Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IEEEXplore
IEEEXplore
Authorized licensed use limited to: Tec de Monterrey. Downloaded on July 25, 2009 at 14:56 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
improve the total efficiency of the whole system by the direct basic step-up converter level and has a ripple content of
control of the quantity of hydrogen fuel consumed via the period T/N.
control of the fuel cell output current [13]. The simplest
converter structure with this functionality is the basic, single
level, step-up converter. However, this topology suffers D2
from excessive component stress because of the high current N
on the fuel cell side. Interleaving the basic, single level, step-
up converter makes it possible to improve the quality of the D
fuel cell output current in terms of current ripple magnitude N
n
and harmonics. ,JW
4 2 theollvatl J I XN = )
( VI
(k-N.u).(N.a+l-k) (2)
theorical XN Nc I-a
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 The advantage of the interleaving technique may be
Duty cycle, -
demonstrated by normalising the fuel cell output current
Fig. 2. Theoretical and actual output/input ratio. ripple to that due to a basic, single level step-up converter:
Al
=100 XN % (4)
II. BASIC INTERLEAVED STEP-UP CONVERTERS A ind N
In this section we consider N interleaved basic, step-up
converters for two cases dependent on the way the N where Al .d is the peak-to-peak current ripple of the simple
inductances are manufactured. level step-up converter.
A. Individual inductances Figure 4 depicts the current ripple reduction ratio for
Figure 3 depicts a basic interleaved step-up converter of N values of N from 2 to 4. It can be observed that the peak
identical levels where the inductances L1 to LN are realised current ripple is reduced by a factor of 1/N for N interleaved
by a separate magnetic core. The gate signals to the power converters and that the minimum current ripple occurs at
switching devices K1 to KN are successively phase shifted by discrete duty cycles given by ac = a/N; where a = 1 to N-i,
T/N where T is the switching period. Thus, the current giving the theoretical case for complete current ripple
delivered by the fuel cell is shared equally between each cancellation.
Authorized licensed use limited to: Tec de Monterrey. Downloaded on July 25, 2009 at 14:56 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
50
30 \
. <, \ 1 ,> , ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~j,.j where
windings.
vj =Lj. dtddt'L
L1 and M1
di Lj N
diLji,
dt
WN =k.
1 -SO (5) LI L2 L3 LN
Authorized licensed use limited to: Tec de Monterrey. Downloaded on July 25, 2009 at 14:56 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Note that whilst the active volume of the magnetic circuit arrangement the external cores will saturate unless their
remains the same, the N inductances realised on a combined dimensions are increased. This arrangement is not of interest.
magnetic core will occupy lower space than the N-individual Another arrangement of basic interleaved, single step-up
inductances. converters can be considered as discussed in [16]. Here, the
authors have considered two interleaved structures where the
TABLE I inductors are replaced by an interphase transformer (IPT).
IMPACT OF CENTRAL COLUNM ON INPUT CURRENT RIPPLE However, this IPT performs the interleaving function but
1c << 11L It = 11L c >>» L does not contribute to an improved step-up voltage ratio
(No central (Same (Different which is limited, as in the basic and multiple level
column) material) material) interleaved structures, to approximately 4.
R L(ind) 2 lo 2 lo 2 lo Thus, when a high step-up voltage is required, the
FL -S sL SO IL SO previous structures show a limitation as depicted in Figure 2.
RL(com) lo 1 1 One solution is to cascade the converters to reach the desired
ItL -So 'SOItL 0tL'SO step-up ratio of 8 to 10:1. Alternatively, full-bridge
topologies can be used.
Rc 0lo lo lo
| *c N SO |Lc N So Ic N s0 II. INTERLEAVED FULL-BRIDGE DC-DC CONVERTER
(R L(com) + N Rc lo 2.1oo
In this part, we consider interleaving structures that
*c SO FL SO OL
contain a transformer to achieve the desired voltage step-up
So
AiL(com) increased 1 greater than 4. The principle of operation can be analysed
1
AhL(independant) under steady state conditions and shown to be similar to the
2
previous circuit topologies without transformer, hence we
Figure 7 illustrates simulation results for the case of three will not present the case of N interleaved structures. Also,
interleaved converters having independent inductances (a) note here that, only voltage-fed full-bridges converters are
combined inductances with [t = It L (b), and combined considered. In fact, current-fed, full-bridge converters need
ItLc the 7highlextra circuitry to make them work properly, otherwise, they
c
inductances with p »> L (C). Figure 7 highlights benefit can be damaged by overvoltages appearing at switching
indctncewtht
Figure
of combining inductances in the same magnetic core. Indeed, instants due to the transformer leakage inductance.
with the same magnetic core between the central and external Additionally, structures with voltage clamping snubbers
columns, we do not change the current ripple seen by the fuel seem to be unsuitable for fuel cell applications because
cell. However, the ripple in each converter level is reduced. power sometimes needs to be reinjected to the supply, which
In the case where different material is used between the is unacceptable for fuel cell systems.
central and external columns, i.e. when the condition of The considered structure is depicted in Figure 8 and
»c >>L is satisfied, the current ripple seen by both the fuel consists of three H-bridge converters, interleaved on the
cell and each converter level is reduced. primary side of each transformer. The transformer secondary
windings are star connected and supply a three phase diode-
'LI 'L2 'L3 bridge rectifier.
will notgetconsiderinsight
To first of the behaviour of the
the leakage inductance of eachstructure,
we
1 V,\ / a T IL *Vl a-T transformer.
L\\ \ \'.,\'\. \ '\\, ind Lind (a) In fact, with the parasitic capacitance of each semi-
conductor, they can avoid apparition of high di/dt. Besides,
they can allow commutation at zero voltage.
v K
~~~~~~~~V
-2xT- 1+
~~~~~~~~_
LX' /\\/'\,//'\ I'''X3
LIRL
(b)K
1 a24
L
K"
FiL.7.2 Individual converter cub2ents (left) and fuel cell cur2en (right).
Authorized licensed use limited to: Tec de Monterrey. Downloaded on July 25, 2009 at 14:56 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
A. Principle of operation III. THREE-PHASE PWM INVERTER-RECTIFIER
Control of the three individual full-bridge converters is STRUCTURE
delayed by 1/3 of the switching period in order to obtain The three-phase PWM inverter-rectifier is depicted in fig.
three-phase balanced (fundamental) voltages. For each 10. In this case a star-star three-phase transformer is used.
converter, phase shift control is adopted. It consists of Two types of control signals can be applied to the power
holding the gate signal of the top switches of one leg on semi-conductors; 1800 conduction (a) or 1200 conduction (b).
during half of the period and delaying the top switches of the The secondary phase voltage obtained for each control
other leg by an angle a, this considered to be the duty cycle schematic is shown in Fig. 11.
of the structure. A complementary control is adopted for
switches situated on the bottom of the structure. Three cases A Inverter switch ratings
arise, depending on the duty cycle. In fact, the phase voltage The maximum current rating of each semi-conductor is
in the secondary side of the transformer has a particular equal to lfc for 1200 conduction control and lfc /2 for 1800
shape depending on the phase shift and hence the DC output conduction. The peak voltage Vp across each semi-conductor
voltage of the rectifier [17], as illustrated in Figure 9, is equal to Vfc in both cases. Hence, the total converter
showing the case for 0< a <.2/3(a), n/3 < a < 2 2r/3 (b), switch rating is given by:
2 .2/3 < a < fC (c). 6 I
The main feature of this configuration is that the voltage VA = fc,k V = 3- Ifc Vfc 180°conduction (10)
can be doubled depending on the duty cycle and hence allow k=l 2 p,k
the use of a transformer with a lower turn ratio. Besides, by 6
choosing appropriate control, the DC inductor L is subject to VA = E I V = 6 -fc* Vfc 120conduction (11)
no current ripple (Fig. 9-c), allowing a reduced size. k=l
B. Inverter switch ratings
For the three cases, the maximum current flowing through L
the semi-conductor is giving by:
Imax 2c
S=2 (8)a v2
lf being the nominal current delivered by the fuel cells. Co
The peak voltage VP across the semi-conductor is equal to H H H
the fuel cell output voltage Vfc. Thus, the total converter
switch rating is then given by:
Fig. 10. Three-phase PWM inverter-rectifier structure.
VA =1A2
, 1 fc,kV
2 Vpk
k12 .
k=1 (9)
= 6Ifc Vp Vs,i
2.n.VfJ3
vn.Vfc/3
Vs3-1V'iVQ ~~~~~~~~VDC
nl.Vrc flK .Vrc
o
/2 '17l^
_ ,_
0
.T/I
l|I
_(01a)_s_7, T
(a)
X /3 X ~~~~~~/6 1 13 '172
2.n.V-c
nl.V~
, vs 1
v
O (b.ratT i I T ) 1 1 f lVf
-n.Vfc X I1I
lla6 v 1 j l1
T
0 >I (c)
-n.Vrc
V Fig. 11. Secondary phase voltages. (a) 1800 conduction. (b) 1200 conduction.
Authorized licensed use limited to: Tec de Monterrey. Downloaded on July 25, 2009 at 14:56 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
IV. COMPARISON OF THE STRUCTURES converters allows for boosting of converter the output
The main feature of interleaving basic step-up converters voltage when three individuals transformers are used. It is an
is that it reduces the fuel cell input current ripple according to attractive structure but, for vehicle prototype design has a
the number of basic converters being interleaved. trade-off in terms of core volume. The three-phase PWM
Besides, the volume of each inductance is reduced by the inverter-rectifier improves on transformer volume. Moreover,
number of the interleaved converter compared to one basic with proper control, it allows for lower total installed silicon.
converter. Moreover, when inductances are combined and
with appropriate material, we can further reduce the current
ripple, and gain space. However, the voltage step-up is VI. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
constrained to approximately 4. For a high voltage bus one The authors acknowledge the support of the UK
can use cascaded converters. Engineering and Physical Science Research Council
Another solution is to use structures with a transformer. (EPSRC), via Grant No. GR/S81971/01.
An interleaved, three individual, full-bridge converter has the
advantage of boosting the output voltage by a factor of two
without increasing the transformer turns ratio and with a VII. REFERENCES
proper control, the output current can exhibit low current [1] Rodatz P., Buchi F., Onder C., Guzzella L. "Operational aspects of a
ripple. However, this topology has the disadvantage of large PEFC stack under practical conditions," Journal of power
requiring higher total switch utilisation compared to the sources
PWM three-phase, inverter-rectifier. Besides, in the PWM [2] A. J. Appleby, and F. R. Foulkes. "Fuel Cell Handbook," Book, Van
three-phase, inverter-rectifier structure, we can reduce the Nostrand Reinhold, 1989.R. S.
number of switches, whic allw[3] EG&G Technical Services Inc. "Fuel Cell Handbook
(Sixth Edition),"
number of switches, which allows a reduction of their Book, U.S. Department of Energy, 2002.
associated gate components. Moreover, the use of a three- [4] MES-DEA, Fuel cell technical datasheet, http://wwwcebide.
phase transformer in the PWM three-phase inverter-rectifier [5] N. Schofield, H.T. Yap and C.M. Bingham. "Hybrid energy sources
structure is the best choice since it requires a smaller core. for electric and fuel cell vehicle propulsion," IEEE VPP Conf., (2005).
more adequate since we [6] Gemmen
The 1800 conduction control is also moreadequate "Analysis for the Effect of Inverter Ripple Current on Fuel
obTain the lowerchotal switchntroliS
ation
obtain the lower total switch utilisation.
Cell Operating Condition," ASME Inter. Mech. Eng. Congress and
Exposition, pp. 279-289, Nov. 2001.
Normalised to Vfc Ifc and considering 1:10 step [7] s. K. Mazumder, K. Acharya, C. L. Haynes, R. Jr. Williams, M. R.
von Spakovsky, D. J. Nelson, D. F. Rancruel, J. Hartvigsen, R. S.
requirement, Table II summarises the silicon requirement for
presented in the paper.
Gemmen "Solid-oxide-fuel-cell performance and durability: resolution
each structure presented in the paper.
each structure
of the effects of power-conditioning systems and application loads,"
IEEE trans. On Power Electronics, pp. 1263 -1278, Vol. 19, Issue
5, Sept. 2004.
TABLE II [8] K. Acharya, S. K. Mazumder, R. K. Burra, "Impact of power-
AUDIT OF CONVERTER SILICION REQUIREMENTS electronics systems on the performance and durability of tubular solid-
oxide fuel cell," Proc. of IEEE Applied Power Electronics Conference
Structure No. of No. of Maximum silicon VA and Exposition, Vol. 3, pp. 1515 -1520, 2004.
switches diodes rating [9] F. Profumo, A. Tenconi, M. Cerchio, R. Bojoi, G. Gianolio "Fuel Cells
for Electric Power Generation: Peculiarities and Dedicated Solutions
2x Basic 2 2 8 for Power Electronic Conditioning Systems," EPE 2004.
converter [10] Iftikhar A. Khan, "DC-To-DC Converters for Electric and Hybrid
Interleaved N 2N 2N 8 Vehicules".
basic converters [11] Liang Yan, Brad Lehman "An Integrated Magnetic Isolated Two-
Inductor Boost Converter: Analysis, Design and Experimentation,"
Interleaved Full- 12 18 9 IEEE Trans. On Power Electronics, Vol. 20, No. 2, pp. 332-42, March
Bridge converter (3 diodes, 6 switches) 2005.
[12] Rik W. A. A. De Doncker, D. M. Divan, M. H. Kheraluwala "A Three-
Three-phase 6 12 6 1200 (diodes/switches) Phase Soft-Switched High-Power-Density dc/dc Converter for High-
PWM inverter- Power Applications," IEEE Trans. On Industry Applications, Vol. 27,
rectifier converter 5 1800 (2 diodes, 3 No. 1, pp. 63-73, January/February 1991.
switches) [13] K. Rajashekara "Propulsion System Strategies for Fuel Cell Vehicles,"
SAE Technical paper series.
[14] A. Lachichi "Mod6lisation et stabilit6 d'un r6gulateur hybride de
courant/Application aux convertisseurs pour piles a combustible," Phd
thesis, Universit6 of Franche-Comt6, 2005, http 5//te1ccsd.cnrsfr/tel-
V. CONCLUSIONS 00083112/en/
Because of their intrinsic characteristics, fuel cells cannot [15] S. Chandrasekaran, L. U. Gokdere "Integrated Magnetics for
be used without the use of static inverters to feed an electric Interleaved DC-DC Boost Converter," IEEE PESC'04.
[16] G. Calderon-Lopez, A. J. Forsyth, D. R. Nuttall "Design and
load. The paper has presented three examples of DC-DC PerformanceEvalationofa O-kWInterleavedBoost Converterfora
converter topologies based on interleaving techniques. Fuwel Cell Electric Vehicle," IPEMC 2006.
The first structure considers an interleaved, basic, single [17] c. Liu, A. Johnson, J-S. Lai "Modeling and Control of a Novel Six-Leg
ste-upconertr.This
step-upconverter. ~
structure, even simple, improves the
~ '
Thlree-phlase High-Power Converter for Low Voltage Fuel Cell
Applications," IEEE Power Electronics Specialists Conference, pp.
quality of the current drawn by the fuel cell, especially when 4715-21, 2004.
all inductances are realised in the same magnetic core with
appropriate material. However, it presents limits when a high
voltage step-up is required. Structures with transformers have
then been investigated. The use of three, full-bridge DC-DC
Authorized licensed use limited to: Tec de Monterrey. Downloaded on July 25, 2009 at 14:56 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.