Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Bridge Engineering - Major Bridges (PDF) - Cowi
Bridge Engineering - Major Bridges (PDF) - Cowi
Major bridges
COWI A/S
COWI, founded in 1930, is a privately owned and other academic specialists. The net capital and training. Roads, railways and airports with
company and completely independent of any and annual turnover are at present EUR 79 more than 3000 bridges of all types and sizes have
manufacturer, supplier or contractor. The and 376 million, respectively. More than 50% been constructed according to COWI’s designs.
COWI Foundation is the majority shareholder of the turnover comes from international
and supports research and development in the projects. Bridge engineering
various fields of consultancy activities. The skills represented in the COWI Group COWI is an international market leader in bridge
The head-office is located in Lyngby, a suburb are complementary to a very large extent, and engineering. Highly professional staff with broad
about 12 km north of Denmark’s capital Co- hence we can create synergy between the versa- international experience have reached this position
penhagen. tile bouquet of disciplines required in complex through a continuous commitment to work of the
COWI is a leading northern European con- projects and offer total solutions to our clients highest professional standards and a constant
sulting group. We provide state-of-the-art services considering all constraints and options in a search for efficient and innovative solutions.
within the fields of engineering, environmental balanced way. COWI is proud to present its capabilities and
science and economics with due consideration achievements in bridge engineering. We have en-
for the environment and society. COWI is a Transportation deavoured to present COWI’s comprehensive ser-
leader within its fields because COWI’s 3,500 COWI has more than 75 years of experience in vices within bridge engineering in this brochure.
employees are leaders within theirs. transportation covering all phases of infra- Please, do not hesitate to contact us for further in-
COWI’s staff includes engineers, planners, structure projects from initial planning and fea- formation.
sociologists, biologists, agronomists, economists sibility studies to maintenance management
• Development assistance
• Urban and regional development
• Environmental and social due diligence
�
• Geographical information systems and IT • Environmental policy and regulation
• Mapping • Natural resources management
• Energy planning and systems • Environmental protection
• Health, safety
� and
environment
• Welfare economics and services Economics Environmental science
• Public administration
• Social development and HRD
Engineering
• Transport planning and
management �
the three Es: Engineering, Environmental • Railways and metros • Commercial buildings
Science and Economics • Telecommunications
• Residential buildings
Bridges
• Suspension bridges
• Cable-stayed bridges
• Girder bridges
Bridge engineering 3
• Moveable bridges
• Urban bridges
References
COWI is recognized worldwide for its state-of- for a road bridge crossing of the Strait of Gi-
the-art knowledge on suspension bridges. This braltar between Spain and Morocco. Bridge • Messina Bridge, Italy
knowledge has been acquired through our in- piers and construction methods for foundation • Great Belt Bridge, Denmark
volvement in numerous suspension bridge at water depths of 300 to 500 m were devel- • Hålogaland, Norway
projects. oped utilizing technologies and concepts from
• Chacao Bridge, Chile
deep water gravity platforms and steel jackets
• High Coast Bridge, Sweden
New concepts from the off-shore oil industry. Also a com-
Closed box steel bridge girders, aerodynami- bined road and railway tender design for the • Aquitaine Bridge, France
cally shaped, were introduced by COWI in the 3,300 m Messina bridge has been carried out • Viaduc du Chavanon, France
New Little Belt Bridge in Denmark at the same here as a triple girder deck with rail on the cen- • Älvsborg Bridge, Sweden
time as in the Severn Bridge in UK. tre girder.
• YongJong Bridge, Korea
An innovative approach with dehumidifica-
• Trekantsambandet, Norway
tion of the air inside the closed box girder was Rehabilitation design
also introduced to avoid corrosion of the inte- A complete replacement design of main cables • Gibraltar Strait Crossing,
Spain − Morocco
rior surfaces. This approach has later been de- and hangers of the Aquitaine Bridge in France
veloped for dehumidification of main has been made, enabling a widening from 5 to • New Little Belt Bridge, Denmark
suspension cables. 6 lanes. Temporary ancillary cables supported • 2nd Bosporus, Turkey
COWI has designed maximum expansion the structure during construction which was • Hardanger Bridge, Norway
lengths in bridge girders to reduce maintenance made with full traffic on the bridge.
and hydraulic buffers to limit bridge girder ex-
pansions. Span length
3500
it
Wind engineering
tra
it
rS
tra
lta
S
ra
na
COWI introduced tuned mass dampers and ap-
3000
ib
si
G
es
M
plication to suppress vortex induced vibrations
2500
on cable-stayed and suspension bridges.
o
ky
ai
-K
hi
as
Ak
2000
en
l t
Be
um
at
ho
ng
re
K yo
Twin deck and closed elliptical bridge girder
Xi
G
ya
r
r
ky
a- aik
nd u g yin
e
be
un
ng
ai
im -K
um
co K in g
ur shi a
da
Ts Jian
ru M
1500
st
s
o
o ru
H
lu
us m
oa
ar
shapes have been investigated for extreme sus-
et po
ng
H
s
C
w
Ya
i -S os
ro
ig
su B
ar
l
H
M
ia
nd
ot nd
N
or
d
g
pension spans in the range from 3,500 to 5,000 m
la
r
im co
a
in
em
Se hi
om
o
o
sk
Ts
Sh Se
og
et
a
M
in
im
c
y
-S
o
1000
ål
ip a
at
Ta
kø
pa
ca
sh
m ad
H
an
al
As
ha
m
3.
no
Se in
is
Aquitaine Bridge,
to
Za
C
Ak
iB
In
ar ing
Se
er
o
Al
am
ut
iv
Pe Xil
n-
lR
ar
France
in
sa
hn
ho
M
Bi
rd
ng
O
uc
d
o
ta
500
ak
St
ca
Ki
su
en
ai
s
um
H
ne
m
H
je
Other
0
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015
Year of completion New Little Belt
World's longest suspension bridge spans Bridge, Denmark
5
6 Great Belt Link, East Bridge, Denmark
The high-level motorway bridge is one out of surface, are unpainted and are protected by de-
the three major components in the EUR 4 bil- humidification of the inside air volume.
lion Great Belt Link. The East Bridge is the
landmark and spans the international naviga- Cables
tion route between the Baltic Sea and the The length of the main cables is approximately
North Sea and allows a clearance of 65 m be- 3,000 m with an outer diameter of 0.82 m. The
low the bridge girder. The bridge carries a dual cables were installed by aerial spinning.
lane motorway with emergency lanes.
Photo: Per Brogaard With a main span of 1,624 m the East Bridge Pylons
has the second longest suspended span in the Rising 254 m above sea level, the pylon has
world. The side spans are 535 m each and the slightly tapered legs with a rectangular, hollow
approach bridges are 2,544 m and 1,552 m cross-section. The lower part around the water
long, respectively. The substructures including line is designed as a monolithic structure with
Services pylons, are constructed of concrete and the su- heavily reinforced 1.2 m thick walls to resist
perstructure is of steel. impact loads of 670 MN from a 250,000 DWT
• Conceptual design
tanker.
• Tender design
Superstructure The pylons are supported by large founda-
• Tender evaluation assistance The superstructure is an aerodynamically tion caissons placed on a gravel bed at a water
• Detailed design shaped fully welded closed box girder and con- depth of approximately 20 m. The cellular
• General supervision during tinuous over the full length of 2,694 m be- 78 x 35 m caissons, 20 m high and weighing
construction tween the two anchor blocks. The traditional 30,000 tonnes, were cast in a dry dock and
• Inspection and maintenance of steel expansion joints at the tower positions are thus towed about 30 nautical miles to the bridge
structures, equipment and mechanical avoided. In addition, hydraulic buffers between site.
installations the anchor blocks and the girder are installed
• Implementation of IT management to restrain longitudinal short-term movements. Anchor blocks
system Compared to a traditional system with joints Located at a water depth of approximately 10 m,
• Specialist studies, incl. ship collision at the pylons, the continuous system in combi- the anchor blocks shall resist cable forces of
nation with the hydraulic buffers improves the 600 MN. Excavation to 25 m below sea level
Project period
overall stiffness and stability of the bridge and was necessary to construct a wedge-shaped
1986 – 1998 leads to low maintenance costs. foundation base suitable for large horizontal
O&M superstructure ongoing
The box girder is suitable for rationalised re- loading. Each anchor block caisson covers
petitive fabrication. The interior surfaces, which 6,100 m² and weighed 50,000 tonnes in the
The Messina Strait Suspension Bridge will con- Suspended deck The tower legs are founded inside circular dia-
nect the coasts of Sicily and Calabria in south- The suspended deck is arranged with the cross- phragm walls on two circular foundations
ern Italy and it will carry a four lane highway girders spaced at 30 m as the main elements, which are connected by a concrete box tie.
with emergency lanes and a dual railway line. whereas the two roadway girders and the cen-
The bridge will be spectacular due to the tral railway girder are taken as secondary ele- Anchor blocks
world-record breaking 3,300 m main span ments spanning between the cross-girders. On both sides the anchor blocks are arranged
which is 65 % longer than the present longest Thereby the Messina Strait Bridge will be the as gravity based buried structures. The layout
suspension bridge and twice the main span of first bridge in the world to adopt the triple box is slightly different on the two sides due to lo-
the Great Belt East Bridge. The design life of concept for the suspended deck. The deck is cal soil and terrain conditions.
the bridge is 200 years which is twice the de- continuous from expansion joint to expansion
sign life normally applied for major suspension joint − the total length is 3,666 m. The naviga- Tender design
bridges. tion clearance at mid-span is 65 m. Load combinations including wind or earth-
quake loading are governing for the design of
Cables the bridge. The bridge is designed to be aero-
The main cables consist of twin cables spaced dynamic stable for wind speeds at deck level
at 1.75 m − i.e. a total of four cables with a di- up to 75 m/s, and with regard to earthquake it
ameter of 1.2 m are required for the bridge. can resist peak ground accelerations up to
The sag to span ratio of the cables is fixed to 6.3 m/s2. As part of the tender design a global
1:11. The length of the main cables is approx. 3D analysis model of the bridge structure was
5,300 m and the distance between the main established using COWI’s in-house developed
cables is 52 m. program IBDAS. The analyses included static
as well as dynamic analyses − e.g. dynamic
Towers wind analyses, seismic analyses by spectral re-
Services The towers are designed using S460 steel and sponse spectrum and seismic time histories, ac-
they are arranged as frame structures with cidental actions like rupture of a hanger and
• Pre-bid investigations in order to evaluate possible
savings. slightly inclined legs (inclination of approx. 2°) comfort analyses for train passengers.
and three connecting cross-beams. The overall The tender proposal prepared by COWI and
• Tender design of the bridge structure including all
structural elements, mechanical, electrical and railway dimension of the tower leg cross-section is 20 x ATI Impregilo proved to be the winning scheme
installations and life cycle cost studies 12 m, and the tower top level is at 382.6 m. and the contractor has signed the contract.
Parties
Client: ATI Impregilo
Designer: COWI
9
10 High Coast Bridge, Sweden
The High Coast Bridge carries the European lons are placed directly into the water. Conse- namic behaviour of the bridge. Consequently,
interstate highway E4 and crosses the river quently, the pylons needed to be strengthened the girder cross-section has been shaped to
Ångermanälven about 500 km north of Stock- to withstand ship collision impact from vessels minimise areas prone to snow accumulation,
holm. With a main span of 1,210 m the bridge up to 40,000 tons displacement. particularly close to the edges.
is one of the largest suspension bridges in Eu-
rope. The overall length is 1,800 m including Superstructure Experimental verification
side spans of 310 and 280 m. The bridge is de- The bridge girder is continuous from abutment Experimental verification of natural frequen-
signed to carry a dual-lane highway, although to abutment leading to a 1.8 km expansion sec- cies and structural damping has been carried
the effective width of 17.8 m will make it pos- tion. A rigid central fixation is introduced at out at the completed bridge. Damping meas-
sible for it to carry a four-lane highway in the mid-span between the main cables and the urements have been analysed and the results
future. The bridge has a minimum clearance bridge deck to control the differential horizon- indicated a clear amplitude dependence of the
under the main span of 40 m. tal movements. The continuous girder concept damping of torsional modes.
leads to a simple arrangement at the pylons,
Design reduced installation and maintenance costs for
The experience gained by COWI through the the expansion joints and improved vertical and
design of the Great Belt East Bridge has been horizontal stiffness. The interior of the box Services
useful in the design of the High Coast Bridge. girder, including the suspender anchorages, is
• Tender design
As a result a 4 m high and 22 m wide single- protected against corrosion by dehumidifica-
• Detailed design
cell box girder was designed, a low span to sag tion.
ratio of 9.5 was chosen, a cable distance of • Wind engineering
20.8 m was applied and a central fixation be- Aerodynamic design • Technical follow-up during
tween cable and girder was arranged in order The scenic beauty of the surrounding landscape construction
to obtain the best performance. All structural and the severe winters with risk of snow and • Dehumidification of main cables
elements were examined by FEM-analyses. ice accumulation were decisive environmental Project period
factors in the design of the bridge. The suspen-
1991 − 1997
Pylons sion span is the longest built at such northerly
Extending to a maximum level of 178.5 m the latitude and the risk of icing and heavy snow- Parties
pylons are plane frame reinforced concrete fall required special attention regarding aero- Client: The Swedish National Road
structures with transversely inclined legs fea- dynamic stability. Accumulated snow and ice Administration through Kjessler &
turing two transverse beams. As a result of an may alter the cross-sectional shape of the Mannerstråle
optimised technical and aesthetic design the py- girder, which, in turn, will alter the aerody-
References • Zárate-Brazo Largo Bridges, COWI has a track record comprising many couver, Canada. Later COWI was involved in
Argentina world-class cable-stayed bridges for both road the design of the record-breaking Normandy
• Sungai Johor, Malaysia
• Naini Bridge, India traffic and railway traffic and is involved in de- Bridge in France and the Stonecutters Bridge in
• Suramadu, Indonesia
• Nelson Mandela Bridge, South tailed design and design check of world-record Hong Kong. Design review and construction
• Sutong Bridge, China
Africa cable-stayed bridge projects. consultancy is carried out for the Sutong
• Stonecutters Bridge, The maximum span of cable-stayed bridges Bridge in China. The Stonecutters and Sutong
• Skarnsundet Bridge, Norway
Hong Kong
have increased significantly over the years and bridges will both have a main span of more
• Helgeland Bridge, Norway
• Busan-Geoje, Korea COWI has been involved in most of the record- than 1000 m.
• Grenland Bridge, Norway
• Øresund Bridge, breaking cable-stayed bridges.
Sweden − Denmark • Farø Bridge, Denmark Road and railway bridges
• Normandy Bridge, France • Paranaiba Bridge, Brazil Road bridges COWI has also carried out the design for the
• 2nd Panama Bridge, Panama • Seo-Hae Grand Bridge, Korea Back in 1986 COWI’s subsidiary in North Øresund Bridge, the world’s longest cable-
America, Buckland & Taylor Ltd., designed the stayed bridge span for combined road and rail-
• 2nd Orinoco Bridge, Venezuela
465 m main span Alex Fraser Bridge in Van- way traffic.
Span length
1200
tte ng
rs
cu uto
o ne S
St
n
eo
1000
ch
dy
In
a
ar
an
d
t
2n
Ta
rm
No
e
tz
ng
800
Ya
u
in
gP
g
nj
u
in
in
ho
on a
nj
iri N
M
u
az
Na
g
ho
nt 3rd
n
sh
Se e u
ta
t
de
ar ob gp
gz
d
i
Jin
rn p u
Ba
2n
m
un
ag i K an
i el
r
Sk ay
ho
A
ve Xu
am en
a s sh Y
ns
n-
600
tu
Jo
er
eg v
io
ar
d
a
M Ra
u
as
ai
R
am
Ka
su
ng
IX
Fr
ur
Se
oh
re
Su
dy ga
ng
th
a
ex
O
k
m
Vi Hi
Ti
Ar
d
Yo
Al
Ra
2n
400
200
Stonecutters Bridge across the Rambler Chan- span of 1,018 m. The main span is supported
nel is part of the Route 8 project in Hong from two single central towers both placed on Services
Kong, an east-west expressway linking Hong land providing a clear entrance to the container • Evaluation of feasibility of a
Kong international airport, Chek Lap Kok at port with a vertical clearance of minimum cable-stayed option
Lantau and the urban areas of the Kowloon 73.5 m. The 53.5 m wide bridge deck consists • Organise design competition
peninsula. COWI assisted the Highways De- of twin box girders connected by cross-girders. • Detailed design of main bridge
partment with a detailed feasibility study with The stay cables connect to the outside edges of
special attention to the aerodynamic response the deck only. The deck is in steel in the main Project period
and stability of a long span cable-supported span and 50 m into the first back span while 1999 − 2010
bridge. Unlike the other major bridges of Hong the rest of the back spans are in concrete.
Kong, Stonecutters Bridge will be clearly visible COWI together with Arup won the prestig- Parties
from the populated areas of west Kowloon and ious contract of detailed design and construc- Authorities: Highways
Department, HK
Hong Kong Island. The Highways Department tion supervision of the bridge. COWI is
of Hong Kong realised the potential of the site, responsible for the design of towers, steel su- COWI’s client:
Ove Arup & Partners, HK Ltd.
with the dramatic setting for a world-record perstructure and stay cables. Furthermore,
cable-stayed span in one of the busiest harbours COWI has carried out the global analyses and Designer for main bridge: COWI
in the world, and decided to procure the design supervision of the extensive program for wind
concept through an international design com- tunnel testing including interpretation of the
petition. results. COWI has designed bridge equipment
and the structural monitoring system.
Design competition The detailed design of the bridge has been
COWI and Ove Arup and Partners in Hong particularly challenging:
Kong worked jointly to organise the design • it is the first detailed design of a cable-stayed Bridge girder
competition for the Stonecutters Bridge. An in- bridge with a span over 1 km
dependent technical evaluation of Stage 2 sub- • the site is exposed to typhoon winds
missions was performed by COWI and in- • the busy harbour puts severe restrictions on
cluded: Structural and aerodynamic adequacy construction operations
check of girders, stay cables and towers by • the scope for structural modifications was
means of IBDAS and DVMFLOW. limited as the overall appearance of the win-
Photo mounting:
Detailed design be maintained
The winning project of the design competition The construction of the bridge will be completed
was a cable-stayed bridge with a record main in 2010.
The 7,844 m long bridge between Sweden and Pylons and piers
Denmark includes the world’s longest cable- The concrete pylons are 203.5 m high and
stayed bridge span for combined motorway founded on limestone. Prefabricated caissons
and railway traffic. are placed at a foundation depth of approxi-
The bridge crosses the international naviga- mately 15 m, and the pylon shafts are cast in
tion route with a main span of 490 m and two place. Artificial islands are established around
side spans of 160 m and 141 m on each side of the pylons and near-by piers to protect against
the main span and a height of 57 m above the ship impact. All caissons, piers and pier shafts
sea. The approach bridges towards Sweden and are prefabricated onshore and assembled off-
Denmark are 3,739 m and 3,013 m, respectively. shore.
Parties
Bridge authority: Øresundskonsortiet
Contractor: Sundlink Contractors HB:
Skanska AB (S)
Hochtief AG (D)
Højgaard & Schultz A/S (DK)
Monberg & Thorsen A/S (DK)
Designer: CV Joint Venture:
COWI A/S (DK)
Sweco AB (S)
Photo: Miklos Szabo
Photo: Øresundsbro Konsortiet
17
18 Busan-Geoje fixed link, bridges, Korea
The Busan-Geoje fixed link is a major infra- thermore, a fast track approach − with concur- Foundations
Services (bridges) structure development in the south-eastern part rent design, approval and construction − was The bridges rest on direct foundations consist-
• Basic design of Korea. It will provide easy access between adopted to minimize the project implementa- ing of concrete caissons formed by a cell struc-
metropolitan Busan and Geoje Island. The tion time. ture on a thick base slab, except for two pile
• Detailed design
Busan-Geoje fixed link has a total length of 8.2 The link is located on open sea and concur- foundations with inclined 2 m reinforced con-
• Technical follow-up during
km and comprises three main parts: two rent high wind and wave loads were governing crete piles. The design for ship impact was
construction
bridges (Lot 1 and Lot 2) and a 4 km long im- factors for the design. Each of the two bridge based on a probabilistic approach analysing
Project period mersed tunnel (Lot 3). These main elements are sections consists of a cable-stayed bridge and the effect of future traffic scenarios with ships
2003 − 2010 separated by two intermediate islands. approach bridges. The cable-stayed bridge in up to 60,000 DWT crossing the alignment.
The design was prepared directly for the con- Lot 1 has three pylons and two main spans of Numerical simulations and physical testing
Parties tractor providing the opportunity to conceive a 230 m, while Lot 2 has a traditional two pylon were used to determine wave loads and to opti-
Concessionaire: GK Fixed cost-efficient structure that was optimised to cable-stayed bridge with a main span of 475 m. mise the scour protection.
Link Corporation suit the contractor’s methods and equipment
Client: Daewoo Enginering & from the beginning. Large scale prefabrication Superstructure Prefabrication
Construction and the erection of large elements were major The bridges have traditional plated steel-con- In two prefabrication yards caissons, pier
considerations in the design development. Fur- crete composite decks that will carry a four- shafts and the approach bridge girders are pre-
lane motorway. In addition, there is a climbing fabricated. The caissons are transported to site
lane in one direction in Lot 2. The cross-sec- by floating dock and installed by a 3,000 t
tion and the fairings of the cable-stayed bridges floating crane which is also used to transport
were optimised by extensive numerical simula- and install the other parts.
tions and wind tunnel testing.
Technical follow-up during construction
Pylons During the construction COWI assists the Con-
A distinct feature of the bridges is their dia- tractor to assess design changes and further op-
mond shaped pylons with curved legs. The timise the design with regards to speed and
shape of the pylons provides the visual appear- construction methods. Furthermore, COWI re-
ance desired and, at the same time, the triangu- views temporary structures and carries out the
lated cable system improves aeroelastic stabil- camber control for the pylons and the cable-
ity compared to a layout with more traditional stayed bridge girder.
H-shaped pylons with vertical cable planes.
19
120m
Daejuk 80m
40m
0m
-40m
20 Sutong Bridge, Jiangsu Province, P.R. China
The Sutong Bridge will cross the Yangtze River side span on each side. The pylons are 306 m
upstream from Shanghai and will carry a six- high inverted Y concrete pylons. The super-
lane highway with emergency lanes. The total structure is a closed steel box girder with an
length of the bridge will be 6 km. The main overall width of 40 m and a height of 4 m.
bridge will be a cable-stayed bridge with a The pylon foundation consists of a total of 131
world-record breaking 1,088 m main span. large diameter bored piles with a diameter of 2.8
m reaching a depth of approximately 120 m.
Special fairway bridge and approach The aerodynamic behaviour of a 1,088 m
bridges main span cable-stayed bridge is a critical issue
The special fairway bridge is a rigid frame con- and significant efforts were required to docu-
crete bridge with a main span of 268 m. The ment the adequacy of the design, including par-
height of the girder is 15 m at the piers and 4.5 allel wind tunnel studies and numerical
m in the centre of the main span. The bridge simulations with COWI’s in-house developed
provides a navigational clearance of 220 m programmes DVMFLOW and IBDAS.
horizontally and 39 m vertically. The approach Due to strong currents significant scour was
bridges are concrete girder bridges with spans expected in the Yangtze River around the foun-
varying between 42 m and 75 m. dations. It was consequently decided to estab-
lish scour protection around the pylons. COWI
Cable-stayed bridge prepared the basic design for the protection
The 1,088 m main span cable-stayed bridge and specified the model tests to be carried out.
provides a navigational clearance of 891 m The final design was subsequently reviewed
horizontally and 62 m vertically in the main and COWI further provided consultancy on
span and 220 m horizontal clearance in one the construction of the scour protection.
Illustration: D+W
Råån Railway Bridge in Sweden with
tubular steel joints Årsta Bridge, Sweden
23
24 Moveable bridges
Brygge Bridge,
Copenhagen,
Denmark
Photo: Martin Professional A/S
25
26 Urban bridges
Aesthetics
COWI has an extensive tradition for collabora-
tion with recognised architects when designing
bridges − in particular urban bridges in order
to make the bridges fit into the existing envi-
ronment.
Landmarks
Nelson Mandela Bridge, South
Bridges may achieve landmark qualities when Africa. Light and transparent
they are designed with unique characteristic
shapes and may become points of attraction
for the citizens and visitors to the city.
Functional sculptures
Of course the bridges have a function and if Lusail Ring Bridge. Landmark
for Lusail Developemnt, Doha,
the structural elements can be given simple ge-
Qatar
ometric forms, the final result may have the
supplementary quality that the bridge becomes
a sculpture and thereby adds quality to the in-
ventory of the city.
Ågade Pedestrians Bridge,
Copenhagen, Denmark. A
gateway to the city
Munksjö Bridge, Sweden
27
Services
We provide:
• Assessment of demand impacts of service
changes and users willingness to pay for ser-
vices based on advanced customised market
research
• Strategic demand modelling to establish an
overall demand for the infrastructure and the
effects of different service and toll levels
• Economic and financial project analysis of
project alternatives to assist in the process to
select the optimal project type and alignment
within the frame of project goals defined by
the customer
• Independent assessment of decision basis,
Photo: Scanpix/Lars Bahl
budget assumptions and risk management
for large infrastructure projects
Project delivery
We advise on:
• Project finance and organisational set-up for
large projects including the various ways of
financing infrastructure projects
• Assessing the potential of public-private part-
nerships for specific projects considering
project risks and revenue potentials
State-of-the-art knowledge
The first cable-supported bridges were designed
by COWI back in the 1950’s. COWI is today
recognised for its state-of-the-art knowledge on
design of major bridges.
Innovations
Today’s innovations are often tomorrow’s best
practices. This is the case with dehumidifica-
tion of the interior of box girders for corrosion
protection, first introduced by COWI on the
New Little Belt Bridge, Denmark in 1970. The
application of numerical models for aerody-
namic analyses of structures is another example.
Contract management
Throughout the contract period the construc-
tion management organisation will have a need
for an in-depth knowledge of the contract as to
legal and commercial aspects.
Progress
Monitoring the progress of the project in all
aspects is of major importance for the con-
struction management. Progress analyses are a
prerequisite for decisions on actions to mitigate
threats against milestones and budget.
Cost control
Monitoring the economical development re-
2nd Panama Canal Crossing
lated to the works progress is essential for deci- dents as well as delays in production. An over- project, but not directly included in the man-
sions on possible mitigations against an over- all risk assessment includes construction risks, agement hereof, are well informed and able to
run of the budget. This includes agreed budget time and economy. make them heard.
changes as well as recorded claims.
Authorities Technical follow-up
Risk management The objective of the authority management is The objective of the technical follow-up man-
Construction of an infrastructure project of a to ensure timely and correct communication re- agement is to ensure that the construction
certain magnitude implies considerable risks garding applications, permissions and approval management forms a consistent estimate of the
for e.g. environment, third parties, time sched- of use. optimal handling of a technical problem being
ule and economy. Risk assessment during the the responsibility of the management.
construction period is an important tool for the Third parties
construction management giving part of the The objective of the third parties’ management
basis for mitigating actions against major acci- is to ensure that all parties influenced by the
34 Site supervision
The experience of site supervision on a world- • Review of the contractor’s method state- • Suspension of works
wide basis is accumulated in COWI, including ments, work procedures and control plans • Site instructions to the contractor
disciplines like: • Safety issues
Tasks at project completion
Preconstruction tasks Tasks during construction • The contractor’s application for taking over
• Project review with the contractor • Site meetings • Tests on completion
• Review of performance security • Variations to the contract • As-built documentation
• Review of the contractor’s insurance policies • Non-conformances • Taking over certificate
• Review of the contractor’s work and pay- • Works contract accounts
ment plan • Payment certificates Tasks after project completion
• Review of the contractor’s quality, environ- • Progress reports • Statement on completion submitted by the
mental, health and safety plan • Taking over parts of the work contractor
• Completion payment certificate
• Defects notification period
• Performance certificate
• Final payment certificate
Documentation
Upon completion of the construction works,
the site supervision has delivered a comprehen-
sive documentation of the quality of the project
including possible changes agreed during the
period of construction.
Naini Bridge,
Allahabad, India
Operation and management 35
Concept
Operation management normally comprises:
• Administration with a description of organi-
sational responsibility for operation and
Replacement of edge beams,
maintenance and relations to external parties waterproofing and pavement
• An inventory with a systematic filing system on motorway bridge, Denmark
for all inventory data
• Management tools including systems devel- near the capacity limit. New and innovative so- Maintenance management systems
oped to fulfill the need for information to the: lutions are required to maintain the structures. Efficient computerised systems are needed in
- public • Inspection and maintenance activities aim to order to support the management concept and
- management maintain the structures by preventive mainte- to optimise the use of allocated funds amongst
- bodies engaged in the operation and the nance with a minimum of corrective mainte- all the components of infrastructure elements.
maintenance nance. The daily maintenance comprises COWI has more than 20 years of experience
- managing of tasks including time, economy, principal and special inspections, preventive in implementing both management concepts
quality, safety and environmental matters and corrective maintenance and monitoring and computer tools e.g. in Singapore, China,
• Traffic and technical operation consultancy • Equipment and materials including advise on Thailand, Spain, Denmark and Uruguay.
in preparing procedures and instructions for necessary maintenance equipment and tools
the daily operation with instructions about use and servicing Repair of expansion joint on
the New Little Belt Suspension
Bridge, Denmark
COWI has extensive experience in designing COWI has been involved in designing equip-
maintenance works to be carried out during ment for inspection of bridge girders, main
traffic flow in urban environments and traffic cables and pylons.
36 Re-evaluation and rehabilitation
Corroded stay cable from the Measurement of cross section Petrographic analysis, micro-
Zárate-Brazo Largo Bridges, of corroded reinforcement scope photo of air entrained
Argentina homogeneous concrete
Decommissioning 37
Illustration: D+W
Sitra Causeway, Bahrain
Services
• Concept development
• Monitoring and signal analysis
• Analytical/theoretical models
• Detailed design of cable dampers
Inspection of and tuned mass dampers
damper cylinder.
Great Belt, East • Installation supervision
Bridge, Denmark
• Testing and verification
Risk policy
The process involves formulation of safety
goals including screening of potential risks, se-
lection of the main types of risk of concern and
a formulation of the corresponding acceptance
criteria.
Risk analysis
A preliminary identification and qualitative
screening and ranking of the risks can be used
to select the main risks to be quantitatively as-
sessed.
The process involves means of achieving the
safety goals including quantitative risk analyses
of accidents, their spectrum of consequences,
Photo: Aksel G Frandsen
the corresponding probabilities of occurrence
and the selection of design criteria. Tjörn Bridge, Sweden. Ship impact catastrophe, 1980
Examples are arrangement of navigation
channel and navigation span such that ship col-
lision to bridges will not occur frequently, but General hazards Consequences
only as extreme events as a result of failures • Road accidents • Loss of bridge structure
and errors. • Rail accidents • Injuries and loss of lives
Risk allocation
• Ship collision to bridges crossing • Disruption of bridge traffic until
Risk mitigation In this way it is possible for the client/owner to waterways remedial work has been made
In the case that the risk acceptance criteria are select the most suitable concept and corre-
• Earthquake
not initially met, risk-reducing measures are sponding design basis in the sense that the pro-
• Scour
identified and their risk-reducing effects are as- tection against accidents is based on his pre-
sessed. ferred balance of costs and risks. • Fire and explosions
• Extreme environmental impact such
as ice impact, high waters, large
waves and typhoons
Construction risk management 43
Risk policy
For each type of risk, specific minimum risk
objectives may be defined in addition to gen-
eral risk objectives.
For example, the general public should be
exposed only to a small additional risk from
the construction of a bridge − compared to the
risk they are normally exposed to.
Risk analysis
Systematic construction risk management tech-
niques can be used throughout the bridge
project development.
The use of construction risk management
from the early stages of a project may influence
the selection of construction methods aiming at
the reduction of the inherent risks.
Helgeland Bridge, Norway.
Risk mitigation
Potential problems can be clearly identified and
assessed such that appropriate risk mitigation General hazards Specific hazards Consequences
measures can be developed and implemented in • Contractual disputes • Accidents’ occurrences • Incidents and injuries to staff
a timely manner, and construction methods • Insolvency and institutional • Unforeseen adverse conditions • Incident and injuries to third parties
and supervision procedures can be selected to problems
• Inadequate designs, specifications • Damage to neighbouring facilities
minimise risks. • Authorities’ interference and programmes
• Environmental pollution and
• Third party interference • Failure of major equipment damage
Risk allocation
• Labour disputes • Works that are substandard, slow or • Financial losses
The evaluation of the risks may also be used to
out of tolerance
allocate the available resources in a optimal • Unplanned costs
manner. • Delays
• Bad reputation
44 Ship collision and ship impact protection
Major bridges often cross navigation channels The geotechnical modelling group in COWI a 2D numerical simulation model that com-
and ship impact may therefore become a signif- has generic FEM-models and significant experi- bines the dynamics of the ship and the layout
icant hazard for the safety of both structures ence in analysis of ship impact protection dol- geometry and response characteristics of the
and users. phins and in determining the energy dissipating dolphins.
The risk from ship impact can be controlled capabilities during the large plastic deforma-
preventively by increasing the navigational tions. Risk analysis
clearance and improving the navigational ar- Comparison with the results of an extensive Statistical data and projections on the ship traf-
rangement near the bridge. Risk control by scale model testing program conducted in the fic are combined with the simulation model to
protective means can be achieved externally − large geo-centrifuge at GeoDelft has given a estimate the frequency that a ship will be able
e.g. by installing protection islands or dolphins strong experimental confirmation of the FEM- to pass the protection arrangement and reach a
− or by increasing the strength of the bridge modelling. pier with a sufficient impact speed to cause col-
piers to resists accidental impact from ships. COWIs advanced modelling techniques thus lapse.
Physical and numerical model
permit full assessment and utilisation of the en- of protection dolphins for 2nd
Dolphin capacity ergy dissipation capacity of protection dol- Optimization of protection layout Incheon Bridge, Korea
Utilisation of the full dissipative capacity of phins. Iterative use of the models and risk estimation
protection dolphins requires detailed 3D com- enables a systematic optimisation of the layout
puter modelling to describe the significant de- Simulation of impact scenarios to achieve a cost-effective protection that satis-
formations and displacements occurring during The combined effect of an arrangement of pro- fies a predefined or established upper limit for
an impact. tection dolphins is analysed in full detail using the frequency of collapse due to ship impact.
References
• 2nd Incheon Ship Impact
Protection Project
• Arthur Ravenel Jr. Bridge
Ingoing traffic (New Cooper River
X Bridge)
PG(X)
VMAX
VIMPACT(X)
VMIN
2nd Incheon Bridge, Korea Traffic distribution through main span, 2nd Incheon Bridge, Korea
Structural health monitoring 45
a more traditional painting system, and it has • Stonecutters Bridge, Hong Kong
been used on several major steel bridges for • Normandy Bridge, France
corrosion protection of the interior of steel box • High Coast bridge, Sweden
girders − and also main cable steel at the an-
• Humber Bridge, United Kingdom
chorages.
A dehumidification system can be designed Suspension bridge main cables:
Fibre composites and stainless steel block steel would involve extensive works
The Herning pedestrian bridge pushes the lim- above the bridge deck being both costly and
its of the state-of-the-art within application of difficult, and restrictions on traffic during re-
fibre-reinforced polymers. This project is the pair works would be required.
result of a research and development project
initiated by the Danish road directorate. Environmentally friendly concrete
The cable-stayed bridge has a central steel A Danish research project entitled “Green
pylon and two 40 m side spans with a width of Concrete” has the objective to create new
4 m. All 16 cable-stays are made of carbon fi- knowledge about environmentally friendly
bre-reinforced polymer (CFRP) cables, as are types of concrete and to develop technological
the six non-bonded post-tensioning cables in solutions aimed at promoting the use of this
the bridge deck. type of concrete.
The reinforcement in half of the bridge deck The project developed the following strategies:
consists of CFRP bars and stirrups. The rein- • Cements that require less energy under pro-
forcement in the other half of the bridge deck duction using e.g. 18% renewable fuels in-
is a combination of stainless steel and conven- stead of coal
tional reinforcement steel. • Reduction in CO2 emissions by using large
The cross-section is over-reinforced and the amounts of fly ash (>> 20%)
compression zones are confined by means of • Bridge decks without surface protection (as-
stirrups. The result is a flexural failure gov- phalt or moisture barrier)
erned by ductile concrete crushing due to the • Combine stainless steel and black reinforce-
high ultimate compression strain of confined ment to relax requirements to concrete
concrete. The strategies help to reduce the impact on the
environment throughout the service life of the
Stainless structural steel structure.
For the Stonecutters Bridge in Hong Kong the The suggested strategies were tested in a mo-
pylon tops have been designed with a stainless torway bridge (2002) built by the Danish road
steel surface in order to minimize future main- directorate. The bridge stands as a tangible
tenance on the outside of the pylons and also proof of the applicability of environmentally
for aesthetic reasons. Repainting of ordinary friendly concrete.
Concrete exposed
to harsh marine
environment
Photo: Gitte C
and construction supervision.
Knippelsbro, Denmark
Total length: 140 m Sheikh Zayed Bridge, Abu Dhabi,
United Arab Emirates
Main span: 2 fixed spans both 44 m and a
double-leaved steel span channel of 35 m Total length: 842 m
Completed: 1991 Main span: 234 m
Client: Port of Copenhagen and Municipality Completed: 2005
of Copenhagen Client: Works Department, Emirate of
Services by COWI: Conceptual design, Abu Dhabi
detailed design and supervision of Services by COWI: Independent design
construction. check.
����������������
������� ����������������
���������������������
������������������������
��������������
����������������
�������������������
�����������������
��������������
�����
������ ������������������������
����������������� ����������������������
������������������ ������ �����������������������
�������������������� �������������������������� ��������������������
�����
������ ���������������������������������
����� �������������� ����������������������������������������
��������������� ����������������������� ������������������������������ ���������������������
�����
��������������������� �����
������������������������
������� ������������������
������������������������ ��������������
������
������������������
�������������������� �������� COWI Group
����������������������� ���������������
���������������������� main office:
��������� ������������
����� ���������������������������� �����������������������
����������������������������������
COWI A/S
Parallelvej 2
DK-2800 Kongens Lyngby
Denmark
Tel. +45 45 97 22 11
�������������� Fax +45 45 97 22 12
������������������������������ www.cowi.com