You are on page 1of 4

456 EQUINE VETERINARY JOURNAL

Equine vet. J. (2010) 42 (5) 456-459


doi: 10.1111/j.2042-3306.2010.00035.x

Case Report
Trema micrantha toxicity in horses in Brazil evj_35 456..459

P. M. BANDARRA, S. P. PAVARINI, D. L. RAYMUNDO, A. M. R. CORRÊA, P. M. O. PEDROSO and D. DRIEMEIER*

Departmento de Patologia Clínica, Faculdade de Veterinária, UFRGS. Porto Alegre-RS, Brazil.

Keywords: horse; hepatotoxicity; hyperammonaemia; poisoning; Trema micrantha

Summary T. micrantha poisoning is characterised by hepatic insufficiency


due to hepatocellular necrosis (Traverso et al. 2003, 2004). On the
After ingesting green leaves of T. micrantha, 2 horses showed other hand, T. micrantha has been described as having analgesic,
apathy, locomotor deficit, blindness, recumbency, paddling, anti-inflammatory and hypoglycaemic properties (Barbera et al.
coma and death. The main gross findings were scattered 1992; Schoenfelder et al. 2006). This communication describes
haemorrhages, enhanced lobular pattern of the liver, and and discusses the clinical and pathological findings observed in an
cerebral oedema. Histological changes included disseminated outbreak of T. micrantha poisoning in horses.
haemorrhages, massive hepatocellular necrosis, neuronal
degeneration, Alzheimer type II astrocytes and cerebral Case history and clinical findings
perivascular oedema. Clinicopathological findings which were
comparable with those observed in Trema micrantha poisoned The disease occurred at a ranch in southern Brazil, where 2 of 5
ruminants, associated with epidemiological evidence suggested horses were affected and died. Animals were kept in a 2.5 hectare
the diagnosis. Trema micrantha poisoning should be evaluated paddock. Horses had been exclusively grazing at pastures. Natural
as a possible cause in the diagnosis of equine hepatopathy and poisoning occurred due to the consumption of green leaves of the
occasional secondary encephalopathy. branches of a T. micrantha tree (Fig 1A) that had fallen during a
storm 4 days before the outbreak. Branches of the plant showed
Introduction clear evidence that parts had been bitten off. A 6-year-old mare and
her 1-year-old colt were affected and showed locomotor deficit,
Many fast-growing pioneer trees compose the genus Trema apathy, lateral recumbency, paddling, intermittent tonic
(Ulmaceae), some of which have been proved toxic to livestock. contractions of locomotor and neck muscles (Fig 1B), and coma.
Trema micrantha is widely distributed in South America, but it also The mare died 48 h after the onset of clinical signs and was
occurs in Central and North America. In Brazil, T. micrantha is necropsied 11 h after death. In addition to the above described
particularly abundant in woodland habitats or as secondary clinical signs, the foal also went blind and remained recumbent and
vegetation in derelict areas (Pio-Correa 1984; Vasquez 1998). T. unconscious for 8 days, when it was subjected to euthanasia in
micrantha has also been used as a pioneer tree in reforestation extremis by i.v. injection of barbiturates and immediately
systems, particularly for the recovery of burned or degraded soils necropsied. The owner reported that the affected mare was the
(Castellani and Aguiar 1998; Kissmann 1999). T. micrantha leaves dominant animal in the group.
are palatable and readily consumed by cattle and other herbivores,
particularly in times of food shortage, occasions in which the plant Post mortem findings
has been used as a source of forage (Kissmann 1999). The
suspicion of T. micrantha poisoning in livestock was derived from Necropsy was performed in both horses and samples of multiple
field observations in the past decade of small south Brazilian goat tissues were collected, fixed in formalin, processed for histology
flocks and cattle herds. Subsequently, natural T. micrantha and stained using haematoxylin-eosin, periodic acid Schiff1 or oil
poisoning has been observed in goats (Traverso et al. 2003) and the red2 method (Johnson 1992). Liver presenting as an enhanced
experimental poisoning induced in rabbit, goats and cattle at doses lobular pattern (Fig 1C), haemorrhages in subcutaneous tissues and
of 30, 35 and 50 g/kg bwt, respectively (Traverso and Driemeier thyroid and adrenal glands, faeces covered by mucus and blood,
2000; Traverso et al. 2004). Poison peach or Trema tomentosa (T. and mild to moderate cerebral oedema (Fig 1D) were the main
aspera), which has been shown to contain a trematoxin (Oelrichs gross findings. Histological findings in the mare included
1968), has also been linked to poisoning in horses (Hill et al. 1985) centrilobular hepatocellular necrosis associated with haemorrhage,
and other animals (Mulhearn 1942; Mcckenzie et al. 1985; and moderate fatty hepatocellular degeneration in periportal areas
Trueman and Powell 1991). The clinicopathological syndrome in (Fig 2A). Severe subcapsular haemorrhage in the adrenal glands

*Corresponding author. Email: davetpat@ufrgs.br


[Paper received for publication 11.09.09; Accepted 01.10.09]

© 2010 EVJ Ltd


P. M. Bandarra et al. 457

Fig 1: (A) Trema micrantha tree that had fallen during a storm. The subsequent access of horses to their leaves caused the poisoning. Insert: detail of the
plant. (B) Recumbent colt poisoned by T. micrantha during an episode of generalised tonic muscular contraction. (C) Liver from a T. micrantha poisoned
mare. Note enhanced lobular pattern. (D) Encephalon of a T. micrantha poisoned colt. Transverse section at the level of cerebellum and cerebellar
peduncules. Note oedematous white substance characterised by a yellowish colouration in circled areas of the cerebellar vermis (top) and pons (bottom).

Fig 2: (A) Liver of a T. micrantha poisoned mare. Severe centrilobular hepatocyte necrosis, moderate diffuse fat degeneration and severe diffuse hepatic
haemorrhage (haematoxylin and eosin, 40¥). (B) Cortex frontal from a T. micrantha poisoned colt. Capillary vessel showing extravasated plasma and
hyaline globules (arrowheads) and Alzheimer type II astrocytes (arrows) (periodic acid Schiff, 400¥).

and in the thyroid, and moderate diffuse congestion in heart, absent antiglial fibrillar acid protein3 immunostaining (1:500)
kidneys and intestines were also seen. associated with positive immunostaining for S-100 protein3 (1:200)
The foal had severe diffuse hepatocellular fatty degeneration, performed on sections of cerebral cortex indicated the presence of
individual hepatocyte necrosis and multifocal ductal proliferation. Alzheimer type II astrocytes (Summers et al. 1995).
Cerebral cortex presented neuronal tumefaction with varying
numbers of Alzheimer type II astrocytes (Fig 2B). Additionally, all Discussion
levels of the brain and cerebellum had perivascular oedema
characterised by extravasated protein globules best visualised in T. micrantha poisoning was suspected upon clinical and
periodic acid Schiff stained sections (Fig 2B). In addition, pathological study of findings (Traverso et al. 2003, 2004)
tumefaction and tubular necrosis were detected in the kidneys. associated with the presence of the plant in the paddock where
Refrigerated fresh samples of brain, cerebellum and cervical affected animals had been kept. Evidence that parts of the plant had
spinal cord from both horses were analysed by direct been bitten off and the absence of other known causes of
immunofluorescence of rabies, with negative results. Weak or hepatotoxicity confirmed the diagnosis. The condition described
© 2010 EVJ Ltd
458 Trema micrantha toxicity in horses

here may have been associated with monopolisation of the fallen associated with a source of algae. Although field observations of T.
tree by dominant individuals, which therefore may have ingested micrantha poisoning in Brazil have been linked mainly to goat
larger quantities of green leaves of T. micrantha as compared to the flocks, the present report indicates that special caution should be
other animals in the paddock. Certainly, the good palatability of T. taken when keeping horses in areas with T. micrantha.
micrantha (Traverso et al. 2004) has played a role in the disease
described here. In Brazil, sporadic cases of hepatotoxicity in horses
Acknowledgements
have also been linked to the consumption of Senecio brasiliensis,
Crotalaria retusa and Brachiaria decumbens; however, none of
This study was funded by The Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de
these plants has been associated with acute liver necrosis. On the
Pessoal de Nível Superior (CAPES) and Conselho Nacional de
other hand, numerous plants may cause acute liver necrosis in
Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (CNPq), Brazil.
ruminants in Brazil (Tokarnia et al. 2002; Riet-Correa and Méndez
Authors are grateful to Professor Cláudio Estêvão Farias da Cruz
2007). Centrilobular hepatocellular degeneration and necrosis are
for reviewing this manuscript.
particularly common findings in association with hepatotoxic
insults and may be due to particularities of blood flow and high
enzymatic activity of the mixed-function oxidases in this region of Manufacturers’ addresses
the hepatic lobule (Cullen 2007).
Haemorrhages may be secondary to the damaged liver due to 1
Merck S.A., Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.
2
the excessive consumption of coagulation factors in necrotic insults Sigma Chemical Co., St. Louis, Missouri, USA.
3
DAKO, Carpentaria, California, USA.
as well as to the inability to further synthesise coagulation factors
and platelets (Stalker and Hayes 2007). Neurological findings were
probably linked to hepatic encephalopathy and associated with the References
action of neurotoxins, in particular ammonia, and possibly with
several other phenomena, such as alterations in neurotransmission, Barbera, R., Trovato, A., Rapisarda, A. and Ragusa, S. (1992) Analgesic and anti-
permeability of the blood-brain barrier, and energy metabolism inflammatory activity in acute and chronic conditions of Trema guineense
(Schum. Et Thonn.) Ficalho and Trema micrantha Blume extracts in rodents.
(Häussinger et al. 2002). Astrocytes exhibiting signs of Alzheimer Phytother. Res. 6, 146-148.
type II degeneration, cerebral oedema and neuronal degeneration Castellani, E.D. and Aguiar, I.B. (1998) Preliminary conditions for germination of
have all been described in cases of hepatic encephalopathy Trema micrantha (L.) Blume seeds. Rev. Bras. Eng. Agric. Ambien. 2, 80-83.
(Häussinger et al. 2002; Cullen 2007; Norenberg et al. 2009). Cullen, J.M. (2007) Liver, biliary system and exocrine pancreas. In: Pathologic Basis
The foal affected by T. micrantha poisoning had been recumbent of Veterinary Disease, 4th edn., Eds: M.D. Mcgavin and J.F. Zachary, Mosby
and exhibited impaired consciousness for at least 8 days before the Elsevier, St. Louis. pp 393-461.
decision on euthanasia was made; therefore, it may be said that the Gava, A. and Barros, C. (1997) Senecio sp. poisoning of horses in southern Brazil.
Pesq. Vet. Bras. 17, 36-40.
animal could have survived longer. Except for the Senecio-
Häussinger, D., Schliess, F. and Kircheis, G. (2002) Pathogenesis of hepatic
associated chronic disease in horses (Gava and Barros 1997), such a
encephalopathy. J. Gastroenterol. Hepatol. 17, 256-259.
long course of neurological failure due to hyperammonaemia has not
Hill, B.D., Wills, L.D. and Dowling, R.M. (1985) Suspected poisoning of horses by
been seen with most of the Brazilian hepatotoxic plants (Tokarnia Trema aspera (poison peach). Aust. vet. J. 6, 107-108.
et al. 2002; Riet-Correa and Méndez 2007). Affected animals Humphreys, D.J. (1988) Veterinary Toxicology, 3rd edn., Baillière Tindall, London. pp
usually die sooner than that. Hepatic lesions were more severe in the 222-309.
mare than in its foal, which showed mainly degenerative liver Johnson, F.B. (1992) Lipids. In: Laboratory Methods in Histotechnology, Eds: E.B.
changes, possibly manifested as a stage subsequent to the acute liver Prophet, B. Mills, J.B. Arrington and L.H. Sobin, American Registry of
Pathology, Washington. pp 175-182.
damage. This animal probably remained recumbent due to
neurological deficit secondary to hyperammonaemia. Kissmann, K.G. (1999) Plantas Infestantes E Nocivas, BASF, São Paulo. pp 643-644.

Nigropallidal encephalomalacia or ‘chewing disease’, a Knight, A.P. and Walter, R.G. (2001) Plants affecting the nervous system. In: A Guide
to Plant Poisoning of Animals in North America, Eds: A.P. Knignt and R.G.
clinically similar condition caused by the consumption of Walter, Teton New Media, Wyoming. pp 225-226.
Centaurea solstitialis (yellow star-thistle), affects horses in the Maxie, M.G. and Youssef, S. (2007) Nervous system. In: Pathology of Domestic
USA, Argentina and Australia (Humphreys 1988; Knight and Animals, 4th edn., Vol. 1, Eds: M.G. Maxie, K.V.F. Jubb, P.C. Kennedy and
Walter 2001), but not in Brazil. Theiler’s disease, an acute and N. Palmer, Elsevier, St Louis. pp 358-359.
sporadic hepatic disease of unknown aetiology, has not been Mcckenzie, R.A., Green, P.E., Thornton, A.M., Chung, Y.S., Mackenzie, A.R.,
associated with acute hepatic necrosis and haemorrhage (Stalker Cybinski, D.H. and St. George, T.D. (1985) Diseases of deer in south eastern
Queensland. Aust. vet. J. 62, 424.
and Hayes 2007), changes usually seen in T. micrantha toxicosis.
Morgavi, D.P. and Riley, R.T. (2007) An historical overview of field disease outbreaks
Although cerebellar lesions in T. micrantha poisoning may known or suspected to be caused by consumption of feeds contaminated with
resemble those seen in cases of Fusarium verticillioides-induced Fusarium toxins. Anim. Feed Sci. Technol. 137, 201-212.
equine leukoencephalomalacia, malacia is the predominant change Mulhearn, C.R. (1942) Poison peach (Trema aspera): a plant poisonous to stock. Aust.
induced by this mycotoxin-associated condition (Humphreys 1988; vet. J. 18, 68-72.
Morgavi and Riley 2007). In addition, these horses had been fed Norenberg, M.D., Rama Rao, K.V. and Jayakumar, A.R. (2009) Signaling factors in
exclusively at pastures, in which there was no source of corn. the mechanism of ammonia neurotoxicity. Metabol. Brain Dis. 24, 103-117.

Furthermore, the vascular lesions observed in cases of Oelrichs, P.B. (1968) Isolation and purification of trema toxin from Trema aspera.
Phytochemistry 7, 1691-1693.
leukoencephalomalacia may also affect larger vessels (Maxie and
Pio-Correa, M. (1984) Dicionário das Plantas Úteis do Brasil e das Exóticas
Youssef 2007) than those seen in cases of T. micrantha poisoning, Cultivadas, Vol. II, Ministério da Agricultura, Brasília. p 439.
in which plasma exudation occurred only surrounding capillaries
Riet-Correa, F. and Méndez, M.C. (2007) Intoxicações por plantas e micotoxinas. In:
and has not been associated with malacia. Finally, liver failure Doenças de ruminantes e eqüídeos, 3rd edn., Vol. 2, Eds: F. Riet-Correa, A.L.
caused by blue-green algal toxins (Humphreys 1988) is usually Schild, R.A.A. Lemos and J.R.J. Borges, Pallotti, Santa Maria. pp 99-221.

© 2010 EVJ Ltd


P. M. Bandarra et al. 459

Schoenfelder, T., Cirimbelli, T.M. and Citadini-Zanette, V. (2006) Acute effect of Traverso, S.D., Corrêa, A.M.R., Schmitz, M., Colodel, E.M. and Driemeier, D. (2004)
Trema micrantha (Ulmacea) on serum glucose levels in normal and diabetic rats. Intoxicação experimental por Trema micrantha (Ulmaceae) em bovinos. Pesq. Vet.
J. Ethnopharmacol. 107, 456-459. Bras. 24, 211-216.
Stalker, M.J. and Hayes, M.A. (2007) Liver and biliary system. In: Pathology of Trueman, K.F. and Powell, M.W. (1991) Suspected poisoning of camels by Trema
Domestic Animals, 4th edn., Vol. 1, Eds: M.G. Maxie, K.V.F. Jubb, P.C. Kennedy tomentosa (poison peach). Aust. vet. J. 68, 213-214.
and N. Palmer, Elsevier, St Louis. pp 297-381. Vasquez, Y.C. (1998) Trema micrantha (L.) Blume (Ulmaceae): a promising
Summers, A.B., Cummings, J.F. and de Lahunta, A. (1995) Veterinary neotropical tree for site amelioration of deforested land. Agrofor. Syst. 40,
Neuropathology, Mosby, St Louis. pp 210-211. 97-104.
Tokarnia, C.H., Döbereiner, J. and Peixoto, P.V. (2002) Poisonous plants affecting
livestock in Brazil. Toxicon 40, 1635-1660.
Traverso, S.D. and Driemeier, D. (2000) Experimental Trema micrantha (Ulmaceae) Author contributions All authors contributed to the initiation,
poisoning in rabbits. Vet. human Toxicol. 42, 301-302. conception and planning of this study. It execution was by P.M.B.,
Traverso, S.D., Colodel, E.M., Loretti, A.P., Corrêa, A.M.R. and Driemeier, D. (2003) S.P.P., D.J.R., A.M.R.C. and D.D. and the pathology and writing by
Intoxicação natural por Trema micrantha em caprinos. Ciênc. Rural 33, 133-136. P.M.B., S.P.P., D.J.R. and D.D.

Equinesports Veterinary Manual


Second edition
A.V. van Weezel Errens EVJ Price: £49.50
plus postage & packing
Publisher: Lotlorièn, 2009 • Paperback

We all understand that modern-day equestrian sports cannot be compared to the way horses
were historically used. Stakes are high and sponsors and many other professional parties have
become important players. However, in no way must we allow this to compromise the well-
being of our competition horses. Veterinary care and the administration of therapeutic
substances must be permitted when called for and detection of clinically in-effective levels
of medications should not always have to constitute a violation of anti-doping and medication
rules. The labyrinth of rules and regulations and the dynamic nature of the science of
pharmacology make giving sound advice difficult, especially considering the time-pressure
experienced by veterinarians and other equine professionals.
The Equinesports Veterinary Manual discusses the pharmacokinetics of equine medication
available today and discusses international regulations. It advises on the therapeutic effects
and the consequences these substances may have on withdrawal times for competition. It
explains and discusses the most relevant international competition regulations of the international regulatory bodies (FEI,
IFHA, IFAHR, FEQHA, AQHA, ARCI, USEF, CPMA, WADA), laboratory outcomes (EHSLC, RMTC) and the European policies
on veterinary medication. In this edition we have also elaborated on the regulations and risks concerning nutritional
supplements.
The Equinesports Veterinary Manual is meant for those veterinarians and other equine professionals involved in the
management of competition horses.

EVJ Bookshop, Mulberry House, 31 Market Street, Fordham, Ely, Cambs. CB7 5LQ, UK
Tel: 01638 720068 ! Fax: 01638 721868 ! Email: emma@evj.co.uk ! www.evj.co.uk

© 2010 EVJ Ltd

You might also like