Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Logical Fallacies 2021 - Summary
Logical Fallacies 2021 - Summary
5. FLAMBOYANCE -- The manner in which someone speaks can easily draw unwarranted
support for a thesis or idea. Incisive wit, verbal facility, equanimity and repartee have no bearing
at all on the soundness/legitimacy of a position. It is the essence of what is said, not the manner
in which it is said, that counts. As Bertrand Russell once noted, the purpose of being educated is
to defend ourselves against the seductions of eloquence.
9. RED HERRING -- An attempt to divert attention away from the crux of an argument by
introduction of anecdote, irrelevant detail, subsidiary facts, tangential references, and the like.
Like many logicall fallacies, this one overlaps others. I'll leave it to the reader to apply a few
brain cells and determine where (hint: several itmes listed at the top of this section qualify).
10. POST HOC, ERGO PROPTER HOC ("after this, therefore because of this". Identifying
a false cause and effect) -- This might also be described as the causality fallacy: Event Y
follows from Event X, so one automatically concludes that X caused Y. (A young kid walks by a
neighbor's house and sees a cat scurrying away; he looks up and sees a giant hole in the window.
The hole, he infers, must have been caused by the cat, who fell through the pane. The inference
is hasty, because the hole might have been caused by any number of things -- a baseball that
missed a friend's glove and flew over his head; young brothers fighting inside and accidentally
smashing the window, etc.).
11. ARGUING FROM "IS" TO "OUGHT" -- A fallacy first articulated by David Hume
(1711-1776) in which someone argues from a premise containing only a descriptive term, to a
conclusion containing an "ought." Example: "There is nothing morally wrong with the institution
of slavery. It has been with us in some form for thousands of years." (The fact that slavery has
been with us or is with us is not moral justification of the act. What is may not be the same thing
as what ought to be.) Put in modern terms, "There is nothing wrong with the concept of men
wearing nothing below the beltline except for pants and low-heeled shoes. That's what men have
done for the last hundred years or so, so it's the way things ought to be."
12. ARGUMENTUM AD BACULINUM -- Fallacy that occurs when threat of force is made,
either implicitly or explicitly. Example: "I'm willing to discuss this in even more depth, but if
you don't come around soon, there may be dire consequences." (Baculum from the Latin means
"stick").
14. GENETIC FALLACY -- A fallacy that occurs when someone attacks the cause or origin of
a belief rather than its substance. Why a person believes something is not relevant to the belief's
legitimacy/soundness/validity. Example: "Smith's belief in God stems from a subsconscious need
for a fatherly figure and is thus a total joke." (The psychological link may in fact be true and may
even shed some light on the personality of Smith, but is nevertheless irrelevant to the
truth/falsehood of his belief.)