n Se eh ashen che Se be ale Se mg St He Tob Obs Ete pel tne age Ml ltd uJ oi Wer pol cal aye least Gees le grey dpa Ky Slag seth Lt Jag sbinl Inia cles sy Se J cneats Spa el jag by lat eal Noe Eppign Spal ocr la eal Slabs 19 dash seal pyr Up a!) Mia! BTL a lay! Ugel deel ule Ji gent eae aya SoS cab VOTH tay UT J pays pel al okey aul ayny lob pay wer stl sells gl Sp cg2—Bi a le Ny et ade gare fi a Soagy ah al GLE GAS Sy ee pel fle spbis aS cul lasegene 8,85 Epdiy pol fala Sisley s tale Epo dpal Aer dase game 2 Epay abt te JL VY ssS cal (ZFC) Sisal gyoy Jol Blew Eo2e dpal shoal pale deadl SIS dees jl i Iaae yarns Ope Spel eb J CAS ISI I ie alge 2iSt Dita Soe ee Sip gle classe Epoye dpel ale S28 aptly ash jn 5 alae Siz hal ulaae Epp Ipel gin Sal GLE Az ye fay elle gla “ie Je SS lj Sal pe jt Joma pete 3h Noes by em cel slain Cope Sei SiS es oa! ie Cpe eh S kage din gl Sep all ol ele abate et Sel dans shag gine ale Gb 41 ome Lad ANA creer eb U RIA gal PA oe ae tt by a Eyam A he D shiel dep Sig hel glass Epaye dpe lbose Eno 90 Jono! 2 SMinel » Hy hel 42 oly 9 as Jae alae ol alle tansTy ule Alb gas vs Seal ct plese ES ae a Al ad ae ees sone atin cas Bs bled bal sas Sy Se S Cena coke Jee gcost ab SS pdb IG AT gyn al 236 peste Seo ute og eh yey ey a olahe HE sath Wey Ath U ya gh as Wyo aegeme il ZS Shean, Se ayes JI Sle S yepidge duel cal psi! gal a3 Se we Ete dol alle ysl gel sae i oo eal (ab s> seiniltl lal 40 SS 424; ely lho ale wach ( 1 nga ol nae See fig coo Bil fat alae y eal alleen Eg ld ESes6ij Sess ages ssl bared bh hal de Si ages wife pho ginglal hal 4b Si ZRC + 59 yes pitti foo sae Se hel se gilli alas de Se aye Sagcy | sims sles! cel 9) gelely c—! di lB ah GL. BEC + als syns plan ton by lel ase S, cl eee Ui gad a ole tots deal uel JB Gta Ss vl a! ek sl Sle Geter Upel Ory by SAS ya ahs Or ZEC + 64 slike pitas ZFC + br gulhle SI ie obin Bil ads 2 be 9 br Fb FS meyye shim le HL 6 Cw SE Lol plasse aS Gane Or 2 5 hol ase lasse ayy 2 eb she Eye cal 2S Ge O39 S gt al Me gleslil lease y gilyaso US ybel AS deg ge 15 38 Sots a,' 5h a6. apes BID ad abs Sl col doe ggida alae jl gle pame aS af be aygh cane, Wnt BUS! y Ugelaien! S25 jh eslagh Ub abs pine sen gil plese zene pie Ss ane ee itysheona algae ont oe ulatenne ABST Ach SEI hegene Se ACR Sl ayl jt sips aly cel age ya FRR Saleen gt f(A) R\A 815 9 iy Hegeme SUES ght Sse bs gtiSil depen 22S Coed eal oped ogy al 2 2S yan Cone ely il gate ot py Smit pti gladegene aslesenw 3 bi ute Eh Gel y 42h ag $1 coal Coal PCR tegen Gent ABT Ath AIK glee PCR $i Sul atl yasite LS le al aame Bptge aula agg Ry P ve ga ped® dS Se tilye th ie tbe pet Ile ue SEITE jets deyenegs Se AIST ch Yaak iy Aegene Se AC BL SI Gels Sth Gide slid jl alld tepme A Salo CIB, 2S A cat capes att ABT cel lS Hegerags Se se Ss laa cate loa gane ilyiga jeage 2, Bye 88h bags Mast lI cype 9 Sle 39 depen SACR SAS yah.) ay) syns cer EE SR Nien SACKS aS 5.4 eal Neon Se Lap lp cb ope ib A gn ob JAE A coublactl gy agra gel ual Ste sp cape eS el le | Sil lanegane ng 81 yh jib Sil Wace 3S yal alae Joe 5 gf S abt ayny all gait Je 1) pe yy eal pie ody a be pt Tb lair ol ulenne Sai aah age hak a Je i Iasegene Bs page Bate hlsl eee le Epeae Upel abe Sulina slid Cibe ale gy y3 cal etls Go apse tS oe tage Saf gm Sth sae J) fang lle seb pal eel 42h ech lbs Ble ole ete dae ei le gear dl OT le gems a Cl pb she abl tegane Se ayes dally Wl age 5 yeyage pel gbsb ut al ld open etree dpelecic IE MS yesoedighes land wl Ende Blicl abla in Lif a 5 Sh oe Sa shad ¥ SV] < nab JX/< ny sel X ylateyeneg segs Kj) ZS Elecel ile hol tel slegene get (e] Athy wl jl pS Sea glo sae (hj he + be pie litle i poll el hiya ted bg je Beane asi le S ele glee Od dota ab Dey yh lyons X 8 (il) a denew ay ge lb ly al sia de pain Jle ya Oo See bis plac St js Ieyasu hip pay dyal Some ch al Si hal las at hie sl ie BI gytSel Sie eto ge 9 Cla yao olay has stl Lay SWS tate laden yl goes gly ys atalel 4 bs on sil el glaub ym shah Eobn fan WS Ow atl laepae Bhs UlyhS do Sas od bg © erhgle abi oS pntge Col ala & glans Ul asepne i abe ZEC Ep ige pel 2) Lal getge el cela tStegene b Tare a2 Te aloe cS gah aS eat SS le BIEL JU Unde gene Bi 0 bg sel 3b a ot i ey lS he 2) Sunee b Be wie CT Sees Sl dr say 145 pyle ese Coane Sy gle abl lyn apt Sg sleDhbl SS ai al elf Edge Upol e Seoul ala gla aS TEC 8 age hs$f DENS vayly jt okey ke Ts = Tare 1% =Ty soa el Epnye al Sy 0S BE Bir ay ile ily Sal ang le he Baye et AST OV Or Sloss eaegene Wha oS ginny hs To, CT», slael fi lana Las SS. Ge 5 oy eel 9 weal ly 5 3S cob ohf al jl ealll lps SL, agg 6 alae 3B glee a aye As nile aS ye g (ena glee 98 Lt cri tala ake le Epaye Gol SesPesbical S aan lees eb IST ly Gill he gers Abi Fy2ye fool Se SI lL gD aM wile Ep age Sel Se SL ae lB th cea Ste ay nid 8 Sil tegare gee S Ath Sm el Ov 4S ues pS cal Ot AS ye 9 tal sleepy east Gat Joe te tSil lepane rsd 2S come lel jks S aon jhe 25,5 sl S lize ole Sapige an sshayl cone aptly Ja 5 ple | Siz hal sue tpoye yal (ott a Seu ap SIS hg lle Epos ily he Bode pel le Suede A We S hE Eee Spal als cely lead ol col Gucittgn S 22k a> Shap daly GSIyioboats eb shad wave gla gl tS ee anci ys al sap cane Calg so yiley ga Selene LS LS led Oy gal ulasse Gales S feb Epa Urol 5 pS yin gine ashe oom al 19 pS a ong OE Enter dpe 2G tegen AE GL pt yshege oad EL po Ss on ett Gb neyo hi Ege Spal as,l5l jf ealicecle bye bal a8 Extn dye Sapte nt Ole Exdr del a Jb oSls aS ceolst Lad geay Geb geal jl y yIGLL ndegene aa eS eat ble epee pel le pet Si gl lL lntegem bi Epay I'S, Suni Ble pels Sle Exteel oe AB lit Sibls 9 Sol get wile Epayedpel ae! cul je ad cymae yeneye Zh sbel pili a tee wale ly) hsb obs ese oe LE gers Bact ya S aye Ural 305 bo ay dpe! ul Jl geld dle pl silat oa plan aS has ab lf 39969 yegdye Banas cute, Seal ge tage oe a lp GLb ylyen 29 9 Gene alg ull Sy aS ayls ayey ae Lag Le Gly pt Hebi SYS S ay cust Jp Soyo apse che ele ihe ae bbl > S gest Sel Whe de ol i dub ad Se cat Phil be laaegene ta algal cle bS eb le Bye Upel toe RP phe ak stl wif dry Wh Sin pets peed Wy ser dake seg ath ZEC+ Oy NGL pikes ZEC + Or ye SI Sian sen ab ely cell ode ol yi cle oth aby tlithe ute ar ald iE fay deel Soy 25S abl yess xl) JI sleee Sm agnge daly ilps LPC ZEC 44 dae fash ease WitEsl S csusbe ald aya bogs IE Eptge Jel Sb Os 5 wsd C22 SL ENTE HG y MRC H lan J ue ish LS.NV he apaliyg of ~ SoS hui ox bce lease! | nae gene bi jo colin hS ans segs Bie al cael sae ay eolelae a uasS otal ae ee GUS lg SS lly ale Spa SoS ated Hail ind sigan yl SS a jm S352 cota) BI a) Ede ol lle alae gti lnaegeme hyo iatny cll el satis ele Soe Shy galt J) bes See) ald abe ux b him igh taal 6 Ue als pol obfied Ae ute aatb sou Col (lag) Lack 2S esasegune UT pln S if oy ce Se lass ome UF So ying Se Sle Suis CAIs plaacgemags san SI sdeebil, gine use Lea alge she as ose aeebe lesb alg 4 diggs Coke gdb cont pena gl ola hie ne | lode gene Beran Sint Erte dpa! ppt lice Sul gage dl at Jus BS seasm SD Ete Ira! aoe she oe re cana aS be ute JLT te] sla cea) tt Ga Sy Alea ale ACR AS yi Bure Sh Sp 88 9 I A ed Seb? ede QU Se Se VU Latah ape ae Se ab Ya Sy Sp alia abs J ay el VL Sh K Mgt Meee > Slashersse mes ymin lye Seale ta Se sae ly 24 SS yes san Vy Vlg " To, = Tare. To =Ty el sae Se SalI Sle Sol wile poy Jol SS Sapte tchare 33909 pie Es (lect cde Ort CHE SOLS sah ays eosalinggdle lel sclflasl» 1 af Sle @ ya ath aya ayey ibe ill yatl ke et ly Cael SIS jae Sead Se = Ty NE Epa hel crest Stan cole slmayhs pale Je 2 ot aby G2 lsh a bus he a9 Sel least Edge el S ath tl ang Ll hol 3h Sal I Sle la bS ole yg sal Wh 2 ail ge oly abe 19 Tj) CAS ah big al GLU Lg Epye PUL arte nel Eptee ool Se Sil jh zal po 9 g9 phew Ul le oll ssl i Sil eins adyel say: ys Sosa lle cay Jaf coal aay paleatiye Id AW ily Ole Ep aye A gee — abl aby tae Gi pb il tlh lel yl tet SighOil yt S aye Jian 13 ayy lade game BF y alae bp pitt ofS 1 pene ti ys ah gill sae! & tj» JN Sm pga 8 Rey ate (lb gha eeespne bbs ya JOE! 4 AS ce peat Sila gs Inte gne ly ile lan Se Gabe gi all 4b La Bp ay el nyt lel 4 bi le ; ap sal lly ol alae! a by je jae oS at als GLY Ste atl ofl sal gl go gp S aca lb LT cA GANS Y coal Gale Gude cpl Ath sites st gang pop a Jb Lo Me Ld aT as she wfc S a4 al ote il he aclne le epi I pa slay S gS ol Heys Mil gtueys y sole Gabe db ge 2 yl coal te acl 295 gytie agra lle 9 2 asta JLT Jyh 9 eae game Bi Siu SLES I Se cen gl Alege ole eu j! Salad you sl Sig) cul ay aig al alga lan get eb WT abe Spe glean Slo apn i Sul10 an ANS! Se col alacaa rele Hegere lat Sil pyle Scoel $3 yo cl Sesh na te att 2pSt dv stairs Bae cal cl mee padsintegene 2 IE Aye ee pedal che una baselya delete og bly Slt Sh Coops Con pi Epoye Up sale Wy ed cet g aE hetng ately gS, 28S ESI Re gage ph ans nS le Eps ual a Se! gh (oh ESI oa pine pls gy ome lacgeme Jlacl (cm cole $I ob sale ola BE ST eens tay ely Ko ec asi cet) lB le pate (ZFC +) cote LE ee ly Eten al daar to bul uns le te ca gly ls ages lS ek gaagine i close ala gles deal gles GS sh4 eel a coal gb ihe abigail lle Ul pal sgrmn Sotdige LE op age Sie ghel wlosse yess! arin bt sy il gl 3 ay lye Utam) H de Epo Lap CIS oles Sty eta 4 uegene Ib pg ed Sorin botem desk | aes gp! Sete ayy CIF JL ate gh ya rishi ee Sterns Heb pl ip Saeed oat gl Sle ly 3S 2 tcl Sol sesame steele SL coleey (le Lge canst Saye els 1S Caley ye ice Jae Se shgetab hy S Cael Gn b yee pl nel iS ng hil ya Saihige yee | alo uot y Sip he lanse Gl» lb eu 1. D, Martin and J, Stel, Ieration trees J. Amer. Math. Soe. 7 (190), 1-78 2. Y. N. Moschovahis, Deserptive Set ‘Theory: Studios in Logic and the Foundations of Math, Vol, 100: Amster dam: North-Holland (1980) 4. J. Mycilsi and M, Steinhaus, A mathematical axcan contradicting the axiom of choice, Bull, Pol Acad. 10 (1962), 1-3. ‘© W_ Hugh Woodin, “Large cardinal asioms and independence: 19) 135, revisited, Math. Integencer, (3) 18 Sr A GANGS roy ee 9 Sip hel aaie tye dye eV Soil cal 2 Cis ie eel S ath woe le T Sein Supers ab yy PEA Sl oy st ah alee Se 17: Seq + {+,\} ab aye Say fo Sy gute seals pa V Seibalys SGa chews Sy ath Abel S) 7 aS yond ta lis Veybe 1S. sre 7 alzal i) my Myo yy > I> VEEN akeg my = 20) fe hee Fhe Se sel cnn = FO Myy HY) pe! 8 yee Tl Sel glenna go 3 V Sigh Slaceal ¥ gSeib Blot af cell T Sab abe 7 wFleal Se ssh aeae age ety Seal pedly 9% 2547 ab als SL whews a T oS et ce ak nls a pha ggg WES Ih I Se YE Seth 99 iI Seger ol ile Seek eA eye S sctl tls ang le al 2 Bla! SII I be le yelb ldetgene jf egler ule cab agaeen Ga esil STA = [0 3] St dls ely 2yls agey deel Be ae Sm Get 12 V oSesb Col Gilt con th ae Sash 92 6am eS ijl ip dV oSes dors te 2 alee Se) Seth chy wil ole ore Se ab sors dx ibid Sik NK le Sl eal ose Ga ik Bh) Ga is S pSe gl jl eel phe (Sil goa aah ls fe SiN ct Lagi pk bd eee A Wide ole Mental a. abies o! etl ap alee Ga wil ss degen il glade game 9 gle Se Wath (ptt85l deyane ya WS agtge net gg Sl cast G2 GSN get a Galley te Gy ylyge s Cal Legere “ath Sd putt il paseyene S call je cng So Eile Sey ea 2 Slate Geta ald 9 ant Big Sly 22h GL Edy Jol gin bled LI Fay Le BR Gen aghe Sl it bie ESI ont Geel il poke 1S eta al Sab pty LIGL gn Opto acl oat dab Ex ty dpel Scams gi anny lew te ns? sch SB SII Gok pie od S args Be hea hl dle Ve Jab ge Myrach atl ole Epdye dpe! l gales street dpcl ye Colesal ae cats le ele samy bi ey singe ont ag 2 c2ls any Sip gil lala geLal lease I oe Same ly ate Tw pemenon