Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jean-Louis Cohen - Exhibitionist Revisionism - Exposing Architectural History (September 1999)
Jean-Louis Cohen - Exhibitionist Revisionism - Exposing Architectural History (September 1999)
JEAN-LOUIS COHEN
lnstitute of Fine Arts, New York
Institut Français d'Architecture, Paris
S
ituated at the intersection of practice and history, ums, and emerging architecture centers. 1 Once we acknowl
architecture exhibitions have increased dramatically edge that the most popular of these exhibitions attract an
in number since the 1960s. Once rather an exception audience that has little in common with the audience for
in art museums, they have played a central role in architec scholarly publications, we realize the extent to which we are
tural education in the twentieth century, both in schools still dealing with a major point of contact between the intellec
based on the traditional Beaux-Arts model, however mod tual community and the public at large. At first glance, one
emized, and in those derived from Bauhaus pedagogy. Such might argue that exhibitions lend a certain social legitimacy
exhibitions were, however, relatively rare in cultural insti to the collective work of historical research. In this respect,
tutions, where architecture was featured only during cele the corpus of recent exhibitions deserves analysis, not the
brations of major fi gures past or present, or within the least for the edification of academie authorities prone to
framework of the world's fairs and universal expositions. In judge the careers and perspectives of scholarly disciplines
the past three decades, however, architecture exhibitions in market terms.
have experienced exponential growth, while at the same Taken as a group, the impressive ensemble of recent
rime becoming the privileged site for unveiling scholarly exhibitions is extraordinarily heterogeneous, so much so
research. Catalogues, the publication of which is made pos that one might wonder whether they might legitimately be
sible by such events, are steadily becoming primary ourlets counted as part of a single field of cultural production
for historiographie discoveries. Previously episodie, the (Figures 1-3). What does a major retrospective of the work
direct involvement of architectural historians in exhibitions of an American hero such as Frank Lloyd Wright (MoMA,
has evolved rapidly from a mere extension of a historian's 1994), with all of its drawings and models, have in common
primary professional activity to become, at rimes, its pri with a small show of modest presentation boards honoring
mary vehicle. Indeed, a veritable curatorial market has the French architects of Algiers (Ecole Polytechnique d'Al
emerged, in which academics, museum curators, and free ger, 1998), the latter a delicate operation in an Algeria con
lance historians compete for the limited resources of spe fronting the temptations of nationalism? What do the
cialized museums of architecture and the architecture and intellectual speculations of Das Abenteuer der Ideen (The
design departments created within art museums since 1980. adventure of ideas, National Gallery, West Berlin, 1987)2
Thousands of shows, from the largest, with blockbuster have in common with the displays of building permits and
appeal, to the much more modest monographie exhibits, construction files from municipal archives so often mounted
have thus found their way into galleries in schools, muse- by local history societies? Nothing other than the fact that
Figure 1 Alvar Aalto: Between
Humanism and Materialism, The
Museum of Modern Art, New York,
1998. Photograph courtesy Museum
of Modern Art, New York
all of these exhibitions dialogue within a kind of museum a new light, while Raffaello architetto (Palazzo dei Conserva
without walls, one infinitely flexible and in which hierar tori, Rome, 1984) led to the reevaluation of some works by
chies can at cimes become jumbled. Raphael previously considered minor. 4
The functions that architectural exhibitions take on are, And much progress in the intellectual underpinnings
in fact, eminently variable. They can set out to highlight con of exhibitions can be observed. Since the 1960s, rather
temporary or recent work that has been overlooked or that superficial interrogations, such as the Sources du XXe siècle
has developed outside of the mainstream. The Carlo Scarpa (Sources of the twentieth century, Musée National d'Art
retrospective (Venice, 1984) exemplifies this type of belated Moderne, Paris, 1960- 196 1) 5 have given way to thematic
reparation. 3 They may also serve to resurrect a forgotten cross sections of specific artistic and architectural move
work of architecture, or a neglected aspect of a great artist's ments that open new questions and present new material.
oeuvre. For instance, the 1967 Rudolph Schindler exhibition Sorne of these have been research operations on a national
in Santa Barbara presented the architecture of Los Angeles in scale, such as the cluster of four exhibitions on Dutch archi-
one might cite the popular undertakings organized by Jean Gallery, London, 1995), a somewhat confused denunciation
Dethier at the Centre Georges Pompidou, such as Le Temps of certain collusions or troubling convergences between
des gares ( 1979) and Architectures de terre ( 198 1), both of radical architects and totalitarian systems. 17 But one might
which traveled for years in reduced versions. 15 also question the practice of enclosing oneself within the
More refined in terms of exhibition strategy are those corpus of exhibitions, viewed as a sort of microcosm within
expositions with an agenda of critique, or even denuncia which political, intellectual, and artistic change would be
tion. The Modern Movement made significant use of this self-explanatory. The commemoration of great fairs such as
polemical weapon, crossing out with great red Xs images of those held in Paris ( 1889, 1925, 193 1, 1937) as well as
bourgeois salons or eclectic palaces, in order to pass judg Chicago and New York (1893, 1933, and 1939) in exhibi
ment graphically. One memorable example of this strategy tions documenting the pavilions and their displays has car
is the "Tavolo degli orrori" (Panel of horrors) collaged by ried such a risk of narcissism and self-referentiality rather
Pier Maria Bardi for the Second Italian Exhibition of Ratio than historie analysis. Of course, it is easy to find original
nal Architecture (Milan, 193 1); this predated the Nazis' material on the world's fairs, since they have usually been
famous reversai of the scheme with the Entartete Kunst well preserved, and exhibitions produce exceptional
(Degenerate art) exhibition (Munich, 1938). Recent years encounters between mass culture and architecture, but they
have seen the denunciation of the denunciation with the are not necessarily the moments of rupture that an overly
reconstruction of the Degenerate Art exhibition at the Los schematic historical interpretation based simply on the
Angeles County Museum of Art (1991). 16 This type of his larger-scale public moments would allow one to believe.
torical reconstruction has proven infinitely more stimulat Nor must we overlook the impact-at least in terms of
ing than exhibitions such as Art and Power (Hayward sheer numbers-of what I would call "legitimizing exhibi-
between disciplines within or at the limits of architecture digest the technological transformations taking place in
itself. These investigations have profoundly rejuvenated the professional practice, revolutionized by computers. Initially
monograph as a tool of research, leading to critical recon used in order to highlight geometric features or load-bear
structions of biographical itineraries. Between the exhibi ing structures, computers have more recently made it pos
tions dedicated to Le Corbusier or to Mies van der Rohe in sible to reconstruct entire environments and to simulate
the early 1970s and those opened less than fifteen years urban integration. And this has made possible interpretive
later, a space made up of doubts, of reconsiderations, and hypotheses and even reconstructions of sequences of design
of more complex interpretations has opened up. They have transformations of a sort limited previously to very special
revealed new genealogies for fi gures once considered great ized conceptual models, such as Luigi Moretti's studies of
originating genuises. It was exhibitions that underscored Renaissance and Baroque buildings published in Spazio in
the importance of such father figures as Peter Behrens and 1952. 19 The use of groups of models all at the same scale
Auguste Perret, and revealed the interesting relationship of a major innovation of the early 1970s used brilliantly in the
Modernism to earlier traditions-Le Corbusier's indebted memorable Palladio exhibition held in the Basilica at
ness in the concept of the promenade architecturale to Vicenza ( 1973)--has enhanced the capacity to measure con
Au guste Choisy's analysis of the Acropolis in his Histoire de stants and variations in a given architect's work (Figure 5). 20
l'architecture ( 1899), or Mies van der Rohe's multifaceted More recently, the possibility of completing and simulating
relationship to Schinkel. theoretical or unrealized projects has corne within reach.
The monographie approach to an architect's work or The virtual reconstructions by MIT's Team Unbuilt for At
to an individual building has been revitalized recently. Such the End of the Century: One Hundred Years ofArchitecture, an
monographie exhibitions are different from those prevalent exhibition produced by the Los Angeles Museum of Con
in art museums, which set out to corne to terms with a temporary Art ( 1998), mark an important threshold in
painter's or sculptor's entire body of work. To the extent respect to finesse and tectonic realism, which will soon be
that they provoke encounters among specialists from adja made obsolete by the sheer progress of computing (Figures
cent if often mutually indifferent fields, these operations 6, 7). 21 Recourse to computers facilitates the reconstruction
help to undermine the tendencies of architectural history and presentation of the design and the construction
to bury itself in its own world. processes, a task difficult to accomplish with finite
The new interpretive or narrative constructs built in sequences of two-dimensional documents. And it creates a
this way also rely on contemporary technical means, which world of representations with great potential for commu
reframe the respective roles of drawings, photographs, and nicating to nonprofessional audiences. But there is an obvi
archival documents. With a certain time lag, exhibitions ous risk that must be avoided, namely, transforming
Figure 8 L'art de l'ingénieur, constructeur, entrepreneur, inventeur, Centre Georges Pompidou, Paris, 1997.
Photograph courtesy Centre Georges Pompidou, Paris
exhibition galleries into boring reproductions of architec l'ingénieur (Centre Georges Pompidou, 1997; Figure 8).22
ture studios; rather, visual pleasure must be allied with dis For evoking actual built spaces, the realism of movie sets in
covery. This dangerous desiccation returns to the question the exhibition Cités-Cinés (Grande Halle de la Villette, 1988)
of modes of assembly and orchestration of documents in remains unequaled in its poetry and freshness (Fi gure 9).
expository narration. Computers can condense the narra The exhibition was based on the projection of film excerpts
tion, extend it via hyperimage links, or contextualize it. inside full-sized reconstructions of the sets where they had
The possibility of re-creating the very process of con been shot, whether based on real cities, like Alexandre
struction was given rather spectacular form in the installa Trauner's Paris, or on fictional ones, like Erich Kettelhut's
tion of images projected onto large-scale screens for L'art de Metropolis. More mundane but nonetheless effective, some
exhibitions have reconstructed fragments of buildings, as in ture by Peter Eisenman for the exhibition of his own work,
Blueprintsfor Modern L iving (Museum of Contemporary Art, the Cities ofArtificial Excavation of 1994. 25 In a similar vein,
Los Angeles, 1990), to place on exhibition structural solu Daniel Libeskind reproduced the experience of his spaces
tions and spatial qualities of particular buildings (Figure 10).23 within the large Brutalist container of the Dutch Architec
But no matter what the exhibition format, the question ture Museum in Rotterdam (Unfolding , 1998). 26
of space remains crucial in any exhibition in which the his These undertakings run the risk, as in some recent his
tory of architecture is concerned (Figure 1 1). Yves Michaud torical exhibitions, of a kind of mannerism-to use an
has discussed the ambiguous relationship between the artist admittedly debatable art-historical concept that I will
and the curator in art exhibitions. In architectural exhibi employ in relationship to the use of architectural elements
tions the addition of a designer turns this mad couple into that are deformed or extracted from their original context;
a hellish threesome. 24 In addition to the architectural work one might even speak of the anamorphosis of the architect's
exhibited, a new work is layered on top. This can take work. It is critical distance that is in question here. In the
diverse forms, from Boris Podrecca's contribution to the Louis I. Kahn exhibition, seen at two sites located 7,000
Venice Scarpa retrospective (Galleria dell' Accademia, miles apart, Arata Isozaki did not resist the temptation of
Venice, 1984) to the Mastering the City exhibition (Nether producing a Kahnesque design. 27 The opposite approach
lands Art Institute, Rotterdam, 1998). Scenography, as was taken in the Le Corbusier centenary exhibition, L'aven
exhibition design is now somewhat pompously called, is ture Le Corbusier (Centre Georges Pompidou, 1987), where
indissociable from contemporary museographic undertak Vittorio Gregotti used the pattern of a type of giant super
ings, to the point where it develops sometimes market to re-create the manifold aspects of the work of the
autonomously from, or even in conflict with, the architec architect, pamphleteer, and artist.
ture of the museum itself. The scenography of an architec Just how can one assess the specific contribution of this
tural exhibition thus has a problematic status: Is it the rich field of exhibitions to the enterprise of architectural
humble servant of a scholarly agenda, a commentary upon and cultural history? The exhibition is but one moment in
it, an act of taking distance, a three-dimensional demon the sequence of events that comprise research, in its trajec
stration of that which is difficult to discern in two-dimen tory from an initial definition of a problem or issue to the
sional documents? In contesting the envelope that is the diffusion of findings. Yet the exhibition is only very rarely
museum, the scenography of exhibitions devoted to con the end of the journey. Nevertheless, it often constitutes a
temporary works is capable of condensing an architectural major step in the research process, because it provokes a
strategy. This was the case of the labyrinth introduced into kind of crystallization of results that themselves trigger new
the sober enclosure of the Canadian Centre for Architec- developments. This step is rendered more vital when