Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Solar Commission Report
Solar Commission Report
CCIMMISSION REPO&T
BY
IIONI'BI.E MR. JUSTICE 6. SIVABAJAN (RETD.)
Voruue r
VOLUME No. I
PREFACE I
ACKNOWT,EDGMENTS V
I PRELIMINARY 1
REFERENCE
I
OF REFERENCE I
I
19.07.20L3- ANATYSTS
I
C. CCTV 315
CONTENTS
VOLUME No. II
XVI .
rTEM NO.4 OE THE TERMS OE
742
REFERENCE
RECOMMENDATTONS
XVIIT. 845
PREFACE
ry
Ministers, MLAs, MPs and seweral Political Leaders
hy
vlt
ry
vIt
v
IX
ry
X
v
1
PREMILINARY
wy
3
ry
5
ry
6
ry
1
ny
8
ry
9
W,
10
examined.
3. Two UDF MPs frorn Kerala and MLAs both UDE and
ry
11
Yy
t2
SOI,AR SCAM
Y
h
13
ry
l4
Yy
15
v
15
W
17
\vy
18
Yy
19
on.
v
effi-ciently.
23
W
24
ry
25
W
26
as referred above?
ry
27
- 1 (one)
5. Court Officer
1 (one)
6. Peons 2 (two)
, . 9LLYEL i (one)
8. Part Time Sweeper 1 (one)
The Courmission is given the power to make
Government Service.
ry
proposal regarding the requirements such as
w
29
W
31
1. Pr j-wate Secretary
(In the grade of Senior Stenographer)
-1
2. Personal Peon
3. Accountant (Gazetted Cadre)
1
4. Court Officer (Gazetted Cadre)
1
v
34
hyz
35
h,$
35
ky
31
?r,*
business man at Pathanamthitta. In al]. these
dealings, according to hirn, important political
personalities ineluding the Hon'bIe Chief
Mini-ster of the State are involved which can be
brought to 1i9ht if the petitioner is given an
Wy
39
W
40
W
4t
v
42
t
44
lW
45
W
46
Itvz
47
17tn, 19th and 20th of ,June and 8th and 9th of ,fu1y
ry
49
W
50
W
52
v
statements filed by the parties and found it
53
their own.
ry
54
reference.
v
2016 as CII l and Exts.X 797 to 800 were marked.
55
Sri.T.C.Mathew, a businessman at
Thiruvananthpuram was examined as CW 7 on 16-01-
56
vo1 .I PP 274-2801 .
W
58
v
Chronicle was examined as CW 69 on 28-07-20L5 in
59
9,y
60
w
61
Vo1.V PP 726-2sO)
were examined.
Sri. Sandeep was examined as Cw 45 on 25-05-
20tS & 30-11-2015 (DW VoI .V- PP L-1-1 and Dw
t
62
Vol.xII- PP 269-2881
Parties A to F impleaded were also examined.
Adwocate Sri. B.K. Guruprasad- A Party was examined
as CW 26 on 10-03-2015 and Ext. X87 to X89 marked
(DW VoI .III- PP 33-51),' Sri. Isaac Varghese, the
B Party was exannined as CW 27 on 12-3-2015and
W
63
w
64
2'7 4-283)
ey,
65
Vo1. VI PP 155-172)
W
65
f
67
rrr- PP 18-32).
ff^r
68
XXII PP 25 8s).
()
70
eV
77
102-L37l .
ry
73
examined as Cw 91.
W
74
105.
examined as CW 118.
W
16
W
77
to 195.
ty
18
!97 to 2O2.
W
79
ry
80
PY/
81
ay
83
longer retrievable' .
that basis. He did not ask them nor did they tel1
him the details of the subscribers of those
ry
84
v
85
Y
86
c].arifications.
eV
87
He further said.
lry,
88
hy
90
-A 1100.
She said.
q
92
W
93
9) Sri.Adoor Prakash
10) Sri . K. C.Venugopal , M. P.
11)Sri.Shibu Baby John
12) Sri . S . B. Sarma, P. S . to the Minister
Sri. Shibu Baby John
1 3 ) Sri . AryadarrMuhammed
18)Adv.P. Nazaru1la
19) Sri. Pratheeshkumar, Addl . P.S.
to Houre Minister
The notices and the reply thereto received
al:e compiled in book form under the capt5-on 'Book
w
95
W
96
heard in detail .
v
97
vy
100
W
101
\y
102
I
103
transparent manner ,
W
104
was on 2 9th.
W
105
ry
107
follows:
"The Chief Minister, his office, his personal
assistants, his personal security office, cJ.ose
w
108
W
109
v
directed.
110
0
v
111
V
112
ry
113
one dishonoured.
I
1,1,4
ry
115
!y
116
[y.
120
Nair.
c
721
the next day and that she cErme along with her
personal staff in the C.M's office and handed
ry
723
ry
1,26
ry
727
ry
128
ry
129
W
130
W
131
Iry
t32
!y
It is an admitted position that
Saritha S Nair had very good contacts
with Tenny Joppan and .Tikkumon Jacob. The
ry
134
v
135
W
136
hy
731
)y
138
W
139
Chandy.
60).
W
L4l
]
742
v
Mohamned. In the representation su-bmi-tted
143
ry
1,44
)v''+
145
tuy
146
v
747
ry
148
vr{-
749
a
v
150
Yw
151
vv
752
vh{L_
153
qv
154
ery
155
h,
757
ry
158
v
V
159
corrected.
v
Y
150
v
v
161
v
162
ry
163
hy
164
try
165
Saritha.
ry
155
ty
167
try
168
In{-
169
t
110
ty
After attending the function in the Vig'yan
Bhavan he along with Planning Minister
Sri.K.C.Joseph carne out to catch the 5.30 flight
to Thiruvananthapurarn and proceeded to the !oad.
It took some time for the car to come. He spoke
minute.
ry
712
ry
773
w
114
registered.
ry
175
ey
1,7 6
taken.
ry
180
Association.
9w,
,,/
182
?Y
183
ry
784
accused . "
LY,,
185
fol]-ows:
The main allegations with respect to which
inquiry is ordered hawe already been stated
supra. The details contained in the said
tetter according to the petitioner and other
parties are also stated. If, as a matter of
fact, the averments rnade by the petitioner
hy
186
Vry
1,87
v
188
ry
189
ry
190
ry
191
sti1J- pendj.ng.
w
L92
?Y
193
Ey
194
vY
195
Assernbly as follows:
q'n+.,.
L,/
196
qtv
198
|,W,
,
,,/
199
ry
200
ry
201,
ry
1n)
%ry.
I/"
203
+ry
204
as misunderstood.
ry
205
Py
206
t
Y
207
Nine Lakhs.
yty
208
ry
209
h*z
277
I
ry
21,2
ty
213
only 4 pages.
W
21,5
C.M. on twice.
Sri.Oommen Chandy .
9y
216
Sri.P.S.Sreekumaran, g].ves an
W
217
So1ar Company.
4) Sri.Biju Radhakrishnan, CEO of Team Solar
Company rneets the C.M. in the Government
Yy
218
f ,2
21,9
ry
220
| \>{z
227
t
v
223
ry
224
v
225
Y
226
Superintendent room.
ry
227
DE
1
He said, it perplexed him why Pheney
lg
229
L*,.
230
Pages.
cannot be mentioned.
Compilations.
ry
232
W)
original letter written by her itself is produced
before the Commission (Ext.X 639 (b) ) . The
lry
234
W
235
ry
236
lry
237
Iy
238
ltr,1,
240
may die even now for, she has the congress blood
no case against cheats. I{hen case is reqistered
against wilJ- he not become an accused in the
Mega Power Project cases. It is based on his
word Mega Project inwestors were brought. He
W
24L
where near what she got from the CM, Her money,
her body every thing lost and kept her now
W
242
cases.
wants them.
L
v
243
against them.
W
244
i',JL
245
W
246
(Jail) immediately.
4l Saritha's shifti-ng from Jail, one of
the reasons, is this letter, DGP (Jail) said.
5) Contrary to the instructions of the
DGP (Jai1) the Vanitha Jail Superintendent
permits a stranger to accompany Saritha's
mother wi-thout production of his
identification documents before preparing the
complaint.
W
247
ry
248
its contents.
lry
249
w
250
ry
257
ry
__--
252
ry
253
ry
254
Nair' .
ry
256
ry
257
other witnesses.
ry
258
ty,
259
ry
260
APPENDIX
ty
267
PY'h
This is not the first time that she is
cheated by people who she loved and believed. She
W
263
ry
264
him were there. Seeing her they were sent out and
CM came near to them and gave all sorts of
assurances (perumazha) to Sraedharan Nair. As per
ly
266
may die even now for, she has the cong,ress blood
l*,.
261
ry
268
v
269
n{\
270
Y
271,
v
272
ry
274
ry
275
ty
I
276
phone.
ry
271
W
Radhakrishnan, Sha1u and politici-ans. Remai-ns
Lvr+,
279
ry
280
against them.
sleedharan Nair
Direct and ta].ked.
(5) Then besides delay
Solar Po]-icy even not
done .
(7) sought 10t
couaission.
Result.
lw
281
Rose House,
LeMelidian. Kerala House.
Secretary)
11. I.G.K Padmakumar Sexua]. harassment Kaloor
Flat
Online cal.ls, telephone
sex .
ry
282
W
283
1
Seizure of CD from Coimbatore
w
285
Ieu
'/
287
w
289
w
290
?ry
297
W
I
____--
292
W,+,
293
ry
294
white key-chain.
5) MobiJ-e charger USB with connector one Ln
num-ber,
!pv
,,/
295
Park.
w
296
ry
297
!ry
298
ky
299
w
300
Pry
301
/ry
302
ry
303
W
304
{ry
305
v
307
wy
_---
308
Recommendations
w
309
t,
v
310
life imprisonment.
W
311
v
court,
312
tuy
313
W
314
prisoners ?
w
315
ccTv
The main allegations which are the subject
matter of item 1 of the terrns of reference,
settled, centres round the office of the Chief
Minister. Allegations are to the effect that
Smt.Saritha S.Nai! was a regular visitor in the
office of the Chief Minister. The complainant 1n
ug
316
W
311
g e (o 6oJ o'l
9j rorg o1 a c o'l a a c col'l ,1J o c cD 6fie oY Go o;
w
)11
o rru 1e g o'1 o cor gloa -o{ a CI er @J gg "d ^61 eofl rn'l cor rD
o-fl
w
322
Y
323
w
32s
v
326
W
327
ry
328
monitored.
Py,
331
{ry
There is no existing system of 74 days
ry
333
ry
recovering the data by way of wisual or documents
retrieved.
v
338
W
341
krtu,
-r'
342
W
343
W
344
ry
345
therefor.
346
ry
341
avoided.