Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1808-Article Text-8068-3-10-20230716
1808-Article Text-8068-3-10-20230716
1 Maternal, Fetal and Neonatal Health Research Center, Institute of Family Health, Tehran
University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
2 Department of Clinical and Health Psychology, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
Objective: This study aimed to investigate and identify the psychosocial factors that are associated with
paternal postpartum depression.
Materials and methods: A longitudinal correlation study with 150 fathers was performed with three time
frames (late pregnancy, postpartum, and four weeks postpartum). The Edinburgh Postnatal Depression
Scale assessed those with depression (38.7%; n=58) and those without depressive symptoms (61.3%;
n=92). Psychological variables related to paternal depression were also assessed through questionnaires.
Results: Psychological variables such as marital adjustment and stress had a significant relationship
with paternal depression. In addition, depressed fathers experienced less marital compatibility and more
tension than non-depressed fathers.
Conclusion: These findings emphasize the importance of considering the psychosocial variables that
affect paternal psychological health. Mental health professionals may be able to reduce mental
disorders, stress, psychological distress, and marital maladjustment in fathers with appropriate
psychological interventions.
Keywords: Father; Depression; Postpartum Period; Psychology; Marital Relationship; Paternal Behavior
Copyright © 2022 Tehran University of Medical Sciences. Published by Tehran University of Medical Sciences.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 4.0 International license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/).
Noncommercial uses of the work are permitted, provided the original work is properly cited.
272 Vol. 16, No. 4, December 2022 http://jfrh.tums.ac.ir Journal of Family and Reproductive Health
Paternal Postpartum Depression
Journal of Family and Reproductive Health http://jfrh.tums.ac.ir Vol. 16, No. 4, December 2022 273
Shariat et al.
questionnaires, researchers contacted all of the as 0 and the bottom box scored as 3, and Questions
participating fathers by telephone. Participants could 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, and 10 are reverse scored from 3-0.
also refer to the research setting (hospitals) to The score range is from 0-30 (24). The cut-off score
complete the questionnaires in oral sessions. A room of the questionnaire is equal to or greater than 12
with adequate space was provided to meet fathers and (12 ≤), and its Cronbach's alpha value is 0.70 (25).
complete questionnaires at Vali Asr and Milad The Dyadic Adjustment Scale (DAS) includes
hospitals (n = 215). Sixty-five fathers dropped out of 32 items, which evaluates marital satisfaction over
the study (30%). Sixty-nine percent (n = 45) of the the prior 12 months (26). This scale has 4 subsets of
fathers refused to participate because of a lack of the main scale: (1) Dyadic Consensus, comprising
interest in the study and its continuation; thirty-one 13 items that ask participants to agree or disagree on
percent of them (n = 20) were interested in taking a number of issues; (2) Dyadic satisfaction, which
part in the study but due to work involvement and includes 10 items that evaluate aspects of perceived
lack of time refused to participate. stability of marriage and how to manage problems
Fathers who agreed to participate in the study all and disputes; (3) Affectional Expression, containing
met at the hospital with the researcher (n = 150), and 4 items that examine the degree of accord on how
the researcher explained how and when to complete emotions are expressed; and (4) Bilateral Dyadic
the self-assessment questionnaires at three different Cohesion, consisting of 5 items that distinguish the
times: (1) late in pregnancy; (2) postnatal; and (3) frequency of interactions between couples. Higher
4 weeks after delivery. The minimum time estimated scores demonstrate a higher quality of marital
to complete the questionnaires was 15 minutes and the relationships. The internal consistency of this scale is
maximum was 90 minutes. The questionnaires were 0.91, (Alpha=0.80) (27).
given to the fathers in three separate envelopes with The Parent Expectations Survey (PES) is used to
the date of implementation on them. Participants were measure perceptions of self-efficacy immediately
asked to send questionnaires to the hospital after after entering parenthood (28). The Parent
completion. Gift cards of 50,000 tomān (US $12) were Expectations Survey contains 25 statements each
given to fathers for the completion of questionnaires. rated from 0-10. The sum of the scores represents the
The Ethics Committee of Tehran University of mean of all expressions. The highest score indicates a
Medical Sciences approved this project (# 24057). greater perception of parental efficacy. The internal
After a thorough explanation of the plan and its aims, stability is PES 0.90, (Alpha=0.70) (1).
informed consent was obtained from the participators. One of the most common measurements for stress
The Beck Depression Inventory (BDI) is a is the Parenting Stress Index (PSI), a 120-item
self-scored scale containing 21 items. In this test the questionnaire developed by Abidin in 1995 (29). The
key symptoms that are examined include mood, short form of this questionnaire (PSI-Sf), based on the
pessimism, sense of failure, despair, guilt, punishment, long form, contains 36 parental self-reported items that
self-hatred, self-criticism, suicidal ideation, crying, are scored based on the Likert scale from 1-5. The
irritability, social withdrawal, poor decision making, questionnaire has three subscales and each of these has
change in body image, difficulty at work, insomnia, 12 items and a score range from 12-60. Higher scores
fatigue, loss of appetite, weight loss, burn out indicate an increase in parental stress. The three
syndrome, and loss of libido. The scoring scale is subscales include: (1) the Parental Distress (PD) scale
presented in a multiple-choice format with numerical which indicates parental distress based on the parental
values of 0-3 (0 = minimum, 3 = maximum) and the role-the PD factor indicates 12.2% of parental stress
possible total for the whole test is from zero to and the Cronbach's alpha is 0.82; (2) the Difficult
sixty-three (22). (13 <Mild Depression, 19 < Moderate Child (DC) scale which is for children who are
Depression, and 28 <Severe Depression). The validity difficult to take care of-the DC factor includes 13.2%
and reliability of the questionnaires were 0.93 and of parental stress and the Cronbach's alpha is 0.83);
0.92, respectively, (Alpha=0.92) (23). and (3) the Parent-Child Dysfunctional Interaction
The Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (P-CDI) scale which manifests 12.6% of parental
(EPDS) is a postnatal rating scale for depression that distress and has a Cronbach's alpha of 0.78 (1,30).
contains 10 items scored on a scale of 0-3 based on The Multidimensional Scale of Perceived Social
the severity of depressive symptoms. Questions 1, 2, Support (MSPSS) has been developed to measure
and 4 are scored from 0 to 3 with the top box scored perceived social support from family, friends, and
274 Vol. 16, No. 4, December 2022 http://jfrh.tums.ac.ir Journal of Family and Reproductive Health
Paternal Postpartum Depression
influential people in life (31) and this tool consists of adequate income levels. Of these, 66.7% of the
12 items each of which has a range from 1-7 fathers (100 persons) were working for the
(1 = strongly disagree to 7 = strongly agree). For the government and 33.3% of them (50 persons) had
total score, the scores of all the items are summed up private or freelance jobs. Duration of married life
and divided by the number of items (12). The score of ranged from 2 to 19 years with a mean and standard
each subscale is also obtained by summing the scores of deviation of M = 7; SD = 4.24; the most frequent
the items divided by the number of items (4). The duration was 6 years or less (53.3%). Results showed
reliability of the scale using the Cronbach's alpha that 56.7% of fathers (n = 85) were experiencing
coefficient for the three subscales (family, friends, fatherhood for the first time, 33.3% (n = 50) had one
important people in life) and the total score were child, and 10% (n = 15) had two children before the
reported at 0.89, 0.90, 0.90, and 0.94, respectively (32). birth of their newborn. According to reports given by
Information such as paternal age (≤34 vs. > 34 the fathers, 86.4% (95) of mothers had a cesarean
years), level of education (university education vs. no section while 13.6% (15) of mothers had a normal
university education), father's job (public vs. private), delivery. Fathers who reported a history of abortion
socioeconomic class (low and medium vs. good), comprised 46.7% (70 women) of which 16.7%
duration of marriage (≤6 vs. >6 years), having/ (25 women) experienced abortion once, 23.3%
not having children and number of children (1 child (35 women) twice, 3.3% (5 women) three times and
vs. 2 children), type of delivery (normal vs. cesarean 3.3% (5 women) four times. The results demonstrated
section), having/not having an abortion before birth that 50% of infants (75 persons) were female and half
and the number of abortions (once versus more than were male. Sixty-five parents dropped out of the
once)was obtained from the demographic study due to work difficulties and lack of interest in
characteristics of the father’s questionnaire and the completing the questionnaires (Table 1).
data was encoded. It should be noted that 40 fathers
did not report the type of delivery while only 110 Table 1: Characteristics of the sample
fathers did indicate this on the questionnaire. Variables Variables Total (n=150) %
with more than 3 categories and continuous variables Age of the Father
were divided into 2 categories based on the median. ≤ 34 years (22-34 years) 51.3% (77)
Data were analyzed with using descriptive > 34 years (35-48 years) 48.7% (73)
statistics (frequency, percentage, mean and standard Level of education
< University 50% (75)
deviation) and correlational statistics (chi-square test
≥ University 50% (75)
and t-test 2 independent samples) the relationship
Job of the Father
between postpartum depression and psychosocial Government Job 66.7% (100)
factors and demographic characteristics and Private Job 33.3% (50)
dependent sample t-test for measuring the relation Socio-economic Level
between the tests in two stages of after birth and one Low & Medium 53.3% (80)
month after childbirth. And also using SPSS Good 46.7% (70)
software (version 20.0 Armonk, NY: IBM Corp). Duration of marriage
≤ 6 years (2-6 years) 53.3% (80)
Results > 6 years (7-19 years) 46.7% (70)
The samples included 150 fathers who participated in Having child 43.3% (65)
Number of child
the study. These fathers had a mean age of M = 34.44
One child 33.3% (50)
(SD = 5.14) and an age range of 22-48 years. The
Two children 10% (15)
highest frequency in age was 34 and 51.3% were Type of delivery
under this age. Regarding educational level, 10.7% Natural 13.6% (15)
(n = 16) were under high school level, 39.3% (n = 59) Cesarean 86.4% (95)
had a diploma and 50% (n = 75) had bachelor's Abortion experience (yes) 46.7% (70)
degrees or above. In determining the socio-economic Once (Abortion) 16.7% (25)
level based on income, 3.3% (5 persons) had low and More than once (Abortion) 30% (45)
inadequate income, 50% (75 persons) were at the
middle-income level, and 46.7% (70 persons) had The results regarding the relationship between the
Journal of Family and Reproductive Health http://jfrh.tums.ac.ir Vol. 16, No. 4, December 2022 275
Shariat et al.
demographic variables of prenatal depression and the two groups of depressed and non-depressed
postnatal depression showed that there were no fathers (Table 3).
significant differences between depressed and
non-depressed groups using the Beck (prenatal) and Discussion
Edinburgh (postnatal) tests, and the groups were The results showed that the prevalence of
identical. The Beck Depression Inventory assessed postpartum depression in fathers was from 38.7% to
paternal depression at 35 weeks and late pregnancy. 28% based on EPDS and BACK. These statistics
The results showed that 38.7% (58 fathers) had signs show that the rate of postpartum depression among
of depression, and it was mild depression. In addition, Iranian fathers and other studies with a prevalence
the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Questionnaire of 3 to 12% (33,34). Therefore, shows that The
assessed paternal depression for two time frames prevalence of depression in Iranian fathers is higher
(after birth and four weeks after birth). Results than other studies .It may be due to severe economic
showed that 30% (45 fathers) had depressive problems in the country. In the general population,
symptoms the second stage and had depression the prevalence of mood disorders was reported to be
28% (42 fathers) in the third time. The prevalence 14.6%, major depressive disorder in men 10.2%, and
and frequency of depression appeared to be the same depression in adult men 10% (35). According to the
at all three periods (prenatal, postnatal, and four presented statistics, it seems that paternal depression
weeks postpartum) and did change over time. is more than the average population and depression
In analyzing the data of psychosocial variables at among men in Iran increases with pregnancy and
the two stages of postnatal and one month after birth, has a high prevalence. The results of this study
the results showed that paternal depression decreased showed that psychological factors, such as marital
one month after childbirth in comparison to the adjustment four weeks after Birth is significantly
postnatal stage and this difference was statistically associated with paternal depression. Other studies
significant (M = 4.80 VS M = 4.47; P = 0.018). In have shown that spousal depression and low marital
addition, according to fathers’ reports, infant care satisfaction are significantly associated with
ability (parental expectations) increased one month postpartum depression one-month postpartum (36).
after delivery with a statistically significant Shorey reported marital dissatisfaction and sexual
difference (M = 169.20 VS M = 177.00; P ≤ 0.0001). needs, it is effective in postpartum depression for
Finally, paternal stress had a decrease that was parents (37). The results of the present study showed
statistically significant (M = 73.13 VS M = 69.40; that fathers in the depressed group had more stress
P ≤ 0.0001) by the one-month-after-birth time frame than the non-depressed group after delivery.
in comparison to the postnatal stage. Other Previous studies demonstrated that psychological
psychosocial variables such as marital compatibility distress was significantly associated with
and parental support had no statistically significant postpartum depression (38) and that fathers who had
difference among fathers at the two stages of stress or poor physical health were exposed to
postnatal and one month after birth (Table 2). depressive symptoms. Increased symptoms of
There was no significant difference in parental postpartum depression are associated with various
expectations and perceived social support between social and psychological factors (33).
276 Vol. 16, No. 4, December 2022 http://jfrh.tums.ac.ir Journal of Family and Reproductive Health
Paternal Postpartum Depression
The results of the present study indicated that related to postpartum depression are more than
paternal depression and stress decreased one month depression unrelated to the postnatal phase and
after birth while parental self-efficacy in parenthood generalized anxiety after delivery is more common
increased during the month after childbirth. than postpartum depression (42-44). Paternal anxiety
This study investigates the psychosocial factors increases before and during delivery and decreases
connected to paternal depression, such as marital after childbirth. Paternal anxiety has a negative
adjustment, parental expectations, social support, and impact on the father's psychological health, physical
psychological stress, which lead to an increase of health, social relationships, and parental skills and
awareness and understanding of paternal depression. causes stress, depression, fatigue, and decreased
Reports have suggested that postpartum depression is paternal self-efficacy (45). Depression and stressful
associated with poor marital relationships (39, 40). responses of the father may affect the family
Experts in the psychological health field have environment and, ultimately, the growth of the child
suggested that parental mental health and marital and adolescent. Findings have indicated that
relations should be considered. Identifying the factors symptoms of paternal depression and father-child
associated with paternal depression, which can lead conflicts are associated with emotional and
to the prevention of marital dissatisfaction or increase behavioral problems in children, which may have
the quality of marital relations, is vital for the been brought about through negative parenting.
prevention and early detection of paternal depression Preventive interventions focused on symptoms of
(36). Paternal depression is associated with a history paternal depression, and father-child conflict should
of mental disorders, psychological distress during be considered (46-48).
pregnancy, low income, unemployment, maternal Investigations in most studies focus on maternal
postpartum depression, and neonatal diseases that are depression, and few studies have focused on paternal
undergoing medical treatment (38). Psychosocial psychological health and how it affects children.
variables should be considered as effective risk Therefore, further studies are needed to investigate
factors in early screening and targeted prevention is the prevalence of psychiatric disorders and their
available for fathers who are at risk of depression related factors in fathers. Men generally tend to be
during the transition to parenthood (41). Professionals treated less; however, they may be more willing to
need to develop training packages that help spouses have their symptoms of depression treated if they are
achieve marital satisfaction and its positive aware of the positive effects of treatment on their
consequences on psychological health, which include child. Thus, health care providers and professionals
models of healthy communication between couples who are dealing with children and families should
during pregnancy to one year after childbirth, and encourage fathers to promote the psychological
provide these training packages to health care health of all family members (49). In addition, it
providers so they can present them to those in need of seems that systemic collaboration is possible between
marital counseling services. mental health professionals and gynecologists-
Stress, anxiety, and depressive symptoms have midwives in the procedure of postpartum depression
been reported in fathers during the transition to treatment, and therapeutic and psychological services
parenthood. Findings show that symptoms of anxiety could be provided immediately after delivery to
Journal of Family and Reproductive Health http://jfrh.tums.ac.ir Vol. 16, No. 4, December 2022 277
Shariat et al.
depressed mothers and mothers who are hospitalized problems. BDI (late pregnancy) and EPDS
(50). Unfortunately, during pregnancy, only the (postpartum) questionnaires were used as tools for
physical and mental health of the mother is screening and identifying signs and symptoms of
considered, and the mental health of fathers is not depression in fathers. It should be noted that fathers
examined; as a result, the diagnoses of anxiety, stress who received a score of 14 on the BDI or a score of
and emotional problems of fathers are neither 12 on the EPDS via face-to-face interviews, were
common nor taken seriously by medical professionals given information about psychological health so they
and health care providers (51). It seems that could use psychological services if they desired.
professionals and health care providers do not have One of the limitations of this study was the selection
the knowledge, cognition, and planning necessary to of individuals using the available sampling method,
provide health care to fathers and their needs are which may not lead to the same chance of presences all
neglected (1). Given the importance of family health of the fathers generally with different experiences.
and the lack of information on paternal postpartum Another limitation of this study was sampling
depression, especially in developing countries, from public hospitals in Tehran, where people from
paternal mental health screening during the prenatal different socioeconomic classes referred, and no
stage (even before pregnancy) should be performed sampling was done in private hospitals in Tehran.
(52). Various studies have indicated that potential This study needs to be repeated with a variety of
psychological therapies include cognitive-behavioral samples from different private and public centers.
therapy (CBT); group work; electronic support Another limitation of this study, which is related
(e-support); and psychotherapy interventions for to cultural issues in our country, is the unwillingness
incompatibilities and cognitive distortions related to of men to complete questionnaires. Also, due to the
masculine identity, masculine role expectations, and large number of questionnaires, there is a possibility
feelings of isolation and rejection are effective in that the questionnaires may not have been completed
promoting paternal mental health in the perinatal and correctly. It seems that the use of diagnostic
postpartum periods (53). It also appears that parental interviews and oral questioning is the best option for
involvement, especially of fathers, in parenting can conducting studies on men in our country.
lead to a sense of self-efficacy, increased levels of
social cohesion, reinforcement of self-perception of Conclusion
skills, and confidence in parents of young children. In This study demonstrated that paternal depression was
addition to these, an increase in individual and group significantly associated with some psychological
adaptation, reduction of anxiety, and no used merely variables such as marital adjustment and stress. Also,
limited and specific solutions to solve problems (54). depression, efficacy, or parental expectations and
In one qualitative study, it was reported that a lack of paternal stress were assessed at two stages of
awareness by fathers regarding postpartum paternal postnatal and one month postpartum. The results
depression (PPD) leads to inappropriate assessment showed that paternal depression and stress decreased
and diagnosis of PPD. Fathers acknowledged that an over time, while fathers’ parental efficacy in caring for
increase in the awareness of the community could their children increased. These findings indicate the
encourage treatment. Experts believe that supportive importance of screening for postnatal depression in
resources should be provided to men as the first step fathers. Given the importance of this subject, it seems
to encouraging treatment and identifying treatment that screening should take place not only from the time
priorities in men (51). We suggested for future of pregnancy but also until at least one year after
research such as having qualitative in-depth childbirth. Paternal depression affects psychological
interviews from Iranian fathers to understand their in- components such as mental health, stress, marital
depth emotional needs. relations, quality of life, and relations or interaction
Strengths and Limitations: This study with the child; therefore, psychology professionals
investigated the psychological factors affecting should pay special attention to the mental health of
paternal depression postnatal and one month fathers. Improving the psychological health of the
postpartum. As no prior research has been done on father can lead to the health of the whole family.
paternal depression in our country, this is the first
study in this field. The fathers who participated in Conflict of Interests
this study appeared to have no psychological All authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
278 Vol. 16, No. 4, December 2022 http://jfrh.tums.ac.ir Journal of Family and Reproductive Health
Paternal Postpartum Depression
Journal of Family and Reproductive Health http://jfrh.tums.ac.ir Vol. 16, No. 4, December 2022 279
Shariat et al.
280 Vol. 16, No. 4, December 2022 http://jfrh.tums.ac.ir Journal of Family and Reproductive Health
Paternal Postpartum Depression
Med 2016; 46: 1719-33. Nigeria. J Psychosom Obstet Gynaecol 2019; 40: 57-65.
48. Sweeney S, MacBeth A. The effects of paternal 53. O'Brien AP, McNeil KA, Fletcher R, Conrad A, Wilson
depression on child and adolescent outcomes: A A J, Jones D, et al. New Fathers' Perinatal Depression
systematic review. J Affect Disord 2016; 205: 44-59. and Anxiety-Treatment Options: An Integrative Review.
49. Tichovolsky MH, Griffith SF, Rolon-Arroyo B, Arnold Am J Mens Health 2017; 11: 863-76.
DH, Harvey EA. A Longitudinal Study of Fathers' and 54. Sinclair F, Naud J.Social support and emergence of a
Young Children's Depressive Symptoms. J Clin Child feeling of parental efficiency: a pilot study on the
Adolesc Psychol 2018; 47: S190-S204. contribution of the EcoFamille program. Sante Ment
50. Šebela A, Hanka J, Mohr P. Diagnostics and modern Que. 2005;30 :193-208.
trends in therapy of postpartum depression. Ceska
Gynekol 2019; 84: 68-72.
Citation: Shariat M, Abedinia N, Charousaei H,
51. Cameron E E, Hunter D, Sedov ID, Tomfohr-Madsen
Fatahi F. The Relationship Between Paternal
LM. What do dads want? Treatment preferences for
Postpartum Depression and Psychosocial
paternal postpartum depression. J Affect Disord 2017;
Variables: A longitudinal Study in Iran. J Family
215: 62-70.
Reprod Health 2022; 16(4): 272-81.
52. Ayinde O, Lasebikan VO. Factors associated with
paternal perinatal depression in fathers of newborns in
Journal of Family and Reproductive Health http://jfrh.tums.ac.ir Vol. 16, No. 4, December 2022 281