AGAINST

ow the vision 'ene Nation'Buppe 5es adteynative

voces )

8 basimultaneus eletions conpnssise denocacy

Jand dederaliam
So leto stort
toleentold that bitics in Îhdia bec
cole -inated Hace in. he19 90S. d Seguel
bequal to
Hhat aaeableaatire asets Hat ere ting
changed dor the bete Hu 20l4& 2019. But t
a naairei. sbme.convenience to. tho Sueqie toda
ohicht hasavidly soughtiito omte . Taking
examle, . h Nov. 2020 , Modi calledbt simuttaesus
j aleions Saidi he need64, the hgUt He said
it is not a matte 8 debote but what the
lcountuy needs. But does this heally stoþ the
debate nthe

So ohat is'ne Notion ne Eleion i9

ke coneept o "ome Nation,Ône tlecion in Trdio

ynahnrise eleions q n the Lok Sabha
|aims to tate
Hhe loue hose ) India's Paliament) nd al
 assembliea. the idea is to hold heo oleio
lher bn a single dat on wwi.in a
a
ehecitie time 4uame . ven the eas, PM
Modi' has juahed stngsy o the i deo
Siultaneous Lok Babka ard ate senloy oa.
he decisoo to task Horind to look into t
undersBteS he qoyenment's ouBUsnes a hat
alectioneabpaooch he ausemoly ala in e
states aee due this úea in Norembe Decenbe
which l be dolowd by thesLok sabha eections
shich is likely ito be hel in Mey - June 2024.
sweve, the Aecent mees qovt. have th
the tossibilhy he aene
ele ction and onestate bstls hich ane
sckeduled atex,
teadorith the Lok &abha contost,

1 hink we can Hhis a BJP dqenda .

PM Manendua NModi bas omastenty adrocated
imultuneas elecions ng since
victeyin theY2014 ok Sabha
pole. Even he 2014 BJP pall manisto
 |bielly mentiomed oo wnde Tnstitutional
Rajoum,
stating he BIP " wil seek to eralwe a mehod for
"hetding Asxemay lo Lok 3abho olections simutane
Onsutation wib otho aties
he BJP'S agum ent was to Neduce eletion
axquqment
exbenses bot þoltical oes e the qorerrnUn
ohile ensuing Slate governnen to

By 2019, he he ByP -eleased anothermanilesto

(Santals Pata) dor Lok Sabha tols, t uche
elined thei stance nde " G6d
Gosd Govenanee
|n imutanesulecons it said it was
comnited to halding simutanesus eledions
Patliamert 8ttedssernbis and local bodies to
qovt eseH Ces und
heduce expendilne,'uttlise Jovt
orces liciertly,
secuwityblannunot and enable iechive
aine tobld senss

His all baities TRe docunment also

a onrnon veter liat fer
lenbhasi aed the qoal ol to
al' electins to enswne evey citijen's ught
vote and aroid onsi on caused muifle
Lts,
 Page No.:
Avuoy Date:
youv

ter winning he elecion,in hís aldves, to

hation, Msli ackneuele dq ed he debate on
simult anes elections thd aled a
demochitic diseuss lon

+7o imbement Brne Nation , One ELectin

Gne Election",charqes
nould' also be hequuned in he Crnstitadion D
othes legad ramewsrks. Bne Nation - Gne
tleton wuld need a constitutiondl amind
ment then t would heedtor be takn
totate assembes. is nata mew Concest
takenláce times in:the 1950s
and G0s Inda hi euer states&
Brnale ebulation that Lonld ete. e
j Smsty jt was
that neqional
ssues ig ht qetr ovesha doedbuthe natioal
Uban issuesadeing he eletal oterme a
educed

he ag eement among al boliical aties

ip
nc y
signillcart hodle s well as of potion
paies hase Btbsed to 'Dne nlation ne
aylection ey alo cite the otential nabib
Ho madch the elreion stqies
e nation a Badi'es.
 Th 20l9, Rebeet came Page No.:
youv
Shell ie s) 50% EV Date:

ndine
haxe to
Houxre,the bopeet o) siultanesus electi'ons
mecessitates constitutional amendments to align
state legisLaive assembly texrns with he
Lok Sabha's dwation , caordrenis to thhe
Rebr esentation l the Peoble Act and athe
paxliamerntay þaocesses koguld adso be esential
Simultaneaus electiou weuld equine unilaorally
whent
shating e: eytnding the tem
Legislatues In der 6 aRgn thein' ection dates
with the diée date i Hhe Aet the courty
inuaesus elecion
agaiste s i i d dernocacñ becalse
4 dHembt to fmÙose an ntilicic cyde o
eledions hile inmiting vetehs' oiions
Reseamch conducted by the, tDFC insti thde enid
hat il election.ae held at six moth intoval
hee'sa beNcent likelihoed o votes tares
the sone
state.
polilical ty
assemblies andthe Lok Sabha , This dhsbs
to 61' elections ae held6 months
nake i g t n ut)
20)S -- BTø 36
 Date:
youV
Do Jedea
Net feasible, and can
and impact fdenalism
carn imbact

2018, he taw Comssion badoanis ed a tun

In
da cosultaion on
|only feU hauties - Sinomani ka Dal
the AIA bMK. he Sanajwadi Paty o the
Telanqana (now Bhorat) Razhba Sarnithi buboe
thedea. Nine oties BJP ally Ghoa
Feord Pasdty Tinamool Conquess Aaige AAP.
-DMK, Teluu Desan Paty, CPI, CPi-M,
Fewand Blo andethhe JD7s) spbssedt.
They sund he imere undbcHatc
and against the puincßles dederalism,
New, wth the qovt calling abiet sbeial' sesion
nd establishing he HLC o Gne Nation,ene Elhio),
hoe is sfe culationhat t wil attent to pans
elated eqislation soon. oweveh, tine o
Consultatios abeans imited doubt hems
about toe eoobexation Tanil Nadu cM M"k Stalin
called t "BJPI attmtt to imbese uniumity
ereything, SoMe au ques hat BJP
queahat inted
 Chiel MiNtu the BJP -uled dtates sutat the
idea, shereas BTD, ovehing
elcomed he move gpvening Ddisha,has
noith the AIADMK
Sinomahi Akali Dal .

ne Nation, ne Elecion ininteasible ina

Conty Ute Tnia. The RSS- BJP/s deshe s
On e hation - one lauw
ke hey
One leade OYe utuer, and one heligi
teqi on
on nvon't
lon wh ndian kealities. They can'
here

Given the stong etest todqed by the shpesition bantia,

may hich ule a no. citi ca stotes, the
Gne ation Bne Ele dtiondoeks ike a haud ' t ta
jca ack 4 the qovt
Sone ear that t state olilis inlena national
lections,it mauy ead to unstable qorenmens
contaay to tedoualism, Additionally , the bossibit
e undias mandatas could nocessitaleequert tueh
eections. ghile cost he ducion is dted ,expense
hare usen: een in non- pason panchayat nd
Locol body poda Thag vieso' combig hese
 Page No.:

Avuoy Date: youv

bislls s unnealsatio and a theeat to demnthatie

ideals n he long tem

The execse 8 holding siultone9Us eletions

her the hecommendo ons
egine ateast iee onstiutiona
would eq
dmendents - in AntideS 83,85, 172, 14 &
3
356.
beh
(Do anyone knoo how many amendmens have
made i date (lo5)
qprna awae He qerner al bublc with this
Who is
comblicated stucae l shich the qovt
suty
The Lay Comcion's Daoat hebot on siultinesus
polls in 2018 ao suggeited that atteast 80%
the states sheuld aati he Constittional
amendnents, Hi AEe t4 deas wh
Hhe dissetion stete tssenbes

A can The flanning

Jhalding
non- tate. the eion Get /Panliament
 Page No.:
youv
Date:

Loannet Imose ita nil on states he Union got.

apvt.
can athehuise only qet the Stales uled bs h e
BJP to yoluntanit Aecbnmernd he i s s iGp
he Stte cssemblies But Staes hale by
he
agaee.
Rost I nil leave to usto you þesble to make a a
inion e ysu.Thank au tor time. Have a
goed day ahead