Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Suwinto Johan
President University
ABSTRACT
This research aims to guide the merger and acquisition process for business practitioners in Asia.
The research uses qualitative, descriptive analysis, and inductive approaches. This research is
based on the samples of 20 transactions that have been performed in the last 25 years. The
transactions involve companies from Indonesia, Malaysia, United States, United Kingdom, Japan,
and Canada. The study proposes a merger and acquisition model with seven steps: determining the
strategy, searching for the target, reviewing the target, confirmation and negotiation, transaction,
and integrating into a business. The result of this study contributes to a new model of merger
acquisition integration. The model will show the integration process in the financial services
industry in South East Asia. The results support previous studies. The acquisition and integration
model will assist the company's management in South East Asian countries to manage the merger
integration process, especially in the financial industry. This research provides an integration
model according to transactions in Asia in the financial service industry.
Keywords: merger and acquisition model, synergy, merger, and acquisition integration.
evaluation process that fuels these deals – as a the pharmaceutical industry. The
result, most executives often get deals wrong. pharmaceutical industry should focus on
An analysis of 2,500 deals shows that more outsourcing and diversification rather than
than 60% of them destroy shareholder value. vertical integration.
The impediments of mergers and acquisitions Also, Adra and Barbopoulos (2017)
come from human resources and technical discovered that acquisition with stock
resources. The condition from the side of financing is associated with a significant loss
human resources is due to the process of on shareholders' wealth during the
uniting the culture. announcement. This phenomenon is caused
Before the merger and acquisition, the by the high alertness shown by the investors
initial process is essential. Determining the in the stock market. Hassan et al. (2015) also
organic or inorganic growth strategy becomes concluded that tight supervision and the
a crucial step, followed by the introductory relationship between the components related
process as the initial merger and acquisition to the evaluation process of the acquisition
step. Spacek (2016) stated that many merger have a significant impact on the result of
and acquisition transactions are focused on merger and acquisition, especially on the
the pre-acquisition process, not on the Post- cross-border transaction. If the selection
Acquisition Integration Process (PAIP). The process is done correctly, it will result in a
valuation is focused on the synergic effects better merger and acquisition transaction. A
and financial benefit potentials. Merger and failed acquisition may be associated with the
acquisitions failure rates are very high, growth of assets (Mortal and Schill, 2015).
averaging about 50% (Koi-Akrofi, 2016). Moreover, Fisher and Pooe (2019)
Merger and acquisition is the act of researched 350 employees of a hotel, a target
combining two companies that are of acquisition. This research found that
complementary to one another, not two organizational support has a strong positive
companies that are precisely alike. This and significant linear relationship with brand
difference poses another challenge in the satisfaction and brand trust. Organizational
merging process. Koi-Akrofi (2016) found that support has a moderate positive influence on
the integration stage of the whole merger and organizational citizenship in a post-
acquisition process is the most problematic acquisition situation. Next, Bauer et al. (2016)
area contributing to merger and acquisition found that fast integration is critical in an
failure. The problems in the integration stage acquisition transaction. This research was
are human factors and low strategies. On the conducted on 116 transactions in Central
contrary, Johan (2018) maintained that Europe from 2007 to 2009. This research
mergers and acquisitions' success is finds that cultural compatibility between
determined by the first stage in the due organizations is essential to accelerate the
diligence process, target company's condition, speed of integration. In integration, the
managerial experience, target company's size, organizations have to separate the difference
and takeover process. between human resource and task integration
roles.
II. LITERATURE REVIEW Furthermore, Alalaya and Alfarajat (2018)
Dierks et al. (2018) found that mergers discovered that the theory shows a higher
and acquisitions should focus on value rather consequence as outcomes arising from pre-
than volume. This research was performed in existing structural characteristics. The size of
36
Jurnal Bisnis STRATEGI ● Vol. 30 No. 1 Juli 2021, halaman 35 – 46
P-ISSN : 1410-1246, E-ISSN : 2580-1171
the organization is significant, and it harms and the concept of experience. Merger and
performance. Huang et al. (2016) found that acquisitions deals with a more significant
the national cultural differences in post- number of advisors show a higher deal
acquisition performance may affect the failure completion rate. In contrast, deals with a more
of mergers and acquisitions. This research substantial number of participating firms
was conducted on 2,115 transactions in the present the opposite result.
technology industry. This research discovers Following this, Sarala et al. (2016)
that national cultural differences can create suggested that sociocultural interfirm
"cultural clashes" to undermine cross-border linkages between merging firms influence the
acquisitions' value creation. level of knowledge transfer in mergers and
Following this, Junni et al. (2015) clarified acquisitions. Human Resources (HR)
the effect of knowledge transfer on acquisition flexibility is vital for developing the
performance. Complementary knowledge sociocultural interfirm links in Mergers and
bases of the acquirer and the target enhanced Acquisitions (M&As). Organizational cultural
target and mutual knowledge transfer, but no differences are essential antecedents of HR
acquirer knowledge transfer. Mutual flexibility in M&As. Brueller et al. (2016)
knowledge transfer increased slightly when identified three generic M&A strategies –
the target had a more substantial knowledge annex & assimilate, harvest & protect, and link
base. Greve and Zhang (2017) analyzed how & promote. This research elaborates on the
the old state socialism logic and the new theoretical and practical contributions and
market capitalism logic competed to influence charts a course for future inquiry and research
Chinese firms' mergers and acquisitions. This applications. Kucukkocaoglu and Bozkurt
research finds that institutional affect merger (2018) found three performance changes
and acquisition decisions via coalitions after the merger and acquisition in Turkish
committed to each reason – partnership banks. This research was conducted on nine
whose balance of power. banks from 2001-2012 in Turkey.
Popli et al. (2015) analyzed 197 service Furthermore, Vulanovic (2016) studies
industries in India. This research finds that the how particular purpose acquisition
relationship between cultural differences and companies (SPACs) are related to their post-
deal abandonment in cross-border merger survival. An increase in the pre-
acquisitions is contingent on firm-level merger commitment by SPAC stakeholders
cultural experiences reserve and industry and initial positive market performance
affiliation. Ahammad et al. (2016) indicated increase post-merger survival likelihood. On
that knowledge transfer and employee the contrary, mergers with higher transaction
retention positively influence cross-border costs and focused on foreign companies
acquisition performance. Organizational exhibit increased failure like a hood.
culture difference has a negative influence on
cross-border acquisition performance. This III. METHOD
research was conducted on a company from This research uses qualitative, descriptive
the United Kingdom, which acquired analysis, and inductive methods. It is essential
companies from North America and Europe. to continue to develop new
Besides, Han et al. (2016) examined the conceptualizations, theoretical frameworks,
determinants of global merger and acquisition and techniques to advance knowledge of post-
deals by using organizational learning theory merger integration method dynamics
37
Jurnal Bisnis STRATEGI ● Vol. 30 No. 1 Juli 2021, halaman 35 – 46
P-ISSN : 1410-1246, E-ISSN : 2580-1171
(Graebner et al., 2014). Application of case case, testing extant theory and building new
study method to merger and acquisitions approach, and foresee increasing use of it
research in particular and management among different management streams.
research, in general, has embarked emerging (Reddy, 2015).
markets setting for purposes including the
38
Jurnal Bisnis STRATEGI ● Vol. 30 No. 1 Juli 2021, halaman 35 – 46
P-ISSN : 1410-1246, E-ISSN : 2580-1171
This research is based on the experience in of the transactions are listed in table 1. To
handling 20 merger and acquisition respect the transactions' confidentiality, the
transactions for 25 years with the target companies' names will not be mentioned in
companies from Malaysia and Indonesia. this paper.
Acquirer companies operate in the financial Of 20 transactions, 18 are in the financial
industry originating from United States, Japan, services industry and 2 in the consumer goods
United Kingdom, Canada, and Malaysia. Total industry. The summary of the transaction is
transactions include 12 mergers and stated in table 2. The total transaction
acquisitions, seven divestments, and one joint involves top-tier multinational companies
venture (greenfield) transaction. The details during 1996-2019.
IV. RESULT AND DISCUSSION This stage includes all the actions that need to
Based on the research in handling the be performed before the closing, starting from
transactions above, the model of merger and determining the design up to final negotiation.
acquisition model is created as figure 1. The According to Ashkenas et al. (1998) in
merger and acquisition integration model is the Wheel of Fortune Integration of General
divided into three main stages: pre-closing, Electric, this process is divided into four main
closing, and post-closing. The first stage is the stages: start, foundation building, rapid
Pre-Closing stage. Pre-Closing is a stage in integration, and assimilation. These four
determining the strategy up to negotiating. stages are divided into ten small stages.
Signing De
ion
App
N e g al
otat
Fin
rov
al
al
Clo
sin
g
Closin
De
a l rm
nfi
Co sults
g
Re
Post Closing
Integration
Pre-Closing
sing Design TOM
Post Clo
Va
lua
l s
tio
ua A
Us ess
n
sin
Bu
ND
Searchin
Strategy
A
g
39
Jurnal Bisnis STRATEGI ● Vol. 30 No. 1 Juli 2021, halaman 35 – 46
P-ISSN : 1410-1246, E-ISSN : 2580-1171
The second stage is called the Closing performed by the Japanese companies have
stage, which is the finishing stage of every particular characteristics, namely: (1)
legal requirement. The third stage is the Requiring longer preparation time compared
Integration stage. The integration stage is the to the companies from other countries; (2)
most critical in actualizing the points that Seeing the business model as a long-term
were decided in the Pre-Closing stage. This investment; (3) Prioritizing harmony and
stage determines the success or failure of a trust in dealing with their partners or sellers.
transaction. From the three stages above, the model is
From 20 transactions that had been further elaborated into the following steps as
successfully executed, the transactions stated in table 3.
The estimated time required to finish the through mergers and acquisitions. In deciding
entire process from the due diligence to the plan, the acquiring company needs to
closing the deal is approximately 4 to 6 consider the resources currently available to
months. Japanese company requires a longer the company and the desired recourses that
time compared to the companies from other the company needs to obtain. If the company
countries. This process will take a longer time cannot provide the resources internally, the
in search of a suitable target company. From company needs to perform mergers and
100 target companies, only one company may acquisitions with other entities.
be selected for the due diligence process, but Apart from the resources, the period's
deal closing is not guaranteed. The advisers length to achieve the resources will differ
will become involved in the process during the between organic and inorganic strategies. The
second stage. All of the advisers will be organic approach will require a longer time
involved until the deal closes. After the deal than the inorganic strategy in obtaining
closes, the acquirer company will take resources. However, the organic strategy
responsibility. Generally, the advisers will be offers a faster integration process than the
paid based on the success fee. inorganic method.
In the first stage, the acquiring company From 20 transactions analyzed in this
determines the strategy to achieve growth. research, 95% of the transactions are market
The organic approach prioritizes internal expansion transactions. This expansion is
development. The inorganic process is growth carried out on new markets or countries to
40
Jurnal Bisnis STRATEGI ● Vol. 30 No. 1 Juli 2021, halaman 35 – 46
P-ISSN : 1410-1246, E-ISSN : 2580-1171
reach potential markets through horizontal Agreement. The initial agreement can also be
integration. Market expansion is performed referred to as the initial Memorandum of
by penetrating the new demand in other Understanding (MoU), which outlines every
countries. Horizontal integration is executed aspect of merger and acquisition that will be
through mergers or acquisitions of similar performed, including estimating the target
companies with different business company's price range.
characteristics. The companies may differ in a For Japanese companies, the MoU signing
market segment, geographical branches, is practically a guaranteed commitment. They
technology, or human resource. The details have a meticulous approach to signing the
are stated in table 4. MoU. Nonetheless, it takes Japanese
Dyer et al. (2004) discovered several companies a much longer time to reach the
types of synergy in merging companies. This MoU signing stage than the companies from
synergy is based on the needs of natural other countries.
resources, the similarity of resources,
competition level, and certainty of market Reviewing target
level. Based on the factors above, companies After signing the MoU, the target company will
will determine the form of an alliance they be reviewed through the following steps:
require, namely acquisition, capital • Due diligence
investment, or collaboration. This step is performed to verify the available
information. This process involves several
Searching target company external parties, such as accountants,
After the inorganic decision is decided, the appraisers, tax consultants, law consultants,
company will determine the desired target etc.
company. The target company has to possess • Valuation
the selected resources. The target company After performing the due diligence, the
must fulfill all the requirements set by the acquirer has to perform a projection modeling
acquiring company. Searching for the target on the target company. This projection
can involve up to 100 companies, and only one includes every synergy factor that can be
company will satisfy all the criteria. created, expenses, and other factors that need
From 20 transactions performed in the to be considered if the synergy is performed.
past, the acquiring companies generally • Industry analysis
search for the stock market's target Aside from the target company, the acquirer
companies. They are prone to search for must perform an analysis of the target
companies that have been listed in the stock company's industry. This analysis includes the
exchange or public companies. They believe structure, conduct, and performance analysis.
that the regulators also monitor these target In this step, the company must prepare the
companies. Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI)
calculation to determine the industry
Signing the initial/confidentiality concentration.
agreement with the target company • Financing scheme
Once the acquiring company has found a It is determining the financing scheme
target company, the acquiring company and through stock or cash payment. Financing
the target company must sign an initial through stocks with the right issue shall be
agreement, including the Confidentiality converted to cash or exchanging stock. The
41
Jurnal Bisnis STRATEGI ● Vol. 30 No. 1 Juli 2021, halaman 35 – 46
P-ISSN : 1410-1246, E-ISSN : 2580-1171
financing scheme has to be aligned to the existing company. The merge includes many
strategy that will be implemented. aspects, including integrating the human
• Design Target Operating Model (TOM) resource and other technical aspects.
The next step is creating a business model or • Governance, regulatory compliance, and
TOM for the new entity and formulating the deal structure
plan to merge the new company into the
Table 4. Integration Model
Integration Model By
No Transaction
Acquirer
Geographic Expansion
1 Convertible Bond to Equity
(Market Expansion)
Geographic Expansion
2 Exercise of Share Buyback Option
(Market Expansion)
3 A Group of Textile Companies Acquiring a Retail Chain Market-Based Integration
Economies of Scale (Market
4 Acquisition of Indonesian Distressed Asset
Expansion)
Geographic Expansion
5 Divestment of a Leasing Company in Malaysia
(Market Expansion)
Economies of Scale (Market
6 Acquired Portfolio by the Largest Foreign Bank
Expansion)
A Consortium of Indonesian Conglomerate to Acquire a Horizontal Integration
7
Finance Company (Market Expansion)
A Consortium Between the Largest Conglomerate and a Horizontal Integration
8
Foreign Bank to Acquire a Private Bank (Market Expansion)
A Local Conglomerate Acquired Shares from a Japanese Economies of Scale (Market
9
Trading Company Expansion)
Sovereign Wealth Fund and a Japanese Trading Company
Geographic Expansion
10 Acquiring a Finance Company from One of the Largest
(Market Expansion)
Automotive Group in Indonesia
Horizontal Integration
11 The merger of Two Banks in Indonesia
(Market Expansion)
Joint Venture Between a Japanese Automotive Group and a Geographic Expansion
12
Local Conglomerate in Indonesia (Market Expansion)
Geographic Expansion
13 Divestment of Finance Company
(Market Expansion)
Divestment of a Finance Company to a Japanese Financial Geographic Expansion
14
Group (Market Expansion)
Geographic Expansion
15 Divestment of an Insurance Company to a Private Equity
(Market Expansion)
Divestment of a Finance Company to a Japanese Largest Geographic Expansion
16
Banking Group (Market Expansion)
Geographic Expansion
17 Divestment of a Retail Chain to a Global China Retail Chain
(Market Expansion)
Divestment of a Finance Company to a Thai's Company Geographic Expansion
18
(Japanese Company) (Market Expansion)
Acquisition of a Finance Company by a Japanese Banking Geographic Expansion
19
Group (Market Expansion)
Geographic Expansion
20 Acquisition of a Finance Company by a Private Equity Firm
(Market Expansion)
42
Jurnal Bisnis STRATEGI ● Vol. 30 No. 1 Juli 2021, halaman 35 – 46
P-ISSN : 1410-1246, E-ISSN : 2580-1171
43
Jurnal Bisnis STRATEGI ● Vol. 30 No. 1 Juli 2021, halaman 35 – 46
P-ISSN : 1410-1246, E-ISSN : 2580-1171
time. Otherwise, the company will have to determining the strategy, searching for the
spend additional energy. target, reviewing the target company,
confirmation negotiation, transaction, and
V. CONCLUSION AND IMPLICATIONS integrating into a business. This acquisition
The acquisition preparation stage is model is based on retail industries such as
crucial in the merger and acquisition process. retail financial services and consumer goods,
The f on the acquisition preparation shall not such as banks, insurance, and customer
be the main focus of the merger and finance companies with target companies
acquisition process. This model proposes from two countries and acquiring companies
seven stages of merger and acquisition: from multiple countries.
VI. REFERENCES
Adra S. and L.G. Barbopoulos. (2017). The Valuation Effects of Investor Attention in Stock-
Financed Acquisitions. Journal of Empirical Finance 45: 108-125
Ahammad, M.F., S.Y. Tarba, Y. Liu, and K.W. Glaister. (2016). Knowledge Transfer and Cross
Border Acquisition Performance: The Impact of Cultural Distance and Employee Retention.
International Business Review 25(1): 66-75.
Ashkenas, R., L. DeMonaco, and S. Francis. (1998). Making the Deal Real: How GE Capital
Integrates Acquisitions. Harvard Business Review: 1-14.
Bauer F., D. King, and K. Matzler. (2016). Speed of Acquisition Integration: Separating the Role
of Human and Task Integration 32: 150-165
Brueller N.N., A. Carmeli, and G.D. Markman. (2016). Linking Merger and Acquisitions Strategies
to Post-Merger Integration: A Configurational Perspective of Human Resource
Management. Journal of Management. XX (X)
Dierks, R.M.L, O. Bruyere, and J.Y. Reginster. (2018). Critical analysis of Valuation and Strategical
Orientation of Merger and Acquisition Deals in the Pharmaceutical Industry. Expert
Review of Pharmacoeconomics & Outcomes Research
http://doi.org/10.1080/14737167.2018.1417040
Dyer, J.H., P. Kale, and H. Singh. (2004). When to Ally and When to Acquire, Harvard Business
Review 1-9
Fisher, W., and R.I.D. Pooe. (2019). Organizational Citizenship and the Morning After – A Case of
an Acquisition of a Local Hotel Chain by a Global Brand. African Journal of Hospitality,
Tourism and Leisure 8(3): 1-19
44
Jurnal Bisnis STRATEGI ● Vol. 30 No. 1 Juli 2021, halaman 35 – 46
P-ISSN : 1410-1246, E-ISSN : 2580-1171
Graebner M.E., Heimeriks K.H., and Huy Q.N. (2014). The Process of Post-Merger Integration: A
Review and Agenda for Future Research. Acadamy of Management Annals 11(1): 1-32.
Greve, H.R., and C.M. Zhang. (2017) Institutional Logics and Power Sources: Merger and
Acquisitions Decisions. Academy of Management Journal 60(2):671-694
https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2015.0698
Han, B.S., E.K. Park, T.K. Kang. (2016). Determinants of Global Merger and Acquisitions (M&A)
Deals Completion: Focus on the Role of the Firms' M&A Experience. Journal of International
Trade & Commerce 12(3): 23-44. http://dx.doi.org/10.16980/jitc.12.3.201606.23
Hassan, I., A. Chidlow, A.M. Romero-Martinez. (2016). Selection, Valuation and Performance
Assessment: Are These Truly Inter-Linked Within the M&A Transaction? International
Business Review 25: 255-266.
Huang, Z., Z. Huang, and D.J. Brass. (2016). Cross-Border Acquisitions and The Asymmetric Effect
of Power Distance Value Difference on Long-Term Post-Acquisition Performance. Strategic
Management Journal. Doi: 10.1002/smj.2530
Johan, S. (2011). Implementasi Strategi Bisnis dan Korporasi Melalui Merger dan Akuisisi.
Lin L.H., Y.L. Hob, and W.H. Lin. (2015). Post-Acquisition Performance: Contingency of
Acquisition Strategy. Procedia - Social And Behavioral Sciences 207: 59-69
Mortal, S and M.J. Schill. (2015). The Post-Acquisition Returns of Stock Deals: Evidence of the
Pervasiveness of the Asset Growth Effect. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 50
(3): 477-507
Popli, M., M. Akbar, V. Kumas, and A. Gaur. (2015). Reconceptualizing Cultural Distance: The Role
of Cultural Experience Reserve in Cross-Border Acquisitions. Journal of World Business
Reddy, K.S. (2015). The State of Case Study Approach in Mergers and Acquisitions Literature: A
45
Jurnal Bisnis STRATEGI ● Vol. 30 No. 1 Juli 2021, halaman 35 – 46
P-ISSN : 1410-1246, E-ISSN : 2580-1171
46