You are on page 1of 11

J O U R N A L OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY

Rationalization of Esthetic Restorative Dentistry


Based on Biomimetics

zyxwvutsrq
P A S C A L M A G N E , D R M E DD E N T ‘
W I L L I A M H . D O U G L A S , BDS, MS, P H D +

ABSTRACT: The exponential progressivism that characterizes the current decade often comes with
substantial financial implications. Dental care is not spared by this phenomenon. However, new
generations of concepts emerging from biomimetics provide the operator with the ability to
restore the biomechanical, structural, and esthetic integrity of teeth. The development of adhesion
and the evolution of porcelain veneers constitute striking examples of this nascent process. Indi-
cations for bonding porcelain are extending to more perilous situations (crown-fractured incisors,
nonvital teeth), resulting in considerable improvements, comprising both the medical-biologic
aspect (economy of sound tissues and maintenance of tooth vitality) and the socioeconomical
context (decrease of costs compared to traditional and more invasive prosthetic treatments).
CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: In the bonded porcelain veneer and its extensions, restorative dentistry
has found new solutions for the anterior segment that balance the need for functional and esthetic
reconstruction. The optimal stiffness of porcelain in thin section, the ideal surface characteristics,

zyxwvut
and the biomechanical continuum achieved through high performance bonding mean the crown
of the tooth as a whole can support incisal or masticatory function. By the same token, the con-
duction of optical effects from within the tooth combined with the ideal surface features of the

zyxwvutsrqp
porcelain veneer make this restorative approach the ultimate in esthetic satisfaction, for both the

zyxwvutsrqp
zyxwvutsrq
practitioner and the patient.

“Knowledge is dropping from the However, the abundance of devel- decrease of treatment costs. Both
tongue of the wise ...” (The Bible in opments in dental materials and prudence and wisdom need to be
Basic English, Proverbs 15:2) technology also has generated a combined with knowledge and
plethora of dental products in the progress when it comes to improv-

I n the current decade, the most


exciting developments in den-
tistry are emerging. Oral implantol-
marketplace. The practitioner and
the dental technician alike are faced
with difficult choices, owing to the
ing the patients’ welfare.

In this perplexing context, no one


ogy, guided tissue regeneration, and growing number of treatment will contest the need for less costly,
adhesive restorative dentistry con- modalities. Further, the expansion more reasonable, satisfactory, and
stitute strategic growth areas in mode of technology does not rationalized substitutes for current
both research and clinical practice. always lead to simplification and treatments. The answer might come

*Visiting Associate Professor, Minnesota Dental Research Center for Biomaterials and Biomechanics
Department o f Oral Science, School of Dentistry, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota, and
Lecturer, Department of Prosthodontics and Department of Prevention and Therapeutics, School of Dental
Medicine, University of Geneva, Geneva, Switzerland
‘Professor and Academic Director, Minnesota Dental Research Center for Biomaterials and Biomechanics
Department o f Oral Science, School of Dentistry, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota

VOLUME 1 1 , NUMBER 1 z
5
zyxwvutsrqpon
J O U R N A L OF E S T H E T I C D E N T I S T R Y

Rationalization of Esthetic Restorative Dentistry


Based on Biomimetics

from a newly emerging interdiscipli- Several research disciplines in den- BIOMIMETICS AND PORCELAIN

nary biomaterial science designated VENEERS: S E T T I N G T H E STA N DARDS


tal medicine have evolved with the
FOR ANTERIOR TEETH
“biomimetics.”l This concept of prospect to mimic oral structures.
medical research involves the inves- However, this still nascent disci- Enamel-Dentin Complex:
tigation of both structures and phys- pline is applied mostly at a molecu- A Reference in Arrangement and
ical functions of biologic “compos- lar level, aiming to enhance wound Material Properties
ites” and the designing of new and healing, repair, and regeneration of Mimicking in science involves
improved substitutes. In dental med- soft and hard tissue^.^.^ The benefit designing to reproduce and copy a
icine, the term biomimetics is a use- of biomimetics, when extended to a model, that is, a reference. For the
ful, increasingly applicable word. The macrostructural level, is that it can restorative dentist, the unquestion-
primary meaning refers to material trigger innovative principles in able reference is the intact natural
processing in a manner similar to restorative dentistry. Restoring or tooth. Biomimetics therefore starts
the natural process within the oral mimicking the biomechanical, with the understanding of hard tis-
cavity, such as the calcification of a structural, and esthetic integrity of sue arrangement and related stress
soft tissue precursor. The secondary teeth constitutes the driving force of distribution. Enamel and dentin

zy
meaning of biomimetics refers to the this process. The object of this form a complex structure that pro-
mimicking or recovery of the bio- report, then, is to propose modern vides a tooth with unique charac-
mechanics of the original tooth by criteria for the rationalization of teristic~~:on the one hand, the
the restoration. This of course is the esthetic restorative dentistry based hardness of enamel protects the soft
goal of restorative dentistry. on biomimetics. underlying dentin; on the other

zyxwvutsr
zyxwvutsrqponm
Figure 1. Palatal view of a central incisor and first principal stress distribution. The palatal surface displays a contrasting
anatomy. Strong proximal crests extend from the incisal edge to the tubercule, delineating a deep concavity with thin enamel.
A 2-D finite element (FE) model o f a buccolingual cross-section was used to predict the effect of a SO-Nload on the incisal
edge (white arrow). A, Tensile stress concentration in the concavity. The facial half o f the tooth is mainly subjected to com-
pressive stresses (gray surface). B, The same FE model modified to simulate the convex geometry and thickness o f enamel at
the level of the proximal crest; the resulting stresses are significantly decreased.

6 1999
MAGNE AND DOUGLAS zy

zyxwvutsrq
Figure 2. Enamel microcracks. Numerous composite restorations compen-
sated for incisal tooth wear. On the central incisors, thin enamel was char-
acterized by the presence of multiple vertical cracks. Porcelain veneers were
planned to establish stability of function and esthetics (see Figure 5).

hand, the crack-arresting effect of replaced by an incisal edge that has tion in the anteroposterior direction
dentin and of the thick collagen the obvious function of cutting. is a major contributor to the fracture
fibers at the dentin-enamel junction The labial aspect of the incisors is strength of the tooth. The effect of
compensate for the inherently brit- mainly convex, whereas the palatal varying enamel reductions is quan-
tle nature of enamel.5 The struc- part of the tooth displays a deep titatively determined by the crown
tural and physical interrelation concavity extending axially between flexure, which can be measured
between an extremely hard tissue the dental cingulum and the incisal under simulated conditions by bond-
and a more pliable softer tissue edge and laterally between the two ed strain gauges. It appears that the
provides the natural tooth with its strong proximal ridges (Figure 1). palatal concavity, which provides
unique ability to withstand mastica- Because of this specific shape, the the incisor with its sharp incisal edge
tory and thermal loads during a incisal edge assumes a blade-like and cutting ability, is an area of stress
lifetime. Although multiple enamel configuration, determining the cut- concentration (see Figure 1, A).8
cracks are typically encountered in ting efficiency of the tooth. Owing This shortcoming can be compen-

zyxwvutsr
aged teeth, these senile changes sel- to the arrangement and position of sated for by specific areas featuring
dom propagate through the entire the anterior dentition, the mechani- convex and thick enamel, such as
enameldentin complex of the tooth. cal loads act mainly in the bucco- the cingulum and the marginal
palatal plane of each tooth. ridges (see Figure 1, B). It can be
Anatomic Features of Anterior Mesiodistal loads are restrained by presumed that moderate stress con-
Dentition: Enamel as a “Regulator” proximal contact areas. Anterior centrations would occur on the
of Stresses esthetic techniques often involve totally convex palatal surfaces, such
Anatomically, the anterior segment labial and interproximal reduction as that found on canines. Canines
of the dental arch is characterized of enamel, which makes the tooth also present curvilinear facial sur-
by the process of “incisivization.” crown more def~rrnable.~?’ The faces that may better withstand
Thus the occlusal table is gradually resistance of the crown to deforma- compressive forces. The effect of

V O L U M E 11, N U M B E R 1
J O U R N A L OF E S T H E T I C D E N T I S T R Y zyxwvutsrqp zyxw
Rationalization of Esthetic Restorative Dentistry
Based on Biomimetics

zyxwvutsrqpo
Figure 3 . Generalized enamel dysplasia. A, Upper teeth previously were treated using classic PFM crowns. Lower teeth still
exhibited the original surface defects, the situation being complicated by marked crowding. B, After a complex preprosthetic
phase, including the extraction of a mandibular incisor, followed by orthodontic realignment, seven veneers were placed on
the remaining mandibular incisors and first premolars along with six maxillary anterior crowns.

shape (convex versus concave) and chanical properties. Morphologic consequences of biomechanical
composition (enamel-dentin distri- defects, as in the case of enamel mismatch (lack of biomimetics)
bution) are universal and do not dysplasia, generate both mechanical between tooth and restoration has
depend on the exact load direction and esthetic problems (Figure 3 , A). been documented in the literature.
or magnitude. Thus, the way stresses If only localized, the defects can be A simulated impact study showed
are distributed in a tooth structure treated using composite resins; the problematic root fracture pat-
is orchestrated by the anatomy and however, generalized enamel dys- tern generated with stiff restora-

zyxwvu
geometry of the enamel shell. The plasia is best treated with ceramic tions (gold crowns, porcelain-fused-
latter may be conceptualized as a restorations (Figure 3 , B). to-metal [PFM] crowns), whereas
regulator in the balance of stresses. teeth veneered with bonded porce-
When enamel is worn down or Risks of Biomechanical Mismatch: lain performed similarly to intact
removed from the facial surface, its Resilience as a Possible Indicator teeth.9 Other authors have shown
replacement should be carried out Owing to the improvement of adhe- the excessive ultimate strength of
using materials with similar proper- sive procedures and the development teeth bonded with porcelain veneers
ties, to restore the original bio- of restorative materials, the bio- when it comes to the restoration of
mechanical behavior of the tooth- mechanical behavior of the enamel- incisal length.lOJ1A key element to
the biomimetic principle. Aged dentin complex can be partially understanding these contrasting
teeth with thin enamel are expected recovered. In this context, it seems behaviors is the concept of tooth
to display higher surface stresses.8 reasonable to conclude that new compliance or flexibility. The latter
The presence of numerous enamel restorative approaches should not constitutes an essential quality in
microcracks stands as a confirma- necessarily aim to create a restora- any structure, otherwise it would be

z
tion of this fact (Figure 2). When tion with the strongest materials unable to absorb the energy of a
the original enamel thickness is but rather a restoration that is com- blow. In other words, a compliant
restored, using porcelain as a sub- patible with the mechanical and restoration will cushion a sudden
stitute, the tooth recovers its origi- biologic properties of underlying blow by bending elastically under
nal structural, optical, and biome- dental tissues. The dramatic the load. Up to a point, the more

8 1999
MAGNE AND DOUGLAS

resilient a structure is the better.12


Clinically, the most compliant
pared to teeth restored with veneers
or different types of crown^.^ The
zyx
can be paid in the form of either a
mechanical or a biologic failure

zy
structure is often constituted by respect of the aforementioned para- (pulpal involvement). A crown frac-

zy
intact natural teeth, which can be meters goes well beyond pure ture might be a preferable event if
considered a reference. Stokes and mechanical considerations. In vivo, one considers that the energy
Hood showed that in an impact sit- mechanical events are intimately absorbed during fracture can pre-
uation, the intact tooth absorbed balanced with the biologic integrity vent further biologic damage or
the highest energy of fracture, com- of the tooth. The price of a blow root injury (Figure 4).

zy
Figure 4. Self-protection of tooth vitality by crown fracture.
A, The left maxillary central incis,orfractured following a
trauma that involved both upper central incisors. B, The
situation was potentially compromised by pulpal exposure.
C, After direct capping under rubber dam, the tooth fragment
was adhesively bonded to the remaining tooth substance;
1-week postoperative view reveals the favorable situation. D,
One month later, the unfractured central incisor showed evi-
dent signs of pulp necrosis. E, The severe organic discol-
oration was completely removed by internal bleaching after
root canal treatment was accomplished. The tooth was
slightly overbleached to anticipate initial color relapse.

V O L U M E 1 1 , NUMBER 1 zy
9
JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY

Rationalization of Esthetic Restorative Dentistry

zyxwvutsr
Based on Biomimetics

Porcelain Veneers: An Essential BONDING: THE CORNERSTONE sive mechanical properties; how-
OF STRUCTURAL INTEGRITY
Component to Mimic Anterior ever, when assembled at the DEJ,
Tooth Response First Goal: To Preserve Enamel they constitute a unique structure.
Among modern dental materials, through Diagnostic Wax-Ups Full-thickness enamel cracks almost
ceramics best feature the physico- Enamel is a specialized tissue. The never propagate through the DEJ or
mechanical characteristics of fact that it is etchable makes it along the plane of the DEJ. This
enamel in terms of elastic modulus, exceedingly valuable to the clini- sets the reference for the ceramic-
fracture strength, hardness, and cian. The long-term success.of composite-tooth restorative com-
thermal expansion. Stiffness and porcelain veneers bonded to enamel plex. The success of bonding to
hardness of dentin are more likely stands as a witness for the clinical tooth relies on adequate prepara-
to be simulated by some composite value of enamel.l3-l6 Tooth prepa- tion and conditioning of the sur-
resin materials. Because of their ration techniques for laminate, have faces involved, namely the ceramics
elastic modulus, composites alone not always promoted this fact. (etching and silane application) and
are not able to restore the loss of Reduction burs with calibrated dia- the mineralized dental tissues (etch-
stiffness following tooth prepara- mond rings were proposed to cut ing of the enamel, conditioning of
tion and the related extensive loss enamel with depth control related the dentin). For both enamel and
of enamel.’ Thus, porcelain veneers to the preexisting tooth surface. ceramic surfaces, etching proce-
can be considered to be an essential When the initial enamel is already dures combined with the use of a
component in restorative dentistry. thin, reduction made using such liquid resin have demonstrated their
Similarities are expected in the depth cuts may lead to major efficiency and longevity in extreme
stress pattern and compliance of dentin exposures. In cases of thin oral conditions.”J8 If a substantial
intact teeth and teeth for which the initial enamel, the restoration goal accessible area of dentin has been
restoration reproduces the geome- should be to restore the original exposed by the preparation, local
try and arrangement of enamel and volume of the tooth. Therefore, a

zyxwv
application of a dentin bonding
dentin using ceramic and composite diagnostic wax-up restoring the agent (DBA) is recommended. In
as enamel and dentin substitutes, original volume of the tooth should spite of encouraging results, the
respectively. But the great potential be used as a reference for tooth absolute reliability and clinical per-
of porcelain veneers is not limited reduction, using silicon matrices as a formance of the dentin bond still
to the respect of scientific and guide in vivo (see Figure 5, D and E). are impaired by the composite poly-
objective parameters related to biol- This simple procedure allows the merization shrinkage and stresses
ogy and mechanics. Ceramic lami- saving of a significant amount of resulting from thermal dimensional
nates provide the clinician with a sound tissue, not only enamel but change^.'^,^^ The choice of the
powerful modality with regard to also the critical dentin-enamel restorative method has a critical
esthetics. Even in those cases in junction (DEJ). impact on the behavior of the
which it is not the primary objec- dentin-resin interface.21In addition
tive, oral esthetics still requires spe- Dentin-Enamel Junction: to the aforementioned variables,
cial consideration. Modifications of A Reference for Dentin Bonding dentin is a heterogeneous substrate,

zyxwvut
form, position, and color of anterior The structural integrity of the intact and it is difficult to predict the
teeth generate significant effects on tooth can be explained in part by overall behavior of the dentin-resin
the smile, which in turn contributes the structure-property relations at interface. Multiple clinical parame-
to enhance the personality and the DEJ.s Enamel and dentin con- ters may be involved within the
social life of the patient (Figure 5). sidered alone do not feature impres- same tooth, such as the preparation

10 1999
MAGNE AND DOUGLAS zy

zyxwvutsrqpo
zyxwvu
zyxw
zyxwvu
zyxwvutsrqp
Figure 5. Major functional and morphologic modifications in the adult. The patient complained about the instability of exist-
ing composites restoring the incisal edges of upper anterior teeth. A and B, The issue was both esthetic (short, aged teeth) and
functional (thinned enamel, insufficient anterior guidance). C,The initial model revealed the loss o f tooth morphology, affect-
ing the facial surface of enamel. D, An additive wax-up reestablishing both the proximal crests and the original volume of the
tooth is imperative when planning porcelain veneers. A silicon matrix of the wax-up was used as a reference for tooth reduc-
tion. E, In vivo, a significant space was found between the preexisting surface of the tooth and the future restoration. This
procedure allowed the saving of a consistent amount of tooth substance. F, In spite of the thin preexisting enamel, tooth
preparation was confined to enamel on both central incisors. G and H, The final situation was functionally stable and dis-
played balanced esthetics and an improved lipline as well as intact and healthy periodontal tissues.

VOLUME 1 1 , NUMBER 1 11
JOURNAL O F ESTHETIC DENTISTRY

Rationalization of Esthetic Restorative Dentistry


Based on Biomimetics

depth, previous pathologies, and EDUCATIONAL SITUATIONS: and 21.0 MPa, respectively. These
CROWN-FRACTURED INCISORS
contamination by dental products values are well above the strength
applied to the tooth.22>23 The use of porcelain veneers is par- of intact teeth, which in a similar
ticularly interesting in the presence experiment by Munksgaard et a1
Clinically, two methods may be of crown-fractured incisors with fractured at an average 16 MPa.27

zyxw
applied to promote dentin adhesion short clinical crowns or insufficient Therefore, the use of a simplified
when placing indirect bonded residual tooth structure to provide approach (ceramic only without
restorations. The first and conven- adequate stability for a conventional composite buildup) to the restora-
tional approach consists of delaying type of fixed prosthetic restoration. tion of crown-fractured incisors
the application of the DBA (acid The clinical case shown in Figure 6 could be justified (see Figure 6).
etching followed by the application represents one end of the spectrum However, one may question the
of the primer liquid and the bond- in which veneer restorations permit biomechanical behavior of single
ing resin) until the last treatment the maintenance of tooth vitality teeth restored with extremely rigid
stage, when proceeding to luting in spite of a severe breakdown of and strong coronal restorations.
the veneer. To avoid incomplete tooth structure. The benefit of this For instance, using in vitro simu-
seating of the restoration, it is usu- approach is significant for two lated impacts, Stokes and Hood
ally recommended to keep the additional reasons: (1)it allows clearly demonstrated that the exces-
adhesive resin uncured when plac- maximum preservation of tooth sive strength of conventional pros-
ing the veneer. It is assumed that substance and (2)it prevents the thetic restorations, such as gold
the pressure of the luting composite use of costly, more invasive and risky and metal-ceramic crowns, yielded
during the seating of the veneer procedures (root canal therapy, use root fractures that would be diffi-
may create a collapse of demineral- of an endodontic post, core buildup cult to r e ~ t o r e . ~
ized collagen fibers and subse- and full crown coverage).
quently affect the adhesive interface Modulation of restoration strength
c o h e s i ~ e n e s s . ~More
' > ~ ~recently, a The strength of the tooth-restoration might be considered, to avoid stress
new approach was proposed to complex is an important clinical transfer and catastrophic failures at
optimize DBA a p p l i ~ a t i o n . ~ ~ ? ~ ~concern when one is restoring the level of the root. The combina-
Because the DBA appears to have a extensively fractured incisors; so is tion of both composites and ceram-
superior potential for adhesion the exact definition of the restora- ics seems theoretically appropriate
when applied to freshly prepared tive design, i.e., whether the missing to reproduce the original stiffness
dentin, its application is recom- tooth substance should be replaced of the tooth and to modulate the
mended immediately after the com- using (a) the veneer alone, (b) a tooth-restoration strength. How-
pletion of tooth preparation, before composite buildup along with the ever, no scientific investigations
the final impression itself. A sub- veneer, or (c) the fractured tooth have been conducted to define, when
stantial clinical advantage is that fragment itself along with the restoring extensive loss of dentin,
this precautionary measure protects veneer. A surprising answer was the optimal configuration of the

z
the pulpodentinal organ and pre- given in an assessment of strength restoration and related thicknesses
vents sensitivity and bacterial leak- by Andreasen et al,1° who used of composite and ceramic; in fact,
age during the provisional phase. veneered sheep incisors in a load- few scientific articles specifically
The use of a filled adhesive facili- to-failure test and found ultimate have addressed the problem of
tates the procedure. strength of 28.2 MPa, 20.2 MPa, internal stress distribution, stress

12 1999
zy
zyx
MAGNE A N D DOUGLAS

Figure 6. Crown-fractured incisors restored with veneers. A and


B, The pulp was not exposed despite the extensive loss of tooth
substance on the right maxillary central incisor. C, Silicon
matrices (obtained from an additive wax-up restoring the origi-
nal thickness of enamel) were used as a reference to guide the
realization of reduction grooves. D, The preparation is confined
to enamel except for the fractured surface. E and F, Bonded
porcelain laminates allowed the preservation of tooth vitality,
the respect for the surrounding soft tissues, and the reestablish-
ment of an attractive smile line. G, In vivo transillumination
with an optical fiber shows how the “ceramic-only” design
allowed the dental technician to use specific dentin-like porce-
lains to ensure an optimal optical transition between the intact
half of the tooth and the bulk of the restoration.

VOLUME 11, NUMBER 1 zy 13


JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY

Rationalization of Esthetic Restorative Dentistry


Based on Biomimetics

transfer, or tooth stiffness after the shown to have a significant influ- ported by the Swiss Foundation for
placement of porcelain ence in the development of post- Medical-Biological Grants and in part by

fied design using ceramic alone

zyxw
Clinicians often prefer the simpli-

zyxwvutsr
even to replace missing portions of
dentin since the procedure is straight
forward and features optimal
bonding flaws if used as a thick lut- the Minnesota Dental Research Center
ing agent and demonstrated
marginal leakage when placed as a
whole ~ e n e e r . ~ O
The
- ~ ~crack
propensity of porcelain may be sig-
for Biomaterials and Biomechanics.

REFERENCES
1. Sarikaya M . An introduction to biomimet-
ics: a structural viewpoint. Microsc Res

zyxw
Tech 1994; 27:360-375.
esthetic results (see Figure 6 , E-G). nificantly reduced by providing the
The dental technician can use spe- restoration with a favorable config- 2. Slavkin HC. Biomimetics: replacing body
parts is no longer science fiction. J Am
cific porcelains for the accurate uration, namely providing a suffi- Dent Assoc 1996; 127:1254-1257.
reproduction of the anatomy and cient and homogeneous thickness of 3. Mann S. The biomimetics of enamel: a
optical characteristics of dentin paradigm for organised biomaterial synthe-
ceramics combined to a minimal sis. Ciba Found Symp 1997; 205:261-269.
(opaque dentin for adequate trans-
lucency and fluorescent stains for
adequate luminescence). Most com-
posite resins do not allow such pre-
cise characterization. However,
with regard to biomimetics, ceramic-
thickness of luting c ~ m p o s i t e . ~ ’ ~ ~ ~
Tooth reduction as well as minimal
application of the die spacer during
laboratory procedures undoubtedly
represent key elements in this mat-
ter. The wear properties of ceramics
zy
z
4. Kraus BS, Jordan RE, Abrams L. Histol-
ogy of the teeth and their investing struc-
tures. In: Kraus BS, sd. Kraus’ dental
anatomy and occlusion. Baltimore:
Williams and Wilkins, 1969:135.

5. Lin CP. Doudas WH. Structure-brobertv . . ,


relations and-crack resistance at the bovine
dentin-enamel junction. J Dent Res 1994;
7 3 2 072-1 078.
only designs may present an exces- may be another potential issue in
sive strength. In case of recurrent this total performance picture of 6. Douglas WH. The esthetic motif in
research and clinical practice. Quintes-
trauma to the crown this could gen- porcelain veneers, as they are for sence Int 1989; 20:739-745.
erate a fatal root fracture or at least porcelain inlays o r traditional PFM 7. Reeh ES, Ross GK. Tooth stiffness with
the loss of an additional portion of Here again, biomimet- composite veneers: a strain gauge and
finite element evaluation. Dent Mater
the tooth. These assumptions now ics significantly contributes to the 1994; 10:247-252.
require experimental validations development of more “friendly” 8. Magne P, Versluis A, Douglas WH. Ration-
using the latest generation of dentin and bioactive materials with self- alization of incisor shape: experimental-
numerical analysis. J Prosthet Dent.
adhesives, since the dentin bond healing properties. They constitute (In press)
proves to be an essential determi- a possible and promising answer to 9. Stokes AAN, Hood JAA. Impact fracture
nant in the fracture pattern and characteristics of intact and crowned
the problem of ear.^',^^ For the human central incisors. J Oral Rehabil

zyxw
fracture mechanics of the tooth.29 future, the bioactivity of ceramics 1993; 20:89-95.

offers the potential of bonding to 10. Andreasen FM, Flugge E, Daugaard-


REMAINING CONCERNS AND Jensen J, Munksgaard EC. Treatment of
tooth without using composite crown fractured incisors with laminate
CONCLUSIONS veneer restorations. An experimental study.
resins,39avoiding the time-consum- Endod Dent Traumatol1992; 8:30-35.
Even though the combination of ing traditional bonding procedures.
composite and ceramic seems to be 11. Wall JG, Reisbick MH, Johnston WM.
Incisal-edge strength of porcelain laminate
the best means to reproduce the ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
veneers restoring mandibular incisors. Int
J Prosthodont 1992; 5:441446.
behavior of the intact tooth, there is The authors thank Mr. Michel Magne, of
12. Gordon J E . Strain energy and modern

z
still a concern of the additive effects the Oral Design Center, Dental Labora- fracture mechanics. In: Gordon JG, ed.
of the curing contraction and high Structures: or why things don’t fall down.
tory, Montreux, Switzerland, for the real- New York: Da Capo Press, 1978:70-109.
thermal expansion of certain com- ization of the technical work presented in
13. Calamia JR. Clinical evaluation of etched
posite resins. The latter has been this report. Dr. Pascal Magne was sup- porcelain veneers. Am J Dent 1989; 2:9-15.

14 1999
M A G N E A N D DOUGLAS zy
zyxwvutsrqponm
zyxwvuts
14. Calamia JR. The current status of etched
porcelain veneer restorations. J Indiana
Dent Assoc 1993; 72:10-15.

IS. Nordbo H, Rygh-Thoresen N , Henaug T .


24. Dietschi D, Magne P, Holz J . Bonded-to-
tooth ceramic restorations: in vitro evalua-
tion ofthe efficiency and failure mode of
two modern adhesives. Schweiz Monatsschr
Zahnmed 1995; 1OS:299-305.
33. Lacy AM, Wada C, Du W , Watanabe L.
In vitro microleakage at the gingival mar-
gin of porcelain and resin veneers. J Pros-
thet Dent 1992; 67:7-10.

zyx
Clinical performances of porcelain lami- 34. De Long R, Sasik C, Pintado MR, Dou-
nate veneers without incisal overlapping: 2 s . Bertschinger C, Paul SJ,Liithy H, Scharer glas W H . The wear of enamel when
3-year results. J Dent 1994; 22:342-345. P. Dual application of dentin bonding opposed by ceramic systems. Dent Mater
agents: its effect on the bond strength. 1989; 5:266-271.
16. Meijering AC, Roeters FJM, Mulder J , Am J Dent 1996; 9:1S5-119.
Creugers NHJ. Patients’ satisfaction with 35. Seghi RR, Rosenstrel SF, Bauer P. Abra-
different types of veneer restorations. 26. Paul SJ, Scharer P. The dual bonding tech- sion of human enamel by different dental
J Dent 1997; 25:493497. nique: a modified method to improve ceramics in vitro. J Dent Res 1991;
adhesive luting procedures. Int J Periodon- 70:221-225.
17. Williamson RT, Mitchell RJ, Breeding LC. tics Restorative Dent 1997; 17:536-545.
The effect of fatigue on the shear bond 36. Krejci I, Lutz F, Reimer M, Heinzmann
strength of resin bonded to porcelain. 2 7. Munksgaard EC, Hojtved L, Jorgensen JL. Wear of ceramic inlays, their enamel
J Prosthodont 1993; 2:115-119. EH, Andreasen J O , Andreasen FM. antagonists, and luting cements. J A m
Enamel-dentin crown fractures bonded Ceram SOL1993; 69:425430.
18. Roulet J F , Soderholm KJ, Longmate J . with various bonding agents. Endod Dent
Effects of treatment and storage conditions Traumato1 1991; 7:73-77. 37. Hench LL. Bioceramics: from concept to
on ceramiclcomposite bond strength. J Dent clinic. J A m Ceram SOL 1991; 74:1487-
Res 1995; 74:381-387. 28. Highton R, Caputo AA, Matyas J. A photo- 1510.
elastic study of stress on porcelain lami-

zyxw
zyxwvutsr
19. Ciucchi B, Bouillaguet S, Delaloye M, nate preparations. J Prosthet Dent 1987; 38. Francis LF, Vaidya KJ, Huang HY, Wolf
Holz J . Volume of the internal gap formed 58:157-161. W D . Design and processing of ceramic-
under composite restorations in vitro. J based analogs to the dental crown. Mater
Dent 1997; 25:3OS-312. 2 9. Versluis A , Tantbirojn D, Douglas WH. Sci Eng 199s; C3:63-74.

zyxwvutsrqpo
Why do shear bond tests pull out dentin?
20. Van Meerbeek B, Perdigao J , Lambrechts J Dent Res 1997; 76:1298-1307. 39. Efflandt S, Magne P, Douglas W H , Fran-
P, Vanherle G. The clinical performances cis LF. Bonding of bioactive glasses to
of adhesives. J Dent 1997; 26:l-20. 3 0. Barghi N , Berry TG. Post-bonding crack human dentin. Presented at the 1 Sth Con-
formation in porcelain veneers. J Esthet ference on Bioceramics, BioCeramics 11th
21. Herzfeld D. Evaluation of the marginal Dent 1997; 951-54. New York, November 5-8, 1998.
and internal adaptation of Class I1 com.
posite restorations after an in vitro fatigue 31. Magne P, Kwon KR, Belser U, Hodges JS,
test. Thesis: University of Geneva, 1996. Douglas W H . Crack propensity of porce-
lain laminate veneers: a simulated opera- Reprint requests: Pascal Magne, Dr. Med.
22. Nakajima M, Sano H, Burrow MF, et al. tory evaluation. J Prosthet Dent. (In press) Dent., 16-212 Moos Tower, 515 Delaware
Tensile bond strength and S E M evaluation Street S. E., Minneapolis, M N 55455-0329
of caries-affected dentin using dentin adhe- 32. Magne P, Versluis A, Douglas WH. Effect
sives. J Dent Res 1995; 74:1679-1688. of luting composite shrinkage and thermal 0 1 999 B.C. Decker Inc.
loads on the stress distribution in porce-
23. Pashley DH, Sano H, Ciucchi B , lain laminate veneers. J Prosthet Dent.
Yoshiyama M, Carvalho RM. Adhesion (In press)
testing of dentin bonding agents: a review.
Dent Mater 1995; 11:117-125.

VOLUME 1 1 , NUMBER 1 15

You might also like