Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: N. Soltani, R.A. Khavari-Nejad, M. Tabatabaei Yazdi, Sh. Shokravi & E.
Fernández-Valiente (2005) Screening of Soil Cyanobacteria for Antifungal and Antibacterial Activity,
Pharmaceutical Biology, 43:5, 455-459, DOI: 10.1080/13880200590963871
Abstract
Soil cyanobacteria isolated from the paddy fields of active biocide components could be another important
seven provinces in Iran was evaluated for antimicrobial selective advantage (Mundt et al., 2001). Terresterial
activity. Aqueous, petroleum ether, and methanol and marine cyanobacteria have proved to be an
extracts from 76 microalgae were examined for anti- extremely valuable source of novel bioactive agents
microbial properties against four bacteria and two fungi. (Jaki et al., 2000; Hirata et al., 2000).
Of total microalgae, 22.4% (17 cyanobacteria) exhibited Screening of cyanobacteria for antibiotics and other
antimicrobial effects. Selected cyanobacteria with posi- pharmacologically active compounds has recently
tive antimicrobial activities were members of the families received considerable attention, cyanobacteria are as
Stigonemataceae, Nostocaceae, Oscillatoriaceae, and novel bioactive natural producers (Borowitzka, 1995;
Chroococcaceae. Growth of Bacillus subtilis Persian Borowitzka & Borowitzka, 1988). Many active sub-
Type Culture Collection (PTCC) 1204 and Staphylo- stances with antibacterial, antiviral, fungicide, enzyme
coccus epidermidis PTCC 1114 were inhibited by 12 and inhibiting, immunosuppressive, cytotoxic, and algicide
14 species of cyanobacteria, respectively. Also, eight cya- activity have been isolated from cyanobacterial biomass
nobacteria inhibited the growth of Escherichia coli or in some cases from the medium of laboratory cultures
PTCC 1047, and two species inhibited the growth of (Knubel et al., 1990; Mule et al., 1991; Gerwork et al.,
Salmonella typhi PTCC 1108. Considering fungi, six 1994; Falch et al., 1995; Jaki et al., 1999).
species inhibited the growth of Candida kefyr ATCC Cyanobacteria of local habitats have rarely been
1140, and one cyanobacterium species inhibited the screened for biological effects. Ghasemi et al. (2003) have
growth of Candida albicans ATCC 14053. Furthermore, surveyed antibacterial activities of microalgae of northern
one of the paddy fields (Khozestan) showed no anti- Iran. Also, a novel antimicrobial substance named
microbial activity. Parsiguine has been identified (Ghasemi et al., 2004).
Therefore, in a continuing investigation, the biological
activities of various species and strains of terrestrial cya-
Keywords: Antibiotics, antimicrobial activity, cyano-
nobacteria in different provinces of Iran were studied.
bacteria, paddy fields, soil.
The ability to produce antimicrobial substances may be
noticed not only as a defensive instrument for the strains
but also as a good source of new bioactive compounds
Introduction from a pharmaceutical point-of-view. Accordingly, 228
Cyanoacteria are a major component of microbial flora lipophilic and hydrophilic extracts obtained from 76
in rice paddy fields and contribute to the fertility of such samples of cultured soil cyanobacteria were investigated
ecosystems (Roger & Kulasooriya, 1980). Producing to detect their antimicrobial effects.
Table 2. List of cyanobacteria with antimicrobial activity. the current observations. Petroleum ether, methanol,
and supernatant extracts of F. ambigua FS18 had inhibit-
Order Family Genera
ony activity against B. subtilis PTCC 1204, S. epidermidis
Chroococcales Chroococcaceae Chroococcus sp. PTCC 1114, and E. coli PTCC 1047. In addition, cell
Oscillatoriales Oscillatoriaceae Oscillatoria sp. extracts of this strain had antifungal activity against
Plectonema sp. C. kefyr ATCC 38296.
Nostocales Nostocaceae Nostoc spp. As mentioned, few studies have been done in relation
Stigonematales Stigonemataceae Stigonema spp. to cyanobacteria of Iran (Ghasemi et al., 2003), and this
Fischerella spp. study follows a screening program for isolation and
Hapalosiphon spp.
identification of antimicrobial-producing species from
Iranian paddy fields. No inhibition was shown against
Also, H. hibernicus FS 33 indicated a widespread E. coli PTCC 1047 and no antimicrobial activity was
spectrum of antimicrobial activities. Only two cyano- detected in nonpolar extracts (Ghasemi et al., 2003). In
bacteria indicated antibacterial activity against Salmon- spite of that, data obtained from this research demon-
ella typhi PTCC 1108, and these results were detected strated antimicrobial activity against E. coli PTCC
in petroleum ether extracts. 1047 in six methanol, three petroleum ether, and one
Results showed that in species with activity against aqueous extract. A diterpenoid with antibacterial activity
S. epidermidis PTCC 1114, the Ai (Antimicrobial index) from Nostoc commune Vaucher against E. coli who iso-
varied between 32 and 112. This is comparable with the lated by Jaki et al. (1999).
results of Ghasemi et al. (2003). It was different in other No inhibition was observed against C. albicans ATCC
cases, for instance 38–78 against B. subtilis PTCC 1204 14053 by a methanol extract of Nostoc muscorum C. A.
and 32–86 against E. coli PTCC 1047. With respect to Agardh FS 13. This disagreed with the observations of
S. typhi PTCC 1108, the activity index was around 84 Cano et al. (1990), who have evaluated the antifungal
and changed to 83–175 in experiments with C. kefyr activity of terrestrial cyanobacterium N. muscorum
ATCC 38296. But it decreased to 80 in relation to C. albi- against the same fungus by 20.83%. Mule et al. (1991)
cans ATCC 14053. On the other hand, Fischerella ambi- also indicated that phenolic compounds of N. muscorum
gua (Naeg.) Gomont FS18 has the highest Ai (112) in the exert an inhibitory effect on C. albicans.
methanol extract against S. epidermidis PTCC 1114. It The antibacterial effect against S. typhi was only
seems this species may have potent antimicrobial activity found in more lipophilic extracts (petroleum ether).
and can be the subject of future experiments. The aqueous extracts were ineffective, a phenomenon
that has already been described by Mundt et al. (2001).
The antimicrobial activities of algal extracts are shown
in Tables 1 and 3. Data in Table 3 show the cyanobacteria
Discussion
with antimicrobial effects belong to the following families.
In the past decades, screening programs have revealed Stigonemataceae: Stigonema ocellatum (Dillw.) Thuret FS
that cyanobacteria are a potential source of new active 23, S. turfaceum (Berkeley) Cooke FS 14, S. ocellatum FS
substances for medicine and pharmacy, and numerous 30, H. brasiliensis Borge FS 6, H. aureus West & West
active compounds have been isolated (Moore et al., FS 3, H. fontinalis (Agardh) Bornet FS 7, H. hiberinicus
1989; Falch et al., 1995; Jaki et al., 1999). But few have FS 33, Fischerella ambigua FS 2, and F. ambigua FS 18;
been done with respect to cyanobacteria from paddy Nostocaceae: Nostoc muscorum C. A. Agardh FS 13,
fields. Possibly, the synthesis of highly active toxin can Nostoc sp. FS 4, N. linckia (Roth) Bornet & Thuret FS 8,
be a defense option of cyanobacteria in these environ- N. microscopicum Carmichael FS 21, and N. punctiforme
ments against other organisms like bacteria, fungi, C. A. Agardh FS 5; Oscillatoriaceae: Plectonema notatum
viruses, and eukaryotic microalgae (Mundt et al., 2001). Schmidle FS 28 and Oscillatoria angusta Koppe FS 19;
Cyanobacteria from the paddy fields of northern Chroococcaceae:Chroococcus sp. FS 1.
Thailand have produced bioactive substances with anti- Apparently, the potent antibacterial cyanobacteria
biotic activity against B. subtilis (Chetsumon et al., from different localities of Iran belong to Stigonemata-
1993). This is in agreement with results obtained in the ceae and Nostocaceae. These results are in agreement
current project in which cell extracts and culture media with other experiments in which cyanobacteria such
of 11 species had activity against B. subtilis. as H. fontinalis (Moore et al., 1987), F. ambigua (Falch
Also, extracts of terrestrial Fischerella ambigua were et al., 1995), F. musciola (Borzi) Gomont (Hagmann &
the most active in the test systems used (Falch et al., Jüttner, 1996), N. spongiaeforme C. A. Agardh (Hirata
1995). The polychlorinated aromatics, ambigols A and et al., 2000), and N. commune (Jaki et al., 2000) produce
B, were isolated as the agents responsible for the pro- antimicrobial substances.
nounced antimicrobial activities of the lipophilic In a few cases, species like Plectonema notatum FS 28
extracts. These activities were also well established in (Golestan Province) and Oscillatoria angusta FS 19
458 N. Soltani et al.
Bioautographic assay
FS 23 MeOH þ þ þ þ
FS 30 H2O þ
FS 14 PE þ þ
H2O þ þ
FS 21 PE þ
MeOH þ þ þ
FS 13 MeOH þ þ þ
FS 4 PE þ
FS 5 PE þ þ
FS 8 PE þ
H2O þ
FS 18 PE þ þ þ þ
MeOH þ þ þ þ
H2O þ þ þ
FS 6 H2O þ
FS 3 PE þ
H2O þ þ
FS 7 MeOH þ þ þ
H2O þ
FS 33 PE þ þ þ þ þ þ
MeOH þ þ þ þ
H2O þ þ þ
FS 2 MeOH þ þ
FS 28 PE þ
FS 19 PE þ þ
MeOH þ þ
H2O þ þ
FS 1 MeOH þ
PE, petroleum ether extract; MeOH, methanol extract; H2O, aqueous extract.
(Mazandaran Province) showed antibacterial effects Seventeen species from different localities showed
against B. subtilis PTCC 1204 and S. epidermidis PTCC antimicrobial effects. The extracts were most effective
1114. Antimicrobial activity of Chroococcus sp. FS 1 against S. epidermidis PTCC 1114 and to a lesser extent
was observed in one paddy field in Mazandaran Province S. typhi PTCC 1108. Ten extracts inhibited E. coli PTCC
against S. epidermidis PTCC 1114 (Tables 1 and 3). 1047. Most inhibition was produced by methanol
A variety of solvents with different polarities were used extracts. These results disagreed with Ghasemi et al.
for the extraction of algal bioactive materials. All extracts (2003) and Kellam and Walker (1989).
showed antimicrobial activity, probably because of the The most potent species, Hapalosiphon hiberinicus FS
different polarity of active components. But the percentage 33, was collected from different paddy fields of Fars
of methanol extracts with positive effects was higher, indi- Province. Interestingly, specimens of this species from
cating a higher chance of finding antimicrobial activity in paddy fields of Khoozestan Province showed no antibac-
methanol extracts. It was found that active compounds terial production. The cyanobacteria of paddy fields of
was higher against Gram-positive bacteria (S. epidermidis Iran showed different antimicrobial behaviors (Tables 1
PTCC 1114, B. subtilis PTCC 1204) in comparison with and 3).
Gram-negative bacteria (E. coli PTCC 1047, S. typhi PTCC It was interesting that some species showed similar
1108), the same results that Ghasemi et al. (2003) have characteristics. For example, F. ambigua FS18 that was
observed. Gram-positive bacteria (S. epidermidis PTCC collected from Gillan Province showed very strong and
1114, S. aureus Rosenbach PTCC 1112, S. haemolyticus permanent antibacterial abilities, agreeing with reported
Schleifer & Kloos ATCC 29970) are more sensitive than activity by Ghasemi et al. (2003) for the same species
Gram-negative bacteria [Shigella sonnei (Levine) Weldin collected in Golestan Province.
PTCC 1325, Escherichia coli PTCC 1047, and Proteus It seems that among all of the species studied in the
vulgaris Hauser PTCC 1312]. current work for antibacterial and antifungal activity,
Antimicrobial activity of cyanobacteria 459
Fischerella and Hapalosiphon had most prominent effects Gerwork WH, Roberts MA, Proteau PJ, Chen JL (1994):
and display a potential that warrants further investigation. Screening cultured marine microalgae for anticancer-
Data also indicated that the highest percentage of colo- type activity. J Appl Phycol 6: 143–149.
nization and distribution of cyanobacteria in soil cultures Ghasemi Y, Tabatabai Yazdi M, Shokravi Sh, Soltani N,
and also the highest rate of antimicrobial activity belonged Zarrini G (2003): Antifungal and antibacterial activity
to northern provinces (70.5% in Golestan, Gillan, and of paddy-fields cyanobacteria from the north of Iran.
Mazandaran Provinces). The lower colonization was J Sci I R Iran 14: 203–209.
seen in Fars (17.7%), Isfahan (5.9%), and Ilam (5.9%), Ghasemi Y, Tabatabai Yazdi M, Shafiee A, Amini M,
respectively. Shokravi Sh, Zarrini G (2004): Parsiguine, a novel anti-
As results indicated (Table 1), none of isolated sam- microbial substance from Fischerella ambigua. Pharm
ples from Khoozestan Province (south of Iran) demon- Biol 42: 318–322.
strated antimicrobial activity. Also, the distribution and Hagmann L, Jüttner F (1996): Fischerellin A, a novel
colonization of microalgae in these cultures were lower photosystem-II-inhibiting alleolochemical of the cyano-
than other locations. Nostoc microscopicum, which was bacterium Fischerella muscicola with antifungal and
the dominant species in these paddy fields, exhibited no herbicide activity. Tetrahedron Lett 37: 6539–16542.
antimicrobial ability (data not shown). The current Hirata K, Takashina J, Nakagami H, Ueyama S, Murakami
results show that most of the investigated cyanobacteria K, Kanamori T, Jaki B, Heilmann J, Sticher O (2000):
induced a response in at least one of the test systems New antibacterial metabolites from the cyanobacterium
applied. The most promising cyanobacterial strains for Nostoc commune (EAWAG 122b). J Nat Prod 63:
further studies appeared to be Fischerella ambigua FS 1283–1285.
18, Hapalosiphon hibernicus FS 33, and Oscillatoria angu- Jaki B, Orjala J, Sticher O (1999): A novel extracellular
sta FS 19. diterpenoid with antibacterial activity from the cyano-
bacterium Nostoc commune. J Nat Prod 62: 502–503.
Jaki B, Heilmann J, Sticher O (2000): New antibacterial
Acknowledgments metabolites from the cyanobavterium Nostoc commune
EAWAG 122b. J Nat Prod 63: 1283–1285.
The authors wish to thank Dr. Y. Ghasemi and Mr. G.
John DM, Whitton BA, Brook AJ (2003): The Freshwater
Zarrini for collection and spectral studies. Mrs. Ladan
Algal Flora of the British Isles, an Identification Guide
Baftehchi is also thanked for her participation in isolation
to Freshwater and Terrestrial Algae. Cambridge,
of microalgae.
Cambridge University Press, pp. 117–122.
Kaushik BD (1987): Laboratory Methods for Blue-Green
Algae. New Delhi Associated Publishing Company,
References
pp. 50–60.
Anagnostidis K, Komarek J (1990): Modern approaches to Kellam SJ, Walker JM (1989): Antibacterial activity from
the classification of cyanobacteria. Stigonematales. marine microalgae in laboratory culture. Br Phycol
Arch Hydrobiol 4: 224–286. J 24: 191–194.
Borowitzka MA (1995): Microalgae as sources of pharma- Knubel G, Larsen LK, Moore RE (1990): Cytotoxic, anti-
ceuticals and other biologically active compounds. viral indolocarbobazoles from a blue-green alga belong-
J Appl Phycol 7: 3–15. ing to the Nostocaceae. J Antibiot 43: 1236–1239.
Borowitzka MA, Borowitzka LJ (1988): Micro-algal Bio- Lorain V (1996): Antibiotic in Laboratory Medicine.
technology. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, Baltimore, Williams & Wilkins, pp. 1–51.
pp. 179–180. Moore RE, Cheuk C, Yang XG, Patterson GML (1989):
Cano MMS, Mule MCZ, Caire GZ, Halperin DR (1990): Hapalindoles, antibacterial and antimycotic alkaloids
Inhibition of Candida albicans and Staphylococcus from the cyanophtye Hapalosiphon fontinalis. J Org
aureus by phenolic compounds from the terrestrial cya- Chem 52: 1036–1043.
nobacterium Nostoc muscorum. J Appl Phycol 2: 79–81. Mule MCZ, Caire GZ, Cano MS, Halperin DR (1991):
Chetsumon A, Miyamato K, Hirata K, Miura Y, Ikuta Y, Bioactive compounds from Nostoc muscorum (cyano-
Hamsaki A (1993): Factors affecting antibiotic pro- bacteria). Cytobios 66: 169–172.
duction in bioreactors with immobilized algal cells. Mundt S, Kreitlow1 S, Nowotny A, Effmert U (2001): Bio-
Appl Biochem Biotech 37: 573–586. logical and pharmacological investigation of selected
Desikachary TV (1959): Cyanophyta. New Delhi, Indian cyanobacteria. Int J Hyg Environ Health 203: 327–334.
Council of Agricultural Research, pp. 1–686. Prescott GW (1962): Algae of the Western Great Lake Area.
Falch BS, Konig GM, Wright AD, Sticher O, Angerhofer Dubuque W.M.C. Brown Company pp. 543–551.
CK, Pezzuto JM, Bachmann H (1995): Biological Roger PA, Kulasooriya SA (1980): Blue-green Algae and
activities of cyanobacteria: Evaluation of extracts and Rice. Los Banos, Laguna, Philippines, International
pure compounds. Planta Med 61: 321–328. Rice Research Institute, pp. 1–112.