PSYCHOLOGY AND EDUCATION (2020) 57(8): 872-876 ISSN:00333077
TITLE: “LEGEND OF KAPPIRI MUTHAPPAN IN KOCHI: A
COUNTER-DISCOURSE AGAINST PORTUGUESE COLONIAL
DOMINATION”
Sonia Lucy C A
PAD Scholar Christ University, Bangalore
ABSTRACT
Kochi is a city dotted with remnants of trans-Atlantic slave trade practiced by European colonisers. Most people in Kerala do not
know about coastal Kerala’s African connection. While Kerala’s cultural connections with Europe are well articulated through
literature, museums and heritage sites, linkages with Africa and the forced migration of Africans to the Malabar Coast remain
obscure and are recalled primarily through rituals and folklore. One such folklore is that of the cigar smoking African slave,
locally known @ Kappiri Muthappan. Although it is unclear how these slaves came to be called kappiri, itis believed that the
‘word might have been a corruption of the word ‘kaffr,” meaning non-believer, “which is what Arab travellers called the people of
Arica,” said historian M.G.S Narayanan. “Kappiri’ isthe local slang for African slaves shipped to Kerala in the 16th century by
the Portuguese,
Historian KL Bernard in his book “History of Fort Cochin’ discusses what came to be called Kappiri mathil (Kappiri walls) and
their subsequent evolution into protective spirits called kappiri muthappan, He says."In 1663, Portuguese, who had treasures made
niches in their thick wall, ted up Kaffrs in them, placed their treasures beneath tied-up slaves and made them promise that the
treasures would be kept safe till their descendants came to claim them. The niches were then plastered up with mortar,” (Bernard
12) Over time, local beliefs took over and the wall niches where these slaves were chained up were reified and began to be
‘worshipped. The local legend says that the slaves turned into spirits which were called Kapiti Muthappan Possibly one of the
prominent ones that is actively worshipped today, is the shrine in Mangatfummkku in Mattancherry near Fort Kochi. There is just a
simple black platform, without idols or symbols.The legend even found a place in the third edition of Kochi Muziris Biennale via
the Dutch artist Gabriel Lester's installation ‘Dwelling Kappiri Spicits’.
The paper tries to analyse the myth of Kappiri Muthappan from a subaltem perspective. It looks upon these narratives as a
resistance mechanism of the resilient people to defy and live through the multi-pronged system of oppressive caste hierarchy,
subverting these very structures. The myth would be studied as a counter discourse developed by some sections of subaltern-
community who would have been culturally scarred by their stigmatised status in the caste order and in their struggle to find
sustenance from the oppressive system. The customary practice in Mattancheiry of offering prasadam(holy offering) to Kappiti
Muthappan will be looked upon as a subversion and appropriation of the dominant European religious practices. Further, the
scope of this paper is to study how the shrines of Kappiri Muthappan becomes a heterotopic space as conceived by Michel
Foucault and how the concept of hybridity posited by Homi Bhabha becomes a third space for the coastal communities 10
withstand the marginalisation they face. Third space can be understood as a location and/or practice. As a practice it reveals @
differential consciousness that according to Chela Sandoval “arises between and through [different] meaning systems" (Sandoval
180), capturing the movement that joins different networks of consciousness and revealing a potential for greater understanding,
As a location, third space can be a space of shared understanding and meaning making.
Keywords:
Kappiri Muthappan, Trans-national slave trade, Subaltern deity, Kochi’ folklore, Indo-African hybridity
Article Received: 18 October 2020, Revised: 3 November 2020, Accepted: 24 December 2020
Introduction: Folktale of Kappiri Muthappan
The city of Kochi known for being a hotpot of
varied culture and customs holds in its abyss of
memory a less heard legend of Kappiri
Muthappan. According to the Encyclopaedia of
Religion and Ethics, “Myths are not created out of
nothing; a myth is always the covering, the shell,
toa kernel of truth contained inside. Folktales are
www: psychologyandeducation.net
the myths of the race”. The folktale of Kappiri
‘Muthappan too entails a racial history of African
presence in the colonial town of Kochi. The
history of the legend dates back to the pre-colonial
Kochi when the city was a lub of spice trade. The
colony of Portuguese settlement saw many slaves
of African origin being transported across the
ocean via trade route from East Aftican coast to
72PSYCHOLOGY AND EDUCATION (2020) 57(8): 872-876
ISSN:00333077
Kochi. There are evidences of trans-Atlantic slave
trade between colonial port cities during the reign
of Portuguese and Dutch imperialists, The
presence of Afticans in Kochi could thus be
attributed to the historical evidence given by
historian Edward Alpers in his book “The Affican
Diaspora in the Indian Ocean: A Comparative
Perspective’.
Kappiri Muthappan is a term used to refer to the
spirits of the African slaves who wereslaughtered
by their Portuguese masters as oblation to safe
guard their riches when they retreated under
Dutchcoup. The historical evidence of Portuguese
decampment can be traced to the Dutch expedition
under Ryckloff Van Goens; the troops arrived
from Ceylon to Vypin islands conquering the port
city of Kochi. The legend says that the Portuguese
masters chained their African slaves along with
their treasures and buried them secretly in
unknown recesses to get back to their riches at
some later point of time. The occult practice of
sacrifice was under the pact that these slaves
would safeguard their treasures until the rightful
master returns to claim it. It is popularly believed
that the ghosts of these African slaves wander
around the place they were chained in order to
protect their master’s riches. Over time these
wandering spirits acquired the status of a deity
worshipped mainly to get hold of the abandoned
colonial treasure they were protecting. The
devotees show their benevolence to Kappiri
Muthappan by sanetifying the locale where they
were chained as shrines. Usually these shrines are
located under Aanjili tree (Artocarpus hirutus) in
unmarked niches at boundary walls or comers of
streets, It is believed that the Portuguese might
have planted trees as identifiers of their treasures
buried along with African slaves for the ease of
retrieval. This is the probable reason for the belief
that Kappiri resides in trees, and why local
residents pray and make offerings to stones
installed under tees to please Kapiti.
The term Kappiri is a colloquial term in
Malayalam used to refer to people African origin.
Malayalam author. ~=S -K__Pottakkad’s
www: psychologyandeducation.net
Kaappirikalude Naatil is a memoir of his visit to
Affican subcontinent. The etymology of the word
canbe traced = to the.-—words
Kafir/Qafir/Cafferwhich roughly translates as ‘an
unbeliever’, It is an Arabie term used by Arab
traders to refer to Africans who were their slaves
and who were not followers of Islam (Shihan de
Silva Jayasuriya and Pankhurst 8)
The shrine stamps its difference because of the
unconventional offerings given by devotees like
arrack, toddy, cigar, fried fish, meat, eggs etc. as
Prasad. Moreover, the places where these shrines
are located makes it unique; unlike the places of
worship of other religions which has a reified and
pompous infrastructure, the demigod of Kappiri
Muthappan stands onunadomed black stone inside
miniature house like structures attached to
compound walls on roadside.
REPRESENTATION OF KAPPIRI
MUTHAPPAN IN LITERATURE AND ART
Various works of literature in Malayalam
language and Malayali authors have represented
the myth of Kappiri Muthappan in their novels.
One of the earliest is Rafi Ponjkkara’s novel Ora
Pro Nobiswhich came out in 1981. The novel is a
spiel of the descendants of the African slave who
volunteered to kill himself to guard the treasure of
his master. The vow of the Kappiri was that his
spirit would guard the treasure until his master’s
rightful heirs come to claim it. The attempts made
by Kappiri’s youngest generation of successors to
reclaim the assets and the resistance put forward
by their ancestor to protect the secrecy of the
location of the wealth becomes the plot of the
story. The duel between two generations of
Kappiri Muthappan’s scions, one to protect the
legacy and another to dismantle it gets
culmination in the eldest living ancestor
permanently destroying the records of the locale
of the treasure. The superstitious belief that curse
would befall to whosever trying to unlawfully
claim the treasure is reinforced in the novel.
Adiyalaprethamby renowned novelist and
scriptwriter P F Mathews is another work that
873PSYCHOLOGY AND EDUCATION (2020) 57(8): 872-876
ISSN:00333077
gives an eerie representation of the Aftican deity.
It is a Malayalam language novel which tells the
story of Achambi from a Latin catholic family
from Kochi who resorts to worshipping of the
demigod of Kappiri Muthappan. The Aanyii tree
in the compound of his home is believed by him
to be the treasure house of Portuguese masters
who sacrificed his slave in order to protect hi
valuables. The story revolves around the
necromantie practices that Achambi and his slave
does to sweep off Kappiri’s feet. The
apprehension of his relatives on his practice occult
customs and his relentless attempt to please the
demigod to amass the treasure that the Kappiri is
believed to protect becomes the center-stone of
the novel. The work of literature points towards
the anti-fundamentalist approach of Achambi and
how the staunch believers of Christian faith
oppose his practices. Thus, Achambi and Kappiri
become iconoclastic figures in the novel who
inverts the power dynamics of conventional
religious traditions.
Whereas, George Thundiparambil’s
English language novel Mayawhich came out in
2008has as its narrator the spirit of Kappiri
Muthappan. The story is set against the backdrop
of contemporary Fortkochi where tourist girl
chances upon the Kappiri to listen to the 500 year
old history of Portuguese, Dutch and British rule
in Kochi. Kappiri narrates his voyage along with
Vasco Da Gama to Kerala as a slave, his angst of
being uprooted fiom his homeland and his
attempts to redeem himself from the etemal
slavery as ghost. The central figure of Kappiri and
his accounts problematises the history of
discovery of Kerala by Vasco Da Gama. Rather
than viewing the history from above Mayatries to
narrate a counter-history from the perspective of
the colonised. The notion of White man’s burden
to civilise the colonised and slave trade have been
critiqued and presented with an eye of suspicion.
The history of triumph of colonisers is subverted
through the perspective given by Thundiparambil
through the eyes of the Aftican slave.
www: psychologyandeducation.net
The third edition of Kochi Muziris
Biennale in 2016-17 saw an installation by the
Dutch artist Gabriel Lester giving a visual treat of
the myth and the history behind it through his
“Dwelling Kappiri Spirits’. The installation was a
simulation of a wooden boat caught up in roaring
winds of ocean, Inside the void of the dim lit
wooden structure stood a teapoy with an ashtray
and a perpetually burning cigar representing the
lasting impact of the Kappiri on the mind of
Kochiites as well as the Dutch. There happens a
temporal freezing of history inside the installation.
I. Myth of Kappiri Muthappan as a
Counter-narrative
‘The legend of Kappiri Muthappan has as its
key figure a subaltern slave who was murdered for
the selfish desires of its colonial master. Through
this folktale the people of Kochi is creating a
micro history which was refused a place in the
Eurocentric history written down by imperialist
intellectuals. The legend stands as what
McCracken has called "ballast", it has transcended
from being a cultural waste to become a public
record of the atrocious practices of Portuguese
imperialists.The historicisation of the myth is an
unconscious act of the post-colonial community of
constructing and disseminating a counter-
discourse against hegemonic colonial culture. It is
rather a process of artistic and literary
decolonization using culturally retained
marginalised memory.The shrines of Kappiri
Muthappan are an example of how cultural
memories of colonial history are remembered,
performed, and circulated through religion. Bruce
Lincoln held that myth is an “ideology in narrative
form”, then the myth of Kappiri Muthappan too
can be considered as a remnant of an embedded
ideology in the memories of the people of
Kochi. The Kappiri walls where these slaves are
believed to have been chained stand as
embodiments of colonial memory of forced
migration of African slaves to Kochi as a part of
trans-Atlantic slave trade. The legend is a means to
deconstruct
Portuguese, Dutch and British colonial powers.
authoritarian discourses. of
874PSYCHOLOGY AND EDUCATION (2020) 57(8): 872-876
ISSN:00333077
The myth of Kappiri encompasses athird space
which is geographical as well as discursive. The
myth is a discursive space because it manifests the
collective memory of disempowered subjects
chained down by power and subordination of the
colonial dominance. David Butz and Michael
Ripmeester in Finding Space for Resistant
Subeulturesargue that Third Space can be
understood as an “ontological category,” a model
through which all spaces can be theorized, and
where resistance is “comprised of hybridized,
ambiguous, cautious, and often somewhat
accommodative practices.”(Butz, Michael 21) On
a geographical level, third space of Kappiri myth
composes of the differential consciousness of the
people of Kochi through which they create
meaning and shared understanding of Afro-Asian
culture. Thestone structure worshipped as Kappiri
Muthappan becomes a pretext embedding abstract
meanings of struggles of the marginalised and
their desire for upward mobility in social
hierarchy so as to be accepted to the
mainstream.Kappiri Muthappan worship
thenbecomes an unconscious practice of resistance
as the deity gets transformed from a mere property
to asubculture. What is peculiar to the practice of
Kapiti worship is that the deity has not been
institutionalised into a recognised god nor does it
have a well-built temple like structure resembling
a shrine. The deity is offered food items like meat
and alcohol which are considered as taboo by
various institutionalised religions. The anrack
offered can be seen as a subversion of holy wine
and the meat as that of holy bread of Christian
religious custom. Further, it is cigar that is bumt
instead of incense at the shrine which again is a
strategic subversion of dominant customary
practice of most religions. Rather than slavishly
imitating the religious practices put forth by
imperialist, practices of worship of the slave deity
creates a counter culture by strategically
dismantling all those customs and traditions
reified by imperialists. Milton Yinger in his 1982
book, Countercultures: The Promise and Peril of a
World Tumed Upside Down _notes,
www: psychologyandeducation.net
“Countercultures and the many types of
intentional communities they commonly create are
not social aberrations. For thousands of years
there have been attempts to provide alternatives
for the existing social order in response to the
perennial grounds for dissent: hierarchy and
privilege [....] disgust with hedonism and
consumerism [..., and] a decline in the quality of
life.” (Yinger 1) Thus, Kappiri worship is an
alternative and not a social aberration. The
idols in the shrines of Kappiri Muthappan in
Kochi become a transgressive artefact embodying
the influence of colonial rule in India. The act of
praying and offering unconventional prasad is an
act of subversion of trivialities, thereby
undermining thepower play of cultural ideologyof
the time. The brahminical hegemonic cultural
authority that prevailed in Kochi gets
unknowingly sabotaged by the practice where
taboo items like toddy and arrack become
sacrosanct bene-faction to the deity of Kappiri
Muthappan.
CONCLUSION
The myth of Kappiti Muthappan is a petit
narrative which is a part of micro-history of
African presence in Kochi. The paper tries to
prove that the less popular history known only
among the older generation of natives is given an
uncanny tone by giving the marginalised African
slaves spectral qualities. This can be seen as an
undeliberate and unconscious attempt by the
natives to subvert the codes of colonial
domination. The collective memory of atrocious
servitude and resistance against enslavement gets
manifested in the form of the myth of cigar
smoking African spirit that protects the destitute
Therefore, the myth can be considered as a
counter history narrated from subaltemn point of
view, toppling down the conventional hegemonic
top-down perspective. Kappiri Muthappan can be
considered as what Mary Douglas and Baron
Isherwood calls, “a sediment that builds up the
structure of culture like a coral island."
875PSYCHOLOGY AND EDUCATION (2020) 57(8): 872-876
ISSN:003
33077
REFERENCES
[1] Alpers, Edward, 2003. "The Affican
Diaspora in the Indian Ocean: A
2
2]
(3)
4]
[5]
(6)
071
[8]
[9]
[10]
(1)
Comparative Perspective." In The African
Diaspora in the Indian Ocean, edited by
Shihan De Silva Jayasuriya and Richard
Pankhurst, 19-50. Trenton, NJ: Africa World
Press.
Appadurai, Arjun, 1996, Modernity at
Large: Cultural Dimensions of
Globalization. Minneapolis: University of
Minnesota Press.
Hastings, James. Encyclopedia Of Religion
and Ethics: Arthur-Bunyan (Classic
Reprint). Forgotten Books, 2016.
Grossberg, Lawrence. “Another Boring Day
in Paradise: Rock and Roll and the
Empowerment of Everyday Life.” Popular
Music, vol. 4, 1984, pp. 225-258,
doi:10,1017/s0261143000006243
Jeychandran, Neelima. “Memory, Heritage,
and Cultural Display in the Former Colonial
Port Cities of Elmina (Ghana) and Fort
Kochi (India).” EScholarship, University of
California, University of California, 21 July
2015, escholarship.org/uc/item/8r99s82c.
Leary, Timothy. Flashbacks. New York:
Penguin, 1983.
Lincoln, Bruce. (2000). Theorizing Mth
Narrative, Ideology, and Scholarship.
Bibliovault OAI Repository, the University
of Chicago Press. 121. 10.2307/606705.
Maddy. The Kappiri Slaves of Cochin. 21
Feb. 2015,
maddy06,blogspot.com/2015/02/the-kappiri-
slaves-of-cochin html.
Mathews, P. F. Adivalapretham. 1st ed.,
Green Books, 2019.
McCracken, Grant David. Culture and
Consumption. Indiana Univ. Press, 2005.
NewindianXpress, Shalet Jimmy. “Kappiri
Muthappan: From Slaves to Folk Deity.”
The New Indian Express, The New Indian
Express, 10 June 2013,
www.newindianexpress.comy/states/kerala/K
www: psychologyandeducation.net
(12]
(13)
(4)
15]
[16]
u7
[18]
appiri-Muthappan-From-slaves-to-folk-
deity/2013/06/10/article1628188.ece
Ponjikkara, Rafi. Ora Pro Nobis. 2nd ed.,
Pranatha Books, 2018.
Surendranath, Nidhi. “Once a Slave, Now a
Deity.” The Hindu, The Hindu, 16 June
2013,
www.thehindu.com/news/cities/Kochi/once-
a-slave-now-a-deity/article4820623.ece
Thundiparambil, George. Maya, Ist ed.,
Gauli Publishers, 2008,
Williams, P., & Hannerz, E. (2014).
Articulating the "Counter" in Subculture
Studies. MC Joumal, 176)
https://doi.org/10.5204/me}.912
Will Straw - The Thingishness of Things
https://www.rochester.edwin_visible_culture
/issue2/straw.htm. Accessed 10 Jan. 2021.
'] Yinger, J. Milton, “Contraculture and
Subculture.” American Sociological
Review 25.5 (1960): 625-635
Countercultures: The Promise and Peril of a
World Tumed Upside Down. New York:
Free Press, 1982.