Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Duke, Vásquez y Rosales 2018
Duke, Vásquez y Rosales 2018
Keywords: Due to the arid environment and excellent preservation on the north coast of Peru, the evidence obtained from
Starch grain analysis macrobotanical remains are the primary sources of information on plant use. However, some plants, such as
Archaeobotany potatoes, are infrequently recovered as macrobotanicals because they are usually consumed in their entirety. For
Moche this reason, we have applied starch grain analyses to ceramic and lithic materials recovered from the Late Moche
Peru
(AD 600–850) site of Wasi Huachuma (Je-65) in the lower Jequetepeque valley, Peru. The results of these
analyses revealed the presence of potato (Solanum tuberosum) on the ceramics indicating the regular con-
sumption of potato at this site during this period. Prior to this, physical evidence of potato had only been
recovered from one other Moche context—dental calculus from Huaca Cao Viejo. This indicates that macro-
botanical analyses alone are insufficient for uncovering the spectrum of foodstuffs utilized by the Moche. We
argue for a more rigorous and consistent application of starch grain analysis, in order to obtain as much in-
formation as possible about past plant utilization, rather than relying on macrobotanical remains alone.
1. Introduction entirety, including potatoes and other tubers, would be essentially in-
visible in the macrobotanical record, even in areas with excellent pre-
Due to the arid environment and subsequent excellent preservation servation. Thus, it is necessary to seek information regarding the use of
on the north coast of Peru, evidence obtained from macrobotanical these types of materials via others means, including conducting starch
remains has been the primary source of information on plant use in this grain analyses on the processing tools and serving implements re-
region. This rich and varied database has been invaluable in building an covered archaeologically (Louderback and Pavlik, 2017; Rumold and
understanding of the uses of a wide range of plants and marine algae. Aldenderfer, 2016; Ugent and Peterson, 1988). What we argue is that
Despite this, the biological characteristics of many plants and modes of starch grain analysis is an essential element in recovering as much in-
processing often preclude macrobotanical evidence of their use. The formation as possible on the plants that were utilized in this region in
application of starch grain analyses on the north coast of Peru, and the past, in addition to the rich and varied macrobotanical evidence
other regions with excellent plant preservation, can only improve our available on the north coast of Peru.
understanding of plant usage as well as reduce the impact of pre- This case study comes from the Late Moche (AD 600–850) site of
servational bias on the evidentiary record. Wasi Huachuma (Je-65; Fig. 1). The recovery of potato (Solanum tu-
Starch grain analyses of residues are not particularly new to ar- berosum) starch grains from residues on ceramics was a surprising de-
chaeology nor to Peru (see Briuer, 1976; Duncan et al., 2009; Loy et al., velopment due the previous lack of evidence of potato from other
1992; Piperno and Dillehay, 2008; Ugent et al., 1986). Analyses of Moche sites. Potato has been found at only one other Moche site, Huaca
starch grains provides complementary evidence for plant use to sup- Cao Viejo, as starch grains from the dental calculus of a sacrificed in-
plement the data from macrobotanical materials. Importantly, many dividual (Vásquez et al., 2014). It has long been presumed that potatoes
plants used by past societies are not easily recovered in situ as whole or constituted an insignificant part of the Moche culinary repertoire as a
partial specimens or through flotation due to a number of reasons, in- specialty crop (Bourget, 1990, 2006; Reinhard et al., 2007:535; Ugent
cluding environmental conditions such as wet or acidic soils hastening et al., 1982). This argument has been based partly on their highland
their biodegradation or the consumption by humans (or animals) of the origin and prevalence (Salaman, 1949; Towle, 1961:84–87), but mostly
entire item. For these reasons, soft bodied plants that are eaten in their because of their relative absence from the excavated botanical material
∗
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: guy.duke@utrgv.edu (G.S. Duke).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jas.2018.10.006
Received 22 June 2018; Received in revised form 3 October 2018; Accepted 16 October 2018
0305-4403/ © 2018 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
G.S. Duke et al. Journal of Archaeological Science 100 (2018) 74–79
Fig. 1. Map of the Lower Jequetepeque Valley and some important Moche sites.
record. However, starch grains from potatoes were found within mul- evidence of common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris), cotton (Gossypium bar-
tiple quotidian contexts at Wasi Huachuma as part of a relatively con- badense), coca (Erythroxylum coca), and chilli pepper (Capsicum sp.)
stricted range of plant materials indicating that they were a common (Vásquez and Rosales, 2014:17–24). Faunal materials included camelid
part of the daily diet at this site. (Lama sp.), guinea pig (Cavia porcellus), eared dove (Zenaida auriculata),
marine fish (Mugil cephalus, Galeichthys peruvianus, Stellifer minor, Cy-
2. Research site and context noscion sp., Sardinops sagax), mollusks (Tegula atra, Donax obesulus,
Prisogaster niger, Polinices uber, Thais chocolata), and arthropods (Pla-
The Moche period in the Jequetepeque valley, which spanned from tyxanthus orbignyi, Macrobrachium sp., Hypolobocera sp.) (Vásquez and
approximately AD 200–850, was characterized by a number of shared Rosales, 2014:8–16). For the most part, each of these materials was
practices and traditions, from ceramic styles to modes of architectural available locally, either from the nearby irrigated fields or the Pacific
construction, as well as the expansion of irrigation systems and urba- Ocean (see Chiou, 2017:58–61). All are common elements recovered
nization. While these practices and traditions obviously were altered from Moche sites in the Jequetepeque and elsewhere. Notably, neither
and modified over the centuries, it is clear that a definitive “Moche tubers nor other underground storage organs (USOs) such as sweet
tradition” was present throughout the north coast valleys, including the potato were recovered as macroremains at Wasi Huachuma.
Jequetepeque. By the Late Moche period, from AD 600–850, political
control of the Jequetepeque had splintered, likely due to a combination 3. Microbotanical methods and results
of environmental instability and political or military disruption from
external groups leading to a period of internecine conflict (Castillo, In addition to the macrobotanical and faunal materials, four arti-
2001; Dillehay, 2001; Dillehay et al., 2004; Johnson et al., 2011; facts—a small grinding stone (Fig. 3a), two non-diagnostic ceramic
Quilter and Koons, 2012; Shimada et al., 1991; Swenson, 2007, 2008). body sherds, and a large, intact pot (Fig. 3b)—were analyzed for starch
Wasi Huachuma is located on the lower northeast slope of the grains. The grinding stone and one of the ceramic sherds were re-
Catalina Hills in the lower Jequetepeque valley, in relatively close covered from the same sub-floor fill within a domestic structure on the
proximity to three major regional centers of political power: Cerro south edge of Sector C. The other ceramic sherd came from a domestic
Chepén, San José de Moro, and Pacatnamú (Cusicanqui, 2010; Donnan floor on the north side of Sector C. The whole vessel was found on its
and Cock, 1997; Rosas, 2010) (Fig. 1). Radiocarbon dates from five side within a sand matrix below the floor in the northern domestic
secure contexts place its occupation firmly within the Late Moche structure. Its mouth opened to the east with botanical and faunal ma-
period from AD 600–850 (see Duke, 2017:123–149). The site consists of terials around it (Duke, 2017:137–143).
seven distinct sectors delineated by three dry arroyos running northeast All of the above materials were carefully excavated using clean tools
from the top of the hills to the irrigated plain below (Dillehay et al., and gloves. The grinding stone and ceramic sherds were small enough
2009:86–89; Duke, 2017:100–109; Swenson, 2004:609–617) (Fig. 2). to be securely wrapped in foil and plastic to prevent contamination and
Sector B is the lower, central area of the site. It features a three-tiered, sent to the laboratory for analysis. The whole vessel, however, was too
ramped platform mound (Structure B) and associated out-buildings. large for this. Instead, while in the field we poured a small amount of
The low ridge rising along the northwest side of Sector B demarcates unadulterated distilled water into the vessel, then used a new tooth-
Sector C, where the data in this paper derive, with a hill at the north brush, boiled and cleaned in distilled water, to gently scour the inside
end designated Sector E. Along this ridge are a number of stone bottom, and poured the resulting mixture into a sterile bottle.
alignments and disinterred burials. This area of the site has been The samples containing microbotanical remains were treated at the
identified as Wasi Huachuma's primary residential area (Dillehay et al., Archeobios laboratory in Trujillo by Victor Vásquez and Teresa Rosales.
2009:86–89; Duke, 2017:130–161; Swenson, 2004:609–617). The ceramic sherds and grinding stone were cleaned with compressed
There is significant evidence of habitation and food processing in air to remove the adhered dust and other particles to ensure that the
Sector C, including burnt floors, hearths, food processing implements, starch grains analyzed were obtained directly from the object rather
such as grinding stones, cutters and scrapers, and ceramic graters, and than from the sediments from which they were uncovered. A sterile
the remains of food items themselves (Duke, 2017:130–161). The needle (one for each item) was used to scrape areas of the grinding
macrobotanical materials recovered both in situ and via flotation from stone with white-to-yellow sediments that could contain starch grains.
Sector C included maize (Zea mays), squash (Cucurbita sp.), lúcuma The residue was transferred directly to a slide where a few drops of
(Pouteria lucuma), and sapote (Capparis sp.) as well as reeds (Phragmites saline solution had been previously added. This procedure was per-
australis) and algarroba (Prosopis sp.). Flotation processing recovered formed on each sample three to five times separately by sampling the
75
G.S. Duke et al. Journal of Archaeological Science 100 (2018) 74–79
different areas such as the interstices and fissures of each sample. A of edible plants was used, including tubers, roots, cereals, beans of
solution of distilled water and glycerin v/v was then applied, which was various species and native fruits. The starch grains were identifiable
added to the suspension of residues to retard the drying and to allow the because they retained their shape and characteristics of the surface, and
grains to be easier to manipulate when detected. Starch grains from the some still exhibited the typical cross that is produced with polarized
bottled sample from the whole vessel were sampled with a sterile light. Once the starch grains were identified, they were measured using
Pasteur pipette. Three drops of the suspension were placed on a moon a micron measuring reticle inserted into the microscope eyepiece. The
slide which was covered with a moon coverslip. starch grains were photographed with a SONY Cybershot 12 megapixel
The recovered microbotanical samples were dried at ambient tem- digital camera. The results from these assays revealed potato starch
perature and conditioned for taxonomic identification. The taxonomic from all of the ceramics, as well as maize starch from the whole vessel
identification of the remains was carried out by using a 400× com- and the grinding stone (Fig. 4a–d; Table 1) (Vásquez and Rosales,
pound microscope under both standard and polarized light. The iden- 2014:23–24).
tification was based on comparing the morphological characteristics of
the archaeological samples with documented examples from other re-
searchers (Guevara, 1973; Loy, 1990; Piperno et al., 2006; Reichert, 4. Implications for research
1913; Torrence and Barton, 2006).
For the identification of starch grains, a modern reference collection The larger project compared culinary materials from Wasi
Huachuma with those from Huaca Colorada on the south side of the
76
G.S. Duke et al. Journal of Archaeological Science 100 (2018) 74–79
Fig. 3. a. Grinding stone from Unit 3, Level 5, Wasi Huachuma. b. Whole vessel from Unit 5, Level 5, Feature 4, Wasi Huachuma.
river (see Duke, 2017; Swenson et al., 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2015). genera) (Duke, 2017:415–448) indicates that these are unlikely sce-
With one exception,1 potato was the only plant species found solely at narios. Importantly, starch grain analyses were not conducted on ma-
Wasi Huachuma (Vásquez and Rosales, 2014). While this could be due terials from Huaca Colorada. Thus, we argue that the lack of evidence
to any number of reasons, including exclusive use on the north side of for potato there2 is more likely due to a lack of microbotanical analysis
the valley or use as a one-time novelty import, the sheer variety of plant
remains at Huaca Colorada (30 distinct species/genera) in comparison
2
to the relatively limited scope at Wasi Huachuma (14 distinct species/ Solanum sp. at Huaca Colorada were only recovered from flotation samples.
The specific parts of the plant were not identified. These materials could be
potato or any other member of the Solanum genus present in the region during
this period, such as Solanum muricatum (pepino) (Fernández and Rodríquez,
1
A generic desert shrub (Encelia sp.), which grows wild along the hills and 2007:209–212) or Solanum betaceum (tree tomato) (Fernández and Rodríquez,
arroyos in the area (Vásquez and Rosales, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013). 2007:204–207).
77
G.S. Duke et al. Journal of Archaeological Science 100 (2018) 74–79
Table 1
Identified starch grains and observations from Wasi Huachuma during the 2013 field season.
Material Context Identified species Measurements L × W (microns) Observations Image
Whole ceramic vessel (tinaja) Sector C, Unit 5–13, Level 5, Solanum tuberosum 28.6 × 20.8 damaged
Feature 4 20.8 × 15.6 hydrolyzed
Zea mays 18.2 × 15.6 damaged
15.6 × 15.6 damaged
26 × 20.8 damaged
18.2 × 18.2 with fissures in hilum
Non-diagnostic ceramic body sherd Sector C, Unit 3–13, Level 5 Solanum tuberosum 39 × 20.8 typical, well-preserved Fig. 4a and b
15.6 × 15.6 ovoid
Non-diagnostic ceramic body sherd Sector C, Unit 5–13, Level 3, SE Solanum tuberosum 28.6 × 16.9 elliptical, well-preserved
portion
Grinding stone Sector C, Unit 3–13, Level 5 Zea mays 20.8 × 16.9 polyhedral Fig. 4c and d
26.3 × 26.3 polyhedral, with fissures in
hilum
78
G.S. Duke et al. Journal of Archaeological Science 100 (2018) 74–79
Empire in the Prehistoric Jequetepeque Valley, Peru. Archaeopress, Oxford, UK, pp. Informe Final Proyecto Arqueologico Jatanca-huaca Colorada, Valle Jequetepeque
51–64. Temporada 2011. Ministerio de Cultura, Lima.
Kolata, Alan L., 1986. The agricultural foundations of the Tiwanaku state: a view from the Swenson, Edward R., Warner, John P., Spence-Morrow, Giles, Guengerich, Anna, Alaica,
heartland. Am. Antiq. 51 (4), 748–762. Aleksa, Chiguala, Jorge Y., Crandall, James, Joosten, Katrina, Lynch, Sally, 2011.
Louderback, Lisbeth A., Pavlik, Bruce M., 2017. Starch granule evidence for the earliest Informe final de la temporada de investigacion 2010. Ministerio de Cultura, Lima.
potato use in north America. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A 114 (29), 7606–7610. Swenson, Edward R., Alaica, Aleksa, Lynch, Sally, Spence-Morrow, Giles, Chiguala, Jorge
Loy, Thomas H., 1990. Prehistoric organic residues: recent advances in identification, Y., Duke, Guy S., Joosten, Katrina, Warner, John P., 2013. Informe Final Proyecto
dating, and their antiquity. In: Ernst, Pernicka (Ed.), Archaeometry ’90. Springer Arqueologico Jatanca-huaca Colorada, Valle Jequetepeque Temporada 2012.
Verlag, Boston, pp. 645–656. Ministerio de Cultura, Lima.
Loy, Thomas H., Spriggs, Matthew, Wickler, Stephen, 1992. Direct evidence for human Swenson, Edward R., Warner, John P., Seoane, Francisco, Chiguala, Jorge Y., 2015.
use of plants 28,000 years ago: starch residues on stone artefacts from the northern Informe Final Proyecto Arqueologico Jatanca-Huaca Colorada de la Temporada de
Solomon Islands. Antiquity 66, 898–912. Investigacion 2014. Ministerio de Cultura, Lima.
Piperno, Dolores, Dillehay, Tom, 2008. Starch grains on human teeth reveal early broad Torrence, Robin, Barton, Huw, 2006. Ancient Starch Research. Left Coast Press, Walnut
crop diet in northern Peru. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A 105 (50), 19622–19627. Creek.
Retrieved from: http://www.jstor.org.ezhost.utrgv.edu:2048/stable/25465698. Towle, Margaret A., 1961. The Ethnobotany of Pre-columbian Peru, vol. 30 Viking Fund
Piperno, Dolores R., 2006. Identifying Manioc (Manihot esculenta Crantz) and other crops Publication in Anthropology, Chicago.
in Pre-Columbian Tropical America through starch grain analysis: a case study from Ugent, Donald, Peterson, Linda W., 1988. Archaeological remains of potato and sweet
Central Panama. In: Zeder, Melinda A., Bradley, Daniel G., Emshwiller, Eve, Smith, potato in Peru. International Potato Center Circular 16 (3), 1–10.
Bruce D. (Eds.), Documenting Domestication: New Genetic and Archaeological Ugent, Donald, Pozorski, Shelia, Pozorski, Thomas, 1982. Archaeological potato tuber
Paradigms. University of California Press, Berkeley, pp. 46–67. remains from the Casma valley of Peru. Econ. Bot. 36 (2), 182–192.
Quilter, Jeffrey, Koons, Michelle L., 2012. The fall of the Moche: a critique of claims for Ugent, Donald, Pozorski, Shelia, Pozorski, Thomas, 1986. Archaeological Manioc
South America's first state. Lat. Am. Antiq. 23 (2), 127–143. (Manihot) from coastal Peru. Econ. Bot. 40 (1), 78–102. Retrieved from: http://www.
Reichert, E.T., 1913. The Differentiation and Specificity of Starches in Relation to Genera, jstor.org.ezhost.utrgv.edu:2048/stable/4254832.
Species, Etc. Carnegie Institution of Washington, Washington, D.C. Vásquez S, Victor F., Rosales T, Teresa E., 2010. Restos de fauna y vegetales de Huaca
Reinhard, Karl J., Bryant, Vaughn M., Vinton, Sheila D., 2007. Comment on reinterpreting Colorada, valle de Jequetepeque – temporada 2009. In: Swenson, Edward R.,
the pollen data from Dos Cabezas. Int. J. Osteoarchaeol. 17 (5), 531–541. http://doi. Chiguala, Jorge Y., Warner, John P. (Eds.), Informe Final Proyecto Arqueologico
org/10.1002/oa.886. Jatanca-Huaca Colorada, Valle Jequetepeque Temporada 2009, apendice 1.
Rosas R, Marco, 2010. Cerro Chepén and the Late Moche Collapse in the Jequetepeque Ministerio de Cultura, Lima.
Valley, North Coast of Peru. PhD dissertation. Department of Anthropology, Vásquez S, Victor F., Rosales T, Teresa E., 2011. Restos de fauna y vegetales de Huaca
University of New Mexico, Albuquerque. Colorada, valle de Jequetepeque – temporada 2010. In: Swenson, Edward R.,
Rumold, Claudia U., Aldenderfer, Mark S., 2016. Late archaic-early formative period Chiguala, Jorge Y., Warner, John P. (Eds.), Informe Final Proyecto Arqueologico
microbotanical evidence for potato at Jiskairumoko in the Titicaca basin of southern Jatanca-Huaca Colorada, Valle Jequetepeque Temporada 2010, apendice 1.
Peru. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A 113 (48), 13672–13677. Ministerio de Cultura, Lima.
Salaman, Redcliffe N., 1949. The History and Social Influence of the Potato. Cambridge Vásquez S, Victor F., Rosales T, Teresa E., 2012. Restos de fauna y vegetales de Huaca
University Press, Cambridge, UK. Colorada, valle de Jequetepeque – temporada 2011. In: Swenson, Edward R.,
Shimada, Izumi, Schaaf, Crystal, Thompson, Lonnie, Mosley-Thompson, Ellen, 1991. Chiguala, Jorge Y., Warner, John P. (Eds.), Informe Final Proyecto Arqueologico
Cultural impacts of severe droughts in the prehistoric andes: application of a 1,500- Jatanca-Huaca Colorada, Valle Jequetepeque Temporada 2011, apendice 1.
year Ice core precipitation record. World Archaeol. 22 (3), 247–270. Ministerio de Cultura, Lima.
Swenson, Edward R., 2004. Ritual and Power in the Urban Hinterland: Religious Vásquez S, Victor F., Rosales T, Teresa E., 2013. Restos de fauna y vegetales de Huaca
Pluralism and Political Decentralization in Late Moche Jequetepeque, Peru. PhD Colorada, valle de Jequetepeque – temporada 2012. In: Swenson, Edward R.,
dissertation. Department of Anthropology, University of Chicago, Illinois. Chiguala, Jorge Y., Warner, John P. (Eds.), Informe Final Proyecto Arqueologico
Swenson, Edward R., 2007. Adaptive strategies or ideological innovations? Interpreting Jatanca-Huaca Colorada, Valle Jequetepeque Temporada 2012, apendice 1.
sociopolitical developments in the Jequetepeque valley of Peru during the late Moche Ministerio de Cultura, Lima.
period. J. Anthropol. Archaeol. 26 (2), 253–282. Vásquez S, Victor F., Rosales T, Teresa E., 2014. Restos de fauna y vegetales del sitio Je64,
Swenson, Edward R., 2008. San Ildefonso and the “popularization”of Moche ideology in valle de Jequetepeque – temporada 2013. In: Duke, Guy S., Jessica, J., Ramírez, G.
the Jequetepeque valley. Arqueol. Mochica Nuevos Enfoques 411–431. (Eds.), Proyecto de Investigación Arqueologica: la vida doméstica y la dieta en Wasi
Swenson, Edward R., Warner, John P., Crandall, James, Chiguala, Jorge Y., 2010. Huachuma (Je-64), Valle Jequetepeque – Informe Final de Temporada 2013, apen-
Proyecto de investigacion aqueologica Jatanca - Huaca Colorada, Valle de dice 1. Ministerio de Cultura, Lima.
Jequetepeque: Informe final, temporada 2009. Ministerio de Cultura, Lima. Vásquez S, Victor F., Franco Jordán, Régulo, Rosales T, Teresa E., 2014. Almidones an-
Swenson, Edward R., Warner, John P., Alaica, Aleksa, Gataveckas, Katrina, Joosten, tiguos del cálculo dental de un entierro mochica de la Huaca Cao Viejo, complejo
Katrina, Chiguala, Jorge Y., Duke, Guy S., Lynch, Sally, Spence-Morrow, Giles, 2012. arqueológico El Brujo, costa norte del Perú. Rev. Archaeobios 8 (1), 6–16.
79