Chapter 8: Developing Musicaltyin Blementary Students | 223
Gem te en ine sre sd
naturally play musically, while others achieve
‘only correct notes and chythm on their own, Stil others enjoy displaying their technical skills
‘without demonstrating an interest in playing musically. For the nore innate students, the
teacher's jb is to make them aware oftheir musical instincts so they can use them effectively.
For those who do not play musically itis the teacher's job to teach and develop musicality
Ten elementary students can communicate musically. Avital frst step isto help students
learn to produce a musical, xptesive sound and to solve technical difficulties that might
interfre with musical communication, Ii that which lies beyond correct notes and rhythm
that makes music come alive. Some pices may not be perfected or polished to a performance
level, put from the very iret leson, teachers can make sure that al piece ar played musically
in some way. One piece might be reassigned fora faster tempo, another fora louder dynamic,
8 third made mote exciting with greater varity in articulation, an tl another piee may be
‘mademore musical by adding the pedal.
In addition to learning and playing repertoire pieces, there aw’ many other experiences
that contribute to musical playing Students can become musical ntheir plying as follows
+ by discovering that music communicates mood or emotion and creates character
or personality in sound
+ by learning how to listen to their own plying
+ byunderstanding the construction of the music (musi literacy or theory)
+ by ereatng their own music
+ by playing in ensembles
‘Tut Rote oF Moon, EMOTION AND CHARACTER
{Inaction to developing the technica skills necessary fo producinga good sound a the piano,
students must associate mood, emotion and/or character with each piece as critical element in
achieving a musial performance. A good performance tll story or paints picture Teachers
can coach a musical performance, giving suggestions about interpretation, musical style and
fxprestion, but students must understand mood. emotion, and chaacter for performances to
become more than programmed perfection.
In the early stages of learning, understanding the composer's musical intent begins with
imagay. In “Giant Vines Growing” (See example 8.1), the frst thee lines move from the low
register ofthe piano to the high register. The ast line also moves fiom avery low C to a very
high C. This movement on the keyboard represents the growing of he vine from a sed inthe
_grours to very tl plant. The dynamics which begin with mp anc rach fPby the end of the
thied line charactrie the lage size of the plant,
\When pieces are approached through the imagination, musical playing s encouraged asa
resultof that image.224 | PROFESSIONAL PIANO TEACHING.
Example 8.1 “Gian Vines Growing” p15 Hom A Day in he ung, by lon George
GIANT VINES GROWING
“Many beginning pices are very simple so the teacher must sllthe sound of the pieces to
students. “A Secret” (se example 82) uses onl two diferent notes forthe whole piece and
consists almost entirely of quarter notes. Students will play more musialy if teachers draw
from the students experiences with secrets (fom the known tothe unknown). The fllowing.
‘Questions can stimulate the students imagination and make the piece more interesting:
+ Doyyu speak loudly or whisper when telling 2 secret?
+ Doyyou get clase to. persons ear when you tella secret?
+ Tsitfun toe secrets?
‘+ To whom do you like to tel secret?
‘+ Do you feel special when someone tells youa secret?(Chapter 8: Developing Musialty in Elementary Students | 225
Example 82°, Secret p 16 rom The MT: Time to Begin, by Cl, Goss nd Holand
Cm Cee id
x =F 1. Learning about P
“This simple piece wll come to life through such questions. Students might play the piece more
softly and keep the fingers very close to the keys because they can imagine themselves telling or
hearing a secret
‘To show that they love the sound of music, no matter how simple, and to encourage that,
same love and excitement in students, teachers can offer enthusiastic comments about pices
+ "Ljust ove this piece”
‘+ “This is my favorite piece in this book”
‘+ "Doesn't this piece sound exciting?”
‘+ "Lihink this piece sounds just like a beautiful, peaceful summer day?
It is sometimes dificult to evoke an image with pieces that have generic titles such as
sonatin, variation or suite. When the ttle ofa piece i a characterltempo indication such as.
Allegro, Andante, ot Adagio, fr example, teacher can initiate discussion about the composer's
intentions for the mood. Students are more likely to pinpoint the music's character if they
develop a large repertory of descriptive words forthe mood, emotion, or character. Instead
of limiting the definition of Allegro to “lively” students can be led to se words suchas joyful,
bright, cheeefl excited, radiant, ecstatic, jovial, or festive. Each piece exhibits characteristics226 | PROFESSIONAL PIANO TEACHING
that suggest its own special descriptive word or words. Once a word ischosen, then a story
‘might unfold, If jovial” seems to be the best descriptive word for apiece of music with a
generic ttle, additional words and image, such as jolly, party, dancing, ce cheering, help lead
students to an explicit image.
‘Teachers can prepare a list of descriptive nouns, adjectives and vert, such as those that
follow to help students develop a variety of touches interpret the dynamics, or fee the phrases.
busy dinry joyful sarcastic spin
busting — | dragging — | mocking | scampe stroke
caress fearsome | pet smudge teasing
cradle fost powerful | snap teeing
crash fossy prancing | sneaky tornado
cushion grand questioning | sparkly warm
Here are some cther ways a teacher might capture the imagination of students
‘+ Describe a piece asa rubber band that stretches with tension and eases back.
‘+ Ask students to iron phrases to get the wrinkles out
‘+ Askstudents to playa if picking up a feather, to ge a delicate sound
‘+ Ask students to push onthe key as if it were made of rubber, to get fll sound,
‘+ Make up words or sentences for musical phrases
4+ Make pa story about apiece
+ Ask students to move to piece, a the teacher plays it,
‘Tut Rote oF AuRAL DEVELOPMENT
‘The ability to listen critically to one's own playing isthe single most important skill needed for
‘creating a beautiful sound and developing musical playing. Music is heard and goes beyond
‘what is een onthe page and wht i physically accomplished atthe keyboard
‘The primary purpose of ear development isto help students listen toand judge their own
playing for acuracy, musical content and quality of sound. When students heat and listen
to musical elements, they are mote likely to observe those things and play them accurately.
Far development promotes inner hearing, which directs physical motions, thereby teaching
students to heat inwardly and play what they see, When students develep audiaton (to hear
and comprehend music inthe mind!) they become good readers and independent leatnes,
“They then know when they are playing the correct pitches and rhythms and are able to detect,
their own errors. Too often, teachers focus on technical proficiency, or precision and perfection,
Gordon isa or Mac Leaning < pening >‘Chapter 8: Developing Musicalty in Elementary Students | 227
erroneously thinking that musical playing will result, When students listen, precision and
perfection ae postive by-products. Other advantages include the ability to create beautiful
sounds artistic playing, and the ability to learn music quickly and accurately.
Therefore, beginning a lesson with activities that “tune-up the ears” seems as logical as
beginning the lesson with technical exercises or hearing a practiced piece. Such ear-training
activites direct the student to hear accurately what is being learned. Systematic and regular
aural experiences ensue that tis sil develops in a continuous fasion
Playing by Ear
When students play familie songs by er, they are learning to develop the ear in the most
natural way. Students must know the melody for songs they will play by ear. When teachers
“ig faite ngs fr stent to play by eat, students need to berold the following:
+ where to begin
+ the fist interval
‘+ which keys they will use to play the song
At fist the easiest songs are those that can be played entirely on Back keys. Late, these
songs can be transposed tothe white Keys. uch pieces (and their starting pitches) inchude "Old
MacDonald Had a Farm” (F-sharp),“Hot Cross Buns" (B-flat
flat) and “The Farmer in the Dell" (C-sharp)
[Next familiar songs that stay within the fve-inger position can be played by ear, These
‘would include "When the Saints Go Marching tn’ “Ode to Joy" (om Beethoven's Ninth
‘Symphony) and “Tingle Bells” (chorus). After students have learned the entre sale, they can
play songs with 2 wider melodic range. Some stadents may not be able to play the complete
song.at first. These students can be asked to play only missing measures rather than the entice
melody. For example, a student could be given the following as a practice assignment and
asked to play the missing measures by eat (se example 8:3),
ample 83 enter in pling ya
Away in a Manger
ares Mray228 | PROFESSIONAL PIANO TEACHING
When students are playing pieces with simple tonic, dominant and subdominant
accompaniments, they an also begin to learn to harmonize melodies by ear. Many familie
songs like “Itsy Bitsy Spider” "Merrily We Roll Along” or "London Bridge” can be harmonized
‘with tonic and dominant. A fist, students can simply harmonize wih tonic and dominant
single tones. Thea they can play the open Sth ofthe tonie and move the bottom note down a
‘half step forminga oth of the Vo15 chord, or add a major 2nd below the top note ofthe Sth tO
‘suggest the same chord. Late, ful toni and dominant V6/S chords canbe played.
-zample 4 Fore fon nd dominant for elementary hamenaaton|
Tonle Dominant Tonle Dominant 1 W
Sees might ist be gen the melody and some harmonies an ase o complete the
sssing harmonies year ee example 83)
sample neglect ei meion
Skip to My Lou
7 7
melodies that can be harmonized with tonic, dominant and subdominant include
"When the Saints Go Marching In” “Amazing Grace” and “Bingo”
Listening to the Sound
‘Young students who are asked, “What kind of sound do you want?” before they begin to play will
learn to imagine the sound ofthe musi through audition. Overtime the brain will begin to
develop an aulto-y image of the sound and a vsual image ofthe physical motions required to
make that sound cn the piano, This active listening gradually results in sn ease of playing since
the brain has enoagh advance notice to tell the body the physical motions required to make(Chapter 8: Developing Musicalityn Elementary Students | 2297
‘that sound on the piano. The physical esponse tothe notation ako becomes more automatic
‘Asa result, technical difficulties and physical tension are reduced. The physical response also
includes the elements that make the sound musical
Teachers who ask questions such a, "Did your playing sound loud (sof)?" of, "Did you
play withthe sound you wanted?” produce students who listen to their own playing using
critical listening sil. Other thought-provoking questions include the following
‘+ Can you make your playing sound jus ike mine?
‘+ How many phrases did you hear when I played? How many di you hear when you
played?
+ Which ofthese two performances sounds better? Why?
+ Did your staccatos sound short and snappy?
+ Did you hear the ends ofthe phrases?
+ Did you hear the melody or the accompaniment more?
+ Did your eighth notes all sound the same?
+ Did you hear the sound getting louder in this line?
‘The same approach to listening and questioning can help students correct their own
mistakes, Teachers can ask, "What interval is this” followed by," What interval dd you play?”
‘or “What does this rhythm Sound lke?” and then, “What rhythm did you play?
Because many students may not know what constitutes an appropriate musical sound,
teachers should model good musical sounds by playing regulary or by using compact disk
recordings inthe lessons to demonstrat the students’ music. Teachers an also play student's
piece in any ofa number of inappropriate ways, such as the following:
+ byaccenting the fist beat of each measure
+ byraccentng the last nots of phrases
+ byperforming lullaby loudly
Students can then critique the musical result
Students can be asked to playa piece or a phase with no dynami: change and then with
exaggerated dynamics. They wil hear that musi is more intresting when dynamics ae used,
The same procedure canbe used for articulations
Ear Development Drawn from the Student's Study Pieces
Ear training is most effective when the drills are drawn from the pieces and concepts students
are learning and playing. For example, in the Beginning pages of feds Premier Piano Course,
Lesson Book 1A, students learn about “higher” and “lower” Two pieces that reinforce these
‘concepts are almost identical, except that one piece goes up and the other goes down (see
‘examples 4.30 and 4.32 on pages 115 and 116). The teacher can ply one ofthe pieces while the230 | PROFESSIONAL PIANO TEACHING
student looksat the scores ofboth pices (but not at the Keyboard) and then tls which pice
‘was played. This simple exercise reinforces the concept of higher and lower and prepares the
stent to ply the pieces accurately
‘Teachers can play the lines from the second page of "The Greatest Show on Earth (see
‘example 8.6) one ata time in any order, begining on the frst measure ofeach system. The
students idenify which in was played. Each ine of musi in this piece has similar characteristics
but is diferert from the others. This equirs students to listen tothe playing and observe the
score carefully
‘Example 8.6 “The Greatest how on ant (xe) 9.35 om
‘Aled’ Bos Pan Libro eson Book 18 by Palmer, Manus nd Lethco
Another ‘ype of ear-development activity that uses the student's Iterature isan editing
game, Prior tothe lesson, the teacher rewrites a portion ofa piece on a dry-erase board oF
‘manuscript paper, changing the piece by adding or deleting certain elements. ‘The student
follows the reaitten score while the teacher plays it several times. The frst time it splayed
cxaclyas it was rewritten. With each subsequent playing, one thing is changed. The student
finds the change and corrects it inthe score. Through several play-throughs, one change eachChapter 8: Developing Muscalityin lementary Students | 231
time, the piece eventually returns tits original form. Changes shouldbe basic and simple, but
‘an increase in difficulty asthe student advances,
The first four measures of “My Robot” (see example 8.7 might be rewritten to look like
example 83.
‘Example 8.7 My Robt (rm, 1-1, p55 km Ales Basi Pano Libra, eson Book 1A
by Palmer, anus and ethan
Moderately fast
Sf
Conce | made a fine 1o-ol, Madehim of 2 Kich-en pot
‘Example 8 Altered version of ‘My Robo on. -8)
Slowly
Teacher Student
first playing playsas notated inthe | listens and follows the
altered score altered sore
second plying plays forte changes pin m. 1 to f
‘hired playing plays mm. 1-2legato | erasesstaccatos and
writs phrase mark
fourth playing playsmm.3-4legato | erasesstaccatos and writes
phrase mark
Sith playing plays moderately fast | changes“slowly” to “fast”
sixth playing plays m.4 as inthe changes notation to two
original version ‘quarter notes and aha note232 | PROFESSIONAL PIANO TEACHING
‘As the student progresses, more sophisticated elementsin the score can bealtered. The first
‘our measures of ‘When Our Band Goes Marching By!” (ee example 89) might be rewriten,
‘o look like example 8.10
‘Example 89 “when Ou: Sand Goes Marching By” (mm. 1-8), 6 fom Ales Base
Plano bray, Lesion Book 1B by Paet Manis ad eco
March tempo :
{Wn or and gee mat np
f,
‘xample 8.10 Alte vesion of "When Our Band Goes Marching By" (re. I~)
‘Teacher Student
first paying plays as notated in listens and follows the
altered sore altered score
second playing plays m.4asinthe changes the RH notation to
original version whole note (F)
‘play the rhythm ofm.1 | changes the notation to
fasinthe original version | (QJ J)
plays the rhythm of m.3 | changes the notation of
asinthe original version | m.3to(J J)(Chapter 8: Developing Musialty in Elementary Students | 233,
Listening and Responding Physically
‘Using the body to express whats heard helps build music into the body and makes car-training
fun, Some simple examples for elementary students include the following:
‘Teacher
plays music in & time and accents the first
beat ofeach measure
plays a piece and changes dynamics from
Toud to soft at unexpected times
‘plays musi, changing from legato to
staccato at unexpected times
‘Student
‘walks tothe beat and claps onthe fist
‘eat of each measure
moves (walks, svays, jogs) making large,
energetic body motions when the music
isloud and small, gentle motions when
the music is soft
walks with sliding steps when the music
islegato and with tiptoe steps when the
plays series of tonic and dominant
chords, changing from tonic to dominant
tor daminant to tonic at unexpected times
shape of phrases inthe following ways:
Feeling hearing and responding to phrases ar
can help stents hear beginnings and endings of phrases and help them feel the length and
‘makes body motions tothe chord that
isheatd to reflect the tension (and sus
pense) ofthe dominant chords and more
| axe motions forthe tonic chords
re essential parts of musical plying. Teachers
‘Teacher
Student
‘plays loud and soft phrases alternately
play ascending and descending phrases
plays short, familar song, making the
phrases clear
raises hisher arms atthe end ofeach
‘walks with large steps for loud phrases
and emall steps for soft phesees
‘walk forwaed when phrases ascend and
‘backward when phrases descend
phrase
|" improvises music in which the phrases
ae ratvely long and very clearly
Aelneated
plays a picce from the student’ reper
‘making beautifully shaped pheases
describes the shape and length ofthe
phrases with arm mations, changing
arm each time a new phrase begins
pallsa string out of an imaginary (or
real ball of string for each phrase1234 | PROFESSIONAL PIANO TEACHING.
Singing
“The most natural way to begin melodic ear-trainingis through singing, When students ears to
sing their pieces, phrasing, memory and legato playing are all facilitated,
Beginning leone may include singing feria songs withthe teacher F zame shdents
have trouble matching the pitches of the songs, teachers can spend a portion of every leson
singing with them, ‘The teacher can ask the student to sing any pitch and then match hisher
voice to the students. From that pitch the teacher changes the pitch one step either up or
down, asking the student to copy. After several lessons, the teacher will be able to lead the
student tothe pitches ofthe songs. Students who ae given this opportunity to Fearn to match
pitch in this gradual way wil key be comfortable singing inthe future.
‘Once students can match the pitches ofthe songs, they wil be ready to match the teacter’s
pitch and can begin to sing back short melodic fragments using a single syllable such as “a”
‘The frst short melodies might be similar to the fllowing examples.
a 3
‘When student! voces are able to match pitcher that are used in the pieces and execies
they are playing, teachers can ask students to sing the pieces and exercises that are in the
students singing range, Singing the lyrics of pieces sa natural way to incorporate singing ino.
the lesson and practice. Inthe piece “Position G” (see example 8.11), only the fs ine is inthe
“young student's vocal range, but the second line could be sung two octaves higher.
Example 8.11 Poston Gp. 50 tom Aes Bsc Panola, Lesson Book 1A
by Palmer Manus ad eto
Playing in G Postion(Chapter 8: Developing Musicalty in Elementary Students | 235
Ear-Training Drills
ar-training drills will assure that all aspects of aural development are covered. At the
clementary levels itis dificult to extrapolate enough eae-training material rom playing e
listening and movement activities, singing, and from the students repertoire. Some beginning
‘methods include eartraining books that drill concepts being studied. Ear taining activities
can be devised from the methods and materials being taught.
[At the elementary level, aural drills are useful for learning the following concepts:
+ Iowan high + rhythm patterns
+ Joud and sot «intervals
+ short and long (articulation) + chords
+ fast and slow (tempo) + major and minor sounds
‘The teacher can select eartraining drills that will prepare for the musical ideas in the
student's future repertoire. For example, a teacher might use a rhythm patter from a future
piece fra clapping dil, Teachers ace to consider the following when presenting ear-taining
drills to students:
+ Directions for adil should state clealy what students are listening for and how they
ate to identify
+ All drills shouldbe presented a minimum of two times
+ Pitch drills should be played slowly in the middle register of the piano,
+ Iisimportant for students to experience individual intervals (and chords) through
playing and listening before being asked to distinguish between them,
+ Tohelp students distinguish between pais of intervals (or chords), they should be
played both blocked and broken as well a ascending and descending.
++ Adominant chord (V) willbe more easly ecognized by ene ifthe 7h ofthe chord is
included,
{+ Identification of specific intervals chords, or major and minor sounds may be
facilitated through imagery and descriptive words such as rough, smooth, peaceful,
happy, spooky, mysterious, angry, and dark.
‘Teachers should stop an aural drill activity as son asthe students accuracy falters. When
such difficulties occur, teachers can assume that one o more of the following has happened:
‘+ Theteacher didnot sufficiently gain the student’ attention at the beginning ofthe
activity (teachers can simply sa, listen” before each new example)
+The sequencing of the activity was incorrect
+The activity was too complex.
+ Theexample was presented to0 quickly
+ The student needed to hear the example again,236 | PROFESSIONAL PIANO TEACHING.
Because individual students learn in different ways, they can be allowed to respond to
ills in various ways including the fllowing:
+ respond verbally to questions
+ demi by name what they hear
+ choose corel from several options
+ write the answer
+ sing the response
4+ lap-backtp-back or play-back what they hear
+ move to what they hgar
Categories of Aural Dri
“There ae several categorie of exrtraining drills that canbe applied to a variety of music
ements. Ldntifyng things that are the same o diferent; choosing the correct faseard for
‘whats heard clapping, tapping o plying back whats hears countingand rhythmic notation
sre ome methods that canbe used to promote aural development.
Sameand Different.
From the frst lesson, teachers can pay pairs of short musical ideasor clap pairsof short shythms
and ask students fo tell whether the two examples sound the same or diferent. Students can