Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mental Health Nursing - August-September 2022
Mental Health Nursing - August-September 2022
Mental Health
• Making mental
health
nursing
Sustainable
• COPING With
ECO-ANXIETY
• THE WORK OF
CLIMATE CARES
• The NURSES
SUSTAINABILITY CLIMATE
CHALLENGE
and mental Health • STUDENT
Special Issue PART 2 PERSPECTIVE
Mental Health
INTRODUCTION
WE NEED SUSTAINABILITY,
• COPING With
ECO-ANXIETY
• THE WORK OF
CLIMATE CARES
• The NURSES
SUSTAINABILITY CLIMATE
CHALLENGE
and mental Health
T
he politics of climate change has • Evri Anagnostara, head of nursing,
Barnet, Enfield and Haringey Mental
historically involved a binary Health NHS Trust
choice: to believe or to deny. • Mark Brown, development director,
Social Spider Community Interest
In contemporary times, as both the Company
• Terez Burrows, deputy modern matron,
debate and the planet broil, it seems Rampton High Secure Hospital
the affirmative choice has developed • Lawrence Benson, senior lecturer in
healthcare management and policy,
an overtly, at times overwhelming, University of Manchester, and service
user representative
psychological dimension – and not a • Vanessa Gilmartin Garrity, mental
positive one. To believe is now to be health nurse and independent
consultant
frightened. The affirmative has, in a • Joanna Johnston, mental health nurse
• Steven Jones, Professor (mental
Nietzschean vocabulary, almost become a health), University of Chester
form of life-denial. There is evidence for • Donna Kemp, lecturer, University of
Huddersfield
this everywhere. • Nicky Lambert, director of teaching
and learning/associate Professor,
In June of this year, The New York Middlesex University
Times opinion section accepted letters mental health nursing. But politically • Stephen McKenna-Lawson, lecturer,
Swansea University
under the heading ‘Is it Ethical to Have speaking, a discourse of despair that • Athia Manawar, senior nurse practice
placement facilitator, Tees Esk Wear
Children in a Climate Crisis?’ There is produces guilt and demotivation must Valleys Foundation Trust
• Dave Munday, lead professional officer,
growing acknowledgement that the be questioned if the goal is change Health Sector, Unite the Union
angst related to perceptions of ecological and rescue, not dread and inertia. Put • Neil Murphy, senior lecturer,
University of Salford
emergency may be discreet and deserving differently, nurses would not use guilt or • Emily Prescott, mental health nurse,
care homes sector
of its own label – climate or eco anxiety shame as a therapeutic tool when working • Mike Ramsay, lecturer in nursing
– defined broadly as “heightened with individuals, so why would we indulge (mental health)/postqualifying BSc
lead, University of Dundee
emotional, mental or somatic distress such narratives on a macro scale? • Jonathon Slater, trainee approved
clinician, Nottinghamshire NHS
in response to dangerous changes in There is term, a model, that already Foundation Trust
the climate system”. The burden of this exists within healthcare that can guide
Publisher
falls more on the younger generation, us here: salutogenesis. This describes Mental Health Nurses Association
©MHNA 2022
who are already seeking record levels of a paradigm of healthcare focused on
psychological help. health and wellbeing, rather than disease Advertising
Mental Health Nurses Association
This is no surprise when you consider (pathogenesis). If we reflect on the mhneditor@gmail.com
the language used. ‘Climate change’ has climate discourse, loud voices and images Subscriptions
MHN is free to members of the Mental
become ‘climate catastrophe’. I have often promote the latter. To paraphrase Health Nurses Association. Annual
already used words such as ‘emergency’ Agent Smith in The Matrix: “The planet subscription (six issues/one volume) for
non-members £72.45/£108.75 Institutions
and ‘dangerous’. However, from the is sick, humans are the disease.” While (VAT and postage included). No part-
volume orders accepted. Orders (cheques
point of view of professionals concerned holding certain truths around carbon payable to Unite the union) to:
primarily with improving how people feel emissions to be self-evident, untempered MHN subscriptions, PO Box 35,
Robertsbridge TN32 5WN
and manage in life, we must ask whether fatalism quickly becomes self-defeating. Tel: 01580 883844 Email: mhn@c-cms.com
this sort of discourse – one oriented Conversely, there is arguably great The views expressed in Mental Health
towards the negative – is pragmatically value of the language of sustainability as Nursing are not necessarily those of the
publisher nor of the editor, except where
useful when it comes to achieving a salutogenic dimension of the climate expressly stated. While every care has
been taken in compiling this publication
significant structural change. discussion. As a model of thought and call and the statements it contains, neither the
That is not to say we should be apathetic to action, it promotes agency and hope. promoter nor the publisher can accept any
responsibility for any inaccuracies, or for
towards the world, and only entertain These are well-established themes of the products or services advertised
adaptations to it, no matter how horrible good nursing, central premises to any ISSN 1353-0283 (online version ISSN 2043-7051)
it seems. This would proffer ignorance, philosophy of care, and as such reveals
moral bankruptcy and betray the critical nursing to be well placed to adopt if not
consciousness baked into the history of lead green initiatives in the 21st century. n
CONTENTS
04
NEWS
• Report says young people need flexible support • Mental
health waiting times are harming young people, survey finds
• Air pollution increases the risk of dementia • Extra funding
for mental health services as part of winter planning
14
06 WHAT KIND OF ‘GREEN’
MENTAL HEALTH NURSES
NHS PAY AWARD 2022/23 FAQS SHOULD WE BE?
Unite the Union’s responses to frequently asked
Simon Hall reflects on the challenges posed
questions about this year’s NHS pay award
by environment changes and the options
available to mental health nurses
08
THE NURSES CLIMATE CHALLENGE: 16
LEADING THE FIGHT AGAINST
CLIMATE COLLAPSE,
CLIMATE CHANGE
ECO ANXIETY AND MENTAL
Anna Fuhrmann outlines the impacts of climate HEALTH NURSING
change and how nurses can act to address it
Fred Ehresmann reports on the climate
change literature and its relation to mental
health nursing
10
SUSTAINABILITY IN
MENTAL HEALTH NURSING 18
STUDENT FOCUS:
Stefi Barna and Siobhan Parslow-Williams describe
how mental health nurses can play a key role in WE CAN TAKE SMALL STEPS
improving health outcomes using the sustainability TO HELP SAVE THE PLANET
in quality improvement framework
Mike Palmer considers the actions students and
staff can take to improve sustainability
20
CLIMATE CARES: PUSHING FOR
ACTION AT THE BORDERLANDS
OF CLIMATE CHANGE AND
MENTAL HEALTH
Jessica Newberry Le Vay and James Diffey report
on the joint initiative that is bringing together a
multidisciplinary team to better understand and
support mental health in the climate crisis
Mental health waiting times are harming young people, survey finds
Thousands of young people are being left while they were waiting for support. the government to end the crisis in young
waiting so long for mental health support The figures come as latest NHS data people’s mental health.
or treatment that they have attempted to shows 66,389 young people aged 19 Emma Thomas, chief executive of
take their own lives, according to research and under were referred to child and YoungMinds, said: “These numbers paint
conducted by the charity YoungMinds. adolescent mental health services in April, a shocking picture of the situation young
Almost 14,000 young people aged under a 109% rise from the 31,720 referred in the people in this country face when it comes
25 completed a survey the charity used for same month before the pandemic. to their mental health.
a government consultation on a ten-year The survey also revealed that more than “We have also seen this reflected in calls
strategy for mental health a third of young people (37%) said they did to our parents’ helpline, with an increasing
More than one in four young people not feel supported by their GP when they number of people saying their child has
(26%) said they had tried to take their own tried to access mental health support or attempted to take their own life and still
life as a result of having to wait for mental advice, and that more than two-thirds of isn’t receiving the right care.
health support, and more than four in young people (71%) said they experienced “For years, politicians have promised
ten (44%) waited more than a month for problems with their relationships with that they will get a grip of the situation,
mental health support after seeking it and family and friends as a result of having to including a recent commitment to a ten
almost one in 10 (9%) young people were wait for mental health support. year plan. But the reality is that with every
turned away. Over half of young people As a result, the charity has launched an month of inaction, things are getting
(58%) said their mental health got worse ‘End The Wait’ campaign, which calls on rapidly worse for young people.”
1. What is the pay award for NHS workers in England 6. What will happen next and how can we show this
for 2022/23? pay award is not good enough for NHS workers in
• The NHS Pay Review Body (PRB) recommendation is for a pay England?
rise effective from 1 April 2022, for all Agenda for Change staff At this stage, your union, Unite is consulting you on whether you
at the full time equivalent salary, of £1,400. and your colleagues would be prepared to take strike action or
• This pay rise will be increased to 4 percent for staff at the top action short of a strike over the government’s pitiful pay award of
of band 6 and all those on band 7. £1,400, which works out at just 4% for many.
• This 4 percent uplift will not be applied to bands 8 and 9.
7. What are the time scales for the consultative
• This increase will include the National Living wage adjustment ballot?
made on 1 April 2022, which applied to Bands 1 and 2. This The consultative ballot will run between Monday 8th August and
means the £1,400 increase will be applied on top of the Sunday 11th September 2022. Unite is recommending you vote
National Living Wage adjustment made in April earlier this year. yes to taking industrial action so that we can make the
government listen and negotiate a better deal.
2. How is NHS Pay in England determined?
NHS pay in England is imposed not negotiated. 8. How will the ballot be conducted?
Health unions do not negotiate with the government on NHS pay It will be an online ballot and every member will be sent a unique
in England, Wales and Northern Ireland. Instead, the UK code to allow them to vote. The ballot will ask you three questions
government uses the NHS Pay Review Body (PRB) process to and will also give you an opportunity to update the details Unite
make decisions on NHS staff pay awards. Unite submits evidence holds on you. As well as being emailed, some members will be
to the PRB report, the PRB then writes a report for the UK sent a letter in the post with a QR code that will allow members to
Government, who then decide whether to implement the access their ballot paper who have no email address registered
recommendations for England. with Unite. In addition to this, text messages will be sent out with
the link to the ballot once voting starts to those who have not
Governments in Wales and Northern Ireland make the same voted. We hope that this will ensure that all members will be able
decision for NHS workers in their Countries, while the Scottish to access the ballot.
Government negotiates NHS pay with trade unions.
9. I do not have access to the internet; can I vote?
3. What is Unite in Health's view of the pay award? You will be able to vote. In the first instance speak to a Unite rep
Unite along with other recognised Trade Unions submitted who should be able to assist you access to the internet, or do ask a
evidence to the PRB asking for an inflation busting pay rise for family member or close friend with access to the internet to assist
NHS workers which would address the staffing crisis in the NHS. you. Failing this contact your local Unite Regional office and a
With real inflation (RPI) running at over 11 percent, the member of Unite staff should be able to assist.
government’s imposed £1,400 pay award for NHS staff, which
works out at just 4 percent for many, amounts to a ‘massive 10. What is a consultative ballot?
national pay cut’. It will also lead to more NHS cuts, as there’s no A consultative ballot is conducted to find out your views. If the
extra money from the Treasury to fund it. collective view is to oppose the settlement and take Industrial
action we are required by law to hold another ballot which has to
We believe enough is enough and NHS workers shouldn’t accept be conducted by post and is conducted by a neutral third party.
another year of a below inflation pay rise. As our General Only after the second legal postal ballot can any action be taken.
Secretary, Sharon Graham has said “This is a kick in the teeth to
NHS workers from the Government”. 11. Will my employer find out how I vote?
Certainly not. The UK Government and the NHS employers will be
4. Will the pay increase impact on universal credit? informed of the result of the ballot but no personal information
There is a possibility that the pay rise may have an impact on or voting preference will be disclosed.
universal credit and we would advise you seek expert advice on
this if this concerns you. Unite is not able to provide expert advice
on universal credit.
17. Can I be struck off my professional register for Talk to your colleagues about why their vote matters. Put up a
taking strike action? campaign poster in your workplace.
Not at all. The different registration bodies and regulators will all • Organise workplace stalls, ‘tea break’ chats and branch
produce their statements regarding Industrial action. These meetings. Talk to your Unite official to order a supply of
bodies all recognise and acknowledge the right to strike and materials.
registrants’ democratic right to express their legal right to take • Talk to your Unite reps for more ideas on how to get the vote
industrial action. Registrant and regulatory bodies will also out in your workplace!
remind us that standards and codes should also be followed as
• Keep checking your email and reading your texts from us!
much a possible.
18. Do I need to tell my manager that I intend to go on If you do not receive a ballot paper either by text, email or post or
strike? know of members who haven’t, please make sure your current
There is no requirement or obligation to inform your manager of contact details are up to date by contacting your local Unite
your intention to take industrial action. District or Regional office, details provided by clicking the
following link www.unitetheunion.org/what-we-do/
19. I’m worried about public perception of NHS workers unite-in-your-region. We strongly urge you to vote for action
who choose to strike in the consultative ballot and show to the Government “Enough
The public are behind you! From the recent poll conducted by the is enough”.
joint health union’s campaign “With NHS Staff” 55 percent of
respondents support a pay rise of at least 9 percent and 58 Pay us like you Care
percent of respondents believe NHS staff would be justified in
taking Industrial action if they received a below inflation pay rise.
It’s important to note that Unite will provide a ‘life and limb’ and
emergency cover to ensure no patients are put at risk. There is no
point in any industrial action if it does not cause some level of
FAIR PAY
for nhs workers
disruption and inconvenience, but rest assured emergency
C
limate change is the greatest but are more severe for the already eur.nursesclimatechallenge.org/en).
public health threat of the 21st vulnerable such as elderly people and It supports nurses in educating their
century. It already negatively those with pre-existing physical and colleagues and communities about the
affects patient and community health mental conditions. health impacts of climate change.
and has an impact on nurses’ work. The effects of climate change will Launched in January 2021, the
Extreme weather events, changing get worse in the next decades as Nurses Climate Challenge (NCC)
disease patterns, and the increasing temperatures are projected to increase Europe provides resources tailored
socioeconomic impacts of climate by more than 1.5ºC (see https://www. to nurses working in the European
change put nurses and other health ipcc.ch/sr15), which will have an healthcare sector, such as theoretical
professionals at the forefront of immense impact on human health and knowledge on climate and health,
fighting the health impacts of our wellbeing. education and advocacy material, and
changing climate. practical measures to integrate climate
The healthcare sector is at the How can nurses act on knowledge into nursing practice.
frontline of climate change, bearing climate change? Alongside these resources, the NCC
the costs of increased disease and more As one of the most trusted professions Europe also serves as a networking
frequent extreme weather events. The (and making up more than 50% of the opportunity for nurses to share their
pressure created by climate change healthcare workforce worldwide), experiences, successes, and challenges.
will also increase the workload and nurses play a critical role in health
psychological stress on healthcare promotion, disease prevention, Creating a climate-smart
professionals. delivering primary and community healthcare system
care, and hold a vital role in educating Nursing practice itself also needs to
Climate change threatens our patients and healthcare professionals change – by mitigating emissions from
health about climate solutions. healthcare delivery, adapting our
The health impacts of climate change As nurses, we need to learn care, and making healthcare climate
include increased respiratory and about climate change and its health resilient.
cardiovascular disease, injuries, and implications to protect our patients Ironically, the very sector
premature deaths related to extreme and communities. We have to empower responsible for healing people is also
weather events. Changing access to each other to acquire the necessary contributing to climate change. It is
food and water supplies as well as knowledge and speak up by advocating estimated to account for 4.4% of global
the increased spread of waterborne and teaching others. We need to learn net emissions (see https://noharm-
illnesses and other infectious diseases how to reduce the environmental europe.org/content/global/health-care-
also add to the increasing health impact of our own work, as well as climate-footprint-report), which, if it
burden. Climate change also threatens how we can protect our vulnerable were a country, would make it the fifth
mental health through post-traumatic patients from climate change effects. biggest emitter in the world.
stress, worsening socioeconomic To support this learning and With this level of emissions and
determinants of health, solastalgia sharing of knowledge and expertise, vast consumption of resources, raw
(distress from environmental change), Health Care Without Harm (https:// materials, and products, the healthcare
and ecoanxiety. noharm-europe.org) created the sector damages the environment and
These health impacts affect us all, Nurses Climate Challenge (https:// undermines our health.
The Nurses Climate Challenge climate change to adequately prepare with knowledge on environmental
Europe collects resources and practical the next generation of nurses. determinants and climate effects on
solutions to empower nurses to fight As future nurses, nursing students the health of specific patient groups.
climate change. It is crucial to share will face the full impacts of climate The transferability of sustainability
knowledge and good examples with change in their work and, in the next competencies into practice should
our colleagues around the world to decades, will have to care for patients be encouraged and climate change,
encourage replication and reduce the who are suffering from the health health, and health promotion can be
negative impacts of climate change on issues climate change creates. It is integrated into clinical teaching.
our patients. extremely important to teach them Nurses must come together and
Nurses need to use their potential now about the challenges they will take a leading role in fighting climate
and become leaders to initiate the encounter when they start practising. change and its impacts on our patients.
changes needed in health systems and We are trusted and educated to realise
society. The NCC Europe provides a The future of climate-smart the potential of early preventative
growing set of free, comprehensive, nursing action. As nurses, we always think
and easy-to-use resources. Healthcare Planetary health, sustainability and systemically, with our patients’ social
needs to both become resilient to climate change are not yet commonly and physical health environments in
climate change and reduce its own taught in nursing schools and mind when supporting their healing.
negative impact. universities across Europe. We need to start integrating
As nurses, we are one of the most To encourage the inclusion of environmental and long-term impacts
trusted professions in Europe and this important content, Health Care of climate change into our practice to
worldwide, and we can use this trust Without Harm Europe, together with keep our patients and communities
to advocate for climate action and ten nursing schools from across healthy. We need to start connecting
teach others about the urgency of our Europe, has developed the Nursing across Europe to teach and learn, and
situation. School Commitment. find the best solutions for climate-
Not only is it important for practising Through the Nursing School smart nursing practice. n
nurses to become knowledgeable and Commitment, nursing educators are
to act, but nursing curricula across pledging to include sustainability and Anna Fuhrmann is a climate officer at
Europe have to integrate the new planetary health in nursing education. Health Care Without Harm Europe and
challenges and opportunities posed by Existing courses can be supplemented a paediatric nurse
Sustainability in
mental health nursing
Siobhan Parslow-Williams
Stefi Barna
Abstract fires; unplanned mass migration due to This article explores the role mental
With the goal of decarbonisation weather and resource related conflict; health nurses can play in reducing
and carbon neutrality in the health and increases in infectious and non- carbon emissions. It takes into
sector by 2045, health professionals
communicable disease. consideration the aspects of healthcare
must implement systemic changes
in their clinical practice to reduce Globally, healthcare has a carbon most damaging to planetary health
carbon use, while meeting equity footprint of 2 gigatonnes of CO2, (see Figure 1), and applies principles of
targets and improving health equivalent to the annual greenhouse sustainable clinical practice healthcare
outcomes. Sustainable healthcare
gas emissions of 514 coal-fired power to guide nurses and departments to
practices address the socio-ecological
determinants that undermine plants. The health system produces 5% make sustainable change both locally
population health, help clinicians of the European Union’s CO2 emissions, and nationally.
intervene as early as possible in approximately 7% of Australia’s, and
the disease process, deliver ‘lean’
in the US it may contribute as much as Sustainable healthcare
healthcare pathways and reduce the
‘triple bottom line’ costs of healthcare 10%. If the global health care sector An environmentally sustainable
provision, in order to benefit patients, were a country itself, it would be the healthcare system offers high-quality
populations and the environment. fifth largest greenhouse gas emitter on services in the present without
Mental health nurses can play a key the planet. compromising the ability to meet the
role in improving health outcomes
The UN Agenda 2030 Sustainable health needs of the future, reduces
using the sustainability in quality
improvement (SusQI) framework. Development Goals have called for the the health system’s contribution to
“mobilisation of all available resources, the climate crisis, creates resilience
Key words participation of all countries, all to extreme weather and offers an
Sustainable value, quality
stakeholders and all people” to work unprecedented opportunity to protect
improvement, SusQI, prevention,
patient self-care, lean care pathways, toward more sustainable futures. the health of our patients, populations,
low carbon treatments To meet national Paris Agreement and planet.
goals, 50 countries have committed to The term sustainable healthcare
creating climate-resilient, low carbon, evokes for many people energy-
G
lobal warming, biodiversity sustainable health systems, including efficient buildings and renewable
loss and the chemical pollution 14 countries that have set a target date energy sources. However, Figure 1
of air, land and water are of reaching net zero emissions by 2050 reminds us that the energy efficiency of
fundamentally undermining the or earlier (Wise, 2021; NHS Net Zero buildings will only deliver a tiny wedge
environmental conditions that support Expert Panel, 2020). of the carbon reduction required for a
human life on Earth. While climate change is no doubt the net zero system.
The destruction of the global natural most important health threat of the The sustainable value equation
environment has been recognised as century, it also presents the “greatest (Figure 2) (Mortimer et al, 2018) is a
the largest threat to human health and opportunity to redefine the social useful tool for calculating outcomes
wellbeing in the 21st century and is and environmental determinants of for patients as well as populations,
already affecting population health health” (Watts et al, 2015), calling each and to weigh them against a ‘triple
around the world (Watts et al, 2015). and every healthcare professional bottom line’ of financial, as well as
Already we are seeing extreme- and department to drastically reduce environmental and social impacts or
weather related morbidity and carbon use, while meeting equity costs (Mortimer et al, 2018).
mortality from flooding, storms and targets and improving health outcomes. Financial costs can be calculated by
LATEST MAGAZINES
HIGH QUAllTY TRUE-PDF
MAG DOWN LOAD.ORG
SUSTAINABILITY
Special issue
patient care and saving money. Figure 4. Driver diagram of sustainable healthcare principles
For more information visit: https://
sustainablehealthcare.org.uk/green-
ward-competition.
5. Education
Learn more about sustainable
healthcare. Educate your colleagues
about the impacts of climate change on
health.
The Nurses Climate Challenge
provides tools and information
about the role of the nurse and
climate change: see: https://
nursesclimatechallenge.org.
Learn how to implement
environmental changes in practice.
The Centre for Sustainable Healthcare
offers various practical online resources
and courses aimed at healthcare
professionals on its website at: https://
sustainablehealthcare.org.uk/courses.
By taking action individually and
professionally mental health nurses Figure 5. The four steps of SusQI
could make a big difference and help
make healthcare sustainable now and in
the future.
Conclusion
Sustainable healthcare addresses
the socio-ecological determinants
that undermine population health,
intervenes as early as possible in
the disease process, delivers ‘lean’
healthcare pathways, and overall polluting, and which can most improve Siobhan Parslow-Williams is the quality
reduces the environmental and socio- quality of care. improvement education lead and Stefi
economic costs of healthcare provision, Evaluations of healthcare Barna is the education director for the
benefiting patients, populations, and the interventions from a triple bottom line Centre for Sustainable Healthcare
environment. perspective are rare and need to be
Within the health system, mental conducted more frequently to guide
References
health care contributes significantly to sustainable clinical decision-making. Centre for Sustainable Healthcare. (2022) Sustainable Quality
Improvement. SusQI. (Available at: https://www.susqi.org
sustainable practice through its reliance Tools such as the sustainability in
(Accessed 16 May 2022).
on non-pharmacological, low-cost and quality improvement framework are Mortimer F. (2010) The sustainable physician. Clin Med 10(2):
D110-111.
low-carbon treatments that empower available to design, measure and report Mortimer F, Isherwood J, Wilkinson A, Vaux E. (2018)
Sustainability in quality improvement: redefining value. Futur
patients for self-management (Palstam changes in clinical operations to facilitate Healthc J 5(2): 88. doi:10.7861/FUTUREHOSP.5-2-88.
et al, 2021). a socially, economically and ecologically NHS Net Zero Expert Panel. (2020) Delivering a “Net Zero”
National Health Service. Available at: https://www.england.
The carbon footprint of mental sustainable healthcare (Centre for nhs.uk/greenernhs/wp-content/uploads/sites/51/2020/10/
delivering-a-net-zero-national-health-service.pdf (Accessed 16
healthcare can be reduced, particularly Sustainable Healthcare, 2022). May 2022).
Palstam A, Andersson M, Lange E, Grenholm A. (2021) A Call to
in the areas of pharmaceuticals, By generating evidence for clinical Include a Perspective of Sustainable Development in Physical
procurement, care pathways, and travel. decision making over the coming Therapy Research. Phys Ther 101(3). doi:10.1093/PTJ/
PZAA228.
Concepts such as the sustainable value decade, mental health nursing can make Watts N, Adger WN, Agnolucci P et al. (2015) Health and climate
change: policy responses to protect public health. Lancet
equation can guide sustainable clinical a significant contribution to achieving a 386(10006): 1861-1914. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(15)60854-6.
Wise J. (2021) COP26: Fifty countries commit to climate resilient
decision-making by revealing which net zero health sector by 2045 (NHS Net and low carbon health systems. BMJ 375: n2734. doi:10.1136/
techniques and processes are the most Zero Expert Panel, 2020). n BMJ.N2734.
T
he question posed by the title of real obstacle (Murali and Oyebode, people have the right to smoke and to
this article is important as we 2004), but it can still be a aspiration. live their live as they wish.
face the growing climate crisis Yet even this sounds defeatist. This notion of ‘interfering’ around
and consider what we can do to help. Shouldn’t being green and aiming for choice was a strong one, but we do
A good starting point that I often sustainable practice be a human right now offer legitimate alternatives and
refer to, is an article by Gunasekara et or a way of life for us all? that is important.
al (2014), which explores what makes It is important to consider what
an excellent mental health nurse. Rising to the challenge our choices are around this climate
In our everyday roles we make it our Previously our profession has emergency? We need to explore ways
business to learn about each person’s considered and met significant of doing things differently and we have
hopes, goals, strengths, and aspirations, dilemmas, although maybe not with a moral duty to do what we can to
and to do what we can to encourage not such a global impact. influence and encourage any greener
progress along the ‘recovery path’. So It was not so long ago when we practices.
it’s important to consider how we can addressed tackling the challenge of This can start by us being really
make this recovery path greener. smoking, especially in our inpatient positive role models. As mental health
It firstly means that as a profession units, and now after systematic change nurses we always give and share a bit
we will need to recognise and respond we are now thankfully saving lives by about ourselves and maybe we can
to ‘climate anxiety’ and other related banning smoking. start the change to being greener by
conditions that are linked to climate I do remember the counter looking at ourselves and colleagues.
change (Kameg, 2020). arguments proposed at the time, that I suspect there are significant
Hence, I would not be surprised
in the future if the ‘Recovery Star’
(Mackeith and Burns, 2010) grew a
new arm based on climate concerns or
amendments made to its user manual
to capture this phenomena.
Wanting to be ‘green’
The hardest concept for mental health
nursing is probably dealing with the
Anja-#pray for ukraine# #helping hands# stop the war from Pixabay
numbers of mental health nurses “Fear of the climate produce with our service users and
who choose the humble bicycle as their families.
their main mode of transport or make emergency is I miss the walking groups as a way of
conscious efforts to reduce their plastic
use as two possible examples from
real and we connecting our service users and their
families with nature, yet for some it
many. should not try to was just great mechanism at providing
I think as a collective of a safe space for others to connect with
professionals, my impression is that we
sugar-coat it” themselves.
do have a social consciousness about Thus I can see the introduction of
climate change and that we do care I believe this will create a bigger horticulture therapy and its benefits
about this. ‘social’ emotional tie to save our into the mental health nursing
planet. As a collective we can make a curriculum having a bigger impact on
Learning from the past difference in collaboration with our recovery and the climate emergency
If we look into our past, we might service users, as mutual role models. than some of the skills required
find some answers there on how to be This may sound controversial, but I on their the current skills passport
greener. am not convinced how conventional (Gonzalex et al, 2010; Howarth et al,
I have looked to see if there has been cognitive behavioural therapy will 2016; Howarth et al, 2018).
a study on a calculated eco footprint of work with climate anxiety as the Maybe that is the clue we have
our old asylums compared to modern reality is that the planet we live in, is from our nursing past, so it is more
day inpatient hospitals, but I couldn’t in a climate emergency. of a reintroduction of what worked in
find one. The fear is real and maybe even the past rather than spending all our
My opinion is that our old hospitals more controversial is that we should efforts creating something radically
were self-sufficient in many ways with not even try to sugar-coat it. new.
many growing and nurturing produce Hence, we might need to explore Mental health nursing values the
on site, having onsite laundries, and how we adapt our entire therapy importance of connecting our service
the majority of staff were local and portfolio to address this eco-anxiety users to the world and more than ever
could walk or cycle to work. (Bauldon and Jachens, 2021), and we it needs to have a full tint of green. n
Now, many hospital sites rely on need to start now.
important deliveries from afar, staff From this we need to review and Simon Hall is a mental health nurse
run the gauntlet daily for car parking modernise mental health nursing and senior teaching fellow at the
spaces and all the green space has gone education on two fronts. University of Southampton
What can we learn from this? Firstly, we need to recognise that @Simon4Hall
our future nursing students will come
Options for being greener into our profession with a passion
References
practitioners about climate preservation and some Bauden P, Jachens L. (2021) A Scoping Review of Interventions
for the Treatment of Eco-Anxiety. International Journal of
The pandemic had a big impact for will come into nursing with lived Environmental Research and Public Health 18: 9636-54.
Gonzalez MT, Hartig T, Patil G. (2010) Therapeutic horticulture
community mental health nursing, experience of climate anxiety. in clinical depression: A prospective study. Research and
as more mental health nurses and Secondly we need to teach Theory for Nursing Practice 23: 312-28.
Gunasekara I, Pentland T, Rodgers T, Patterson S. (2014) What
colleagues worked from home and interventions to support others who makes an excellent mental health nurse? A pragmatic inquiry
initiated and conducted by people with lived experience of
reached out to support those in need experience this. service use. International Journal of Mental Health Nursing
23(2): 101-9.
via various digital platforms. Currently, one of the things we are Hogg T, Stanley S, O’Brien L, Wilson M, Watsford C. (2021)
The growth of telehealth in mental now looking at is creating simple The Hogg Eco-Anxiety Scale: Development and validation
of a multidimensional scale. Global Environmental Change
health is diverse and has its benefits family based simulations that 71: 1-10.
Howarth M, Rogers M, Withnell N, McQuarrie C. (2018)
in terms of increasing access to mental encourage our nursing students to Growing spaces: an evaluation of the mental health recovery
programme using mixed methods. Journal of Research in
services and reducing costs (Touris et have eco-anxiety conversations, and Nursing 23(6): 476-89.
al, 2020). potentially to look to develop the use Howarth M, Withnell N, McQuarrie C. (2016) The Influence
of therapeutic horticulture on social integration. Journal of
However, I actually don’t think of the Hogg Eco-Anxiety Scale into our Public Mental Health 15(3): 136-40.
Kameg B. (2020) Climate Change and Mental Health –
more digitally remote working is the practice (Hogg et al, 2021). Implications for Nurses. Journal of Psychosocial Nursing
‘Eureka’ solution to the climate crisis. 58(9): 25-30.
MacKeith J, Burns S. (2010) The Recovery Star: Organisation
I think we need to do the opposite, by Developing solutions Guide. Second edition. Mental Health Providers Forum:
London.
having mental health nurses physically On reflection, since moving to Murali V, Oyebode F. (2004) Poverty, social inequality and mental
health. Advances in Psychiatric Treatment 10: 216-24.
going out and connecting more to our academia, I do miss the green benefits Torous J, Jän Myrick K, Rauseo-Ricupero N, Firth J. (2020)
greener spaces with our service users of the early intervention for psychosis Digital Mental Health and COVID-19: Using Technology
Today to Accelerate the Curve on Access and Quality
and their families. allotment group and sharing the Tomorrow. JMIR Mental Health 7(3): e18848.
Climate collapse,
eco anxiety and
mental health nursing
Fred Ehresmann
“Planet Earth is
O
ne bed-time in the late summer public health crisis (Harmer et al,
of 2018 my youngest daughter, 2020), academics and practitioners are
then eight years old, told me certainly adding their voices to the triaged onto a
of a planet that is dying and her fears
that she would not live long enough
sounding of the alarm.
waiting list, with the
to experience being a teenager or a The size of the challenge paramedics trying
grown-up. So, what have I made of all the reading
Somehow, I felt that this was not a so far? The latest report from the
to keep it going”
conversation that was going to end Intergovernmental Panel on Climate
with the words “Don’t you worry, Change (2022) confirms that the jury is
everything’s going to be fine.” The now officially in. In any event, we as a species seem to
deployment of a Dad joke – “The planet Anthropogenic climate change is be in the deepest of trouble. To use a
will probably still be alive on Saturday under way to such an extent that we medical metaphor, if our home planet
when we go for hot chocolate” – bought are facing a species-wide challenge were a patient, there would be a crash
me the time that I would need to play that, given the underwhelming team, tubes, bleeping machines, an
catch-up and deploy a suitably well international response from those with army of nurses and a small gaggle of
informed and reassuring response. the power and resources to make a specialist consultants on hand. What
To say that the subsequent four years difference, could result in catastrophic we have is planet Earth triaged onto a
have been a bit of an emotional roller- consequences. waiting list, with the paramedics trying
coaster ride could win medals for Theories abound not only about to keep it going and pushed up the list
understatement. how we have ended up in this mess as a matter of urgency.
The world of climate science and what needs to happen next, but
literature really is not for the faint- also what may well happen should Psychological trauma
hearted. However, I discovered quickly responses continue to be inadequate. While I have used a metaphor drawn
that a path has already been made For some, civilisational collapse and from physical medicine, we know
through the complex and growing human extinction in the near term are that where there is physical trauma,
maze of information that is available. inevitably on the table (McPherson, psychological trauma is often not
From a range of papers proposing 2020; Ozarko, 2018). far behind, and working with people
clear links between climate change For others, we are on the threshold who are experiencing psychological
and its impacts on mental health (for of a major transformation of human trauma is the bread-and-butter work
example Tromble et al, 2017; Hayes et consciousness that represents the of the mental health nurse (Isobel and
al, 2018; Kameg, 2020) to suggestions next evolutionary leap for our species Delgado, 2018; Menschner and Maul,
that climate change and its future (Patten, 2017). 2016).
impacts to be core components in Between these two poles there We are all facing an international
nurse education (for example Leffers seems to be a range of positions public health crisis and, as the
et al, 2017; Rosa and Upvall, 2019) and narratives. I am still unsure recent pandemic has demonstrated,
and clamouring for the World Health as to whether we are talking nurses from all disciplines are on the
Organization to declare the climate hospice nursing or midwifery with frontline.
emergency to be an international complications. As a mental health nurse who has
been talking increasingly regularly Woodbury (2019) suggests an Climate Psychology Alliance from the
with people who have been profoundly alternative formulation of ‘climate oncoming storm.
impacted by our climate and ecological trauma’ that speaks to the enormity of Finally, I seem to have found
crises, I am forced to ask myself ‘what what climate scientists are predicting somewhere to roll up my sleeves and
does mental health actually mean in a is ahead for us if we continue to act get stuck in with ‘climate cafes’ and
context that is so unstable and where with the ongoing inadequate level of their free therapeutic outreach service.
the future seems to look so bleak?’ changes that are required to steer us They’ve been very kind and very
With the term ‘eco anxiety’ entering away from catastrophe. welcoming. But it can be a bit lonely
the narrative, and the arrival of the As we know, trauma responses are being the only mental health nurse in
Hogg Eco-Anxiety Scale (Hogg et al, not conceptualised as pathology but as the village. Anyone else fancy joining
2021), the pathologising of people’s adaptations and attempts to continue me? n
genuine and valid fears for the future functioning – sane responses to insane
seems to be under way. circumstances. Fred Ehresmann is a mental health
Waiting in the wings are fledgling nurse specialising in working with
recommendations for the ‘treatment’ The relevance of mental children, young people and their
of eco anxiety (Borden and Jachens, health nursing families, and is a senior lecturer
2021). While some of the initial Arguably, climate breakdown and in mental health nursing at the
findings are promising and the absence the predicted consequences raise University of the West of England.
of a pharmacological approach challenging questions about the He is a member of the Climate
reassuring, the use of the word relevance of mental health nursing Psychology Alliance (see https://www.
‘treatment’ is still a bit of a worry. beyond holding the keys, doing the obs, climatepsychologyalliance.org)
Perhaps eco anxiety is the kind of dishing out the meds and supervising
term that brings an air of familiarity people in the community.
to an emerging phenomenon that is Perhaps predictably, the
References
unfamiliar, perhaps bringing a sense of psychologists and psychotherapists Bauden P, Jachens L. (2021) A Scoping Review of Interventions
for the Treatment of Eco-Anxiety. International Journal of
reassurance to practitioners seeking to seem to have grasped the nettle Environmental Research and Public Health. 18: 9636-54
know how best to respond. first and started the process of https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph18189636.
Kameg B. (2020) Climate Change and Mental Health –
Joanna Macy (1995) rather more organising a coherent response to an Implications for Nurses. Journal of Psychosocial Nursing
58(9): 25-30).
aptly uses the term ‘environmental increasingly alarming situation, having Harmer A, Eder B, Gepp S, Leetz A, van de Pas R. (2020) WHO
should declare climate change a public health emergency.
despair’. In subsequent writing, for organised themselves into The Climate BMJ 368 https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.m797.
example Macy and Brown (2014), this Psychology Alliance. Hayes K, Blashki G, Wiseman J, Burke S, Reifels L. (2018)
Climate change and mental health: risks, impacts and priority
environmental despair is not packed They appear to have the full backing actions. International Journal of Mental Health Systems
12(28) https://doi.org/10.1186/s13033-018-0210-6.
neatly into a pathological framework, and climate-literacy of their regulatory Hogg T, Stanley S, O’Brien L, Wilson M, Watsford C. (2021)
but rather more eloquently and bodies that the Nursing and Midwifery The Hogg Eco-Anxiety Scale: Development and validation
of a multidimensional scale. Global Environmental
thoughtfully discussed from an eco- Council simply seems unable to Change 71: 102391-401. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
gloenvcha.2021.102391.
systemic perspective. muster. Isobel S, Delgado C. (2018) Safe and collaborative
communication skills: a step towards Mental Health Nurses
The excruciatingly painful Sadly, and arguably predictably, implementing trauma informed care. Archives of Psychiatric
experiences of environmental despair the NMC doesn’t appear to have Nursing 33(2): 291-6.
Leffers J, Levy R, Nicholas P, Sweeney C. (2017) Mandate for
are seen as a sign of healthy awakening the stomach to engage with the the Nursing Profession to Address Climate Change Through
Nursing Education. Journal of Nursing Scholarship 49(6):
to, and empathy for, the distress and issue beyond relegating it to a 679-87.
Macy J. (1995) Working through environmental despair. In:
suffering of a world – human and non- cursory mention of ‘sustainability’ Roszak T, Gomes M, Kanner A. (Eds.). Ecopsychology:
human – that is in freefall destruction, in its labyrinthine and of course Restoring the Earth/Healing the Mind. Counterpoint:
London.
and a gateway to meaningful action. spectacularly vague new standards. Macy J, Brown M. (2014) Coming back to life: the updated
guide to the Work That Reconnects. New Society Publishers:
Once again, mental health nurses London.
McPherson G. (2020) Extinction foretold, extinction ignored.
appear to have been thrown under Nature Bats Last. https://guymcpherson.com/extinction_
“We are all facing the bus of real world events in the foretold_extinction_ignored.
Menschner C, Maul A. (2016) Issue brief: Key ingredients for
ongoing rush to create the perfect
an international
successful trauma-informed care implementation. Centre for
Healthcare Strategies: Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.
generic ‘portable nurse’ and the NMC’s https://www.chcs.org/media/ATC_whitepaper_040616.pdf.
public health crisis, obsession with justifying its own Ozarko D. (2018) Beyond hope: letting go of a world in collapse.
Deb Ozarko Publishing: London.
relevance. Patten T. (2017) A new republic of the heart: a guide to inner
and nurses from all On this one, our regulator has clearly
work for holistic change: awakening into evolutionary
activism. A guide to inner work for holistic change (Sacred
Activism). North Atlantic Books.
disciplines are on taken its eye completely off the ball.
For want of anywhere else to go, I
Rosa W, Upvall M. (2018) The case for a paradigm shift: from
global to planetary nursing. Nursing Forum 54: 165-70.
W
hen I agreed to write an incorporating this into their nursing Do we have any green champions
article on the environment courses. However, this needs to be at the university level currently? At a
and sustainability from done across the board and be an ward level, more sustainability/green
the student perspective, my initial important part of the curriculum so champions are being created in some
reaction was to question how much students can understand the vast effect NHS trusts, which is a positive step.
our profession can do to influence or that providing healthcare has on the This needs to be implemented across all
reduce negative impacts and improve environment. trusts though, and best practice shared.
sustainability. Should an amendment be added to the There is a strong argument for nurses
Luckily, my supportive university NMC Code and Future Nurse Standards to be included in discussions at board
mentors Julia Parkhouse and Stephen for example? I feel that students can level and in executive roles (Butterfield
McKenna-Lawson were on hand with be empowered to identify and suggest et al, 2021). Nurses have exceptionally
some excellent articles and advice, and possible improvements to workplace important contributions to make as
as I did my research I realised there practice by providing them with strong independent practitioners.
was a lack of awareness on my part, sustainability education, as suggested by At Swansea University, we have
which I was keen to overcome. Finding Aronsson et al (2020). a student leadership academy that
out more has been a positive learning We all could be advocates for more enables students to develop and think
journey. environmentally sustainable practices, about their leadership skills. Perhaps
Climate change and sustainability are not just for our patients (Richardson, we could have an environment and
obviously massive issues with many 2020). Sustainable healthcare needs to sustainability academy and develop the
moving parts at local, national and involve patients and make them more next generation of green champions,
international levels. aware of the issues facing the NHS innovators and climate-literate nurses.
A well-quoted figure is that the NHS and the UK in the future. Could this I recently undertook learning
contributes between 4-5.5% of all the form part of the health promotion and disability champion training on a
UK’s carbon emissions and that around public health work that we engage in as placement, which significantly raised
80% of consumables relate to treatment nurses? my awareness and understanding of
and care (Gallagher and Dix, 2020). There is the acronym MECC, standing the issue. Something similar on the
Collectively, as over 60% of the NHS for Make Every Contact Count, for environment and sustainability would
workforce are nurses, it’s possible to see improving patient health. Perhaps be equally beneficial for students.
our current and future importance in adding an extra E for Environment to NHS Wales has set ambitious goals
helping to reduce these figures. Working the end would be useful. of being net zero/carbon neutral by
together we can have a massive impact.
Breaking it down
With an issue so large and complex, I
think the best approach is to break it
down into simpler parts. We could start
with awareness and education.
Climate change/sustainability
education is something that needs
to be incorporated at all educational
Arek Socha from Pixabay
of their lives.
The impacts of the climate crisis on
mental health and wellbeing outcomes
are difficult to measure, and there is still
much that we don’t know about them.
@NurseinPractice #nursinginpractice
Complimentary tickets* are now available to attend any of our Nursing in Practice events. Secure your place
today by signing-up for free at registration.nursinginpractice365.uk
* This is an event for all fully qualified, primary and community-based nurses only.