Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Stock Exchanges
Stock Exchanges
Markets
Stock Exchanges
1 Overview of financial markets
Sections 4
5
Stock exchanges
Investment alternatives
6
FX & Commodity
Sr.No. Area
A Background and overview
A.1 Understanding growth of stock exchanges across the globe
A.2 Landscape of Indian stock exchanges
A.3 Evolution of Indian stock exchanges
A.4 Infrastructural set up and participants
A.5 Understanding growth of stock exchanges of India
A.6 National stock exchange- Data and website
Understanding growth of stock exchanges across the globe
Number of Trades Value of Share Trading
Data source: World Federation of Stock Exchanges, August 2019 Data source: World Federation of Stock Exchanges, August 2019
• While single stop options were down by 2.4 ,
Share of total volumes by asset class traded volume of single stock futures increased
by 2 1 .2 with the Americas seeing a 319.4
growth in number of contracts.
In $ Trillion
and the government. 25.00
20.00
• Rapid growth in the financial sector with 60+ stock 15.00 10.90
exchanges representing a market capitalization of $ 84.68 10.00 6.91
3.28
trillion amongst them. 5.00
2.59 2.52 2.43
0.77
-
U.S. China Japan U.K. Canada India Saudi Arabia Singapore
• Exchanges such as N YSE and NASDAQ in the United States,
OSE/TSE, S SE , L S E are leading w.r.t market capitalisation U.S. China Japan U.K. Canada India Saudi Arabia Singapore
Poorest 6141
~320 Month: 80 return
September
Increasein market cap Historically proven to be the 80% of all trades in the world’s If you invested $ 1000
from 2009-2021 poorest performing month of stock exchangesare automated in 1980, you would
the year have $ 61,410 today
Understanding growth of stock exchanges across the globe
Market performance ratios across jurisdictions (as on 2019) Historical trend of market performance metrics in India
Turnoverto Market cap to
300 120 101 Year Market cap GDP
Market capitalisation to GDP
• India has both low levels turnover to market cap ratio and Market capitalisation to GDP ratio as compared to other jurisdictions.
• For the period 2 0 0 4 to 2 0 1 9 , there has been a drop in the turnover to market cap ratio for India from 101 in 2004 to 29 in 2019.
• For the same period, no linear trend was observed in the market cap to GDP ratio as it increased from 55 in 2004 to 97 in 2010, and declined to 76 thereafter in 2019
Landscape of Indian stock exchanges
About India:
• It is established to promote the growth and development of the securities markets while protecting the rights of the investors.
2019-21 2016-18
➢ Covid-19 Pandemic
➢ Additional ➢ Risk Management Guidelines made
➢ S E N S E X dropped by surveillance more robust
2 9 1 9 . 2 6 points margin
(8.9) in one week introduced ➢ Exposure margins collected upfront as ➢ Demonetization of Indian
due to the pandemic on highly initial margin currency notes and
volatile ➢ Exposure margin applicable on Donald Trump wins U.S.
stocks. underlying published daily. Elections negatively
➢ Delivery margins introduced for physical effect stock market
settlement of equity contracts
Indian equity F&O markets are governed by the regulators set out by SEBI which are enforced by the exchange, clearing corporation and clearing member
Regulator SEBI Apex regulatory body which regulates the stock exchanges in India
1 0 0 .0 0 Trading value of different marketsegments Participant wise trading value in the F&O segment
9 0 .0 0
8 0 .0 0 35,00,00,000
7 0 .0 0 30,00,00,000
6 0 .0 0 25,00,00,000
5 0 .0 0 20,00,00,000
4 0 .0 0
15,00,00,000
3 0 .0 0
10,00,00,000
2 0 .0 0
5,00,00,000
1 0 .0 0
0 .0 0 -
2 0 1 3 -14 2 0 1 4 -15 2 0 1 5 -16 2 0 1 6 -17 2017-18 2 0 1 8 -19 2 0 1 9 -20 2013-14 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18
Capital Market Equity F&O Wholesale Debt Market Currency F&O Interest Rate Futures Institutional investors Retail Propreitary
Number of trades as per instrument type Year wise participant growth age
9 ,0 0,00,00,00 0 2
8 ,0 0,00,00,00 0 1.8
7 ,0 0,00,00,00 0 1.6
6 ,0 0,00,00,00 0 1.4
5 ,0 0,00,00,00 0 1.2
1
4 ,0 0,00,00,00 0
0.8
3 ,0 0,00,00,00 0
0.6
2 ,0 0,00,00,00 0
0.4
1 ,0 0,00,00,00 0
0.2
- 0
2013-14 2014 -15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019 -20 2020-21 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18
Index Futures Stock Futures Index Options Stock Options Institutional investors Retail Propreitary
Navigating the NSE website
Data available at :
Sr.No. Area
B Benchmarking of global exchanges
B.0 Scope of session: Exchanges and benchmarking parameters (USA, UK,
Japan, Singapore)
B.1 Capital requirements
B.2 Risk management mechanisms
B.3 Transaction taxes
Scope of session: Exchanges and benchmarking parameters
Evaluation benchmarks
Margin benefits
Note: The benchmarking has been done for the equity F&O segment
General information
Current practice followed in National Stock Exchange
General information
Trading hours
Products traded
Equity cash Mutual funds Debt Derivatives Primary
► Corporate bonds ► Currency ► Stock IPO issuances
► Equity shares ► Equity
► Debentures ► Equity
► Indexes ► Debt
► Government securities ► Interest
► Commercial papers ► Commodities
Capital requirements
Clearing Member-
➢ Net worth of at least Rs. 300 Lakhs
➢ Deposit of Rs. 50 Lakhs to NSCCL which forms part of security deposit of the CM
Trading cum Clearing Member
➢ Net worth requirement of Rs. 300 Lakhs
➢ Collateral Security Deposit of Rs. 25 Lakhs with NSCCL, Rs. 25 Lakhs IFSD with NSCCL, Rs. 25 Lakhs with NSEIL.
Trading cum Self Clearing Member
➢ Net worth of Rs. 100 Lakhs,
➢ Collateral security deposit with NSCCL of Rs. 25 Lakhs, Rs. 25 Lakhs with IFSD with NSCCL and Rs. 25 Lakhs IFSD with NSEIL
Trading Member:
➢ Net worth of at least Rs. 100 Lakhs
➢ Interest Free Security Deposit of Rs. 25 Lakhs with NSEIL
Current practice followed in National Stock Exchange
General information
Capital requirements • India has the lowest net worth requirement which
stands within the range of INR 1 – 3 crore based on the
Geography Equity Derivatives category of clearing member
India Net worth*: INR 1 – INR 3 crore
• Singapore keep a fixed minimum base capital
Base capital: Base capital:
Singapore requirements of INR 27 crore, INR 360 crore and INR
• CM: SGD 5 0 lakh (INR 2 7 crore) • CM: SGD 5 0 lakh (INR 2 7 crore)
256 crore respectively, which is ~ 9 times, 120 times
Net worth: and 85 times of India respectively
• PCP: JPY 2 0 0 crore (INR 1 4 0 crore)
Japan • ACP: JPY 2,000 crore (INR 1 4 0 0 crore)
Base capital: • Japan has both minimum net worth and base capital
• Not less than JPY 3 0 crore (INR 2 0 crore) requirement which is higher than India at INR 140-
Minimum capital for broker/ dealers:
1400 crore and INR 20 crore respectively
Initial net capital requirement ishigher:
• USD 5 lakh (INR 3.7 crore); or
• USD 2 5 lakh (INR 1 8 crore);
• USD 1 0 lakh (INR 7.4 crore) is
• 12.5 of aggregate indebtedness (not • USA has an initial minimum capital requirement
USA clearing done for other broker/
adopted for ANC)
dealers.
• 5 of aggregate debit items (adopted for
defined as higher of either a fixed amount or variable
Any additional requirements prescribed amount ( of aggregated indebtedness (12.5 ) or
ANC)
by clearing house
aggregate debit items (5 ))
UK LCH Clearing member categories and respective net capital requirements:
• SwapClear Clearing Member: USD 5 crore (INR 3 6 9 crore)
• EquityClear Individual Clearing Member: £ 5 0 lakh- GBP 1 crore (INR 4 7 – 9 4 crore) • United Kingdom, define minimum net capital
• ForexClear Clearing Member: USD 5 crore (INR 3 6 9 crore) requirements for various market segments which
• Net capital requirements of clearing members operating across multiple of these
range between INR 47 – 369 crore
markets will be sum of individual market net capital requirements (min GBP 5 0 lakh)-
(INR 4 7 crore)
• Net capital requirements of clearing members operating across multiple of these
markets will be sum of individual market net capital requirements (min GBP 5 0 lakh)-
(INR 4 7 crore)
Risk management practices
Risk management framework of Indian exchanges
There are multiple provisions made available such as capital adequacy requirements, margins, deposits and settlement guarantee funds
and other protection measures. Some of the key provisions are discussed below:
2 Margin requirements:
• Transactions in securities are subject to margin requirements and every trading member / clearing member deposit or pay such
amount of margins, as may be prescribed by SEBI or the Exchange or Clearing Agency and in turn collect such margins from their
clients.
Settlement guarantee fund • In India, the contribution made by clearing members to the
Settlement Guarantee Fund (‘SGF’) is fixed at a maximum of 25 ,
Geography Fixed contribution Variable contribution as per the SEBI circular. Unlike other geographies considered, no
minimum contribution to the SGF is prescribed
Japan Basis aggregated expected loss for the top 2 – 5 CM • For Japan, the clearing fund size is defined as per the excess risk
in the system by computing the expected loss under stress test.
This is further defined as per different products segments by
Derivative: INR 3.69 Amount determined by giving weights to total
USA crore (derivative) risk (70 ), open interest (15 ) and volume aggregating the risk values of largest clearing members.
Equity: INR 7.38 lakh (15 )
59820
60000
40000
20999
20000
12315
6189
3266 3375
0
India* Singapore Japan USA (NSCC) Hong Kong Germany UK
Levied to penalize for higher concentration of short options in a particular expiry month of long
Concentration margin
dated options
Daily settlement Mark-to-market done at end-of the day to cover for intra-day price movement
Understanding SPAN margin
Objective of SPAN is to identify overall risk in a portfolio of futures and options contracts for each member. Because SPAN is used to determine performance bond
requirements (margin requirements), its overriding objective is to determine the largest loss that a portfolio might reasonably be expected to suffer from one day
to the next day.
SPAN Margin
Price Scan Range Risk Arrays
Risk The gain or loss
Scenarios Volatility Scan value over oneday
Range for the contract
Critical factors:
• Underlying market price
• Volatility (variability) of underlying
instrument
• Time to expiration
Risk management framework of Indian exchanges
Applicability of SPAN margin • Across global exchanges considered under review, SPAN margin
Geography Initial margin is collected as the initial margin. Intermittent periods of higher
India
Singapore Yes
Japan Yes
USA Yes
UK Yes
Risk management framework of Indian exchanges
Instances of levy of event based margins around global events are observed such as during budget, general elections, Brexit etc
Type of
S.No. Event Year Exchange Impact on margining
change
➢ SEBI revised the exposure margins from 5 or 1.5 times the SD to 1 0 or 1.5 times SDfor
Temporary
2010 NSE exchange traded equity derivatives w.e.f Oct 22,2008. This change was reverted back
change
in July 7,2010
Lehman
1
crisis
Process ➢ Implementation of a daily intra-day margin process on derivatives markets w.e.f 10
2007 LCH
change April, 2007
Process ➢ The third intra-day margin call collection time changed to two hours earlier so that it is
2016 LCH
change collected while repo market is still open
2 Brexit
➢ Following the news on Brexit referendum, ASX Clear (Futures) has revised SPAN margin
Temporary
2016 ASX rates for the SPI 200 (AP) and the 10 Year Government Bond 6 Coupon (XT) futures
Change
contracts on June 24, 2016. This change was reverted back in July 15, 2016
Transaction taxes
Transaction taxes
India applies both transaction taxes and profit taxes on participants trading in the secondary markets.
These are defined differently as per the following types: • India applies STT/ CTT on intra-day trades, F&Otrades
1) Product segment: All three product segments (equity, derivative and commodities) have different and commodities trades
taxation rates defined. The rates applicable in the derivatives and commodities segment are lower
as compared to those applicable in equity cash. Agricultural commodities are exempt from taxes. For 8 global jurisdictions under consideration:
2) Trade transaction: There are different cost and tax rates applicable for delivery and non-delivery
where rates applicable are higher for the former. • 1/8 global jurisdictions applies STT rate in cash equity
segment for delivery.
Applicability of rates in India and global jurisdictions
• No jurisdiction applies STT in F&O or CTT on
Applicabi ity in India Applicability in global (outof 8) commodities
l Equity cash Equity cash
S.No. Charge type • 4/8 global jurisdictions apply stamp duty charge in
Non- F&O Com Non- F&O Com
Delivery Delivery
delivery delivery equity cash segment for delivery trades. However
Trans action taxes certain geographies provide options to claim tax rebate,
1 STT Yes Yes Yes** NA 1 0 0 NA
exempt certain securities from this charge etc.
2 CTT NA NA NA Yes** NA 0 NA No
3 Stamp duty* Yes Yes Yes Yes 4 0 0 0
Exchange
4 Yes Yes Yes Yes 8 0 8 8
charge • Most global jurisdictions (5/8) are taxing capital gains.
6 GST Yes Yes Yes Yes 7 0 7 7
However, in these geographies STT is not applied.
Profit taxes
Capital
5 Yes Yes Yes Yes 5 5 5
gain**
NA: Not applicable, *Only buy side; **Only sell side
Transaction taxes
A tax rebate was available under section 88E on STT for all Evolution of STT rates in India
transactions. However, this rebate was removed in 20 0
Additionally, post 2018, along with STT and short term capital gain 8. Cash Non cash
Equity futures
Options
Options Exercised
Date deliverable deliverabl notional
LTCG was also re-introduced (for > 1 lakh capital gain), there s (sell) premium (sell) options
(buy and sell) e (sell) amount(sell)
Securities transaction taxes • India is the only geography applying STT and CTT charge in the
Geography Equities F&O Commodities derivatives and commodities segment respectively
Agri- No CTT
Futures: 0.01
India 0.10 Non Agri- Sell side
Options: • India applies STT on both sides (sell/buy) in case of cash equity
- Futures: 0.01
0.05
- Options: 0.05 and only on sell side in case of derivatives. However, in South
Korea, STT is applicable on sell side for all product segments
Singapore - - -
Japan - - -
USA - - -
UK - - -
Transaction taxes
Stamp duty • India is the only geography that applies stamp duty across all
Geography Equities F&O Commodities product segments and in case of non-delivery trades
2. - Futures
India 0.015
3. - Options • No rebate/provisions/ exemption is available in India unlike other
benchmark geographies such as UK
Singapore - - -
• In comparison to India, geographies like UK have exempted
application of stamp duty in certain market segments like AIM
and high growth markets to reduce the cost of investing in the
Japan - - -
security, providing an incentive to a wider set of investors to back
high growth SMEs in the UK
USA - - -
Ernst & Young LLP is one of the Indian client serving member firms of EYGM Limited. For
more information about our organization, please visit www.ey.com/en_in.
Ernst & Young LLP is a Limited Liability Partnership, registered under the Limited Liability
Partnership Act, 2008 in India, having its registered office at 22 Camac Street, 3rd Floor,
Block C, Kolkata – 700016
This publication contains information in summary form and is therefore intended for general
guidance only. It is not intended to be a substitute for detailed research or the exercise of
professional judgment. Neither EYGM Limited nor any other member of the global Ernst &
Young organization can accept any responsibility for loss occasioned to any person acting or
refraining from action as a result of any material in this publication. On any specific matter,
reference should be made to the appropriateadvisor.