Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Halloumi Cheese: The Product and Its Characteristics: International Journal of Dairy Technology August 2007
Halloumi Cheese: The Product and Its Characteristics: International Journal of Dairy Technology August 2007
net/publication/229542837
CITATIONS READS
31 805
2 authors, including:
Photis Papademas
Cyprus University of Technology
21 PUBLICATIONS 227 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Photis Papademas on 13 March 2015.
The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file. All in-text references underlined in blue are added to the original document
and are linked to publications on ResearchGate, letting you access and read them immediately.
Vol. 51, No 3 August 1998 I n ferncrtionul .Iortrnaf qf Dairy Terhnologj.
Halloumi, the traditional cheese of Cyprus, is extremely popular in the Middlc Eust uiid the
Mediterranean regions of Europe and in recent years exports from Cyprus have risen. The basic
cheesemaking process places halloumi in the family of white brined cheeses, but some of its
characteristics are quite unique. This paper reviews the studies that have been carried out on the
chemical composition, manufacturing procedure(s), sensory quality and storage of halloumi, and
considers some proposed developments, such as the use of reconstituted milk powders or
homogenized milk.
98
Vol, 51, No 3 August 1998 International Journal of Dairy Technology
Fresh pasteurized ovine, caprine, bovine examined as well: and differences in the
milk or a mixture percentages of fat and protein between the
i
Coagulation with rennet at 33kl"C
two milks affected the yield of the cheese.
Alterations in the technology were rated as
important in the following respects: (i) the
for 40-60 min. cooking time of the cheese should be shorter
J-
Curd cutting to 1 cm3 grains
when using ovine milk alone; and (ii) the
pressure applied to the initial curd in order to
expel the whey has to be greater and applied
i
The coagulum rests and precipitates
for a longer period of time when bovine milk
is the main ingredient. Economides et all0
employed pure ovine, caprine and bovine
for 10 min milks for the production of halloumi cheese,
i
Pressure of 550 Pa of curd for 1 h
and a mixture of equal parts of ovine and
caprine milks. The chemical composition of
the cheeses was determined (see Table l), and
i-
Cook for 1 h
Chemical composition
According to the Cypriot Standards, the fin-
J-
Drain and cool
ished product should contain a maximum 3%
of sodium chloride and a minimum fat-in-dry
matter level of 43%. The maximum moisture
J.
Dry salted (3% wiw), and sprinkled
content for halloumi cheese is 46%. Most
products on the market meet these require-
ments, and some typical analyses are shown
with dry Mentha viridis leaves; in Table 1.
fold crossways and leave to chill overnight Shaker et als examined which manufactur-
4
Storage in 11% NaCl whey or
ing variables influenced the chemical compo-
sition and physical and sensory properties of
halloumi cheese made from bovine milk. The
shrink wrap composition was measured in terms of mois-
Fig. 1. Traditional process for production of halloumi ture-non-fat substance (MNFS), fat-in-dry
cheese. matter (FDM), salt-in-moisture (S/M) and
pH. The calcium to solids-non-fat-non-salt
increase in the centre of the block depends (Ca/SNFNS) was also determined as it could
heavily on its dimension^.^ Contrasts between be an important factor with respect to the
the use of ovine or bovine milks have been stretchability of heated cheese. The authors
99
VoI. 51, No 3 August I998 International Journal of Dairy Technology
concluded that improved stretch and melt to detect the adulteration of ovine milk with
characteristics, and a tender mouth feel of the bovine milk used for the manufacture of
heated cheese, could be achieved by lowering kishk, Kaminarides et all' believed that the
both the pH of the cheese and the Ca/SNFNS severe heat treatment employed during the
ratio. Tenderness with respect to mouth feel manufacture of halloumi cheese would, in the
also improved at high levels of MNFS. present context, invalidate the procedure.
Although the traditional cheese is always
made with ovine milk-a raw material that is Physical properties of halloumi
in short supply, the growing market demand As mentioned above, halloumi cheese should
for halloumi has raised the fear that manu- melt and stretch on heating, which means that
facturers may attempt to adulterate ovine the compact texture of the cheese will be
milk with the bovine equivalent. The possi- partly lost and a degree of flow introduced to
bility of detecting bovine milk in halloumi the melted cheese. These properties are often
cheese that should be of ovine origin was referred to as the 'meltability' and 'stretcha-
examined by Kaminarides et all1 using poly- bility' of the cheese and, although obvious to
acrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE). This the consumer, they are characteristics that are
approach was based on the fact that the elec- not easy to quantify.
trophoretic mobility of bovine and ovine a,l- Nevertheless, attempts to assess these fea-
caseins differ, with bovine a,l -casein showing tures and, in one study, the meltability of hal-
more rapid migration. The electrophoretic loumi cheese was determined' by measuring
profile of this specific casein ( a , ~was
) chosen the percentage increase in area after cubes of
because it remains almost intact during both cheese (2 cm sides) were placed in sealed alu-
cheese manufacture (cooking of the curd) and minium dishes and held in a boiling water
cold storage under brine (7% NaCl). bath for 25 minutes. The stretchability was
For the detection of bovine milk, samples measured by placing pieces of cheese pre-
of halloumi cheese at 1 day and 40 days after warmed in a water bath at 85°C for 4.5 min-
production were subjected to PAGE. A den- utes onto the base plate of an Instron Testing
sitometer, adjusted with the asl-casein band Instrument (Instron Ltd, High Wycombe,
from genuine bovine halloumi cheese, was UK), and then with a special hook, stretching
used to quantify the level of bovine milk pre- the soft cheese until the strand broke; the
sent in the adulterated samples by expressing length of the strand at the point of breaking
the density of the band for bovine o&-casein of was recorded. The relevant figures are shown
each sample as a percentage of that from gen- in Table 2, along with some com arable data
uine bovine milk. The authors detected per- relating to mozzarella B
An alterna-
centages as low as 2.5% bovine milk in tive method for measuring meltability is the
samples of ovine halloumi cheese, irrespective Schreiber Test,ls which involves positioning
of the age of the cheese. Linear relationships round samples of cheese in glass petri dishes,
between the densities of the bovine &I-casein and then placing the dishes in an oven at
bands in the adulterated samples and the per- 232°C for exactly 5 minutes.I6 The dishes are
centages of bovine milk in the cheeses were removed from the oven, and the increase in
found to be between 2.5% and 10% levels of diameter of the melted cheese over the original
adulteration, and regression equations were is recorded after approximately 30 minutes.
produced. These equations made it easy to cal-
However, the problem with tests of this
culate levels of bovine milk higher than 2.5%
type is that they are rarely reproducible, and
in cheese samples of unknown composition.
the comparison of the results in Table 2 for
Although Tamime et aZ'* suggested that
immunological techniques could be employed meltability suggests that the variation is
between techniques rather than products; it is
most unlikely that halloumi cheese would
spread on heating more than mozzarella.
Nevertheless, the values for relative stretcha-
bility are more in line with the expected
results, in that the properties of mozzarella
made from fresh milk are quite different from
those made from the recombined material;
the same appears to be true for halloumi.
The effect of homogenization pressure on
the physical properties of mozzarella cheese can
be seen from the results obtained by Lelievre et
aL4 The most likely explanation is that, as
the homogenization pressure is raised, the
increased number of small fat globules retain
additional casein at the fat-water interface. The
formation of permanent crosslinks between
the casein micelles then effectively traps the fat
phase, so reducing the flow properties of the
100
Vol. 51, No 3 August 1998 International Journal of Dairy Technology
heated cheese; a similar trend is evident with have little in common with other brined
halloumi cheese. This hypothesis also explains cheeses like feta or domiati, as the cooking of
the action of lecithin, in that by forming a sur- the curd causes considerable losses. Indeed, the
face film over the fat globules, the lecithin coat- main volatiles found in commercial halloumi
ing prevents the casein micelles from adsorbing cheese were an unidentified lactone, probably
onto the fat-water interface; the crosslinking arising from the breakdown of fat, and some
reactions are, therefore, limited, so leaving the alcohols, acids and phenols arising from the
cheese to stretch and flow under stress. degradation of amino acids. Partial Least
Whether or not the use of recombined milk Square regression analysis was used to predict
has exaggerated the proposed interactions is mean sensory scores from the headspace data,
not clear, but a similar effect was reported by and a ‘minty’ flavour was predicted successful-
Apostolopoulos,’3who compared the stretch- ly from the presence of pulegone, ‘mint ter-
ability of mozzarella cheese manufactured by pene’ and carvone. The presence of a fatty
a standard procedure with the properties of flavour was loosely predicted on the basis of
mozzarella cheese made with homogenized two compounds only-acetic acid and an
milk (17.2 MPa). In the case of the standard unidentified compound-while predictions of
cheese, the average stretchability was 53 cm creamy and milky associated with nonanone
but, probably for the reasons given earlier, and phenol were adequate.
homogenization reduced this figure to 27 cm. Two points worth mentioning in this con-
Neither the ripening time during manufac- text are: (i) the complete absence of starter
ture nor time in storage affect significantly the cultures and/or enzymes in both the tradition-
stretch values of mozzarella cheese,13 proba- al and current cheesemaking practices apart,
bly because any potential proteolytic activity of course, from the rennet which is used to
from residual coagulant is prevented by the coagulate the milk and the natural enzymes
heat treatment of the curd (58-60°C). This present in the milk; and (ii) traditionally,
inactivation means that any degradation of ovine and/or caprine milks were used for the
the paracasein is limited as, consequently, are manufacture of halloumi but nowadays the
changes in the melting characteristics of the large dairies use bovine milk almost exclu-
cheese. The cooking of halloumi is likely to sively. This gradual transition towards bovine
have a similar effect, but the influence of
milk has resulted from the low levels of pro-
other aspects of processing might merit fur-
duction of ovine and caprine milks, but the
ther attention.
For example, Renda et all6 reported that change has had an impact on the sensory
the meltability of mozzarella cheese was quality of the cheese, since the ‘old’ aroma
affected by the speed of mechanical mixer and flavour have been lost.
screws used for stretching the curd during The use of starter cultures to ripen pasteur-
manufacture. In particular, the highest screw ized milk prior to coagulation has been sug-
speed resulted in a cheese with lower moisture gested as a means to enhance the flavour
and FDM contents, and these compositional profile,” and a mixture of mesophilic bacteria,
changes reduced the meltability values eg, Lactococcus lactis subsp lactis and
obtained with the Schreiber Test. Processing Lactococcus lactis subsp cremoris, or ther-
variables, such as the time and temperature mophilic species like Streptococcus tho-
of pressing, that could affect the moisture mophilus might be considered. Papademas
content of halloumi cheese could be equally (unpublished data) has examined the employ-
important, and this aspect of halloumi manu- ment of coccus: rod mixtures of thermophilic
facture could merit further attention. microorganisms, such as Strep thermophilus
and Lactobacillus helveticus, a combination
Sensory features of halloumi that shows both high proteolytic and acidify-
The analysis of volatiles of halloumi and their ing a~tivity.’~-’’Whether this proposal will
relationship with flavour has been r e p ~ r t e d , ’ ~provide halloumi from bovine milk with a
and a panel of 11 assessors used Quantitative more intense flavour remains to be established.
Descriptive Analysis to profile the flavour and
texture attributes of raw, fried and grilled hal- Storage conditions and microbiology
loumi cheese. Principal Component Analysis It has been determined that halloumi cheese
of the sensory data highlighted significant dif- can be stored successfully for a week at 20°C or
ferences between individual product-cooking for 40 days at 4°C and during storage the salt
combinations, and specific analyses of the and moisture contents increase as the cheese
flavour components differentiated between absorbed brine.22The change in levels of solu-
sweet and sour sensations. The descriptors for ble nitrogen was minimal during storage, so
texture ranged from coarse and grainy to confirming that proteolytic activity is limited.
milky and creamy, and the ‘milky, creamy This latter observation is accounted for by the
and fatty’ characters of halloumi cheese were high temperatures employed when the curd is
easily detected by assessors when the cheese cooked, which eliminates most of the microor-
was heated. ganisms that could initiate proteolytic and/or
The volatiles in halloumi cheese, as detected lipolytic action; >1o3colony forming units (cfu)
by gas chromatography (headspace analysis) g-’ were reported for fresh halloumi.”
101
Vol. 51, No 3 August 1998 International Journal of Dairy Technology
102
Vol. 51, No 3 August I998 International Journal of Dairy Technology
cheese, the use of the procedure could cause kishk with bovine milk. In Production and Utilization
of Ewe and Goat Milk. Robinson R K, Vallerand F,
legal problems as far as the identity of the Le Jaouen J-C, eds. IDF Document No. SI 9603.
cheese is concerned. Brussels: International Dairy Federation.
Some standard methods for the sampling 13 Apostolopoulos C (1994) Simple empirical and fun-
damental methods to determine objectively the
of milk and milk products are included in the stretchability of Mozzarella cheese. Journal of Dairy
Cyprus Standards, as are methods for the Research 61 405413.
chemical and microbiological analyses of the 14 Guinee T P and O’Callaghan D J (1997) The use of a
simple empirical method for objective quantification
same it ern^.*^-^^ The compilation of such stan- of the stretchability of cheese on cooked pizza pies.
dards has proved to be valuable as far as the Journal of Food Engineering 31 147-161.
15 Kosikowski F V (1982) Cheese and Fermented Milk
drive to improve the quality of halloumi Foods, 2nd ed, pp 382412. Brooktondale NY: F V
cheese is concerned, but finding uniform Kosikowski and Associates.
methods of analysis for the physical or 16 Renda A, Barbano D M, Yun J J, Kindstedt P S and
Mulvaney S J (1997) Influence of screw speeds of
organoleptic properties of the product may be the mixer at low temperature on characteristics of
more difficult. Mozzarella cheese. Journal of Dairy Science 80
1901- 1907.
17 Pigott J R, Margomenou A, Withers S J and Conner
Photis Papademas wishes to thank the Cyprus J M (in press) Sensory characterisation of Halloumi
Milk Industry Organization (CMIO) for cheese and relationship with headspace composition.
financial support, and Keses Dairy, Limassol, In Proceedings of the Ninth International Flavour
Conference. Mussinan C, ed. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
Cyprus, for their helpful discussions. 18 Robinson R K (1991) Halloumi cheese-the product
and its manufacture. In Feta and Related Cheeses, pp
144-158. Robinson R K. Tamime A Y. eds. London:
REFERENCES Ellis Horwood.
19 Haddadin M S Y (1986) Microbiology of white-brined
1 Fox P F (1986) Cheese: an overview. In Cheese: cheeses. In Developments in Food Microbiology, vol 2,
Chemistry, Physics and Microbiology, vol 1, 2nd ed, pp 67-89. Robinson R K, ed. London: Elsevier
pp 1-37. Fox P F, ed. London: Chapman & Hall. Applied Science.
2 Information Bulletin (1997) Statistics and Research 20 Kindstedt P S (1991) Functional properties of moz-
Department, Ministry of Finance. Nicosia, Cyprus. zarella cheese on vizza: a review. Cultured Dairy
3 Robinson R K, Haddadin M S Y and Abdullah B M Products Journal 26-27-3 1.
(1991) Halloumi cheese-some aspects of manufac- 21 Kindstedt P S (1993) Effect of manufacturing factors,
ture and quality. South African Journal of Dairy composition, and proteolysis on the functional char-
Science 23 61-64. acteristics of mozzarella cheese. Critical Reviews in
4 Lelievre J, Shaker R S and Taylor M W (1990) The Food Science and Nutrition 33 167-187.
role of homogenization in the manufacture of hallou- 22 Anifantakis E M and Kaminarides S E (1984)
mi and mozzarella cheese from recombined milk. Changes in the microflora and the quality of
Journal of the Society of Dairy Technology 43 21-24. Halloumi cheese kept in 10% brine at 4°C and 20°C.
5 Anifantakis E M and Kaminarides S E (1981) Greek Dairy Federation Bulletin l(3) 5-15.
Contribution to the study of Halloumi cheese. Journal 23 Gohil V S, Ahmed M A, Davies R and Robinson R
of Agricultural Research 5 4411150. K (1995) Incidence of Listeria spp. in retail foods in
6 Anifantakis E M and Kaminarides S E (1982) the United Arab Emirates. Journal of Food Protection
Contribution to the study of Halloumi cheese made 58 102-104.
from cow’s milk. Journal of Agricultural Research 6 24 Kaminarides S E and Anifantakis E M (1985)
119-127. Changes in the microbiological burden and the quali-
7 Anifantakis E M and Kaminarides S E (1983) ty of Halloumi cheese kept in brine 10% at 4°C and
Contribution to the study of Halloumi cheese made 20°C. Modern Technology and Quality Control.
from sheep’s milk. Australian Journal of Dairy Proceedings of the First Panhellenic Food Conference,
Technology 58 29-3 1. pp 384395. Thessaloniki: Thessaloniki University
8 Shaker R R, Lelievre J, Taylor M W, Anderson J A of Agriculture.
and Gilles J (1987) Manufacture, composition and 25 Lelievre J, Shaker R S and Taylor M W (1991) The
functional properties of Halloumi cheese from bovine influence of milk powder characteristics of the prop-
milk. New Zealand Journal of Dairy Science and erties of Halloumi cheese made from recombined
Technology 22 181-189. milk. Journal of the Society of Dairy Technology 44
9 CYS 94 (1985) Standard for fresh Halloumi cheese. 414.
Cyprus Organization for Standards and Control of 26 OKeefe A M and Phelan J A (1983) Manufacture of
Quality 1-3; Nicosia. Halloumi cheese. Research Report. Dublin: Food
10 Economides S, Georghiades E and Mavrogenis A P Science and Technology, The Agricultural Institute.
(1987) The effect of different milks on the vield and 27 CYS 95 (1980) Standard for sampling method for milk
chemical composition of Halloumi cheese. kechnical and milk products. Cyprus Organization for Standards
Bulletin 90. Cyprus: Agricultural Research Institute. and Control of Quality 1-8, Nicosia.
11 Kaminarides S E, Kandarakis J G and Moschopoulou 28 CYS 96 (1981) Standard for method of analyses for
E (1995) Detection of bovine milk in ovine Halloumi milk and milk products. Cyprus Organization for
cheese by electrophoresis of al-casein. Australian Standards and Control of Quality 1-20, Nicosia.
Journal of Dairy Technology 50 58-61, 29 CYS 96/Part 2 (1982) Standard for microbiological
12 Tamime A Y, Barclay M N I, OConnor T P and method for the examination of milk and milk products.
Anifantakis E M (1996) Comparison of different Cyprus Organization for Standards and Control of
methods to detect the adulteration of caprine milk Quality 1-27, Nicosia.
103