You are on page 1of 5

,17(5&(5$0²5()5$&725,(60$18$/,, 

5(9,(:3$3(56

E. Prestes1, A.P. Luz1, D.T. Gomes2, V.C. Pandolfelli1

Sintering Effect of Al and a Boron Source


in High-Alumina Nano-Bonded Refractory
Castables
7+($87+256

The corresponding author, Ana Paula da Luz, is Senior Eduardo Prestes is currently a postdoctoral researcher
Researcher at the Materials Engineering Department, (UEPG, Brazil) and business partner at ENGEMAT Projects
Federal University of São Carlos, Brazil, from which she and Consulting (www.engematpr.com.br). He trained as
earned her Ph.D. in Materials Science and Engineering. a materials engineer (State University of Ponta Grossa –
She received B.Sc. and M.Sc. degrees in Chemical and UEPG, Brazil, 2005), with a Ph.D. Degree in Engineering
Materials Engineering, respectively, from the Engineer- and Materials Science from Federal University of São
ing School of Lorena (EEL-USP), Brazil. Through July Carlos – UFSCar, Brazil, 2013. His areas of professional
2015, she has authored or co-authored 53 papers in interest are: refractory castables, asphalt pavement,
peer-reviewed journals and 27 in conference proceedings. She also co- nanocellulose-based drug delivery systems and melt processing of polymer
authored the book “FIRE Compendium Series – Refractory Castable Engi- biocomposites.
neering” with Dr. M.A.L. Braulio and Prof. Dr. V.C. Pandolfelli, which was
recently published by Göller-Verlag, Germany. Her main research interests
include: refractory castables design, processing and characterization, ther-
modynamic simulations, and porous insulating materials.
E-Mail: anapaula.light@gmail.com

Victor C. Pandolfelli is Full Professor in the Materials Research and Education) since 2004, an international consortium involving
Engineering Department, Federal University of São Carlos, 11 universities and 16 key private sector refractories companies. Pandolfelli
Brazil, from which he received B.S. and M.S. degrees in is a full member and serves on the Advisory Board of the World Academy of
ceramics. He earned his Ph.D. from Leeds University Ceramics (WAC), is full member of the Brazilian Academy of Sciences and
(England) and spent a year as a visiting researcher at of the Brazilian National Academy of Engineering, and is a Fellow of the
École Polytechnique in Montreal (Canada). He has au- American Ceramic Society. He is also Guest Professor of Wuhan University
thored or co-authored 2 books, 469 papers in journals of Science and Technology (WUST) in China. Since 1993 he has coordinated
and 233 in proceedings, and holds 8 patents. During his Alcoa Laboratory at Federal University of S. Carlos and is responsible for
career, he received 83 international (Japan, Germany and USA) and national training and teaching both undergraduate and graduate students. He has
awards for his scientific and technological achievements. Pandolfelli is also active partnerships with refractory industry companies, raw materials sup-
a member of the editorial boards of 12 scientific journals. He is the Latin- pliers and end-users.
American coordinator of FIRE (Federation for International Refractories

$%675$&7 .(<:25'6

Petrochemical refractory end-users face difficulties in finding commercial products with optimized thermo-mechanical proper- castable, colloidal silica,
ties for the low operational temperatures (<900 °C) in fluid catalytic cracking units. Blending colloidal binders with sintering sintering additives,
additives in castable compositions is an interesting alternative that may overcome the limited densification of conventional alumina
cement-bonded systems. This work investigated the effects associated with use of Al and/or boron sources added to high- INTERCERAM 64 (2015) [4-5]
alumina colloidal silica-bonded castables sintered at temperatures up to 1000 °C. In situ measurements of hot elastic modulus
and hot modulus of rupture, and XRD and SEM analyses were performed to explain the reaction mechanisms and phase evolu-
tion associated with Al and boron-based compound performance at high temperatures. The test results indicate that added
boron induced formation of Al4B2O9 and generated liquid phase in the microstructure of the castables. Aluminium powder was
oxidized (giving rise to alumina), which resulted in increased castable stiffness. This latter transformation was only observed
in colloidal silica-containing compositions. The best thermo-mechanical performance in the 600–815 °C range was obtained
for castables containing both Al and boron.

1 Introduction Calcium aluminate cement is the most applied binder in conven-


Improved performance of refractory products in recent years has tional refractory compositions used for steel-making processes. At
been associated with continuous evolution of raw materials, dis- room temperature, after reaction with water, this additive induces
persing agents, installation techniques and operational practices. hydraulic bonding between the fine matrix and coarse aggregates
However, there is still a shortage of commercial refractory materials [4]. Nevertheless, decomposition of cement hydrated phases (i.e.
with suitable properties (e.g. high mechanical strength) designed CAH10, C2AH8, C3AH6 and AH3, where C = CaO, A = Al2O3 and H =
for specific applications, such as fluid catalytic cracking units in the H2O) during drying/heating usually results in an increase of overall
petrochemical industry, at temperatures below 900 °C [1–3]. porosity and, consequently, reduction of the mechanical resistance
of refractory materials up to 500 °C [4–6].
Due to their high specific surface area and reactivity, binder suspen-
1 Federal University of São Carlos, Materials Engineering Department,
Rod. Washington Luiz, km 235, São Carlos, SP, 13565-905 (Brazil) sions containing nanoparticles (colloidal alumina or colloidal silica)
2 Petrobras, CENPES/EB-AB-G-E/EEQ – Rio de Janeiro, RJ (Brazil) are an alternative to allow development of castable compositions
 ,17(5&(5$0²5()5$&725,(60$18$/,,

5(9,(:3$3(56

with more suitable thermo-mechanical properties at intermediate which correlates the E value, the natural vibration frequencies
temperatures (<900 °C) [5, 7–9]. In addition, it has been reported and the sample’s dimensions [12]. For the fundamental flexural
that incorporation of sintering additives (Al, Si, boron-based com- frequency of a rectangular bar, Young’s modulus E (in Pa) is giv-
pounds, etc.) can lead to major improvements in the stiffness and en by:
mechanical strength of different refractory systems in the 500 to
1000 °C range [2, 3, 10]. The enhanced performance of boron-con- (1)
taining compositions has been associated with generation of a tran-
sient liquid (B2O3-rich phase) in their microstructures above 450 °C. where m is mass (g), b is width (mm), L is length (mm), t is thick-
The densification process is sped up by reaction of this liquid with ness (mm), ff is the fundamental resonance frequency of the bar
other materials contained in the refractory mixture, giving rise to (Hz), and T1 is a correction factor for the fundamental flexural
new solid components (i.e. borates) [3, 10]. Boron additives seem mode that accounts for the finite thickness of the bar, Poisson’s ratio
suitable for development of castables for petrochemical applications and other factors.
as they may induce faster sintering and take advantage of the low Hot modulus of rupture (HMOR) measurements were made by
melting temperature of aluminium (~660 °C [10]). 3-point bending tests carried out with Netzsch HBTS 422 equip-
Therefore, this work evaluates the performance of high-alumina ment (Germany) at 600, 815 and 1000 °C using samples pre-fired
nano-bonded refractory castables containing Al and/or a boron for 5 h at the HMOR testing temperature (ASTM C583-8). Due to
source. The reaction mechanisms and phase evolution effects due to their higher reactivity, matrix samples were analysed with XRD to
the action of these additives were investigated via in situ hot elastic identify the phase transformations that take place in the matrix
modulus and hot modulus of rupture measurements, and XRD and fraction (particle size <100 μm). After thermal treatment at 600,
SEM analyses. 815 and 1000 °C/5 h, the samples were ground and sieved in a Tyler
#325 mesh screen. The powders were then placed in sample holders
2 Materials and techniques and evaluated on a Bruker D8 Focus device with Cu-K_ radiation
High-alumina vibratable refractory castables were designed accord- [h = 1,5406 Å] and a nickel filter, using 40 mA, 40 mV and a scan-
ing to the Alfred particle packing model (q = 0.26) [5]. The base ning step of 0.021 °. SEM images and EDS mappings of fired (815
refractory was composed of tabular alumina (d <6 mm, Almatis, and 1000 °C for 5 h) and polished castable samples were made with
Germany), reactive aluminas (CL370C and CT3000SG, Almatis, DSM 960 equipment (Zeiss, USA) to identify the phase transforma-
Germany) and silica fume (MS971D, Elkem, Norway). 1.9 mass-% tions that occurred in the refractory microstructure and highlight
Al powder (d <45 μm, Alcoa, Brazil) and/or 1.2 mass-% boron the action of the sintering additives.
source (BS, d <45 μm, B2O3 content ~53.84 mass-%) [2] were also
added to the mixture, as described in Table 1. 7 mass-% of a colloidal 3 Results and discussion
silica suspension (binder source) with 40 mass-% solid concentration The evolution of elastic modulus as a function of temperature is an
(Bindzil 1440, Eka Chemicals, Sweden) was added to the Al2O3-con- interesting parameter. It can help to point out the temperature ranges
taining compositions to attain castables with roughly 60 % vibrata- where the most important microstructural transformations are tak-
ble flowability. Finally, 0.01 mass-% dead-burnt magnesia was in- ing place in a refractory material. Figure 1 shows E-curves for the ref-
corporated into the dry-mix to induce colloidal silica gelation and, erence CS composition (additive-free mixture) and the castables con-
consequently, setting of the refractory. taining boron source (BS) or aluminium powder (Al). It shows that
The refractories were mixed in a rheometer especially developed for densification of the CS samples (due to colloidal silica interaction
refractory castable processing [11]. The mixtures were then cast in with the other materials) took place mainly above 700 °C, leading to a
metallic moulds to make prismatic samples (150 mm × 25 mm × continuous increase of E-values up to 1000 °C. However, the addition
25 mm) that were cured at 50 °C/24 h (without humidity control) of sintering additives directly affected the castable’s stiffness, resulting
and dried at 110 °C/24 h. The evolution of elastic modulus (E) with in markedly different behaviour at high temperature. Faster sintering
temperature was evaluated for each sample to identify the effects of of the CS + BS castable was detected in Fig. 1 due to a rapid increase
Al and BS during sintering. Measurements were performed from 30 of E values above 600 °C. The main transformations associated with
through 1000 °C (heating cycles having a heating rate of 2 °C/min) the CS + Al material were observed at a higher temperature (>800 °C).
using the bar resonance technique (ASTM C 1198-91). This method Thus, each additive (BS or Al) promoted densification and improved
is based on excitation and detection of the sample’s responding stiffness of the refractories in a different temperature range.
vibration spectrum using piezoelectric transducers. Wide-frequen- Figure 2 presents the hot modulus of rupture (HMOR) of the
cy scanning is performed in order to excite and capture the natural evaluated castables. Addition of boron-compound to the castable
resonance frequencies of the ceramic bars. Elastic modulus is calcu- (CS + BS) enhanced the samples’ mechanical strength at 600 and
lated from the vibration spectrum by applying a Pickett equation 815 °C compared to the reference material (CS).

Table 1 • General design of the evaluated castable compositions


Raw material / mass-% CS CS + Al CS + BS CS + Al + BS
Tabular alumina (d <6 mm) 86 86 86 86
Reactive aluminas (CL370C and CT3000SG) 12.1 10.2 10.9 9.0
Silica fume 1.9 1.9 1.9 1.9
Aluminium powder (Al, d <45 μm) – 1.9 – 1.9
Boron source (BS, d <45 μm) – – 1.2 1.2
Colloidal silica (CS, 40 mass-% solids) 7.0 7.0 7.0 7.0
Dead-burnt MgO (d <212 μm) 0.01 0.01 0.01 0.01
Total water content in the colloidal silica suspension 4.2 4.2 4.2 4.2
,17(5&(5$0²5()5$&725,(60$18$/,, 

5(9,(:3$3(56

1 2

Hot modulus of rupture / MPa


Elastic modulus / GPa

Temperature / °C Temperature / °C

Fig. 1 • Elastic modulus evolution during heating (30–1000 °C) of high-alumina Fig. 2 • Hot modulus of rupture of high-alumina nano-bonded castables with
nano-bonded castables with no additive (CS), with 1.2 mass-% boron source no additive (CS), with 1.2 mass-% boron source (CS + BS) and with 1.9 mass-%
(CS + BS) and with 1.9 mass-% Al (CS + Al). All samples were pre-dried at Al (CS + Al). The samples were pre-fired at 600, 815 or 1000 °C for 5 hours
110 °C/24 h

3 4
Elastic modulus / GPa

Intensity (a.u.)

Temperature / °C e / °
Fig. 3 • Comparison of the elastic modulus evolution during heating Fig. 4 • XRD profile of the CS + Al + BS castable matrix after firing at 600, 815
(30–1000 °C) for high-alumina nano-bonded castables containing 1.2 mass-% and 1000 °C for 5 hours. A = Al2O3, B = Al, C = Si, D = SiO2 and E = Al4B2O9
of boron source (CS + BS), 1.9 mass-% Al (CS + Al) or a blend of the two
additives (CS + Al + BS). All samples were pre-dried at 110 °C/24 h

Nevertheless, due to the low melting temperature (~450 °C [2]) of Another interesting alternative is to blend both Al + BS in the casta-
this additive and generation of a boron-rich liquid phase in the ble composition, as each additive should act at different tempera-
refractory structure, a significant drop in HMOR value was seen at tures and their combined presence might lead to improved mechani-
1000 °C. On the other hand, the benefit of Al incorporation in the cal behaviour and densification across a broader temperature range.
alumina-based castable (CS + Al) could be observed at 815 and Figure 3 shows that a refractory containing both additives (CS + Al +
1000 °C since Al melting only takes place at approximately 660 °C. It BS) delivers optimized performance. Sintering reactions start taking
is well known that fluid catalytic cracking units (FCC) usually oper- place above 600 °C (accompanied by an increase in E value) and the
ate in the 600 to 815 °C range. Furthermore, 815 °C is used as the sample stiffness steadily increases up to 1000 °C. Table 2 shows
standard reference value for selection of refractory materials by the HMOR values for the CS + Al + BS sample at 600, 815 and 1000 °C.
petrochemical industry. Based on the results of Figs. 1 and 2, both They reinforce a positive role for these sintering compounds at 600
sintering additives (Al and BS) clearly have potential application in and 815 °C, but although the HMOR value observed for CS + Al +
castables for the petrochemical field. Of the two additives, BS seems BS at 1000 °C is better than that of the CS + BS castable in Fig. 2, the
to be the most promising candidate. presence of liquid phase in the refractory structure clearly affected
the mechanical strength of the castable containing Al + BS.
To identify the main reaction mechanisms responsible for the re-
Table 2 • Hot modulus of rupture measured for the reference
sults presented above, samples of the CS + Al + BS refractory matrix
castable (CS) and the composition containing both sintering
additives (Al + BS)
with d <100 μm (containing reactive aluminas, silica fume, colloidal
silica and sintering additives as specified in Table 1) were prepared,
Test temperature / °C
Castable fired at 600, 815 and 1000 °C for 5 hours, and analysed via X-ray
600 815 1000
diffraction, producing the results shown in Fig. 4.
CS 12.2 ±2.7 15.0 ±1.2 19.9 ±1.9 After firing at 600 °C, Al2O3, SiO2 and Al were the main phases in the
CS + Al + BS 18.4 ±1.0 24.4 ±1.5 9.4 ±0.7 CS + Al + BS castable matrix. Silicon peaks could be detected for the
 ,17(5&(5$0²5()5$&725,(60$18$/,,

5(9,(:3$3(56

5 6

Hot modulus of rupture at 815 °C / MPa


Fig. 6 • Hot modulus of rupture at 815 °C of high-alumina castables containing
colloidal alumina (CA) or colloidal silica (CS) as binder agents

7HPSHUDWXUHƒ&

Fig. 5 • SEM images and EDS mapping of Al and Si for the CS + Al + BS castable
after firing at (a) 815 °C and (b) 1000 °C for 5 hours

samples thermally treated at 815 and 1000 °C. Al4B2O9 was the only
crystalline phase derived from BS interaction with the matrix com-
ponents. Its presence could be observed only at high temperature
&RQFHQWUDWLRQPDVV
(1000 °C). The oxi-reduction reaction responsible for Si generation
in the refractory matrix is [13]: Fig. 7 • B2O3-Al2O3 phase diagram [14]. The blue dashed line highlights the in-
crease in overall liquid content (6L) at higher temperatures (>1000 °C) when a
3SiO2 + 4Al A 2Al2O3 + 3Si (2) composition is located in the B2O3-2Al2O3·B2O3 field

This transformation induced the substantial increases in elastic quence of the presence of nano-silica particles that induce higher Al
modulus from 800 up to 1000 °C highlighted in Figs. 1 and 3, and oxidation.
the significant improvement of hot mechanical strength for the Given this conclusion, the residual SiO2 phase detected in the XRD
CS + Al and CS + Al + BS castables at 815 and 1000 °C (Fig. 2 and analysis of the CS + Al + BS castable samples fired at 815 and
Table 2). SEM images and EDS mapping analysis of the Al (still 1000 °C for 5 hours (Fig. 4) should primarily be from silica fume
present in the material fired at 815 °C) and Si elements contained in crystallization. Furthermore, Al4B2O9 generation is due to a reaction
the CS + Al + BS castable samples (Fig. 5) showed consumption of of B2O3(l) and alumina contained in the refractory matrix fraction.
Al and generation of Si, as indicated by Eq. 2, after the refractory As can be seen in the Al2O3-B2O3 phase diagram of Fig. 7, B2O3(l) (in-
was fired at 1000 °C for 5 hours. Al oxidation led to alumina forma- dicated as “melt”) should be found even at temperatures around
tion and new ceramic bonds were most likely generated among the 800 °C, and under thermodynamic equilibrium conditions in the
matrix components of the castable, resulting in a material with im- presence of alumina, liquid B2O3 can incorporate alumina oxide in-
proved stiffness. to its composition. Depending on the firing temperature and alu-
In order to fully understand the aluminium powder reaction mech- mina content in the system, two different aluminium borates might
anism, it is important to identify which silica source (silica fume or precipitate from this liquid phase: 2Al2O3·B2O3 (Al4B2O9) or
colloidal silica) plays a role in the oxi-reduction transformation of 9Al2O3·2B2O3·(Al18B4O33).
Eq. 2. Therefore, additional castable compositions containing col- Between 600 and 1000 °C, a number of sintering effects were associ-
loidal alumina (CA, 7.0 mass-% of VP Disp. W 640 ZX suspension ated with addition of boron source to high-alumina compositions.
containing 40 mass-% solids, Evonik Degussa GmbH, Germany) in- From 600 to 815 °C (see Fig. 3 and Table 2) B2O3 melted and gave
stead of colloidal silica as binder, with and without Al + BS, were rise to a viscous liquid phase which initially filled pores and induced
prepared. Measurements of the hot modulus of rupture at 815 °C a faster diffusion rate of the more reactive components in the casta-
were performed for the colloidal alumina-bonded materials and the ble matrix. This favoured sintering of the structure and led to im-
results were compared to those of the CS-based systems (Fig. 6). provement of material stiffness and mechanical strength over that
As the same amount of silica fume was contained in all castable temperature range.
compositions (1.9 mass-%), the differences in the HMOR values in Although the main phases expected to be found in CS + Al + BS re-
Fig. 6 are mainly related to the binder agent added to the materials. fractory were 9Al2O3·2B2O3 and Al2O3 (according to the matrix com-
The better performance of the CS + Al + BS refractory is a conse- position and Fig. 7), the interaction of B2O3(l) and fine alumina at
,17(5&(5$0²5()5$&725,(60$18$/,, 

5(9,(:3$3(56

1000 °C resulted in 2Al2O3·B2O3 precipitation (see Fig. 4) and also References


generation of liquid phase with lower viscosity, indicating that ther- [1] Bittencourt, L.R.M., Fernandes, M.R., Da Silva, S.L.C., Rulff, B.M.: The effect of
coke deposition on the mechanical and thermomechanical properties of dense
modynamic equilibrium of the system was not achieved during fir- and insulating castable used in FCC units, In Proceedings of UNITECR 2003,
ing. The liquid contained in the CS + Al + BS microstructure was (2003) 549–552[2] Luz, A.P., Santos Jr, T., Medeiros, J., Pandolfelli, V.C.:Thermal
responsible for the drop in hot modulus of rupture at 1000 °C shock damage evaluation of refractory castables via hot elastic modulus meas-
urements, Ceram. Internat. 39 (2013) 6189–6197
(Table 2). Moreover, as temperature increases further, it is expected [3] Luz, A.P., Silva Neto, A.B., Santos Jr, T., Medeiros, J., Pandolfelli, V.C.: Mullite-
that 2Al2O3·B2O3 will be decomposed (according to the peritetic based refractory castable engineering for the petrochemical industry. Ceram. In-
reaction above 1000 °C in Fig. 7), leading to precipitation of ternat. 39 (2013) 9063–9070
[4] Braulio, M.A.L., Milanez, D.H., Sako, E.Y., Bittencourt, L.R.M., Pandolfelli, V.C.:
9Al2O3·2B2O3 and additional liquid generation (the 6L indicated in Binder agents and their effects in alumina-magnesia refractory castables.
Fig. 7). Therefore, care must be taken during the design of refractory Cerâmica 56 (2010) 325–330 (in Portuguese)
compositions containing boron-based additives. When a permanent [5] Luz, A.P., Braulio, M.A.L., Pandolfelli, V.C.: Refractory castable engineering. 1st
Ed. Baden-Baden: Goller Verlag, (2015) 157–245
liquid is generated, the refractoriness of the castable system can be [6] Parr, C., Simonin, F., Touzo, B., Wohmeyer, C., Valdelievre, B., Namba, A.: The
adversely affected, preventing its application at high temperatures. impact of calcium aluminate cement hydration upon the properties of refractory
Fortunately, as reported in recent studies [2, 3], depending on the castables. In Proceedings of TARJ Meeting (2004) 1–17
[7] Ismael, M.R., Dos Santos, R.D., Salomão, R., Pandolfelli, V.C.: Colloidal silica as a
selected binder system (calcium aluminate cement and/or hydrata- nanostructured binder for refractory castables. Refractories Applications and
ble alumina), different reaction products might be formed between News 11 [4] (2006) 16–20
600 and 1200 °C in high-alumina boron-containing castables, in- [8] Ismael, M.R., Valenzuela, F.A.O., Polito, L.A., Pandolfelli, V.C. Thermo-mechani-
cal properties of colloidal silica-bonded refractory castables. Cerâmica 53[327]
ducing consumption of the boron-rich liquid and possibly make the (2007) 314–318 (in Portuguese)
liquid phase be a transient component of the castable. [9] Nouri-Khezrabad, N., Braulio, M.A.L., Pandolfelli, V.C., Golestani-Fard, F., Rezaie,
H.R.: Nano-bonded refractory castables. Ceram. Internat. 39 (2013) 3479–3497
[10] Braulio, M.A.L., Morbioli, G.G., Medeiros, J., Gallo, J.B., Pandolfelli, V.C.: Nano-
4 Conclusions bonded wide temperature range designed refractory castables. J. Amer. Ceram.
This work proves that a blend of Al and a boron source can be a suit- Soc. 95 (2012) [3] 1100–1104
able route for developing high-alumina nano-bonded refractories [11] Pileggi, R. G., Pandolfelli, V. C., Paiva, A.E., Gallo, J.: Novel rheometer for refrac-
tory castables. Amer. Ceram. Soc. Bull. 79 (2000) [1] 54–58
with improved thermo-mechanical properties for the petrochemi- [12] Pickett, G.: Equations for computing elastic constants from flexural and torsional
cal industry. The boron-based compound acted mainly between resonant frequencies of vibration of prisms and cylinders. Proc. Amer. Soc. Test-
600–815 °C and benefit from added Al was observed above 800 °C. ing Mater. 45 (1945) 846–865
[13] Siljan, O. J., Rian, G., Pettersen, D.G., Solheim, A., Shøning, C.: Refractories for
A combination of these sintering additives induced better perform- molten aluminum contact, Part I: thermodynamics and kinetics, In Proceedings of
ance of the evaluated castable across a broader temperature range. UNITECR 2001, (2001) 531–550
Al oxidation due to reaction with SiO2 was only identified in colloi- [14] Sokolov, V.A., Gasparyan, M.D.: Synthesis and properties of fusion-cast refracto-
ries in the Al2O3–B2O3 system. Refractories and Industrial Ceramics 45 (2004) [3]
dal silica-containing castables, indicating that the higher reactivity 177–180
of this SiO2 source was responsible for transformations that im-
proved hot modulus of rupture values and improved the strength of
high-alumina compositions.

Acknowledgments
The authors are grateful to FIRE, Petrobras, FIPAI and CNPq for
supporting this work. Received: 27.07.2015

You might also like