Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/360864628
CITATIONS READS
0 5,281
1 author:
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Appraisal of the Rules of Shareholders’ Protection in the New Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021: are there Improvements from the Old Code? View project
Analysis of the CSR Role of Companies in Promoting Social Welfare? View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Samuel Maireg Biresaw on 26 May 2022.
Legal background
For many decades, Ethiopia’s Commercial Code of 1960 (“Old Code”) had
governed the majority of business and commercial relationships (including the
formation, operation, and termination of businesses and business organisations).
However, there was a perceived need to update the law to adequately govern the
then economic development and the market-led economic system, and thereby lay
a firm legal foundation for the conduct of commercial activities that ensure
economic development and global competitiveness. The Old Code also contained
noticeable gaps and insufficiencies that were inadequate for the practical operations
of businesses and business organisations. To that effect, the Old Code has been
recently amended and replaced by the Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021,
Proclamation Number 1243/2021 (“New Code”).
Some of the following major changes introduced by the New Code that impact
the legal and institutional framework of business and commercial relationships in
Ethiopia are considered.1
1
The Preamble of the Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021, Proclamation No.1243/2021, repeals Books I, II, and
III of the Commercial Code of Ethiopia 1960. However, Books III (Carriage and Insurance) and IV (Negotiable
Instruments) of the Old Code continue to apply pending the issuance of the Financial Services Code; See art.55(4)
of the Constitution of the Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia.
2
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 274, 312, 313, 355–361, 366, 381, 395, 427, 431, 441, 486, 555.
3
See s.4 and 5 of the Preamble of the Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021.
4
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 art.4(1–3).
5
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 art.5(1–37).
6
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 6–8, 27–29, 32, 36.
7
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 36–60.
Commercial registration
Similarly, to facilitate economic activities nationwide, detect pseudo businesses,
and ascertain transparency and accountability in the regulation of businesses, the
New Code also mandates the Ministry of Trade and Industry to establish and
administer the Federal Commercial Register of Traders, Businesses, and Business
Organisations having nationwide applications that undertake registration of traders
and business organisations. In addition, it also provides the option to Regional
States, Addis Ababa, and Dire Dawa City Administrations to establish their regional
commercial registers that undertake commercial registration.9 As a testament to
its modern nature, the New Code imposes the duty on the Ministry of Trade and
Industry to establish and administer a central commercial registration database
with a national application, which shall be organised making use of modern
information technology and be open and accessible to the public through the
Ministry’s website.10 Additionally, the fact that the New Code introduced the option
to make commercial entries, registration as a trader, and written statements online
through the database destined for that purpose enables traders to access such
services remotely, cheaply, and comfortably.11
Business organisations
8
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 65(1–3), 61–69.
9
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 70–71, 265–266.
10
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 72–81.
11
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 79, 83(3), 82–89.
12
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 122–167.
13
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 168–171.
14
Cross-refer art. 212 of the 1960 Commercial Code with art. 174 of the Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021. The
1960 Commercial Code recognized only six types of Business Organisations, which are Ordinary Partnership, General
Partnership, Limited Partnership, Joint Venture, Share Company, and Private Limited Company.
15
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 1960 arts 210–213, 227–270 dealt with Ordinary Partnerships. The New Code is
justified in abolishing Ordinary Partnerships that existed illusively and defined non-exclusively in the Old Code. That
is because, the provisions governing Ordinary Partnerships in the Old Code were highly equivocal and in pragmatic
and such partnerships were not considered as commercial in nature and hence, were not subjected to bankruptcy law,
which are all reasons that practically relegated Ordinary Partnerships to the realm of non-commercial organisations.
16
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 172–174.
17
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 221–233.
18
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 534–545.
19
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 art. 221.
20
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 art. 534.
21
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 5–10.
22
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 art.172.
23
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 183–211.
24
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 212–220.
25
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 221–233.
26
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 234–244.
27
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 245–494.
28
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 495–533.
29
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 534–545.
Disclosure requirements
To guarantee transparency, accountability, and accessibility in the operation and
administration of business organisations in Ethiopia, the New Code, based on the
international best practice, adopted modern rules that guarantee the disclosure of
adequate, timely, and authentic material information by the company or its directors
towards shareholders and interested third parties including the duty of companies
to disclose major share ownership in the company and to establish a secured and
accessible website.31
Shareholders’ protection
The New Code contains modern rules and requirements to protect the interests of
shareholders in general and minority shareholders in particular. Accordingly, the
New Code: established a powerful general meeting of shareholders,32 vested with
the power to decide on fundamental governance issues;33 guaranteed the right of
shareholders to call a meeting and set an agenda of meetings;34 guaranteed the right
of shareholders to participate in meetings and vote through proxy and by using
electronic mediums;35 ascertained the equal rights of voting to all the shareholders
regardless of class and number of shares by awarding one vote to each share and
expressly prohibiting multiple voting rights or the issuance of shares without voting
rights;36 introduced a two-tier board structure that delineates the powers and duties
of the supervisory board and the management board, thereby encouraging division
of labour, specialisation, and board independence and preventing conflict of interest,
agency costs, self-dealing, and rents in corporate control;37 guaranteed the absolute
rights of shareholders to elect, remove, and replace directors;38 ascertained the
rights of shareholders as a group to file a derivative suit against directors on behalf
of the company;39 guaranteed the right of shareholders to challenge the resolutions
30
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 32–35, 245, 248–49, 258–264, 293, 294, 562, 295, 296–97, 296 (1, 2),
300, 379, 301, 306, 312, 554, 331–32, 337–38, 343–45, 299, 364, 466, 470, 559–561, 292–294, 403, 562, 558, 403,
407, 550–53, 291, 558; It has also introduced efficient and modern rules for the formation, operation, affiliation,
merger, division, and termination of Sole-proprietorships and Business Organisations in Ethiopia.
31
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 274, 274, 292, 293, 294, 311, 312, 313, 315(6(a)), 381, 382, 386,
387(1–4), 388, 389, 392, 399, 403, 405, 441, 474, 491–494, 554–558, 562.
32
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 262(2)-264, 268(2), 272(3), 275–278, 362–391, 400, 402(2–3), 444,
442, 452, 460, 473–475, 565–577.
33
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 306, 362–391, 394(4), 395.
34
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 303(3–4), 315(6), 328, 351(1–5), 366(1–2), 367, 370, 372, 382, 389,
393, 394, 395,473, 481.
35
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 262(4), 271–272, 283–284, 292, 309, 310, 362, 370, 371, 373, 376, 377,
397, 401, 403(1–4), 422–424, 448(2), 547, 562(1–3).
36
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 275(2), 278(2), 279(2), 289(7), 291(1–5), 363, 364, 375, 379, 383, 384,
385(1–4), 386, 390, 397(1), 401, 448(1)–461, 470.
37
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 296, 297, 301–314, 315–330, 331–336, 337, 338, 379, 347, 436(2), 478;
Similarly, the New Code adopts clear division of power, duties, and independence between the offices of the General
Manager and the Chairperson of the board. Moreover, the New Code also generally recognises Board Committees.
38
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 296, 298, 301, 303, 305, 331, 333, 385, 394.
39
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 179, 306, 315–319, 320–327, 328, 329, 330, 395, 426–428.
of the general meeting that are invalid or illegal;40 and ascertained the right of a
shareholder to offer a mandatory bid to buy the remaining shares in the company.41
Creditors’ protection
The New Code also contains modern rules and requirements that protect the
interests of corporate creditors such as the minimum capital requirement;42
restrictions imposed on the payment of a dividend;43 restrictions imposed on the
repurchases of shares;44 prohibition of under-valued transactions;45 duties imposed
on the directors towards creditors in normal times and during insolvency;46 the
recognised forms and variety of security mechanisms;47 and the special protection
accorded to creditors’ interests through various procedures that are adopted and
followed during bankruptcy proceedings.48
40
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 292, 306, 362, 363, 364, 374, 381, 383(2), 384, 385, 386, 391, 394, 396,
397, 398, 399, 401, 402, 403, 562.
41
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 267–269, 276, 292–295, 381, 382, 398(2), 399, 403, 442–461, 556, 558,
562.
42
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 247(1–2), 254, 268, 281, 282.
43
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 291, 304(4), 432(1–3), 433–437, 438(1–5), 439–441, 487.
44
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 275–277.
45
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 306(1–6), 307(1–3).
46
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 316–322, 325–328, 329(1–3), 330.
47
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 136–142, 143–155, 156–167, 168–171, 576.
48
Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 arts 177, 178, 190, 191, 201, 202, 205–207, 211, 216, 218, 228, 232, 241,
242, 265, 26877, 289, 292–295, 302, 306, 311–313, 334, 442–461, 462–472, 588–825.
49
See arts 558–825 of the Commercial Code of Ethiopia 2021 on Preventive Restructuring, Reorganisation, and
Bankruptcy Law.