You are on page 1of 28

1

Wealth and Investment

Special edition on
Succession and
Estate planning

In collaboration with
AF Mpanga Advocates ENS Africa Arcadia Advocates East Africa Venture Capital Association (EAVCA)
2

Stanbic - Wealth and Investment (WI)


The Wealth and Investment proposition centres on
managing, growing and protecting the generational
wealth of our clients and their families. Our
Bernice Kamahunde Mvano goals-driven investment approach allows our clients
Head Wealth & Investment
Stanbic Bank Uganda
to take a long-term view of their investments, whilst
simultaneously meeting their short-term lifestyle
needs.The Wealth and Investment focus is on finding
out what matters most to the clients, by
understanding the dreams, goals and ambitions they
have for themselves, their families and their
businesses. The WI team crafts a financial plan that
ensures they are living their desired lifestyle, safe in
the knowledge that the generational needs of their
families are taken care of.
3

Our Wealth Quotient Plan


and Protect

Fundamental to a successful wealth strategy is our


ability to take a holistic and comprehensive view - eate Liv
e
Cr an
considering our clients’ needs today and tomorrow, as

d
an
well as the needs of future generations. Solutions that

En
ld

joy
meet the needs of our clients and their families range

Bui
from investment services (onshore and offshore), risk YOU AND
solutions (insurance) and financing for different financial YOUR FAMILY
goals and objectives.

cy
ga
Sa

Le
ve
We believe that wealth serves two functions – to create

d
d

an

an
value and to give purpose to life. At Stanbic, we remain In s
ve on
committed to partnering with our clients on their st s i
Pa s
personal wealth journeys.
4

Tailored solutions to Grow your Wealth


A World of Effortless banking
Access to:
1 2 Access to:

• Specialised Lending. • Insurance



and Protect • Life

• Inward and outward bank guarantees.
Plan • Personal Banking
• On and Offshore.
• Commercial and Residential Property Lending. • Current account.
• Investment leverage. • Transactional cards.
te Liv
ea
• Savings.
r e an
C • Foreign exchange.

nager & We
• Lifestyle benefits.
a

d
• Digital.
M

d
an
al
p

En
• Internet Banking.

ld

th

joy
• Banking App.

sh
Bui

Ma
Relation
YOU AND

nager
YOUR FAMILY

cy
Investment solutions to Preserve
your Wealth

ga
Sa
Crafting your Legacy and enabling
Access to: your passions

Le
Te
ve
s
• Discretionary and Advisory Investment Management. a m O f E xp e r t

d
d
an
Access to:

an
• Global Strategic Asset Allocation Process.
In s
• Single manger and Multi-manager solutions.
ve on
• Estate And Legacy Planning.
st
ssi
• Online Share Trading. • Wills.
• Goals-based Investing / Asset Pa • Trusts (Domestic And Offshore).
and Liabilities Matching. • Offshore Company Structures.
• Family office solutions. • Residential programmes.
Plan
and Protect
• Lifelong cashflow modelling. • Intergenerational planning.
• Pre and post retirement solutions.
• Tax Free Investment Accounts. 360 APP

• Wealth 360 App.

3 4
Creating Value Giving Purpose
5

Tax Structuring and Planning


for Estates In Uganda
AF Mpanga Advocates
6

Introduction 4. A transfer of assets from the estate to the Common Assumptions Vs Reality
Tax structuring and planning involves understanding beneficiary attracts stamp duty, whereas a 1. Assumption that Uganda has an inheritance
the tax laws and regulations related to estate transfer from the deceased person to the tax. Reality: There is no inheritance tax in
planning and implementing strategies to minimize administrator does not attract stamp duty. Uganda.
the tax burden on the estate.
5. Trusts: Establishing a trust can provide various 2. Assumption: All inherited assets are subject to
General Key Considerations benefits for estate planning. Trusts can help tax: Reality: In Uganda, the mere act of inheriting
protect assets, provide for specific beneficiaries, assets itself does not trigger a tax liability.
Here are some key considerations and strategies for
and potentially reduce tax liabilities. However, income generated from inherited
tax-efficient estate planning in Uganda:
assets, such as rental income or dividends, may
1. Understand the Inheritance Tax: Uganda 6. Life Insurance: Life insurance policies can be a be subject to income tax in the hands of the
does not currently have a specific inheritance useful tool for estate planning. The proceeds from beneficiary.
tax. However, it is important to consider other a life insurance policy are generally tax-free in
applicable taxes, such as capital gains tax and Uganda and can be used to cover estate expenses 3. Assumption: There is a fixed tax rate for
stamp duty, which may be triggered during the or provide for beneficiaries. inherited assets. Reality: The tax treatment of
transfer of assets. inherited assets depends on the type of asset and
7. Asset Valuation: Accurate valuation of assets the income generated from it. Different tax rates
2. Should one keep assets in a company/Trust or is crucial for estate planning, especially for and rules may apply to different types of income,
Not? calculating potential tax liabilities. Ensure that such as rental income, dividends, or capital gains.
your assets are properly appraised to establish
3. Will and Testament: Creating a valid will is their fair market value. 4. Assumption: The recipient of an inheritance must
essential for effective estate planning. A will pay tax immediately. Reality: Tax on inherited
allows you to specify how your assets should 8. Marital deductions: transfer of assets between assets is generally due when income is earned
be distributed and can help minimize tax spouses does not attract capital gains tax. from those assets. For example, if a beneficiary
implications by utilizing exemptions and reliefs sells an inherited property and realizes a capital
available under the law. 9. Transmission of shares in a company from the gain, the capital gains tax becomes payable at the
deceased to a beneficiary do not attract capital time of the sale.
gains tax.
7

5. Assumption: The value of the inherited assets is a political subdivision of a government and a listed include; rental income, dividends, interest,
the same as the taxable amount. Reality: In some institution. capital gains, and other income earned by the
cases, the taxable amount may not be the same trust’s assets. Deductions and allowances
as the fair market value of the inherited assets. When selecting what establishment to use, different applicable to corporations are also available to
Certain deductions, exemptions, or reliefs may considerations are made based off the nature of trusts.
be available under the law, reducing the taxable business and assets to be held, the tax deductions
amount. and benefits, the various tax obligations among 4. Withholding Tax: If the trust receives income
others. from certain sources, such as dividends, interest,
6. Assumption: Inherited assets abroad are not or royalties, the payer of such income may be
Taxation of Trusts in Uganda
subject to Ugandan tax. Reality: Uganda follows required to withhold tax at the applicable rates
the worldwide income principle, which means When establishing and managing a trust in Uganda, before making the payment to the trust. The
that residents are generally subject to tax on there are several key aspects of taxation applicable trustee can utilise this as a withholding tax credit
their worldwide income, including income to trusts in Uganda to consider: when calculating the trust’s overall tax liability.
earned from inherited assets located outside 1. Income Tax for Trusts: Trusts in Uganda are
the country. However, double tax treaties, if subject to income tax on their chargeable 5. Capital Gains Tax: If a trust sells or transfers
applicable, may provide relief from double income. (Section 70- 73 of the ITA). The income business assets and realizes capital gains, it may
taxation. of the trust is generally taxed at 30%. be subject to capital gains tax. Capital gains are
generally taxed at a rate of 30% imposed on
7. Assumption: Informal transfers of inheritance 2. Trustee’s Tax Obligations: The trustee of a the gain realized from the sale or transfer of the
are tax-free. Reality: Even if an inheritance trust is responsible for filing a separate tax asset.
transfer is conducted informally, it is still subject return for the trust and paying the income tax
to tax obligations. It is important to adhere to the due on behalf of the trust. The trustee must 6. Compliance and Reporting: The trustee of
tax laws and properly account for any income register for tax purposes with the Uganda a trust is required to keep proper accounting
generated from inherited assets. Revenue Authority (URA) and obtain a Tax records and submit an annual tax return to the
Identification Number (TIN) for the trust. URA, disclosing the trust’s income, deductions,
and tax payable. Failure to comply with tax
Types of Asset vehicles subject to tax in 3. Taxable Income of the Trust: The taxable obligations can result in penalties and interest
Uganda income of a trust in Uganda is calculated charges.
The Income Tax Act imposes taxes on every person similarly to other persons/taxpayers. It includes NB: There are similar requirements and obligations
who has chargeable income for the year of income. income generated from all geographical sources with a company.
A person includes an individual, a partnership, a for a resident trust and income sourced from
trust, a company, a retirement fund, a government, Uganda for non-resident trusts. Specific sources
8 8

Ronald Kalema Vanessa Mbekeka


Partner, Head Tax Practice Associate
AF Mpanga AF Mpanga
LLB, Makerere University, LLM New York University LLB (Hons), Post Graduate Diploma Legal Practice, Certified Tax Advisor ICPAU
Ronald Kalema is a partner in the Corporate In addition to an LLM in International Taxation Mbekeka Vanessa M is an Associate at Vanessa has advised multi-sectoral
Department and Head of our Tax Practice. from the New York University School of Law, AF Mpanga and is an Advocate of the clients on the legal and tax implications
Ronald has a Post Graduate Diploma in Legal High Court and all courts subordinate of their various business transactions
He has twelve years of high-level tax advisory Practice from the Law Development Centre thereto. She is a member of the East and undertakings.
and litigation experience, having held senior and where he won the Uganda Law Society prize for African Law Society and Uganda law
managerial positions at both KPMG and Ernst & academic excellence, and an LLB from Makerere society. She completed the Certified She has experience drafting tax
Young. University, where he graduated among the top Tax Advisory course with the Institute opinions, handling tax objections, tax
5% in his year. of Certified Public Accountants audits and reconciliations, tax health
Ronald has advised major Ugandan and checks, private ruling applications,
multinational companies across various sectors Uganda. She is a specialized tax
He is a member of the East African Law Society practitioner with about 5 years’ representation at the Tax Appeals
on issues ranging from tax dispute resolution and and the Uganda Law Society where he is actively Tribunal, and applications for tax
tax audit support to tax restructuring, customs experience having worked at Grant
involved with the tax cluster. He has successfully Thornton and Ernst & Young. exemptions among other tax-related
planning, international tax, transfer pricing, tax led discussions with the Parliamentary Public matters.
policy and the tax implications of private equity Finance Committee on adoption of key tax
transactions and mergers and acquisitions. amendments for Uganda.
Notably, he has extensive experience in assisting
clients whose tax disputes have reached the Tax
Appeals Tribunal.
9

A Private Equity
Perspective
Estate and Succession Planning in
Family-Owned Businesses (FoBs)
10
1 | A Private
A Private Equity Perspective
Equity Perspective | |Estate
Estateandand Succession
Succession Planning
Planning in Family-Owned
in Family-Owned Businesses Businesses

Presentation Scope
A Private Equity Perspective-Estate and Succession Planning in FoBs

This presentation addresses the following questions:

1. What are the defining characteristics of FoBs in Uganda?


2. What are the capital needs of FoBs, and what are the potential sources of capital?
3. What is private equity financing, and what is the value-add of the financing option to an FoB?
4. What estate and succession planning considerations should an FoB take into account when seeking
out private equity financing?
5. How can FoBs leverage private equity financing in the estate and succession planning process?
6. What are the risks to FoBs associated with Private Equity Financing, primarily as relates to family and
succession planning, and how can these be mitigated?

Classified as Internal use only


11
A2Private Equity
| A Private Equity Perspective | Estate
Perspective | Estate and Succession
and Succession PlanningPlanning in Family-Owned
in Family-Owned Businesses Businesses

Uganda’s Family-Owned Businesses (FoBs)


Defining Characteristics of FoBs with a turnover of +$5 million

Dominant Sectors Sector Breakdown Annual Revenues


Transport
7.2% Agriculture
Telecommunications 11.65%
1.4% Consumer Goods
Real Estate 7.2% 5.8%
Education
.
Manufacturing Agriculture Food and Beverages 1.4%
21.7% 11.6% 17.4% Oil & Gas 4.3%
Financial Services
Media 1.4% 8.7%

Food &
Leisure and Beverages
Traditional Sectors: Most FoBs operate in traditional Tourism 7.2% 17.4%
sectors, which take up a big share of Uganda’s economic
Industrial
output (GDP).These sectors tend to be fast growing when a Manufacturing
country is relatively poor such as Uganda. Healthcare
21.7% 4.3%
Multi-Sector Focus:A Significant number of FoBs are large
conglomerates with interests across various sectors often Tertiary Sectors: Besides the dominant sectors, the other half of Revenue: by virtue of operating in multiple sectors,
structured as a group of companies. FoBs operate across ten (10) sectors, largely in the tertiary sector. hedging the risk of sector concentration, FoBs earn
substantive revenues of $10 million -$100 million.This
Source:Asoko (2020) East Africa’s Family Owned Business Landscape applies to FoBs with annual revenues of +$5million.
Classified as Internal use only
12
A3Private Equity
| A Private EquityPerspective
Perspective | |and
Estate Estate and Succession
Succession Planning in
Planning in Family-Owned Family-Owned Businesses
Businesses

Financing the Growth of FoBs


Capital Needs and Sources

Financing Needs Financing Sources

Horizon FoB Financing Needs


Auto-financing
1. Expansion in existing markets through (retained earnings)
Short term organic growth, Internal financing
financing 2. Funding day to day operations,
needs Family members
3. Development of new or improved
investing in equity
products or services.
Financing Sources

1. Acquisitions, Bank debt


Long term 2. Expansion in new geographical markets,
financing 3. Expansion in new sectors
External financing
needs (diversification).
Private equity

Source: KPMG (2014) Financing Matters | Financing Family Business Growth through individual investors
Classified as Internal use only
13
A4
Private Equity
| A Private Perspective
Equity Perspective | | and
Estate Estate and Succession
Succession Planning inBusinesses
Planning in Family-Owned Family-Owned Businesses

Unpacking Private Equity


Patient Capital - An Alternative Capital Source for FoBs

During the holding period, the At the end of the holding period,
Invests capital in the companies Hold its investment interests in
with…. the company for a period of … investor creates value in the exit their investment in the
in the form of either….
company by…. company through either….
Invests in mature companies
Product : A product or service with •Equity financing – this involves •3-5 years- medium term horizon •Board oversight : Get sits on the •Exit by management buyout –
•a competitive edge or unique selling take up of a minority or majority board so that they can adequately the Founders buy back shares held by
point. equity position –by an investor in •OR guide a company towards growth. For the investor, with the investor exiting.
exchange for capital.The funding is equity and quasi equity providers, as This may be the best option for FoBs
Team : An experienced management unsecured (no collateral) and the they do not request (collateral) as it ensures full ownership of
•5-10 years- long term horizon
•team able to drive company growth. investor shares the risks (losses) and security for capital extended, their interests reverts back to the family at
This is important as investors are not rewards (profits) with the founders. oversight at board level is also a the end of the holding period.
involved in the day to day means to ensure their investment is
•Quasi-Equity /Mezzanine secure.Through their oversight role,
management of the company. •Exit by trade sale – The investor
financing – this is subordinated the board can influence decisions to transfers their [majority or minority]
debt that blends features of debt enhance a company’s EBITDA.
Growth potential : High growth equity interests in a company to a
with features of equity. It is
•prospects in a market and evidence strategic acquirer.
subordinated to pure debt but senior •Valuable connections : For
A Private Equity of ability to obtain substantive market to equity. It allows founders to companies that have expanded as far
Investment Fund share. retain ownership but often has as their various resources or •Exit by secondary buyout – The
embedded options for converting management team can take them, investor transfers their [majority or
Business plan : Sufficiently ambitious debt into equity.The funding is investors offer access to a wealth of minority] equity interests in a
• Growth Stage company to another investor.
•but realistic development prospects unsecured (no collateral). invaluable resources accessible
Private Equity : through their network.These may
with a focus on companies that are
Range of $250,000 to looking for capital to grow into new include operational executives, •Exit by Initial Public Offering
•Private debt financing- this is
$10 million per markets or restructure operations. industry experts, new suppliers, –Listing on the stock exchange
senior debt , but differs from
investment in a Interest is in projected annual profits commercial bank debt as it is offered economies of scale and access to through an Initial public offer.
company. (EBITDA) of 20-25%. by non-bank institutions. Ownership new markets.
is retained by the founder .The •BUT
• Mid Private Equity : funding may be secured. Interest rates
Range of $10 million have a fixed timeframe and conclude •Non-participation in
when the debt matures. management : Investors Do not
to $100 million per engage in the day to day management
investment in a of the company. For this reason,
company. investors will typically want to invest
in a company with a sound and
competent management team.
Classified as Internal use only
14
A5
Private Equity
| A Private Perspective
Equity Perspective | | and
Estate Estate and Succession
Succession Planning inBusinesses
Planning in Family-Owned Family-Owned Businesses

Private Equity and FoBs


Estate and Succession Planning Considerations
Generation Personal Motivations and Priorities Defining Characteristics Suitability When to seek private equity Ideal private equity financing
Legacy versus business continuity of private financing options
(what the family/ FoB seeks to achieve as relates to the equity
generational transition.This influences ownership and financing
management transition decisions)
1 st Legacy and family togetherness : Maintaining family The 1 stgeneration (Founders) of FoBs often possess a strong Moderate Succession Motivation: Want to Mezzanine financing or equity
Generation control and leaving a legacy for the 2 nd generation (children) drive and have a clear vision for the company both during and build a business empire to outlast financing with minority stake with
nd rd
(Founders) to inherit is a key driver for the 1 st generation. beyond their lifetime. In developing countries such as Uganda, ones own lifetime into the 2 and 3 management buyout as the agreed
Business continuity :A secondary priority for the founder they build their businesses in traditional sectors driving GDPs generation but lack adequate upon exit strategy.An exit by
is to minimise conflict between children- particularly where of developing economies, and leverage on personal networks financing (own or bank debt) or management buyout would ensure the
children may not get along. Here, the founder may choose- and political ties to build their businesses towards success. technical ability to drive aspirations business ownership reverts to the
nd
during their lifetime- to grant some children ownership of relating to acquisitions, diversification family for the 2 and subsequent
the company, and in fairness, bequeath other children with into new products, or expansion into generations to inherit.
other [real estate] properties outside the business. new markets.

nd
2nd Legacy and family togetherness : Sentimental The 2 generation observed their parents build the FoB (from Succession motivation: Similar to Mezzanine financing with
Generation attachments to [departed] parents who founded an FoB scratch), were personally mentored by the 1 stgeneration, the above, but due to sentimental management buyout as the agreed
(Children of make keeping the business in the family an overriding therefore retaining and pursuing the original vision, and are able reasons, may not be open to transfer upon exit strategy.As mezzanine
Founders) motivation for the 2 nd generation, with very little appetite to quickly resolve inter-sibling conflicts relating to the FoB as Low of minority ownership as would be financing allows owners to retain
for even partial transfer of control, even where the business they shared a similar upbringing in the same household.They the case under equity financing. ownership to the extent possible
may benefit from alternative financing. also may still have and maintain the political connections their (unless equity options rights are
parents built the business on. triggered), this may be suitable.

rd
3rd Business continuity: The priority is often to 1) minimise The 3 generation often lacks the vision, drive and [business] Succession motivation: Cousins Equity financing with no restrictions
st nd
Generation family conflict and litigation–often between cousins and connections as did the 1 and 2 generation, and may not have interested in the business may want on exit options if business continuity is
st
(Grand different family branches- 2) continue the family sentimental attachments to the company as their parents did. to buy out those not active or the core objective.The Founders (1
Children of legacy-regardless of who leads [or owns] the company as Many are better educated than previous generations –mostly interested.Those not active or generation) must anticipate and plan
Founders) either a family or non-family member. abroad- and may want to pursue careers outside the family interested may want to liquidate their for the eventuality of non-family
rd High
business. Further, by the 3 generation, the FoB’s ownership [equity] positions in the company and ownership in their will under
may split among cousins who may not have a similar upbringing move on to their own lives and provisions for share transfer (i.e. who
or strong relationships as their parents did for amicable pursue their own personal and can and cannot own shares in the
resolution of conflicts arising, resulting in litigation. business aspirations. company in subsequent generations).

Classified as Internal use only


A6
Private Equity 15
| A Private EquityPerspective
Perspective | |and
Estate Estate and Succession
Succession Planning in
Planning in Family-Owned Family-Owned Businesses
Businesses

Risks and Risk Management Strategies


FoB Strategies for Mitigating Risks and Challenges associated with Private Equity Financing

FoB Concern Risk Mitigation Strategy by the FoB Private Equity Risk Mitigation Strategy by the FoB
(Risk) Concern (Risk)

Concern Remedy : Sale only a minority stake in the business to a private equity firm. Concern Remedy : Streamline corporate governance
Loss of control Poor corporate policies, practices and systems prior to seeking
This will ensure: governance out private equity financing.
1. The FoB retains majority control of the business. within FoBs and
2. The FoB gains incremental access to capital and subject matter expertise from the investor and the unclear lines of Aspects of good corporate governance include:
investors’ network of advisors and consultants. separation 1. A properly constituted Board
3. The owners of the FoB obtain liquidity for their equity positions transferred to the investor. between family 2. A clearly and explicitly drawn line between
and business. the business and the family.
Concern Remedy : Conduct due diligence on private equity firms to assess the alignment between the practices of
3. Evidence of management accountability.
Misalignment the capital provider with the FoBs needs and expectations.
between the
expectations of the Aspects to assess include:
FoB and private 1. The history of the private equity firm in investing in FoBs.
equity investor 2. References from other FoBs the private equity firm has invested in previously.
3. The private equity firms’ experience in the sector in which the FoB operates.
4. Alignment of the private equity firm’s exit strategy with the needs of the FoB as regards succession
planning (e.g. planned exit by management buyout as opposed to trade sale to a strategic acquirer)
5. Alignment of private equity firm’s investment horizon with that of the FoB with a preference for
those with longer holding periods (5-10 yeas).
6. The governance protections that are available to the FoB owner.
7. Clarity from the private equity firm on what value uplift the partnership will result in i.e. on how the
private equity firm intends to create value over and above what the owner can achieve on their own.
Classified as Internal use only
16
A7
Private Equity
| A Private Perspective
Equity Perspective | | and
Estate Estate and Succession
Succession Planning inBusinesses
Planning in Family-Owned Family-Owned Businesses

Conclusion and Key Takeaways


A Private Equity Perspective-Estate and Succession Planning in FoBs

The following are the key takeaways:

1. Private Equity financing can be an important alternative source of capital and financing for large and established (mature) FoBs
with aspirations consisting of Acquisitions, Expansion in new geographical markets or Expansion in new sectors (diversification).
2. Besides extending capital access to an FoB, the private equity financing model ensures that an FoB has access to a resource pool
of expertise to accelerate business growth.
3. For the 1 stgeneration (founders), private equity can provide a company with the needed impetus for growth. On exit by the
private equity firm through a management buyout, the founder can hand over to subsequent generations a sound business.
4. For the 3rdgeneration (founders’ grandchildren), private equity can provide an avenue through which different conflicting
branches of the family can liquidate their positions and exit.The Founders (1st generation) must anticipate and plan for the
eventuality of non-family ownership in their will under provisions for share transfer (i.e. who can and cannot own shares in the
company going forward).
5. To manage risks associated with private equity investors, such as loss of control, owners of FoBs can opt for minority stake
private equity investments. Most investors in Africa take on minority positions.
6. To qualify for private equity financing, FoBs must strengthen their corporate governance policies, systems and structures

Classified as Internal use only


17
A8
Private Equity
| A Private Perspective
Equity Perspective | | and
Estate Estate and Succession
Succession Planning inBusinesses
Planning in Family-Owned Family-Owned Businesses

References and Useful Resources


Asoko Insight. (2020).East Africa's family-owned business landscape
. Asoko Insight.

BVCA. (2010). A Guide to Private Equity. BVCA.

Deloitte. (2020). Private company issues and opportunities 2020- Family business edition
. Deloitte.

EVCA. (2007). A guide to private equity and venture capital for entrepreneurs. EVCA.

KPMG. (2014). Family matters | Financing family business growth through individual investors
. KPMG.

KPMG. (2023). Succession planning in family businesses


. KPMG.

OECD. (2015). New approaches to SME and entrepreneurship financing: broadening the range of instruments
.

OECD.

Classified as Internal use only


18

A Will:
As a tool to protect
business and
preserve wealth.
Presentation by Isaac Bakayana.
Advocate with Arcadia Advocates. Lecturing Estate
Planning at School of Law, Makerere University.
19
A Will: As a tool to protect business and preserve wealth.

Why must you have a Will? When to draft a Will? How to draft a Will?
• A business (property) is built over a lifetime. • Drafting a Will commences in thought and will be • Though a Will may not remove conflict in a business/
complete upon fulfilment of all legal requirements. family, it reduces the chances of conflict.
• The business owner will grow it, will make forecasts,
will give it direction, find customers, not sleep, have • To start a business, maintain it successfully and • If preparing the Will commenced with the business,
dreams (nightmares)… generate wealth that will run across generations takes the Will will re-affirm what is already in place.
a lot of ingenuity, time and effort.
• Just like planning for the business, a plan for what • A Will must be signed by its author and his/her
• As a business runs during the lifetime of its proprietor
happens to the business upon the pioneer’s death, is signature attested to by two adults.
(s), the writing of the Will should also be running
important/very important…
simultaneously. • A Will being the “wishes” of the maker contains: The
• Manage the future and the risk associated with the • The Will, upon fulfilling the few legal requirements, author’s particulars, confirmation of soundness of
future (business continuity and preservation of is a document that carries ideas, principles, themes mind, A person’s history, burial site and distribution of
wealth). against which the business was built or should be roles for the burial, Spouse (s) (If any).
preserved.
• Child (ren).
But what is a Will? • During the proprietor’s lifetime, he/she should identify
• Will is – a “Wish; desire; choice”. It is a “legal expres- individuals within and outside the family that have the • Property (if any) and its management or distribution
sion of an individual’s wishes about the disposition of skill to run the business. • Heir.
his or her property after death;…a document by which
a person directs his or her estate to be distributed • The beneficiaries of the Will need not be the managers
of the business. • Executors.
upon death…”
• Therefore, running the business today, must run • Desires/Word of advice, Signatures (of author and
• A Will is a wish or desire or choice about what a person witnesses), date.
simultaneously with writing the Will.
desires to be done with their property, their remains,
their business upon death. • Better still, if the business is run through a successful • Writing vague Wills.
structure, that ought to be suggested/maintained in
• A Will may stipulate who should or should not attend a the Will. • Running a business and giving no thought at all to its
burial, the color of clothes that should be used, which continuity.
• A Will for emphasis contains the desires/wishes of
child has been a nuisance.
the author. So, the author will write his/her desires/ • Being “surprised” by the onset of death and making a
wishes for his/her business. Will in those circumstances.

20
A Will: As a tool to protect business and preserve wealth.

Recommended practices: • In the creation of the trust, the owner (settlor)


appoints suitable trustees to manage the property/
• Amending a Will under the influence of “new
• Have a Will. run the business.
influencers” and abandoning the ethos on which the
business was built, run and managed. • Write a Will (on clear principles) simultaneously as • Appoints other professionals to render services to
you run the business. the trust while simultaneously conferring benefit
• Introducing “new” people to the business who have no
business acumen onto the beneficiaries.
• Avoid a discussion of the Will during your lifetime
especially with the potential beneficiaries/or • The trustees manage the property/business, are
• Making complex Wills that may be impossible to
keeping it within their reach. fully accountable to the beneficiaries, but the latter
implement (at times making “unacceptable” Wills).
are not permitted to interfere in the function of the
• Making a Will without duly assessing the strengths
and weakness of the beneficiaries in whose charge the
What of a Trust as a wealth trust.

business is placed. preservation tool? • Therefore, a trust if well utilized and appropriately
designed, is a tool for preservation of wealth.
• Making a Will to punish either a spouse or a child • A trust is a proprietary (property) relationship
(writing a Will not on business principles). involving the owner (settlor), the trustee (the • Thoughts as we end…
manager) and the beneficiaries.
• Grow the business.
• It is has been labelled as one of the greatest
innovations of the English man because of its • The World will continue after you, so must your
versatile nature and the capacity to be put to business.
various uses. • Your business should not follow you after your
• For the preservation of wealth, it can be used death.
to protect the beneficiaries against themselves • The business generation of tomorrow, starts its
(protective trusts), the Trustees can be training today.
empowered to confer benefit when they deem it
fit (discretionary trusts), can confer benefit to the • It is your Will. Its pulse should be business
beneficiaries but without giving them the asset preservation.
(entitlement to income and not capital), can benefit
the children and their children (life tenants and
remainder persons), can be used to encourage the
hard-working beneficiaries (advancement).
21

Corporate
governance for
family businesses
By Donald Nyakairu & Martha Mutamba
30 June 2023
22
Corporate governance for family businesses

Scope of presentation Introduction Principles of corporate


• Introduction: What is corporate governance and why is it important? • Corporate governance involves a set of governance
relationships and the networks between a
• Principles of corporate governance • Responsibility – Companies should
company’s management, its board of directors,
• Forms of business ownership its shareholders and other stakeholders ensure that procedures and structures are
in place so that people know what they are
• Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) • It can be defined as the system by which responsible for and what they are liable to
companies are directed and controlled account for.
• How to effectively implement corporate governance
• It is the structure through which the objectives • Accountability – Companies should clearly
• Separation of ownership and control
of a company are set and the means in which set out who is accountable for what and over
• Corporate governance for family-owned businesses those objectives are attained and monitored what time period, so that stakeholders are
• It is a key tool for reconciling divergent interests, clear on who they should hold responsible.
Intention of presentation planning for strategy and succession, accessing
• Understand corporate governance and its importance capital, cultivating a company image and • Transparency – Clarity of process in
ensuring legal compliance making decisions and carrying them
• Understand relationship between shareholders, management and the out. Transparency builds trust between a
board of directors company and its stakeholders.
• Understand why corporate governance is necessary to incentivize
Why is corporate governance
• Fairness – All key stakeholders should be
good business practices important? treated fairly when decisions are made or
• How to implement corporate governance in the most effective way • Improved share performance actions are taken by a company.
• Relevance of good corporate governance practices for family owned- • Good corporate governance ensures the
businesses shareholders get a fair return from their
investment
• Improved operational performance
• Improved oversight, monitoring and evaluation
• Effective decision making
• Succession planning
• Improved access to external financing
23
Corporate governance for family businesses

Forms of business ownership How to effectively implement corporate • Management reports and is accountable to the board
• Sole proprietorship governance of directors
• Balance board composition – Greater diversity on • The board of directors reports and is accountable to
• Partnership
boards introduces new ways of thinking and better the shareholders at the annual general meeting
• Joint venture decision making
Corporate governance for family-owned
• Private limited liability company • Evaluate the board regularly
businesses
• Single member company • Ensure director independence • Founders are often the owners, decision makers and
managers in family-owned businesses
• Company limited by guarantee • Ensure auditor independence – Have both internal
and external auditors • This can create conflict with other family members
Environmental, Social and Governance who may have different views as to the future direction
• Transparency – Share accurate, clear and easy to
(ESG) of the business
understand information with stakeholders. Both good
• New priorities in the business of the future and bad news • Corporate governance attempts to keep conflict at a
minimum
• It is the framework for responsible corporate action • Define shareholder rights
that reconciles social and environmental concerns in • It ensures long-term sustainability of the business and
business operations • Aim for long-term value creation
is a key tool in succession planning
• More and more family business leaders are confronted • Document policies and procedures
with the fact that ‘stakeholders’ expect them to
actively contribute to solving global challenges. The Separation of ownership and control
bar is higher than ever, and they are expected to take • Shareholders own shares in a company – an intangible
responsibility – not only for their company´s financial interest in an intangible entity.
performance but also for societal goals, for a better
• Shareholders delegate the right to control a company
world
and use its assets to the board of directors and
• ESG strategy: to position companies as leading management of the company
providers of sustainable, responsible, and innovative
• The board of directors and management have the
products and services – and to demonstrate
time and expertise to get the most out of a company’s
exemplary corporate governance
assets for the benefit of the company – which returns
value to the shareholders
24
Corporate governance for family businesses

Implementing corporate governance in family-owned


businesses
Shareholder level Board level
• Agree on and document the family’s • Where the board is made up wholly of
vision, mission and values for the family members, the board may set
business. This allows management to up an advisory board or appoint non-
be aware of the direction the business executive directors who are experienced
should be moving in and under what and respected, to support the family
ethical framework. in areas such as strategic planning,
marketing, development of human
• Agree on the process for appointing, capital and expansion into new markets
and the number of family members to
be appointed to the company’s board of Management level
directors.
• Education and career planning to ensure
• Agree on a mechanism for family family members have the expertise to
members to sell their shareholding take up management positions in the
and exit the company – pre-emption company to ensure control stay with the
rights, shares first offered to the existing family.
shareholders before they can be sold to
outsiders.
25 25

Donald Nyakairu designation:


Partner, ENSafrica

LLB (Hons) (Makerere University)


LLM (University College, University of London)
Diploma in Legal Practice (Law Development Centre, Kampala, Uganda)

Donald Nyakairu is a Partner at ENSafrica l Uganda. He His experience further includes advising clients in respect • Uganda Law Society and the East African Law Society
is a highly experienced corporate commercial lawyer. He of M&A, encompassing the evaluation of financials, due
has particular expertise in the information technology and diligence and post acquisition restructuring. • Commonwealth Partnership for Technology Management
telecommunications sector, having acted as managing – Networker
director, chief legal counsel and company secretary at Donald is a respected former diplomat who, during his
• Visiting lecturer on telecommunication law – International
one of the largest telecommunications solutions providers posting to the Uganda High Commission in London, was
Law Institute, Kampala, Uganda
in Uganda for 10 years. He is a registered insolvency responsible for all Commonwealth-related matters. He
practitioner and has been involved in several insolvency liaised with the Commonwealth Secretariat and numerous • Member of Ministerial Task Force on the development of
matters both as provisional administrator, a receiver and international bodies in the United Kingdom such as the ICT Infrastructure in Uganda – 2007
has advised on business rescue. He advises several clients International Coffee Organisation, Centre for Agriculture
• Member of Procurement Committees for various World
operating in national and international payment systems. and Biosciences International, the International Sugar
Bank/African Development Bank projects including the
Organisation and the Commonwealth Partnership for
Project implementation Unit of the Ministry of Education,
Donald has been involved in various telecom sector Technology Management.
National Water and Sewerage Corporation and the
studies including rural community development funding,
Donald represents many corporate clients and assists Ministry of Works, Transport and Communications
determination of interconnection rates, mobile money,
spectrum re-farming and quality of service. He was companies in setting up their local operations in Uganda and Donald is recognised as a leading/recommended lawyer by:
chairman of the Finance and Commercial Group for the with their regulatory compliance. His clients also include
banks, large corporates, insurance companies, fintechs • IFLR1000 Financial and Corporate Guide; Banking, M&A
Eastern Africa Submarine Cable System and participated in
which he advises on licensing, various aspects of recovery, – 2023, 2022, 2021, 2020, 2019, 2018, 2017, 2016, 2015
the drawing up of various documents including the contract
business restructuring and securitisation. (Uganda)
with the supplier and the construction and maintenance
agreement. Donald also served as the chairman of the He is a member of the following professional bodies/ • Chambers Global Guide 2023, 2022, 2021, 2020, 2019,
East African Backhaul System and, accordingly, has in- associations: 2018, 2017, 2016, 2015 – General Business Law (Uganda)
depth knowledge and experience in respect of telecoms
• The Legal 500 EMEA 2023, 2022, 2021, 2020, 2019, 2018
infrastructure development.
– Legal Market Overview (Uganda)
26 26

Martha Mutamba
Associate, ENSafrica
LLM (London School of Economics and Political Science)
LLB (Hons) (University of Dar es Salaam)
Diploma in Legal Practice (The Law Development Centre)

Martha Mutamba is an Associate at ENSafrica reports, preparation and review of transaction


in Uganda. She specialises in M&A, corporate documents and drafting a number of commercial
restructurings, energy and general corporate documents including shareholders’ agreements
commercial advisory. and share purchase agreements. Martha has also
been involved in advising telecommunication
Her experience includes advising clients on companies on share and asset purchases.
corporate and commercial matters, M&A
processes, conducting legal due diligence Martha is a member of the Uganda Law Society
investigations, preparation of due diligence and East Africa Law Society.
27
28

You might also like