Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pediatric Vocal Fold Paralysis
Pediatric Vocal Fold Paralysis
Objective: To review our experience of pediatric vocal Iatrogenic causes (43% [n = 44]) formed the largest group,
fold paralysis (VFP), with particular emphasis on etio- followed by idiopathic VFP (35% [n = 36]), neurologi-
logical factors, associated airway pathologic conditions, cal causes (16% [n = 16]), and finally birth trauma (5%
and treatment and prognostic outcomes. [n = 5]). Associated upper airway pathologic condi-
tions were noted in 66% (n = 23) of patients who under-
Design: Retrospective case review of a cohort of pa- went tracheotomy. Tracheotomy was necessary in only
tients presenting with VFP. 57% (n = 28) of children with bilateral VFP. Prognosis
was variable depending upon the cause, with neurologi-
Setting: Tertiary referral center. cal VFP having the highest rate of recovery (71% [5/7])
and iatrogenic VFP the lowest rate (46% [12/26]).
Patients: A consecutive sample of 102 patients present-
ing with VFP to Great Ormond Street Hospital for Chil- Conclusion: Recovery after an interval of up to 11 years
dren, London, England, over a 14-year period from 1980 was seen in idiopathic bilateral VFP; this has significant
to 1994. implications when considering lateralization proce-
dures in these patients.
Results: There was an almost equal distribution of uni-
lateral (52% [n = 53]) and bilateral (48% [n = 49]) VFP. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2000;126:21-25
V
OCAL FOLD paralysis (VFP) Diagnosis depends on careful evalu-
is the absence of move- ation of the larynx by an experienced pe-
ment of the vocal folds fol- diatric otolaryngologist. This may be per-
lowing dysfunction of the formed by direct laryngoscopy with the
motor nerve supply to the patient under general anesthesia, by dy-
larynx. Presenting symptoms in children in- namic assessment of the larynx during the
clude stridor, a weak cry or voice, feeding lightening of anesthesia, or by flexible
difficulties, and aspiration. It is the second fiberoptic endoscopy; however, the last
most common cause of neonatal stridor and technique may not identify other associ-
has been reported to account for 10% of all ated airway pathologic conditions. Ultra-
congenital anomalies affecting the larynx.1 sonography of the larynx is a useful ad-
Vocal cord paralysis may be unilateral junctive examination that we now use
From the Great Ormond Street
or bilateral. Stridor is the most common pre- routinely.2
Hospital for Children, London, senting symptom and is often the reason for The treatment of VFP depends pri-
England (Drs Daya, Hosni, the failure of neonates to wean from nasal marily on a patient’s symptoms, particu-
Bejar-Solar, Evans, and Bailey). continuouspositiveairwaypressuretherapy. larly the extent of airway compromise. The
Dr Bejar-Solar is now with In bilateral cases, the stridor is usually more presence of associated laryngeal patho-
the Department of Pediatric severe; in the past, tracheotomy has tradi- logic conditions is an important consid-
Otolaryngology, National tionally been recommended for these pa- eration. Patterns do emerge, however, de-
Autonomous University of tients. Dysphonia is not a typical feature of pending on the type of VFP and the cause.
Mexico, Mexico City. Dr Daya bilateral VFP, since most cases are abduc- Greater morbidity is generally seen in bi-
is now with the Department of
Pediatric Otolaryngology,
tor palsies, with the folds in close apposition lateral VFP, but, interestingly, in idio-
The Hospital for Sick Children, to each other. In contrast, dysphonia is usu- pathic bilateral VFP, recovery is more
Toronto, Ontario. Dr Hosni ally found in unilateral VFP. likely.
is now a consulting There are a number of causes of VFP, In this review, we present a compre-
otolaryngologist at Frimley including iatrogenic, neurological disor- hensive summary of 102 consecutive cases
Park Hospital, Surrey, England. ders, birth trauma, and idiopathic. of VFP seen at Great Ormond Street Hos-
ARCH OTOLARYNGOL HEAD NECK SURG/ VOL 126, JAN 2000 WWW.ARCHOTO.COM
21
ARCH OTOLARYNGOL HEAD NECK SURG/ VOL 126, JAN 2000 WWW.ARCHOTO.COM
22
ARCH OTOLARYNGOL HEAD NECK SURG/ VOL 126, JAN 2000 WWW.ARCHOTO.COM
23
*Includes only patients who had records with specific reference to outcome of VFP.
†Number of patients for whom VFP recovery was recorded/number of patients with records specifying VFP outcomes.
4 years, 13 patients (72%) had recovered. Five patients eral VFP in our study in contrast to the predominance
with bilateral VFP (18%) took between 5 and 11 years of patients with bilateral VFP in other series.3,4,7,8
to recover. Patients with VFP of idiopathic origin constituted
Of the patients with VFP secondary to surgery the next most common group, with rates similar to those
(n = 26), 12 (46%) recovered within 5 years. reported by Cohen et al4 and de Gaudemar et al.3 Inter-
There were 10 deaths, 1 of which was tracheotomy estingly, patients with bilateral VFP dominated this group
related. The remaining 9 deaths were non–airway re- (26/36 [72%]), a finding that has also been observed in
lated. other studies.
Neurological disease is an important factor in bilat-
COMMENT eral VFP, and all patients with VFP should have a thor-
ough neurological assessment, including a magnetic reso-
Although VFP is the second most common cause of stri- nance imaging scan. Arnold Chiari malformation is the
dor in the neonatal period, there are only a few pub- most frequent neurological condition causing VFP, and
lished studies reviewing this condition in children. The it invariably results in bilateral VFP. Recovery from VFP
largest series have been reported by de Gaudemar et al following decompression has been reported,4 but we did
(N = 113),3 Cohen et al (N = 100),4 and Emery and Fea- not observe this in our group of patients.
ron (N = 71).5 There is some variation among these stud- Birth trauma resulted in fewer cases (5/102 [5%])
ies, particularly regarding the cause of VFP, the ratio of in our study compared with other series (approximately
bilateral to unilateral VFP, and prognosis. Many of these 20%).4,5 Our lower rate may be explained by the ab-
variations reflect the referral patterns of the respective sence of an on-site maternity department. Within this
institutions. group, it was surprising that all patients had bilateral VFP,
Among the 102 patients in our study, the most com- since one would have expected unilateral VFP to be more
mon presenting symptom of VFP was stridor; this was likely. Although Emery and Fearon5 reported a predomi-
evident in almost all patients with bilateral VFP (96%) nance of left-sided VFP, other series have also noted a
and in most patients with unilateral VFP (72%). An ab- higher incidence of bilateral VFP.4,7 It is possible that these
normal cry or dysphonia and feeding difficulty were more were cases of congenital idiopathic VFP and the history
commonly seen in patients with unilateral VFP. In pa- of birth trauma was simply coincidental.
tients with bilateral VFP, the vocal folds are usually in
the paramedian or median position, which results in main- TREATMENT AND PROGNOSIS
tained apposition of the vocal folds and allows near-
normal vocal function and reduces the risk of aspira- Because of the nature of the referral sources at Great Or-
tion. Cyanosis and apneic episodes were more likely to mond Street Hospital for Children, where many children
occur in patients with bilateral VFP. come from far afield and some from overseas, local fol-
low-up is encouraged. This is reflected in our lower fol-
CAUSES OF VFP low-up rate (64% [65/102]) compared with other series
(Emery and Fearon,5 92%; de Gaudemar et al,3 79%).
The most frequent cause of VFP in this study was sur- ThetreatmentofVFPisdeterminedbyapatient’ssymp-
gery (43% [44/102]). Although similar figures were re- toms, particularly by the severity of airway obstruction. Be-
ported by Zbar and Smith6 and Emery and Fearon,5 other fore surgical treatment is considered, parents are advised
series reported lower rates.3,4,7,8 This variation is prob- to position the child so that he or she is sitting up and to
ably institution-specific and related to the presence and thicken the food. If gastroesophageal reflux is suspected,
activity of a pediatric cardiothoracic surgery service. The then this is also treated. In addition, all children with VFP
closure of a patent ductus arteriosus was the most com- are seen by a speech pathologist. An assessment of the child’s
mon cause of VFP in this group, occurring in 11 (25%) ability to cope with VFP is made initially by observation and
of the 44 patients who underwent surgery. Because the oxygen saturation monitoring and thereafter by observa-
left recurrent laryngeal nerve is highly susceptible to dam- tion alone if the child’s condition is stable. No specific rec-
age during surgery, this would account for the almost ommendations about restriction of activity are given, since
equal distribution of patients with bilateral and unilat- we believe that the child will do this automatically.
ARCH OTOLARYNGOL HEAD NECK SURG/ VOL 126, JAN 2000 WWW.ARCHOTO.COM
24
ARCH OTOLARYNGOL HEAD NECK SURG/ VOL 126, JAN 2000 WWW.ARCHOTO.COM
25