Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Spreadsheet Models
Chapter 10
Spreadsheet Models
Solutions:
1. a.
P(q) = Rq − FC − ( MC )q − ( LC ) q
10 - 1
c.
10 - 2
Spreadsheet Models
2. a.
b.
10 - 3
Spreadsheet Models
3. a.
10 - 4
Spreadsheet Models
b.
c.
10 - 5
Spreadsheet Models
d.
Scenario 4 yields the highest profit ($40,000) and scenario 2 the lowest (–$118,000).
4.
a.
10 - 6
Spreadsheet Models
b.
10 - 7
Spreadsheet Models
5.
a.
10 - 8
Spreadsheet Models
b.
c.
The best case (highest) profit is $3,593.75 and the worst case (lowest) profit is $425.00.
10 - 9
Spreadsheet Models
6. a.
10 - 10
Spreadsheet Models
b.
c.
10 - 11
Spreadsheet Models
7. a. The screenshot below displays the annual calculations. The future value of Lindsay’s investments can
also be computed using the Excel function =FV(B6, 30, -B5); the negative sign for the annual investment
is required as the future value command assumes a stream of payments not deposits.
10 - 12
Spreadsheet Models
b.
10 - 13
Spreadsheet Models
8.
10 - 14
Spreadsheet Models
10 - 15
Spreadsheet Models
9.
a. There are errors in the calculations of Rent in row 26 for Years 2 through 5. As shown below, instead
of the Inflation Rate ($B$9), the calculations for Rent in Years 2 through 5 use the Tax Rate ($B$8).
To correct this error, we must replace $B$8 with $B$9 in cells D26:G26 (highlighted above).
With these corrections, the new correct Total Discounted Cash Flow is $744,862.61.
b. The Scenario Summary shows that Scenario 1 gives the highest profit ($990,306) and scenario 3 the
lowest profit ($487,322). The range then is $990,306 – $487,322 = $502,984.
10 - 16
Spreadsheet Models
10.
10 - 17
Spreadsheet Models
11.
Error #1: The formula in cell C17 is:
=SUMPRODUCT(C8:G11,B22:F25)
but should be
=SUMPRODUCT(B8:F11,B22:F25)
10 - 18
Spreadsheet Models
but should be
=SUM(B22:F22)
10 - 19
Spreadsheet Models
12.
a. A portion of the spreadsheet is shown below.
10 - 20
Spreadsheet Models
13.
a. A portion of the spreadsheet is shown below.
10 - 21
Spreadsheet Models
14. a.
b.
10 - 22
Spreadsheet Models
15.
a.
10 - 23
Spreadsheet Models
b. The lower the stock price, the more beneficial the put options. The options are worth nothing at a stock
price of $26 or above. There is a benefit from the put options to the overall portfolio for stock prices of
$24 or lower.
16.
a.
b. Part of the Data Table is shown below. Max profit occurs at Camera A price of $270 and Camera
B price of $390.
10 - 24
Spreadsheet Models
17.
18.
10 - 25
Spreadsheet Models
To answer this question, use Goal Seek to find the additional payment that makes the given month balance
$0. The answers are shown below in J14:J16.
Key formulas:
10 - 26
Spreadsheet Models
20. Floyd’s Bumpers total cost of the May shipments is $641,596.98. A portion of the spreadsheet is shown
below:
10 - 27
Spreadsheet Models
The rows of the distance table are the customer zips and are located in I6:I1034. The distribution centers
are located in J4:N4.
The following functions are used for each column (and similarly for other rows):
B6: =VLOOKUP(A6,$Q$6:$R$1034,2)
C6: =MATCH(A6,$I$6:$I$1034,0)
D6: =MATCH(B6,$J$4:$N$4,0)
E6: =INDEX($J$6:$N$1034,C6,D6)
10 - 28
Spreadsheet Models
F6: =($C$2+$G$2)*E6
10 - 29
Spreadsheet Models
We use goal seek to find the discount rate that results in an NPV of $25,995:
The result is 10.9%. So effectively the dealer is making 10.9% interest on the loan of $25,995.
10 - 30
Spreadsheet Models
Chapter 10
Spreadsheet Models
We take as the base case for Tim’s retirement planning problem the parameter settings below:
While there are many ways to model this problem, any sound approach will have the following characteristics:
There spreadsheet model will have a parameters section and a model section.
There will be essentially two modules for calculating the age when funds run out and the balance at the beginning of
retirement. These are a pre-retirement module and a post-retirement module. During the pre-retirement time, money
is accumulated through salary-based contributions from Tim, additional pre-tax contributions from Tim, the school’s
contribution to Tim’s account, and returns on the investment. During the post-retirement time, spending is taken out
of the account, taxes must be paid on the amount withdrawn, and returns on investment accrue into the account.
Below we show each portions of each individual module. Note that we inflate the salary by the appropriate amount
each year (column C) and we include the return on investment along with the other cash flows into the fund
(Column H).
10 - 31
Spreadsheet Models
10 - 32
Spreadsheet Models
Note that spending is inflated in (Column L). We use the INDEX function in cell N27 to find the beginning balance
based on the year of retirement. We use an IF statement to determine if funds are still available or not. In cell Q27,
we use an INDEX function with the MATCH function to find the first occurrence of a one in column P and return
the age of Tim when this occurs.
There are many factors at work here and student responses may vary. However, the impact of retirement age and
additional pre-tax contributions is specifically requested. A data table as shown below indicates how age when funds
run out varies with these inputs.
10 - 33
Spreadsheet Models
90 70
Age When Funds Run Out
68
85 66
64
80
62
75 60
70
65
0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 14000 16000 18000
Additional Pre-tax Contributions
Obviously as retirement age and pre-tax contributions increase, so too will the age when funds run out. For a given
age, contributing the maximum pre-tax additional contributions will earn Tim an additional 4 to 6 years. Delaying
retirement by 5 years (from 65 to 70) will earn Tim an additional two to three years.
While retirement age and pre-tax additional contributions are choices Tim can make, many other factors will have
an impact on his retirement account. For example, the rate of inflation and the return on the pre-retirement funds are
variables that Tim cannot directly control. The following table and chart below show the impact of these factors on
the age when funds run out.
10 - 34
Solution Manual for Business Analytics, 4th Edition, Jeffrey D. Camm, James J. Cochran, Mich
Spreadsheet Models
110
Pre-Retirement Return
Age whenFunds Run Out
100
0
90 0.01
0.02
80
0.03
70 0.04
0.05
60
0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1
Inflation
As the chart shows, even moderate inflation can have a major impact on how long the fund lasts after retirement.
Contributing more or strong returns can help mitigate the impact of inflation.
10 - 35