Definition of

Pattern Code Meaning of Code 1

Pattern
Articles that define and differentiate or
give historical background on either the
CONCEPTUAL open source phenomenon in general or
OSS Descriptive
: Articles on one (or more) of exemplary open
combined under source applications (such as
this pattern LinuxOperating System)
provide a OSS Articles that talk about various technical
Benefits of OSS
descriptive Benefits/Drawba and non-technical benefits or drawbacks
Adoption (S7)
account of OSS, cks and risks of using open source software.
talk about its
potential and Articles examining the future role and How OSS
realized OSS power of OSS that provide a glimpse of Knowledge will
advantages and Vision/RoadMap and/or future predictions about where evolve in future
Categorization
disadvantages, OSS is heading. (S12)
Conceptual of Methods,
compare OSS OSS Research Articles that categorize OSR, create Tools,
with proprietary Categorization/ frameworksArticles to
thatorganize
compare research
OSS with efforts,Techniques,
software, and Research and/or
proprietarypropose
software
research
fromagendas/models
both process Approaches of
attempt to Agenda to
and
guide
product
and shape
perspectives.
future OSR.
Such Interaction
provide comparisons include feature, attribute, design of OSS
categorizations design structure, or overall process Difference
(S2) in
and models of OSS Versus
comparisons as well as elaborations on evolution of OSS
existing research Proprietary
competitive factors, risk, legal, and Vs CSS (S10)
as well as financial
Articlesaspects.
in this category
Proprietary
propose
in this Business model
agendas to shape Business/
economic
sense sometimes
models tomeans
explaintraditional
OSS, devise with Open
future research Economic
software
business development
models to explore
practices
how orOSSsimply
can Source in
efforts. Models and
be taken advantage closed of, and/or talk about
source. Commerical
Strategies/Polici This category covers studies on various
firm or nation level strategies and Organization
es of OSS aspects of software quality including
policies involving OSS. (S15)
performance,reliability, adaptability,
flexibility, maintainability, usability, and
functionality. While some articles
investigate potential relationships
between development process,
Articles in this category represent a
methodology and ideology, and quality,
subset of software quality. Specifically, Predicting OSS
Software Quality others look at how quality factors are
studies in this category focus on defect (S8)
linked to OSS adoption and utilization.
handling and bug fixing processes within
Key components of high quality OSS
OSS teams. Some articles focus on
delivery are assessed and quality of OSS
Software performance (defined as the ratio of Defect
PERFORMANC applications are compared to those of
Quality-Testing submitted bugs to resolved ones) whereas Prediction in
E METRICS: Articles in this
proprietary category represent
applications on differenta
and Bug Fixes some others zoom in on the bug fixing OSS (S8)
This pattern subset
levels. of software
Some articles quality
talk aboutwithOSS
a
process and practices as an indication of
groups articles particular focus tools
quality on security.
in The
underlying social patterns or as a OSS Security in
that investigate Software dilemma surrounding general.public disclosure
surrogate for organizational learning. OSS
quality aspects Quality-OSS of vulnerabilities is discussed and the
OSS bug tracking tools are evaluated Development
and efficiencies Security security
Articlesofin
OSSthisapplications
category evaluate
is evaluated
the
Performance against proprietary ones. (S4)
of OSS, efficiencies
and compared of open
withsource
that ofcreation
proprietary
and
Metrics Software provide
systems.comparisons
The rationaleoffor structure
OSS useand in
performance of
OSS Development- security
relativeappliances
performance is elaborated
of OSS and on.
development OSS Code proprietary projects. While this category
teams and Efficiencies is inextricably linked to overall quality, it
determinants of only covers certain aspects of quality
success for OSS such as maintainability.
projects.
 quality aspects
and efficiencies
Performance
of OSS,
Metrics
performance of
OSS
development Factors
teams and Articles investigating factors that may
Effecting
determinants of affect developer performance,
Productivity of
success for OSS Development productivity, and creativity, and
Software
projects. Team contribute to the success of OSS
Development
Performance Studies in this category investigate
projects.Relationships between theone or
Teams in Open
many determinants
various of OSS success
project characteristics and
and team
Source Projects
the relationships
performance among
are explored.
them. Various
Success
(S60)
Factors
definitions of success as well as factors
OSS Success Affecting OSS
contributing to the success of OSS
(S22)
projects are evaluated. Aspects of OSS
projects that are considered as successful
Articles in this arecategory
looked at. investigate and
compare various OSS license types, their
terms and risks, as well as determinants
of license selection. The potential impacts
Articles in this category focus on
of license choice on development activity
intellectual property rights and issues
This pattern and on the success of the OSS project are Selection of OSS
OSS Licensing concerning OSS. Patents, trademarks,
hosts articles considered. Steps that can be taken to license (S45)
copyright, as well as ideological and
that talk about ensure license compliance and related
ethical aspects are considered. The
licensing of OSS infringement risks are deliberated.
relationship between intellectual
applications, Whether OSS type licensing can be
OSS Intellectual property rights and OSS
intellectual extended into other areas of technology is
Property Rights commercialization,
Articles assessingintellectual
legal issuesproperty
and
property rights discussed.
Legal and regimes
risks/uncertainties
and quality/stability
concerning of OSS,
OSS.and
and intellectualLegal
propertyand rights and
Regulatory
implications, affordability
ideological views
are explored.
on openPotential
source
various legal OSS Legal
ownership
impact andare effects
debated
of intellectual
and legal
issues, and the Issues
enforceability
Articles
property about
of OSS
protection OSS onterms
standards and licenses
the strength andand
importance/impl regulation.
are discussed.
direction ofThe The
differences
innovation needare forbetween
existingopen
law
investigated.
ications of standards
to extend and OSStangible
beyond are highlighted.
propertyTheto
standardization OSS Standards links between virtualopen standards
reality is voiced. and agility Certification
and regulation. and Regulation and OSS and regulation are investigated. (S40)
The potential effects of standards on
community evolution and OSS diffusion
This category covers articles that
are looked at.
examine the process of OSS development.
Various elements of the development
process that range from OSS
methodology and design structures to
Articles that look at the definitions of the
OSS architectures and work practices are OSS Interaction
community construct as well as the
Process assessed. Methods for determining Design Process
underlying social, cultural, and economic
developer responsibilities, (S2)
elements of OSS communities Sponsored Characteristics
selforganization of work, and a number
and autonomous communities are of the
of techniques (agile practices, extreme
differentiated and their norms, value Communities
Articles
programming examiningetc.) the
are formation
investigated. of OSS
The
Communities systems, and common practices are Developing
teamseffects
potential and how individuals
of process make
characteristics
investigated. Community governance the OSS of
decisions
on product about
quality
whatare teams
addressed.
to join.
structures as well as coordination Safety Critical
Strategies and processes by which new Barriers Faced
practices are assessed. The effect of Systems (S5)
people join are evaluated and by
community portals on collaboration and
Team Formation interactions between team members are NewCommers
Studies
the in this category
relationship between look at how
communities
investigated. Studies looking at the of OSS Projects
communities
and commercial producing
firms collective
are lookedgoods
at.
geographical location or network (S9)
govern
embeddedness of developers involved in
themselves. Various definitions of
OSS projects are also included in this OSS Ecosystem
Governance governance are investigated and
category. (S11)
dimensions
Articles thatand investigate
types of governance
individual and are
categorized.
project-level Community
factors leading hierarchies,
to the
conflict
emergence
management,
of project and leaders
decision
This pattern Team/Project among
making OSS
mechanisms
community areparticipants.
examined.
groups articles Leadership Studies that talk about the link between
that address skills of OSS leaders and its influence on
various aspects OSS success are also included in this
of the group.
production of
OSS
applications. It
covers a number
of input related
topics such as
developer
motivations and OSS Production
team formation,
 This pattern
groups articles
that address
various aspects Articles in this category are concerned
of the with individual and collective learning
production of Individual and
practices in OSS projects. Factors
OSS Team Learning
Articles that
affecting examine
learning the properties
process and adaptive of
applications. It OSS modemechanisms
learning of distributed areinnovation and
investigated.
covers a number look at the role of communities in
of input related creating, shaping, and disseminating Open Source
topics such as Innovation
innovations. The process of OSS Innovation (S44)
developer Studies
innovationin this
is category
explored examine
and the rolethe role
of
motivations and OSS Production of volunteer
online networking
users andindevelopers
the innovationin OSS
team formation, Role of This category looks at collaboration and Participation of
development process
and isanalyze
investigated.
the relationship
process topics Volunteer its role in creation and dissemination of women in OSS
between different actors in OSS
such as the Users/Developer knowledge. Knowledge-sharing activities Development
production. Both the determinants and
development s in OSS communities are compared with (S63)
results of volunteer involvement in OSS
process itself, those at traditional organizations, and
projects are investigated. Knowledge loss
and governance, Collaboration Articles in this
potential groupofinvestigate
benefits OSS stylethe
due to turnover
as well as a few and Knowledge dynamics that affect
collaboration the motivation
in organizations are of
in OS projects
output related Sharing discussed.
participants
Articles
in OSS
investigating
communities.the task
(S25)
topics such as Intrinsic
assignmentand and
extrinsic
workmotivations
allocation
learning and mechanismsincludingin personal
collaborative
attributes,
efforts and
User and Intrinsic
community Articles
attitudes,behavioral
ones assessing
focusingfactors
on corporations’
patterns,
affectingand
Developer motivations
evolution. jobrelated
motivations
collaboration
factors
to engage
are
and
included
how
in open
they
insource
this
affect
Motivations (S15)
development
individual developers’
endeavors.
category. Firm
selections
efforts
of in
commercialization
projects/project preferences
of OSS as well areas Software
Role of indirect effects evaluated.
on emergence of OSS Intensive
Commercial Implications
projects arefor assessed.
commercial Various
firms are Organization
Studies focusing on components-based
Corporations scenarios of firm participation including Adopting OSS
discussed.
development, code reuse, and
sponsored communities as well as code (S7)
modularity. Some of these articles assess
Software donations are discussed. Potential link Use of OSS code
potential effects of OSS component reuse
Development- between organizational sponsorship and in Development
on software development economics.
Use of OSS OSS success is investigated. of Safety Critical
Modularity comparisons between OSS
Components Systems (S5)
and proprietary software as well as
These studies look at the relationship
module quality evaluations among OSS
OSS Production- between characteristics of OSS
applications are also provided.
Role of licenses/intellectual propertyrights and
Licensing and IP levels of project participation, developer
activity,and project progress.
Self- Articles in this category examine the self- OSS Evolution
Organization organization process of OSS, its effects Prediction, co
(Product and on product and community evolution and evolution, and
Community how it is different from that of Community
Evolution) proprietary systems. evolution (S6)

Articles focusing on OSS applications for

Telecommunicat
the telecommunications industry, OSS Platforms
ions, Networking
wireless technologies, networking, and (S37)
and Architecture
systems architecture/infrastructure.
Articles focusing on OSS applications for
education such as course management
Use of FLOSS
and administrative systems, integrated
Education Projects in SE
learning environments, open access
Education (1)
learning repositories, and financial
Articles focusing on OSS applications for
systems for educational institutions.
Libraries, libraries, online archives, and
Archives, repositories. Known OSS database
Databases and applications are evaluated and their pros
Repositories and cons in relation to proprietary
alternatives are discussed.
 Content,
OSS Web
Information and Articles focusing on OSS applications for
Application
Knowledge web content or corporate information
Development
ManagementSys and knowledge management systems.
(S19)
tems
Imaging, Articles focusing on OSS applications for
Plotting and graphical manipulation, visual imaging
Visual and plotting.

Articles focusing on OSS applications for

Security and
computer/online security. The threat of
Cybercrime
cybercrime is discussed.
Articles focusing on OSS applications for
corporate supply chain management such
Supply chain as OSS enterprise resource planning and
management customer relationship management
and optimization systems,
Articleselectronic
focusing on data
OSS interchange
desktop and and
This pattern
operational
server operating
planningsystems
and optimization
or OSS
hosts a bundle of
components for applications.
those systems. Known
articles that Desktop and
OSS and widely used OSS operating systems OSS Platforms
focus on area or server operating
Applications such as Linux and FreeBSD (or various (S37)
discipline systems
distributions of such systems) are
specific OSS
evaluated in different contexts that tie to
applications.
other research categories.
Gaming and Articles focusing on OSS applications for
Simulations Articles computer
focusing
gaming
on OSS
and applications
simulations. for
the software development and
Articles
engineeringfocusing on OSS
industry, such applications
as various
Software that
openhelpsource
researchers
programming,
organizescripting,
and share Use of OSS in
Development digital modeling,
information
and markup
for research
languages;
purposes Safety Crtical
and Engineering website/application such as:
development and Systems (S5)
personalization;
• OSS citation document
object oriented
and webpage
software;
integrated management
development software,
environments,
Academic and
and
Articles
• virtualization
Collaborative
focusing on and
OSS
OSScluster
tools
applications
that
computing.
help for
Commerical
develop
biomedical newandresearch
healthapproaches
sciences research
such as
Research
OSS
and social
practice.
computing
Such applications
applications range
that
from
wouldlarge allowinfrastructural
the creation ofapplications
new research to
exchangecommunities,
biomedical information
and to
Biomedical and Use of OSS in
smaller
• OSS data scalegathering
informaticsandtools that tools
analysis allow
Health Sciences Dentistry (S30)
handling
for both qualitative
of large biomedical
and quantitative
datasets
Articles
such focusing
as genome ondatabases,
OSS applications
research. analyze for
business,
complex data,professional,
or allowor other social Critical Barriers
collaboration
Business,
among
sciences,biomedical
such as project,
and health
business process to adopting
researchers
Professional and
management andandpractitioners.
business intelligence OSBI Tools
Social Sciences
tools, accounting, statistics, and (S17)
economics applications.
Articles focusing on OSS applications for
natural sciences such as chemistry,
Natural Sciences
physics, GIS, astronomy, and
environmental sciences.
Articles focusing on OSS applications for
Public Sector
the public and the non-profit sector as
and E-
well as specific tools and applications for
Government
e-Government.
 Articles in this category explore key
drivers of OSS adoption as well as user
OSS Adoption- OSS Adoption
characteristics. Adoption and diffusion
General (S7)
models are investigated and illustrated
through case studies.
Studies in this category explore barriers
to OSS and reasons for rejection. OSS Adoption
OSS Adoption-
Strategies employed by commercial firms RIsks/Barriers/
Barriers
against the perceived threat of OSS are Challenges (S7)
Articles in this also covered. Open Source
pattern focus Articles that evaluate key factors in open Software
mainly on the OSS Adoption- source software adoption decisions and Evaluation,
technology Decision Factors investigating when, how, and why Selection, and
outputs of OSS barriers to adoption are overcome. Adoption
development OSS Diffusion Studies in this category explore Factors(S47)
process and OSS implications of using open source
address various Articles that elaborate on the importance
Implementation- software in a project. Implementation
aspects of OSS of user support community groups both
General challenges arediscussed and lessons
adoption and for implementation and for longterm
learned listed
implementation. OSS viability of OSS. Implications for
Implementation- commercial firms aiming to use OSS in
Implementation hybrid form are discussed. Some articles
Communities in this category investigate the role of
and Networks Studies that explore
collaborative business thenetworks
roles playedin OSSand
OSS contributions
implementation. made by Focus
governments
on both to
Implementation- commercial OSS initiatives
and nonprofit during networks
the are
Governments/Na implementation possible.
process. Nonprofit
tions organizations are also included in this
category
Studies in this category investigate how
various OSS approaches can influence
non software areas. These studies look at
wider socio-political effects of OSS and
see OSS as a broader icon for openness
Articles that focus on the concept of open
and collaboration and key to
innovation, that is, investment of Inner source
Open Paradigm understanding future forms of
This important resources by individuals/firms to create (S7)
organizations. The primary focus is
pattern groups public goods innovations. Some studies
Articles
placed on in benefits
this category
that caninvestigate
be derived the
articles that look at costs and benefits of open
frompossibility of the use ofand
the OSS philosophy OSS style
translation
explore innovation while others explore potential Open Innovation
knowledge
of OSS exchange
approaches in to
other
corporate
industries
implications of Open Innovation replication of this model in other in Field of RE
management
and use of that OSS emulate
principles OSSforstyle
moreand
OSS over and industries. The main focus is on the open (S35)
effective governance
knowledgepractices.
acquisition and
beyond the and distributed nature of innovation, role
augmentation of current knowledge
software ofcommunities and nonproprietary
Open management practices. Some studies
development networking during the innovation
Knowledge Studies focus
in this
on structure
category exploring
assess linkages
domain. In process as well as its theoretical and
Flows between
collaborative
open standards,
structures proprietary
for knowledge and
general, these managerial implications.
Beyond Software OSS exchange
developmentwhile some
and argueothersthat
track
open
categories source is one
direction (but not theflows
of knowledge only)among
way to
investigate the enforce
Articles
projectsand that exploit
investigate
throughout open
socialthe
standards.
possibility
networks Some
andof
possibility of the Open Standards
aarticles
new model
consider theirof
approach education
impactopen based success
onstandards
project onasthe
a
applicability of OSS or movement.
businesson the
strategy OSS
overallwhereasis discussed
transparency
some othersas it
of
OSS style relates to
develop educational
a pragmatic
governance platforms,
concern an
for the
organization and importance
efficacy of ofopen
opensource
standards education
for long-
work practices Open Education software
term access
is assessed.
to information.
Some articles
to other domains Studies propose
in this thecategory
OSS modelelaborate
as an on how
and their opportunity
OSS changes to revolutionize
the traditionally future
implications for User or Co-
administrative
hierarchicalsystems
power and whilecontrol
some others
of
users. production of
look
producers
at known by moving
cases offromopenconsumer
education
goods and
towards
such as a co-producer
MIT’s OpenCourseWare.
perspective and
consumer
its implications for producers. Evolution
implications
of corporate brands from closed to open
brands are discussed.
 2 3 4 5 6 7

Major
Difficulties and
Benefits and Benefits and
key challenges of
Challenges of Challenges of
Using OS in
Innersource Innersource
Computer
(S43) (S51)
Science
Education (S21)

Categorization
of Security
State of the Art
Areas, Socio Classification
State of the Art Categorization on Predicting
Technical State of the Art Framework of
of Empirical of OSS Safety OSS Projects
Advantages of Aspects, OSS Evolution how
Research in OSS Critical Domains both Code and
using OS in Knowledge Difference (S6) Organization
(S3) (S5) Strategies Community
Computer Problemes and between Adopt OSS (S7)
adopted by Dimension
Distinguishing
(S8)
Science Reconciliation
their of
Resolutions knowledge Certification of
practitioners to Factors between
Education as OSS(S4)
with Plan management, OSS Vs Closed
implement FLOSS and
Compared to Driven and Agile loss and sharing Source Projects
frequenct Properitory
Reconciliation
Traditional (S23) of OSS VS Strategies (S40)
releases in OSS Software (S41)
strategies have
Educational proparitary adopted by
Knowledge projects (S28)
been
Approaches
adopted by Commercial (S25) practitioners to
Retention
organizations
(S21) or OSS Business implement
Strategies in
communities and model (S24) frequenct
OSS (S25)
their results releases in OSS
(S23) projects (S28)
Characteristics/
Aspects,
Structure,
Matrix and
development,vali Usability Factors
Quality Model Aspects of
OSS Quality dation,usage and that affect OSS
for Assessing OSS Quality Usability
Assessment Quality of Aceptability and
Quality of OSS (S38) Evaluation of
Models (S31) Quality Sustainability
Ecosystem (S32) Ecommerce
Evaluation (S67)
Website (S62)
Bug Report Models/Framew
Severity Level ork for OSS
Prediction in (S61)
OSS (S52)
OSS Success and
Quality (S38)

Approaches,
Datasets,
OSS Software Implement Open Source
Effort Maintenance Techniques, and
Development frequenct Software
Estimation Effort Variables of
Process and releases in OSS Development
(S19) Estimation (S20) Maintenance
Activities (S16) projects (S28) Process (S48) Understanding
Company Effort
Organizations community
Participation in Effect of Quality model Estimation (S66)
Participation in participation
OSS OSS knowledge loss for assessing
OSS and engagement
Ecosystem[ (S11) Development on community quality of OSS
Communities in open source
Communities (S25) Ecosystem (S32)
(S7) software
(S15)
Open Source Projects (S50)
Team Structure
and Evolution
(S65)
set of measures
to evaluate
aspects of OSS
ecosystem (S32)
Open Innovation
in SE (S74)
Power Relations
of OSSEco and
its Impact on
Developers,
Artifacts and
Relationship
within
Ecosystem (S70)

OSS Developers'
Management Forking
Women
(Developer Contributors Motivations of Motivation Motivation
motivation in
Attraction, Motivations developers and Factors of OSS Interpretation,
joining OSS
Retention and (S25) scientists (S44) (S45) Categories and
projects (S53)
Commitment) Consequences
How
(S18) Set of measures (S57)
Commercial
OSS to evaluate
Organizations
Ecosystem[ (S11) aspects of OSS
Introduce OSS
ecosystem (S32)
Open(S15)
source as
Part of
Integrating OSS
Component
in Software
Based Software
Systems (S7)
Engineering
(S15)

A Software
Architecture
OSS Evolution
OSS Evolution Degradation in
Prediction, Co Software Organization
Process Support Open Source
Evolution, and Evolvability and Community
and Prediction Software: A
Community (S13) Evolution (S39)
(S29) Systematic
Evolution (S10)
Literature
Review (S46)

Open IoT
platform (S56)

Use of OS in Students
Use of FLOSS
Computer Using OSS in CS Perception of
Projects in SE
Science Education (S51) OSS literature
Education (33)
Education (21) (S59)
GIS and Web
Software (S27)

OSS
Development,
Practices,
Project
Management
with GitHub
(S68)

Usage/
Challenges/
Utilization of
Utilization of Issues/
Open Source
OSS in Health Oppertunites of
Innovation in
Record System OSS for
Drug Discovery
(S34) Assistive
(S44)
Technologies
(S64)
 Open Source
Software Open Source
OSS Adoption OSS Adoption
Evaluation, Adoption
(S14) (S15)
Legal, Technical
Selection, and Factors (S49)
Critical Barriers and (S47)
Adoption
that Prevent Organizational
Risk Factors in Adoption
Organizations Risk in OSS
OSS Adoption Barriers of OSS
from Adopting Adoption and
(S14) (S41)
Open Source BI Risk Analysis
Tools (S17) Techniques
Success Factors
Open Source (S36)
in Adopting/
Adoption
adapting OSS
Factors (S49)
(S55)

Inner Source
Benefits and Software
Innersource Open design Challenges of Development
(S15) (S26) Innersource (Benefits and
(S43) Challenges)
Open and (S54)
Open Innovation Collaborative
Open Innovation
for Industry 4.0 Innovation of
Failures (S72)
(S69) Electricity
Sector (S73)
 8 9 10 11 12 13

Categorization
Categorization of Maintenance
State of the Art State of the Art State of the Art Categorization
of Barriers of Effort
OSS of OSS of OSS of OSS
New commers Estimation
Evolution[ (S10) Ecosystem (S11) Knowledge (S12) Evolution (S13)
(S9) Techniques
Relation of OSS (S20)
with Agile
Software
Development
(S42)
 Techniques,
Accuracy
Criteria,
Validation
Method, Tools,
Dataset of OSS
Power Relations
Maintenance
Attributes of
of OSSEco and
Effort
OSS Community
its Impact on
Estimation
Communites (S71)
to Aspect of
Developers,
measure Health Software
Artifacts and
and Success of Development
Relationship
OSS (S68)
within
Project(S65)
Ecosystem (S70)
 Impact of
sentiments
Participation of
of programmers
women in OSS
in open source
Development
software
(S63)
projects and
artifacts (S58)
 14 15 16 17 18 19

State of the Art

and
Categorization
Categorization
Categorization of Knowledge State of the Art
Categorization of Quality
of Reconciliation Creation, in OSS
of Characteristics, State of the Art
Approaches, Knowledge Evolution
Characteristics Methods, of Risk Analysis
Strategies,Propo Sharing,Knowle Research to
of COSS Domains of of OSS Adoption
sals, Challenges, dge Support OSS
Business Model Quality (S36)
Opportunites, Management Evolution
(S24) Assessment
Models (S23) Activities, Process (S29)
Models (S31)
Knowledge Loss
and Mitigation
Strategies (S25)
 Mapping with Taxonomy

20 21 22 23 24 25

Categorization
of Facets, Categorization State of the Art
Categorization State of the Art
Approaches, of Key Issues of and Proposed
of research in Framework for in Inner Source
Metrics, Certification and Solution of
area of Quality FLOSS Software
Datasets, State of the Art Architectural
and success Adoption (S41) Development
Domains etc of and Solutions Degradation
(S38) (S43)
OSS evolution (S40) (S46)
(S39)
 26 27 28 29 30 31

State of the Art

Categorization
of OSS State of the Art
of OSS State of the Art Categorization
development on Bug Report
Evaluation, of Community of Benefits and
Process and Categorization Severity
Selection, and dynamics in Challenges For
Categorization of Adoption Prediction and
Adoption Open Source Use of OSS in
of OSS process Factors (S49) Categorization
Models Software Computer
Activities of Features etc
and Factors Projects (S50) Education (S51)
Characteristics (S52)
(S47)
(S48)
 32 33 34 35 36 37

Categorization Categorization
of Open Source of Factors
Categorization
Developers' Categorization Affecting
Categorization of Success
Categorization Forking of Impacts of Software
of Inner Source Factors for
of IoT Platforms Motivational Sentiments on Development
Software Open Source
and Opennness Behaviour, Software Productivity in
Development Software
Types (S56) Forking Practices and Software
(S54) Development
Methodologies Artifacts (S58) Development
(S55)
and Aspects of and OS Projects
Forking (S57) (S60)
 38 39 40 41 42 43

Categorization Categorization
of Quality Categorization of Approaches, Categorization
Taxonomy of
Evaluation of Women Datasets, of Research of
OSS Teams Research in
Models/Framew Participation in Categorization
Techniques, and
Area of Usability
Open Source
orks of OSS OSS Variables of Development
(S65) of Sustainable
(S61) Development Maintenance with GitHub
OSS (S67)
(S63) Effort (S68)
Estimation (S66)
 44 45 46 47

Categorization
1
of Techniques,
Accuracy
Categorization Criteria,
Categorization Categorization
of Power Validation
of Open of Open
Relation Method, Tools, 47
Innovation Innovation
dynamics in OSS Dataset of OSS
Failures (S72) Research (S74)
Ecosystem (S70) Maintenance
Effort
Estimation (S71)
8

65

0
1

13

10

0
0

49

0
2

17
5

13

0
 9

Total 168