Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jurnal 3 Proportion and Clinical Relevance
Jurnal 3 Proportion and Clinical Relevance
Behr et al.
Intraspinal Air in Pneumomediastinum
Cardiopulmonary Imaging
Original Research
Downloaded from www.ajronline.org by 114.125.201.184 on 03/31/21 from IP address 114.125.201.184. Copyright ARRS. For personal use only; all rights reserved
P
represent the official views of the National Institutes
of Health.
enon in which air is present in graphic finding than initially believed [2].
the extradural or intradural com- Although intraaxial spinal air often marks
1
Department of Radiology, Memorial Sloan Kettering partments of the spinal canal. severe cranial or spinal injury [3], spinal epi-
Cancer Center, 1275 York Ave, Box 29, New York, NY Case reports in the literature most frequently dural air is generally asymptomatic and
10065. Address correspondence to G. Behr
describe pneumorrhachis in association with resolves without neurologic sequelae [1]. Be-
(behrg@mskcc.org).
iatrogenic injury or direct trauma to the cause of the frequency with which pneumor-
2
Department of Radiology, Columbia University Medical spine or skull but also note it in cases of rhachis may be observed in cases of pneumo-
Center, New York, NY. pneumomediastinum, pneumopericardium, mediastinum, awareness of the phenomenon
3
and pneumoperitoneum [1]. The frequency and its most typically benign nature may
Greater Baltimore Medical Center, Baltimore, MD.
of pneumorrhachis among patients with spare patients additional imaging, instrumen-
4
Department of Internal Medicine, Memorial Hermann pneumomediastinum is unknown. Fewer tation, and other unnecessary measures [4, 5].
Hospital, Houston, TX. than 150 cases have been described in the lit- The purpose of this retrospective, single-
erature, and it is usually described as exceed- center study was to determine the incidence
AJR 2018; 211:321–326 ingly rare. In one study, however, the investi- of pneumorrhachis associated with pneumo-
0361–803X/18/2112–321
gators estimated a proportion of 9.5% among mediastinum and to assess the most common
children with spontaneous pneumomediasti- findings and causes of pneumorrhachis-
© American Roentgen Ray Society num (42 subjects, four cases), suggesting that associated pneumomediastinum.
Materials and Methods Results the spinal air was introduced exclusively by
Medical records from New York Presbyterian We found 422 instances of the word direct penetration. After exclusion of this pa-
Hospital–Columbia University Medical Center “pneumomediastinum” in the CT reports. tient, the proportion of pneumorrhachis was
were retrospectively reviewed from January 2005 After reviewing these CT scans, we iden- 5.8% (Table 1). Details of each subject are
to September 2013. We conducted a search of the tified 241 separate patients whose scans summarized in Table 2.
PACS radiographic database for all CT scans con- showed pneumomediastinum. One patient, a In each case epidural spinal air was pre-
Downloaded from www.ajronline.org by 114.125.201.184 on 03/31/21 from IP address 114.125.201.184. Copyright ARRS. For personal use only; all rights reserved
taining the word “pneumomediastinum” in their 47-year-old woman with interstitial lung dis- sent, and the patients had no related neurolog-
official reports. Approval for the study was ob- ease and without pneumorrhachis, had two ic symptoms. There were no significant dif-
tained from the Columbia University Medical scans showing pneumomediastinum sepa- ferences in age (p = 0.52) or sex (p = 0.77)
Center institutional review board. rated by a 4-month interval. We considered between those with pneumorrhachis and those
Each scan was reviewed by two investigators these to represent two discrete episodes of without it, nor was there any difference re-
(attending radiologist with 6 years’ experience and pneumomediastinum. This yields a total of garding the presence of pneumothorax (p =
4th-year medical student trained to identify air in 242 instances of pneumomediastinum. 0.585) or median sternotomy (p = 0.088).
the mediastinum and spinal canal on CT images). The mean age of patients with pneumo- Pneumorrhachis was observed more fre-
Data collected included age and sex of the patient; mediastinum was 54.6 years and of patients quently in cases of the most severe grade (grade
date and type of scan; presence, location, and sever- with coexisting pneumorrhachis was 51.0 C) of pneumomediastinum (11 cases [8.2%],
ity of pneumomediastinum; presence of pneumo- years. We identified 15 cases of pneumorrha- p = 0.304); the relationship, however, was not
thorax; presence of median sternotomy wires; and chis, which corresponds to an overall propor- statistically significant. However, pneumorrha-
presence and location of pneumorrhachis. Repeat tion of 6.1%. One subject with evidence of chis was observed significantly more frequent-
scans (scans determined to be within the same clin- pneumorrhachis on a CT scan was excluded ly in patients with distribution of air in all three
ical episode of pneumomediastinum) were exclud- from our analysis because of a recent history mediastinal compartments (13 cases [16.2%],
ed from the analysis. The readers had access to the of a gunshot wound involving the spine. Al- p < 0.001). It was observed significantly less
original radiologist’s reported findings. Each reader though that patient’s CT revealed both medi- frequently in patients with air distributions lim-
independently assessed for the presence or absence astinal and spinal air, there was a chance that ited to the anterior compartment (0 cases) and
of pneumomediastinum and pneumorrhachis. Dis-
crepancies were resolved by consensus. Only one
TABLE 1: Rates of Pneumorrhachis
reader recorded details such as location and sever-
ity of the pneumomediastinum. Pneumorrhachis Pneumorrhachis
Presence or absence of pneumomediasti- Characteristic All Patients Absent Present p
num and of air in the spinal canal was assessed No. 242 228 14
by means of CT in both standard soft-tissue and
Mean age (y) 54.4 ± 20.4 54.6 ± 20.1 51 ± 24.1 0.52
lung window and level settings. The severity of
pneumomediastinum was graded according to Sex 0.77
the following schema described by Kaneki et al. Male 167 (69.0) 158 (69.3) 9 (64.3)
[6] in 2000. This schema is roughly analogous to Female 75 (31.0) 70 (30.7) 5 (35.7)
the distribution of air within a vertical medias-
Pneumothorax present 102 95 (41.7) 7 (50.0) 0.585
tinal plane: A, air only superior to the carina; B,
air both above and below the carina but terminat- Sternotomy present 90 88 (38.6) 2 (14.3) 0.088
ing superior to the orifice of the pulmonary veins; Grade 0.304
C, air that extends inferiorly even further; and O, A 28 27 (11.8) 1 (7.1)
air in another pattern (e.g., isolated to an inferior
B 37 37 (16.2) 0 (0)
area). Distribution, correlating to air distribution
in a transverse plane, was defined as anterior, mid- C 134 123 (53.9) 11 (78.6)
dle, and posterior. Anterior indicated air anterior O (other) 43 41 (18.0) 2 (14.3)
to the great vessels; middle, air between the great Distribution < 0.001
vessels and the esophagus; and posterior, air pos-
Anterior only 76 76 (33.3) 0 (0)
terior to the esophagus.
Patient charts were reviewed to determine the Middle or posterior 86 85 (37.3) 1 (7.1)
likely cause of pneumomediastinum if this in- Anterior, middle, and posterior 80 67 (29.4) 13 (92.9)
formation was not evident from the scan itself. Causea 0.146
Causes of pneumomediastinum were defined as
1, Spontaneous 15 12 (5.3) 3 (21.4)
spontaneous, secondary to underlying lung abnor-
malities, secondary to iatrogenic injury, and sec- 2, Underlying lung abnormality 32 30 (13.2) 2 (14.3)
ondary to other trauma. Data were stratified ac- 3, Iatrogenic 181 172 (75.4) 9 (64.3)
cording to presence or absence of pneumorrhachis 4, Traumatic 8 8 (3.5) 0 (0)
and according to each of the foregoing variables.
Note—Values in parentheses are percentages.
The two-tailed t test was used to calculate p for aThe cause could not be determined for six patients, so they were not included in this analysis, and the total
age and the Fisher exact test for all other variables. number of patients in this section is 236.
in patients with air in the middle and posterior ic ketoacidosis [18], leukemia [19], influenza been most frequently described in associa-
compartments (one case [1.2%]). [20], weightlifting [21, 22], and peanut aspira- tion with pneumomediastinum.
The proportion of pneumorrhachis was tion [23]. Overall, fewer than 150 cases have Pneumomediastinum may result from iat-
also greater in patients with spontaneous been described in the literature. rogenic or traumatic injury, extension of sub-
pneumomediastinum. Among 15 cases of Iatrogenic introduction of air via lumbar cutaneous emphysema or retropneumoperito-
spontaneous pneumomediastinum, three puncture, spinal or epidural anesthesia, or spi- neum, tracheobronchial or esophageal lesions,
Downloaded from www.ajronline.org by 114.125.201.184 on 03/31/21 from IP address 114.125.201.184. Copyright ARRS. For personal use only; all rights reserved
(20.0%) included pneumorrhachis. Of these nal surgery is the most commonly reported or alveolar rupture, also known as the Mack-
cases, one was associated with cough and up- cause of pneumorrhachis [4, 24]. The second lin effect [26, 27]. Macklin in 1939 observed
per respiratory tract infection in a long-time most common cause reported is traumatic in- that high intrathoracic pressure, as during a
marijuana user and two occurred in the con- jury, which introduces air into the spinal canal Valsalva maneuver, creates high intraalveo-
text of forceful emesis. The two patients with either directly or indirectly via an open skull lar pressure that may rupture alveoli. Conse-
emesis underwent barium esophagraphy, fracture or a basilar fracture of the sinuses or quent air leaks spread along bronchovascular
which excluded esophageal rupture. mastoid airspaces. Spinal abnormalities in- sheaths to the mediastinum and take the path
cluding malignancy, degeneration, infection, of least resistance to the cervical soft tissues.
Discussion and inflammation are also known to cause in- Balachandran et al. [28] in 1993 hypothesized
Pneumorrhachis was first described in traspinal air collections [1]. These causes may that because there are no fascial barriers be-
1977 [7]. The original term for this phenome- result in subarachnoid or intradural air in ad- tween the posterior mediastinum and the ret-
non was pneumomyelogram. Additional terms dition to epidural air. Intraaxial air may be as- ropharyngeal and epidural spaces, this free
have included intraspinal pneumocele, spinal sociated with clinically significant neurologic mediastinal and cervical soft-tissue air may
or epidural pneumatosis, spinal and epidural symptoms and morbidity, although it usually enter paraspinal tissues then travel through
emphysema, aerorachia, and pneumosacchus is a marker rather than a cause of morbidity [1, neural foramina alongside neurovascular bun-
[1]. A review published in 2006 [1] identified 3]. In patients with trauma, the intraaxial pres- dles into the epidural space. Thus, events that
86 cases of pneumorrhachis described in iso- ence of spinal air indicates the presence of a acutely increase intrathoracic pressure (e.g.,
lated case reports and small series. A review severe injury [3]. coughing, sneezing, vomiting, strenuous ex-
published in 2010 [4] identified 50 cases in 42 Epidural air, in contrast, is usually asymp- ercise) can cause pneumomediastinum and
studies ending in March 2009. Since 2009 an tomatic and benign, although there have pneumorrhachis. We observed cases of pneu-
additional 46 cases have been described in 45 been case reports of patients with neurolog- morrhachis with air extending into the neu-
reports. The causes range from trauma [8–10] ic symptoms associated with pneumorrha- ral foramina, illustrating the hypothesis of
and asthma [11] to colon cancer [12], sacral chis [1, 3, 25]. Epidural air may result from Balachandran et al. (Figs. 1 and 2).
pressure sore [13], sacral meningomyelocele the processes described earlier or dissection The precise proportion of pneumorrhachis
[14], dermatomyositis [15], enterocutaneous of free air from the soft tissues, chest, abdo- among cases of pneumomediastinum is un-
fistula [16], sigmoid perforation [17], diabet- men, and heart into the spinal canal. It has known. Until recently, it was thought to be an
exceedingly rare phenomenon. Kono et al. [2], development of intraspinal air. However, this den is also associated with increased likeli-
however, in 2007 found a 9.5% proportion of finding did not reach statistical significance. hood of air dissecting into the epidural space.
pneumorrhachis among children with spon- An increased proportion of pneumorrha- The primary limitation of this study was its
taneous pneumomediastinum (four cases in chis was significantly and positively asso- limited size. Although we identified 242 clini-
42 patients), suggesting that pneumorrhachis ciated with a wide distribution of air in the cal episodes of pneumomediastinum, we were
may be much more common than initially pneumomediastinum in the horizontal (pseu- only able to find 14 cases of pneumorrha-
Downloaded from www.ajronline.org by 114.125.201.184 on 03/31/21 from IP address 114.125.201.184. Copyright ARRS. For personal use only; all rights reserved
thought. Our findings support this hypothesis. docompartmental) planes. The proportion of chis. The small size of this sample limited the
We report a pneumorrhachis proportion of pneumorrhachis was significantly lower in depth of our analysis. Even so, we were able to
5.8% (14 cases in 242 episodes of pneumome- patients with air limited to only one or two derive several statistically significant findings.
diastinum). The trend toward an increased rate pseudocompartments. However, pneumor- The patient population at our institu-
among patients with spontaneous pneumome- rhachis was not significantly associated with tion may have skewed our sample. Most
diastinum (20%) suggests that increased in- distribution of air in the pneumomediasti- of the cases of pneumomediastinum were
trathoracic pressure (as seen in spontaneous num in the vertical (severity) direction. Thus, observed in patients recovering from sur-
pneumomediastinum) is a risk factor for the we may infer that a high mediastinal air bur- gery or who had chronic illnesses. Only 24
cases (9.9%) occurred outside this popula-
tion. Columbia University Medical Center
is a center for cardiothoracic and transplant
surgery, not a level I trauma center, which
suggests that the true proportion of pneu-
morrhachis in a more general population of
patients may be different.
Furthermore, our methods may have led to
underestimation of cases of pneumorrhachis
in another way. Because this was a retrospec-
tive study, chest imaging was not available
for some patients who had had pneumome-
diastinum diagnosed on a neck or abdomi-
nal scan, and neck imaging was not avail-
able for cases diagnosed on a chest scan. We
may have missed pneumorrhachis in these
patients. In addition, physicians may use CT
differently in a population of young patients
A with apparent spontaneous pneumomediasti-
num than they do in older patients recovering
from surgery or with acute illnesses. There-
fore, the younger patients (with the suspected
higher proportion of pneumorrhachis) may
not have undergone cross-sectional imaging
at the same rate as older patients.
The retrospective nature of this study over
a period of several years also results in non-
uniform image acquisition parameters and
postprocessing technique between patients.
For example, coronal and sagittal recon-
structed images were viewed when available.
Given the high contrast between air and oth-
er tissues, we do not believe this significantly
affected our results.
Conclusion
Pneumorrhachis is an underrecognized,
albeit typically benign, finding when seen in
the context of pneumomediastinum. Its pres-
ence is associated with a larger distribution
B C of mediastinal air in the horizontal (pseudo-
compartmental) distribution. The data sug-
Fig. 1—17-year-old boy with cough and posttussive emesis.
A–C, Axial (A), coronal (B), and sagittal (C) reconstructions of lung window CT scans show extensive gest a trend that pneumorrhachis is more
pneumomediastinum, soft-tissue emphysema, and pneumorrhachis. common when the pneumomediastinum is
pneumomediastinum, subcutaneous emphysema report and review. Phys Sportsmed 2009; 37:147– pulmonic blood vessels from alveoli to mediasti-
and pneumorrhachis as complications of common 153 num: clinical implications. Arch Intern Med 1939;
flu. Am J Case Rep 2012; 13:198–201 23. Sankar J, Jain A, Suresh CP. Peanut aspiration 64:913–926
21. Germino JC, Medverd JR, Nguyen VT, Favinger leading to pneumorrhachis in a pre-schooler. BMJ 27. Caceres M, Ali SZ, Braud R, Weiman D, Garrett
JL, Marder CP. Craniocervical hyperpneumatiza- Case Rep 2013; 2013:bcr2012007675 HE. Jr Spontaneous pneumomediastinum: a com-
tion with concurrent pneumorrhachis, pneumo- 24. Goh BK, Ng KK, Hoe MN. Traumatic epidural parative study and review of the literature. Ann
Downloaded from www.ajronline.org by 114.125.201.184 on 03/31/21 from IP address 114.125.201.184. Copyright ARRS. For personal use only; all rights reserved
mediastinum, and subcutaneous emphysema in a emphysema. Spine 2004; 29:E528–E530 Thorac Surg 2008; 86:962–966
weightlifter. Spine J 2013; 13:e47–e53 25. Aujayeb A, Doe S, Worthy S. Pneumomediasti- 28. Balachandran S, Guinto FC, Goodman P, Cavallo
22. Sadarangani S, Patel DR, Pejka S. Spontaneous num and pneumorrhachis: a lot of air about noth- FM. Epidural pneumatosis associated with spon-
pneumomediastinum and epidural pneumatosis in ing? Breathe (Sheff) 2012; 8:331–334 taneous pneumomediastinum. AJNR 1993;
an adolescent precipitated by weight lifting: a case 26. Macklin CC. Transport of air along sheaths of 14:271–272