Professional Documents
Culture Documents
GHG Quantification A Thesis by Bereket.Y
GHG Quantification A Thesis by Bereket.Y
A Thesis Paper Submitted To The Master's Programme, College Of Urban Development And
Engineering; Ethiopian Civil Service University, In Partial Fulfillment Of The Requirements
For The Award Of A Master‟s Degree In Environment And Climate Change Management.
June 2022
DECLARATION
I hereby declare that this thesis entitled “The carbon footprint of Ethiopian Airlines group:
Quantification of a scope−one emission.” was composed by myself, with the guidance of my
advisor MR. ALEMAYEHU.A, that the work contained herein is my own except where
explicitly stated otherwise in the text, and that this work has not been submitted, in whole or
in part, for any other degree or processional qualification.
Date: _______________________
The undersigned certify that they have read and hereby recommend to the Ethiopian Civil
Service College to accept the thesis submitted by MR. BEREKET YEMANBIRHAN, and
entitled “The carbon footprint of Ethiopian airlines group: quantification of a scope−1
emission.", in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the award of a Master's Degree in the
environment and climate change management.
Date………………………
Date………………………
Date………………………
Date………………………
Abstract
The ultimate goal of this research paper is quantifying GHG emission from Ethiopian Airlines
group, which is from scope one emissions (emissions are direct emissions that result from
activities among associate organization's control) the year 2021. Calculating one's carbon
footprint may be a necessary step to understanding a given entity's contribution to global
warming and can be used for various purposes, from public reporting to setting a target for
reducing emissions. Primary data was obtained from the Ethiopian Aviation Authority,
Ethiopian Airlines Group and the Ministry of Transport and Logistics. Those activity data was
examined using professional software (IPCC inventory program) and excel GHG emission
inventory tools.
Emission from stationary combustion which is from backup generators and boilers at 2021
was 6679.725 tCO2 tonnes, from international and domestic flights counts 95% from all
emission‟s sources at the study year which is 5,480,268.37 tCO2 tonnes, from mobile sources
rather than international and domestic flight at 2021 was 24434.05 metric tonnes of CO2e
was emitted from vehicles, trucks cars and other mobiles source like construction equipment‟s
and From the final emission category scope 1 fugitive emission 127,491.1 tCO2 were emitted
from fire suppression system and 15,902.9 tCO2 from Refrigeration and cooling Equipment‟s.
The emission from the airline is more than the inventory results quantified by the author of
this paper because of some factors like missing activity data and unmeasured non-CO2-effects
from the airline; principally emissions of nitrogen oxides, contrails and aviation-induced
cirrus clouds, and these effects are estimated to be almost as significant as the CO2 emissions
themselves in terms of their global warming potential (GWP) 100-year perspective.
From the GHG inventory, emission from international flight is the most significant 95% and
needs to be addressed in such a manner, where increasing demand for air travel with a growth
average rate of 20% every single year will impose a significant impact on climate change,
where travel demand and fossil fuel burning are related each other.
Key words: carbon footprint, global warming, fugitive emission, stationary combustion, carbon dioxide
equivalent, GWP
Acknowledgement
First of all, Praise and gratitude to Almighty God submitted by the author to the Lord Jesus
Christ My Savior and the Virgin Mary for blessings and help to complete this thesis on time.
Then I would like to thank my mother Asegedech Gorfe and my whole family for their
upbringing of me and their tireless efforts and support in every path I take to achieve my
dreams and goals.
I would like to thank the following people for helping me to finalize the paper by offering me
relevant data and with heartfelt advice…
Mr. Tadesse Agonafir – from group internal audit, QMS, SMS, compliance and business
sustainability/ Ethiopian airlines
Mr. Shiferaw Nora and Tesema Adamu – from Ethiopian civil Aviation Authority
I wish to extend my special thanks to friends; Addisu, Tseganesh, Senafeqesh and Magi.
And I would like to express my gratitude to my primary supervisor, Mr. Alemayehu Agizew,
who guided me throughout this Master‟s thesis.
June, 2022
Contents
Contents
DECLARATION .............................................................................................................................. i
APPROVAL SHEET OF RESEARCH PAPER ...........................................................................ii
Abstract .......................................................................................................................................... iii
Acknowledgement ..........................................................................................................................iv
Contents ............................................................................................................................................ v
List of Tables ..................................................................................................................................ix
List of Figures .................................................................................................................................. x
List of Appendices ..........................................................................................................................xi
List of Acronyms ...........................................................................................................................xii
Chapter one ...................................................................................................................................... 1
1 Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 1
1.1 Background ....................................................................................................................... 2
1.3 Problem Statement ............................................................................................................. 4
1.4 Objectives............................................................................................................................... 5
1.4.1 Main Objective................................................................................................................ 5
1.4.2 Specific objectives .......................................................................................................... 5
1.6 Significance of the Study ...................................................................................................... 6
1.7 Scope of the Study ................................................................................................................. 7
1.7.1 General purpose of the study ......................................................................................... 7
1.7.2 Boundaries of the study .................................................................................................. 7
Chapter two .................................................................................................................................... 10
2. LITERATURE REVIEW ......................................................................................................... 10
2.1 Introduction .......................................................................................................................... 10
2.1.1 An introduction to Carbon Footprint ............................................................................... 10
2.1.2 Importance and Need for CF assessment .................................................................... 12
2.1.3 Emission category description ..................................................................................... 12
List of Tables
List of Figures
List of Appendices
List of Acronyms
HVAC – Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning GWP – global warming potential
Since the late last decade, 63% of annual emissions are caused by developing countries.
The industry, energy, and prosperity that have long been the preserve of only a handful of
developed countries are finally expanding rapidly in the developing world, but the growth has
a dangerous side effect cause of CO2 emissions. [1]
Let‟s take an example; Africa's giant airline, Ethiopian Airlines which will seriously impose a
considerable climate impact in a way that Carbon dioxide emissions in developing countries
are closely tied to their economy and play a vital role within the world‟s future emissions.[2]
Carbon emissions from the transport sector were more or less eight billion tons in 2016,
accounting for nearly 24% of worldwide carbon emissions. World transportation carbon
emissions inflated by 71% in 2016 compared to emissions in 1990, among that civil aviation
had the best growth rate, reaching, calculated that the civil aviation business accounts for
nearly 2.5% of global carbon emissions since 2010. Aviation might account for 25% of global
carbon emissions by 2050 if transport demand continues. As an extra complication, the
characteristics of multinational civil aviation are specified most of the associated carbon
emissions are emitted into the higher layer and troposphere 1, considerably impacting climate
change. [3]
From global scale (developed nations, giant companies, and industries) to the lowest
individual level of contribution, hence a given nation, company, firm even an individual must
reiterate the critical state of the climate crisis and therefore the role we all have in combating
it.) For example in the aviation industry, ground-based airport GHG emissions are caused by
gasoline and diesel oil for airport vehicles and ground support equipment, fuel for electricity
1
Compared with the greenhouse gases produced by ground transportation of the same volume, the impact of
carbon emissions emitted from aircraft on climate is magnified by 1.9–5.1 times. source: (Larsson et al., 2018)
1 By: Bereket Yemanbirhan
Thesis paper Ethiopian civil service university
and heating, jet fuel for auxiliary power units that power aircraft at airport gates, and other
sources. [4]
Calculating one‟s carbon footprint may be a necessary step to understanding a given entity
like a company's contribution to global warming, so in such a way that we may identify ways
to scale back it to in situ conditions [5] plus the carbon footprint of a company is an extensive
measure of its impact on the environment. Hence it represents an indirect indicator of the
consumption of energy, products, and services and measures the quantity of carbon footprint
which corresponds to a company‟s activities or products.
1.1 Background
Humans have emitted about 450 billion tonnes of carbon from the industrial revolution that
has contributed to this climate crisis in the world. [6] our activities are calculable to own
caused just about 1.0°C of world global warming higher than pre-industrial levels, with a
possible vary of 0.8C0 to 1.2C0. [7]
The warming of the earth is probably going to raise 1.5C0 between 2030 and 2052 if it
continues to extend at this rate. (High confidence) GHGs trap heat radiated from the sun in the
atmosphere, warming the planet‟s surface. Many GHGs occur naturally in the atmosphere, but
their increased human concentration is enabled.
The GHG Protocol, Corporate Accounting and Reporting Standard cover the accounting and
reporting of seven GHGs covered by the Kyoto Protocol are Carbon dioxide (CO2), Methane
(CH4), Nitrous oxide (N 2O), Hydro fluorocarbons (HFCs), Per−fluoro carbons (PFCs),
Sulfur hexafluoride (SF6) and Nitrogen tri−fluoride (NF3).
With the increasing concern about world temperature change and carbon emissions as a
causative factor, several firms and organizations are following "carbon footprint" comes to
estimate their contributions to global climate change.
The Carbon Registry protocol definitions help organizations to analyze their carbon
footprints. The scope of these protocols varies but generally suggests estimating only direct
emissions and emissions from purchased energy, paying less attention to supply chain
emissions. [8]
Thorough understanding of their footprints, companies will not be able to pursue the most
cost-effective carbon mitigation strategies. In such a way, this thesis will be focused on
calculating Ethiopia's Airlines GHG emission, specifically the Scope 1 emission, from the
direct emissions that occur from sources owned or controlled by the company (Ethiopian
Airlines). That is if the company owns or controls the activities or equipment‟s associated
with the emissions.
From various purposes of carbon foot−printing some of them are for; publicly reporting
greenhouse gas emissions, for setting a target for reducing emissions (to set reductions to
target it is necessary to know what current emissions are), to identify which activities
contribute the most to a footprint (to identify the important areas for reduction efforts), to
measure changes in emissions over time, and to monitor the effectiveness of reduction
activities and for offsetting emissions (to offset emissions it is necessary to know how many
reductions credits to purchase).
Developed nations are the largest emitters of GHGs at the global level, but I argued that giant
companies operating in developing nations will impose a significant amount at the global
level of warming by emitting GHGs. Hence this research will quantify Ethiopian Airlines'
scope one greenhouse gas emissions and the author of this thesis strongly insight a new
paradigm shift towards emissions from firms, companies, industries located in developing
nations.
The Center for Biological Diversity states referring to researches on the field; Greenhouse gas
emissions from aviation are a considerable contributor to warming. If the aviation sector were
a country, it'd place sixth in emissions, between Japan and Germany. Left unbridled global
aviation can generate a calculable 43 metric Gg tons of dioxide emissions through 2050,
constituting nearly 5% of the world emissions allowable to stay global warming below 1.5
degrees Celsius. Air transport is responsible for 12% of CO 2 emissions from all transport
sources, compared to 74% for road transport. [9]
Within the United States, aircraft are one among the fastest-growing sources of emissions:
Emissions from domestic aviation alone have inflated 17% since 1990, to account for 9% of
greenhouse gas emissions from the U.S. transportation sector. Flights outward-bound from
airports within us and its territories are to blame for nearly one-quarter of worldwide traveler
transport-related carbon emissions, the bulk of that come back from domestic flights.
The good news is that, at a summit in Boston, five Gregorian calendar month 2021 – the
worldwide transportation business has adopted a long-run climate goal of net-zero carbon
emissions by 2050, confirming the commitment of the world's airlines, airports, traffic
management, and also the manufacturers of craft associate degreed engines to cut back
greenhouse emission emissions in support of the Paris Agreement 1.5ºC goal.
This updates an earlier industry-wide goal set in 2009 and comes when yesterday‟s resolution
of the International transportation Association membership to adopt a net-zero goal.
Ethiopian airline as a leading aviation industry at a global level is expected to have a valuable
carbon emission and has to be quantified to achieve the above goal.
On August 30, 2018, Ethiopian Airlines, the largest Aviation Group in Africa and SKYTRAX
Four Star Global Airlines, was certified for establishing and maintaining an environmental
management system in compliance with the requirements of ISO 14001:2015.
An effective environmental management system is paramount for any business, from the
largest corporates to the smallest of businesses. But first, given businesses need to be able
to calculate their carbon footprint this is an initial step to improving businesses by
Reducing the cost of waste management, Implementing more effective distribution routes and
plans, Lowering the use of energy and materials, saving money in the process, Improving the
image and identity of the business And obviously, reducing the negative impact that a
company has on the environment.
The famous saying states “You manage what you measure." Keep in mind the time factor,
where Airlines are currently only responsible for 2 to 4% of emissions; but their share will
rise to over 25% by 2050 if aviation continues on its current growth trajectory. [10]
There is no empirical study about carbon emission from Ethiopian airlines' at the time of
this very research is taken.
The reality that developed nations are the most GHG emitters is not questionable, in such a
way that emissions from developing nations like Ethiopia are not well quantified/known.
An Ethiopian airline is one of the most giant airlines in the world, in both cargo ship and air
freight, hence quantifying emission within giant corporates will be mandatory for various
purposes from global warming reduction policy to adaptation strategies to be held.
1.4 Objectives
The main objective of this research is to quantify/measure the carbon footprint of Ethiopian
Airlines, which is a scope one emission.
This very thesis will quantify scope− one emission from Ethiopian Airline/Addis Ababa bole
international airport, specifically listed below.
Recent research on carbon emission has indicated vast contributions with the aid of using
aviation enterprise of GHG emissions with vast implications for environmental sustainability.
The Tourism sector was directly influenced and inter-connected with the transport sector,
especially with aviation has been an increasing number of depending on-air delivery and has
contributed the biggest share of the boom of GHG emissions within side the delivery sector.
It bills for 24%-28% of all power-associated CO2 emissions; which aviation bills for
approximately 3.4% of all emissions of CO2.
For instance, Australia and Europe have already imposed low-carbon guidelines aimed toward
aviation organizations so that you can enhance environmental credentials below Kyoto
Protocol obligations. [11]
This very thesis/research is unique and significant based on the list below.
a. Based on originality – this very research is an empirical study, where some studies
are conducted (carbon footprint) in some Airlines located in the USA and some
European countries but the author of this thesis did not find any study on Ethiopian
Airlines.
But Airlines located in developing nations are rare and no study is found for
Ethiopian Airlines.
b. Based on Relevance – The quantification serves for the decision-making body like
environmental and policymakers to formulate a way forward.
So, the result of this research will be a benchmark for any environmental and policy
measurements taken by any government body.
To summarize, quantifying the annual carbon footprint will assist the Ethiopian airline/airport
to comprehend overall emissions (for now scope one) carbon footprint and track variations in
a yearly manner.
The carbon footprint covering 12 months is a key component of Airport Carbon Accreditation
and accounting. [12] The year 2021 is the duration at which the scope 1 emission from
Ethiopian Airlines will be quantified and assessed.
Table 1 Duration of Emission quantification
Start date End date Indicate if you are providing Select the number of past
emissions data for past reporting reporting years you will be
years providing emissions
data for
Reporting Jan 1, 2021 Dec 31, 2021 Two years emission data for Not applicable for emissions
year international flights. from fugitive and mobile sources
Eight years emission data for like vehicles and any other
domestic flight. related sources.
This scope one GHG Emission quantification will only focus on the legal territory owned by
Ethiopian Airlines.
The origins of the emissions are solely from the operations held at Bole international airport
only.
According to GHG protocol at setting an organizational boundary, the scopes may be direct or
indirect emissions for operations that fall among a company‟s established structure.
The operational boundary (scope 1, scope 2, and scope 3) is set at the company level when
setting the organizational boundary. The chosen operational boundary is uniformly applied to
spot and reason direct and indirect emissions at every operational level.
This thesis/research solely centered only on scope one emission, Scope one emissions: direct
emissions that result from activities among associate organization's control (for example, fuel
combustion, company vehicles, method emissions, and fugitive emissions)
8 By: Bereket Yemanbirhan
Thesis paper Ethiopian civil service university
As part of the control approach, a company represents 100% of GHG emissions from the
operations on which it verifies.
This research will quantify the emission calculation under the operational control approach,
which, the airline (Ethiopian airline) is being considered as own the authority to introduce and
implement its operating policies (ownership=100%responsibilty)
Chapter two
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Introduction
Carbon dioxide concentrations in the atmosphere had been steadily increasing and
accelerating since regular measurements began in 1958. [13]
A literature search in January 2022 for the term carbon and footprint written in Google
scholar for the years the 1950s to 2022 yields 670,000 hits, in science direct 66,388 hits, and
semantic scholar 2,060,000hits in total.
The CF concept is related to and evolved from the older concept of ecological footprint,
which was developed at the University of British Columbia in the early 1990s by Canadian
ecologist William Rees and Swiss-born regional planner Mathis Wackernagel. [14]
Global Footprint "The demand on bio capacity required to sequester (through photosynthesis) the carbon dioxide
Network (CO2) emissions from fossil fuel combustion."
Grub & Ellis "A carbon footprint is a measure of the amount of carbon dioxide emitted through the
combustion of fossil fuels. In the case of a business organization, it is the amount of CO2 emitted
either directly or indirectly as a result of its everyday operations. It also might reflect the fossil
energy represented in a product or commodity reaching market."
Parliamentary Office "A „carbon footprint‟ is the total amount of CO2 and other greenhouse gases, emitted over the
of Science and full life cycle of a process or product. It is expressed as grams of CO2 equivalent per kilowatt-
Technology hour of generation (gCO2eq/kWh), which accounts for the different global warming effects of
other greenhouse gases."
To manage (for adapting and mitigating) and for addressing climate change-related issues, a
given nation, firm, company, etc. has to quantify its carbon footprint.
Almost all kinds of literature written in the field associate "carbon footprint" with climate
change and global warming, but studies on CF (carbon footprint) got their specific behavior
based on spatial, temporal layout, cooperation intensity, and knowledge hierarchy. [17]
For example CF can be expressed as, carbon footprint as Areal CF (ACF) and Personal CF
(PCF). Where, ACF analyses usually include government consumption and investments,
whereas PCF analyses do not. [18]
"Carbon footprint" has been used to assess the GHG emissions that a certain product or
service creates during its lifespan, and it is primarily represented in CO 2 -equivalents (CO2 -
eq.) that include CO2, CH4, and N2O emissions. The Carbon footprint is a subset of life-cycle
analysis (LCA) that focuses solely on the GWP component. [19]
Carbon footprint analysis can assist people in understanding the environmental effects of
human activity and organizations, as well as provide scientific resources to assist countries in
reducing carbon emissions and climate change. [20]
GHG concentrations in the atmosphere have risen dramatically over the last two centuries.
Human activities such as industry, agriculture, deforestation, waste disposal, and, most
notably, unprecedented use of fossil fuels have been causing an increase in GHG emissions.
CO2 concentrations, for example, increased from about 280 parts per million by volume
(ppmv) in preindustrial times to 372 ppmv in 2001 and have continued to rise at a rate of
about 0.5 percent per year, whereas current CH4 atmospheric concentrations are rising at a
rate of 0.02 ppmv per year. Similarly, anthropogenic activities have increased N2 O sources by
about 40%–50% compared to preindustrial levels. [21]
Three "scopes" (scope 1, scope 2, and scope 3) are defined for GHG accounting and reporting
purposes to help characterize direct and indirect emission sources, improve transparency, and
provide utility for different types of organizations and different types of climate policies and
business goals.
Scope 1 emissions are direct greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions caused by sources controlled
or owned by an organization (e.g., emissions associated with fuel combustion in boilers,
furnaces, and vehicles). [22]
BUY− Emissions from the organizations purchased and used electricity Emissions are
produced during the energy production process and are eventually used by the organization.
Scope 3 emissions are the outcome of actions carried out on assets that are not owned or
controlled by the reporting entity but have an indirect influence on its value chain. Scope 3
emissions cover all sources that do not fall within an organization's scope 1 or scope 2
boundaries. [23]
Note that Scope 1 and 2 emissions are required for many organizations around the world and
refer to systems that an entity has reasonable control over, such as onsite and purchased
energy. Scope 3 emissions are focused on sources of emissions that are more external to a
specific organization, such as those that occur throughout the supply chain. Scope 3 emissions
are mostly voluntary to report; however, in most cases, reducing Scope 3 has the greatest
potential impact. [24]
Runways, aprons and taxiways, gates, ground service equipment storage sites, freight
equipment storage sites, aerobridges, check-in facilities, government inspection, security gate
lounges, baggage processing facilities and trolleys, freight information displays, washrooms,
13 By: Bereket Yemanbirhan
Thesis paper Ethiopian civil service university
car parking, kerbside access, restaurants, and duty-free retail shops are examples of airport
infrastructure and facilities. [25]
The international aviation sector was not included in the Paris Agreement on climate change.
As a result, it is not addressed by individual nations in their pledges to reduce emissions,
known as Nationally Determined Contributions. Yet, without tackling aviation – and
shipping, another sector with international emissions – meeting the 2C0 or 1.5C0 warming
limits of the agreement is made more difficult. [26]
Aircraft are not the only source of aviation emissions. Power units that provide power and air
conditioning to aircraft parked at airport terminals, stationary airport power sources, and
construction machinery operating at the airport. [27] In a given Airport, Carbon dioxide and
other GHGs are discharged into the air when fossil fuels are used to generate electricity, in
furnaces, and to power vehicles. CO 2 makes up the majority of GHG emissions, with lesser
contributions from nitrous oxide (N2O), methane (CH4 ), refrigerants, and other compounds. [4]
The Paris Agreement aims to keep the average global temperature rise this century below 2C0
above pre-industrial levels and continues efforts to limit temperature rise to 1.5C°. The
Agreement requires all signatories to make every effort to achieve this goal through national
14 By: Bereket Yemanbirhan
Thesis paper Ethiopian civil service university
determination in all respects. The agreement includes requiring all signatories to report
regularly on their emissions and implementation efforts. A global inventory will be conducted
every five years to assess collective progress towards achieving the goals of the Agreement
and to inform future actions by each country. [28] Then Quantifying the GHG is true will be
done also by firms, industries, companies located by every country mentioned by the
agreement mentioned.
A GHG inventory quantifies the GHGs emitted or removed from the atmosphere over a while
by a specific country, establishment, company, industry, etc. by estimating net carbon dioxide
emigrations. The IPCC description for net carbon dioxide emigrations is the" difference
between sources (any process, exertion, or operation that releases a greenhouse gas, aerosol,
or greenhouse gas or aerosol precursor in the atmosphere) and sinks (any process, exertion or
medium that removes a greenhouse gas, aerosol or greenhouse gas or aerosol precursor from
the atmosphere) of carbon dioxide in a given area or region for a given period. [29]
2
Note: "Schematic overview of the processes by which aviation emissions and increased cirrus cloudiness affect
the climate system. Net positive RF (warming) contributions arise from CO2, water vapor, NOx, and soot
emissions, and contrail cirrus (consisting of linear contrails and the cirrus cloudiness arising from them).
15 By: Bereket Yemanbirhan
Thesis paper Ethiopian civil service university
Negative RF (cooling) contributions arise from sulfate aerosol production. Net warming from NOx emissions is
a sum over warming (short-term ozone increase) and cooling (decreases in methane and stratospheric water
vapor, and a long-term decrease in ozone) terms. Net warming from contrail cirrus is a sum over the day/night
cycle. These contributions involve a large number of chemical, microphysical, transport, and radiative processes
in the global atmosphere. Source: Lee et al (2020)"
16 By: Bereket Yemanbirhan
Thesis paper Ethiopian civil service university
Offset their residual emissions, thereby achieving Level 3+ (Neutrality) and Level 4+
(Transition) respectively. [30]
In our continent, currently, there are only 12 accredited airports in 7 countries at Level 1
'Mapping', representing 15.8% of African air passenger traffic. Located in South Africa,
Nigeria, Kenya, Morocco, Saint Helena (part of the British overseas territory of St.) and
Dzaoudzi Pamandzi International Airport (Dzaoudzi is a commune in the French overseas
department of Mayotte, in the Indian Ocean. ... is located on Pamandzi Island in the
neighboring commune of Pamandzi.) Ethiopian Airlines is certified as a 4-Star Airline for the
best of its airport and onboard product and body of workers service. [31]
This will make the airport one of the busiest airports all over the globe which environmental
issues must concern us. From the above table, there is a minimum study about African
Airports, with no study for Ethiopian airline/Bole international airport.
Hence we can say that there is a "lack of study” in such a way that this thesis will fill the gap
of knowledge about emission (in a quantitative manner by assessing the scope of one
emission)
2.4 Conclusion
There is a lack of commitment at companies, industries and private firms to calculate their
carbon footprint and in such a way act environmentally. But knowing the emission level in
every aspect of GHG inventory and accounting is not an easy job to be done for many reasons
like lack of data, uncertainty issues, and so many others. The aviation industry is one of the
contributors to global warming, which some Aviation companies located in Europe and
Australia impose policy action to the sector to be green and sustainable. There are no
empirical studies that quantify Ethiopian airlines' GHG emissions; hence this gap of
knowledge will be filled by this thesis.
The accuracy of the footprint depends on collecting consumption data for all of the emission
sources within the established boundary. It‟s necessary to clarify any gaps within the data and
list any assumptions that are created in hard the footprint. The carbon footprint is typically
calculated using activity data collected multiplied by standard emissions factors, though there
are different calculation methods, like calculation of the utilization of models or
measurement. [32]
A carbon footprint is measured in tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent (tCO 2 e). By employing
a carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2 e) the greenhouse gases can be compared on a like-for-like
basis relative to at least one unit of carbon dioxide. By multiplying the emissions of all half-
dozen greenhouse gases by its one hundred years global warming potential (GWP)
Therefore this very study will merely objectives‟ will be the carbon inventory of Ethiopian
airline/location− Bole international airport.
"The greenhouse gases CO2, CH4 , and N2O are emitted during the combustion of fuels in
mobile sources. For most transportation modes, CH4 and N2O emissions comprise a relatively
small proportion of overall transportation-related GHG emissions (approximately one percent
combined). For on-road vehicles less than 15 years old, CH 4, and N2O emissions typically
account for one percent of emissions or less. However, for older gasoline-fueled on-road
vehicles, CH4, and N2Ocould be a more significant (approximately five percent) portion of
total GHG emissions. CH4 and N2O emissions are typically an even higher percentage of total
GHG emissions from non-road or alternative fuel vehicles. Organizations should account for
all CO2, CH4, and N 2O emissions associated with mobile combustion. Given the relative
emissions contributions of each gas, CH 4 and N2O emissions are sometimes excluded by
assuming that they are not material." [22]
Chapter three
3.1 Introduction
Carbon Quantification Once the quantifying body has resolved key accounting issues, the
entity applies the GHG calculation tools needed to address all emission sources within its
scope. During the quantification phase, the quantifier will need to use more than one GHG
calculation tool to cover all the sources of GHG emissions identified in his territory.
GHG emissions are quantified by direct measurement or calculation methods. The selection of
a quantification method will depend on the information that is available for each source.
Direct measurement systems monitor GHG concentration and flows. Calculation-based
methods use activity data and emission factors to estimate GHG emissions. I used the second
methods for this thesis.
The two widely used GHG emission inventory and accounting guidelines are the greenhouse
protocol and the ISO standards.
The GHG Protocol Corporate Standard provides standards and guidance for companies and
other types of organizations that compile an inventory of greenhouse gas emissions. It
includes the balancing and reporting of the six greenhouse gases covered by the Kyoto
Protocol.
ii. Project level accounting standard− dispense specific principles, concepts, and methods
for quantifying and reporting greenhouse gas reductions – for example, decrease in
greenhouse gas emissions or increase in removals and/or storage – from projects climate
change mitigation (GHG projects).
i. ISO 14064-1: 2018 Part 1: This ISO is the first part and it‟s the main standard for
Greenhouse gases, contains Specifications with guidance at the organization level for
quantification and reporting of greenhouse gas emissions and removals.
ii. ISO 14064-2:2019 Part 2: Specification with guidance at the project level for
quantification, monitoring, and reporting of greenhouse gas emission reductions or
removal enhancements.
iii. ISO 14064-3:2019 Part 3: Specification with guidance for the verification and
validation of greenhouse gas statements.
1. EPA climate leaders protocol− is an effort by EPA, The Climate Leaders Greenhouse Gas
Inventory Protocol is based on the Greenhouse Gas Protocol (GHG Protocol) developed
by the World Resources Institute (WRI) and the World Business Council for Sustainable
Development.
2. California climate action registry protocol − The California Climate Action Registry is a
Climate Action Reserve program committed to solving climate change by accounting for
and reducing emissions. It was created by the State of California in 2001 to promote and
protect the first actions of companies to manage and reduce their greenhouse gases
(GHG).
3. The IPCC guideline − Consists of methodologies for estimating national inventories of
anthropogenic emissions from sources and greenhouse gas sinks. The 2006 IPCC
Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories (2006 IPCC Guidelines) provide and
were recently updated by 2019G.C.
21 By: Bereket Yemanbirhan
Thesis paper Ethiopian civil service university
Addis Ababa Bole International Airport serves the city of Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. The airport
is located in the Bole sub-city, 6 km (3.7 mi) southeast of Addis Ababa city center and 65 km
(40 mi) north of Debre−Zeyit. Formerly known as Haile Selassie International Airport, it is
the main of Ethiopian Airlines, the national airline that serves destinations in Ethiopia and
throughout the African continent, as well as offering nonstop service hub to Asia, Europe, and
North and South America. It is also the base of the Ethiopian Aviation Academy, a major
pilot training and aircraft maintenance center in Africa.
Ethiopian Airlines is the national airline of Ethiopia based mostly in Addis Ababa. One
amongst the leading airlines on the African continent, Ethiopian Airlines serves over sixty
international destinations across Africa, Asia, Europe, the center East and North America, still
as operative an in-depth domestic and international lading network. Ethiopian Airlines
became a member of Star Alliance in Dec-2011.
Ethiopian Airlines was founded on December 30, 1945, by Emperor Haile Selassie with
support from TWA. It began operating on 8 April 1946 with weekly service between Addis
Ababa and Cairo using five Douglas DC3 propeller aircraft.
The airline began long-haul flights to Frankfurt in 1958 and launched its first jet service from
Addis Ababa to Nairobi in January 1963. [34]
Based on greenhouse gas protocol− from Corporate Accounting and Reporting Standard, the
data lists below are needed for the quantification process.
Mobile Combustion
Data required: Total fuel used by each vehicle, Total distance traveled by each vehicle and
Fuel efficiency of each vehicle.
Refrigerants and Fugitives Includes leaks in Ethiopian Airlines HVAC system 3, chillers,
refrigerators, etc., through which refrigerant gas escapes. Most refrigerant gases contribute
to global warming when leaked into the atmosphere
Is activity-related data (volume of fuel consumed, total power spent, the mass of trash created,
etc.) that may be used to compute emissions using an emission factor.
3
HVAC stands for Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning. HVAC refers to the different systems used for
moving air between indoor and outdoor areas, along with heating and cooling both residential and commercial
buildings. Source: (Petro Home Service, 2019)
23 By: Bereket Yemanbirhan
Thesis paper Ethiopian civil service university
The emission factor (EF) is the number of emissions produced per unit of activity; it is the
Coefficient relating GHG activity data with the GHG emission. The value of EF can be
determined from a variety of well-known sources. When the checklist is finished, activity data
is gathered and emission factors are chosen.
Will be calculated fuel consumption at the airport (Bole international airport) to produce
electricity, steam, heat, or power.
Where
The CO 2 emissions associated with fuel combustion are a function of the volume of fuel
combusted, the density of the fuel, the carbon content of the fuel, and the fraction of carbon
that is oxidized to CO2. (Greenhouse Gas Inventory Guidance Direct Emissions from Mobile
Combustion Source, 2020)
The IPPC inventory software is used at this very paper for quantifying GHG from Mobile
sources like Domestic flights, international flights and trucks, cars, buses and any other
vehicles owned by Ethiopian airlines group.
24 By: Bereket Yemanbirhan
Thesis paper Ethiopian civil service university
This thesis will use EPA methodology (Greenhouse Gas Inventory Guidance Direct Fugitive
Emissions from Refrigeration, Air Conditioning, Fire Suppression, and Industrial Gases; for
this section.
Determine the number and types of refrigeration including the types of refrigerant used and
the total refrigerant capacity of each piece of equipment.
Identify any new equipment that was installed during the reporting period (2021) and was
charged on-site.
Where: CN= amount of refrigerant charged into the new piece of equipment
I will estimate losses from equipment leaks and service losses over the life of the equipment.
Identify any pieces of equipment that were disposed of during the reporting period. And
calculate the emission using eqution4.
Add the emissions from each piece of equipment for each type of emission (installation,
operation, and disposal) to get total emissions. Calculate separate totals for each type of
refrigerant used. Multiply the emissions of each refrigerant by the refrigerant‟s GWP to
calculate CO2 equivalent emissions.
Required data, statistics, information, material, etc. will be gathered from Ethiopian Airlines
is primary data, Ethiopian civil aviation, Federal transport ministry, and secondary data
will be gathered from the web and related bodies.
There are so many guidelines that are used to quantify GHG emission, for every section of the
calculation this thesis used the IPPC GHG inventory software, excel sheets from the
greenhouse gas protocol and EPA guidelines for calculating fugitive emissions, and any other
comparative guidelines published in the field recently.
There is uncertainty associated with all methods of calculating CO 2, CH4 , and N2O emissions
26 By: Bereket Yemanbirhan
Thesis paper Ethiopian civil service university
from all sources of GHG emissions. EPA recommends that any interested body which desires
to calculate GHG emissions spot the areas of uncertainty in their emissions calculations and
build a shot to use the foremost correct information possible.
For the purpose of this very thesis paper I used to assess the uncertainty using the IPCC GHG
inventory software.
IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories, 2006 insights about intrinsic
differences in the uncertainties of CO 2 emission factors of petroleum products, coal, and
natural gas. Petroleum products typically conform to fairly tight specifications which limit the
possible range of carbon content and calorific value and are also sourced from a relatively
small number of refineries and/or import terminals.
Emission factors for CH4and especially N2O are highly uncertain. High uncertainties in
emission factors may be ascribed to lack of relevant measurements and subsequent
generalizations, uncertainties in measurements, or an insufficient understanding of the
emission generating process. Furthermore, due to stochastic variations in process conditions,
high variability of the real-time emission factors for these gases might also occur.
In Scope 1 refrigerants: the quantity of leaked gas is assumed to equal the amount of gas
replaced in these systems by your HVAC or chiller maintenance company.
In Mobile combustion: “The greenhouse gases CO2, CH4, and N2O are emitted during the
combustion of fuels in mobile sources. For most transportation modes, CH4 and N2O
emissions comprise a relatively small proportion of overall transportation-related GHG
emissions (approximately one percent combined). For on-road vehicles less than 15 years old,
CH4, and N2O emissions typically account for one percent of emissions or less. However, for
older gasoline-fueled on-road vehicles, CH4, and N2O could be a more significant
(approximately five percent) portion of total GHG emissions. CH4 and N2O emissions are
typically an even higher percentage of total GHG emissions from non-road or alternative fuel
vehicles." (Greenhouse Gas Inventory Guidance Direct Emissions from Mobile Combustion,
2020)
Informed consent: potential participants (from Ethiopian Airlines, Ethiopian civil aviation,
Federal transport ministry, and related bodies) receive and understand all the information they
need to decide whether they want to cooperate and give any data or information needed.
Confidentiality statement: data and any valuable information gathered from Ethiopian
Airlines, Ethiopian civil aviation, Federal transport ministry, and related bodies will be kept
absolute hidden from everyone else and I will anonymize4 personally identifiable data so that
it can‟t be linked to other data by anyone else.
4
Remove identifying particulars or details from (something, especially medical test results), typically for
statistical or other purposes.
28 By: Bereket Yemanbirhan
Thesis paper Ethiopian civil service university
The previous chapters point out that climate change is happening, which is an inevitable
phenomenon. Every sector agriculture, deforestation, power, transport, industrial and building
should ensure sustainable development that withstands the hazards of climate change.
We do know now that, we can hold out against climate change with two possible approaches:
reducing and stabilizing the levels of heat-trapping greenhouse gases in the atmosphere
(“mitigation”) and/or adapting to the climate change already in the pipeline (“adaptation”). [35]
Adapting and/or mitigating to climate change for a given entity is not a priority but primarily
eloquent the sources of GHGs and quantifying the amount of those GHGs; is must that is
assessing the carbon footprint of a given entity.
Thus, this thesis is assessing the carbon inventory of Ethiopian Airlines group basically the
year 2021, Addis Ababa bole international airport by quantifying its scope 1 emissions. By
doing this the study will analyze the threshold level of the emission and overall environmental
performance of the Airport.
electricity off or
generator
from stationary
on average did
generators)
30
percentage of the energy refrigerant from mobile combustion
emissions to consumption
international air space of the airline
Thesis paper
by the airline, by
comparing to the How many equipment’s are at the Quantity of a given type of
global trend airline each mobile source
Amount of equipment leaks and
service losses over the life of the
equipment
Identify any pieces of equipment that
were disposed of during the
reporting period
1 Passenger Cars
3 Heavy-Duty Vehicles
4 Aircraft− a given
Model ofCommercial
mobile
Executive Jetscombustion
type
Mileage
Gross emissions from Primary
Fuelsourceusagefrom EA,
international flights civil aviation authority, and
type used
Fuel ministry
transport
Ethiopian civil service university
1.
E 2.
IPCC inventory
E Operation
Calculation Tool
=C×(x/100)×T
Mobile Combustion
00)× (1 – z/100)
Disposal=CD×(y/1
Thesis paper Ethiopian civil service university
Chapter four
For the purpose of analysis and communication this chapter is presented in three sections. The
first section dealt the outcome (Emissions) of raw data/activity data for the three categories of
GHG inventory….
From the results which is GHG emission data gained from section one, section two and three
will be the discussion/ the analysis part hence the quantitative data is interpreted from various
point of views in such a way that two of this papers' of objectives is gone to be meet.
4.1 Results
There are 3 GHG inventory sections below according to IPCC category, which is quantified in
this paper. The first section is Emission from stationary combustion mainly from various
types of backup generators, boilers and heaters which almost all of them consume Diesel fuel.
The second inventory section is Emission from mobile combustion like emission from
international flight, domestic flight and companies Vehicles of all type. Three years, from
2019−2021 Emission trend is analyzed for international flight and 9 years flight history data
is analyzed for GHG emissions from domestic flight that is from 2013 to 2021. For companies
owned vehicles (Ethiopian airlines group), trucks, automobiles and any other mobile fuel
consuming equipment‟s; emission of year 2021 is quantified activity data for the pervious
years is not available for the inventory in such a way that the trend projection will be done
based purchasing increments order of by extrapolation.
31 By: Bereket Yemanbirhan
Thesis paper Ethiopian civil service university
The third part of the inventory quantifies emissions from fugitive sources like refrigerants and
fire supplants located at various locations of the airline and emission from year 2021 is
calculated and emission projection will made based on material purchasing trend from the
company.
Note: the ultimate goal of this research paper is quantifying GHG emission of scope one for
the year 2021 and I used Fuel use data where most accurate for calculating CO2 emissions.
Emission from stationary combustion came from, includes fuel consumption at a facility to
produce electricity, steam, heat, or power. The combustion of fossil fuels by natural gas
boilers, diesel generators and other equipment emits carbon dioxide, methane, and nitrous
oxide into the atmosphere.
There are 48 different types of generators at various locations of the airport with different
capacity, 7 boilers where 2 of them are out of service at the time of inventory and 4 gas
burners that use Butane gas. (See Annex for detailed information)
Three GHG were assumed to be emitted during stationary combustion carbon dioxide,
methane and nitrous oxide.
Assumptions
The default oxidation factor is assumed to be 1, unless better information is available. (2006
IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories)
Tier 1
This inventory used Tier 1 method which, emission estimates requires the following for each
source category and fuel. This method is used because there are no technologies with
emission controls at the corporate.
32 By: Bereket Yemanbirhan
Thesis paper Ethiopian civil service university
For Stationary Combustion, the activity data are the amounts and types of fuel combusted.
Table 6 activity data/Fuel Consumption for Generators, boilers and gas burners
Source: Ethiopian airlines group (group internal audit, QMS, SMS, compliance and business
sustainability department)
Calculating Emissions
There are two main methods for estimating GHG emissions from stationary combustion
sources:
Direct measurement
Analysis of fuel input
The first method needs rigorous continuous emission control approach in such a way that for
this paper I used Fuel analysis method which uses a mass balance approach in which carbon
content factors are applied to fuel input to determine emissions.
EPA greenhouse inventory guide line is used for calculating the stationary combustion.
Emissions = Fuel x EF1 use this Equation when fuel consumption is known only in mass or
volume units, and no information is available about the fuel heat content or carbon content.
EF1 = CO2, CH4, or N2O emission factor per mass or volume unit
At this very section which is transport, the inventory includes International Aviation or flight,
Domestic Aviation/flight and Road Transportation of Ethiopian airlines group.
Ethiopian airlines fly to African 62cites, Europe, North and South America - 22 Cities, Gulf,
and Middle East & Asia - 26 Cities. This flight destination of the Airline makes Ethiopian
the world's 4th largest airline by the number of countries served. Which means the load will
bring more Climatic issues.
Activity data
Year fuel quantities (in tonnes): Fuel type Number of total flights
4000000
3000000
2000000
1000000
0
Inventory year 2019 2020 2021
5
“To understand the kind of damage that climate change will inflict, look at COVID-19 and spread the pain out
over a much longer period.” source: https://www.gatesnotes.com/Energy/Climate-and-COVID-19
36 By: Bereket Yemanbirhan
Thesis paper Ethiopian civil service university
Ethiopian airlines almost fly 23 destinations domestically for a various travelers from tourists
up to local citizens.
The Number of passengers flying with the airline is dramatically increasing every single year
which on average 200,000 new passengers‟ are added.
Table 11 Ethiopian airlines domestic flight Annual passenger travel data from
2013−2021
Source: EFDR ministry of transport and logistics/environment department
Activity data
Table 12 Ethiopian airlines domestic flight Annual fuel consumption data from
2013−2021
Source: EFDR ministry of transport and logistics/environment department
Emission factor
100000
50000
0
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022
year of inventory
Figure 8 GHG emission trend from domestic flight from 2013 to 2021
4.1.2.3 Quantifying emission from vehicles, trucks and any other fuel consuming
machinery
This section of the inventory is quantifying GHG from any mobile combustion activities
owned by Ethiopian airlines. For the purpose calculation I separately calculate emission from
diesel consuming mobile sources and Benzene or regular fuel consuming sources, in such a
way that the activity data is annual fuel usage for both cases.
Table 15 Inventory of vehicles, car and fuel consuming machinery at calendar year 2021
Category Quantity in units
Ambulance 4
Automobile 186
Bus (any type) 121
Construction trucks and machinery 70
Dry Cargo 9
Field Vehicle/ PICK-UP 19
Liquid Cargo 7
Motor Bicycle and 3 wheel 2
Other 17
Vehicle with Machinery 306
Total 741
Activity data
There are different types of vehicles, trucks, cars, equipment‟s with machinery and
construction trucks which burn diesel and regular fuel. Total fuel usage for year 2021 is taken
for GHG inventory.
Table 16 Year 2021 Fuel Consumption/ Diesel for trucks, cars, vehicles and any other
machines
Source: Ethiopian airlines group (group internal audit, QMS, SMS, compliance and business
sustainability department)
month of Purchased fuel 2021 Fuel type Quantity in liters L
January Diesel 785564
February Diesel 493618
March Diesel 1033961
April Diesel 870736
May Diesel 609469
June Diesel 637927
July Diesel 653920
August Diesel 1444630
September Diesel 783190
October Diesel 155958
November Diesel 574226
December Diesel 506978
Total fuel usage 8,550,177 Liters
Scope 1
(metric tonnes)
Fuel Use 292.42 TJ CO2 22883.070
CH4 0.003
N2O 0.004
Total (metric tonnes CO2e) 22883.070
Table 19 Year 2021 Fuel Consumption/ regular or Benzene for trucks, cars and any
other vehicles
Source: Ethiopian airlines group (group internal audit, QMS, SMS, compliance and business
sustainability department)
month of Purchased fuel 2021 Fuel type Quantity in liters L
January Regular 14093
February Regular 271433
March Regular 33427
April Regular 13559
May Regular 39979
June Regular 46982
July Regular 30648
August Regular 59618
September Regular 26915
October Regular 75254
November Regular 31479
December Regular 11103
Total fuel usage 654,490 Liters
CH4 25 kg/TJ
N2O 3.2 kg/TJ
Therefore, 24434.05 metric tonnes of CO2e was emitted from vehicles, trucks cars and other
mobiles source like construction equipment‟s.
0%
2%
Domestic flight
98%
Activity data
The following data used for the Screening Method requires for organization's/Ethiopian
airlines to quantify emissions from fugitive sources.
a. Type of Equipment
b. Number of Units
c. Refrigerant or Fire Suppressant Used
d. Total Refrigerant or Fire Suppressant Charge for the Equipment.
EPAs GHG inventory excel spreadsheet is used for quantifying fugitive emissions, for the
purpose of refrigerant and cooling system calculation screening method is used.
Table 22 Type of Equipment and Default Capacity Ranges (Lower to Upper Range)
Domestic Refrigeration Domestic refrigeration units (capacity 0.05 to 0.5 kg)
Medium/Large Medium and large commercial refrigeration units (capacity 50 to 2,000 kg)
Commercial
Transport Refrigeration Transportation refrigeration units (capacity 3 to 8 kg)
Industrial Refrigeration Industrial, food processing and cold storage units (capacity 10 to 10,000 kg)
Table 23 Source Level Refrigeration Gas CO2 Equivalent Emissions year 2021 -
Screening Method
Data gap
Equipment capacity data of 5 Cool Dolly Cooling System, one Air Compressor Refrigeration
Air dryer, two Oils refrigerator, one Oils Blast chiller, eight Ozti counter type refrigerator
(bench type), four BICOLD Chiller, five MISA Cold room, one Rosh Freezer and three FRC
Blast chillers were not found at the inventory.
Totally 27 different types of items data is not available at the time of inventory, Hence the
total Emission from refrigerant and cooling system may exceed above the calculated value.
HFC, PFC, and CO2 fire suppressants are required to be included in the GHG inventory.
Other fire suppressants such as Halon compounds, HCFCs, aqueous solutions, or inert gases
are typically excluded from a GHG inventory. (Epa.gov, 2013)
Fire suppression equipment can be divided into two broad categories, fixed and portable
equipment. Screening Method provides an emission factor for each type of equipment.
Assumption
From greenhouse gas inventory guideline for fugitive emissions, Emissions from fixed
systems are assumed to be 2.5 percent (0.025) of the total capacity of the units for each gas.
Emissions from portable equipment are assumed to be 3.5 percent (0.035) of the total capacity
of the units for each gas. By adding the capacities of each portable unit for each gas and of
each fixed unit for each gas and multiply the total capacity by the appropriate emission factor
the total emission is calculated.
Activity data
There were totally 15 portable CO2 fire suppression systems located at various locations of
the airline with range of capacity from 2kg to 30kg, 32 fixed types (Fixed on buildings/hangar
Fire suppression system), 3 FM 200 Fire suppressors, which emit HFC-227ea gas, 54 ABC
Dry Chemical powder fire suppression system which I got full data. (See appendix 8) other fire
suppression systems like water and foam are ignored for the inventory.
Table 24 Total fugitive emission from fire suppression system year 2021
Type of Equipment Gas Gas GWP Capacity (kg) CO2 Equivalent Emissions (kg)
(Fixed/Portable) Type
Portable CO2 1 1,090.00 21.8
Fixed CO2 1 171 2.6
Fixed HFC-227ea 3,220 516 24,922.80
Portable HFC-236fa 9,810 269 52,777.80
Fixed HFC-236fa 9,810 338.2 49,766.10
Total CO2 Equivalent Emissions (metric tons) – Fire suppression system 127491.1
Data gap
Capacity data of totally ten fixed ABC dry chemical type fire suppression systems, ten CO 2
fire suppression systems and one unknown both type and capacity were found at the raw data.
For the study year 2021 the total GHG emission was 5654776.128 tonnes of tCO 2.
Direct Emissions
from Stationary
Combustion
0.118%
Direct Emissions
from Mobile
Combustion Direct Emissions
97% Other from Fugitive
3% Sources
2.88%
4.2 Discussion
A reliable power supply is essential to the operation of any business. However, in most
developing countries, the power supply is highly unreliable. For example, duration of a
typical electrical outage (hours) in Ethiopia was reported at 4.6 hours in 2015.
This will lead to using backup generators‟ for generating electricity and heat by burning fossil
fuel with a direct emission of GHGs.
The relationship between energy consumption and carbon emission is two side of the same
coin. Giant Corporate companies like Ethiopian airlines group, with higher energy
consumption6 will bring environmental damage and climate change.
6
The causal relationship between economic growth, energy consumption and Environmental damage is three
inter−dependent scenarios.
47 By: Bereket Yemanbirhan
Thesis paper Ethiopian civil service university
Liquid fuel consumption of the Airline for international flight year 2021 was 1.702167M
tonnes of Jet A1 with respective GHG emission 5,378,847.353 tCO2 tonnes. Those figures
means in other words…
This increasing demand for air travel with a growth average rate of 20% every single year will
impose a significant impact on climate change, where travel demand and fossil fuel burning
are related each other.
Paramet 2010/1 2011/1 2012/1 2013/1 2014/1 2015/1 2016/1 2017/18 2018/19 2019/2
ers 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 0
Aircraft 46 48 58 66 76 77 87 108 116 126
140
120
100
80 Aircraft
60
Destination
40
20
2019/20
2018/19
2017/18
2016/17
2015/16
2014/15 Passenger number
2013/14
2012/13
2011/12
2010/11
Section three: assessing the percentage of emissions to international air space by the
airline, by comparing to the global trend
Airspace Under global airspace, countries would be responsible for all flight emissions over
their national territory – or out to their 12 mile territorial sea limit. Emissions of over flights
(aircraft not landing in their territory) would be included. Emissions from international
aviation (International Bunkers) are outlined as Emissions from flights that depart in one
country and arrive in an exceedingly totally different country, as well as take-offs and
landings for these flight stages” whereas Emissions from domestic aviation are defined as
Emissions from civil domestic traveler and freight traffic that departs and arrives within the
same country (commercial, private, agriculture, etc.), including take-offs and landings. [36]
50 By: Bereket Yemanbirhan
Thesis paper Ethiopian civil service university
From chapter 4 emission summery from year 2021 there was 5.4 million tonnes of tCO 2, it‟s
observed that 95% emission came from international flight. Hence the airline emit 5.4M
tonnes of tCO2e to the international airspace at 2021, this figure will be boosted at the coming
years because of an increasing demand for air travel by passengers and number of
destinations.
Backup generators
International flight
Domestic flight
Other mobile sources
Fugitive sources
ICAO divides the world into six statistical regions. Flights within the Asia-Pacific region
caused the most CO2 emissions related to passenger transport in 2013, 2018 and 2019.
This region accounted for 22% of total global emissions in 2013, and this share rose to 25%.
In 2018 and 2019 four of the top 10 departure countries with the most aviation emissions
(China, Japan, India and Australia) are in the Asia Pacific region. Flights within North
America account for 16% of global passenger carbon emissions2019, up from almost 19% in
2013. Flights within Europe, between EU countries and outside the EU accounted for 14% of
total global emissions in 2019, up from 13% in 2013. [37]
Figure 16 Carbon dioxide emissions from commercial aviation worldwide from 2004 to
2022 (in million metric tons)
Source:https://www.statista.com/statistics/1186820/co2-emissions-commercial-aviation-
worldwide/
The trend shows an increment level of emission every single year, hence combating climate
change hindered by the aviation industry will be difficult unless new paradigm shift is
adopted.
These new ideology may bring a greener airline‟s all over the world by adopting new
technological aircrafts with alternative biofuel usage alongside with carbon offsetting
multilateral options like market based approach.
Chapter five
Surpassingly emission on 2020 was very low compared to the pervious and the late years. As
we remember year 2020 was year of Covid19 pandemic and human/anthropogenic
interference on the environment have been barely less.
The total GHG emission from the airline is above from the finding of this research paper
because of…
There were missing activity data from Refrigerant, cooling system and fire suppression
systems.
1) Fuel usage is applied for estimating emissions from mobile sources, this will bring
some quantity uncertainty of CH4 and N2O emissions: where both depend more on the
emission control technologies employed in the vehicle and the distance traveled.
2) There are unmeasured non-CO2 -effects from the airline; principally emissions of
nitrogen oxides, contrails7 and aviation-induced cirrus clouds, and these effects are
estimated to be almost as significant as the CO 2 emissions themselves in terms of
their global warming potential (GWP) 100-year perspective.
According to vehicle inventory from the past years 24.5% increment is observed, which at
least 30 vehicles are added to the compline‟s system in such a way that this none electric cars
will impose climate change with an increasing factor every year.
Based on emission significance from year 2021, emission from Mobile combustion, fugitive
emission and emission from stationary combustion will be ranked from higher significant to
the lower. From mobile combustion emission from international flight is the most significant
and needs to be addressed in such a manner, where emission from stationary combustion is
almost 0.118% comparing to others; but it isn’t meant to be ignored.
7
Contrails are line-shaped clouds sometimes produced by aircraft engine exhaust, typically at aircraft cruise
altitudes several miles above the Earth's surface. source: web
53 By: Bereket Yemanbirhan
Thesis paper Ethiopian civil service university
It‟s a growing pattern we observe at global and in Ethiopian context, hence projected emission
by 2050 will; commercial aircraft emissions could triple given the projected growth of
passenger air travel and freight. other emissions will also continue to grow, the collective use
of fossil fuel burning from automobiles, unpredictable production of electricity by backup
generators, and an exceeding growth of cargo section (this section uses giant refrigerant and
cooling systems‟) of the airline will lead further climate change in considerable amount for the
future, unless technological and other mitigation measures are taken.
Energy demand will be grown for the coming years as long as with increment of both number
of passengers and flight destination, where growth in every aspect is observed within every
year this will bring an exceeding GHG emission year from year.
From its annual growth (Ethiopian airlines), It‟s obvious that the airline will have a
considerable emission share to an international airspace for the coming years and now.
There must be Commitment on solar and energy storage solutions that can provide
reliable, sustainable, affordable energy to the airline relying on fossil fuel generators.
The second option is using new generation low emission backup generators like Euro
G5 backup generators.
Alternative Fuels (biofuels) − it‟s obvious that by decreasing fossil fuel dependency it
will be a cut back for GHG emissions.
New technologies for the industry− purchasing aircrafts with more efficient engine
technologies like Electric and hybrid-electric propulsion aircrafts of airbus.
Investing in emissions offsets within or outside of the aviation sector.− from voluntary
offsetting schemes for passengers, to Carbon Offsetting and Reduction Scheme for
International Aviation (CORSIA8) and/or a global initiative9 to stabilize CO 2 output.
8
The objective of CORSIA is to achieve carbon-neutral growth for the aviation industry from 2020 onwards.
Forecasted to reduce approximately 2.5 billion tonnes of CO2 between 2021 and 2035, CORSIA is one of the
largest carbon pricing instruments in the world in terms of greenhouse gas emissions coverage. source: web
54 By: Bereket Yemanbirhan
Thesis paper Ethiopian civil service university
Changing from fossil burning none electric vehicles‟ to electric ones' – there is a good
start at Ethiopian airline group for shifting up from fuel burning vehicle‟s to electric.
From the truck inventory record 0n 2021 there were 103.
Changing paradigm from using HFCs and PFCs related fire suppression systems to
zero or low-GWP extinguishing agents to reduce CO 2 e emissions. The options to
HFCs and PFCs in general flooding system are each in-type gaseous agents and not-
in-type options. The in-type gaseous options consist of CO 2, inert gases, and
fluorinated ketones, and the not-in-type options consist of various substances and
structures which include dispersed and condensed aerosol extinguishing systems,
water sprinklers, water mist, foam, and inert gas generators.
Avoid leaks from refrigerant, continuous inspection on the equipment‟s with proper
servicing, facilitate transition to low-GWP refrigerants and properly destroy
refrigerants at end of life.
Finally adhering to international agreements for combating climate change is a way for both
actions that is adaptation and mitigation measures to take in multilateral way for example, the
International Air Transport Association (IATA) in 2009, set three global goals for the aviation
industry to address its climate impact: An annual average fuel efficiency improvement of
1.5% from 2009 to 2020, Stabilize net CO2 emissions at 2020 levels with carbon-neutral
growth and Reduce aviation‟s net CO 2 emissions to half of what they were in 2005, by
205010.
The first two goals are out dated and not achieved so far but there is a room for goal 3 yet,
that requires continued investment in new technologies and strong support mechanisms for
deployment of sustainable aviation fuels.
9
Ethiopia summited State Action Plan on CO2 Emissions Reduction Activities from aviation industry for IACO
on Jan 2020.
10
IATA - Fly Net Zero. Fly Net Zero is the commitment of airlines to achieve net zero carbon by 2050, bringing
air transport in line with the Paris agreement to limit global warming to 1.5°C.
source: https://www.iata.org/en/programs/environment/flynetzero/
55 By: Bereket Yemanbirhan
Thesis paper Ethiopian civil service university
Another way to fight climate change within an aviation industry is "Action Plan on the
reduction of Greenhouse Gas Emissions from aviation". It was initiated by ICAO to bring its
190 member states together; it‟s the first and globally harmonized agreement from a sector on
goal to address its CO2 emission which was provided to COP15 11.
11
The overall goal for the United Nations Climate Change Conference of the Parties (COP 15) in Denmark was
to establish a global climate agreement intended to enter into force in 2013 following the end of the Kyoto
Agreement‟s first commitment period.
56 By: Bereket Yemanbirhan
Thesis paper Ethiopian civil service university
References
[1] Climate Change and Development in Three Charts | Center for Global
Development | Ideas to Action. (2015, August 18). Center for Global Development |
Ideas to Action; www.cgdev.org. https://www.cgdev.org/blog/climate-change-and-
development-three-charts
[2] Wu, Y., Luo, J., Shen, L., & Skitmore, M. (2018, May 19). Sustainability | Free Full-
Text | The Effects of an Energy Use Paradigm Shift on Carbon Emissions: A
Simulation Study. MDPI; www.mdpi.com. https://www.mdpi.com/2071-
1050/10/5/1639
[3] Energy Study Institute (EESI), E. and. (2019, October 17). Fact Sheet | The Growth
in Greenhouse Gas Emissions from Commercial Aviation (2019) | White
Papers | EESI. Fact Sheet | The Growth in Greenhouse Gas Emissions from
Commercial Aviation (2019) | White Papers | EESI; www.eesi.org.
https://www.eesi.org/papers/view/fact-sheet-the-growth-in-greenhouse-
gas-emissions-from-commercial-aviation
[4] Airport Carbon Emissions Reduction. (2022, March 28). Airport Carbon Emissions
Reduction; www.faa.gov.
https://www.faa.gov/airports/environmental/air_quality/carbon_emissions_reductio
n/.
[5] JIWA, A., & Nakanishi, D. G. (2020, Dec 15). Courier Workshop episode 4: Carbon
footprint . Courier; www.couriermedia.com. Retrieved Feb 20, 2022, from
https://www.couriermedia.com/podcast/tracing-your-carbon-footprint/
[6] Akanwa, A & Joe-Ikechebelu, N (2019, Dec 12). The Developing World’s
Contribution to Global Warming and the Resulting Consequences of Climate Change
in These Regions: A Nigerian Case Study . www.intechopen.com. Retrieved Feb 21,
2022, from https://www.intechopen.com/chapters/70313
[7] Masson-Delmotte, V., Zhai, P., Pörtner, H.-O., Roberts, D., Skea, J., Shukla, P.,
Pirani, A., Moufouma-Okia, W., Péan, C., Pidcock, R., Connors, S., Matthews, J., Chen,
Y., Zhou, X., Gomis, M., Lonnoy, E., Maycock, T., Tignor, M. and Waterfield, T. (2019).
Global warming of 1.5°C An IPCC Special Report on the impacts of global warming of
1.5°C above pre-industrial levels and related global greenhouse gas emission
[8] Timothy, P., Sandra, B., & Kenneth, A. (2008). Comparison of registry
methodologies for reporting carbon benefits for afforestation projects in the United
States (Vol. 11). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envsci.2008.06.004
[9] Air transport action group (2020). Facts & figures. [online] Atag.org. Available at:
https://www.atag.org/facts-figures.html.
[10] Larsson, J., Kamb, A., Nässén, J. and Åkerman, J. (2018). Measuring greenhouse
gas emissions from international air travel of a country’s residents methodological
development and application for Sweden. Environmental Impact Assessment
Review, 72, pp.137–144.
[12] Airport Carbon Accreditation (2022) – Home page. [online] Available at:
https://www.airportcarbonaccredited.org/ [Accessed 20 Jan. 2022].
[14] Noelle Eckley Selin (2013). Carbon footprint | ecology and conservation. In:
Encyclopedia Britannica. [Online] Available at:
https://www.britannica.com/science/carbon-footprint.
[17] Chen, R., Zhang, R. and Han, H. (2021). Where has carbon footprint research
gone? Ecological Indicators, 120, p.106882.
[18] Heinonen, J., Ottelin, J., Ala-Mantila, S., Wiedmann, T., Clarke, J. and Junnila, S.
(2020). Spatial consumption-based carbon footprint assessments - A review of
recent developments in the field. Journal of Cleaner Production, 256, p.120335.
[19] Weidema, B.P., Thrane, M., Christensen, P., Schmidt, J. and Løkke, S. (2008).
Carbon Footprint. Journal of Industrial Ecology, [online] 12(1), pp.3–6. Available at:
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1530-9290.2008.00005.x.
[20] Mahnaz, A., Hossein, Y. and Mahsa, M.R.S. (2020). Carbon Footprint And Its
Calculation Methods With Emphasis On Electricity Generation From Renewable And
Fossil Sources. www.sid.ir, [online] 6(2), pp.31–41. Available at:
https://www.sid.ir/en/Journal/ViewPaper.aspx?ID=794313 [Accessed 1 Feb. 2022].
[22] US EPA, O. (2020). Scope 1 and Scope 2 Inventory Guidance. [online] US EPA.
Available at:
https://www.epa.gov/climateleadership/scope-1-and-scope-2-inventory-guidance.
[23] US EPA, (2016). Scope 3 Inventory Guidance. [online] www.epa.gov. Available at:
https://www.epa.gov/climateleadership/scope-3-inventory-guidance.
[24] Anthesis, (2022) What are Scope 1, 2 & 3 Emissions? [online] Available at:
https://www.anthesisgroup.com/scope-1-2-3-emissions/.
[26] Carbon Brief. (2020). Guest post: Calculating the true climate impact of aviation
emissions. [online] Available at: https://www.carbonbrief.org/guest-post-
calculating-the-true-climate-impact-of-aviation-emissions.
[27] States., U. (2005). Aviation & emissions: a primer. Washington, D.C.: Federal
Aviation Administration, Office Of Environment And Energy. Pp2
59 By: Bereket Yemanbirhan
Thesis paper Ethiopian civil service university
[28] Jonas, M., Bun, R., Nahorski, Z., Marland, G., Gusti, M. and Danylo, O. (2019).
Quantifying greenhouse gas emissions. Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for
Global Change, 24(6), pp.839–852.
[29] Pulselli, F.M. and Marchi, M. (2015). Global Warming Potential and the Net
Carbon Balance [Online] Science Direct. Available at:
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B9780124095489095269.
[30] Airport carbon accreditation (2022). Airports & CO2 . [online] Available at:
https://www.airportcarbonaccreditation.org/participants/europe.html [Accessed 5
Feb. 2022].
https://www.novapublishers.com/catalog/product_info.php?products_id=5999.
[33] Johnston, A.H., and Karanfil, T. (2013). Calculating the greenhouse gas emissions
of water utilities. Journal - American Water Works Association, [online] 105(7),
pp.E363–E371. Available
at:https://www.clemson.edu/cecas/departments/eees/documents/Anthony_Johnsto
n_Thesis.pdf [Accessed 22 Feb. 2022].
[35] NASA (2019). Global climate change adaptation and mitigation. [online] Climate
Change: Vital Signs of the Planet. Available at:
https://climate.nasa.gov/solutions/adaptation-mitigation/.
[36] Transport & Environment. (2013). Allocating aviation CO2 emissions - The
Appendices
Data
Head Stand by Stand by Generator 9/16/2012 P1050 0276617/006 New simulator Diesel
Office- Generator
FM Stand by Stand by diesel generator 2018 500P 3604/18 Head Office Diesel
Generator
Generator
Stand by Stand by diesel generator 2/1/2019 1500P 12105/19 Old simulator Diesel
Generator
service
service
Mobile stand by Movable Stand by 2021 100P 100P-SA Airport emergence Diesel
(Bore Hole)
Stand by Stand by diesel generator 5/1/2020 C27505 E201806799 New Medical unit Diesel
Generator
KVA
KVA CAFTERIA)
Power DIESEL GENERATING 2017 18V 2000 G25F 17100855 HANGAR #5 Diesel
ENGIN)1102KW
Power DIESEL GENERATING 2017 18V 2000 G26F 17100856 HANGAR #5 Diesel
ENGIN)1102KW
PORTABLE
2.8 MW 1.0/115/70-Y
1.4 MW 1.0/95/70-Y
CAT-FM Generator Stand by diesel Generator 23-Jun-15 C200D5 G15K846850 Inflight Catering Diesel
EAA- Generator # 1 Stand by diesel generator 2014 AC110K 25401270 AMTS Diesel
ATM01954
347633 5
T/V13.01 314.0043
T/V13.01 314.0041
Warehouse )
& Alternator
-A05K534010
Generator Diesel Stand by April, 2016 Perkins Engine Engine - ETCT#2 ( Diesel
Alternator - café)
EC043 2M4
Generator Diesel Stand by April, 2016 Perkins Engine Engine - ETCT#2 ( Diesel
EC043 2M4
Generator Diesel Stand by April, 2016 Perkins Engine Engine - ETCT#2 ( Diesel
EC043 2M4
Welding Diesel Welding KHM595 PS 328 423 0011 ETCT'S Cargo Diesel
(Portable)
GENERATOR 1f TERMINAL
GENERATOR 1f TERMINAL
ET- Generator STAND-BY 2018.04 PWM 1500S TJ1801036 SKY LIGHT Diesel
Hotel Generator STAND-BY 2018.04 PWM 1500S TJ1801037 SKY LIGHT Diesel
GENERATOR HOTEL
Ethiopia Generator 1260 Stand by diesel generator 2001 QSK 60 f01k1411990 ADD .APT. OLD Diesel
Services- )
FM Generator 1260 Stand by diesel generator 2001 QSK 60 f01k1411980 ADD .APT. OLD Diesel
Generator 1260 Stand by diesel generator 2001 QSK 60 F01k142000 ADD .APT. OLD Diesel
Generator 1260 Stand by diesel generator 2001 QSK 60 F01k141970 ADD .APT. OLD Diesel
Generator 350 Stand by diesel generator 2000 COMIUNCE 100k114900 ADD. APT . Diesel
Generator 1.8 Stand by diesel generator 27-Sep-16 QSK 60 -G4 64537-54 ADDF.APT NEW Diesel
gen set 01 )
Generator 1.8 Stand by diesel generator 11/1/2016 QSK 60 -G4 64537-63 ADDF.APT NEW Diesel
gen set 02 )
Generator 1.8 Stand by diesel generator 9/26/2016 QSK 60 -G4 64537 -53 ADDF.APT NEW Diesel
gen set 03 )
Generator 1.8 Stand by diesel generator 11/10/2016 QSK 60 -G4 64537 -65 ADDF.APT NEW Diesel
gen set 04 )
Generator 1.8 Stand by diesel generator 24-Oct-16 QSK 60 -G4 64537 -57 ADDF.APT NEW Diesel
gen set 05 )
Generator 1.8 Stand by diesel generator 17-Oct-16 QSK 60 -G4 64537 -55 ADDF.APT NEW Diesel
gen set 06 )
new Mobil Stand by mobile diesel 1-Sep-18 C175D5E l18l8085412 NEW FOR Diesel
LIGHT SYSTEM
Source: https://www.generatorsource.com/
Name of Model Year of Type of Application Location Numb Full Remain Type of
Equipment Man. Fugitive Capacit ing Gas Used
y(KG)/ Quantit
LT. y (KG)
FRC Blast OBC402AP _ Refrigeration fast cooling catering 1 no data no data R-404A
chiller 2P/DX +SXS food
FRC Blast OBC402AP _ Refrigeration fast cooling catering 1 no data no data R-404A
chiller 2P/DX +SXS food
FRC Blast OBC402AP _ Refrigeration fast cooling catering 1 no data no data R-404A
chiller 2P/DX +SXS food
Misa Cold room M/MGP200RSEE 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 9.9KG 9.9KG R-404A
550R system
Misa Cold room M/MGP75RSEE2 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 7.0KG 7.0KG R-404A
60R system
Misa Cold room M/MGP25RSEE8 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 2.45K 2.45K R-404A
0R system G G
Misa Cold room M/MGP15RSEE5 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 1.6KG 1.6KG R-404A
0R system
Misa Cold room M/MGP15RSEE5 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 1.6KG 1.6KG R-404A
0R system
Misa Cold room M/MGP30RSEE1 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 3.6KG 3.6KG R-404A
25R system
Misa Cold room M/MGP30RSEE1 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 3.6KG 3.6KG R-404A
25R system
Misa Cold room M/MGP30RSEE1 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 3.6KG 3.6KG R-404A
25R system
Misa Cold room M/MGP30RSEE1 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 3.6KG 3.6KG R-404A
25R system
Misa Cold room M/MGP15RSEE5 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 1.6KG 1.6KG R-404A
0R system
Misa Cold room M/MGP75RSEE2 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 7.0KG 7.0KG R-404A
60R system
Misa Cold room M/MGP50RSEE2 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 7.0KG 7.0KG R-404A
00R system
Misa Cold room M/MGP40RSEE1 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 4.5KG 4.5KG R-404A
35R system
Misa Cold room M/MGP75RSEE2 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 7.0KG 7.0KG R-404A
60R system
Misa Cold room M/MGP40RSEE1 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 4.5KG 4.5KG R-404A
35R system
Misa Cold room M/MGP30RSEE1 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 3.6KG 3.6KG R-404A
25R system
Misa Cold room M/MGP50RSEE2 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 7.0KG 7.0KG R-404A
00R system
Misa Cold room M/MGP40RSEE1 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 4.5KG 4.5KG R-404A
35R system
Misa Cold room M/MGP25RSEE8 18/06/2015 Refrigeration deep freezing catering 1 2.45K 2.45K R-404A
0R freezer G G
MISA M/MGN50RSEE8 18/06/2015 Refrigeration deep freezing catering 1 3.6KG 3.6KG R-404A
Freezer#01 5R freezer
CELTIC M/MGN100RSEE _ Refrigeration deep freezing catering 1 7.0KG 7.0KG R-404A
Freezer 150R freezer
CELTIC M/MGN100RSEE _ Refrigeration deep freezing catering 1 7.0KG 7.0KG R-404A
Freezer 150R freezer
MISA cold 4TES-12Y-4OP 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 no data no data R-404A
room system
MISA cold 4TES-12Y-4OP 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 no data no data R-404A
room system
MISA cold 4TES-12Y-4OP 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 no data no data R-404A
room system
Rosh Freezer GN1410TNM _ Refrigeration deep freezing catering 1 no data no data R-404A
freezer
MISA 10114556 _ Refrigeration deep freezing catering 1 no data no data R-404A
Freezer#02 freezer
MISA 10114556 _ Refrigeration deep freezing catering 1 no data no data R-404A
Freezer#02 freezer
MISA Fish cold 10054821 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 no data no data R-404A
room system
MISA mix cold 10054821 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 no data no data R-404A
room system
MISA meat 10054821 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 no data no data R-404A
cold room system
MISA Cold 10054821 18/06/2015 Refrigeration cooling catering 1 no data no data R-404A
room system
BICOLD WHA 2090 _ Refrigeration cooling catering 1 no data no data R-404A
Chiller system
BICOLD WHA2315 _ Refrigeration cooling catering 1 no data no data R-404A
Chiller system
BICOLD WHA 2315 _ Refrigeration cooling catering 1 no data no data R-404A
Chiller system
BICOLD WHA 2315 _ Refrigeration cooling catering 1 no data no data R-410A
Chiller system
Ozti counter PZC54.HO NTS _ Refrigeration cooling C9 1 no data no data R-404A
type system
refrigerator(ben
ch type)
Ozti counter PZC54.HO NTS _ Refrigeration cooling C9 1 no data no data R-404A
type system
refrigerator(ben
ch type)
Ozti counter PZC54.HO NTS _ Refrigeration cooling C9 1 no data no data R-404A
type system
refrigerator(ben
ch type)
Ozti counter PZC54.HO NTS _ Refrigeration cooling C9 1 no data no data R-404A
type system
refrigerator(ben
ch type)
Ozti counter PZC54.HO NTS _ Refrigeration cooling C9 1 no data no data R-404A
type system
refrigerator(ben
ch type)
storage 1)
Methane CH4 25
Appendices 9 Uncertainty analysis @sample for domestic flight year 2021 generated by
IPCC GHG inventory software
2006 IPCC Categories Gas Base Year Year T Activity Emission Combined Contributi
emissions emissions Data Factor Uncertaint on to
or or Uncertaint Uncertainty y Variance
removals removals y (%) (%) by
(Gg CO2 (Gg CO2 (%) Category
equivalent) equivalent) in Year T
1.A - Fuel Combustion
Activities
1.A.3.a.ii - Domestic CO2 0 101.42101 5 4.1708292 6.511207 41.657883
Aviation - Liquid Fuels
1.A.3.a.ii - Domestic CH4 0 0.014894 5 100 100.12492 0.0002124
Aviation - Liquid Fuels
1.A.3.a.ii - Domestic N2O 0 0.8794549 5 150 150.08331 1.6642183
Aviation - Liquid Fuels