Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Program Preview comfortable and proficient with personal selling activities. These
strategies have been used by one of the authors (McDonough) in
Marketing pharmaceutical care is not the responsibility of the promoting pharmacy services at Main at Locust Pharmacy in
few innovative pharmacists who try it first. Rather, it is the respon- Davenport, Iowa.
sibility of everyone in the profession.
—Charles D. Hepler1
Personal Selling: An Overlooked
In recent years, pharmacists have made significant progress in Promotional Strategy
building the supply of pharmaceutical care services. Pharmacists
in a variety of practice settings are developing new clinical ser- A number of recent articles and other publications have
vices and disease management programs to help patients achieve reviewed basic marketing principles and their application to phar-
desired health outcomes. These services range from blood lipid macy practice.6–8 Traditionally, the general framework for mar-
management and diabetes education to smoking cessation pro- keting has followed a set of basic principles called the five Ps,
grams and cancer risk assessment.2–5 briefly described as follows:
As pharmaceutical care pioneer Charles D. Hepler has noted, n Product (or service)—the item marketed, such as a pharmacy
however, the pharmacy profession has put far less focus on build- service.
ing demand for these same services. Because many patients and n Price—the fee paid by the patient, insurer, or other third party
physicians may not yet recognize the value of pharmacy-based payer, such as an employer.
patient services, the demand for pharmaceutical care remains lim- n Promotion—activities to raise awareness of the service, such as
ited. Although some pharmacies have developed and implement- advertising or public relations.
ed effective marketing strategies to build demand for new services, n Place—the site at which the service is offered, such as the phar-
many others have experienced difficulty in this regard.6 macy, a health fair, or work-
Creating and maintaining mutually beneficial relationships with place.
“Using Personal Selling
patients, physicians, and other stakeholders is essential for suc- n Positioning—a term that Skills to Promote Pharmacy
cessful marketing of pharmacy-based services. This approach, describes how the service Services” is part of the continuing
education program The Dynamics
known as relationship marketing, depends on effective use of per- will likely be viewed by of Pharmaceutical Care: Enriching
sonal (one-on-one) selling skills.6 By combining personal selling prospective patients. Patients’ Health appearing in
skills with a sound marketing plan, pharmacists can more effec- Personal selling is a compo- the Journal of the American
Pharmacists Association. The
tively promote and generate demand for their patient services. This nent of promotional activities, series is developed by the
article reviews techniques that help pharmacists become more but it is often overlooked in American Pharmacists Association,
and supported by an educational
daily practice or dismissed by grant from Merck & Co., Inc.
Continuing education credits: See page 373 for learning objectives and pharmacists as unnecessary or
test questions for this article, which is number 202-000-03-231-H04 in
too hard to implement.
APhA’s educational programs. CE answer sheets are located inside the
back cover of this issue.To take the CE test for this article online, go to Although considered a form of
http://www.pharmacist.com/gateway.cfm?redirType=cecity&courseID=6305 promotion, personal selling dif-
Vol. 43, No. 3 May/June 2003 Journal of the American Pharmacists Association (www.japha.org) 363
FEATURE Personal Selling Skills
fers from traditional promotional strategies because it involves effective way to build awareness is through one-on-one dia-
interpersonal communication between the pharmacist and the logue between the pharmacist and patient (a personal selling
patient (or between the pharmacist and the physician or other strategy). For example, a pharmacy might promote its asthma
stakeholder). Unlike mass media approaches to pharmacy promo- management program through advertisements on local radio
tion (e.g., newspaper advertisements), which tend to be broad- and cable television outlets. To increase the effectiveness of
based and impersonal, personal selling requires the pharmacist to these promotions, the pharmacists and other staff may use per-
initiate a dialogue with the patient, use effective questioning and sonal selling skills to inform appropriate patients about the pro-
listening skills to identify the individual’s unmet health needs, and gram.
persuasively present a service that meets explicitly stated and n Interpretation. In this stage, the individual considers the mean-
mutually agreed-upon goals. ing of the service with respect to his or her situation, drawing
Applying the techniques of personal selling to everyday on prior knowledge and beliefs. For example, if a woman with
encounters with patients can help pharmacists attract and retain asthma becomes aware of a pharmacy’s new asthma manage-
patients for pharmacy services and programs. Although some ment program, she may begin to recall her recent episodes of
practitioners may recoil at the concept of selling their services to wheezing and shortness of breath. She may worry that acute
patients, it is important to remember that these same techniques asthma attacks are keeping her from participating in usual daily
can improve the provision and quality of pharmaceutical care. activities and wonder whether she could improve her health by
Through effective use of personal selling skills, pharmacists can asking the pharmacist for more information. These thought pro-
become more adept at uncovering patients’ unmet health needs, cesses lead into the next stage: integration.
offering services that meet those needs and identifying ways to n Integration. In this stage, the individual synthesizes informa-
improve service quality. tion about the product or service to form an evaluation or opin-
Personal selling strategies are best viewed as one integral com- ion. In the pharmacy setting, patients base their evaluation of
ponent of a comprehensive pharmacy marketing plan.7–12 The plan services on their health needs and such factors as convenience,
should be based on a careful market analysis to ensure that pro- cost, and past experiences. Using the previous example, if the
posed or existing pharmacy services can fulfill unmet health needs patient with asthma has recently experienced acute symptoms,
in the community. A mission statement that communicates the she may be inclined to try a new asthma management service
goals and purpose of the service to patients and other stakeholders or at least learn more about it. Conversely, if her illness is well
is also recommended. controlled or if she does not understand how the service could
Businesses that adopt a personal selling approach tend to have a help her manage her disease better, she may form a neutral (or,
greater organizational commitment to marketing than do those that possibly, negative) attitude about the service.
depend almost exclusively on advertising.13 This observation is n Decision. Based on their initial evaluation, consumers decide
likely to hold true for pharmacy as well, even though most phar- whether to purchase a new product or service. In the pharmacy,
macists have not yet embraced personal selling. patients are more likely to purchase a service if they believe it
will help them solve a health problem (e.g., pain or discomfort)
or achieve a desired health outcome (e.g., improved disease
Stages of Consumer Purchasing management or risk reduction). For example, the patient who is
Decisions experiencing acute asthma symptoms may believe that the
pharmacy service will help her regain control of her condition
Pharmacists who want to build patients’ awareness and demand through improved medication management. In this situation,
for their services can benefit from understanding the cognitive she recognizes the value of the service and may wish to pur-
processes consumers go through when deciding to purchase a chase it.
product or service. Although these models have been developed to Typically, patrons go through the cognitive processing cycle
explain and predict purchasing behavior for consumer products more than once before deciding to use a service. Pharmacists need
and services, they can provide insight into how patients make deci- to keep in mind that people’s health needs may change over time
sions about using pharmacy services.14,15 for many reasons, such as worsening of a medical condition, onset
Before purchasing a product or service, consumers typically go of medication adverse effects, or the occurrence of a major life
through four contemplative stages: awareness, interpretation, inte- event (e.g., pregnancy, menopause, or the natural process of
gration, and decision. aging).
n Awareness. In this preliminary stage, an individual becomes Instead of becoming discouraged when patients choose not to
aware of a product or service through one or more means, such use a service after the initial encounter, pharmacists need to con-
as an advertisement or word of mouth. In the pharmacy setting, tinue to help them identify their unmet health needs and offer ser-
patrons usually become aware of new patient care services vices that can aid them in reaching desired outcomes. For exam-
through newspaper or radio advertisements, bag stuffers, ple, a woman who has previously declined to enroll in a pharma-
brochures, or in-store signage. Another less utilized but highly cy-based smoking cessation program may decide to participate
364 Journal of the American Pharmacists Association (www.japha.org) May/June 2003 Vol. 43, No. 3
Personal Selling Skills FEATURE
after she learns she is pregnant and realizes the potential harm to
her fetus. Similarly, a man with diabetes who has been reluctant to Figure 1. M odel for Personal Selling of
enroll in a diabetes education program may change his mind if he Pharm acy Services
experiences a serious complication, such as a diabetic foot ulcer or
erectile dysfunction.
Vol. 43, No. 3 May/June 2003 Journal of the American Pharmacists Association (www.japha.org) 365
FEATURE Personal Selling Skills
366 Journal of the American Pharmacists Association (www.japha.org) May/June 2003 Vol. 43, No. 3
Personal Selling Skills FEATURE
Figure 2. Using Personal Selling Skills at M ain at Locust Pharm acy: A Case Example
For the past several years, one of the authors (McDonough) has been integrating personal selling skills into the marketing mix
at Main at Locust Pharmacy. The following case example illustrates each step in the model for personal selling of pharmacy
services, using a case from the Pharmacy Check-Up Program. This medication review service is offered to patients who have
problems with or questions about their drug therapy. To provide the service, the pharmacist takes a comprehensive medical and
medication history, reviews the patient’s medications, identifies any drug therapy issues, and develops a written action plan to
resolve the problems. The pharmacist’s recommendations are provided verbally and in writing. If approved by the patient, a
summary is sent to the physician.
Preliminary Stage: Gathering Patient Information
A woman who appears to be in her early 60s enters the pharmacy and asks to speak with the pharmacist. W hen the pharmacist
inquires how he can help her, the woman mentions she would like to get her blood pressure checked. The pharmacist begins by
asking several situation questions:
Pharmacist: W hat are your current medical problems?
Patient: Right now, my only problem is high blood pressure.
Pharmacist: Are you taking any medications?
Patient: Yes. I’m taking this expensive blood pressure medication. [She hands a prescription vial to the pharmacist, who
identifies the medication as an angiotensin receptor antagonist, 50 mg daily.]
Pharmacist: Are you taking any over-the-counter products, such as a vitamin or herbal supplement?
Patient: Yes. I take several vitamin and herbal supplements that I get through the mail. They are supposed to give me more
energy and slow down aging, but I’m not sure what the actual ingredients are. I take about 8 to 10 tablets every day.
At this point, the pharmacist does not know if the patient’s blood pressure is well controlled or to what extent her supplement
use represents a drug therapy problem. However, the groundwork has been laid to move to Step 1 (assessing information) and
Step 2 (probing for clarification). As the pharmacist walks the patient back to the counseling area to measure her blood pressure,
he begins to ask problem questions to determine potential issues with the patient’s drug therapy or medical condition.
Steps 1 and 2: Assessing Information and Asking Probing Questions
Pharmacist: How has your blood pressure been running?
Patient: It’s been too high the last few times I went to my doctor. She suggested I start monitoring more frequently on my own.
That’s why I came in today.
Pharmacist: Do you know the target goal for your blood pressure?
Patient: Well, I’m not exactly sure.
Pharmacist: I also wanted to ask about your supplements. Have you thought about what may be in them—and if they could be
affecting your blood pressure?
Patient: Now that you mention it, I realize I don’t know what’s in some of them. And they sure do cost me a lot of money each
month.
These probing questions have identified two potential problems, or implied needs, for this patient. First, she mentions that her
blood pressure readings have been elevated and she needs to monitor them more frequently. Second, she acknowledges she
knows little about her supplements, which are financially burdensome. At this point, the pharmacist has identified the patient’s
implied needs, but he has not determined whether the patient fully realizes the implications for her health and well-being. This
leads the pharmacist to ask implication questions to assess how much impact the patient’s concerns have on her life.
Pharmacist: You mentioned you want to monitor your blood pressure more frequently. Do you have any specific concerns
about your blood pressure?
Patient: My mother died of a stroke at about my age. I worry the same thing will happen to me if I don’t get this condition under
control.
Pharmacist: You also have some concerns about how much you’re spending on supplements, right?
Patient: Yes, my husband and I are retired and living on a fixed income. I’ve been wondering if I might be taking supplements
that are making my blood pressure worse or not doing me any good.
The patient’s answers to these questions indicate she has more issues than just getting her blood pressure measured. By
explicitly stating her needs, she has set the stage for the pharmacist to describe a service that may help her address these issues.
At this point, the pharmacist is ready to ask need– payoff questions. The patient’s responses to these questions can help her
recognize some solutions to her problems or concerns.
Pharmacist: It sounds like you want to get your blood pressure under better control and determine if you need to take so many
supplements. Is that right?
Patient: Yes, and I would like to ask you some questions about them.
Pharmacist: W ould it be helpful if we scheduled a time for you to come in and get your blood pressures checked? We can fax
this information to your doctor so she stays up to date with your measurements. We can also share any recommendations we
may make with your doctor.
Patient: Yes, that would be really helpful.
Pharmacist: Also, since you have questions about your supplements, would you be interested in a service to help you sort
through them all? That way, you could be sure that none are worsening your blood pressure. The pharmacist also can answer
any questions that you might have.
Patient: Actually, I would appreciate if someone could do that for me.
As illustrated in this case, the need– payoff questions help the patient to recognize her explicit needs and identify solutions to
them.
Vol. 43, No. 3 May/June 2003 Journal of the American Pharmacists Association (www.japha.org) 367
FEATURE Personal Selling Skills
Figure 2. Using Personal Selling Skills at M ain at Locust Pharm acy: A Case Example
(Continued)
Steps 3 and 4: Presenting the Service’s Features and Benefits and Addressing Patient Concerns
Now that the patient’s needs have been identified, the pharmacist can provide her with a brief presentation on the service’s
features and benefits. The pharmacist can also address any concerns or questions the patient may have.
Pharmacist: W e have a service called the Pharmacy Check-Up Program that includes a complete review of your medications
and any supplements you’re taking. After I meet with you and review your medications, we’ll set up a follow-up appointment to
discuss my recommendations. I’ll answer your questions about your supplements and identify any that may be worsening your
blood pressure. I’ll also see if you’re taking some products you may not need, which will lower your expenses.
Patient: That sounds good, but how much is this service?
Pharmacist: The service costs $75.00 for the initial medication review and a follow-up appointment.
Patient: Oh. That sounds expensive. I’m not sure that I can afford it.
Pharmacist: I understand this may seem expensive. But after talking with you, it sounds like you have some concerns about the
number of supplements you’re taking and their cost. Is this correct?
Patient: Yes, I do want to get my blood pressure controlled and be sure I’m taking the right supplements.
Pharmacist: Our Pharmacy Check-Up Program can help you make the right choices with your supplements and identify
strategies to get your blood pressure under better control. Also, we have a payment installment plan to help you budget the
cost of the service.
Patient: Hmm. That sounds good.
Step 5: Offering the Service
Now that the pharmacist has addressed the patient’s objections, he is ready to offer the service.
Pharmacist: May I schedule a time for you to come in later this week so we can review your supplements?
Patient: Yes, I think that will work, but how long will it take?
Pharmacist: If you bring all your supplements at the time of the appointment, we can probably finish in about 30 minutes. Then
we can schedule a follow-up appointment to go over my recommendations.
Patient: Okay. Do you have any openings for this Thursday morning?
Pharmacist: Yes, I can put you down at 10:00 a.m.
Case Conclusion
This patient chose to schedule the medication review session, which revealed that none of her supplements adversely affected
her blood pressure. However, she was taking several supplements that were therapeutic duplications. The pharmacist reduced her
use to just two supplements daily, which met her desire to continue using these products while reducing the cost. Also, after
reviewing her medications, the patient expressed concern about the cost of her prescription antihypertensive medication. After
consultation with the physician, she was switched to a generic b-blocker and hydrochlorothiazide.
As a result of using the Pharmacy Check-Up Program, the patient’s blood pressure is better controlled, and her expenses have
been reduced. She and her husband subsequently transferred their prescriptions to Main at Locust Pharmacy, and she has enrolled
in the pharmacy’s Hypertension Clinic Program.
patient history, comprehensive assessment of the patient’s drug conveyed the benefit? Another useful technique is to write down
therapy, a set of recommendations for the patient, and copies of the the features and benefits of the service on paper or in the comput-
pharmacist’s work-up and recommendations for the patient and his er. The presentation then can be practiced until the pharmacist
or her physician. The benefits of this program include improved feels comfortable explaining the service to a patient.
control of the patient’s medical condition and, possibly, medica-
tion dose reductions or other changes and more cost-effective
therapy. Step 4: Addressing Patient Concerns
To take advantage of brief encounters with prospective patients, Inevitably, pharmacists will hear objections from patients when
pharmacists need to be able to describe their services quickly and attempting to sell a pharmacy service.8 Keep in mind that objec-
clearly. Indeed, A Practical Guide to Pharmaceutical Care8 rec- tions are the patient’s way of indicating that he or she is listening
ommends that pharmacists learn to describe each patient care ser- but need additional information before making a purchase deci-
vice in just 15 seconds—the estimated time that most customers sion. An initial “no” may simply mean that more dialogue is need-
listen with attention. Although it may not always be necessary (or ed. For example, if a patient states that the service seems too
feasible) to describe a pharmacy service in 15 seconds, the ability expensive, the pharmacist may not have made a strong enough
to present services succinctly and confidently is an important skill. case as to how the service will address the individual’s needs.
To become adept at describing services to prospective cus- Perhaps an explicit need was never identified, or, possibly, the
tomers, pharmacists may find it helpful to rehearse with a col- pharmacist did not demonstrate how the service provides a solu-
league or family member. Ask for honest feedback. Have you tion to the patient’s problem.
expressed yourself clearly and confidently? Have you succinctly It is important not to give up when objections are raised.
368 Journal of the American Pharmacists Association (www.japha.org) May/June 2003 Vol. 43, No. 3
Personal Selling Skills FEATURE
Regardless of the reason for the objection, most can be effectively Step 5: O ffering the S ervice
managed using a three-part process:8 Once all of the patient’s questions or objections have been sat-
1. Acknowledge the objection. This simple feedback mechanism isfactorily addressed, the pharmacist can move to the final (fifth)
assures the patient that the pharmacist has heard and understood step in the model—offering the service. In this last step, the phar-
the objection. The acknowledgment should be neither apologetic macist tries to obtain a commitment from the patient to use or fur-
(“Gee, I’m sorry I have to charge you for this service”), nor defen- ther consider the service. The commitment may consist of the
sive (“Well! Other pharmacies charge a lot more for this service patient’s agreement to enroll in the service or a request for more
than we do”), nor unnecessarily lengthy. Often, simply stating: “I information and some additional time to make a decision. In some
understand how you might feel that way” is sufficient. cases, the patient may not see a current need for the service but
2. Probe for more information. Politely ask for more informa- may be willing to use it in the future if his or her situation changes.
tion about the reason for the objection to ensure a clear under-
standing and help formulate an accurate response.
3. Respond to the objection. Think about the features and bene- Developing Effective Listening Skills
fits of the service as well as the patient’s unique situation. Explain
how the service can address the patient’s needs in a way that Active listening is important for all steps of the personal selling
resolves his or her objection and overcomes his or her reluctance model. In the context of personal selling, this skill has been
to use the service. Figure 3 shows examples of common objections described as “actively sensing, interpreting, evaluating, and
to pharmacy services and ways to respond to them. responding to the verbal and nonverbal messages of present or
Rackham17 has suggested that objections can be minimized by potential customers.”18
more thoroughly identifying the patient’s explicit needs earlier in As the term implies, active listening requires work or effort on
the sales process. Often, objections are raised because the sales- the part of the pharmacist, who must remain attentive throughout
person has not built a strong enough recognition of need in the cus- the communication process and tune out surrounding distractions.
tomer’s mind. Applied to pharmacy practice, this means that dur- The pharmacist is advised to listen nonjudgmentally to the content
ing the probing stage, the pharmacist may have uncovered the of what a patient says and ask open-ended questions to clarify con-
implied need of the patient but did not use implication and need– tent. The pharmacist should avoid interrupting and allow time for
payoff probes to create a strong enough recognition in the patient’s natural pauses in the conversation. Active listening includes atten-
mind of a need to use a service. By developing their questioning tion to both verbal and nonverbal cues, because more than half of
skills, pharmacists can become more effective at identifying all interpersonal communication is estimated to occur through
patients’ explicit needs, a skill that, in turn, may reduce the num- nonverbal means, such as facial expressions, eye contact, and body
ber of objections to using their services. positioning.19
Vol. 43, No. 3 May/June 2003 Journal of the American Pharmacists Association (www.japha.org) 369
FEATURE Personal Selling Skills
370 Journal of the American Pharmacists Association (www.japha.org) May/June 2003 Vol. 43, No. 3
Personal Selling Skills FEATURE
satisfaction with pharmacy services. For example, a patient satis- It is worth noting that technicians and clerks have played a
faction survey might be used to solicit participants’ feedback about major role in promoting pharmacy services to patients at Main at
a service they have used. To improve the usefulness and quality of Locust. In fact, these employees are often the first to pique
the collected data, pharmacists may want to use a validated patient patients’ interest in a service. These leads are passed to the phar-
satisfaction survey.25 Examples of patient satisfaction surveys macist, who then provides the patient with more information about
have recently been published elsewhere.6,25 the service and responds to the patient’s objections and concerns.
This team approach to sales (an underused strategy in most phar-
macies) has been shown to be a valuable way to promote services
Adaptability in other businesses.29,30 Pharmacists are therefore encouraged to
The last element in successful personal selling is the adaptabil- involve all staff members in the promotion of pharmacy services.
ity of salespeople—that is, their ability to adjust their communica-
tion styles or the service itself to fit customers’ needs.22,23 Many
pharmacists already are proficient in tailoring their communication Using Personal Selling Skills With
styles to match the needs of specific patient populations, such as Physicians and Other Stakeholders
young children, seriously ill patients, or patients with sensory dis-
abilities. Developing collaborative relationships with physicians and
Because of the increasingly multicultural composition of the other stakeholders, such as allied health care providers (e.g., dieti-
United States, pharmacists also need to be attuned to cultural influ- tians, nurses) or employers, is another critical component of suc-
ences that can affect their own communication styles and those of cessful marketing of pharmacy services.6 Pharmacists can use per-
their patients.26 Communication styles and nonverbal expressions sonal selling skills to develop these important relationships.
vary markedly among cultures. For example, some people may As they do with patients, pharmacists need to succinctly convey
consider friendly hugging and touching to be signs of warmth the features and benefits of their services to each stakeholder and
and regard, whereas others find these gestures inappropriate and explain how a particular service fills an unmet need. While the fea-
intrusive. tures of the service remain the same, the benefits that are high-
Pharmacists who serve patients who speak only (or primarily) lighted in the presentation stage may differ from one stakeholder
Spanish or a language other than English also may need to adapt to the next. For example, when Main at Locust pharmacists pro-
their services to meet the needs of these populations.27 In particu- mote the Pharmacy Check-Up Program to physicians, the key ben-
lar, strategies need to be in place to overcome language barriers, efit emphasized is the provision of an updated patient medication
such as hiring bilingual or bicultural pharmacy staff (usually the list that includes prescriptions from other physicians as well as
preferred option) or providing language skills training for existing nonprescription drugs, herbal products, and other dietary supple-
employees. ments. In contrast, when the same service is presented to area
employers, the pharmacist shifts the emphasis to such benefits as
reduced health care costs, improved health care quality, and
Training Pharmacy Staff to Use and increased employee productivity.
Improve Their Personal Selling Skills Usually, pharmacists need to invest more time in preparing to
call on physicians than they typically do with patients. Unlike
One issue that commonly arises in pharmacy practice is a nega- patients, whose visits to the pharmacy are usually unscheduled,
tive attitude among pharmacists and support staff toward personal physician meetings can be planned well in advance of the appoint-
selling.28 In the authors’ experience, it can be a daily struggle to ment. The more the pharmacist knows about the physician’s prac-
get the pharmacy staff to actively promote services to patients. tice, the more efficiently he or she can use the time with the physi-
Although the reasons for this reticence vary, many pharmacists cian. Before the meeting, the pharmacist should gather information
feel uncomfortable in their role as service marketers. Others lack about the types of patients seen in the practice, their main demo-
experience with personal selling or have not yet developed suffi- graphic characteristics (e.g., age, sex, income), and the size of the
cient confidence in their questioning or presentation skills. practice. Becoming acquainted with key support staff in the physi-
To help overcome these attitudinal obstacles, Main at Locust cian’s office, such as a receptionist or nurse, also can be helpful for
Pharmacy has implemented training programs to help employees making appointments with busy physicians and establishing long-
learn to effectively promote the various services. As part of this term relationships with them.
training, staff meetings are held to discuss a particular service, dur- If the physician sees value in the pharmacy service and agrees
ing which employees are given a one-page summary of its features to refer patients, it is important to send periodic reminders (such as
and benefits. One of the authors (McDonough) demonstrates how follow-up letters, fliers, or arranging in-person visits) to the prac-
he promotes the services to patients. Then he assesses how well tice. In the authors’ experience, it often takes some time before
other staff members present the service while he plays the role of busy physicians remember to begin referring patients to the phar-
a patient. macy after they have indicated their intention to do so.
Vol. 43, No. 3 May/June 2003 Journal of the American Pharmacists Association (www.japha.org) 371
FEATURE Personal Selling Skills
6. Doucette WR, McDonough RP. Beyond the 4Ps: using relationship mar-
Conclusion keting to build value and demand for pharmacy services. J Am Pharm
Assoc. 2002;42:183–94.
7. McDonough RP, Pithan ES, Doucette WR, Brownlee MJ. Marketing
Although personal selling is a valuable component of success- pharmaceutical care services. J Am Pharm Assoc. 1998;38:667–81.
ful implementation of pharmacy services, many pharmacists do 8. Rovers JP, Currie JD, Hagel H, et al. A Practical Guide to Pharmaceutical
Care. Washington, DC: American Pharmaceutical Association;
not yet feel comfortable in this role. By following the steps in the 1998:chap 9.
personal selling model, pharmacists can use a staged approach to 9. Schwartz A, Sogol E. The marketing of pharmaceutical services, part 2:
promote their services to patients. This strategy focuses on identi- Developing a marketing plan. Drug Topics. 1987;6:69–75.
10. Kotler P, Armstrong G. Principles of Marketing. Upper Saddle River, NJ:
fying patients’ explicit needs and demonstrating how pharmacy Prentice Hall; 1996.
services can effectively address these needs. The skills needed by 11. Berkowitz EN. Essentials of Healthcare Marketing. Gaithersburg, Md:
pharmacists to implement personal selling—good listening skills, Aspen Publishers, Inc; 1996:6–8.
the ability to ask probing questions, and a relationship orientation 12. Kotler P. Marketing Management. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice
Hall; 1997.
with the patient—are consistent with the principles of pharmaceu- 13. Powers TL, Bowers MR. Challenges and opportunities for personal sell-
tical care. By combining personal selling skills with a sound mar- ing. J Health Care Mark. 1992;12(4):26–32.
keting plan, pharmacists can successfully generate demand for 14. McGuire WJ. Some internal psychological factors influencing con-
sumer choice. J Consum Res. 1976;2:302–19.
their patient services. 15. Peter JP, Olson JC. Consumer Behavior: Marketing Strategy
Perspectives. Homewood, Ill: Irwin; 1987.
Keywords: Marketing, promotion, personal selling, relationships, 16. Rantucci MJ. Pharmacists Talking With Patients. Baltimore, Md:
Williams & Wilkins; 1997.
communication skills, listening skills.
17. Rackham N. SPIN Selling. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill; 1988.
Randal P. McDonough, PharmD, MSPharm, and William R. 18. Shepherd CD, Castleberry SB, Ridnour RE. Linking effective listening
Doucette, PhD, are both associate professors, College of Pharmacy, skills with salesperson performance: an exploratory investigation. J Bus
Ind Mark. 1997;12:315–22.
University of Iowa, Iowa City.
19. Knapp M. The effects of territory and personal space. In: Essentials of
Randal P. McDonough is a pharmacist at Main at Locust Pharmacy. Nonverbal Communication. New York, NY: Holt, Rhinehart, & Winston;
1980.
Other than this, the authors declare no financial interests or conflicts of 20. Meldrum H. Interpersonal Communication in Pharmaceutical Care.
interest in any product or service mentioned in the article, including New York, NY: Haworth Press Inc; 1994.
grants, employment, gifts, stock holdings, or honoraria. 21. Van Servellen G. Communication Skills for the Health Care
Professional: Concepts and Techniques. Gaithersburg, Md: Aspen
Correspondence: Randal P. McDonough, PharmD, MSPharm, Publishers, Inc; 1997.
College of Pharmacy, University of Iowa, S513PHAR Pharmacy 22. Keilor BD, Parker RS, Pettijohn CE. Relationship-oriented characteristics
and individual salesperson performance. J Bus Ind Mark. 2000;15(1):7–22.
Building, 115 S. Grand Street, Iowa City, IA 52242. Fax: 319-353-5646.
23. Pettijohn CE, Pettijohn LS, Taylor AJ, Keilor BD. Adaptive selling and
E-mail: randal-mcdonough@uiowa.edu. sales performance: an empirical examination. J Appl Bus Res.
2000;16(1):91–111.
24. Williams MR. The influence of salespersons’ customer orientation on
buyer-seller relationship development. J Bus Ind Mark. 1998;13:271–87.
References 25. Larson LN, Rovers JP, MacKeigan LD. Patient satisfaction with pharma-
ceutical care: update of a validated instrument. J Am Pharm Assoc.
1. Hepler CD, Strand LM, Tromp D, et al. Critically examining pharmaceu- 2002;42:44–50.
tical care. Presented at: American Pharmaceutical Association Annual
Meeting & Exposition; March 19, 2002; Philadelphia, Pa. 26. Health Communications in Culturally Diverse Patients. Washington, DC:
American Pharmacists Association; 2002. Available at: www.pharma-
2. Bluml BM, McKenney JM, Cziraky MJ. Pharmaceutical care services cist.com/education.cfm. Accessed January 13, 2002.
and results in Project ImPACT: Hyperlipidemia. J Am Pharm Assoc.
2000;40:157–65. 27. Sleath B, Wallace J. Providing pharmaceutical care to Spanish-speaking
patients. J Am Pharm Assoc. 2002;42:799–800.
3. Rodriguez de Bittner M, Haines ST. Pharmacy-based diabetes manage-
ment. J Am Pharm Assoc. 1997; NS37:443–55. 28. Nigon D. Sales skills for health care professionals: the emotional side of
sales. Clin Leadersh Manag Rev. 2001;15(2):72–9.
4. Kennedy DT, Small RE. Development and implementation of a smoking
cessation clinic in community pharmacy practice. J Am Pharm Assoc. 29. Thevaranjan A. Joseph K. Incentives and job redesign: the case of the
2001;42:83–92. personal selling function. Manage Decis Econ. 1999;20:205–16.
5. Giles JT, Kennedy DT, Dunn EC, et al. Results of a pharmacy-based 30. Julian CC, Ramaseshan B. The role of customer-contact personnel in
breast cancer risk-assessment and education program. Pharmacother- the marketing of a retail bank’s services. Int J Retail Dist Manage.
apy. 2001;21:243–55. 1994;22:29–34.
372 Journal of the American Pharmacists Association (www.japha.org) May/June 2003 Vol. 43, No. 3
Personal Selling Skills FEATURE
CE Credit 2. Within the marketing plan, personal selling is an integral component of:
a. Product development.
b. Programming.
CE Credit c. Promotional activities.
d. Positioning.
To obtain 1.5 hours of continuing education credit (0.15
CEU) for completing “Using Personal Selling Skills to 3. Personal selling includes all of the following except:
Promote Pharmacy Services,” complete the assessment a. Initiating dialogue with patients.
b. Pushing a particular service to all patients.
exercise and CE registration form and return them to APhA. c. Using effective questioning and listening skills.
To take the CE test for this article online, go to d. Persuasively presenting a service that meets an explicitly
stated patient need.
http://www.pharmacist.com/gateway.cfm?redirType=cecity&courseID=6305
A statement of credit will be awarded to respondents 4. Which of the following statements is false?
achieving a grade of 70% or better. APhA continuing edu- a. Businesses that undertake massive advertising campaigns
cation policy provides you with two opportunities to suc- tend to have greater organizational commitment to marketing
than those that rely on personal selling.
cessfully complete this continuing education examination. b. Through effective use of personal selling skills, pharmacists
Please note that you will not be permitted to submit the can become more adept at uncovering patients’ unmet needs.
c. Effective personal selling strategies use probing questions to
examination a third time. Individuals completing this exer- identify the explicit and implied needs of the patient.
cise successfully by May 31, 2006, can receive credit. d. Applying techniques of personal selling to everyday encoun-
ters with patients can help pharmacists attract and retain
patients for pharmacy services.
The American Pharmacists Association is approved by
the American Council on Pharmaceutical Education as 5. Identify the appropriate order of stages that a consumer typically
®
a provider of continuing pharmaceutical education. goes through before purchasing a product or service.
a. InterpretationÕAwarenessÕIntegrationÕDecision.
b. DecisionÕAwarenessÕInterpretationÕIntegration.
APhA provider number for this program is: c. AwarenessÕInterpretationÕIntegrationÕDecision.
202-000-03-231-H04. d. IntegrationÕAwarenessÕInterpretationÕDecision.
Vol. 43, No. 3 May/June 2003 Journal of the American Pharmacists Association (www.japha.org) 373
FEATURE Personal Selling Skills
10. The SPIN model includes which of the following types of questions? 16. Which of the following statements is false?
a. Situation, problem, implication, and need–payoff. a. Pharmacists need to pay attention to nonverbal cues when
b. Situation, personal selling, implication, and need–payoff. communicating with patients.
c. Service, problem, implication, and need–payoff. b. Active listening requires the pharmacist to remain attentive
d. Situation, problem, explicit, and need–payoff. throughout the dialogue with the patient.
c. Approximately one-tenth of all communication occurs
11. “What current medical conditions do you have?” This query is an through nonverbal communication, such as facial expres-
example of a _____ question. sions, eye contact, and body positioning.
a. Situation. d. Feedback is an essential component of interpersonal commu-
b. Problem. nication.
c. Implication.
d. Need–payoff. 17. Which of the following elements of personal selling seems to be the
most important for developing and maintaining buyer–seller rela-
12. Which type of question helps the patient become aware of the true tionships?
impact of a health concern on larger issues, such as its effect on over- a. Customer orientation.
all well-being? b. Persuasiveness.
a. Situation. c. Service orientation.
b. Problem. d. Adaptability.
c. Implication.
d. Need–payoff. 18. Which element of personal selling refers to pharmacists’ ability to
adjust their communication styles or service to fit the customer’s
13. The objective of _____ questions is to help patients articulate their needs?
explicit needs with regard to a health problem and focus on possible a. Empathetic responding.
solutions. b. Adaptability.
a. Situation. c. Customer orientation.
b. Problem. d. Service orientation.
c. Implication.
d. Need–payoff. 19. If a patient objects to the fee for a pharmacy service, which of the fol-
lowing responses is recommended?
14. Which of the following statements is false? a. Apologize for having to charge for the service.
a. Once the patient’s needs have been uncovered and the phar- b. Offer a detailed explanation of the numerous reasons the
macist has identified an appropriate service to address those pharmacy charges a fee for the service.
needs, the next step is to present the service. c. Vigorously defend the pharmacy’s pricing policies and point
b. Presentation of services should be tailored to the patient’s out that competitors are much more expensive.
specific needs and briefly describe the service’s features. d. None of the above acknowledgments is recommended when
c. In most cases, it is not necessary to establish the benefit responding to this objection.
when promoting a service as long as the features of the ser-
vice have been adequately described. 20. A technique called _______ can help pharmacists demonstrate they
d. Practicing personal selling skills will help pharmacists to bet- have heard not only the patient’s words but also his or her underly-
ter implement their pharmacy services. ing feelings.
a. Emotive therapy.
15. An effective strategy to respond to objections includes all of the fol- b. Empathetic responding.
lowing except: c. Pseudolistening.
a. Acknowledging the objection. d. Culturally competent counseling.
b. Probing for more information.
c. Responding to the objection by describing the features and
benefits of a service.
d. Pointing out the fallacy of the patient’s opinion.
374 Journal of the American Pharmacists Association (www.japha.org) May/June 2003 Vol. 43, No. 3