Professional Documents
Culture Documents
research-article2022
QIXXXX10.1177/10778004221093424Qualitative InquiryKeedle and Willo
Research Article
Qualitative Inquiry
Abstract
In collaboration between a researcher and poet, we have used poetry inquiry to create a collection of found poems from
open-ended survey data. Found poems were created using the written responses from the Australian Birth Experience
Study survey and the poems highlighted women’s experiences of traumatic birth. Analysis was undertaken through reflexive
poetry from the poet and through reflection by the researcher. The poems display themes of lack of control and consent.
These poems illuminate the voices of the women who shared their traumatic birthing stories to gain understanding and
raise awareness in the community on aspects of birth trauma.
Keywords
investigative poetry, methods of inquiry, feminist methodologies, methodologies, qualitative health research, qualitative
research methodologies
Corresponding Author:
The Birth Experience Study (BESt) was an Australian
Hazel Keedle, Lecturer of Nursing & Midwifery, School of Nursing and
national survey that aimed to explore the experiences of Midwifery, Western Sydney University, Locked Bag 1797, Penrith, NSW
women who had a baby in the previous 5 years and was live 2751, Australia.
from March 2021 to December 2021. Ethical approval was Email: h.keedle@westernsydney.edu.au
Keedle and Willo 939
foreboding thought that these women were not heard or seen. Poets’ reflexive response to Screaming out to Stop
I hope that through these poems their voices have been heard. All eyes
The process of creating poetry from the written voices of Behind the tarnished mirror
women was often formulaic and restrictive. As poets are Behind the tubes and Kilner jars
generally beings who experience the world through a lens White coated heroes in formaldehyde
of emotive thought expressed into words, it was impossible Ether Laudanum
for me as the poet to remain methodical and detached from heartbeating the strange
this process. Each poem that grew out of the BESt data gen- And invisibly voiceless
erated a personal emotional and unprompted response. I Anatomically labelled
expressed these feelings in another poem of my own words; Straining
a reflexive poem which is presented after each woman’s Wild &
poem. These reflexive poems were a form of analysis and flailing feral
creation where I could make sense of their journeys, while Acts cascading the
simultaneously freeing my own voice. Inhumane
Free Verse
Findings
This is an entire birth story from one mother that has been
The majority of birthing stories within the data seemed to adjusted ever so slightly to fit within a poetic form.
express an incredible lack of connection with the care pro-
viders (doctors and midwives) and most were in hospital Mother Guilt
settings. Although there were some positive responses, By the time I reached the pushing stage, I. . . was coached to
many of these stories depicted birth trauma. hold my breath. . . . . . and pushing mid contraction. . . I had a
This is shown in the poetry created below. A variety of time limit. . . the baby had to be out within the hour. . .
poetry styles were used, these include tanka poetry, free Eventually, the doctor said. . . the vacuum is. . . our best option.
verse, using end-jams, quatrains, and shaped verse. . . for proceeding. . . which filled my heart with dread. . . I did
The first poem is a slightly adapted tanka, two tankas not have time to answer. . . or consider my options as. . . Baby
with a repeating seven (much like a coda in music) followed at an angle. . . putting pressure on my hips. . . caused. . . a
by a haiku. Tanka poetry dates back to 7th-century Japan painful contraction. . . Without consent, the doctor. . . . . . began
the vacuum process. . . It felt like a hundred strangers. . . had
and, in current literature, has been used in social activism
swarmed into the room. . . all here for the freak show. . . My
(Breckenridge, 2016). The limitation of words in this style screaming continued. . . my partner crying as. . . he watched on
of poetry opens to a more vocal and evocative message. helplessly. . . They moved onto forceps. . . I was yelling to my
partner. . . “This is wrong!.” . . “This is wrong!”. . . Everything
Screaming out to Stop about this was wrong. . . The pain. . . At one point. . . was. . .
My Dreams crushed, hearing Unbearable. . . I thought I was dying. . . I just needed. . . a
Baby’s heartbeat in distress break. . . to. . . catch my breath. . . so. . . . . . I started yelling . .
Told “stop worrying” . “Stop! Stop! Please stop!.” . . My cries ignored. . . they did not
Labelled a “broken mother” stop. . . they did not pause. . . When my baby came out. . . her
Still feels so fresh, eyes well up fraught cries. . . like mine. . . like. . . she was in agony. . . That
will haunt me forever. . . my first words to her. . . were. . . sorry.
“She keeps screaming out to stop” . . for how wrong it all was. . . how she deserved better. . . how
I had failed. . . to protect her. . . in the jaws. . . of a. . . Humanless
“Still screaming to stop” system. . .
just ignore her—keep going -
Reflexive poem to Mother Guilt
We are on the clock
Quite often,
Betrayed, and violated
Our breath, our connected stillness
This expanse we feel
Frivolously dismissive
Lies in the space
my expectations “too high” And weight
Inbetween our words
In a fragile state Folded into each pause
Still feel heavy with regrets We find,
“Why haven’t you pushed him out?” Left hanging
Yet? The spaces in the silence
Held in the quietest corners of our minds
************ In the lull of the waves
Keedle and Willo 941
The breath between the contractions by this method to evoke the experience of an interrupted
Gathering the push or disconnected thought. The empty significance of things
The composure of time through loss, through heavy metaphor (Perloff, 1970), that
This is where our power lies. emotions and words are almost too much to bear.
Below is a found poem inspired by Sylvia Plath’s method Deteriorating in a donated keep sake box
of using end-jams, creating a hinge-like effect, emphasized Lost in trauma my pain breaking free to be
942 Qualitative Inquiry 28(8-9)
We. . .
are
all
drowning. . .
Drowning
in
our
own
Keedle and Willo 943
words. . .
Words
that
refuse
point-blank
to
be
Heard
Reflection and Analysis health professionals to hear and read. To prevent obstetric
violence, we first need to understand and recognize it from
Poetry is often utilized as a means of inquiry—that is, the
the women’s perspective.
process of writing research poems helps the authors develop
new insights. (Furman et al., 2016, p. 304) The aim of this poetry inquiry was to give women who
shared their story in the BESt survey a voice. The seven
As a midwife and midwifery researcher, I (HK) have lis- poems shared in this article and the reflexive poetry
tened to and read countless stories of birth trauma and I responses have provided a platform for their voices to be
frequently feel frustrated and saddened by the trauma expe- heard as well as providing a window into the raw emotions
rienced. However, interacting with these poems affected and experiences of these brave women.
me on a deeper level. The lack of control and consent is a
dominant experience in these poems. A lack of control is Conclusion
often felt by women who experience birth trauma (Keedle
et al., 2019, 2020). The collaboration between researcher and poet has resulted
In the poem “Mother Guilt,” the words “how I had failed in the creation, analysis, and reflection of a series of found
to protect her in the jaws of a humanless system” spoke to poems from the stories of women who completed the
me. Too often women blame themselves for a traumatic Australian BESt survey in 2021. The poems evoke a variety
birthing experience yet when reading this poem, you are of powerful emotions, and this can be used to bring the
drawn into how “out of control” the women felt. Starting experience of birth trauma to a wider audience.
with being coached in second stage, progressing to not Feminist research methodologies identify the impor-
being asked consent for using a vacuum on the baby and tance that the research should be of benefit to the commu-
having strangers observing her birth. Yet, even when she nity of women who shared their stories (Lafrance &
had no control or dignity, she still blamed herself and not Wigginton, 2019). Sharing these stories of birth trauma
the humanless system that she had become victim to. through poetry gives voice to the stories in a way that can
The lack of consent, especially in relation to internal evoke change and shed light on what has often remained a
vaginal examinations, is an example of obstetric violence. private trauma. As researchers, it is our responsibility to
Obstetric violence refers to violence and harassment that give the findings back to the community in a variety of
happens during childbirth (Garcia, 2020). The poem methods and poetry is one such method.
“Obstetric violence” emphasizes the blurring between treat- A collection of poems from the BESt survey data will be
ment and assault. Consent should precede all physical published and made available to academics and the com-
examinations, yet women often report experiences where munity as part of the delivery of findings. Future poetry
they know they did not give consent. This can leave women readings at community events and conferences are also
in a tenuous position questioning whether the outcome of planned. It is hoped that this collection of experiences
having a healthy baby was enough to negate the assault. It expressed through the poetic medium can positively influ-
is not. However, many women are unaware of how to make ence and bring about change at both personal, professional,
a complaint or even if their complaints regarding these situ- policy, and political levels for future women’s birthing
ations will be taken seriously or fall upon deaf ears. experiences.
Reading the poems and the subsequent reflexive poetry “Poetry is political. Writing, performing, and publishing
stirs up a passion in me to fight for all women who continue poetry is important political activity” (Faulkner, 2017,
to experience obstetric violence and birth trauma, both p. 89).
those that speak out against it and for those that remain
silent. These emotions motivate me to write the papers and Declaration of Conflicting Interests
present the findings of our studies, regardless of how The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect
uncomfortable they are for both academics and to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
944 Qualitative Inquiry 28(8-9)
Vedam, S., Stoll, K., Taiwo, T. K., Rubashkin, N., Cheyney, M., Author Biographies
Strauss, N., McLemore, M., Cadena, M., Nethery, E., Rushton, Hazel Keedle, PhD, is a Lecturer of Midwifery at Western Sydney
E., Schummers, L., & Declercq, E. (2019). The Giving Voice University. Hazel’s research interests are vaginal birth after cesar-
to Mothers study: Inequity and mistreatment during pregnancy ean, birth trauma, and maternity experiences explored primarily
and childbirth in the United States. Reproductive Health,16(1), using feminist mixed methodologies. She has published in BMC
Article 77. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12978-019-0729-2 Pregnancy and Childbirth, Women and Birth, Journal of Nursing
Vincent, A. (2018). Is there a definition? Ruminating on poetic Scholarship, as well as writing a chapter in Birthing Outside the
inquiry, strawberries and the continued growth of the field. System (Routledge) and a book for women based on her PhD find-
Art/Research International,3(2), 48–76. ings Birth after Caesarean; your journey to a better birth
Walmsley, H., Cox, S. M., & Leggo, C. (2015). Listening deeply: (Praeclarus Press).
Understanding experiences of reproductive tourism through
poetic inquiry. Creative Approaches to Research,8(3), 15–43. Pixie Willo is currently studying for a Master of Creative Arts
https://www.proquest.com/docview/1758459316?pq-origsite Therapy (Drama Therapy) at University of Melbourne. She has
=gscholar&fromopenview=true# completed a Graduate Certificate of Creative Therapies at Charles
Watson, K., White, C., Hall, H., & Hewitt, A. (2021). Women’s expe- Darwin University and holds a BA Theatre, Performance and
riences of birth trauma: A scoping review. Women Birth,34(5), Creative Writing from the University of New England. Much of
417–424. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wombi.2020.09.016 Pixie’s work is written for performance. Her work is deeply per-
Williamson, E., Pipeva, A., Brodrick, A., Saradjian, A., & Slade, sonal and autobiographical, chronicling her journey as a mother,
P. (2021). The birth trauma psychological therapy service: An feminist and queer writer. Pixie’s first work of poetry was pub-
audit of outcomes. Midwifery, 102, Article 103099. https:// lished in April 2021 in Clarity’s absence (2021) (Girls on Key
doi.org/10.1016/j.midw.2021.103099 Press).