Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Tac attack
Angle of attack
~WE~~l,
special effort to get plenty of water
while you're outside- whether
you're waiting to launch off on your
sortie, working around the jets, or
USAF
doing other important projects Chief of Safety
2 JULY 1988
TAC ATTACK
DEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCE
26 Complacency
lb counter it, you've got to be aware of it.
features
4 Was Lindbergh Wrong?
What can you do to prevent flight mishaps?
10 Continuation Training Traps
You've got a flight full of instructors and you're epartmen
ready to go. Or are you?
14 Know When to Say "Uncle" departments
8 TAC Tips
Do you know when to say "enough is enough"?
9,25, 29 Safety Awards
18 F-16 Trapped Fuel Malfunctions 12 Weapons Words
An approach to the problem from the
operations perspective. 13 Aircrew of Distinction
16 In The Center
22 F-16 Trapped Fuel: Logistically
A maintenance perspective on the trapped fuel 28 Chock Talk
problem. 30 Fleagle Salutes
TACSP 127-1
TAC Attack is not directive in nature. Recommendations are intended to comply with existing directives. Opinions expressed are
those of the authors and not necessarily the positions of TAC or USAF. Mishap information does not identify the persons, places or
units involved and may not be construed as incriminating under Article 31 of the UCMJ. Photos and artwork are representative and
not necessarily of the people or equipment involved.
Contributions are encouraged, as are comments and criticism. We reserve the right to edit all manuscripts for readability and
good taste. Write the Editor, TAC Attack, HQ TAC/SEP, Langley AFB, VA 23665-5563; or call AUTOVON 574-3658.
Distribution F(X) is controlled by TAC/SEP through the PDO, based on a ratio of 1 copy per 10 persons assigned. DOD units
other than USAF have no fixed ratio; requests will be considered individually.
Subscriptions for readers outside DOD are available from the Superintendent of Documents, Government Printing Office,
Washington, D.C. 20402. All correspondence on subscription service should be directed to the Superintendent, not to TAC/SEP
volume 28, number 7
LUME 28 NUMBER
Was Lindbergh
EDWARD C.
ALDRIDGE, <IR.
SECRETARY OF
THE AIR FORCE
GEN ROBERT D. RUS
COMMANDER
- -
-- -
accident is nauseating,
. ....
to blame a dead pilot for an What pilot
COL JACK GAWELKO "The readiness since I can remember.
tendency ever and where
CHIEF OF SAFE T1 but it has been the where he has been in danger when a
has not been in positions going? But
advised against
would have only by his error and
MAJ DON RIGHTMY ER perfect judgement such a position he is judged himself from
man is caught in has extracted
credit for the times he heaped upon him by other
seldom given
Worst of all, blame is themselves, but
JANET worse positions, been in parallel situations
EDITORIAL ASSISTANT pilots, all of whom have chances, one would
caught in them. If one took nothe chances one takes.
without being
lies in the judgement one's of
outlook on life.
Any
STAN HARDISON not fly at all. Safety must rest upon
in turn, into a
ART EDITOR That judgement, and criticize a prather,
ilot for flying
coward can sit in his home by far, die on a mountainside
fog. But I would rather, when a brave man
SSGT DENNIS WALLA mountain in a for his errors
we look is no need to
STA than in bed. Why should from his exp erience, there
dies? 'Unless we can learn the courage and spirit
Rather, we should admire is no daring?
I look for weakness. of man would live where there dying in adven
TAC Attack (ISSN 0494-0380) is pub- in his life. What kind should blame men for
And is life so dear that we
lished monthly by HQ TAC/SEP, Lang- to die?"
ley AFB, VA. POSTMASTER: Send ture? Is there a better way Charles A. Lindbergh
address changes to TAC Attack,
TAC/SEP, Langley AFB, VA Wartime Journals
23665-5563. Second-class postage paid August 26, 1938
at Hampton, Virginia, and additional
mailing offices.
4
wrong?
TACA'ITACK 5
was Lindbergh wrong?
6 JULY1988
. . ..
..
. ..
. ... ·... . .
. .. ·..
. ..
I o 0 oo
- not to take time for one more Despite the fact that the odds are
"gear down and locked" check? probably with you, accidents do
- not to have a plan of escape or an happen. If you take risks such as
awareness of where the high ter- those above, they undoubtedly will.
rain is when you're in the weather If they haven't yet, you've just been Despite talk about fate
(and possibly radio out, too)? lucky, like Lindbergh. and utbe golden BB,"
Lindbergh was right about one
thing- ''safety lies in the judgement tbe things we do or
Contrary to what of the chances one takes." Despite fail to do often have
talk about fate and "the golden BB;' logical and predictable
Lindbergh wrote, most
of us would probably
the things we do or fail to do often consequences.
have logical and predictable conse-
rather die in a bed tban quences. However, luck sometimes
on a mountainside. plays a major part in human
activities. Don't rely on luck or
chance to provide your margin spending parts of the mission
'Ibis is especially true if of safety. "wave-hopping'' to avoid the
one dies in bed at age When Lindbergh took off on his weather and falling asleep several
80 vice tbe mountainside epic flight, his plane was over- times, he made it to Le Bourget,
at age 25. weight. It lacked any direct forward France.
visibility and was poorly They didn't call him "Lucky"
instrumented as well. Despite fornothing. ..->
TACATTACK 7
INTERESTING ITEMS~
MISHAPS WITH MORALS~
FOR THE TAC
tac tips
AffiCREWMAN
10 JULY1988
tor peers. These feelings can cloud could help you avoid this trap. If A continuation training sortie
our judgment and prevent the all else fails, ask them how prepared might train to a wartime mission
attention to detail we normally they feel to accomplish each that differs from day-to-day student
apply in mission planning and exe- mission segment. training or be out of phase with cur-
cution. Selfdiscipline is the key to Next is the continuation training rent student instruction. Once
avoiding this trap. sortie briefing. It is often shorter again, what we consider routine
In day-to-day student sortie plan- than the standard student sortie could be a trap.
ning, we are very careful to struc- (and probably should be) with more What are the flying conditions for
ture each sortie to achieve syllabus standard items and fewer com- today's continuation training sortie:
goals without exceeding student ments on techniques and potential day, night, VFR, IFR, etc? All of
capabilities. Plenty of information is problem areas. The 'Were all the things we would carefully con-
instructors" attitude prevails. Qual- sider for a student sortie are
ity, not quantity, is the key to treated as routine for instructor fly-
avoiding this trap. ing. Just another trap waiting to be
The trap occurs when Our familiarity with the flying stepped into.
you asswne that the area (and each other) might lead us Finally, we never fail to critique
rest of your continuation to omit some aspect of mission plan- student performance inflight or
training flight members ning we see as unnecessary for con- give new directions when things are
tinuation training but would never not going as planned. On an all-
are as current and forget with a student onboard - instructor continuation training
proficient as you are. another trap. flight, the "he knows what he's
doing'' attitude is a trap to be
avoided. Don't blow off the mission
critique with a simple "Nice flight,
available on student performance guys." Everyone benefits from an
and current proficiency levels
All of the things we open discussion of the good, the
(recent sorties with the same stu- would carefully consider bad, or even the ugly.
dent and/or student gradebooks). for a student sortie are Don't be like me. I stepped in a trap
The trap occurs when you assume I probably baited myself. I was very
that the rest of your continuation treated as routine for lucky; the resulting mid-air didn't
training flight members are as cur- instructor flying. cost any airplanes or lives. Flight
rent and proficient as you are. Al- leaders, don't let it happen to
though such information is not as you- keep those traps unbaited.
easy to find, some time spent here _..>
TACATTACK 11
They functioned
as designed
O ne of the most often performed operations on the
flight line is the functional check of weapons sys-
tems. The checks are performed hundreds of times a
day; and when properly performed, no significant haz-
ards are involved. The key phrase is "when properly
performed." One or two missed steps in the checklist
could lead to disastrous consequences. The steps
weapons words "Check ejector carts are removed from all stations" or
"Insure safety pins are installed in all loaded stations"
were not performed in any of the following eight mis-
haps. The jettison systems worked perfectly each
time; unfortunately, the ejector carts were installed
and the aircraft was still on the ground. Damage was
limited to the jettisoned items-this time. We could
have lost an aircraft and came very close to losing a
crew member. Take the time to perform all steps in
Souvenirs: Watch out for your checklist and don't assume someone else has
them already done it. It's your responsibility.
0530 hours- Load crew performed functional check
14 JULY1988
troller talking to me but he seemed
really distant and it was hard to
translate his directions into action.
Fortunately, I managed to follow
his instructions and lowered the
It finally dawned on
me that I couldn't
hack the mission and
out why. After staring at all the
gauges for a long time, I finally I made the first good
realized that I hadn't brought the decision of the day - I
power below military after leveling turned around and
off. About 8-10 minutes after
takeoff, I really began to feel
headed for home.
worse- increased light-
headedness, slight stomach dis- gear. I then noticed that I was
comfort, and some dizziness. I sweating profusely and dropped
made all the appropriate radio my mask. I began to feel a little
away as I made my departure and calls, gang loaded the oxygen better (probably because I was con-
headed toward the working area. regulator and continued to press centrating so hard on the task at
Shortly after level off, I began to toward the area. hand), picked up the runway
feel light-headed and found it hard As I approached the area, I visually and continued to a safe
to concentrate on simple cockpit really began to feel worse and landing.
found it hard to think clearly or In retrospect, my decisions to
read the instruments. It finally "filrthe squares" and "hack the mis-
Shortly after level off, dawned on me that I couldn't hack sion'' were the dumbest ones I've
I began to feel the mission and I made the first made since graduating from pilot
good decision of the day- I turned training. I know I'll certainly never
light-headed and found around and headed for home. Dur- do it again. 'Th.ke it from my
it hard to concentrate ing the return flight, I concen- experience and don't even think
on simple cockpit tasks. trated on my breathing to prevent about flying when you know you're
hyperventilation. I was able to sick. I was lucky- very. You might
maintain some semblance of air- not be as fortunate. The next time
tasks. A second look at the air- craft control, but I was definitely I'm on the schedule and "under the
speed indicator told me I was going not in control of the situation. Dur- weather'', I'll know when to say
way too fast but I couldn't figure ing the GCA, I could hear the con- "Uncle!' _.>
TACATTACK 15
. ..·.·...
•..
·..
. ...
'·
~ . :: ..
•
. ·. ·:
•
. . .: •• • •
..·.·.. ::
: : • • • •• 0
·.' ::·:·. ·. · .: . . ..
. :: . ...
. . ..... .·..
'
.·:
.::·. ': :.
.... :·.. .• . ,· ... : : ·. ·;
·.·.·· .. '
,' •. • '
,·
'· . ·.: .
. . .·.
. · ., ..
:·:: . I ' ' ~ :' . : :
·..... . .. ' ·: :·
....··. .·
. ·.·:
: .~ ': : ~· .
. .
. . ~-. . . . ~
'' . ,.~
·.· .
.. ·.. :..:- :.. ,' :
..·.:: ··.·:.=.:
...··...
··:·.· : ·. .. : :. :·.·.. . .·· .. ,
:· .
. .,' ..·.
· ·,· ·:·
: .... .. :.: .......
.... ···.·
.....
. -:
F-16 TRAPPED FUEL
operator's perspective
18 JULY1988
MALFUNCTIONS:
Lights came on. Neither aircraft running, there is no bleed air to still trapped because without pres-
had the "Bingo fuel warning based pressurize the tanks. We learned sure it won't transfer out of the
on fuselage fuel" mod and neither years ago that without pressure, external tanks and without the
made it home. they won't feed. That's not transfer pumps it won't move into
Anyone with much experience in surprising. the fuselage even if it would trans-
the jet can remember lots of times Once we get past that basic fer into the internal wings.
when the externals haven't fed, and knowledge, things get a little What does this mean to you, the
it's usually not been a big deal. sketchy. Any lieutenant just out of operator, who just flamed out a per-
Usually checklist procedures such the B Course and most SEFEs fectly good airplane? You're not
as cycling the air refueling door know that the primary means of going to get a restart on that engine
solved the problem. The latest fuel transfer in the F-16 is by unless you can fmd some way to
Class A and a similar incident a few siphoning action. As fuel is used manually pump fuel into the reser-
days later pointed out some things from the reservoirs, suction pulls voir tanks. The JFS (jet fuel starter)
we didn't know about the F-16 fuel additional fuel through standpipes won't run and the EPU (emergency
system and som~ misperceptions from the upstream internal tanks. power unit) won't pressurize the
about the Trapped Fuel Checklist. The only thing needed to keep the tanks. Your decision tree has just
First of all, the key to changing a siphoning process going is a run- had a limb cut off. Instead of reach-
trapped fuel situation from a seri- ning engine and an absence of air in ing for the trapped fuel or airstart
ous mishap into a minor incon- the tanks receiving fuel. If you are checklists, it's time to reach for the
venience lies in early recognition operating with fuel only in the flameout landing checklist. As fool-
of the problem. Most of these mis- reservoirs and suddenly introduce ish as it may sound, it's time to jetti-
haps started with a breakdown of fuel into the internal wing tanks, son what was your only source of
basic airmanship. Whether you call siphoning through the fuselage fuel, the external tanks, and prac-
it complacency, channelized atten- tanks may be a slow process tice being a glider pilot if there is a
tion, lack of situational awareness, depending on the amount of air in nearby airfield. If not, look for a
or whatever, it all boils down to not the internal tanks. If you're almost place to park the jet out of harm's
properly flying the aircraft and not out of reservoir fuel, you won't have way.
pa;uing attention to -w hatit takes to enough time to get a useful siphon Trapped fuel is a fact of life in the
keep it in the air. If you notice action going. F-16. The engineers are working on
trapped fuel with 9500 pounds total, Oops, what now? Well, we have ways to keep it from happening, but
it's a lot easier to handle than with transfer pumps to scavenge the regardless of what actions they take
4600 pounds total, 4000 of which is tanks. If the external tanks start to protect us from ourselves, it is
external. Your pucker factor and transferring, the wing transfer still each pilot's responsibility to fly
your priorities take radically differ- pumps should pick up the fuel in the his aircraft. Knowing how much fuel
ent perspectives accordingly. internal wings and pump it into the is on board and where it's at is an
Perhaps the biggest lesson learned fuselage tanks. ''Yeah, that's the essential part of combat readiness.
from our most recent mishap is- if ticket:' We can't kill 'em if we can't get there
your engine flames out due to fuel There are only two problems with and we can't get there if we don't
starvation, any fuel trapped in the the wing transfer pumps: 1) they have any jets left. Early detection is
external tanks will stay right where only pump at a rate of 3000 pounds the key to preventing a trapped fuel
it was trapped. It will never feed. per hour each, and 2) they shut mishap. Regular ops checks in the
There are several things which down when both reservoirs go dry. directed format are the way to
influence this. The first, most obvi- So, if your externals just started to detect it early.
ous one is that with the engine not feed as the engine quit, the fuel is What happens if you don't notice
TACATTACK 19
F-16 trapped fuel malfunction:
TACATIACK 21
F-16 trapped fuel: the maintenance view
Capt George Ireland transfer system works, let's review
TAC/LG how external tank checkout proce-
First, it is important to dures have evolved.
know the basics of exactly Early in the F-16 program, the
external tank checkout procedures
how the fuel tanks transfer
T he United States Air Force is
in the best shape ever since its
inception. Our people are dedi-
fuel to the aircraft fuel
system.
were written to verify that the
external fuel tanks would transfer
into the internal wings at an accept-
cated, well-trained professionals able rate, and that the tank and
and our aircraft are the best in the interconnect tubes would not leak.
world, built to be maintainable and their respective internal wing Although these procedures verified
survivable in any hostile environ- tanks. Finally, let's assume that the external fuel tank operation, they
ment. We work hard at our peace- aircraft is configured with all three did not identify many of the failure
time mission which goes a long way external tanks. This is where some modes that have been experienced
towards pilot competency and keep- changes take place. With the exter- with external fuel tank usage.
ing our fighting machines mission nal fuel transfer switch in the The incorporation ofTCTO
capable and war ready. However, NORM position, fuel is transferred 1F-16-697 (Selective Fill of External
the lessons we learn in the process first from the external centerline Fuel Thnks) provided the capability
of meeting our mission can be tank to the internal wing tanks as to manually shut off fuel flow from
costly. We recently experienced our discussed above. Mter the center- each external tank. This, together
fourth F-16 trapped fuel Class A line tank empties, the low fuel level with new checkout procedures,
flight mishap in TAC. In this mis- float switch in the tank opens and provided detection capability of all
hap, fuel became trapped in the removes electrical power from sole- the major external fuel transfer dis-
external wing tanks but went unno- noid shutoff valves located in the crepancies that have been encoun-
ticed until it was too late. In an external wing tanks. Until now, tered. Component/subsystem
effort to learn from this mishap, let's these valves have been keeping the failures that now can be detected
review the external fuel tank trans- external wing tanks from feeding. are:
fer system on the F-16 and how we Once the valves are de-energized, a. External fuel transfer switch
check this system once an aircraft is fuel transfers from the external and associated wiring.
reconfigured for flight. wing tanks to their respective inter- b. External tank float switch
First, it is important to know the nal wing tanks. With the EXT operation.
basics of exactly how the fuel tanks FUEL TRANS switch in the c. External tank shutoff valves.
transfer fuel to the aircraft fuel sys- WING FIRST position (the aircraft d. Proper tank sequencing
tem. Let's assume the aircraft is is still configured with all external (N 0 RM: centerline empties prior
configured with only a 300-gallon tanks), the solenoid shutoff valve to wing tanks; or WINGS
external centerline tank. The located in the external centerline FIRST: wing tanks empty prior
process is simple. Air pressure tank is energized via the low fuel to centerline tank).
provided by the Environmental level float switches located in the It is important to note that not all
Control System to the external tank external wing tanks. As a result, pylons have been modified with the
provides the motive force to get the the external wing tanks transfer manual shutoff capability incorpo-
fuel to both of the internal wing first. When they are empty, the low- rated in TCTO lF-16-697, but all
tanks simultaneously. Now, with level float switches open and the new pylons have this manual shutoff
two 370-gallon external wing tanks valve in the centerline tank is de- capability. (Shutoff valves are
(no centerline tank) the process is energized allowing the centerline located in 370-gallon tank wing
similar. Air pressure transfers the tank fuel to transfer. Now that you pylons and in the right wheel well
fuel from the external wing tanks to can see how the external fuel tank for centerline tanks.)
TACATTACK 23
TRAPPED FUEL:
MAINTENANCE VIEW
Successful completion of
F-16 trapped fuel: the maintenance view any mission is based on
reamwork. As maint.ainers,
our part of the mission is
to know our aircraft and
maintain them according
to tech data.
24 JULY1988
TAC
CREW CHIEF
SAFETY AWARD
25
complacency
26 JULY1988
Have you ever been guilty of say- crew chief was ingested in the investigation report? In most cases,
ing, or at least thinking, those intake of an F-4D. It only took once!! t here is more than one cause factor.
thoughts? I know it's difficult to Would you have t hought it could • Again, the small things build up
accept some safety requirements, actually happen? Well, it did! until . .. ''boom?' How would you
especially if you've never personally Have you ever read a mishap explain to an inspector or mishap
been involved in a serious mishap investigator that you thought a cer-
that was caused by ignoring what tain regulation or tech order
you thought to be a meaningless requirement wasn't important so
regulation. But, we have to remem- How would you explain you decided not to comply with it?
ber that the regulation is there for a If a mishap does occur in your unit
reason- our safety! It's possible
to an inspector or or mine, let's make sure beforehand
that by itself the regulation may mishap investigator that wflve done everything possible
seem immaterial; but when violated that you thought a to have prevented it. That includes
along with other seemingly minor watching out for any complacency
requirements, the ground work is
certain regulation or that may have crept in and paying
laid for a chain reaction that can tech order requirement attention to the "small thingS:'
lead to catastrophe. wasn't important so you Maybe it's time for each of us to
''Yes, but I've done it a t housand decided not to comply rethink our safety attitude. Remem-
times and haven't had a mishap?' ber, regulations are written for
What about try # 1001? It only takes
with it? our protection. There is no place
once! A recent ground aircraft mis- for complacency when it comes
hap resulted in a fatality when a to safety. _::::-
TACATTACK 27
INCIDENTS AND
INCIDENTAlS
WITH A
chock talk
MAINTENANCE
SLANT
A Hungry Eagle
28 JULY 1988
TAC
OUTSTANDING
ACHIEVEMENT
IN
SAFETY AWARD
TACATTACK
When his flight lead confirmed start. He immediately instructed
that the left engine was streaming the crew chief to have the aircraft
oil, an immediate landing was called shut down. Closer examination re -
for. The weather at the nearest vealed extensive damage under-
suitable emergency airfield was 800 neath the aircraft's "turkey
feet overcast and two miles visibility. feathers!' TSgt Glasser's continual
The heavyweight condition of the attention to detail and
aircraft with fuel and a heavy train- safety awareness have
ing ordnance load further compli- earned him a Fleagle Salute.
cated the recovery. Despite having
only the emergency system to
extend the landing gear and emer- SSgt Allan Bouffard, 158th Tac-
gency braking once on the ground, tical Fighter Group, Vermont
Capt Zelko safely landed his air- Air National Guard, Burlington
craft following an emergency single IAP, Vermont, was the number two
engine approach through instru- man on the end-of-runway (EOR)
ment conditions. Capt Zelko's team for a departing four-ship of
out standing airmanship has F-16s. Although not required by the
Capt Darrell P. Zelko, 355 earned him a Fleagle Salute. EOR workcards to check chip
TFS, 354 TFW, Myrtle Beach detector plugs, SSgt Bouffard had
AFB, SC, was number four in a established a personal habit of look-
flight of A-10s en route to the work- ing at them on each aircraft and, on
ing area for a surface attack tactics TSgt Donald R. Glasser, 58 AGS, this day, found the number four
mission when his master caution 58 TTVV, Luke AFB, Arizona, plug missing in one F-16.
and left generator warning lights has prevented the loss of valuable A missing chip detector could
came on. Capt Zelko verified that Air Force equipment on several have had catastrophic conse-
his engine instruments were nor- occasions while performing duties quences after takeoff by allowing
mal and then began appropriate as an F-16 dedicated crew chief. On the aircraft to pump its oil over-
procedures to reset the generator. one occasion, he discovered a board, resulting in engine seizure
When the reset effort was unsuc- cracked vertical stabilizer cap on an and possible loss of the aircraft.
cessful, Capt Zelko noticed that the aircraft just prior to its launch, This time it was only a sortie lost
left engine oil pressure was drop- preventing a potential dropped due to the ground abort. SSgt
ping out of limits and pulled the object and major structural damage Bouffard's alertness and willing-
power to idle on the left engine. As to the jet. Another time he visually ness to go beyond the
the pressure continued to drop to detected a slight binding of the noz- minimum required have
zero, he shut down the engine. zle on his aircraft during engine earned him a Fleagle Salute.
AIRCREW FATALITIES 2 1 2 19 I 2 9 0 2 IF 0 1
IN THE ENVELOPE EJECTIONS 1 /0 13/0 19/1 1 /0 9/0 0/0 4/0 0/0 0/0 3
OUT OF ENVELOPE EJECTIONS
SUCCESSFUL UNSUCCESSFUL)
L0,12_ 0/5
L, 0/2 0/4 0/0 0 /1
Ar 0/0 0/0
ANG AFR
AIM 14 11,11111114$01411
FY 88 00 10 6 77 59 95 7.9 67 5.9
AFR 87 21.8 11.7 8.5 _12,(0 83 3.0 fr
88 4.3 2.9 2.4 2.2 2.5 3.2 3.1 3.2
OttFY I
MONTH OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP