152 834 121 197 31 637 79,3% 136 183 94 241
Machinery and equipment 152 834 - - 152 834 121 197 31 637 79,3% 136 183 94 241
Transport equipment 2 862 2 862 222 2 640 7,8% 2 700 2 419
Other machinery and equipment 149 972 149 972 120 975 28 997 80,7% 133 483 91 822
Payment for financial assets - 213 (213) - - 122
Total 3 783 429 - 132 000 3 915 429 3 915 435 (6) 100,0% 3 493 060 3 329 921
Economic classification R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 % R'000 R'000
Economic classification R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 R'000 % R'000 R'000
Economic classification
Current payments 302 581 - 27 000 329 581 337 043 (7 462) 102,3% 281 817 284 106
Compensation of employees 180 597 - 8 000 188 597 182 146 6 451 96,6% 168 354 162 379
Salaries and wages 154 643 - - 154 643 149 883 4 760 96,9% 138 286 132 097
Social contributions 25 954 - 8 000 33 954 32 263 1 691 95,0% 30 068 30 282
Goods and services 121 984 - 19 000 140 984 154 897 (13 913) 109,9% 113 463 121 727
Minor assets 61 - - 61 13 48 21,3% 457 42
Communication (G&S) 409 - - 409 389 20 95,1% 809 449
Contractors 98 - - 98 40 58 40,8% 371 14
Agency and support / outsourced services 382 - - 382 446 (64) 116,8% 43 1
Fleet services (including government motor transport) 2 481 - - 2 481 2 597 (116) 104,7% 306 2 609
Inventory: Clothing material and accessories - - - - 736 (736) - - 579
Inventory: Food and food supplies 28 020 - - 28 020 25 084 2 936 89,5% 27 230 25 729
Inventory: Fuel, oil and gas 22 115 - 8 000 30 115 31 701 (1 586) 105,3% 2 083 9 761
1. a Detail of transfers and subsidies as per Appropriation Act 3. Detail on payments for financial assets
(after Virement):
Detail of these transactions per programme can be viewed in the
Detail of these transactions can be viewed in the note on Transfers note on Payments for financial assets to the Annual Financial
and subsidies, disclosure notes and Annexures (1-7) to the Annual Statements.
Financial Statements.
4. Explanations of material variances from Amounts Voted
2. Detail of specifically and exclusively appropriated amounts (after Virement):
voted (after Virement):
District Health Services 15 073 917 14 516 480 557 437 3.7%
Health Sciences & Training 1 123 296 1 106 708 16 588 1.5%
Health Care Support Services 339 156 339 048 108 0.0%
Under expenditure was due to delays in the creation of posts and in payment of
District Health Services
the National Health Laboratory Services (NHLS) account. Underspending on the
HIV and AIDS grant also contributed to the Programme underspending. All
under spent funds have been committed. The Department has applied for
rollovers.
Emergency Medical Services Under expenditure was due to delays in the creation of posts. All underspent
resources have been committed. The Department has applied for rollovers.
Current payments
Buildings and other fixed structures 900 267 785 617 114 650 13%
Machinery and equipment 1 342 920 786 489 556 431 41%
Non-Profit Institutions (NPOs): Non-compliance with the minimum requirements were not met by some of the NPOs resulted in
under-expenditure.
Households: Over-spending in this line item was due payment of Medico Legal claims.
Payment of Capital Assets: Maintenance and Occupational Health & Safety (OHS) projects were prioritized, however, late submission of
invoices by the implementing agent led to underspending within the programme. Machinery and Equipment underspending is due to long
lead times for items that have already been ordered. Delays in procurement processes also contributed to the underspending. The Department
has applied for roll-overs for all unspent funds to reduce accruals.
Comprehensive HIV & AIDS GRANT 4 239 277 3 965 836 273 441 6%
National Tertiary Services Grant 4 390 192 4 137 621 252 571 6%
Health PROF Training & DEV Grant 983 712 947 885 35 527 4%
Health Facility REVIT Grant 892 084 779 939 112 145 13%
NATIONAL TERTIARY SERVICES GRANT The Department has submitted a roll-over application to the value of
The Department incurred the commitments to the value of R252.6 R5.6 million.
million as at 31 March 2019, this is due to the nature of medical
equipment procurement processes as some the items are sourced
internationally. The
REVENUE
EXPENDITURE
Current Expenditure
Compensation of Employees 3 26 902 298 25 085
331
Goods and Services 4 229 501 13 583 391
Interest and Rent on Land 5 7 794 628
ASSETS
Current liabilities
Non-Current liabilities - -
Represented by:
Capitalisation Reserve 54 000 54 000
Recoverable Revenue 79 423 50 936
Capitalisation Reserves
Opening balance 54 000 54 000
Closing balance 54 000 54 000
Recoverable revenue
Opening balance 50 936 34 746
Transfers: 28 487 16 190
Debts recovered 628 1 694
Debts raised 27 859 14 496
Closing balance 79 423 50 936
The amount of R54.0 million is the initial capital investment in Medical Supplies Depot (MSD). No additional investment was made during the
period.
Receipts
Annual Appropriated funds received 1.1 47 543 133 42 739 750
Departmental Revenue Received 2 46 762 330 42 192 834
Interest received 2 780 039 545 942
764 974
Net (increase)/decrease in working capital (78 924) (8 140)
Surrendered to Revenue Fund (1 080 517) (768 070)
Current Payments (42 131 799) (38 668 722)
Net increase/(decrease) in cash and cash equivalents 401 619 (33 729)
Cash and cash equivalents at beginning of period 283 773 317 502
Cash and cash equivalents at end of period 16 685 392 283 773
Where appropriate and meaningful, additional information has been disclosed to enhance the usefulness of the financial statements
and to comply with the statutory requirements of the Public Finance Management Act (PFMA), Act 1 of 1999 (as amended by Act 29
of 1999), and the Treasury Regulations issued in terms of the PFMA and the annual Division of Revenue Act.
1 Basis of preparation
The financial statements have been prepared in accordance with the Modified Cash Standard.
2 Going concern
The financial statements have been prepared on a going concern basis.
3 Presentation currency
Amounts have been presented in the currency of the South African Rand (R) which is also the functional currency of the
Department.
4 Rounding
Unless otherwise stated financial figures have been rounded to the nearest one thousand Rand (R’000).
5 Comparative information
6 Revenue
7 Expenditure
7.4 Leases
10 Investments
Investments are recognised in the statement of financial position at cost.
11 Financial assets
13 Payables
Payables recognised in the statement of financial position are recognised at cost.
14 Capital Assets
15.1 Provisions
Provisions are recorded in the notes to the financial statements when there is a present legal or constructive obligation to forfeit
economic benefits as a result of events in the past and it is probable that an outflow of resources embodying economic benefits
or service potential will be required to settle the obligation and a reliable estimate of the obligation can be made. The provision
is measured as the best estimate of the funds required to settle the present obligation at the reporting date.
15.4 Commitments
Commitments (other than for transfers and subsidies) are recorded at cost in the notes to the financial statements when there
is a contractual arrangement or an approval by management in a manner that raises a valid expectation that the Department
will discharge its responsibilities thereby incurring future expenditure that will result in the outflow of cash.
16 Unauthorised expenditure
Unauthorised expenditure is recognised in the statement of financial position until such time as the expenditure is either:
• approved by Parliament or the Provincial Legislature with funding and the related funds are received; or
• approved by Parliament or the Provincial Legislature without funding and is written off against the appropriation in the
statement of financial performance; or
• transferred to receivables for recovery.
Unauthorised expenditure is measured at the amount of the confirmed unauthorised expenditure.
18 Irregular expenditure
Irregular expenditure is recorded in the notes to the financial statements when confirmed. The amount recorded is equal to
the value of the irregular expenditure incurred unless it is impracticable to determine, in which case reasons therefor are
provided in the note.
Irregular expenditure is removed from the note when it is either condoned by the relevant authority, transferred to receivables
for recovery or not condoned and is not recoverable.
Irregular expenditure receivables are measured at the amount that is expected to be recoverable and are de-recognised when
settled or subsequently written-off as irrecoverable.
21 Capitalisation reserve
The capitalisation reserve comprises of financial assets and/or liabilities originating in a prior reporting period but which are
recognised in the statement of financial position for the first time in the current reporting period. Amounts are recognised in
the capitalisation reserves when identified in the current period and are transferred to the National/Provincial Revenue Fund
when the underlying asset is disposed and the related funds are received.
22 Recoverable revenue
Amounts are recognised as recoverable revenue when a payment made in a previous financial year becomes recoverable from
a debtor in the current financial year. Amounts are either transferred to the National/Provincial Revenue Fund when
recovered or are transferred to the statement of financial performance when written-off.
24 Inventories
At the date of acquisition, inventories are recognised at cost in the statement of financial performance.
Where inventories are acquired as part of a non-exchange transaction, the inventories are measured at fair value as at the
date of acquisition.
Inventories are subsequently measured at the lower of cost and net realisable value or where intended for distribution (or
consumed in the production of goods for distribution) at no or a nominal charge, the lower of cost and current replacement
value.
The cost of inventories is assigned by using the weighted average cost basis.
25 Employee benefits
The value of each major class of employee benefit obligation (accruals, payables not recognised and provisions) is disclosed in
the Employee benefits note.
1. Annual Appropriation
1.1 Annual Appropriation
Included are funds appropriated in terms of the Appropriation Act (and the Adjustments Appropriation Act) for National
Departments (Voted funds) and Provincial Departments
2018/19 2017/18
Final Actual Funds Funds not Final Appropriation
Appropriation Received requested/not Appropriation received
received
R’000 R’000 R’000 R’000 R’000
1. Administration 1 361 130 1 361 130 - 1 085 267 1 085 267
2.District Health Services 15 073 917 15 073 917 - 13 712 101 13 712 101
3.Emergency Medical Services 1 423 203 1 423 203 - 1 268 154 1 268 154
4.Provincial Hospital Services 8 746 469 8 746 469 - 7 892 663 7 892 663
5.Central Hospitals 17 135 226 17 135 226 - 15 333 041 15 333 041
6. Health Science and Training 1 123 296 1 123 296 - 928 471 928 471
7. Health Care Support Services 339 156 339 156 - 289 838 289 838
8. Health Facilities Management 1 559 933 1 559 933 - 1 683 299 1 683 299
2. Departmental Revenue
Sales of Goods and Services include patient fees charged according to the 2018 gazetted Uniform Patient Fee Schedule (UPFS) tariffs. During the period,
the Department exceeded its revenue collection target by R273.8 million.
Sales of scrap, waste and other used current goods 1 442 2 217
“Other sales” include sales of crutches, access cards, boarding of staff, advertisements, immunisation fees, patient transport and special events for EMS.
The increase of 29% in other sales is due to amplified efforts by the Department to increase revenue collection.
Total 95 48
Fines and penalties are charged in respect of illegal parking at the Department’s facilities. The increased collection is due to revised parking tariffs and
the establishment of parking committees.
3. Compensation of Employees
3.1 Salaries and Wages
The overall increase of 7% is due to the annual cost of living adjustment (COLA) during the period under review. The R675.8 million increase in
performance award is due to payment of performance bonuses in June 2018 and December 2018.
Other Non-Pensionable Allowances: Amounts disclosed under this line item represents amongst others service bonus and housing allowances.
Compensative/ circumstantial: The amounts disclosed under this line item represents overtime paid to Health Professionals.
Periodic payments: These are payments made to retired doctors, session doctors and employees being paid a once off salary related payment.
“External Computer Service Providers” include software licences for operating systems and specialized computer services. The decrease in expenditure
was due to withholding of payments of ICT projects which were under investigation.
Investigations 13 -
“Investigations” relate to payments made for investigations done by the Special Investigation Unit (SIU).
4.4 Inventory
Other supplies consist of toiletries, plastics, paper and related items. The 18% increase in expenditure is due to an increase of demand in health care
services as well as higher inflation on medical supplies.
4.5 Consumables
The increase in expenditure is due to higher medical inflation and increased demand on the service platform.
Household supplies: Includes linen, groceries and cleaning detergents.
Other consumables: Includes fuel supplies, gas supplies, laboratory consumables and medical kits.
The amount disclosed under other includes security services, cleaning and payments of laundry services.
The expenditure in foreign travel decreased by 63% due to austerity measures (iron clad) put in place to curb expenditure.
The amount disclosed under other includes security services, cleaning and payments of laundry services.
The increase in interest paid amount is as a result of interest paid which was misallocated in the 2017/18 financial year. A major portion of interest paid
is due to interest charged on court judgements for medico legal claims. Total interest paid for the 2018/19 financial year is R25.7 million.
This amount represents staff and supplier debts that was written off during the year. Debts was written off in accordance with the Department’s policy
and the Prescription Act. All possible measures were taken to ensure that all debt due to the Department is recovered.
Finance lease expenditure relates to rental of cell phones, Government Garage vehicles as well as photocopiers.
10. Receivables
2018/19 2017/18
Note Current Non-current Total Current Non-current 2017/18
9 R’000 R’000 R’000 R’000 R’000 R’000
Claims recoverable 10.1 1 511 - 1 511 552 - 552
Staff debt 10.3 16 949 88 962 105 911 15 690 61 654 77 344
Total 22 352 88 962 111 314 154 889 61 654 216 543
Claims Recoverable include amounts owed by other Departments due to staff transfers.
The disallowance damages & losses represents thefts and losses that are under investigation
Fraud 132 20
Garnishee 2 -
Medical Aid 13 -
Staff debtors older than three years are impaired as the likelihood of recoverability is low.
11. Investments
The investments amount represents the initial investment in Medical Supplies Depot, no further investment was made during the period.
The Department is engaging Provincial Treasury to resolve the R135.6 million amount which is included in “Paid during the year”. This amount is as a
result of previous years’ unauthorized expenditure surrenders and the disclosure of Health and Welfare Sector Training Authority funding in the Revenue
Fund.
The “Unauthorized expenditure” of R12.9 million is disclosed as a result of an unresolved condonation from previous years’ unauthorized expenditure.
The Department is engaging Provincial Treasury to resolve the matter.
Add back non cash/cash movements not deemed operating activities 412 666 699 898
Net cash flow generated by operating activities 1 945 239 1 426 189
The “Unauthorized expenditure” of R12.9 million is disclosed as a result of an unresolved condonation from previous years’ unauthorized expenditure.
The Department is engaging Provincial Treasury to resolve the matter.
16. Reconciliation of cash and cash equivalents for cash flow purposes
Claims against the Department include medico legal and civil claims and claims against state vehicle accidents. Claims against the Department are
classified as contingent liabilities in line with Chapter 14, paragraph 04 of the Modified Cash Standard which defines a contingent liability as a possible
obligation that arises from past events, and whose existence will be confirmed only by the occurrence or non-occurrence of one or more uncertain future
events not wholly within the control of the Department. The Department has appointed the Special Investigation Unit (SIU) to assist with investigating
medico legal related claims, with the aim of eliminating fraudulent claims.
18. Commitments
Capital expenditure
Included in the total commitments are commitments amounting to R1.9 billion which exceeding one year.
2018/19 2017/18
R’000 R’000
Included in the above totals are the following: 30 Days 30+ Days Total Total
Sales of goods and services other than capital assets 55 653 442 232 497 885 227 317
Total 55 653 442 232 497 885 227 317
2018/19 2017/18
R’000 R’000
Listed by economic classification 30 Days 30+ Days Total Total
Goods and services 1 488 661 2 851 662 4 340 323 6 516 019
Confirmed balances with other government entities 754 543 1 156 892
Current year lease commitments for Buildings and Other Fixtures mainly relate to leases that will expire within the next two to five years.
Patient debt is written off where the cost to recover the outstanding debt is assessed to exceed the debt owed. The Department will be investing in
upgrading the ICT infrastructure to assist with patient traceability which will improve revenue collection.
The amount that has been impaired against accrued Departmental revenue relates to patient debts and is according to the Department’s Policy.
Add: Irregular expenditure – relating to prior year 570 088 351 001
Add: Irregular expenditure – relating to current year 2 292 068 1 352 204
Consignment Disciplinary steps finalized, Tender process at an advanced stage. 226 938
Stock condonation to be applied for.
Security Disciplinary steps finalized, Security In-Sourcing strategy to be fully 587 979
Contracts condonation to be applied for. implemented by end of the 2019/20 financial year.
Outsourced Disciplinary steps finalized, Tender to be advertised before end of the second 35 499
Nursing Staff condonation to be applied for. quarter.
Overtime 2000 Critical Posts have been Posts are being advertised. 323
exceeding 30% approved.
Supply Chain Training and up skilling of officials is Stringent monitoring of compliance. 1 268 698
Processes not being implemented.
Followed
Conditional Disciplinary steps finalized, Business plans sent to National Health 236 909
Grants not condonation to be applied for
utilised as per
business plan
A forensic investigation was done which found that the process of procuring V-Blocks IT infrastructure was irregular. Persons implicated have been
reported to the National Directorate of Public Prosecutions for investigations.
24.3 Analysis of Current year’s (relating to current and prior years) fruitless and wasteful expenditure
2018/19
Incident Disciplinary steps taken/criminal proceedings
R’000
Interest on Litigations Corrective measures are being implemented. 12 334
Interest paid by DID for Health Corrective measures are being implemented. 2 245
Total 26 682
The Department is in the process of condoning the Fruitless and Wasteful expenditure that has accumulated over the years. Processes have been put in
place to reduce interest payable to Suppliers.
Medical Supplies Depot (MSD) is a related party to the Department. MSD is an entity of the Department and is accountable to the same Accounting
Officer. All other Gauteng Provincial Government Departments’ are related parties to the Department, by virtue of being under the control of Gauteng
Provincial Government Legislature.
Key management include all staff members who drive the strategy of the department. Employees who are on level 14 but are not driving the
Departmental strategy are not included in this list.
27. Provisions
Furniture and office equipment 160 547 - 5 254 (714) 165 087
Other machinery and equipment 4 884 219 - 611 864 (35 935) 5 460 148
TOTAL MOVABLE TANGIBLE CAPITAL ASSETS 5 826 424 - 760 151 (37 763) 6 548 812
2 268 Movable Tangible Capital Assets under Investigation included in the Assets Register 38 429
Machinery and equipment include assets which are under investigation due to the damage from the fire which occurred during the year.
28.1 Additions
ADDITIONS TO MOVABLE TANGIBLE CAPITAL ASSETS PER ASSET REGISTER FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 MARCH 2019
Other machinery and equipment 630 097 395 (22 581) 3 953 611 864
TOTAL MOVABLE TANGIBLE CAPITAL ASSETS 786 489 11 448 (75 776) 37 990 760 151
28.2 Disposals
DISPOSALS OF MOVABLE TANGIBLE CAPITAL ASSETS PER ASSET REGISTER FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 MARCH 2019
Transport assets -
The value of assets sold for cash is include in the Department’s Revenue collected under sales of scrap.
Furniture and office equipment 149 853 - 14 386 (3 692) 160 547
Other machinery and equipment 4 400 816 - 591 618 (108 215) 4 884 219
TOTAL MOVABLE TANGIBLE CAPITAL ASSETS 5 227 033 - 720 248 (120 857) 5 826 424
Machinery
and equipment
2017/18
R’000 R’000
Opening balance 701 503 701 503
7 315 Minor Capital Assets under Investigations included in the Asset Register 12 538
MOVEMENT IN MINOR ASSETS PER THE ASSET REGISTER FOR THE YEAR ENDED AS AT 31 MARCH 2018
Machinery
and equipment
2017/18
R’000 R’000
Opening balance 695 636 695 636
2017/18
R’000
Overstatement of Intangible Assets
*The opening balance had to be amended as items that do not meet the definition of Intangible Assets were capitalised.
TOTAL IMMOVABLE TANGIBLE CAPITAL ASSETS 1 632 824 608 272 2 241 096
4 projects were completed in the current financial year and 13 in the previous financial years. These projects are due to be transferred to the Gauteng Department
of Infrastructure Development after all certification has been completed.
30.1 Additions
(Capital Work in
Progress current
costs and
finance lease
Cash Non- Cash payments) Total
Other fixed structures 770 532 608 272 (770 532) 608 272
TOTAL ADDITIONS TO IMMOVABLE 770 532 608 272 (770 532) 608 272
*The difference between the amount above and R786.4 million is due to lease payments which were incorrectly allocated.
TOTAL IMMOVABLE TANGIBLE CAPITAL ASSETS 70 949 1 561 875 1 632 824
R’000
The opening balance was adjusted by R255.6 million after a clean-up of the asset register was performed by the Department.
2018/19
Age analysis on ongoing projects R’000
0 to 1 Year 95 871
1 to 3 Years 422 159
3 to 5 Years 604 752
Longer than 5 Years 1 345 778
Total 2 468 560
Opening balance Prior Year Current Ready for use Closing balance
1 April 2017 adjustments Year WIP (Assets to the AR) 31 March 2018
R’000 R’000 R’000 R’000 R’000
Buildings and other fixed structures 3 599 029 (434 308) 703 454 1 561 875 2 306 300
TOTAL 3 599 029 (434 308) 703 454 1 561 875 2 306 300
In the annual report of 2017/18, a printing error occurred, and a closing balance was recorded as 2 470 608 instead of 2 740 608. This error has since
been corrected.
The opening balance had to be amended as items that do not meet the definition of Immovable Assets were capitalised.
2017/18
Age analysis on ongoing projects R’000
0 to 1 Year 345 618
1 to 3 Years 209 030
3 to 5 Years 547 241
Longer than 5 Years 1 204 411
Total 2 306 300
R’000
Division of
Revenue Act/ Roll Total Amount received Amount spent by Under / % of available funds Division of Amount spent
Provincial Grants Overs Available by Department Department (Overspending) spent by Department Revenue Act by Department
R’000 R’000 R’000 R’000 R'000 R'000 % R’000 R’000
Total 10 508 176 28 195 10 536 371 10 536 371 9 856 515 679 856 - 9 755 787 9 602 229
City of Johannesburg Metro 272 638 9 420 282 058 282 061 -
City of Tshwane Metro 165 563 (60 833) 104 730 104 680 -
ANNEXURE 1A
STATEMENT OF CONDITIONAL GRANTS AND OTHER TRANSFERS PAID TO MUNICIPALITIES (Unaudited Annexure)
Re-allocations % of
by National Amount available
DoRA and Treasury or received Amount funds Division
other Roll Total Actual Funds National by spent by Unspent spent by of Revenue Actual
transfers Overs Adjustments Available Transfer Withheld Department municipality municipality funds municipality Act transfer
NAME OF MUNICIPALITY R’000 R’000 R’000 R’000 R’000 R’000 R’000 R’000 R’000 R’000 R’000 R’000 R’000
Category A
City of Johannesburg Metro 128 726 128 726 128 726 121 669 121 669
City of Tshwane Metro 49 837 49 837 49 837 46 541 46 541
Ekurhuleni Metro 137 900 137 900 137 900 130 340 130 340
HIV AND AIDS
Category A
Category A
City of Johannesburg Metro 130 332 130 332 130 332 123 187 123 187
City of Tshwane Metro 102 135 40 854 40 854 95 993 95 993
Ekurhuleni Metro 167 328 (61 281) 167 328 167 328 158 155 158 155
Category C
TOTAL 783 270 (61 281) 721 989 721 992 739 104 739 104
ANNEXURE 1B
STATEMENT OF TRANSFERS TO DEPARTMENTAL AGENCIES AND ACCOUNTS (Unaudited Annexure)
% of Final
Adjusted Roll Total Actual Available funds
Appropriation Overs Adjustments Appropriation
Available Transfer Transferred
DEPARTMENTAL AGENCY/ ACCOUNT R’000 R’000 R’000 R’000 R’000 % R’000
Health and Welfare Seta (HW-SETA) 20 962 - 20 962 20 962 20 962 100% 19 812
ANNEXURE 1C
STATEMENT OF TRANSFERS TO HIGHER EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS (Unaudited Annexure)
% of
Adjusted Roll Total Actual Amount not Available funds Final
Appropriation Overs Adjustments Available Transfer transferred Transferred Appropriation
R’000 R’000 R’000 R’000 R’000 R’000 % R’000
Sefako Makgatho Health Science University 2 681 - - 2 681 2 702 2 702 -1% 210
Community Based Services (Mental Health NPOs) 191 207 191 207 150 495 79% 224 367
Community Health Clinics (Witkoppen Clinic) 13 308 13 308 13 115 99% 12 578
Community Based Services (EPWP NPOs) 120 511 120 511 120 346 100% 112 791
Nelson Mandela Children’s Hospital 200 000 200 000 200 000 100% 150 000
TOTAL 664 528 - - 664 528 615 281 93% 656 625
Household Employee Benefit: Injury on Duty 9 310 - - 9 310 3 834 41% 15 545
Household Employee Benefit: Leave Gratuity 89 481 - - 89 481 96 979 108% 81 350
Household Bursaries: -
Household Claims against State (Cash) 1 376 - 287 000 288 376 586 543 203% 3 300
TOTAL 248 809 - 287 000 535 809 921 440 172% 185 919
Received in Cash
5 530
Equipment - -
Pharmaceuticals - -
Medico – Legal matters 17 542 371 4 229 890 541 961 - 21 230 300
Civil Claims 1 869 597 135 183 1 310 - 2 003 470
Vehicle Liability 12 348 600 205 - 12 743
Premature termination of contracts 1 508 092 - - - 1 508 092
TOTAL 20 932 408 4 365 673 543 476 - 24 754 605
ANNEXURE 4
CLAIMS RECOVERABLE
Department
ANNEXURE 4
CLAIMS RECOVERABLE
Mpumalanga Department of Health & Social Services (Patient fees) - - 26 759 20 862 26 759 20 862
South African Police Services (Patient fees) - - 17 811 11 216 17 811 11 216
Limpopo Department of Health and Social Development (Patient fees) - - 26 748 21 809 26 748 21 809
North West Department of Health and Social Development (Patient fees) - - 62 995 55 753 62 995 55 753
Gauteng Provincial Treasury (Provincial Revenue Fund) - - - 135 609 - 135 609
TOTAL 1 061 29 194 521 280 525 195 582 280 554
ANNEXURE 5
INTER-GOVERNMENT PAYABLES
Department of Justice 101 638 101 499 - - 101 638 101 499
Correctional Services - 37 - - - 37
Department of Defence - - - - - -
Department of Labour - 59 - - - 59
Subtotal 101 693 244 334 - 300 101 693 244 634
ANNEXURE 5
INTER-GOVERNMENT PAYABLES
Current
Medical Supplier Deport 614 687 1 023 222 - - 614 687 1 023 222
G-Fleet 110 194 111 082 - 1 543 111 737 111 082
Subtotal 754 543 1 156 892 - 1 543 556 472 1 156 892
TOTAL 856 236 1 401 226 - 1 543 857 779 1 401 526
ANNEXURE 6
INVENTORIES
Note 2018/19 2017/18
R’000 R’000
Opening balance 981 336 1 148 873
Add/(Less): Received current, not paid (Paid current year, received prior year) - -
- -
Inventory issues increased by 16% compared to the 2017/18 financial period, from R7 067 159 000 to R8 228 071 000. This was a result of increased demand for health care as well as general inflationary increases. Inventory
purchases increased by 18% compared to the 2017/18 financial year in line with the increased demand for health care services provided.
ANNEXURE 7
MOVEMENT IN CAPITAL WORK IN PROGRESS
MOVEMENT IN CAPITAL WORK IN PROGRESS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 MARCH 2019
BUILDINGS AND OTHER FIXED STRUCTURES 2 306 300 770 532 (608 272) 2 468 560
Other fixed structures 2 306 300 770 532 (608 272) 2 468 560
ANNEXURE 7
MOVEMENT IN CAPITAL WORK IN PROGRESS
MOVEMENT IN CAPITAL WORK IN PROGRESS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 MARCH 2018
FIXED STRUCTURES 3 599 029 (434 308) 703 454 (1 561 875) 2 306 300
Dwellings
Non-residential buildings
Other fixed structures 3 599 029 (434 308) 703 454 (1 561 875) 2 306 300
TOTAL 3 599 029 (434 308) 703 454 (1 561 875) 2 306 300
The Accounting Officer of the Gauteng Department of Health (the Prior to MSD online, the depot had to fax or email or physically
Department) hereby submits the annual report for the Gauteng deliver the copy of the orders to the demanders for them to be able
Medical Supplies Depot, to the Executive Authority of the Gauteng to receive stock from the suppliers but since the introduction of MSD
Department of Health, and the Gauteng Provincial Legislature of the online, demanders are now able to see their orders on MSD online.
Republic of South Africa. Prior to MSD online, suppliers had to deliver their payment packs at
the depot so that they can be paid on time but with the introduction
1. General review of the state of affairs of MSD online, suppliers can now
The Medical Supplies Depot (the Depot) operating as a trading entity
of the department is responsible for the supply of essential Significant events that have taken place during the year (Continued)
medicines to Provincial Health institutions and facilities in Gauteng.
In this regard, a levy of 5% is charged on stock issued to the upload their payment packs on MSD online and their payment can
Provincial Health Care Facilities. be effected timeously and if they did not submit all the required
documents, their payment pack will be rejected and the reason for
Essential medicines are procured on contract or quotations and their rejection will be indicated so that they are able to correct and
either store these items at the Depot or orders are placed with submit the correct documentation.
suppliers on behalf of institutions for direct delivery to the various
institutions. Accurate usage of items, as well as money spent by The introduction of the MSD online system improved the payment of
hospitals, can be obtained from the Medical Stock Administration supplier invoices to an extent that in Q3, an average of 98% of
System (MEDSAS). The Economic Order Quantity (EOQ) together supplier invoices were paid within thirty (30) days. Maintenance of
with the First-Expiry-First-Out, (FEFO) system is applied to ensure that the system could not be guaranteed in Q4. Thus, MSD had to
correct stock levels are maintained. partially revert back to the manual document management system
resulting in a reduction of the percentage of suppliers paid within
The Depot prepares financial statements for each financial year in thirty (30) days
accordance with the prescribed practice (Statements of South
African Generally Recognised Accounting Practice- GRAP). The
financial statements are prepared and reported on accordingly. MEDSAS
MEDSAS has given early warnings that its life span will soon come to
The Medical Supplies Depot has a re-packing function, where bulk an end. After crashing in January 2018, the depot has also
medicine is repacked into patient ready packs. The re-packing experienced a few limitations including its inability to allow
expenses are recovered from the normal levy charged. Managers for monitoring antivirus and security patch updates on the MEDSAS
each cost centre were identified and procedures to ensure the servers and end-user workstation environments since Microsoft does
completeness of stock requisitioning and receiving were designed. not support the operating system.
The various cost centre costs are consolidated at finance and reports
are timeously provided to cost centre managers for their use and This could lead to viruses not being effectively detected in the
provide a basis for comparison, monitoring and review purposes. environment. Malware could result in unauthorised access to data
and information resulting in unauthorised activity and possible
1.1 Significant events that have taken place during the year incorrect financial reporting. This could also result in systems being
MSD Online unavailable, due to malfunction, which can impact productivity of
end users and ultimately affect service delivery.
The MSD Online was introduced in April 2017 which assists in the
tracking of orders that have been placed by the depot on behalf of To circumvent this potential risk, management is in the process of
health institutions for their direct delivery orders. implementing a new inventory management system with at least the
following functionalities:
Prior to MSD online, orders had to be manually signed by the • Demand management;
relevant pharmacists and now orders are being signed electronically • Ordering;
and sent off electronically to the supplier and the supplier accepts • Warehousing;
the order on their end as proof of acknowledgement of the order by • Issuing, and
the supplier. • Payment of suppliers
Implementation of new Monitoring and Evaluation document for A summary of major spending trends indicates that medicine prices
the different units in the depot increased at a rate higher than the consumer price index (CPI). This
has the effect that revenue increases at a higher rate and has a
The monitoring and evaluation unit has developed a document for favourable influence on the net profit of the Depot. Cost
the management of the different units in the depot with workplans containment measures and increased demand from healthcare
and targets set to ensure that the depot achieves targets on the providers were also responsible for the improved net profit.
KPI’s. The workplans are monitored on a monthly basis and that is
why the depot was able to achieve all targets on the KPI’s in the
operational plan.
Spending Trends
The Universal Test and Treat Campaign that started in September reported to the South African Health Products Regulatory Authority
2016 was a driving force behind the increase in Revenue which saw for further management. Other Provincial Medicine Depots are
more orders for medical supplies being placed with the depot during alerted through the Affordable Medicines Unit at the National
the financial year. Department of Health.
communicated to other provinces.
Personnel expenses increased due to annual salary increases as well
as more scarce skills / Occupation Specific Dispensation (OSD) posts Tariff policy
on the staff establishment being filled. The tariff policy for the trading account was approved on 1 April
1992 as per the Exchequer Act, Act No. 66 of 1975. Approval was
General Expenditure was slightly higher in the 2018/2019 financial granted for a five percent (5%) levy on the average carrying value of
year when compared to the prior year. This is mainly due to the stock issued to customer hospitals.
increase in distribution costs (R1.8m) and increase in expenditure on
repairs and maintenance (R0.6m). Free Service
The Depot does not provide any free service. The quality control of
2. Services rendered the medicines performed by the laboratory on site is part of the
The Medical Supplies Depot is responsible for the effective and administrative expenses of the Depot, which are recovered as part of
efficient procurement, quality testing, warehousing and distribution the five percent levy charge.
of essential medicines to all the Provincial Health Care Facilities in
Gauteng. The Depot ensures that Essential Medicine List (EML) 3. Capacity constraints
medicines are available to our clients at all times. This involves the The Medical Supplies Depot delivers a vital service to all the Health
evaluation of samples for tender purposes, participation in tender Care Institutions in Gauteng.
adjudication meetings, procurement and distribution of these items,
as well as quality control of medicines distributed to our institutions. As at the end of the year under review the Medical Supplies Depot
had 266 posts on the approved staff establishment, with 75 vacant.
Quality control is carried out in a fully equipped laboratory, where Current year vacancy rate of 28% has a negative impact in terms of
samples are tested from each batch of medicines received. The the depot achieving its objectives.
Depot’s laboratory is the only public sector laboratory in South- This is as a result of a moratorium on the replacement of posts by the
Africa where the findings on quality tests performed are also Department. The Department established a post filling plan
committee. Having submitted a list of its most critical, vacant posts,
MSD was authorised to fill 23 positions in Phase 1 of the process. collated. Information from the following systems is used and
The recruitment process is on-going. involves time-consuming reconciliation procedures to enable
compliance with Statements of SA GRAP for disclosure purposes:
Measures have been taken to strengthen the operations of the
Depot and its management. Despite these challenges nonetheless • Basic Accounting System (BAS)
the depot has managed to put in place compensating measures • Personnel and Salary Administration System (PERSAL)
• Medical Stock Administration System (MEDSAS)
The measures can be demonstrated by two of our key performance • Asset Management System (ASSETWARE)
indicators: • MSDONLINE;
• Manual systems to perform reconciliation procedures and
• KPI 1 “Availability “refers to a situation where stock on hand at accrual based accounting
the depot is sufficient to meet the demand created on MEDSAS
in full, it was measured at 92.32% against a target of 90.00%. 4. Utilisation of donor funds
The Depot received Fluconazole from Pfizer Laboratories for use in
• KPI 2 “Service level” refers to how quickly the MSD takes to the treatment of Oesophageal Candidiasis and Cryptococcal
issue stock in full on MEDSAS. The measurement of this KPI is Meningitis and a further donation of Mebendazole for the
therefore time-based. This KPI ensures that all orders are issued deworming of school children from Janssen Pharmaceutical. This
within 24 hours and the Service level was measured at 85.34% type of donor funding is received on a continuous basis.
against a target of 80.00%.
Please note that the Depot does not account for the economic
Systems for measuring the indicator ‘% of orders supplied to benefit received in the Statement of Financial Performance, as the
institutions on first requests’ were strengthened, and the actual Depot is considered to be only a conduit for hospitals and to control
performance is calculated according to the following definition: ‘If a the receipt of donations for the Department. The donation is
demand/ request (which could consist of multiple different items) is reflected in the financial statements of the Department.
fulfilled 100% within 24 hours, then that order counts towards the
achieving of the target. If even one item is not issued on the system The current market value of donations issued and charged at a value
as part of the request within 24 hours, the order does not count as of one-hundredth of one cent (R0.0001) to all clients of the Depot.
being fulfilled’. This is an extremely high standard to fulfil, but it is The total charge to health institutions for donations received
specific, measurable and time- bound. Also, it holds the Depot to amounted to under R10.
higher standards – meeting orders within 24 hours could have a
life-saving impact at the level of institutions. However, the more
rigorous monitoring system makes it appear that performance is
lower than planned.
A constraint to ensure effective, economical and efficient reporting
exists in that information from various systems needs to be manually
SUSPENSION 50MG/5ML;35ML
180962874 FLUCONAZOLE TABLETS 200MG; 28'S Pfizer Laboratories 12520 R 2785.25 R 34 871 330
R 46 157 337
5. Trading entities
The Medical Supplies Depot operates as a trading entity, known as management has continued to engage with suppliers in a
“The Central Medical Trading Account” since 1 April 1992. The number of ways such as the following:
trading entity acts as a shared supply chain for the procurement and o General meetings with all suppliers - quarterly;
provisioning of pharmaceuticals to the Department’s Health Care o One-on-one-meetings as and when necessary, and
Institutions in Gauteng. o Carrying out supplier satisfaction surveys by way of
suggestion boxes.
Comparative information
A four-year comparative analysis of major accounts is disclosed
• Although it is inevitable not to have expired medicines in a depot
under paragraph 1 above.
environment and where best practices industry estimate as a
benchmark is between 3% and 5% of average stock holding,
6. Organisation to whom transfer payments have been
the Depot adopted a more conservative approach by setting a
made
target not exceeding 2% of the stock holding. This performance
No transfer payment has been made by the Depot in this financial
indicator is reported on to the audit committee quarterly.
year.
9 Discontinued activities
7. Public/Private Partnership (PPP)
No activities were discontinued during the year under review.
No Public Private Partnership has been entered into by the Depot in
this financial year.
10. New/Proposed Activities
The Depot continues to be assisted by the Office of the Chief
The following non-core services have been outsourced to the private
Information Officer (CIO) in the implementation of the possible
sector which consists mostly of Black Economic Empowerment
alternative to the current inventory management systems (MEDSAS)
companies:
which is due for replacement in Q2 of 2019/20.
• Maintenance and support of the MEDSAS computer system; 11. Supply chain management (SCM)
• Distribution of stock to health care institutions; The MSD has a fully-fledged supply chain management system in
• Security of the property and vehicle access control; place including the Pharmaceutical Procurement Committee (PPC)
• Accounting services; with membership comprising of pharmacists, accountants and SCM
• Maintenance, pest control and minor landscaping of the garden personnel. A number of pharmaceutical items are on tenders which
at the Depot; and are administered at national level. The PPC, therefore, only deals
• Cleaning services with procurement sourced from quotations for values not exceeding
R500 000.
8. Corporate governance arrangements
Management has, with the objective of safeguarding the assets of 12. Asset management
the Depot and ensuring high quality of service delivery, prioritised Management is pleased to report that it carried out a full asset
the following areas: verification project on its approximately 6000 moveable assets of
property, plant and equipment (PPE) as required by paragraphs
• The Depot performs an annual strategic risk assessment which is 17.56 – 58 of Generally Recognised Accounting Practice (GRAP) and
followed by quarterly reviews and reporting to the audit in particular GRAP 17. This standard requires an entity to assess the
committee residual values of its PPE at least for each reporting period.
• The Depot has submitted the list of all critical vacant posts to the 13. Inventories
post filling committee for consideration and approval. The valuation method used by the Medical Supplies Depot is the
Implementation of Phase 1 authorised posts once completed moving weighted average method as per the MEDSAS:
will reduce the current vacancy rate at the Depot.
• ICT – Depot is currently considering the replacement of its
current ineffective inventory management system (MEDSAS)
with a new system.
• In an effort to increase Medicines availability, the Depot
Medicine
Closing stock 208 205 999 253 425 024 170 575 222 311 096 708
Medicine
31 March 2019 31 March 2018 31 March 2017 31 March 2016
Description R R R R
Breakages 2 306 7 633 3 288 13 273
Expired stock 1 006 956 1 166 028 2 016 734 2 568 494
The key performance indicators per the strategic plan based on measurable objectives and our actual achievement are reflected in the table
below:
essential medicines Above Continuous monitoring of items that must be moved into
health facilities number of items that are procured through the DDV
(DDVs). system
At a duly constituted sitting for the Gauteng Provincial Legislature held on 03 September 2018, the House adopted the following SCOPA resolutions
relating to the 2017/2018 financial year:
03 Sep Expenditure Management: • Effective and appropriate steps were implemented to try and avoid
2018 Irregular Expenditure irregular expenditure, however, due to the nature of business to ensure
Accounting officer did not always take medicines availability at all healthcare facilities across the province
effective steps to prevent irregular management requested a deviation from BAC which was approved for
expenditure amounting to XJM Consultants and Safranic.
R5 973 944.
• Distribution of Medicines Services-Safranic. This was due to delays in
1. Why were no effective and appropriate supply chain processes which have since been corrected and as such the
steps taken to prevent irregular distribution contract was awarded in January 2018.
expenditure as required by Section
38(1)(c)(ii) of the Public Finance • Financial Services-XJM
Management Act and Treasury Permission for the advertisement of relevant posts to replace the consultants
Regulation 9.1.1? was granted in December 2018. The necessary recruitment processes are
currently underway and are expected to be completed during the
2018/2019 financial year.
03 Sep What investigations have been undertaken Name of Service Type of service Value of Irregular Action Taken
2018 regarding irregular expenditure reported in provider rendered expenditure
2017/2018 financial year and what • Posts have now been made
XJM Consultants Financial services R2,373,721
disciplinary measures have been / will be available. Specifications for
taken against those responsible for irregular adverts have been submitted
to the department
expenditure?
Safranic Distribution of R2,936,22 • A new contract was awarded
effective January 2018 for 3
medicines services
years
03 Sep Considering the numerous turn around • Unavailability of relevant posts to advertise and replace consultants (XJM
2018 strategies actioned in the Entity including Consultants)
setting up the Pharmaceutical Procurement • Delay in the processes leading to the appointment of the service provider
Committee, explain why the irregular (Safranic) medicine distribution.
expenditure recurred? • Delay in the processes leading to the appointment of the service provider
(Fumigation Worx) Cleaning Services
03 Sep What disciplinary steps will be taken against • A new service provider has been appointed for distribution of medicines
2018 the Accounting Officer for non-compliance • A new contract was awarded effective January 2018 for 3 years
with Section 38(1)(c)(ii) of the Public Finance • MSD management has analysed the above 3 categories of irregular
Management Act and Treasury Regulation expenditure. One report is complete and the others are still in progress.
9.1.1?
03 Sep Has the Department developed a strategy to • Please refer to iron clad approach presentation which is included as
2018 address spending on non-essential items? If Annexure A – Presentation
yes, provide the Committee with a copy of
the strategy.
Paragraph 21-22, PG 296 Procurement and • The process of inviting competitive bids had already started and the
03 Sep
Contract Management entity therefore could not afford to have the institution without any
2018
1.Why goods and services with a cleaning services, which would have compromised infection control
transaction value above R500 000 were hence management requested for approval from the Accounting
procured without inviting competitive Officer.
bids and in some instances, deviations
were approved by the Accounting
Officer even though it was practical to
invite competitive bids as prescribed by
Treasury Regulation 16A6.1 and
16A6.4.
03 Sep c. The list should include the name of the Name of Service Type of service Value of Irregular Root cause
provider rendered expenditure
2018 provider and service rendered and the
amount involved. XJM Consultants Financial services R2,373,721 • There was BAC
approval. Please see
attached
Safranic Distribution of R2,936,223 • There was BAC
medicines services approval. Please see
attached
03 Sep d. What is the status quo of the • In both cases, there was a BAC approval for the extension of the
2018 investigations conducted for this contracts.
financial misconduct?
03 Sep e. Provide the Committee with corrective • The matter has been reported to the Risk and Internal Controls Unit and
2018 measures and/or disciplinary steps that are assessing the documentation to determine circumstances around
the MEC will take against the each matter. The outcome of the investigation will determine the action
Accounting Officer for contravening to be taken against the Accounting Officer.
Treasury Regulation 16A.6.1 and
16A.6.4.
a. Why were some quotations awarded to • The points were allocated based on the old PPPFA and not the amended
Bidders based on preference that were PPPFA. The depot was not aware of the amended PPPFA at that time.
not allocated and calculated in We acknowledge the incorrect application of the regulation but it must
accordance with the requirements of be pointed out that no bidder was prejudiced because of the incorrect
the Preferential Procurement Policy application of the regulation.
Framework Act of South 2000 (Act No.
5 of 2000) and its Regulations? • Due to the fact that the correct bidder had been appointed even when
the new regulations were applied, no disciplinary action was taken.
03 Sep What action is being taken to enhance • Middle managers are scheduled to attend a workshop on the 2017
2018 leadership in the department with PPPFA regulations
emphasis on: • The Depot manager is attending a course on Albertina Sisulu Leadership
Course for Health.
b. lack of monitoring controls to ensure • At least 8 officials are scheduled to attend training on various areas
compliance with laws and regulations inclusive of risk management and supply chain/procurement.
• All pharmacists are doing short courses in Continuing Professional
Development.
03 Sep c. Procurement and contract • Please see response in part (a) above
2018 management
03 Sep d. Expenditure management and revenue • The Depot produces monthly management accounts as well as monthly
2018 management. budget vs Expenditure reports in-house hence providing on-going
coaching and mentoring.
03 Sep Other Matters of Interest Year (a) The Allegation(s) (a) The name and (a) The action taken
designation of the because of the
2018 Investigations accused investigation
03 Sep General • The control deficiencies related to operating systems, are largely due to the
2018 Information Technology Controls use of legacy systems. The replacement of the before-mentioned systems
is included in the eHealth implementation architecture, which was defined
What actions have the Trading Entity taken, in partnership with the Department of e-Government.
in partnership with the Department of
e-Government to find solutions to • The legacy systems are due to be replaced in a phased approach with some
information technology controls deficiencies earmarked for replacement by the end of March 2019, and the balance by
to resolve operating systems problems? the end of the 19/20 financial year.
03 Sep What action did the Trading Entity take • The ICT infrastructure was not neglected for 20 years but had been
2018 against the management for neglecting to upgraded in the last seven years.
refurbish the ICT infrastructure for 20 years • The matter is part of the SIU investigation. There is a new Chief Information
and over-reliance on the external service Officer who was not involved in the process and has been tasked to
provider for securing the system? refurbish the ICT infrastructure in collaboration with the department of
e-Government.
03 Sep Does the Trading Entity have a scheduled • The Department currently does not have an ICT infrastructure maintenance
2018 maintenance plan for ICT infrastructure? plan. The Department is in the process to migrate all the systems and data
to the Provincial Fully Managed Data Centre. It is envisaged that this
process will be concluded by the end of the 18/19 financial year.
To mitigate high risk to the Trading Entity, • The current disaster recovery plan is centred around the use of the VBlock
provide the Committee with a progress infrastructure and related technologies. The pending migration of the
report on the implementation of the disaster Departments systems and data, to the Provincial Fully Managed Data
recovery plan. Centre, will result in a Disaster Recovery Plan being defined and restricted
to the before-mentioned data centre.
16. Prior modifications to audit reports 22. Approval and sign off
There were no prior modifications to the audit reports for the entity. The financial statements set out on pages ……. have been approved
by the Accounting Officer.
17. Exemptions and deviations received from the
National Treasury
The entity did not receive any deviations from the National Treasury
or the Gauteng Provincial Treasury (GPT).
18. Investigation
No Investigations were conducted for the Medical Supplies Depot MS NOCAWE THIPA
(MSD) for the year ended 31 March 2019. CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER
GAUTENG MEDICAL SUPPLIES DEPOT
19. Other
The Depot was still incurring a cost relating to price increases not 31 May 2019
recovered from demanders. This is mostly attributable to the back
dated approval of contract price increases by the Gauteng
Department of Finance.
21. Conclusion
The financial year 2018/2019 has had many challenges facing both
the department and the MSD. Despite these challenges
management is pleased to report a success story in terms of service
delivery towards the people of Gauteng. The MSD achieved 100%
of all its predetermined objectives making it possible for medicines
to be available in all the public hospitals and clinics in Gauteng
throughout the year. We look forward to even a better year in
2019/2020.
Report of the Auditor-General to the Gauteng Provincial Legislature on the Gauteng Medical
Suplies Depot
Report on the audit of the financial statements
Opinion Restatement of corresponding figures
1. I have audited the financial statements of the Gauteng Medical 7. As disclosed in note 31 to the financial statements, the
Supplies Depot set out on pages 299 to 327, which comprise corresponding figures for 31 March 2018 have been restated
the statement of financial position as at 31 March 2019, the as a result of errors discovered in the financial statements of
statement of financial performance, the statement of changes the entity for the year ended 31 March 2019.
in net assets and the statement of cash flows for the year then
ended, as well as the notes to the financial statements, Responsibilities of the accounting officer for the financial
including a summary of significant accounting policies. statements
2. In my opinion, the financial statements present fairly, in all 8. The accounting officer is responsible for the preparation and
material respects, the financial position of the Gauteng Medical fair presentation of the financial statements in accordance
Supplies Depot as at 31 March 2019, and its financial with the SA Standards of GRAP and the requirements of the
performance and cash flows for the year then ended in PFMA, and for such internal control as the accounting officer
accordance with the South African Standards of Generally determines is necessary to enable the preparation of financial
Recognised Accounting Practice (SA Standards of GRAP) and statements that are free from material misstatement, whether
the requirements of the Public Finance Management Act of due to fraud or error.
South Africa, 1999 (Act no. 1 of 1999) (PFMA).
9. In preparing the financial statements, the accounting officer is
Basis for opinion responsible for assessing the trading entity’s ability to
3. I conducted my audit in accordance with the International continue as a going concern, disclosing, as applicable, matters
Standards on Auditing (ISAs). My responsibilities under those relating to going concern and using the going concern basis
standards are further described in the auditor-general’s of accounting unless the appropriate governance structure
responsibilities for the audit of the financial statements section either intends to liquidate the trading entity or to cease
of this auditor’s report. operations, or has no realistic alternative but to do so.
4. I am independent of the trading entity in accordance with Auditor-general’s responsibilities for the audit of the
sections 290 and 291 of the International Ethics Standards financial statements
Board for Accountants’ Code of ethics for professional
accountants, parts 1 and 3 of the International Ethics Standards 10.My objectives are to obtain reasonable assurance about
Board for Accountants’ International code of ethics for whether the financial statements as a whole are free from
professional accountants (including International Independence material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error, and to
Standards) (IESBA codes) and the ethical requirements that are issue an auditor’s report that includes my opinion. Reasonable
relevant to my audit in South Africa. I have fulfilled my other assurance is a high level of assurance, but is not a guarantee
ethical responsibilities in accordance with these requirements that an audit conducted in accordance with the ISAs will
and the IESBA codes. always detect a material misstatement when it exists.
Misstatements can arise from fraud or error and are
5. I believe that the audit evidence I have obtained is sufficient and considered material if, individually or in aggregate, they could
appropriate to provide a basis for my opinion. reasonably be expected to influence the economic decisions
of users taken on the basis of these financial statements.
Emphasis of matter
6. I draw attention to the matter below. My opinion is not 11. A further description of my responsibilities for the audit of the
modified in respect of this matter. financial statements is included in the annexure to this
auditor’s report.
13.My procedures address the reported performance information, 16. I did not raise any material findings on the usefulness and
which must be based on the approved performance planning reliability of the reported performance information for the
documents of the trading entity. I have not evaluated the selected programme.
completeness and appropriateness of the performance
indicators included in the planning documents. My procedures Other matters
also did not extend to any disclosures or assertions relating to 17. I draw attention to the matters below.
planned performance strategies and information in respect of
future periods that may be included as part of the reported Achievement of planned targets
performance information. Accordingly, my findings do not 18. Refer to the annual performance report on page 287 for
extend to these matters. information on the achievement of planned targets for the year
and explanations provided for the under/overachievement of a
14. I evaluated the usefulness and reliability of the reported significant number of targets.
performance information in accordance with the criteria
developed from the performance management and reporting
Adjustment of material misstatements
19. I identified material misstatements in the annual performance
framework, as defined in the general notice, for the following
report submitted for auditing. These material misstatements
selected programme presented in the annual performance
were on the reported performance information of medical
report of the trading entity for the year ended 31 March 2019:
supplies depot health care support. As management
subsequently corrected the misstatements, I did not raise any
Pages in the annual material findings on the usefulness and reliability of the
Programme performance report
reported performance information.
Programme 7 – Health care support 73 - 76
Sub-programme medical supplies 287
depot
21. The material findings on compliance with specific matters in key 28. In connection with my audit, my responsibility is to read the
legislations are as follows: other information and, in doing so, consider whether the other
information is materially inconsistent with the financial
Annual financial statements statements and the selected programme presented in the
22.The financial statements submitted for auditing were not annual performance report, or my knowledge obtained in the
prepared in accordance with the prescribed financial reporting audit, or otherwise appears to be materially misstated.
framework as required by section 40(1)(b) of the PFMA.
Material misstatements on commitments identified by the 29. If, based on the work I have performed, I conclude that there is
auditors in the submitted financial statement were a material misstatement in this other information, I am required
subsequently corrected, resulting in the financial statements to report that fact. I have nothing to report in this regard.
receiving an unqualified audit opinion.
Internal control deficiencies
Procurement and contract management 30. I considered internal control relevant to my audit of the financial
23. Some goods and services with a transaction value above R500 statements, reported performance information and compliance
000 were procured without inviting competitive bids and with applicable legislation; however, my objective was not to
deviations were approved by the accounting officer although it express any form of assurance on it. The matters reported
was practical to invite competitive bids, as required by treasury below are limited to the significant internal control deficiencies
regulations 16A6.1 and 16A6.4. Similar non-compliance was that resulted in the findings on compliance with legislation
reported in the previous year. included in this report.
31. The accounting officer did not exercise adequate oversight
Expenditure management responsibility relating to internal controls for procurement and
24.Effective and appropriate steps were not taken to prevent contract management and the preparation of the annual
irregular expenditure amounting to R10 778 051 as disclosed in financial statements.
note 27 to the financial statements, as required by section 32.The entity developed a plan to address the prior year audit
38(1)(c)(ii) of the PFMA and treasury regulation 9.1.1. The findings, but the accounting officer did not provide adequate
majority of the irregular expenditure was caused by oversight relating to implementation and adherence to the
procurement of goods and services without following plan.
competitive bidding processes.
Other information
26.The accounting officer is responsible for the other information.
The other information comprises the information included in
the annual report, which includes the audit committee’s report.
The other information does not include the financial
statements, the auditor’s report and the selected programme
presented in the annual performance report that has been
specifically reported in this auditor’s report.
33. Senior management did not ensure that sufficient controls are
in place to prepare accurate and complete annual financial
statements that are supported by reliable information. This
resulted in material amendments to the annual financial
statements. Furthermore, there was a lack of adequate
monitoring of controls to ensure compliance with laws and
regulations relating to expenditure and procurement and
contract management.
Johannesburg
31 July 2019
• identify and assess the risks of material misstatement of the 4. I also confirm to the accounting officer that I have complied with
financial statements whether due to fraud or error, design and relevant ethical requirements regarding independence, and
perform audit procedures responsive to those risks, and obtain communicate all relationships and other matters that may
audit evidence that is sufficient and appropriate to provide a reasonably be thought to have a bearing on my independence
basis for my opinion. The risk of not detecting a material and, where applicable, related safeguards.
misstatement resulting from fraud is higher than for one
resulting from error, as fraud may involve collusion, forgery,
intentional omissions, misrepresentations, or the override of
internal control
ASSETS
Current Assets
Non-Current Assets
LIABILITIES
Current Liabilities
Trade and other payables from exchange transactions 7 381 448 557 751 495 854
Provisions 8 1 307 383 3 601 652
Finance lease obligations 9 145 963 328 057
382 901 903 755 425 563
Non-Current Liabilities
REVENUE
EXPENSES
OTHER GAINS/(LOSSES)
Loss on disposal of assets (3 244) (41 900)
TOTAL OTHER GAINS/(LOSSES) (3 244) (41 900)
TAXATION 21 - -
Receipts
Sale of goods and services 4 496 721 890 3 900 047 030
Finance income 12 9 816 888 10 919 455
Other receipts 150 576 211 071
Total receipts 4 506 689 354 3 911 177 556
Payments
Compensation of employees (70 175 557) (66 230 539)
Goods and services (4 224 073 813) (3 811 041 357)
Finance costs 18 (125 142) (220 429)
Total payments (4 294 374 512) (3 877 492 325)
Cash and cash equivalents at the beginning of the year 31 419 193 2 625 641
Cash and cash equivalents at the end of the year 4 242 702 338 31 419 193
1.8 Inventories
Derecognition
The carrying amount of inventories is recognized as an expense in
the period that the inventory was sold, distributed, written off or
consumed, unless that cost qualifies for capitalization to the cost of
another asset.
Subsequent measurement
Subsequent to initial recognition, items of property, plant and
equipment are measured at cost less accumulated depreciation and
impairment losses.
Buildings 10
Motor vehicles -
Air-conditioning 4 - 15
Medical equipment 1 - 21
Radio equipment 5 - 10
Telephone system 5 - 10
Audio visual 3 - 19
Domestic equipment 3 - 16
Laboratory equipment 3 - 21
Security equipment 1 - 21
Vehicles 9 - 19
Warehouse equipment 3 - 16
Office furniture -
Kitchen appliances 3 - 21
Office equipment 1 - 23
Computer equipment 1 - 18
Impairment
The entity tests for impairment where there is an indication that an
asset may be impaired. An assessment of whether there is an
indication of possible impairment is done at each reporting date.
Where the carrying amount of an item of property, plant and
equipment is greater than the estimated recoverable amount (or
recoverable service amount), it is written down immediately to its
recoverable amount (or recoverable service amount) and an
impairment loss is charged to the Statement of Financial
Performance.
Intangible assets with indefinite useful lives are not amortised, but
are tested for impairment annually, either individually or at the cash
generating unit level. The assessment of indefinite life is reviewed
annually to determine whether the indefinite life assumption
continues to be supportable. If not, the change in useful life from
indefinite to finite is made on a prospective basis.
1.11 Leases
The lease expense recognised for operating leases is charged to the 1.12 Contributed Capital
Statement of Financial Performance on a straight-line basis over the "The purpose of this reserve is to ensure that there are sufficient
term of the relevant lease. To the extent that the straight-lined lease cash resources to fund the working capital requirements of the
payments differ from the actual lease payments the difference is entity.
recognised in the Statement of Financial Position as either lease
payments in advance (operating lease asset) or lease payments Contributed capital consists of the following items:
payable (operating lease liability) as the case may be. This resulting • Cash received from the Gauteng Department of Health; and
asset and / or liability is measured as the undiscounted difference • Transfers from accumulated surplus based on Treasury approval
between the straight-line lease payments and the contractual lease in terms of Treasury Regulations."
payments.
1.13 Revenue from exchange transactions
The operating lease liability is derecognised when the entity’s
obligation to settle the liability is extinguished. The operating lease Revenue is only recognised when all of the following criteria are
asset is derecognised when the entity no longer anticipates satisfied:
economic benefits to flow from the asset. • The entity retains neither continuing managerial involvement to
the degree usually associated with ownership nor effective
The entity as lessee in a finance lease control over the goods sold;
Leases are classified as finance leases where substantially all the risks • The amount of revenue can be measured reliably; and
and rewards associated with ownership of an asset are transferred • It is probable that the economic benefits or service potential
to the entity through the lease agreement. Assets subject to finance associated with the transaction will flow to the entity and the
leases are recognised in the Statement of Financial Position at the costs incurred or to be incurred in respect of the transaction can
inception of the lease, as is the corresponding finance lease liability. be measured reliably.
The entity has processes and controls in place to aid in the identifica- Key Management Personnel includes all persons having the authori-
tion of related parties. A related party is a person or an entity with ty and responsibility for planning, directing and controlling the
the ability to control or jointly control the other party, or exercise activities of the entity. This includes:
significant influence over the other party, or vice versa, or an entity
that is subject to common control, or joint control. Related party - The senior management team of the entity, including the chief
relationships where control exists are disclosed regardless of wheth- executive officer, the pharmaceutical services director and the
er any transactions took place between the parties during the director of finance and administration.
reporting period.
1.20 Commitments
Where transactions occurred between the entity any one or more
related parties, and those transactions were not within: Commitments are recorded at cost in the notes to the financial
• normal supplier and/or client/recipient relationships on terms statements when there is a contractual arrangement or an approval
and conditions no more or less favorable than those which it is by management in a manner that raises a valid expectation that the
reasonable to expect the entity to have adopted if dealing entity will discharge its responsibilities thereby incurring future
with that individual entity or person in the same expenditure that will result in the outflow of cash.
circumstances; and
• terms and conditions within the normal operating parameters 1.21 Standards, amendments to standards and interpre-
established by the reporting entity’s legal mandate. tations issued not yet effective.
"Further details about those transactions are disclosed in the notes The following Standards of GRAP and / or amendments thereto have
to the financial statements. been issued by the Accounting Standards Board, but will only
Information about such transactions is disclosed in the financial become effective in future periods or have not been given an
statements." effective date by the Minister of Finance. The entity has not early-ad-
opted any of these new Standards or amendments thereto, but has
referred to them for guidance in the development of accounting
policies in accordance with GRAP 3 as read with Directive 5:
GRAP 20 - Related Party Disclosures Approved and effective for periods on or after 1 April 2019.
GRAP 105 - Transfer of Functions Between Entities Under Common Control Approved and not yet effective.
GRAP 106 - Transfer of Functions Between Entities Not Under Common Control Approved and not yet effective.
GRAP 109 - Accounting by Principles and Agents Approved and not yet effective.
2. INVENTORIES
The valuation method used by the Depot is the weighted average cost.
No write down of inventory to net realizable value was required during the current year.
No inventory was pledged as security (2018: Nil).
Cash and cash equivalents earn interest at floating rates based on daily bank
deposit rates. The finance income is recognized in the Statement of Financial Performance.
Owned assets
Computer equipment 289 968 199 514 (158 387) 158 026 (133 264) 355 857
Cellphones & Accessories - 54 185 - - (8 758) 45 427
Fixtures and fittings - - - - - -
Office furniture 999 454 101 575 (71 924) 65 754 (319 005) 775 854
Plant and equipment 6 797 352 4 373 700 (770 183) 734 814 (3 248 164) 7 887 519
8 086 774 4 728 974 (1 000 494) 958 594 (3 709 191) 9 064 657
Leased Assets
Motor vehicles - G-Fleet 591 175 - - - (197 619) 393 556
Office equipment 254 960 - - - (131 958) 123 002
846 135 - - - (329 577) 516 558
Total 8 932 909 4 728 974 (1 000 494) 958 594 (4 038 768) 9 581 215
Note 1 - The Gauteng Medical Supplies Depot has 1061 assets that are fully depreciated but still in use. These are on the Asset Register with a NBV of R100,88.
Note 2 - Included in the 31 March 2018 NBV is an amount of R 3 986 680,39 relating to security equipment will be transferred to Department of Infrastructure &
Development in the 2018/19 financial year.
6 INTANGIBLE ASSETS
Computer software
Cost
Accumulated amortization - 82 422
Carrying value - (82 422)
-
Reconciliation of intangible assets:
Carrying value at beginning of the year -
Additions - 2 810
Disposals/ Impairment - -
Accumulated amortization on disposals/ impairment - (15 732)
Amortization Charge - 15 732
Carrying value at end of the year - (2 810)
-
7 TRADE AND OTHER PAYABLES FROM EXCHANGE TRANSACTIONS
* A leave accrual is recognised for leave due to employees at each reporting period. The accrual for leave is calculated by
multiplying the number of leave days due to each employee by a daily rate based on the total cost to the company. The accrual
is expected to be realised within 12 months of the reporting date.
**Service bonus is accrued and the calculation is based on employee’s number of years in service and their gross salary. It is
normally paid out in the employee’s birthday month.
8 PROVISIONS
Provision for Performance Bonus 1 307 383 3 601 652
Reconciliation of Provision for Performance Bonus:
Provision for performance bonus was calculated based on the amount paid for 2017/2018 financial year as the 2018/2019 performance
appraisals were yet to be concluded at the reporting date. An incremental factor of 6,5% was applied which is the best estimate for the
current year. The provision is anticipated to be paid within 12 months from the reporting date.
Disclosed as:
Current liabilities 145 963 328 057
Non-Current Liabilities 166 339 312 302
312 302 640 359
The finance lease obligations at 31 March 2019 was in respect of 6 photocopier machines and a motor vehicle.
The average interest rate implicit in the leases of the photocopier machines is 17,5% whilst it is 25,3% for the motor vehicle.
* The Gauteng Department of Health contributed capital this amount to the entity to fund its working capital requirements.
** Transfers from accumulated surplus to increase contributed capital occurred in 2007 (R 26 000 000) and in 2009 (R 24 376
790) after treasury approval was obtained.
At 31 March 2019, the entity's employee head count was 191 (2018: 192).
"The entity contributes to a multi-employer pension fund on behalf of its employees. The fund has a defined benefit plan but is
accounted for as a defined contribution plan due to insufficient information being available to apply the rules of the defined benefit
plan. "
The reason why there is insufficient information is because the entity is not assessed separately being part of a multi-employer
Government Employee Pension Fund reporting under the control of National Treasury.
The assets generated by this plan consists of contributions made by both the entity and the employees and are generally held in a
separate administered fund, namely the Government Employees’ Pension Fund. This fund is administered on behalf of the entity by
pension fund administrators and is governed by the Pensions Fund Act, 1956 as amended. The following rates of contribution are
applied: employee contribution is 7.5 % of pensionable salary (basic salary plus annual bonus) as well as entity contribution of 13.0 %
on the same basis.
17 FINANCE COSTS
19 DISTRIBUTION COSTS
20 OPERATIONAL COSTS
21 TAXATION
No provision has been made for taxation as the entity is exempt from income taxation in terms of section 10 (1) of the South
African Income Tax Act No.58 of 1962.
At the reporting date the Depot had outstanding commitments under non-cancellable operating leases and/or contracts, which
fall due as follows:
The lease agreements are not renewable at the end of the lease terms. The operating leases are in respect of office equipment,
motor vehicles and plant and equipment. There is no escalation clause in all operating leases at 31 March 2019 and thus no
straight-lining adjustment was required.
Amount paid in respect of operating leases in the current year amounted to R 468 900 (2018: R 385 321).
23 RELATED PARTIES
Relationships
Controlling entity Gauteng Department of Health
The Medical Supplies Depot is a trading entity under the control of the MEC of Gauteng Department of Health. All transactions
with the Department of Health are considered to be related party transactions and are at arm's length.
2018
Director Director Finance Acting Director Total
Pharmaceutical and Finance and
Services: Mr D Administration: Administration:
Malele Mr J M Smidt* Mr K M Kasumba**
* With effect from 01 September 2018, Mr JM Smidt was transferred to the Gauteng Department of Health.
** Appointed 1 December 2017. Acting allowance only paid from July 2018.
Service in-kind
In the 2018/19 financial year, the Gauteng Department of Health rendered the services listed below at no cost to the entity:
- Corporate Services (Including Human Resources, Risk management and Finance and IT services). The value of these services
could not be reliably estimated.
- Remuneration of Chief Executive Officer of the entity (Ms N Thipa). Her remuneration was paid by the Department of Health.
Her gross remuneration was R 1 422 012 (2018: R 1 347879).
24 RISK MANAGEMENT
General
The main risks faced by the trading entity are interest rate risk, credit risks and liquidity risks. The Depot has developed a
comprehensive risk strategy in terms of Treasury Regulation 3.2 in order to monitor and control these risks. The risk
management process relating to each of these risks is discussed under the headings below.
F igures in Rand
The entity's financial instruments are linked to the South African prime rate.
The following table demonstrates the sensitivity to a reasonable possible change in interest rates, with all other variables held
constant of the entity’s surplus before taxation:
2018
Credit Risk
Financial assets, which potentially subject the Depot to the risk of non-performance by counter parties, consist mainly of
cash and accounts receivable, consisting of trade receivables and staff debtors. Trade accounts receivable consist of a small
consumer base. The Depot limits its treasury counter-party exposure by only dealing with well-established financial
institutions approved by National Treasury. Trade debtors – The Gauteng Department of Health is effectively the only client
of the Depot, although deliveries occur to various health institutions.
Trade debtors – A monthly claim is compiled of all issues from the Depot to health institutions and of payments affected to
suppliers for direct deliveries. This claim is normally paid within a month by Central Office as the Depot follows-up strongly
on outstanding monies to ensure that there is money available to release a weekly run of payments to suppliers.
Staff debtors – Section 17, 30 and 38 of the Public Service Act indicate that any overpayment or wrongly granted
remuneration to staff irrespective of whose fault it is may be recovered from the employee. There are built-in control
measures in Persal to limit overpayments and adjustments have a three-tier approval process. The employee applies or
provides approved documents, a practitioner records the transaction on Persal, a senior reviews the transaction on Persal
and a third person is required to approve the transaction. With death, retirement or resignation there is a prescribed debt
form that needs to be completed and is forwarded with the pension withdrawal form (Z102) to the Department of Finance
where the staff debt is recovered before payment to the employee or employee beneficiaries occur. Where the debt
recovered is inadequate the Department of Finance’s debt recovery section recovers outstanding monies.
Financial assets and liabilities exposed to credit risk at the reporting date were as follows:
Liquidity Risk
The Depot maintains a large amount of inventory, the maximum turnover period for the inventory kept however is twelve weeks
or three months.
Proper stock management processes are in place where stock is ordered based on economic order quantities. The maximum
turnover period of stock kept at the Depot is three months. At least a monthly exercise is done to identify slow moving items and
a memo is issued to health institutions every six months with an inventory list of the items as a reminder that the stock is
available.
Currency Risk
The Depot does not transact with any supplier or customer outside the South African borders and this risk is therefore not
directly applicable. However, this risk arises as suppliers purchase raw material from international suppliers which is subject to
foreign exchange rate fluctuations. Suppliers therefore request, through an application to either National Treasury (State
Tender Board) or the Department of Finance, for a price adjustment based on the fluctuation of foreign exchange rates.
Fair values
At 31 March 2019, the carrying values of cash and cash equivalents, trade and other receivables and trade and other payables
approximate the fair values due to short term maturities of these assets and liabilities as disclosed below:-
Financial Assets
Fair Value
Cash and cash equivalents 242 702 338 31 419 193
Trade and other receivables from exchange transactions 615 410 548 1 024 065 168
Financial Liabilities
Carrying Amount
Trade and other payables from exchange transactions 375 702 712 746 291 632
Finance lease obligation 145 963 328 057
Fair Value
Trade and other payables from exchange transactions 375 702 712 746 291 632
Finance lease obligation 145 963 328 057
25 CONTINGENT LIABILITIES
Currency Risk
The Depot does not transact with any supplier or customer outside the South African borders and this risk is therefore not
directly applicable. However, this risk arises as suppliers purchase raw material from international suppliers which is subject to
foreign exchange rate fluctuations. Suppliers therefore request, through an application to either National Treasury (State
Tender Board) or the Department of Finance, for a price adjustment based on the fluctuation of foreign exchange rates.
Fair values
At 31 March 2019, the carrying values of cash and cash equivalents, trade and other receivables and trade and other payables
approximate the fair values due to short term maturities of these assets and liabilities as disclosed below:-
Financial Assets
Fair Value
Cash and cash equivalents 242 702 338 31 419 193
Trade and other receivables from exchange transactions 615 410 548 1 024 065 168
Financial Liabilities
Carrying Amount
Trade and other payables from exchange transactions 375 702 712 746 291 632
Finance lease obligation 145 963 328 057
Fair Value
Trade and other payables from exchange transactions 375 702 712 746 291 632
Finance lease obligation 145 963 328 057
25 CONTINGENT LIABILITIES
* Broken and expired stock is only recorded as fruitless and wasteful expenditure only if it exceeds 2% of the average inventory on
hand.
27 IRREGULAR EXPENDITURE
There are three (3) contracts that accounted for the current year irregular expenditure:
- Cleaning services 1 437 794
- Security services 6 822 060
- Accounting services 2 518 197
10 778 051
Management has taken the following steps to eliminate the reoccurrence of this irregular expenditure:
• The Department is in the process of insourcing security services for the province which will include Medical Supplies Depot.
• Posts for the replacement of consultants that provide accounting services were created and the recruitment process in the final
stages for appointment.
• The previous cleaning services contract has been terminated and a new service provider was awarded a contract with effect from
October 2018.
28 COMMITMENTS
Approved, contracted and not provided for in the statement of financial position.
Contractual commitments
- Distribution services** 9 597 615 18 052 125
- Cleaning services*** 950 781 -
- IT services 2 243 694 2 116 692
- Orders placed but goods not delivered 453 560 755 663 124 551
466 352 845 683 293 368
Approved, not yet contracted for and not provided for in the statement of financial
position.
Property, Plant & Equipment original useful lives have been reassessed as per table below in the beginning of the current financial
period to reflect the actual pattern service potential derived from the assets. The depreciation is to be calculated on a straight line
basis for the remaining useful lives of the assets.
The change in the useful lives of the assets had the following impact on depreciation
30 COMPARATIVES
There were improvements to the presentation and disclosure in the current year. Changes to the prior year presentation and
disclosure was also made to ensure comparability for users of the annual financial statements. No prior year figures were
changed.
While preparing the annual financial statements of the entity for the year ended 31 March 2019, management noted that
the disclosure of commitments the entity had at 31 March 2018 was not complete. Commitments relating to IT services,
Orders placed but goods not delivered and Capital commitments were erreneously omitted from the disclosure in the annual
financial statements.
There is no impact on the Statement of Financial Position, Statement of Financial Performance, Statement of Changes in
Equity or the Statement of Cash Flows for the year ended 31 March 2018.
The impact on the disclosure in the annual financial statements presented at 31 March 2018 is as follows:
Commitments
There were no events identified after the reporting date that may have a significant impact on the entity's financial position
at 31 March 2019, its financial performance or its cash flows for the year then ended.
We are pleased to present our report for the financial year ended 31 March 2019.
Non-Executive Members
Executive Members
The Audit Committee noted that the Chief Executive Officer attended four out of five scheduled Audit Committee meetings and was
duly represented. The Audit Committee is satisfied that the Entity adhered to the provisions of the GPG Audit Committee Charter in
relation to ensuring that there is proper representation for the Chief Executive Officer.
The Members of the Audit Committee met with the Senior Management of the Entity, Internal Audit and the AGSA, individually and
collectively to address risks and challenges facing the Entity. A number of in-committee meetings were held to address control
weaknesses and deviations within the Entity.
The Audit Committee reports that it has complied with its responsibilities arising from section 38(1)(a) of the PFMA and Treasury
Regulation 3.1.13. The Audit Committee also reports that it has adopted appropriate formal terms of reference as its Audit Committee
Charter, has regulated its affairs in compliance with this Charter and has discharged all its responsibilities as contained therein.
The effectiveness of internal control and Information and Communication Technology (ICT) Governance
The Audit Committee has observed that the control environment of the Entity has not significantly improved during the year under
review. Some deficiencies in the system of internal control and deviations were reported in the Internal Audit and Auditor-General
Reports. The overall opinion of Internal Audit on the internal control design at the Entity is partially adequate and effective.
Management should pay special attention to IT general controls and Occupational Health and Safety processes.
The Audit Committee also reviewed the progress with respect to the ICT Governance in line with the ICT Framework issued by the
Department of Public Services and Administration. Although there was some progress on the ICT internal control, special attention
must be given to the IT general controls as well as the implementation of the Disaster Recovery Plan and the Business Continuity Plan.
This continued to be a high risk for the Entity.
The governance of the MSD and its reliance on the department of health requires resolution to enable it progress and effectively
improve the internal control environment.
Internal Audit
The Audit Committee is satisfied that the Internal Audit plan represents a clear alignment with the key risks, has adequate information
systems coverage, and a good balance across the different categories of audits, i.e. risk-based, mandatory, performance, computer and
follow-up audits.
The Audit Committee has noted improvement in the communication between the Executive Management, the AGSA and the Internal
Audit Function, but more needs to be done to strengthen the Corporate Governance initiatives within the Entity.
Risk Management
Progress on the departmental risk management was reported to the Audit Committee on a quarterly basis. The Audit Committee
stresses that risk management should receive urgent attention. Management should take full responsibility for the entire Enterprise
Risk Management process and continue to support the risk function to even further enhance the performance of the Entity.
Forensic Investigations
Limited forensic investigations were requested for the Entity during the financial year under review.
The quality of quarterly reports submitted in terms of the PFMA and the Division of Revenue Act
The Audit Committee notes the content of financial and non-financial quarterly reports prepared and submitted by the Accounting
Officer of the Entity during the year under review and confirms that the reports were in compliance with the statutory reporting
framework although significant effort must be made to further the quality of these reports .
• Reviewed and discussed the audited Annual Financial Statements to be included in the Annual Report, with the AGSA and the
Accounting Officer;
• Reviewed the Audit Report of the AGSA;
• Reviewed the AGSA’s Management Report and Management’s response thereto;
• Reviewed the Entity’s compliance with legal and regulatory provisions;
• Reviewed significant adjustments resulting from the audit; and
• Reviewed the appropriate accounting policies and relevant disclosures.
The Audit Committee concurs with and accepts the AGSA’s conclusions on the Annual Financial Statements, performance information
and compliance and is of the opinion that the audited Annual Financial Statements be accepted and read together with the report of
the AGSA.
The Audit Committee has met with the Accounting Officer for the Entity to address unresolved issues.
The Audit Committee has met with the Executive Authority for the Entity to apprise the MEC on the performance of the Entity.
The Audit Committee has met with the AGSA to ensure that there are no unresolved issues.