Professional Documents
Culture Documents
KEYWORDS Summary Introduction: Retrobulbar hematoma (RBH), a rare but serious condition, can
Retrobulbar result in permanent vision loss. Although it is a known complication following trauma or facial
hematoma; fracture reduction, sinus surgery, or blepharoplasty, factors related to patient outcomes are not
Facial fracture; well-defined. A systematic review was performed to determine the relation of patient/
Outcomes;
treatment factors to outcomes.
Trauma;
Blepharoplasty;
Methods: Articles retrieved from a PubMed search (1989–2017) were reviewed. Demographic
Lateral canthotomy information, etiology, symptoms, and final vision outcomes were analyzed using Fisher’s exact
tests, single and multiple predictor logistic regression.
Results: Of 429 articles identified, 16 were included in the study. 93 cases of retrobulbar
hematoma were included. 74% occurred after trauma, while 26% occurred postoperatively. Onset
of symptoms occurred after approximately 24 hours. 28% received treatment within 1 hour, 54%
within 1–24 hours, and 18% after 24 hours. 51% had complete visual recovery, while 27% had partial
recovery, and 22% developed blindness. Older patients and patients who sustained trauma were
less likely to have a full recovery (p = 0.029, p = 0.023). Increasing number of symptoms trended
towards a prediction of blindness (p = 0.092). Surgical decompression and shorter time to treat-
ment were each highly predictive of full recovery (p = 0.024, p = 0.003) and decreased likelihood
of blindness (p = 0.037, p = 0.045); use of steroids was not found to be significant.
Discussion: Retrobulbar hematoma is a diagnostic and therapeutic emergency. Factors associ-
ated with improved outcomes include younger age, decreased number of total symptoms,
surgical decompression, and shorter time to treatment. If recognized and treated early with
surgical decompression, recovery of vision is possible.
© 2017 British Association of Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgeons. Published by
Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bjps.2017.10.025
1748-6815/© 2017 British Association of Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgeons. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
156 B. Christie et al.
Retrobulbar hematoma (RBH) is a rare but serious condition Two binary outcome contrasts were formed for the statisti-
that can result in permanent vision loss. It is a known surgi- cal analyses, in order to avoid multiple comparisons1: full
cal complication following facial fracture reduction (0.3%), recovery versus partial recovery / blindness2; blindness versus
endoscopic sinus surgery (0.43%), blepharoplasty (0.055%), full / partial recovery. For each outcome contrast, Fisher’s
and retrobulbar injection of anesthesia (0.44%).1–3 It is also exact test was used to evaluate the association between
a common cause of post-traumatic blindness, especially each categorical factor and the distribution of the two
in the setting of orbital fracture.1,2,4,5 The incidence of outcome groups in the contrast. Single predictor and step-
RBH in patients with orbital fractures is estimated to be wise multiple predictor logistic regression analyses were
0.45–0.6%.2,5,6 applied to test the prediction from the factors to the likeli-
The pathophysiology of retrobulbar hematoma relates to hood of an outcome compared to the other outcome group in
bleeding and compression within the enclosed retrobulbar the contrast. All statistical analyses were performed using
space. As bleeding occurs within the fixed space, pressure SAS statistical software program version 9.4 (SAS Institute,
increases and the globe is displaced anteriorly. This process Cary, NC). A cutoff p-value of 0.05 was used for statistical
leads to an increase in intraorbital pressure, stretching of significance.
the optic nerve and optic vessels, and results in venous
compression, compromising outflow and increasing intraor-
bital pressure.1,2,4,6,7 Further increase in intraorbital pres- Results
sure leads to central retinal artery occlusion and decreased
perfusion pressures, ultimately causing an ischemic optic Article selection
neuropathy that manifests as loss of vision.1,2,4,6–9
Retrobulbar hematoma is a diagnostic and therapeutic As shown in Figure 1, a total of 429 articles were identified
emergency and must be treated urgently to prevent perma- utilizing the initial query. Of these, 236 were excluded on
nent blindness. Factors related to patient outcomes, the basis of title, and 156 articles were excluded on the basis
however, are unknown. The purpose of this study was to of abstract content (Figure 1). Full review of article content
perform a systematic review of published articles in order excluded an additional 21 articles based on absence of indi-
to determine which patient and treatment factors are vidual patient data (n = 10), survey articles (n = 4), absence
related to outcomes. It was our hypothesis that improved of reported retrobulbar hematoma (n = 3), incomplete data
outcomes in cases of retrobulbar hematoma are directly (n = 2), and fewer than 2 patients (n = 2). Sixteen studies
related to shorter time to treatment, and treatment with were thus identified and used for analysis (Table 1).
surgical decompression as opposed to nonoperative
treatment.
Patient demographics
Methods There were a total of 93 cases of retrobulbar hematoma in
the 16 articles reviewed. Mean age of patients was 46 (range
Search methodology 10–92 years). There were 56 males (60%) and 37 females
(40%). Etiology was post-traumatic in 69 (74%)1–6,8–13 and
A PubMed search (1989–2017) was performed using Medical post-operative in 24 (26%).2,3,5,7,8,11,12,14–16 12 studies included
Subject Headings search terms for the following: (retrobul- information about 49 facial fractures.1–4,6,8,11,13 Of the 69 post-
bar OR retroorbital) AND (hemorrhage OR haemorrhage OR traumatic cases of RBH, 17 (25%) were due to motor vehicle
hematoma OR haemotoma OR bleeding). Results included all
ages and sexes, and were limited to the English language and
studies involving humans.
Exclusion criteria included case reports with fewer than 2
patients, studies with incomplete patient data, and studies
with no retrobulbar hematoma reported. Case reports on
subperiosteal hematoma were excluded as well.
Data extraction
steroids, as well as shorter time to treatment were found to hour, the model could not be fitted with the predictor of
predict lower likelihood of blindness (p = 0.037, p = 0.085, time to treatment included.
and p = 0.045). Stepwise multiple logistic regression analyses
also indicated the possible effect of surgery in preventing
blindness (p = 0.037) (Table 4). Time to treatment was not Discussion
included in the stepwise multiple logistic regression analysis
for blindness vs. full/partial recovery because, given a zero Retrobulbar hematoma is a rare but serious condition that
count of blind individuals who were treated in less than one can follow both trauma and elective surgery. While numerous
160 B. Christie et al.
case reports and recommendations have been made, this is unlikely, then, that these symptoms are truly predictive
study represents the first systematic review that attempts to of full recovery, and more likely an association between
leverage the multitude of patient reports against the paucity symptom and outcome linking a particular study. This aber-
of larger case series in an attempt to gather sufficient evi- rancy is mitigated by analyzing total number of symptoms,
dence regarding factors related to patient outcomes. Through which suggested a trend towards increasing number of symp-
analysis of the literature we have identified and analyzed 93 toms being predictive of blindness in single predictor logistic
cases of retrobulbar hematoma represented in 16 included regression analysis.
studies. Overall, our review of visual outcomes suggested Time to treatment was variable among patients and dem-
that approximately half (51%) of patients had complete visual onstrated a robust correlation with outcomes. While the
recovery without visual defects, although 22% of patients majority (82%) of patients received treatment within 24 hours,
developed blindness. Our analysis of both precipitating factors only 28% of patients received treatment within 1 hour. Shorter
and treatment characteristics demonstrate that a number of time to treatment was associated with more likelihood of
aspects have a significant impact on ultimate visual outcomes. full recovery and less likelihood of blindness. This strongly
Our investigation of inciting factors demonstrates that suggests that retrobulbar hematoma outcomes are extremely
both trauma and surgery are well represented as causes for time-sensitive, and confirms previous reports categorizing it
retrobulbar hematoma. While multiple operative interven- as an interventional emergency.
tions were identified as causal, the majority involved open Our investigation of treatment modality also strongly con-
reduction and internal fixation of orbital fractures. Trauma firmed that surgery is the preferred intervention, as it was
cases were significantly less likely to have a full recovery as highly predictive of a full recovery and lower likelihood of
compared to surgical cases. This finding may be related to blindness compared to use of steroids alone or pursuance of
the mechanism causing the hematoma itself, in which nonoperative management. While the addition of steroids to
postoperative bleeding caused by surgical instrumentation surgery was not found to be statistically significant for improv-
tended to be less severe, or it could be related to monitoring ing visual outcomes, the overall intervention of steroids (with
and thresholds to pursue imaging, which may be different or without surgery) trended towards an improvement in visual
between trauma and operative patients. Additionally, factors outcomes, suggesting that, perhaps with a larger number of
such as zone of injury or direct impact to the optic nerve in cases represented, steroids in addition to surgery may prove
addition to hematoma may play a role in the difference in additionally advantageous.
outcomes between an etiology of trauma or surgery. Age was Our study had some limitations, most of which are inher-
also found to be associated with recovery, as younger patients ent to any systematic review. Inclusion of a large number of
were more likely to have improved visual outcomes. studies with a relatively small number of individual cases
Patients presented with a variety of signs and symptoms, can result in limitations of analysis of heterogeneous data, in
including reduced visual acuity, blindness, proptosis, pupil- which certain data sets may become linked within a study. A
lary abnormalities, reduced extraocular movements, and probable example of this phenomenon is in our findings of
increased intraocular pressure.1–16 Pain, commonly described proptosis and reduced visual acuity being paradoxically pre-
as a herald sign for retrobulbar hematoma, was only described dictive of full recovery. Similarly, a number of various sur-
in 15% of patients.2–4,7,8,10,11,14 The symptoms most strongly gical approaches were employed to operatively decompress
predictive of full recovery were an absence of blindness and the orbit, and, when analyzed as individual operative inter-
absence of pupillary disturbances, while the presence of ventions, lacked power to demonstrate any clear advantage
blindness or reduced extraocular motion was strongly pre- of one type of operative approach versus another.
dictive of an outcome of blindness, suggesting that each of In summary, our study is the first of its kind to systemat-
these findings should alert the clinician to a more severe or ically review factors associated with vision outcomes in
advanced process that should be dealt with immediately. patients experiencing retrobulbar hematoma. These results
Additive number of total symptoms were associated with strongly suggest that vision and pupillary changes as well as
blindness, suggesting that, as the pathologic process pro- increasing total number of symptoms are indicative of a
gresses, more symptoms present and make reversal of vision more advanced or severe disease process associated with a
loss less likely. Mean onset of symptoms for both trauma and poor prognosis. As cases often present in a delayed fashion,
surgery occurred around approximately 24 hours. As peri- consideration should be made to closely follow up or observe
ocular surgery is increasingly performed on an outpatient patients. Most importantly, they suggest that time to inter-
basis, the need for close clinical follow up to ensure that vention and surgical decompression are critical to improving
symptoms have not begun to develop should perhaps be visual outcomes and preventing blindness, and the addition
considered. Both clinical exam and radiological diagnosis of steroids may be of benefit. If recognized and treated early
were common as diagnostic tools, suggesting that both are with surgical decompression, recovery of vision is possible.
viable and can continue to be utilized for initial identifica-
tion of retrobulbar hematoma.
Additionally, it was found that symptoms such as propto-
sis and reduced visual acuity were paradoxically predictive References
of a full recovery and absence of reduced visual acuity was
1. Chen Y, Singhal D, Chen Y, Chen C. Management of acute trau-
also associated with blindness. While it is possible that these matic retrobulbar haematomas: a 10-year retrospective review.
symptoms could prompt earlier evaluation and treatment, J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg 2012;65:1325–30.
these findings were thought to be most likely due to lower 2. Colletti G, Valassina D, Rabbiosi D, et al. Traumatic and iatro-
reporting of each individual symptom, as well as heteroge- genic retrobulbar hemorrhage: an 8-patient series. J Oral
neous reporting of individual symptoms across all studies. It Maxillofac Surg 2012;70:e464–8.
Retrobulbar hematoma: A systematic review of factors related to outcomes 161
3. Rosdeutscher J, Stadelmann W. Diagnosis and treatment of ret- 10. Goodall K, Brahma A, Bates A, Leatherbarrow B. Lateral
robulbar hematoma resulting from blunt periorbital trauma. canthotomy and inferior cantholysis: An effective method of
Ann Plast Surg 1998;41:618–22. urgent orbital decompression for sight threatening acute retro-
4. Gerbino G, Ramieri G, Nasi A. Diagnosis and treatment of ret- bulbar haemorrhage. Injury 1999;30:485–90.
robulbar haematomas following blunt orbital trauma: a descrip- 11. Hislop W, Dutton G. Retrobulbar haemorrhage: can blindness be
tion of eight cases. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg 2005;34:127–31. prevented? Injury 1994;25:663–5.
5. Zimmerer R, Schattmann K, Essig H, et al. Efficacy of transcu- 12. Maurer P, Conrad-Hengerer I, Hollstein S, Mizziani T, Hoffmann
taneous transseptal orbital decompression in treating acute E, Hengerer F. Orbital haemorrhage associated with orbital
retrobulbar hemorrhage and a literature review. Craniomaxillofac fractures in geriatric patients on antiplatelet or anticoagulant
Trauma Reconstr 2014;7:17–26. therapy. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg 2013;42:1510–4.
6. Brucoli M, Arcuri F, Giarda M, Benech R, Benech A. Surgical 13. Roccia F, Boffano P, Guglielmi V, et al. Role of the maxillofacial
management of posttraumatic intraorbital hematoma. J Craniofac surgeon in the management of severe ocular injuries after
Surg 2012;23:e58–61. maxillofacial fractures. J Emerg Trauma Shock 2011;4:188–
7. Cheon J, Seo B, Yang J, Son K. Retrobulbar hematoma in blow- 93.
out fracture after open reduction. Arch Plast Surg 2013;40: 14. Corey J, Bumsted R, Panje W, Namon A. Orbital complications
445–9. in functional endoscopic sinus surgery. Otolaryngol Head Neck
8. Jamal B, Diecidue R, Taub D, Champion A, Bilyk J. Orbital Surg 1993;109:814–20.
hemorrhage and compressive optic neuropathy in patients with 15. Liu D. Blindness after blow-out fracture. Ophthalmic Plast Reconstr
midfacial fractures receiving low-molecular weight heparin Surg 1994;10:206–10.
therapy. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 2009;67:1416–9. 16. Saussez S, Choufani G, Brutus J, Cordonnier M Hassid S. Lateral
9. Korinth M, Ince A, Banghard W, Huffmann B, Gilsbach J. Pterional canthotomy: a simple and safe procedure for orbital haemorrhage
orbital decompression in orbital hemorrhage and trauma. J Trauma secondary to endoscopic sinus surgery. Rhinology 1998;36:
2002;53:73–8. 37–9.