Professional Documents
Culture Documents
HECRASMODELPAPER
HECRASMODELPAPER
net/publication/305391998
CITATIONS READS
10 588
3 authors:
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Ismail Mondal on 28 December 2017.
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Abstract The physically-based hydrodynamic model can silt accumulated has been estimated 277,589.92 m3. The
simulate the water flow dynamics of a stream network rate of sedimentation was then calculated and found to be
against time varying boundary conditions that can be 16,328.82 m3/month silt deposition during monsoon and
implemented for the case of Ichamati River. Such river 11,109 m3 silt deposition during non monsoon period. It
models are often an important component of flood fore- may be concluded that out of 6 % annual silt deposition,
casting, tidal fluctuation system that forecasts river levels 5 % silt deposition took place during the month between
in flood prone regions of the middle stream of Ichamati June and October and 1 % silt deposition during the month
river. The measurements of river bed depth/slope, water between November and May. Silt excavation along 20 km
quality (river cross section), floodplain mapping and stretch of Ichamati river showed distinct rejuvenation of
boundary condition flow are essential for the set up of a the river stretch. The program of silt excavation along other
river model. But one can use proxy approaches relying stretches of river Ichamati study area would certainly bring
mostly on remote sensing data from space platforms for the positive impact on the river ecology and environment.
purpose. In this study, we set up the one dimensional river Ecological flow needs to be maintained in rivers in the
analysis system (RAS) model of the hydrologic engineer- upstream due to chocking the silt deposition. Ecological
ing center (HEC) over the stream network of the Ichamati flow in Ichamati river is absent in many stretches of the
river basins. Good quality in situ measurements of river river due to heavy silt deposition.
hydraulics (cross section, slope, flow) were available only
for the upstream and middle stream flood prone region of Keywords Hydrodynamic modeling HEC-RAS Remote
the basin. The de-siltation of the stretch of Ichamati river sensing Hydraulic simulation Nonlinear unsteady flow
under survey i.e. middle part showed impacts which were
positive in ways more than one. The river velocity in the
top strata is 0.3 m/s from model and the river regained its Introduction
ecological flow. Also, the increased salinity of the river
helped in cultivation of different species of fishes, which In the eastern side of the Bhagirathi/Hooghly River the
are socio economically relevant in the adjoining areas. Due only major river is the Ichamati river which is a link
to the increased capacity of the channel in the middle part between the ‘Nadia group of rivers’ (viz. Jalangi,
possibility of flood has also decreased. The total volume of Mathabhanga, Churni etc.) in the north and Sundarban in
the south (Chakravarti 1938; Mondal and Bandyopadhyay
2014b). The Ichamati river, a spill channel of Mathab-
& Ismail Mondal hanaga river, originating from Majdia (krishnaganj Block)
ismailmondal58@gmail.com
Nadia district, India and Bangladesh (for a short distance)
1
Department of Remote Sensing and GIS, Vidyasagar enters into the 24 Parganas (north) district at Bagdah block
University, Paschim, Medinipur 721102, India subsequently, the Ichamati river flowing through eastern
2
Department of Geography and Environment Management, part of the 24 Parganas (north and south) districts ulti-
Vidyasagar University, Paschim, Medinipur 721102, India mately debouches in the Raimangal river vis-a-vis the bay
123
125 Page 2 of 13 Model. Earth Syst. Environ. (2016)2:125
of Bengal. The Ichamati river could be subdivided into two Parganas District in West Bengal, its eastern side has
segments on the basis of the river morphology. international border with Indo-Bangladesh, Nadia District
situated on west, and northern side has Bagdah block and
Upper stretch also southern side bounded by Gaighata block. The study
areas covered maximum portion of the Ichamati river
Brand off point from Mathabhanaga river at Majdia, channel. So this area are connected India and Bangladesh
Krishnaganj Block, Nadia District and beri/Swarupnagar, by NH 35 and road is called Jassore Road which built up
24 Parganas (N) district. In this stretch the river is mori- by King Saharsa and Eastern Railway connected by
bund in nature with high sinuosity and serpentine meanders Sealdah to Bangaon.
exhibiting numerous abandoned scrolls/oxbow lakes. In
this part, the river is practically not receiving any upland
flow excepting in rainy season. (Mondal and Bandyopad- Aim
hyay 2014a, b, c; Mondal and Satpati 2012).
To identify the Morphodynamic change of Ichamati River
Lower segment by HEC RAS Model.
123
Model. Earth Syst. Environ. (2016)2:125 Page 3 of 13 125
time with the development of the deltas of the peninsular alignment of the present N-S straight course of the
rivers (viz. Mayurakshi, Ajay, Damodar) coupled with Damodar river (further downstream of the Bhagirathi river)
neotectonic activities. Thus a narrow strip of low laying which may be considered as a mega lineament and with all
land (Younger Alluvial Plain) developed in the western probability, this was the ancient course of the Ganga river
side of the Bhagirathi–Hooghly river bording older Allu- any time before 800 A.D. Roy 1952) (Fig. 2).
vial Plain. The N-S alignment of the low marshy lands Serpentine (scroll) meandering zone of the Bhagirathi
(with reasonal water bodies/wet lands, meander scars, cut- river between-Samudragarh–Dhatrigram stretch, Burdwan
off meanders), ‘bils/jhils’ in the western part of the present (Barddhaman) district and adjacent part of Nadia district
Bhagirathi river in the Alluvial upland are in the same may be:
123
125 Page 4 of 13 Model. Earth Syst. Environ. (2016)2:125
1. Reflection in the change in riverine discharge and tidal ultimately debouches in the Raimangal river vis-a-vis the
flow of Hooghly river. bay of Bengal. The Ichamati river could be subdivided into
2. Surface expression of normal fault running through the two segments on the basis of the river morphology (Fig. 3).
Burdwan–Debgram–Jalangi area (cf. Sengupta 1966,
refer Chapter II).
What is a hydrodynamic model
123
Model. Earth Syst. Environ. (2016)2:125 Page 5 of 13 125
Channel hydraulics energy equation: Hydraulic analysis of Ichamati river by HEC RAC
V22 V12 model
Z2 þ Y2 þ a2 ¼ Z1þ Y1 þ a1 þ he
2g 2g
Water surface profile
Continuity equation:
V2 A2 ¼ V1 A1 The Ichamati river water surface profiles are computed for a
variety of technical uses like tidal fluctuation and rain water
Z: elevation bottom of the channel, Y: elevation of the during the monsoon season. Profiles are computed for flood
water surface, V: flow velocity, a: coefficient, g: gravity, insurance studies, flood hazard mitigation investigations,
he: head losses, A: area of cross section. other similar design needs. The water surface profile for the
123
125 Page 6 of 13 Model. Earth Syst. Environ. (2016)2:125
Fig. 5 General profile plot— ICHAMAT I RIVE R Plan: P lan 02 7/29/2015 1:02:35 PM
velocities
Geom: hec final Flow:
Ichamti 1
6
Vel Left (m/s), Vel Chnl (m/s), Vel Right (m/s)
Legend
5
Vel Chnl PF 11
4 Vel Chnl PF 1
Vel Left PF 11
3
Vel Right PF 11
2
Vel Left PF 1
1 Vel Right PF 1
0
0 5000 10000 15000 20000
123
Model. Earth Syst. Environ. (2016)2:125 Page 7 of 13 125
1 0.55 0.15 0.01 0.16 0.00 0.72 0.03 0.75 1.16 1.06
2 0.66 0.26 0.04 0.29 0.00 1.72 0.11 1.83 1.28 1.09
3 0.76 0.36 0.07 0.43 0.00 3.03 0.27 3.30 1.39 1.12
4 0.86 0.46 0.12 0.58 0.00 4.62 0.53 5.16 1.50 1.15
5 0.97 0.57 0.17 0.74 0.00 6.47 0.91 7.39 1.61 1.18
6 1.07 0.67 0.24 0.91 0.00 8.56 1.43 9.99 1.72 1.21
7 1.18 0 77 0.32 1.10 0.00 10.9 2.1 13.0 1.83 1.23
8 1.28 0.88 0.41 1.29 0.00 13.4 2.9 16.3 1.94 1.26
9 1.38 0.98 0.52 1.50 0.00 16.2 3.9 20.1 2.06 1.28
10 1.49 1.09 0.G3 1.72 0.00 19.1 5.2 24.3 2.17 1.30
11 1.59 1.19 0.76 1.95 0.00 22.2 6.6 28.8 2.28 1.31
12 1.70 1.29 0.90 2.19 0.00 25.6 8.2 33.8 2.39 1.33
12 1.80 1.40 1.05 2.44 0.00 29.1 10.1 39.2 2.50 1.35
14 1.90 1.50 1.21 2.71 0.00 32.7 12.2 45.0 2.61 1.36
15 2.01 1.60 1.38 2.99 0.00 36.6 14.6 51.2 2.72 1.38
16 2.11 1.71 1.56 3.27 0.00 40.6 17.2 57.9 2.77 1.39
17 2.22 1.81 1.75 3.56 0.00 44.8 20.1 64.9 2.82 1.40
18 2.32 1.91 1.94 3.85 0.00 49.2 23.0 72.2 2.86 1.41
19 2.42 2.02 2.13 4.15 0.00 53.7 26.1 79.8 2.91 1.43
20 2.53 2.12 2.34 4.46 0.00 58.4 29.4 87.7 2.96 1.44
Hydrograph analysis tidal fluctuation. The tide speed is only slightly slower than
the observed and the tide peak is comparable in magnitude
Perennial streams, or streams that flow continuously to that obtained with both other models. Table 3 presents a
throughout the year, are most likely to be fed by ground- comparison of the percent error in peak discharge calcu-
water. These streams contain a base flow component and lated using
are candidates for a hydrograph separation method. The calculated peak discharge observed peak discharge
Ichamati River hydrograph separation method has its basis observed peak discharge
in the physical world. Figure 8 and Table 1 is a stream flow 100
hydrograph that illustrates various rainfall pathways into a
stream. Channel interception or rainfall that falls directly These results are quite promising when one considers
on the stream is represented by the blue curve (Herschy that, the model both hydraulic models are uncalibrated and
1999). Overland flow is represented by the green curve. the channel shape has been approximated as a simple
Subsurface flow or precipitation that infiltrates the land rectangle over the majority of the routing domain (i.e., with
surface yet arrives at the stream in a short time is the major no consideration of floodplain geometry). Of particular
curve, and the base flow or groundwater component that interest are the results at two Points, downstream of the
enters the stream curve (Herschy 1999). All of these lower reach. Despite the crude geometry approximation
components add together to form the shape of the stream employed for the HEC-RAS model (U.S. Corps of Engi-
flow hydrograph. neers 2002) it still approximates the tide speed slightly
better than the model.
Discharge hydrographs of Ichamati river Its over-attenuation of the flood peak magnitude can be
attributed to the need to use 0 of 8 m to ensure solution
Figures 6, 7 and 8 and Tables 1, 2 and 3 shows the output stability.
discharge hydrographs obtained from the various models of Employing larger values would increase this effect,
Ichamati River at Kalanchi and Ramnagar Point, in com- decreasing accuracy further. A value of 0 to 8 m would
parison to the measured data for this event. As the fig- likely lead to solution instability (which is why the user is
ures of the river particularly upstream of the Ramnagar to not allowed this option) (U.S. Corps of Engineers 2002;
lower stream of Kalanchi river geometry approximation the Taggart 1995).
123
125 Page 8 of 13 Model. Earth Syst. Environ. (2016)2:125
Fig. 6 General profile plot— ICHAMAT I RIVE R Plan: P lan 02 7/29/2015 1:02:35 PM
20 Hydr Depth R PF 1
Hydr Depth L PF 1
15 Hydr Depth R PF 11
Hydr Depth L PF 11
10
Hydr Depth C PF 1
5 Hydr Depth C PF 11
0
0 5000 10000 15000 20000
Main Channel Distance (m)
Property Table
RS = 11
3.0
Legend
Area Chan
2.5 Area Overbanks
Total Area
Conv. Overbanks
Elevation (m)
Conv. Total
1.5
Storage Area
Top Width
1.0
0.5
0.0
0 1 2 3 4 5
Bed shear stress of Ichamati river shows the river depth below the water surface measured
after incorporating the reduced level. The sectional flow in
Provides an index of fluid force per unit area on the stream the next column is calculated using area-velocity method.
bed, which has been related to sediment mobilization and The average bed slope of the channel in this 20 km stretch
transport in many theoretical and empirical treatments of of river under study is found to be 5.06 9 10-4. In the next
sediment transport of Ichamati river. two columns bed shear stress and side shear stress are
In the Table 3 scouring zones are determined. In this calculated. We have calculated bed shear stress and side
Table the column 5 shows the cross sectional flow area shear stress using the following formulas
corresponding to respective the station. The column 1 Bed shear stress, sb = cyS0,
123
Model. Earth Syst. Environ. (2016)2:125 Page 9 of 13 125
Stage
Flow
60
10
50
8
Stage (m3/s)
Flow
40
6
30
4
20
2 10
1000 1100 1200 1300 1400 1500 1600 1700 1800 1900
10Oct2014
Date
where c = specific weight of water, 9790 N/m3, y = depth The permissible side shear stress on the side of the
of water from bed, m, S0 = longitudinal slope, channel, sps = K sp
qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
5.06 9 10-4 2h
where K ¼ 1 Sin Sin2
Side shear stress, ss = Kssb
where Ks = 0.066 m ? 0.67 = 0.066(2) ? 0.67 = 0.802 h = tan-1(1/m) = tan-1(1/2) = 26.56
Permissible bed shear stress on the non-cohesive bare Assuming, angle of repose of the bare soil, a = 35
soil has been obtained from a standard graph (referred to K ¼ 0:63
Table 3, Chain 2013) and its value, sp = 11 N/m2.
sps = 6.908 N/m2
123
125 Page 10 of 13 Model. Earth Syst. Environ. (2016)2:125
Table 3 Determination of scouring zone of Ichamati river. Data source: River Research Institute, Haringhata, Nadia
River station Average Average Average Total discharge Sectional flow Bed shear stress
depth (m) velocity slope (m) (m3/s) (m3/s) (N/m2)
From the Table 3 showing the bed shear stress and side at low over bank depths, the slow moving flow in the
shear stress which have crossed their corresponding per- flood plain interact with the fast moving main channel
missible value. intensely and considerable momentum exchange takes
place giving rise to large non uniformity in the
longitudinal velocity distribution. The maximum
Shear stress distribution curves of Ichamati river effected of the Ichamati river catchment area are flood
plain during the monsoonal season; because this river
• Shear stress increases with the increase of depth and are do not continuing suspended sediment load, the
width ratio from the river channel of during monsoonal effected of maximum Block like Bagdah, Bongaon,
season. Gaighata, Baduria, Swarupnagar and Bashirhat Block
• Ichamati river bed condition depend on the hydraulic are effected by rainy season.
radius as well as velocity distribution of channel middle
section of the river.
• Hydraulic radius increases with the increase of depth
Rating curve of Ichamati river
and width ratio.
• With increase of depth ratio, velocity increases and the
In hydrology, a Rating curve is a graph of discharge versus
correspondingly shear stress increases.
stage for a given point on a stream, usually at gauging
stations, where the stream discharge is measured across the
stream channel by HEC RAS Model. Numerous measure-
In a compound meandering channel of Ichamati ments of stream discharge are made over a range of stream
river stages. The rating curve is usually plotted as discharge on
x-axis versus stage (surface elevation) on y-axis (Fig. 9,
– The bed shear stress is increasing and decreasing in the 10, 11).
inner and outer bend respectively right bank of Icha- In the Figs. 5, 6, 7, and 12 are showing the results from a
mati river near Kalanchi and old Bongaon site. 20 km reach of Ichamati River. The computed water sur-
– The maximum value of shear stress occurs along the face elevations are almost identical to those derived from
inner bend of the main channel at low water depth ratio HEC-RAS. The velocities are slightly lower because the
and maximum river are generate meandering and calculation did not divide the cross section into an active
oxbow-lake of middle part of the river, because this flow zone and a tidal water/backwater zone. The cross
upper part only depends on rain water and middle and sectional area occupied by moving water was therefore
lower part are depends on tidal fluctuation. So the greater, resulting in lower velocities. This also means that
middle parts of the river are manly dynamic zone, the HEC water surface elevation should be slightly lower
river is disbalance of the middle part to generate ox- which is the case. The differences in both water surface
bow and meandering. elevation and velocity near distance zero reflect different
– For higher depth ratio, the maximum shear stress assumptions in defining computation starting values.
occurs along the inner bend of the floodplain. Because Overall, the comparison shows that the modeling results
123
Model. Earth Syst. Environ. (2016)2:125 Page 11 of 13 125
Fig. 9 General profile plot— ICHAMAT I RIVE R Plan: P lan 02 7/29/2015 1:02:35 PM
surface area
Geom: hec final Flow:
50 SA Total PF 1
SA Total PF 11
40
SA Chan PF 1
30 SA Chan PF 11
SA Right PF 1
20
SA Right PF 11
10 SA Left PF 1
SA Left PF 11
0
0 5000 10000 15000 20000
Fig. 10 General profile plot— ICHAMAT I RIVE R Plan: P lan 02 7/29/2015 1:02:35 PM
total volume of Ichamati river Geom: hec final Flow:
Ichamti 1
1000
Legend
800 Volume PF 1
Volume (1000 m3)
Volume PF 11
600
400
200
0
0 5000 10000 15000 20000
are consistent with those from HEC. For the prediction Conclusions
result by HEC RAS model of Ichamati river is showing the
Rating Curve of 20 km Stretch. The future prediction result • Flow depth, velocity, shear stress and wave celerity can
shows the maximum change for two places of Kalanchi and be determined from flood hydraulics by the model.
Ramnagar in which the river will generate meander course • The HEC-RAS one-dimensional numerical model was
for further adjustment with the new gradient of hydraulic essential in evaluating the long term bed change of the
discharges. In the Sundarban delta, rivers always adjust reach downstream of the Ichamati river.
with the temporary changes of water levels, shift in tur- • Understanding bed adjustments at this scope allows for
bidity maximum zones, and rapid rate of siltation by mass proper mitigation measures at the Kalanchi and Ram-
events (e.g. storm surges, rivers floods, subsidence etc.) nagar to predicted changes in reach scale bed
and the ponding effects of drainage under present condi- degradation.
tions. Following such adjustments the present Ichamati • River flow data from the one dimensional model was
river section will also follow the lengthening of its course critical in the development of the physical model to
by generating meandering pattern in the near future. define the modeled flow rate, and in the development of
123
125 Page 12 of 13 Model. Earth Syst. Environ. (2016)2:125
Fig. 11 General profile plot— ICHAMAT I RIVE R Plan: P lan 02 7/29/2015 1:02:35 PM
bed shear stress
Geom: hec final Flow:
Shear Chan PF 1
600
Shear LOB PF 11
Shear ROB PF 11
400
Shear LOB PF 1
0
0 5000 10000 15000 20000
the two-dimensional numerical model to define the boundary shear stress is resulted in the outer bend
downstream boundary condition. as compare to the inner bend of a compound
• One-dimensional models require many assumptions meandering channel.
including the accurate representation of a river using • At low water depth ratio, the maximum value of shear
selected cross section data, and neglecting of some stress occurs along the inner bend of the main channel.
orthogonal and vertical velocity components of the But for higher depth ratio, the maximum shear stress
Ichamati river. occurs along the inner bend of the floodplain. It is
• For all cases shear stress increases with the increase recommended that further investigation be focused on
of depth ratio and width ratio. But the increasing rate extending the present analysis to the compound mean-
of shear stress is higher with the depth ratio in dering channel of unsymmetrical cross sections with
comparable to width ratio. Low magnitude of different floodplain width.
123
Model. Earth Syst. Environ. (2016)2:125 Page 13 of 13 125
• The river Ichamati is adjusting its course in few Ichamati river catchment area using geoinformatics techniques,
sections following the temporal change of hydraulic West Bengal, India. Univ J Environ Res Tech 4(3):143–154
Mondal I, Bandyopadhyay J (2014c) Morphodynamic change of the
gradient and plan shape changes by rapid siltation Ichamati river and land use/land cover changes through space
process through the occurrences of mass events in the and time using remote sensing and GIS techniques North 24
Sundarban deltaic complex. Parganas, West Bengal, India, (Bagdah, Bongaon, Gaighata And
Swarupnagar Block, Hyderabad, India, December 9–12, 2014
Mondal M, Satpati LN (2012) Morphodynamic setting and nature of
bank erosion of the Ichamati River in Swarupnagar and Baduria
Blocks, 24 Parganas (N), West Bengal, Indian. J Spatial Sci
3.0(2) Winter, Issue 2012, pp 35–43
References Niyogi D (1975) Quaternary geology of the coastal plain in West
Bengal. Indian J Earth Sci 2:51–61
Acharya SK, Chakraborty P, Lahiri S, Raymahashay BC, Guha S, Roy AD (1952) Safety first and the holding of assets. Econometrica
Bhowmik A (1999) Arsenic poisoning in the Ganges Delta. 20:431–449
Nature 401:545 Sengupta S (1966) Geological and geophysical studies in western part
Chakravarti K (1938) Land-use in relation to the fluvial ecology in the of Bengal Basin, India. Bull Am Assoc Petrol Geol
Bhagirathi-Jalangi riparian tract-Calcutta University, M.A. the- 50:1001–1017
sis, (unpublished) Taggart J (1995) The peace river natural flow and regulated flow
Chain DA (2013) Water-resources engineering, 3rd edn. Prentice scenarios—daily flow data report. Surface Water Assessment
Hall, Cloth, pp 960 (ISBN-13: 978-0132833219, ISBN-10: Branch, Alberta Environmental Protection, Edmonton, AB
0132833212) Umitsu M (1993) Late quaternary sedimentary environments and
Herschy RW (ed.) (1999) Hydrometry—Principles and Practices. landforms in the Ganga Delta. Sediment Geol 83:177–186
Wiley, Chicheste, pp VI ? 376. ISBN 0-471-97350-5 U.S. Corps of Engineers (2002) HEC-RAS River Analysis System,
Mondal I, Bandyopadhyay J (2014a) Coastal zone mapping through Hydraulic Reference Manual. Hydraulic Engineering Center
geospatial technology for resource management of Indian Sun- Report CPD-69, Davis, CA
darban, West Bengal, India. Int J Remote Sens Appl 4(2):103–112
Mondal I, Bandyopadhyay J (2014b) Environmental change of trans
international boundary Indo-Bangladesh border of Sundarban
123