Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Insight in Dementia: When Does It Occur? Evidence For A Nonlinear Relationship Between Insight and Cognitive Status
Insight in Dementia: When Does It Occur? Evidence For A Nonlinear Relationship Between Insight and Cognitive Status
Lack of insight or impaired awareness of deficits in patients with dementia is a relatively neglected area of study. The aim of
this study was to evaluate insight in a group of demented patients with two assessment scales and to assess their relationship
with the cognitive level of disease severity. Sixty-nine consecutive patients affected by Alzheimer's disease (n = 37) and vas-
cular dementia (n = 32) with a wide range of cognitive impairment (MMSE = 17.0 ± 6.4) were recruited. Insight was evalu-
ated with the Guidelines for the Rating of Awareness Deficits (GRAD)—specifically targeted to memory deficits—and the
Clinical Insight Rating scale (CIR), evaluating a broader spectrum of insight (reason for the visit, cognitive deficits, func-
tional deficits, and perception of the progression of the disease). In the whole sample, GRAD and CIR were significantly as-
sociated with MMSE (Spearman's coefficient = .57, p < .001; and r = -.55, p < .001) and with Clinical Dementia Rating
scale (-.57, p < .001; and r = .57, p < .001) respectively. The shape of the relationship of MMSE with CIR and GRAD scales
was assessed with spline smoothers suggesting that the relationship follows a tritinear pattern and is similar for both scales.
Insight was uniformly high for MMSE scores > 24, showed a linear decrease between MMSE scores of 23 and 13, and was
uniformly low for MMSE scores < 12. The tritinear model of the association between insight and cognitive status reflects
more closely the observable decline of insight and can provide estimates of when the decline of insight begins and ends.
P100
INSIGHT IN DEMENTIA P101
tabulation and anosognosia may contribute to the impaired in- and I A D L ) , assessed with the Katz index (Katz, Ford,
sight in AD (Mangone et al., 1991). Moskowitz, & Jackson, 1963) and the Lawton and Brody (1969)
Schacter and Prigatano (1991) warn that unawareness is not a scale, respectively. Dependency was defined as the inability to
unitary entity but probably consists of various forms or types. carry out activities of daily living without regular help of another
Recently, Starkstein, Sabe, Chemerinski, Jason, and Leiguarda person. Information was collected from the primary caregiver.
(1996) have suggested that insight may be a complex function:
5. Behavioral disturbances were evaluated with the
Unawareness of cognitive deficits and unawareness of behavioral
Neuropsychiatric Inventory Scale (NPI; Cummings et al., 1994).
problems may constitute independent phenomena in Alzheimer's
disease, the former related to the severity of intellectual impairment 6. Depressive symptoms were assessed using the Geriatric
10 affected by VD (Vallotti, Zanetti, Bianchetti, & Trabucchi, compared to conventional linear models by usual methods (test-
1997). The interrater intra-class correlation coefficient was .73 ing the significance of the increase of fitting, i.e., the decrease of
for the GRAD and .80 for the CTR. The test-retest coefficient was deviance, by chi-square test). In the present study, we compared
.73 for GRAD and .89 forCTR.Both scales proved to be reliable spline smoothers with piecewise linear models. Different piece-
for the rating of insight. wise linear models were also compared. The optimal point of
discontinuity in piecewise linear models was chosen on die basis
8. A subgroup of 36 participating patients underwent an ex-
of the best-fit, that is, the lowest deviance. In this analysis the
tensive neuropsychological assessment (for details of the tests,
level of statistical significance was set at/? = .05.
see Binetti et al., 1993). Short-term memory was assessed by
auditory-verbal forward digit span and visuospatial span
However, as shown in Figures 1A and IB, the association be- for MMSE scores between 21 and 27, with the lowest deviance
tween insight and cognitive status was not linear. An exploratory (242.7) being observed for the MMSE score of 24.
analysis with spline smoothers showed that the relationship was Table 2 shows fittings of linear and spline smoothers. The
roughly trilinear, with no association between insight and cogni- first model assumes a linear relationship between MMSE and
tion at both ends of the MMSE distribution, and a linear associa- CIR scales. The second and third models assume that the left-
tion in between. most andrightmostportions of the MMSE distribution (MMSE
The GRAD scale scores distribution into only 4 levels pre- <12 and MMSE >24, respectively) are flat and that the remain-
vented any further analysis assuming a normal distribution of ing portion of the MMSE distribution has a linear relationship
the response variable. However, the CIR scale scores distribu- with the CIR scale. Both the second and third models had a sig-
B
Alzheimer's
Vascular
All
8
CO
CO
a: \
\ •~ Alzheimer's
\ Vascular
- All
10 15 20 25 30 10 15 20 25 30
Mini Mental State Examination Mini Mental State Examination
Figure 1. Relationship of Clinical Insight Rating scale (A) and Guidelines for the Rating of Awareness Deficits (B) with MMSE score in Alzheimer's and vascular
dementia patients. Note: The lines denote a smoother function (cubic spline, 4 knots) in all patients and in the two subgroups. Error bars of the smoother function for
all patients are also shown.
P104 ZANETTIETAL.
0.415
r square reduced awareness of deficits (DeBettignies et al., 1990; Feher,
Mahurin, Inbody, Crook, & Pirozzolo, 1991; Reed et al., 1993).
However, the main results of our study suggest that the a pri-
ori assumption of a linear association between insight and cog-
nition, or disease severity, cannot be the correct one, and sug-
gest that this association follows a trilinear pattern. The trilinear
model reflects more closely the observable decline of insight.
The second advantage is that the trilinear model can provide es-
timates of when the decline of insight begins and ends.
assessment used in the present study need to be addressed. sight from declining to absent insight. The trilinear model of
Although the GRAD appears to be a measure of awareness of the association between insight and cognitive status reflects
memory, given the restricted range of scores, the observed pat- more closely the observable decline of insight and can provide
tern of relationship with MMSE might be related to ceiling and estimates of when the decline of insight begins and ends. These
floor effects; moreover, the restricted range of scores makes this results could be useful in developing instruments devised to as-
tool not sensitive enough to detect small changes. On the other sess patient autonomy.
hand, the CIR, although less prone to ceiling or floor effects, is
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
a general measure of awareness because responses to questions
regarding a number of different areas (reason for the visit, cog- Address correspondence to Orazio Zanetti, MD, Alzheimer Disease Unit
Kotler-Cope, S., & Camp, C. J. (1995). Anosognosia in Alzheimer disease. A., Gorelick, P. B., Bick, K. L., Pajeau, A. K., Bell, M. A., DeCarli, C,
Alzheimer Diesease and Associated Disorders, 9, 52-56. Culebras, A., Korcyn, A. D., Bogousslavsky, J., Hartmann, A., &
Lawton, M. P., & Brody, E. M. (1969). Assessment of older people: Self-maintain- Scheinberg, P. (1993). Vascular dementia: Diagnostic criteria for research
ing and instrumental activities of daily living. The Gervntologist, 9, 179-186. studies. Report of NINDS-AIREN International Workgroup. Neurology,
Lopez, O. L., Becher, J. T., Sumsak, D., Dew, M. A., & Dekosky, S. T. (1994). 43, 250-260.
Awareness of cognitive deficits and anosognosia in probable Alzheimer's Schacter, D. (1991). Unawareness of deficit and unawareness of knowledge in pa-
disease. European Neurology, 34, 277-282. tients with memory disorders. In G. Prigatano & D. Schacter (Eds.), Aware-
Mangone, C. A., Hier, D. B., Gorelick, P. B., Ganellen, R. J., Langerberg, P., ness of deficits after brain injury (pp. 127-151). New York: Oxford University
Boarman, R., & Dollear, W. C. (1991). Impaired insight in Alzheimer's Press.
disease. Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry and Neurology, 4, 189-193. Schacter, D., & Prigatano, G. (1991). Forms of unawareness. In G. Prigatano &
McDaniel, K. D., Edland, S. D., Heyman, A., & the CERAD Clinical Investi- D. Schacter (Eds.), Awareness of deficits after brain injury (pp. 258-262).