gihacll s gail Lybasllyl, glucllamilgs Ina alépaye dale 2018-2017 Real dpa ailuell /gscall casytl gabe Ayynall cll geal qaysill cagy il Gradual City-Wide Upgrading iting diye wel al SAU dead — aly yal est is Lecture Objective 6j5l20)] Wlawi a yal Laval diag pladi qeany awn ely ggle go Ay) Aull ete} - Aisa 4/3/20186y5l.0)1 63ial Aigaad plat gaat poy atll et geld Cyd + donao all yd lal ghalbe ga Jaleil aggllal hall (gptaa) dayel baay lonal qual pa le Latatly Urban Clearance — Redevelopment Urban Upgrading 3/8/2018GA CSE Ay jb Jal ya AED cpallall plat Sit) sg (Late seg 5 le coll ponl/g pan ti SU Anat Auta) Abd gall! plainly Sl) : Asi) Maal) Gul shoal Le ( 1985 — 1970) (As Ha ally old Yi St ato! Asta ay ein Aa LDU classy ALA Aly pA -analytical planning (bist badly plat) besa) Action Planning 44it) 4 Ball hadiedy oll YI : Aa Ale jalh GE (1995-1985) Aa a pally Lardiuals YSldall Castot catlgall gale SG) cenealy acplladl) LgbAall plat) Jad Tiay dye dghe Salon py Fis chats 8 gall glo Cal jal) 5S ae Bote A Lats agally cfh Jaa! assy ae “4 Sy pal “ isi pal /ABS at Aabgadi 2S) Alte ol] Aplall oly Biju Galle gyany oY Oba SLs): ANY Ata al Citywide Upgrading Strategies DS pan SY pat ita gl patil Cull Goa colnet Aalgd ood « Physical Transformation Through the dsj ay "ylseidi bhiah Holistic Plan Bylal QUAI ae Gd GIS Lil ag Cilagteall al plasuat de ales Jy any « Agi pall bhally Cle glealt Jay» asi) data management system Clasteal} A pal cleagttl Ohi (5) COLL Lala Gelaa ly Labaily) olally ‘interventions dS) Cygne dua Sysudly La Chasleall oi Gaudi « GRAS Uasptnty « gel Vy Slain ily gil sR gp Kian ola Lutes e 25a dasa ay ltllas « zone of special interest Auats Apaal cilS Aylaas NAL Asst cle pl poly CLaally Lend Queda il gl Ge Gbtiall 3/8/2018 ofigual) placl qual ga ail pli ede Gradual City-Wide Upgrading Al gall alyally Rotates Lasley Gay sl eo gall 1 ai sy Aha GEL Qopany gl) Ib che gpd San DLE Gee Jags Unda daa AUN ca GaN os Aida olpall Ai | Aadays pd rll oll Hija path ganas pA hey Aaland) oa 1 pSiay (10s, > Milly net dE OSs Concept of Gradual City- Wide Upgrading Conventional Approach Pr Leo 1 City-Wide Upgrading Strategy GE ole Dae Upming Pine or Of Ua Delopmart 3/8/2018diol slail gLoU yaya! sLAIjUI aio Yul PAR YY Goal yy Split Leds Clee ood eatin AS cia ant} Age URill g Ansell At pack Age leisy) Ajanti « Hay youll Alavall g Apallell col patil ga gil gill Aig pall « Wuaio ya! sai! yS6 Ggub5 Gui As) ya ABLSLd) glaLLall Slide y CilaLunny sHS61 ce apt anal « SSithall gan Ayal gny Ghia) ques pL YT dee coesay ply Gal Hate divey Ayal gall Bagsnall ALT CLAY ge 8) alt yaa ghlid olan! Juli Je Asean Eyal Sb poy Le YL pe ee lly ae lf Aglaly Zathlly Apel ail de jae isp cept PLY SG steal gall « 3/8/2018 a/sdiol stail p03) yoyjaill sLEI)M amioy Wool Ualo ip aRe epson as Ean carton Soe J Peso Abgsally Auth petal Gaal Ge patie cle jugs -1 Ua haga (i asta cage eth yt AS! JUS ps A Ltd ay GIS 2 eas al aA UL a ay ht gi Aseadiy LelaaY yates « ge Chea 8t ga oy SUN hg a gh SDD cfs eg) TaD QD me Fate lly Sug aly ayipall Agia a hy Seg San 3/8/2018esl Cle pape Syst -2 8 Local work group faa Jas cleans jane io Baal ae Megane op LY abe City work group at Hats opay Al Legere co daa Megane OSS AGM gan HAN ON lg gata GL Urban managers cde = gels cathy la ea Stakeholders gels) Gud - yaa 9 cud — Developers cyst aly gid Stel Go Ota Hlousers cf) ast ogee — ‘Sha pala Sass Gp = a oe Ss ole Samal — BALAN JE pee td Apt ight O “pg bets i ial dah es eee po Hyd plagues gad sO ae tani as AakeyHakgul cata ril Aaed 4d J) bas Saar and re | maurseeseseuaneatt ibaa Jot Ay pllnall cOlSl yest 4 aE qo Gd Gal ae eee) SEE | eee Hai gat) eat gta gas wens Ly iat | [ee ‘Action plans 4a oth se} Local / Public plans aid (ger at pe patiy gh Hey cd sO glad chal! gay Chart Jst sla dae O Sa ee jal SB ye (ipod eae 3/8/2018aes stl Technique git aL ity ed set a aay ga RAY Laat Jad Hegagn gt SE st Ky Mal Ja tena agen Sates chil UR aR ‘ghaty JA Holbe th eo hes geo Weights and Seores System Participatory Decision Making (ABS Delphi technique lela! paket cy © 2 pag sl sad = idea 9B et Jad Megane On oF dS a tying SG da Aegan oo el 0S + psc kina La (ala J) ay 08 I ge» Asa aaa hal pe Elen) ole Span Goal Slel Yo YS, Fata clea ga: bg BD a 3/8/2018EN CA ols laf Heth BU ge TAL Sh alge west gtoly aN Ghia ye Joh foe Gud oigh fyglhad A) city gp Agila ¥ eh pie gla ay Ups Sound Aegan Ha oie oh sine gb a aa IS Sas «Lat passaly «All aay clad 9b GH Hegane le gan oS BGS FH ae Lips testa o 5 ao clasyl Als ps 6 SES Faas Daal Ae game le AE YE asi U2 Ue a # Tr shee! oy (LeLeall Aad sh) Lele Aillyal) Als gi Boon ea §UM gue ila gh HN pajsly ulead gad) oat BS GY dnest onl ( chal! Glues dat Ho gape eal BY playa 3/8/2018 ola3/8/2018 OltQuestions 3/8/201818/07/1439 casloly gael Lyall ag, oshuad clagyl —aylens aeldganga Dale 2018-2017 CO) Kassaball dpeabaall (aslégshall) Glaball aysss eseall cay Hl Aygly Lael segball yyylea Giillaye alliage seal ol Spdalaall cilasl 1 ce Ay sh Ais alll! ple si LH) agi cilagh Wl yaa Leal « ck LM ayaa Cg cg pial) GABLY Che g yay Ca DN gta yale06/07/1439 POs espe ee le a Ga Ss le Gay Ey ty = (GUE ~ Wy gh — Yat) Shi pc gh VI Apeal © pl jae papliiy La ool} gS Quy BAS Jshtiny glia aga (Bt LEAS hla gf Motel cash gh Aaa atl a g Lig Btn iy « GLAM La ob cash il Coe B56 Es gratis gil cpl JSLAly BLE galuat Ui y « Lect Giaaly Aaa ee gl gll Ga chagll Matt aig padi) ats — Aya Mil aah — Kyl yall Ayaitll Ga sal — 1p plabdu) cle (6220) gia ALM! ~ lal alaal — a classy ee sal — sad dy pol Bypall Ques — ela) Landseape gyal euti — Blane = yp AgagdeSAI cols ghuwally Gl gh Wl Alec Addle abst pS gf Saal Qe sca Rags eA tsa tt co BAlly yh Lal cL sly Hl Lule ap Sigh Gaall Gu gh velba) gi pie Ula,06/07/1439 Vp gpa pI DM Aa gh WI ald cake 9 pally ghia!) sans Jal ya Calla pes ple La gM ld Ghia) ass Joel ya Se dal Ass GIS (es Aad) GHD ULE) sale ates scl fl Ua ll « 4.918 Techniques Api gal plasdul : Asad Ata yall « AAI lS cle pally Gbltad yasct (SAY ules) Ai As pall gli Spal od Criteria -- Criterium «les Als cis xt Meg pS foals Agha gb fe Lal a hey Al dls gl ch - he gee BeUS gh JLESI Ag ys Galil Yule GLLIYN 95 ll Shall06/07/1439 AMSAY) jules aya sy Ma yal gh gle Lgl Sey GS jules Alin os Cg pall Shpall « ily Lact o pyle At gg pie JS Of al Ey pia yl Millet psLactiyl y Lotainy) Ug jy Asal Ayal bbs this Agi pally aly ces of al Slats 5 gall Gadd puta ode Ja Lad « pues poet g PAV g Lestat) jaleall gl cea tll pubes alle Sogilaall oda Gd bag. ac Banal pall Audie ce phan Aasdtecall putea : Jie Pais RY subeal gs Le gape Basal 1330 cipal Tey eagally dSteiall pli days + Early oy sitiall ylsull ase cigall Ayan! + clatl uad + Ailaigh Aiud Ad eal + eetling pile aetna tiny + Rigel Lat Bhs egg hall Gi LAL +06/07/1439 Aah gh ald Gta sys shea y pipes GLY! Byte Clad Gayl sheet — Ta Gy wn GIS LT en ae geass | ame Sa a a Spins ol a iy oF Sh oe SLT pm GS aE (ie SRB) as Se Se at | SES IA a a ae aa ae B eae | amen | Sine ey Pa UAT eRe oe | dacs Seas ei ga es eae [San ae a (ata RE eh | Pt A a a eich | ene BORIS aie ewes SaaS | ais seihegeeeedl ies) | satay glo CS GhLbal yond dln 8 Al Apa Lgl egy cme a ee 0g ya FLD gta ANS eg da on oe Hag l BIS Ow GH Sk AS aa Se OAS ans Ee Aa 9 aa ed igs es ae wae Tepes oie | aang ap | SES | orn | | | Sok ns eats |e aia ap ” SOS SS | aaa ae || ae ate wera ‘ira aos nm etic eas | Tp GS ie SHB See acta | dpbndaaie om tos ea SS wits | magus tc 2a SS eS | a hast patho cel woe Sie | 552 3t emit | bed ae asin Seis tee ao Le06/07/1439 Hagh gh cath GhUalh apsas flee S AbjLll Apes a ail Alban lege Gia Jal lia aac yee Fanaa oe SE] tee | aS | Taw SUE ae [ene Rew | ee ie EE reste sg nee wage tag et gs Ea ae ie sh Sage | ee |S Re Sisco | ee sno spatatatle “ha ocala deo Uae wn See | ee mungoes Take |S wehagoc: SUES | Be LS Nip a aaa | Rane ese Sse | ae Sage oo ee BE cea we | ~* raed a ae od cd & Aaa Bae galt Ce gpaall pM GhLL Elgily Gatland Auth AER sit ath Hh gs Bat EL dpa: intervention JS 4gla)) «JySati Gly sisne haat AG yates aay Cay FAD gy pe JS cian] UDSY [aig hg shal) Sy paul Esta JS Agi IS ce gl gl ghia JUS) ake aad aly Tela yly Ctyaall ay Hilly gg pall Glad Ly one te Ai Kates soph gall fe AAS) ple teat pas Seal Ow06/07/1439 Aa gly cold Gall UGA! ulead ¢ yikes psa TANI gue LES ee {Gated oS egy Raa Bed usta Topas = Tadete|| Saat dns Sap fides Jat oth a, eager on seat it Bend Sl an~ satchel = ela a goes ~ Si Ss a) [peasy 5 Gain GESTS gh aa Gee cap iY ith ib cle ht as Questions06/07/1439 coastal gull hgh, cophac eagyl —Kja aalégaga dale 2018-2017 CO) Anebadl delat (ailegsball) ghballayuas epeallelagy Hl Aygly Lal Techniques spill gsLll Giillys allayd saat ot Byplnall cial roe Ay Alls Bl tke Cg 9 4459) techniques 4:3) g yh = Bige Saues See06/07/1439 AadLall Techniques 4st) gal) plaka; QAI Ala pall Agghg¥l cud cite g pally (ghLiall quasi! ile 9 pedal ag pel Lack AHI gpa Gulla! g sits dss fH Aasciually evaluation projects Leg tags Chala uae db JS Jats, clas Vl Shad ean Shady) Lali Li a ds gpk AM cil ll Cod hy eels Methods of projects evaluation “Ae 5 yall py 985 Gye Gua aay pg ab cite g pall ay git lina iS + BSS) asl cob @ sla Canal gag Agha) Ayala Lal projects evaluation Cle. all py sii vin ai Say Upladay Ciba teal gen acti sine Le se lly Malia Lobe lily « value judgment ¢9 Hal Aad le psall TS cla ghey Gg pial OS Cugl pleat ol AVI gh Sgt alta) silat) Oa SUIS! Aaa d ag dag Gh ugha) Lgl cles ial peg gp ini alls 25 gh) Uap ill Cally AbLAY 9 tial pias Aaya «Eg eal 1g) Age ca pS ( psy06/07/1439 Methods of projects evaluation St 344) ps Gye Weights & Scores System Sail ol jy bath als Delphy Technique gi eB. Participatory Decision Making 4S cal 5.0 4ethe 0 Cost-benefit analysis lally Laks gulag satay Cas cles call J gall glad cue pasitl clad Ligh ole oat Fgh izsi (ie techniques (i tly Qualia Clareaill Lgale Alay) cipal UAKly evaluators asia laa! opley aap till + GAG gigiall JLactutly Weights & Scores System Ausailh Ij sls till -Ubi Gee (Giles pall) prctiall gy Abslial (le Ai, phi ola seed peut) C3 lh Cities « plBy! cpl! Lolasas py Aeag jute PLS DUS ce all Jha pay ety gg pee Calan) que ppleall rt Cl ghSll Ga de game is gyda) gf GhLbal yaad aasiill pales ayant - Sone JS Agguall 0 5 gly SU yan Fatal) he g wall gf gbUiall LUG!) Gun . Hash Aaya aan LA js ike g pall Gas 306/07/1439 a)" Hypi Bh aus GAL ig BAN yas gp = fr ed ry Piya bubs dia Ay at; Jd yas Godan ANU dugg fd GLY asasi Saag Sesh Saha Glial PAS gg SS ALR gs pit Lag Ral dB ny iy OD oe Geddes ae ALO at etalon hl Hats AaB ent es ose (3=2-1~0) aaly obi epi kt att py li Bl A Ua Aad a tel Lays pa cals ay ele) hy Hae JS) (5914.93 2) gota cys 0 a se ge gest assed abu cagA gag Lay gh tt 8 gy Hay anh py AB Ata ysl Tybee tually yale gat chat eile errr A cay a gl 4st O A cmd geah ope Garland is Aa ahd Ae can lly pu ep ge a ee ohhh GSA ap ik Gi I Sg Aas eel 2 aa06/07/1439 seeettaeeatins a py Bho ge he {so = t pre Bre aees] 1 : Tet aes | | [[Mtucal Exclusive Projets Shia ciegy2d Unniy Ait ghiie IS, al ans DELPHI TECHNIQUE glils 45 vpleag cilaal ussite Delphi technique 4,2 sold + Objective c& 9254 JSey JLGRYt Esra Lidl 0593 AW a Le gage dbl DL Ga Sys a8 DS pb Cs GIy EUbilly puleall aysats Lysate} aay ULES Bale} Gps aay (gual Gilad Get als ol jy Ls cha gf MBL L a glial U8 SI GA) Bye ¢ pula lanl e2weights cepa Csi) Ese Dake 28 US psy Hisay A glaall 938 WS pty. saall average esl he «al cot ec! ajsisitedl atl ya vail aa « Lb yy cL glia! GLU Gad oY) s cLaaily Wed eel Go06/07/1439 Decision Making 4S)taaly )\ all dele Hagel Chg) Lpanl lla) Goa yall le Gil oda Jats citizen juries Gsse4il Osasaalls panels Ah ily CO Lal gle peal Sey aac Ug ob og pall ode (git PNRM Gaal ail LA Coe dey atyually Lecl AM shoal) @Lasa! el All ea Qeipall lyase eaten absolut Junaid Cpa Aig ys ba GE pl pabll UI eey lil Gal y E252 ag’ le pfluasi dae si options ranking dls) at ty lpasts dh e+ -yes-no recommendations ¥ 4 #4 53.44 4 ch gS eke Gall) cigs I yHl ase Ayagsne Mi all ot Guey Saal Jal! agua Aly ji pil) Aetina Cost-benefit analysis telly Aisi Jatas eh ty Sty ai had ST eet ee eis nop’ ed gd ttt iN oe inartaas) Maa Sn uSieteniat od ge da eae = A ee Seas a aa COSA aa. aged ole sada atta AUS oad 5b OMB atts “dois J common, unit ns aes ol ees ay i Cg dally COLA obs i) gh Es etal LAY Aston se sen Yom te i ena neta + gry valng 4a ach Ln pal alle on rE ay phy se fs guia By ed Se ak ad aa pas ies CESS ais ahaa Cee RE a esa ae06/07/1439 Cost-benefit analysis Sita!)s Aalsa) Jats : Benefit-to-Cost Ratio hel gyal ailye jee sal (ats Joa’ gi) aol, eal ety + (ASN gal ya fed poled AE yep gag Le Sd etn gla Lgle Gly de Seung RLM gd Bs athe pease GP et! Oe Eat agi le Feet al Shay gat lpia) HBL ety ya Ue oo [gay Mgtbslaly oY Sali ats GE a Cost-benefit analysis “tals Jalsa) Jutas Net Present Value 4it.ali 4.80) jes 4 daly pis} Cady Liter) sited) athe SoS U EE Suto g ata ental ( slau ) snes Fads al 1 J4s shadow prices L291 Lud Gus of a 1 CAS GHatlay « By pall Sits JS é e214 mutually exclusive ys! e+ Aas ys G5 a8 cols cogil JUN oy of ap aaly Jui8 ap laa Lata Lead tok diy gl dah JU! Oo AN glilys + mutually exclusive Wey Ls pal ce y call ila «alternatives us ( GeLLal ) leg pata GG Ale gl} Lia gy GL ng + Bias pall ie g pall sal a al eg pall JSS ce AY Lia oe (phy « patie oC Mlaally Syilaall Lag ng Yi Hep Yea06/07/1439 Gilaalhy Sle gyal) USY ashy Gils) Glas pla fly Le a cig ay Bl SY] + v® Os GL 584 techniques «evaluators agusill Cuatially (Oe ol 9K Rg FTO abs Gly CLA . Ce Spall LL) lll ayo! standards ways Auld Gye 4s. Gal Amal Laks « qualitative goals Fgiaaslt ae ‘c.sinee valuation auski Shy GS dieu gle Lye Lg) Sayay Clg dd Cad Cluj pall Lats ) ately AUCH Julss ol ya} Abs aA CU YD 5 aS sh gay Lous Ley ( sal Steele) Meese 9 WS jue ob Cults Cle 5 peal a gi Gye sats Jy ages) Adaya telly LABS Jos Ai ea ese a geal Aa) el as BS i} Hgts g A gg Gee pb hed yp eal Ob jgVhy BLAH ayant cy subjective 4uaid ie, N pat AS Jubal 1 Ul Feline Aly jh auc do Awtiall measurements uAUill G+06/07/1439 lain get AGENT Seg yay ASSAD Lapel ge: AED fly JN gt wae Ae aoe bs Aas Fas | fsa | Suman | bet | eats | | gaa | x > x |of]o]o |*aue x ° ° ° ° O | aaa ° ° ° * x ogy ° ° ° ° ° OO | Abts ne x huss O » O haha, Aad gga oy MDS eas GSua de « Delpy Technique gis Hye LE ee gli ket Reb were at ede ae ws yang GIS AMy BU lal aad cae od gg pad Oy Hal LMI de gene 8+ Tran Roa ha ua che Boy ganas ngs lll lan ass 8S noe 2B Al ys ise) ok YS gilt) sth gga shyla la gf BLS pg average Abasiad lan ec weights yl isl oda tbe 28S og Hay gl De Glass a oS ool Galan oie JS py Da a asl paddy 9A, clyglsf aad Gf le pq oh Bh s ranking06/07/1439 Questionsceusafly cole basa, gihad clagyl Ayla aleganga dle 2018-2017 Ascglall dpabaall lucll Aasyfl aaldgydia Qo dgcargall 2ynall adylnall anlshily spall egillne Silage aaa ah Ayalaall ga anal + pepe Eph duits eultll plc) As bal asp - 4S Atul (Clays) lage - plan BLY ce ype gh AS al La Asuka IBS 4/3/2018 NTEkey words Citizen Participation Public Participation Community Participation Participatory Planning Partnership Community enablement ‘Community empowerment se WA gal a gga sitll A alas a LRT Cigkialy Ciba sia « As tall 8 3S) he g yay AS Lally Labeda cash pled Lay 1966 plo cee Alay al gig te gE gh Has Al daly ISAT pet Lali steal JeLcel yale nag! 1975 ole opie sty lc ole ee J Si Ga ll Labial) Cues Aytaaly Qalily Hib gt tas Aha gt Aste 3 Uy Able ob LsSall b 4/3/2018GAs Laually Labeda ill a ggde Le What is participatory planning? heen eae Go Bae Gay 4 Aly Ay Alsen Jad 9 gal ( ‘Charles Abrams ~ John Turner — Horaico Caminos) cfg ce a posses abst lc Gye Bly Ube 3s} Lata - rn tasted o pha dA oH PY 18 ols YE Saal iba gi as ail A a ees cya ba SOR Sse ai GA 4/3/2018 UpsSAS Likall (Gila ys) Cal gis Le What are the levels of participation? Adylaall (skys) alysis SED aS anal al lL Creation of parameters and objects (Full control) SD eae col ply FR y laa ec oi oh Self planning pestle 8) call LAY Ay all Dig lal y tall hay 1 pS glib Choice arty Silat od a alti dh: AS) ale See oe Pe Re ae ca Se UA Feed back O59 Mecneall dpa gSall CJL oleh) DUB Ga Wad cubs ose} No participation nti ga. 4/3/2018As slide) ai} gb Le Why participatory planning? aL yjlaall silys pista) ae eee Lad ls gl aa ly OS ye AgiSuall Apes Saath Aaline JMS ca My : Ep pial! CHLIS (pb Aarlonall Gg uall LG ltl Lac gh Lally pLith lS) 5 Lidia) DIE Gee ALIS ola ; A ple thy So Lis Bulyj - Eada ay Lats iba pl gg pall yh cell uA DS Oo gl seal : wc BN ays Os 58 All As ea lh eg 4/3/2018a2jlaall silyo enablement & — (U2sj-itll Hagel Haul 545 - BaLyjt Ayla Aly 5 Rall fe Gipsy : empowerment el silly aha ple Atlan cleinall Saye Gh) eainall Ugaily opill ALLA ood pgs ida pag so posi cpa epg iuagy ts petluall ALSia ly Goal Adel dlp wali Ci alsiay) Suplaty shay) My eaipally Lact Atal stata Aadball jglati Salty Ga Who participate? 4/3/2018alal2sall slyetly adylrall aplbaitl 1 dtySighl AogSall « algal cist Muay Apualaall eal gly Ae gSaul Gadd he g plead) Auk LOU y Ada) Gant) BI shoe) ee AB all CY Laall (8 4) gall! A Syed) Capel) BA taall A 5S pall Aa gant) Athy Ge Septal) (AGL all Apallly ClSuNl Bldg dle ) Apaiilly sl psbll Yael y clog cibgtoally Bd pial! 6 GLASAY! pi Jie Aya cL lg A pally Cy neal y AB peal s a8! Cla glee auliiig ) ck gle Agatti g gest (,B Adan) laity plyagal. tlaldzall plyattly aZyloall al ail + Mela tao gSalf ciglaally «chal Bll Slat gh cya Sg sal JES = sal gS y capa 98 Aa pal Os aly Le alae pe UL FLY ga Lays Gg LB “Aggallll cilglaall 8 lal Gb go YS Hysol LgtlgS Lali] Anal agg co Jad Jay is a GS « Bae Glas DLA Gee AGB Cis acally LY) Aa 3S ll Asso Lens Aglaall GLa gl coe la gle SactH Gy 9St le 5 jail Yul - 248 Gilly Gal) 28) Alaa ch atsayt Aas pie ele a gla! 224) cual 1S Gy gSy Aalaiyl geal yall Lads (pte cal Lay Lpald of LS - Ga ple Gib thy TaN LU Gn Bt aes AIS UBL All TAlsall ci) joktall eo ail 4/3/2018shatalclalzall slyatly ayleall ap sL Sl Apa jall y Aresbaall ISLgll lg Le Lady) SLA aly ots cob Jot pyar als Agclaigy! Glau gall y is (All s Agi antl Cileatqvall sols GLibills AL G1 al Le Jats Gil AGASGH GLAD Lay HLA Gy Le yey Ag plea Clasinall § elda yl Deli Ans 5 Qe 95 JSS (Al etl 0) pa ASL CF aL) Y pact Cy 4 peal 202 jill alise|'y pala Agal gal OWSall Ugsle: ated atal dlalsall slyetly 22ytoall apl Lil + Mah Gaeta! cthaltl wld aad cose Cephtball Gl (plas ay 2 praia » iy ele yl 4a pb ae 5s ill (Ging Kigeed gle aekey Cage gall Leall ay gal y ics LAME g Le! Seal AabidL Gch! yh cle 9 Sl Lene aged gy aed Gall) Giny AAG y dyed Ctalsath oS Coshpiseall Quy Agasball Jucrgll Ait Lait) oda aay (EA. AGS yall Aa gS) Aghaall Aa gSal) Easel wClSaallg 4/3/2018 Ni/ssyasaldlalzall slyatly ylaall cpl LS i ppd peu xt gh Aza Labial ye Lie gh gts aes NY hata) Galil Lb Cpe Li ylaly ba gL Sandy Aplally Lelsig ly Apluais! (Cea ay pte YELLE G5 Sg capi AS he Gast gf agealli (i Glial adags jl Leped ald 5 pile Lapin A pane (y 9Si5 Adit Gleadl} aAggibl y< Syataldlaldzall slymlly a2ylrall si bil opel 8 Labial ods auc Ling! al se il jal aay Lats Adal J eas pe) f cae € ele Aye Sal le g pal) ols iad ALS Jy gall) sBhgd paal Sig) Ge al LYE GLa Sell git dca FAIS 45 yall glad are y Lal cbs ail ey ead ob De aaa pally 4/3/2018 Niesyatal..claldzall plyeitly adytarall ail bil + Wedel gaatlg dashed) 4auld) cabaall Bolan CUMS cl pe Apaitlh ey pila A yoall Clea Jats Seka Kayo sh (pened) Agailll olin Yl G yainall Le cdg! o5S Cum UNDP ciballll Basted aati eal cole ley pall lt hy gal Lal gaday GU) sii) Cig ae Labia Uz ailly estan ill Agall Oy gl Atal ae Leolaeyl oghill 8133 of gl Alal ee sly pel po Uns alld Lge Ca 50) a st shal. dlalzall slyntlly a2yloall apse itl : gabil) ellall 2 GR gl] sal plies Sid ya SYM ot Jie dives Ag) yall Ayal Lake (3 yoLall La VRgd Sty) g « Le Aine Salad iil pally Lena Byatt y BS ALB gan Gog coil pally SL Ge all Gl git Build/Operate/Transfer (B.0.T) gE) Atal) &. lal ie ected Gall! gail! Gis (pl) Gigs AS gall Latedl AAjh gall GALS cole cpl squall Cbs Ley Lag Aaigprall ONS ts (pd JpSall Aalall A jal) tay Fake Ui ye Yale Ge 4/3/2018pata klalezall slpsally A2ylarall ipl LS Urban Planner/Designer geil pond! psomal|g taladh phy Ahan fae y Aaghle ogi Sula [gla og pina Luba ag GiagsoN Closing CA Hy Qaiguall ly gL Sly bball 552 gens a sling Lay coll Cytall Aig jh SILA tee Oa ght Coa dese CU By CUBA) Shai) y yl sll 1c] Abed £91996 ale US / J ilant cod Habitat If ie Ay gall Cal peizall Be (sll y Settlements Review and Traditional Dwelling “i545 bs al) yan 925) ijall ols Cal «1 99B ean hs ALL, BS all 93 gatas ol Care gl y AA AyadLzall LAY! (9d (gil pall nalic As} advocate 44 49 mediator Buy Gs pose] Ageatuall a2 laa aplbl cy pag guluell bball nt OedisSt wos Wigs | Sh p ok Fase heh Bt 4/3/2018 Nflll pL MY he g ple cB ad yh galy Lai pbs pl og JBI th = are _ eat da ems a Toa] ri oe] ae = Ta : qos jawed tmetsne epee epee Questions 4/3/2018 N/2cess Slat yl Lis hac si})~Ofla9 OlegegA da10 2ote-2017 aioli! 6y5t201 yUljooll LAI! SlegyiiLo ys Gyoniroll AS jlo yidiiuc aUiaac zal > Myelaall ya apmall + pe Ei Lily eilell ple) Aaah pal - Ast ply Is Lal CL dale Techniques 4/3/2018GAS Lda) G pha/qutlust Le How to apply participatory planning? Techniques adytaall agasll gsbll Identification of local leadership asl gaipal Utes 34a as + ‘The attitude survey pati + Workshops datos + Advisory committee (odie suis + Public hearing pi ghilebauyt chats + Public meeting esta Sh ge La gcd + Forums cyst Public inquiry ci ukicYly ol J31 qanl gain aL ge ctl cle + Gaming simu lad ciel + [dea Gale cqgpdall Aja) Gy wal ce agaty | Bled 0 Uae cla daly luca) Hiya al 4/3/2018GUY! / sunaiwUI wali The attitude survey The attitude survey cssall asglal HLaaSI og gua GE gla) cya ihe heal Gand Gi slu Hs patna Maslaly Anaad Calan y labia hy Aiea adel DS. goa HAY Ge Gab oy al Aaa Ga se ge BLE .interviewers ost) Beeld Ast Ail jaee wl ola Ajanta a) psa pe elily Ll lanl BAT agb pi sual ie Oe Wa cbs gAAVy BLS Oy Stell Jel st gale go paged ce AS igs igen Lil) JL) 9h BL puna A URS Cag gut Yea ag Dcy ul ata) of chet faly Bhs bine (patina 4/3/2018slnaiwill Jao - Pilot Questionnaire 4358) § a9! panei Bayay Olle ASlaoe gaatly 95 che dee Reliability Test ye staey! apleatinny) 8 lly pana Algal aging + slain ela! GAG ayaa g cil Jala SLnALwY OhjLoiwu| pans aoe cual ila gheall ; Aue All pbuh cya 296 cyl} BLY! ppelt « Lag! atlas Apsley! yailadl) pul! ODIBY! ps Qe Sal Le Alb! ase Flas SLY + aged o(Regslad) AGM placing) (a2) Ayaay Ay gil Cita phe plainal ‘Transparency 48U4) « 4/3/2018jyoiul..suodiw) GilLolw) prand evel gl plabhaky « Ciba gheall lad cob Aasdseall (Gaphail) Abs pal) tad + wel) Gaal ae ceils Ay th Dba gto Sain all Ath § jal! alsa Fads Gite Smeal (objects rating method, method of rank order, trade off questionnaire,...ete.) ayy ljbaay! Agiaas quail ay et clke ae + reliability test We slodiw\l silo dint pe oact Stratified Udita dsiyte Ake js) Ja + Aisa Gt Bias KAN! Gall aaa + 30 ce ity da paty Laat ps JSS iby asad ply Ata 50 3! 4/3/2018 Als(COLL) Otogiaast Yus5 - Quantitative 4a cous + .Qualitative- Descriptive 4405 cDulei + OLogisoll Jag go d108))! gs! Quantitative 4/3/2018 Alepala! paid yh 1 Objects Rating Method Objects Rating Method lis psstt Xb Lites soe Cha yall ule platy AMAA) paotiall ppl Go GLSaall dlpae at igsatly Ayana! LAs pu og sae 2 Low High value value 1/23 {4/s{e6;7/[s[9}{ 10 4/3/2018Wate sapniy Objects patie ayfi Ay 1 Sage iow oro DSR Tghag © Garbage eal FSi pan Cin payroue TE Prcnnary Sale Notes T Senay shes Teeuth Fair Na eneugh Toner oo Fae [so neu nial... Rating Method Data Collection Stas) eas rte staat el ye dat tis Judy (Baad 4 yah Aue Uadh U685 patie Good =1 Data Analysis tases! juss pose all 1H pe Jats Mh ghia Jae DUS Gye cially GEE MAN june J plana!) aga) lr ping AMES) palin Aggyay abt Sagp.gall JoLtall ile Ad ghaal! ode Elements of improvements and their rating Elements need to be improved are elements A, C, and B respectively. 4/3/2018iu... Objects Rating Method olial iti Xap b -1 Sate 5yLe GB egal gl pgiilys ote CF all Jigen US G4 plac ay LL AAS Haba Ug cs Sa i AIAN Shall gb aL Le 2d Agree, | Agree |NoAnswer| Disagree | Disagree, strongly strongly 2 1 0 -l 2 wealinll isis Ay pb -2 The Method of Rank Order 4/3/2018 AleThe Method of Rank Order »oUe!! ai 44h -2 Data Collection Glas) o> AS GE Sal SN pan aly cil andl Gpeencll ali (gle dais Uae plane U8 day wall pao ase N in 1 coe ARES joo ob Blements of improvements (A) Street paving By Street fighting Comma sp ¢y Schoo buitdimg” The Method of Rank Order yatistl qui 4b -2 Data Analysis cilasteall Jilad sche hug al afl a 398 JS pall st gle GARE gh Je py “patil td JUNI cS ll gle Algal gd uaa jae JS plsall bau salh Respondents AB ¢ DEF GH 1 4312 87 8 6 Mean 2 wt63 8 5 4 4/3/2018Workshops Jacl ys All Jo te aall Gig” My eaal Yaad) JIS cys Aail € 5 pin OF All gi AABN AB yy Chali) GaSe ill Chagall CUabadaly gle Qe AA yuan os gh Uggs yal Ga” Maybe Sage gall CAEL gf CLE aa cob Maal LL” 9S Bartell Jou Rabaul (iptne 3h UGS) Gay Cfo ben gs ant Habs Bae CIS Het Lagat) hss sDalgall Ga aie se all Gly” Hie GES cla (ph Kiba Zahlt Glan Ath LB gl te calc Abyssal Apulia CAEL Yolo gi saat Leng agian pal Workshops daell ayy 4/3/2018, AleWorkshops Jacl sys Workshop Jezll ys 4/3/2018Gaming simulation Sane gs pall gh Apc Uy Ay i} hyaly My CaS Deal sy Aut gal BL elie Aah Al cla dad i tl oa ats Aposbasc) JL Beata a any ly ad OS HN OE Hydtly Glad qloval andl ig” IIB Goa usted) 1A gy Gl OSes GAS dual) Clad Jal ge Le 4/3/2018aLylauall ales Jalye 1 Hse cpg © Latlgasi ey pci Cpe Aginuall Aged aad ol Gey Labgs Nf Ab) Jeet g B ylaly Adbeciall Uilaslis ot Sys ples Lge call Gaull ast ll eal Aas Lgl Gil ayy Agel) ola Liisi Fag yal All eLbill col Uday “gf Lyls LaalLn LD Cs Gad UG pp hh wall) EUREL y cop patavall Adytaall gles daly Bgl ag Bi Liat Sas ited is dial) cal bi! O-* ELLA Laut cil QyLdiall Aagially cil Yl; Aijralt ELA 8 ha} Lal A gallall Saganll pole 6 gala ord alll Fic) Last) Lltty jubigs (pb deLis SY cog ela) oe Ney AS pally deadly sl) SLAG pte Lg ol} Osa! 4/3/2018 Al"ADyluall alas Jalye Bblat) « col pend alg Hag JS Ge AS pl Oa Grell Ganes Jadettl aon AS ga gall HHS) Ltd oy 8 JS Lg ag BB A Casal gal Lag Lally Ayal ght eo Cs 5 AS fiball ELia GIAy AMI y Gaul ASI Al) ) jaca JSS. cy AS Jota S529 Ala pay pl psy daly AS al os ered SS 7 258 aang Gabilly plall CURE cpus Cslaill eo septal call Aesils ead - ca JK Cpa ald g AS Leia! Ladd Jai! lpi edt - lat) atlas post calla ga Aba sh een) AZylnall gles daly Ayla) i bS) MS yy Cai. gla Forum GALE) GLE Ga glad Jyill Gee tyaell eg etal y cilatal) Guile JLiaty! Dagaaty aay Aad GLdallh gai chs A 4S all GiB Hiss environmental Liat us Baa AS By Lgl g Ail Joe HB forum eco- Wsusi oe goil!"ssround table " byte! village ha AV Yates cqinall Go Cullen pais ciitall oda pias oe pes fase =citizen forum "Cetbl pl) Gatea" pgilatsin| Aditi Ailsa) Aye laigy) cildgall 48S cys Quill gall pedyailly 4/3/2018 Al'sAdylaall gles daly beetsllilly ex tg crosleall te til) « oe degen gait gg pale Anal gg Lee Lhd Cos cqethges pa cally La gag Aallally AIH ci all ey LH geal) ALS (BAS Atay 4 35 pall La gS cb Lig ll 2 Aa jDU 8 Jo) hg Lead og 19 all ee alas Gl Bot gat sls | atl SLAG 98 Ob BUI) le cons cath) CURE (0 Cp patel BY ji) ae jal) Abad Agolch og gall cabal js shaely Ugg yal) Ua BDylaall gles dalye 1 elias © ge Aa cea ally pal Bytes Hate ga. Ge AY TMs Case A yatill ob GS Leal! ysl Use! yd SAY coh LAAN Gye pst) Laid A pall gg pti Gulley Le Lgilen Gulley Leas eile g pall Jy pL] clas Lgl yghadl Laing Lge Lelia Agile BeLisy Lgtiluay clghad olay 4/3/2018 \ | 16Ady laall ahs dalye s hygatl|y daa! « tS ft pet oy By Sl gl as Sas Gabigy ABA IMA Gye ally Ay daa Ayal) Ale Galil selene (slag JSS Se Kyeclaall dead phan SEY ke gyn BAS badly Hae asl OL Fa ee Ea steall Alay aie AS Leal og ginae Sysn + Gaal hy JES AaDLaT Aly ally AS Lal gle! US Easel dale Get ced 9S stall syst yaad Ese dale DS As tall cL alge lel 4/3/2018 Al 7Questions 4/3/2018