University Students Perceptions of An Ideal English Teacher Before and During The COVID 19 Pandemic A Study

Cogent Arts & Humanities
ISSN: (Print) (Online) Journal homepage: https://www.tandfonline.com/loi/oaah20
University students’ perceptions of an ideal

English teacher before and during the COVID-19
pandemic: A study
Sakul Kundra, Nakul Kundra & Awadhesh Kumar Shirotriya
To cite this article: Sakul Kundra, Nakul Kundra & Awadhesh Kumar Shirotriya
(2023) University students’ perceptions of an ideal English teacher before and during
the COVID-19 pandemic: A study, Cogent Arts & Humanities, 10:1, 2245623, DOI:
10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
To link to this article: https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
© 2023 The Author(s). Published by Informa

UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis
Group.
Published online: 17 Aug 2023.
Submit your article to this journal
View related articles
View Crossmark data
Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at

https://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=oaah20
Kundra et al., Cogent Arts & Humanities (2023), 10: 2245623
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
LITERATURE, LINGUISTICS & CRITICISM | RESEARCH ARTICLE

University students’ perceptions of an ideal
English teacher before and during the COVID-19
pandemic: A study
Received: 17 May 2023 Sakul Kundra1*, Nakul Kundra2 and Awadhesh Kumar Shirotriya3
Accepted: 04 August 2023
Abstract: This survey study examines how online teaching during the COVID-19
*Corresponding author: Sakul Kundra,
Associate Dean Research and pandemic affected the students’ perception of an ideal English teacher. A close-
Assistant Professor, College of ended questionnaire prepared in light of the students’ short descriptive views on the
Humanities and Education, Fiji
National University, Lautoka, Fiji characteristics of an ideal English teacher was used to collect data about personal,
E-mail: dr.sakulkundra@gmail.com
social, and professional aspects of an ideal English teacher before the Covd-19
Reviewing editor: pandemic. During the pandemic, the survey was repeated. The present article
Oliver Nyambi, English, University of
the Free State, South Africa compares and contrasts the calculated percentage of the data collected prior to
Additional information is available at and during the pandemic to conclude how the circumstances created by the global
the end of the article crises changed the students’ perceptions of an ideal English teacher. Based on
comparative analysis, this research is a quantitative, descriptive study with some
interesting results. The results reveal that, with the change of circumstances, some
aspects of an ideal teacher remained irrelevant (e.g. age, gender, etc.); some others
remained considerably compelling (e.g. the teacher’s interaction with the students,
reading skills, listening skills, and punctuality); some became more important (e.g.
show concern); some became less important (e.g. dress sense and physical fea
tures). The article touches on the Indian value system to interpret the results.
Subjects: Languages of Asia; Language & Linguistics; Literature
Keywords: professional; social; personal; characteristics; teaching
1. Introduction
This survey study aims to determine how online teaching during the COVID-19 pandemic affected
students’ perception of an ideal English teacher. The onset of the pandemic marked a sudden
change in the education system; classroom teaching came to a sudden halt, and the mode of
instruction was forced to switch from offline to online. Many students, as well as teachers,
ABOUT THE AUTHORS

Dr. Sakul Kundra is Associate Dean Research and Assistant Professor of History at College of
Humanities and Education, Fiji National University. He completed his Ph.D. in History from the Centre
for Historical Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University, India. He is a prolific writer.
Dr. Nakul Kundra completed his Ph.D. (English) from Guru Nanak Dev University, Amritsar, India. He is
an Associate Professor in the Department of English and Modern European Languages at the
University of Allahabad, Prayagraj, India. India's experimental and avant-garde counterculture appeals
to him for its potentiality as a research topic.
Dr. Shirotriya obtained his Ph.D. in Physical Education from Devi Ahilya Vishwadhyalya, Indore (MP),
India in 2015. Presently, he is working as Assistant Professor in Fiji National University, Fiji Islands.
© 2023 The Author(s). Published by Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group.
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution
License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribu
tion, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. The terms on
which this article has been published allow the posting of the Accepted Manuscript in
a repository by the author(s) or with their consent.
Page 1 of 26
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
struggled to get used to the new system for a long time. The teacher’s physical presence was
replaced with his/her virtual existence on different online platforms. The worldwide outbreak of
COVID-19 affected approximately 1.6 billion students in over 200 countries, and educational
institutes and learning spaces were closed, affecting more than 94% of the world’s student
population (Pokhrel & Chhetri, 2021). Juárez-Díaz and Perales (2021) report that, during the
COVID-19 phase, the majority of teachers and all students had unfavourable views, which were
related to certain faculty members’ emphasis on delivering information without engagement and
with limited internet access.
2. Background to the survey study

Some teachers are often labelled as “favourite” teachers by their students. On the other hand, some
hardworking and dedicated English teachers cannot attract students to their classes. A dedicated
non-favourite teacher does not become popular among students irrespective of the fact that he/she
is firm in his/her commitment to his/her role. Sometimes, he/she even goes beyond the call of duty
to ensure that his/her pupils obtain quality education and frequently devotes extra time and effort to
assist struggling students. A favourite teacher, on the other hand, is someone whom students adore
for his/her engaging and relatable teaching approach. He/she easily connects with his/her students,
fostering a warm, welcoming classroom ambience that promotes learning. His/her classes are
pleasant, and he/she is regarded as a role model by many students.
Being an English teacher in India, the second author has always been keen to know his students’
perceptions of an ideal English teacher. He carried out a survey study titled “Students” Perception of
an Ideal English Teacher” as a part of his dissertation work, submitted for the degree of M.A.
(Education) in 2019, i.e., before the outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic. The participants of this
study were the students enrolled in the Department of English of DAV University in Jalandhar
(Punjab, India) in the session 2018–19. The data regarding the personal, social, and professional
characteristics of an ideal English teacher was gathered using a closed-ended questionnaire that
was created in consideration of the students’ brief descriptive views on the characteristics of an ideal
English teacher. The researcher re-conducted the same survey study on the students enrolled in the
same Department in the session 2020–21, i.e., during the pandemic. This article compares the data
collected before the pandemic and the data collected during the pandemic to draw conclusions
regarding how the COVID-19 pandemic affected the student’s perception of an ideal English teacher.
Notably, the pandemic clearly affected the education sector across the world to a great extent.
3. Objectives of the study

The objectives of the study are to find out:
(1) the views of the students of the Department of English, DAV University (Jalandhar), regard
ing some social, personal, and professional aspects of an ideal English teacher.
(2) the effects of the pandemic situation on the students’ perceptions of an ideal English
teacher.
4. Research questions
(1) According to the students of the Department of English, DAV University (Jalandhar), what
are the personal, social, and professional qualities of an ideal English teacher?
(2) How has the COVID-19 pandemic situation affected the students’ perceptions of an ideal
English teacher?
5. Review of literature: An ideal second language teacher

Every language works within the framework of social, cultural, and linguistic codes, and learning
a language involves exposure to such codes in formal and informal contexts. Under normal
circumstances, our communicative interactions in society help us learn and improve speaking
and listening skills in our mother tongue with ease. Such learning is primarily oral and ignores
Page 2 of 26
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
reading and writing skills. On the other hand, it is seen that learning a second language in informal
contexts suffers a severe setback due to the lack of exposure to all the skills of that target
language in day-to-day socio-cultural situations. It may be said that informal learning is arbitrary,
asymmetrical, and unplanned, and importantly, all four skills of any language cannot be excelled
in informal contexts.
A language teacher facilitates and systematically provides opportunities for learning in a graded
manner. Keeping in view learners’ social and professional needs, he/she converts “information”
into knowledge and facilitates learning. He/she consistently evaluates learners’ progress and
ensures their overall development. Typically, high-quality teaching is defined by practices that
are associated with successful outcomes for learners and test scores (Cochran-Smith & Fries,
2001). Students’ ideas and views regarding the ideal teacher are of paramount importance
because students constantly judge teachers and their teaching and make opinions about them
during and after the learning process. Moreover, they are directly influenced by both outstanding
and bad teaching (Follman, 1995).
Kozikoğlu (2017) studies how future education professionals describe the ideal teacher and
asserts that the first three cognitive categories attached to the ideal teacher are teaching peda
gogical skills, humaneness/joviality, and professional content knowledge. Ida (2017) looks at
secondary school students’ perceptions of a good teacher and argues that they want teachers
who put in a lot of effort in assisting students with their learning. Furthermore, in their beliefs,
personal attention, dealing with the issues of pupils, fair treatment, and showing respect for one
another take priority.
Jannah (2019), on the basis of a study conducted at the University of Muhammadiyah Malang,
states that effective ESP (English for Specific Purposes) lecturers have four characteristics: 1)
educational awareness, 2) organisation and communication skills, 3) social and emotional skills, 4)
English proficiency. Megawati (2019) analyses the data collected from 222 students in the fifth
semester in the English Language Education Department at the University of Muhammadiyah
Malang (ELED UMM) and claims that the students give more importance to an English teacher’s
pedagogic competence than his/her personal competence. Urazaliyeva and Kassymova (2018)
argue that the students consider psychological abilities—whereas the teachers consider English
fluency—to be the most important trait of an ideal ELT instructor. Chomaeva and Kubanova (2019)
assert that the students see genuine pedagogical engagement negatively and desire greater
gentleness, happiness, and good emotions from engaging teachers. Barnett (2019) collects infor
mation about the qualities of high-quality teachers from a deliberate sample of people who have
been identified as such by their principals. According to the study, high-quality teachers employ
a variety of tactics that are carefully chosen in light of pupil needs and learning. Self-confidence
and speaking style of teachers, Saini et al. (2019) finds, have the maximum effect on teaching
(92.7% and 86.5%, respectively) in the personal area; in the professional domain, clarification of
doubts (86.5%) was the most crucial factor affecting teaching, followed by the method of teaching
(85.5%); the experience of teachers (86.4%) affects teaching the most, followed by the mastery of
scientific concepts and materials (84.4%) in the scientific area. Ghimire (2019) claims that effective
English language instruction requires dynamic teachers, active and creative learners, effective use
of teaching-learning materials, proper use of the latest technologies, and multiliteracy pedagogy in
the classroom. In secondary schools in Cross River State, Nigeria, Robert and Owan (2019) examine
students’ perceptions of teachers’ efficacy and learning outcomes in mathematics and economics.
They discover that students’ perceptions of teachers’ motivational abilities, instructional strategies,
rapport with students, and level of communication have a significant influence on their learning
outcomes.
Petrova et al. (2020) state that high subject mastery, the capacity to pique students’ interest in
academic material, cooperation with students, and objective knowledge assessment are identified
as the most crucial and preferred qualities of a modern teacher according to high school students.
Page 3 of 26
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
Positive personality traits include the teacher’s ability to communicate productively and gently
with each pupil and his/her high energy level. Students do not care about a teacher’s looks. The
respondents said it is crucial for a teacher to dress professionally and appear neat. Anggraini et al.
(2020) discusses students’ perceptions of the qualities of an ideal maritime English instructor in
a vocational institution. She asserts that the students view their teachers as ideal if they teach
both formal and informal English, incorporate games into their lessons, and set up group and
partner work activities. Additionally, the students favour those teachers who utilise technology and
visual aids to encourage linguistic exploration; conversely, they dislike teachers who talk exces
sively. Karima (2020) finds that according to the student teachers, cultural awareness, classroom
management, and effective communication skills are the most critical characteristics of effective
EFL teacher educators. Hien (2020) finds that exceptional instructional abilities and thorough
subject-matter knowledge are required for TEFL. Yazdanipour and Fakharzadeh (2020) looks at
how the administrators of certain private English language institutions in Iran see language
instructors’ effectiveness and comes to the conclusion that they place less importance on educa
tional issues and learning results. It is found that administrators place greater importance on
a teacher’s looks and personality than on several other job-related characteristics. Casta et al.
(2020) reveals language proficiency, organisation and communication skills, character and person
ality, pedagogical knowledge, socio-affective skills, IT/ICT abilities, and cultural competency are
the seven main theoretical constructs that sum up the traits Thai learners demand from their
language instructors.
Karim (2021) looks at the concept of successful EFL teacher educators from the viewpoints of
student teachers and teacher educators and finds that they view effective EFL teacher educators
in very different ways. The perceptions of the three categories of attributes—subject matter
knowledge, pedagogical knowledge, and organisation and communication skills—between stu
dent teachers and teacher educators differed significantly statistically. Between the teacher
educators and the student teachers, there was no statistically significant difference in how
they perceived socio-affective abilities. Huy (2022) discovers that EFL lecturers’ ability to execute
pedagogical, social, managerial, and technical roles affects their students’ online English learning
engagement. The research suggests that language instructors should receive extra training to
increase their flexibility in generating autonomy-supportive online activities and their digital
competence.
Since learning is a continuous process, teaching is a continuous process of striving for perfection.
A good teacher is flexible and innovative. He/she accommodates himself/herself to ever-changing
conditions and tries to give his/her best with available resources. A good teacher may show some
essential archetypal patterns, but there is no unanimity among researchers about the success or
effectiveness of a teacher (Harris et al., 1960).
Theoretically and practically, no teacher will become totally ideal. That correlation would
mean that the teacher has achieved such a level of perfection that she or he no longer
requires further effort toward improvement (Rusua et al., 2012, p. 1017)
The questionnaire used in this study outlines some important personal, social, and professional
aspects of an ideal English teacher based on the student participants’ descriptive views of the
characteristics of an ideal English teacher. The students broadly referred to the following aspects
in their descriptive accounts:
5.1. Personal and social aspects

Gender, Age, Dress Sense, Looks/Physical Features, Sensitivity, Flexibility, Interactions with Colleagues
and Students, Presence on Social Media, Family and Social Background, Brand Consciousness, and
Availability outside the Class
Page 4 of 26
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
5.2. Professional aspects

Teaching Skill and Experience, Use of Mother Tongue, Technology and Non-Verbal Communication,
Classroom Environment, Attitude Towards Examination Process and Evaluation, Student-Teacher
Relationship, Reading Skills, Listening Skills, Doctorate Degree, Care, Fluency, Expectations,
Knowledge, and Punctuality.
Different studies explore students’ and/or teachers’ perceptions to find out the characteristics of
an ideal/effective teacher and teaching. There is the unavailability of comparative research based
on pre- and during- pandemic data about students’ perceptions of an ideal English teacher’s
personal, social, and professional aspects. The present research is innovative and attempts to
fill in a lacuna in the area of study.
6. Methodology of the study

The methodology of the study comprises the research method, population, sample, tool, and
procedures of data collection and data analysis.
6.1. Research method

The nature of the research is descriptive, and the survey method has been adopted to collect the
data. It is mainly quantitative research.
6.2. Population
The population is the students enrolled in the Department of English of DAV University, Jalandhar,
in the sessions 2018–19 and 2020–21. Eighty-four students participated in the survey in 2019,
whereas eighty students took part in the survey in 2021.
6.3. Sample
The second author was the Coordinator of the Department of English of DAV University, Jalandhar,
at the time of the surveys. So, the population was conveniently available. This is a case of
incidental/convenient sampling. The study involved all the students who were willing to participate
in the research.
6.4. Tools
The following tools are used: i. Paper and Pen ii. Electronic platform. To understand what the
students mean by “an ideal English teacher”, the students enrolled in 2018–19 were asked to write
an essay on “Characteristics of an ideal English teacher”. Their responses were categorised into
general descriptive categories and further used to develop a close-ended questionnaire. This
questionnaire was used in 2019 as well as 2021 to collect the data. In 2019, the responses were
collected manually, whereas the responses were collected on Google Forms in 2021.
6.5. Procedure of data collection

The 2019 data was manually collected through questionnaires. The questionnaires were distrib
uted to all the students, and they were asked to drop their responses in the drop box meant for
data collection. It helped the students to respond freely and without any pressure. They were
allowed to hide their identity. The 2021 data was collected through Google Forms. While collecting
data in 2021, the following instructions were given to the students: “Thank you for your willingness
to fill in this questionnaire, which is the main instrument for collecting data regarding your percep
tion of an ideal English teacher, particularly when teaching is being undertaken remotely and on
digital platforms during the pandemic (Covid 19). This survey research is to serve a dual purpose.
First, the results of the research would give an opportunity to the department teachers to introspect,
retrospect, and analyse their personal, social, and professional aspects to become better teachers.
Secondly, the research work would be published to document the students’ perception of an ideal
English teacher in the Covid-9 situation. This would help other researchers across the world in
a number of ways. Kindly give honest responses keeping in view online teaching during the pan
demic. Your identity would not be revealed under any circumstances.”
Page 5 of 26
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
6.6. Procedure of data analysis

Various attributes are examined by comparing means on discrete attributes between the two
cohorts of students who studied in the same department. In other words, the data has been
analysed with the help of quantitative techniques. First, the participants’ responses are calculated
in percentage, and then the data is comparatively analysed to draw conclusions. The discussion is
developed in connection to Indian cultural beliefs.
6.7. Ethical approval

Ethical approval/consent is taken from the students for filling in the questionnaire. The question
naire at the beginning specifies that it is meant only for the students willing to participate in the
survey. In other words, the research included only those students who were quite willing to
participate in the research. Besides, the second author took permission from the office of Dean,
DAV University, Jalandhar, to pursue an M.A. in Education and carry out the survey in 2019. The
present article is an extension of the research work submitted to IGNO University (New Delhi) in
partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of M.A. in Education.
6.8. Limitation of the study

The second-year and third-year students enrolled in 2018–19 had left before the study was
reconducted during the pandemic in 2020–21. Besides, the newly admitted students in 2019–20
and 2020–21 took part in the study only during the pandemic, as they had not been studying in the
Department in 2018–19. Although the survey study was repeated during the pandemic, all the
participants were not the same. The common point between the two cohorts of the students is
that all of them were taught by the same teachers in the same department.
7. Results and observations
7.1. Observation 7.1: Dress sense, physical looks/features, gender and age
During the pandemic, the percentage of students who believed that a teacher’s dress sense was
not important at all exponentially increased from 17.85 percent to 41.3 percent (Ref. Table 1).
While teaching on virtual platforms like Google Meet and Zoom, it is observed that the teacher
mostly projects his/her face and the area around the shoulders on the screen. Hence, his/her dress
does not remarkably influence his/her students to have an opinion about him/her in the online
mode of teaching. Similarly, a teacher’s looks seem to have more influence in the face-to-face
physical mode of teaching than the virtual mode. The percentage of students who opined that the
teacher’s looks/physical features were not imperative to make an opinion of his/her personality
increased from 50 percent to 61.3 percent during the pandemic. It is found that the physical
teaching mode helps the teacher build rapport with his/her students through effective verbal and
non-verbal communication. On the other hand, non-verbal messages through eyes (Oculesics),
touch (Haptics), and facial gestures, especially microexpressions (Kinesics), are not effectively
conveyed during online teaching. Besides, the 3D visual experience in the physical mode is livelier
and more engaging than the 2D image on the virtual platform.
According to the students, the teacher’s gender and age were irrelevant aspects (Ref. Tables 2 and 3).
Before and during the pandemic, more than 95 percent of the students reported that the gender of the
ideal teacher did not matter to them. Similarly, almost 80 percent of the students said that age was an
irrelevant aspect in this context; an ideal English instructor might be of any age. Before and after the
pandemic, the most popular age range was between 31 and 40. However, this range was selected by
less than 15 percent of the students.
Observation 1 strengthens the traditional Indian idea that the outer aspects of the knowledge
provider are not important at all; importance should be given to knowledge rather than the
knowledge provider (Guru). Kabir, a 15th-century Indian mystic poet and saint, says:
जाति न पूछो साधु की, पूछ लीजिये ज्ञान।
Page 6 of 26
Table 1. Dress sense and physical looks/features
Students’ Not Important (0–20) Slightly Important (21–40) Somewhat Important Very Important (61–80) Most Important (81–100)
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
Responses in (41–60)
Percentage →
Social and Before During Before During Before During Before During Before During
Professional COVID-19 COVID-19 COVID-19 COVID-19 COVID-19 COVID-19 COVID-19 COVID-19 COVID-19 COVID-19
Aspects
Dress Sense 17.85 41.3 35.71 27.5 35.71 18.8 10.71 10 0 2.5
Looks/Physical 50 61.3 29.76 21.3 19.04 8.8 0 7.5 1.19 1.2
Features
Page 7 of 26
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
Table 2. Teacher’s gender

Students’ Responses in Before COVID-19 During COVID-19
Percentage
Male (Man) 2.38 2.5

Female (Woman) 0 0
Gender Neutral 96.42 97.5
Not Answered 1.19 0
Table 3. Teacher’s age group

Percentage
20–30 years 2.35 2.5

31–40 years 14.11 8.8
41–50 years 1.17 3.7
51–60 years 0 1.3
61–70 years 0 0
Above 70 0 0
Age doesn’t matter 82.35 83.8
मोल करो तलवार का, पड़ा रहन दो म्यान ॥
(Ask not a saint of his caste; rather, of his knowledge.

Negotiate the price of the sword, let the sheath be kept aside) (The second author’s
Translation)
The couplet implies that the sword is utilised in a battle, not the sheath that holds it. Similarly, the
knowledge of a sage is useful, not his caste or religion.
7.2. Observation 7.2: Emotional sensitivity and flexibility

Roy and Dasgupta’s (2017) study on underprivileged high-ability middle school students reveals that the
human qualities of teachers are more important than their domain knowledge for students. In the
present survey study, the students expect the ideal teacher to be emotionally sensitive and flexible, and
there is a rise in the expectation level during the pandemic (Ref. Table 4). In other words, as regards the
teacher’s emotional sensitivity and flexibility, a notable percentage of the students opted for the “most
important” and “very important” options during the pandemic. The COVID-19 pandemic instilled a sense
of uncertainty and despair in people, and it was crucial for every individual to be flexible, accommodating
and sensitive towards other fellow beings irrespective of one’s social status. Saint Kabir also emphasises
that human qualities are more important than one’s other achievements. He says,
बड़ा हुआ तो क्या हुआ, जैसे पेड़ खजूर।

पंथी को छाया नहीं, फल लागे अति दूर॥
(So what if you are as tall as a date palm?

There is no shadow for passers-by, and the fruits are far away. (The second author’s
Translation)
Page 8 of 26
Table 4. Emotional sensitivity and flexibility
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
Percentage →
Aspects
Emotional 2.38 5 27.38 21.3 41.66 33.8 25 31.3 3.57 8.8

Sensitivity
Flexibility 2.38 5 14.28 1.2 42.85 22.5 29.76 46.3 10.71 25
Page 9 of 26
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
Kabir emphasises that one’s worldly accomplishments and achievements do not make one great.
Humility lays the foundation for one’s greatness. According to Kabir, despite its height, the date
palm tree cannot provide shade to passers-by or visitors, nor can its fruit be collected easily.
Similarly, one’s worldly accomplishments and achievements are meaningless if one lacks compas
sion and genuine love.
7.3. Observation 7.3: Interactions, relationships, availability and expectations

During the lockdown, the teachers worked from home and a considerable number of students
were of the view that the teachers’ interactions with one another were quite indispensable to
ensure uninterrupted and effective teaching. As regards the teacher’s interactions with his/her
colleagues, the percentage of students who opted for “not important” and “slightly important”
options decreased and the percentage of those who chose “the most important” and “very
important” options increased during the pandemic (Ref. Table 5). At DAV University, the teachers
work within an established framework of communication; they also get a lot of random, informal
opportunities to interact and share information with one another in small or large groups. While
working from home, such opportunities remained unavailable. Interpersonal communication
among teachers on the telephone or virtual platforms was quite crucial in facilitating online
teaching.
As far as the teacher’s interactions with his/her students are concerned, the percentage of
students who opted for “the most important” and “very important” options slightly increased
from 55.94 percent to 58.8 percent (Ref. Table 5). It reveals that more than half of the participants
believe a teacher’s interactions with his/her students are considerably important in the online
mode as well as in the offline mode of teaching. For good teaching and learning to occur, there
must be positive teacher-student contact (Arthur et al., 2003b).
Chan (2018) explores Chinese pupils’ opinions on competent teachers and successful instruction.
Learners respect instructors’ admiration, concern, and cordial relationships with pupils in addition to
their instructional competence. Kabir goes so far as to put human love over worldly knowledge. He says,
पोथी पढ़ि पढ़ि जग मुआ, पंडित भया न कोय |

ढाई आखर प्रेम का, पढ़े सो पंडित होय ||
(Although the world reads a lot, not everyone becomes a scholar.

The one who learns two and a half letters of love becomes a scholar.) (The Second Author’s
Translation)
Kabir thinks that not everyone becomes a scholar, even after reading a lot of books. According to
Kabir, a person will be a true scholar if he/she can read just “two and a half letters” of love, i.e.,
embrace human love and compassion.
The teacher serves as a guide, and his/her active participation was looked forward to throughout
the COVID-19 crisis. In times of uncertainty, the teacher was expected to show concern; during the
pandemic, the number of pupils who selected “the most important” or “very important” options for
the teacher’s expression of concern exponentially shot up from 27.33 percent to 70 percent (Ref.
Table 5). This augmented change in the percentage is the maximum change in the study.
As Sarason (1999) said, “the starting point of all learning is to know the minds and hearts of
your learners” (p.110) . . . The purposeful design of a teacher-student interactive learning
environment enhances the educational experience for students (Gablinske, 2014)
An effective English teacher should have a great rapport with his/her students; a strong student-
teacher relationship lays the foundation for effective learning. With regard to it, approximately
Page 10 of 26
Table 5. Interactions, relationships, availability and expectations
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
Percentage →
Aspects
Interaction with 19.04 12.5 26.19 21.3 26.19 31.3 19.04 23.7 9.52 11.3
Colleagues
Interaction with 2.38 7.5 9.52 7.5 32.14 26.2 45.23 41.3 10.71 17.5
Students Outside
the
Classroom
Show Care 16.66 1.3 28.57 2.5 27.38 26.3 19.04 52.5 8.33 17.5
Strong Student- 0 0 4.76 2.5 25 11.3 48.80 50 21.42 36.3
Teacher
Relationship
Availability for 7.14 3.8 21.42 18.8 36.90 30 26.19 33.8 8.33 13.7
Students Outside
the Classroom/
university
High Expectations 19.04 6.3 28.57 22.5 23.80 41.3 26.19 22.5 2.38 7.5
from All Students
Page 11 of 26
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
86 percent of the students chose “the most important” and “very important” options during the
pandemic, compared to approximately 70 percent before the outbreak (Ref. Table 5). During the
pandemic, when there was a global catastrophe, more students realised the importance of their
teachers’ s emotional support.
For more than 30 percent of the students, the teacher’s availability outside the classroom was
“somewhat important” prior to and during the pandemic (Ref. Table 5). The percentage of students
who considered this aspect to be “the most important” or “very important” went up from 34.52 to
47.5 percent. During the pandemic, the students anticipated their teacher to stay electronically or via
telephone contactable even after classes. The Guru Gita’s description of the guru as a “dispeller of
darkness” (verse 17) is accurate (from gu, “darkness” and ru, “that which dispels”). During hard times,
the students more keenly looked forward to his/her teacher’s guidance and emotional support.
“Having high expectations from all students” was not a very conspicuous aspect of an ideal
English teacher’s professional sphere of life before the pandemic. However, the percentage of
students who chose “not important” and “slightly important” options fell from 47.61 % to 28.8%
during the pandemic (Ref. Table 5). The most favourite option prior to and during the pandemic
was “somewhat important”; 23.80% of the pupils before the pandemic and 41.3% of the pupils
during the pandemic chose it. It is notable that higher expectations for student performance lead
to more favourable academic results (Rist, 1970).
7.4. Observation 7.4: Social media, familial background and brand awareness
The teacher’s familial and social background, brand awareness, and presence on social media do not
greatly influence how his/her students perceive him/her (Ref. Table 6). Regarding his/her presence on
social media sites, more than 72 percent of the students chose “not important” and “slightly
important” options before as well as during the COVID-19 pandemic; regarding his/her family and
social background, more than 90 percent of the students selected “not important” and “slightly
important” options before and during the global crisis; and regarding his/her brand consciousness,
more than 84 percent of the students opted for “not important” and “slightly important” options
before and during the pandemic. Therefore, these three aspects are not essential for an ideal English
teacher; they do not influence students’ perception of the teacher. Kabir, as stated earlier, also
disapproves of a Master’s/Guru’s outer aspects. In his poem “Pedigree”, Kabir says,
Judge not the servant (of the Lord) by his wealth

or social status.
A single piece of sandalwood is far more precious
Than a million of the common babul trees.
A Sadhu’s small thatched hut is far more precious
Than a well-built village owned by a slave
of the world (Ezkiel, 1992).
7.5. Observation 7.5: Technology

Many studies provide evidence that web-based learning contributes to the quality of teaching and
learning skills (Bransford et al., 1999). When offline teaching was supplanted by virtual learning
during the pandemic, technology played a crucial role. However, the online form of instruction
presented a lot of challenges for educators who lacked technical expertise. Before the pandemic,
over 80 percent of the students responded that the use of technology (slides, e-documents, smart
classroom materials, etc.) by an ideal English instructor was “somewhat important” or “very
important” (Ref. Table 7). During the pandemic, however, more than 73% of the students selected
responses ranging between “somewhat important” and “the most important”. It is notable that
the percentage slightly decreased from 80 to 73 percent during the worldwide crisis, which is quite
surprising given that the ideal English teacher is supposed to largely rely on technology in the
online mode of teaching. The data suggests that some students had a positive view of a non-tech-
savvy ideal teacher, and 11.3 percent of the students during the pandemic believed that
Page 12 of 26
Table 6. Social media, familial background and brand awareness
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
Percentage →
Aspects
Presence 57.14 52.5 19.04 20 16.66 20 5.95 6.3 1.19 1.2

on Social
Media
Sites
Family 67.85 75 22.61 17.5 7.14 5 2.38 1.2 0 1.2
and
Social
background
Brand 55.95 72.5 28.57 21.3 13.09 3.7 1.19 2.5 1.19 0
Consciousness
Page 13 of 26
Table 7. Technology
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
Percentage →
Aspects
Use of Technology 0 11.3 19.04 15 52.38 37.5 25 27.5 3.57 8.8
Page 14 of 26
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
technology could not be a deciding factor while assessing the professional aspects of an ideal
English teacher. Notably, there was not a single student who viewed the use of technology as “not
important” prior to the pandemic, when offline instruction was the norm.
7.6. Observation 7.6: Communication

Popa (2018) conducted a study to chalk out a set of personal and professional characteristics of an
ideal teacher from the viewpoint of the students enrolled in a teacher training program. The
researcher finds that the participants consider communication to be one of the most essential
four characteristics of an ideal teacher.
Before and during the pandemic, more than 40 percent of the pupils opted for “the most
important” and “very important” options for the use of non-verbal communication by the ideal
English teacher (Ref. Table 8); approximately 30 percent of the students deemed this factor to
be “somewhat important”. During the pandemic, the percentage of students who considered
this factor to be “slightly important” declined by about 12 percent; more pupils were aware of
the significance of nonverbal communication prior to the pandemic.
Reading and listening skills are essential for an ideal English teacher in both digital and
conventional ways of instruction (Ref. Table 8). This view is supported by the data obtained
before and after the pandemic. Before and during the pandemic, at least 85 percent of the
learners selected “the most important” and “very important” options for listening and reading
skills.
During and after the pandemic, approximately 50 percent of the students considered “fluency” as
a significant professional trait (Ref. Table 8). Before the crisis, 44.04 percent of the students regarded
fluency to be “somewhat important”, while after the outbreak, 31.3 percent of the students held the
same opinion. It is notable that the quality of online communication also depends upon the internet
bandwidth; in the rural interiors where the internet connectivity is poor, it is difficult for students to
grasp the contents of a lecture delivered by a highly fluent teacher.
7.7. Observation 7.7: Doctorate, knowledge, punctuality and teaching skills, experience and
environment
According to around 30 percent of the students, before and during the pandemic, “having
a doctorate degree” and “having teaching experience” are “somewhat important” aspects of
an ideal English teacher’s professional sphere of life (Ref. Table 9). As regards a doctorate
degree, around 40 percent of the students selected “not important” and “slightly important”
options before and during the pandemic. In the case of teaching experience, around 35 percent
of the learners opted for “not important” and “slightly important” options before and during the
pandemic.
Prior to and during the pandemic, over 40 percent of the students considered “knowledge about
other subjects” to be “somewhat important” for an ideal English teacher (Ref. Table 9). It was their
‘most’ favourite choice. Both before and during the pandemic, more than 30 percent of the
students believed this professional aspect to be either “very important” or “most important”.
Seventy percent of the pupils considered timeliness either “very important” or “the most
important” for an ideal English instructor, prior to and during the pandemic (Ref. Table 9).
Disapproving procrastination, Saint Kabir also highlights the importance of punctuality. He says
the world may come to an end at any moment
काल करे सो आज कर, आज करे सो अब

पल में परलय होएगी, बहुरी करोगे कब
Page 15 of 26
Table 8. Non-verbal communication, reading skills, listening skills, and fluency
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
Percentage →
Aspects
Use of Non-Verbal 1.19 3.8 29.76 17.5 27.38 33.8 28.57 35 13.09 10
Communication
Listening Skills 0 0 1.19 1.3 9.52 12.5 58.33 58.8 30.95 27.5
Reading Skills 0 0 1.19 1.3 7.14 13.8 52.38 52.5 39.28 32.5
Fluency 0 6.3 7.14 12.5 44.04 31.3 44.04 46.3 4.76 3.7
Page 16 of 26
Table 9. Doctorate, experience, knowledge, and punctuality
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
Percentage →
Aspects
Doctorate Degree 23.80 27.5 17.85 10 34.52 33.8 21.42 22.5 2.38 6.3
Teaching 16.66 13.8 16.66 21.2 32.14 28.7 25 20 9.52 16.2
Experience
Knowledge about 2.38 6.3 20.23 18.8 40.47 43.8 35.71 20 1.19 11.3
Other Subjects
Punctuality 1.19 2.5 7.14 6.2 22.61 22.5 51.19 42.5 17.85 26.2
Page 17 of 26
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
(Do tomorrow’s work today and today’s work now.

If the opportunity is lost, how can the work be accomplished?) (The Second Author’s
Translation)
Kabir, while discussing the significance of time, advises that if you must complete a task tomorrow,
do it today, and if you must complete a task today, do it now since our lives are so short and will
end in a matter of moments. That is, if you do not act promptly, you will not be able to accomplish
your goals.
Prior to the pandemic, 65.47 percent of the pupils stated that an ideal English teacher would
teach English as a skill (Ref. Table 10). During the pandemic, however, the percentage of students
plummeted to 52.5%. Before and during the pandemic, “English via literature” was the second
most popular option; 21.42 percent of the students before the pandemic and 28.7 percent of the
students during the pandemic believed that an ideal English teacher taught English through
literature. There is a sudden increase of almost 15 percent of the students who opted for
“English as a Language”. Before and during the pandemic, over 60 percent of the pupils claimed
that the ideal English instructor should occasionally use the mother tongue in class (Ref. Table 11).
Table 10. Teaching

Percentage
English as a Language 1.19 16.3

English as a Subject 2.38 2.5
English as a Skill 65.47 52.5
English Through Literature 21.42 28.7
Any Other 9.52 0
Table 11. Mother tongue

Percentage
Always 2.38 5
Usually 21.42 25
Sometimes 65.47 61.3
Rarely 9.52 7.5
Never 1.19 1.2
Table 12. Classroom environment

Percentage
Teacher Centric 7.14 6.3

Student Centric 76.19 51.2
Syllabus Centric 5.95 6.3
Teaching Aids Centric 5.95 28.7
Any Other 4.76 7.5
Page 18 of 26
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
Prior to the pandemic, according to 76.19 percent of the pupils, the classroom environment of
the ideal English instructor should be student-centred (Ref. Table 12). During the pandemic, when
online learning was the modality of instruction, the number of students who chose “the student-
centred” choice decreased to 51.2%. There was a rapid increase in the proportion of students who
believed that the classroom should be centred on teaching aids.
7.8. Observation 7.8: Examination and evaluation

Before and during the COVID-19 pandemic, almost 30 percent of the students stated that the ideal
English teacher should administer weekly tests (Ref. Table 13). The percentage of students who
believed the ideal instructor should conduct tests whenever he/she wishes increased notably from
14.28 percent to 26.3 percent during the pandemic. In light of the adoption of online education,
these students appeared to accept teacher autonomy willingly.
88.09 percent of the students before the international health crisis and 71.3% of the
students during the crisis stated that the ideal English teacher had a serious attitude towards
the examination process; he/she adhered to all norms in spirit (Ref. Table 14). During the
COVID-19 survey, there was an abrupt increase (from 5.95 percent to 28.7 percent) in the
proportion of students who believed that the ideal instructor rigorously followed all examina
tion norms. Several students allegedly took unfair advantage of online exams by copying and
pasting answers and engaging in other unfair means. There was a shift in the perceptions of
a good number of pupils who desired the ideal teacher to be quite strict about the examination
procedure during the pandemic. 88.09 percent of the students before the pandemic and
75 percent of the students during it stated that an ideal English instructor opted for
Table 13. Tests

Percentage
Daily 4.76 1.2

Weekly 33.33 28.7
Fortnightly 14.28 6.3
Monthly 15.47 15
Quarterly 3.57 7.5
Annually 0 0
Not Regularly 13.09 13.8
Whenever the Teacher Feels Like 14.28 26.3
Never 1.19 1.2
Table 14. Attitude towards examination process

Professional Aspect → Attitude Towards Examination Process

Percentage
Very Strictly (Abiding Rules in 5.95 28.7

Letter)
Seriously (Abiding Rules in Spirit) 88.09 71.3
Leniently 4.76 0
Carelessly 1.19 0
Page 19 of 26
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
Table 15. Marking

Professional Aspect → Marking

Percentage
Strictly 5.95 8.8

Lenient 4.76 13.8
Neither Strict nor Lenient 88.09 75
On Mood 1.19 2.5
a balanced approach while evaluating; he/she is neither strict nor lenient while marking (Ref.
Table 15). The increase of almost 10% in the percentage of students who thought that the
ideal English teacher did lenient marking is notable.
8. Conclusion
While sharing their subjective views about an ideal English teacher individually, one or more
students randomly and erratically referred to the following significant/insignificant characteristics:
gender, age, dress sense, looks/physical features, sensitivity, flexibility, interactions with colleagues
and students, presence on social media, family and social background, brand consciousness,
availability outside the class, teaching skill and experience, use of mother tongue, technology
and non-verbal communication, classroom environment, attitude towards examination process
and evaluation, student-teacher relationship, reading skills, listening skills, doctorate degree, care,
fluency, expectations, knowledge, and punctuality.
Online teaching superseded face-to-face teaching and became a norm during the pandemic. The
study reveals that pandemic-stricken changes affected the students’ perceptions of an ideal English
teacher to a large extent. Before the pandemic, “having high expectations from all students” was not
a significant part of an ideal English teacher’s personality. During the pandemic, as regards classroom
environment, there was a sudden inclination towards “teaching aids” though the most favourite
option remained “student centric”; similarly, as regards teaching, there was a sudden inclination
towards “English as a language” though the most favourite option remained “English as a skill”. In
terms of test administration, there was an unexpected preference for “whenever the teacher feels like
it”, while “weekly” remained the most popular option during the pandemic. As for grading, there was
a sudden preference for the option “lenient”, while “neither strict nor lenient” remained the most
popular option during the pandemic. In the COVID-19 survey, the percentage of students who believed
the ideal teacher strictly followed exam norms jumped from 5.95 percent to 28.7 percent. During the
pandemic, the teacher’s dress sense, physical features or looks and fluency were less important; more
students expected the ideal teacher to be emotionally sensitive and flexible, maintain effective
interpersonal relationships with his/her colleagues, remain available “outside the class” virtually/
telephonically and focus on the strong relationship between the teacher and the student. When
compared with the pre-pandemic data, it was also found that more students realised the value of
their teachers’ nonverbal communication and emotional support during the pandemic. In uncertain
times, the teacher was emphatically expected to express his/her concern. The study reinforces the
idea, as in Bekereci (2017)’s study, that perceptions may change with a change in context.
Interestingly, the teacher’s interaction with the students, reading skills, listening skills, and punctuality
were considered crucial before as well as during the pandemic. Undoubtedly, a tech-savvy English
teacher is considered ideal. However, 11.3 percent of the students during the pandemic were of the
view that technology could not be a deciding factor when considering an ideal English teacher’s
professional characteristics. According to the students, the teacher’s gender, age, presence on social
media, familial and social background and brand awareness were mainly irrelevant aspects before as
well as during the pandemic. In the cases of teaching experience, knowledge about other subjects,
Page 20 of 26
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
doctorate degree, and the use of mother tongue, any sudden or important change in perception was
not noticed.
9. Suggestions for future research

Based on the case study, the following suggestions are made for future research:
9.1. Post-COVID research

The research can be expanded by collecting data from the same Department to compare and
contrast the Pre-COVID, During-COVID, and Post-COVID data. The results will help us understand
the effects of the pandemic on students’ perceptions more deeply.
9.2. Teacher training

The next phase of this research can look at the significance of the results for teacher training
programmes. It is critical to research the abilities and competencies required of an ideal English
teacher, both in regular classroom settings and in remote, hybrid, or unsettling learning situations.
This can help guide the creation of customised training programmes to provide instructors with the
skills they need to teach effectively in a variety of settings.
9.3. Cross-cultural and cross-regional investigation

A comparative investigation into the perspectives of university students from various socio-cultural
backgrounds in different geographical settings can provide significant insights for educators deal
ing with varied student groups. This research will shed light on the effect of cultural and geogra
phical characteristics on students’ opinions of an ideal English teacher.
9.4. Pedagogical strategies

It will be fascinating to explore the pedagogical strategies that might assist English teachers in
meeting students’ perceived expectations. Innovative ways should be investigated in order to
improve the learning experience and correspond with students’ changing preferences.
Acknowledgments Investigation, Resources, Data Curation, Writing—Original

The second author, Dr Nakul Kundra, collected the data in Draft, and Writing- Review and Editing. Awadhesh Kumar
2019 for his dissertation titled ‘Students’ Perception of an Shirotriya: Formal Analysis and Writing- Review.
Ideal English Teacher: A Case Study”, submitted to Indira
Gandhi National Open University (IGNOU), New Delhi, for Citation information
the partial fulfilment of M.A. in Education. He is thankful to Cite this article as: University students’ perceptions of an
his supervisor, Dr Manminder Kaur, for her consistent sup ideal English teacher before and during the COVID-19
port. Special thanks are due to all the students who parti pandemic: A study, Sakul Kundra, Nakul Kundra &
cipated in the survey(s). The data was collected at DAV
Awadhesh Kumar Shirotriya, Cogent Arts & Humanities
University, Jalandhar. However, the article was mainly
(2023), 10: 2245623.
written by the second author at the University of
Allahabad in collaboration with the co-authors from Fiji
References
National University, Fiji.
Anggraini, L. P., Ernis, E., & Jelenska, J. M. (2020).
Students’ perceptions towards ideal maritime English
Author details
teacher. Biormatika : Jurnal ilmiah fakultas keguruan
Sakul Kundra1
dan ilmu pendidikan, 16(1), 29–35. https://doi.org/10.
E-mail: dr.sakulkundra@gmail.com
35569/biormatika.v6i02.796
ORCID ID: http://orcid.org/0000-0002-8250-8021
Nakul Kundra2 Arthur, M., Gordon, C., & Butterfield, N. (2003b). Classroom
Awadhesh Kumar Shirotriya3 management: Creating positive learning environ
1
College of Humanities and Education, Fiji National ments. Thomson.
University, Lautoka, Fiji. Barnett, K. (2019). Characteristics of high quality teachers:
2
Department of English and Modern European A qualitative phenomenological study [Thesis]. East
Languages, University of Allahabad, Prayagraj, India. Tennessee State University. Digital Commons@ East
3
Department of Secondary and Sports Education, Fiji Tennessee State University.
National University, Lautoka, Fiji. Bekereci, M. (2017). DDP EFL student teachers’ perceptions
about the qualities of a professional teacher. European
Disclosure statement Journal of Language and Literature Studies, 3(3),
No potential conflict of interest was reported by the 101–108. https://doi.org/10.26417/ejls.v9i1.p101-108
author(s). Bransford, J., Brown, A., & Cocking, R. (1999). How people
learn: Brain, mind, experience, and school. National
Credit author statement Academic Press.
Sakul Kundra: Formal Analysis and Writing- Review. Casta, J., Bangasan, G. C., & Tayco, N. (2020). Qualities of
Nakul Kundra: Conceptualization, Methodology, language teachers and its implications to teacher
Page 21 of 26
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
orientation program development. Pertanika Journal teacher educators. International Journal of

of Social Science and Humanities, 28(4), 3109–3124. Innovation, Creativity & Change, 13(4), 162–180.
https://doi.org/10.47836/pjssh.28.4.34 Kozikoğlu, İ. (2017). Prospective teachers’ cognitive con
Chan, W. (2018). Teaching in higher education: Students’ structs concerning ideal teacher qualifications:
perceptions of effective teaching and good teachers. A phenomenological analysis based on repertory grid
Social Sciences and Education Research Review, 5(1), technique. International Journal of Instruction, 10
40–58. (103), 63–78. https://doi.org/10.12973/iji.2017.1035a
Chomaeva, G., & Kubanova, M. (2019). Features of stu Megawati, J. (2019). An analysis of student’s perception of
dents’ vision of teachers. Paper presentation. SHS professional teacher [Undergraduate thesis].
Web of Conferences ICTDPP-2019. https://doi.org/10. University of Muhammadiyah Malang. UMM
1051/shsconf/20197008012ICTDPP-2019 Institutional Repository.
Cochran-Smith, M., & Fries, M. K. (2001). Sticks, stones, Petrova, E. A., Akimova, N. N., Romanova, A. V., &
and ideology: The discourse of reform in teacher Sokolovskaya, I. E. (2020). High school students’
education. Educational Researcher, 30(8), 3–15. perceptions of the modern teacher image. The
https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X030008003 Education and Science Journal, 22(2), 98–120. https://
Ezkiel, I. A. (1992). Kabir the great mystic. Radha Soami doi.org/10.17853/1994-5639-2020-2-98-120
Satsang Beas. Pokhrel, S., & Chhetri, R. (2021). A literature review on
Follman, J. (1995). Elementary public school pupil rating impact of COVID-19 pandemic on teaching and
of teacher effectiveness. Child Study Journal, 25(1), learning. Higher Education for the Future, 8(1),
57–78. 133–141. https://doi.org/10.1177/
Gablinske, P. B. (2014). A case study of student and tea 2347631120983481
cher relationships and the effect on student learning Popa, M. C. (2018). In search of the ideal teacher–students of
[Thesis]. University of Rhode Island. Open Access education perception. Education and Self Development,
Dissertations. 13(3), 16–24. https://doi.org/10.26907/esd13.3.03
Ghimire, N. (2019). Five facets for effective English lan Rist, R. (1970). Student social class and teacher expecta
guage teaching. Journal of NELTA Gandaki (JoNg), 2, tions: The self-fulfilling prophecy in ghetto education.
65–73. https://doi.org/10.3126/jong.v2i0.26604 Harvard Educational Review, 40(3), 411–451. https://
Harris, C., Chester, W., & Liba, M. R. (1960). Encyclopedia of doi.org/10.17763/haer.40.3.h0m026p670k618q3
education research. McMillan. Robert, A. I., & Owan, V. J. (2019). Students’ perception of
Hien, D. T. (2020). Teacher characteristics: What do EFL teachers effectiveness and learning outcomes in
pre-service teachers expect? VNU Journal of Foreign mathematics and economics in secondary schools of
Studies, 35(6), 90–105. https://doi.org/10.25073/ Cross River state, Nigeria. International Journal of
2525-2445/vnufs.4479 Contemporary Social Science Education (IJCSSE), 2(1),
Huy, N. D. (2022). Exploring EFL undergraduates’ views of 157–165.
the impact teachers have on their online learning Roy, P., & Dasgupta, S. (2017). Ideal teacher qualities as
engagement during the COVID-19 pandemic in perceived by high-ability students from low
Vietnam. International Journal of TESOL & Education, socio-economic backgrounds: A study based in West
2(3), 75–95. https://doi.org/10.54855/ijte.22236 Bengal. Indian Educational Review, 55(2), 19–33.
Ida, Z. S. (2017). What makes a good teacher? Universal Rusua, C., Şoitub, L., & Panaite, O. (2012). The ideal tea
Journal of Educational Research, 5(1), 141–147. cher: Theoretical and investigative approach.
https://doi.org/10.13189/ujer.2017.050118 Procedia-Social & Behavioral Sciences, 33, 1017–1021.
Jannah, A. M. (2019). Students’ perception on effective ESP https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sbspro.2012.01.276
lecturers at university of Muhammadiyah Malang Saini, N., Sethi, G., & Chauhan, P. (2019). Assessing the
[Thesis]. University of Muhammadiyah Malang. UMM student’s perception on teacher’s characteristics for
Institutional Repository. effective teaching. International Journal of Nursing
Juárez-Díaz, C., & Perales, D. (2021). Language teachers’ Education, 11(1), 90–95. https://doi.org/10.5958/
emergency remote teaching experiences during the 0974-9357.2019.00028.X
COVID-19 confinement experiencias. Profile: Issues in Urazaliyeva, U. N., & Kassymova, G. M. (2018). Student’s
Teachers’ Professional Development, 23(2), 121–135. and teacher’s perceptions of an ideal English lan
https://doi.org/10.15446/profile.v23n2.90195 guage teacher at Suleyman Demirel university.
Karim, S. A. (2021). Bridging the gaps between teacher Journal of Educational Sciences, 54(1), 87–93. https://
educators and student teachers’ perceptions about doi.org/10.26577/JES-2018-1-495
the attributes of effective teacher educators. Register Yazdanipour, N., & Fakharzadeh, M. (2020). Effective lan
Journal, 14(1), 1–24. https://doi.org/10.18326/rgt. guage teachers’ characteristics as perceived by
v14i1.1-24 English language private institutes’ administrators in
Karima, S. A. (2020). Uncovering student teachers’ per Iran. The Qualitative Report, 25(8), 3111–3128.
ceptions regarding the characteristics of effective EFL https://doi.org/10.46743/2160-3715/2020.4566
Page 22 of 26
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
Appendix
Questionnaire
Students’ Perceptions of an Ideal English Teacher
Dear Student,
Thank you for your willingness to fill in this questionnaire, which is the main instrument for
collecting data regarding your perceptions of an ideal English teacher. This survey research is to
serve a dual purpose. First, the results of the research would give an opportunity to the department
teachers to introspect, retrospect, and analyse their personal, social, and professional aspects to
become better teachers. Secondly, the research work would be submitted to IGNOU in partial
fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in Education.
Kindly give honest responses. You identity would not be revealed under any circumstances.
– Dr. Nakul Kundra
Please fill in your personal details:
Name (Optional)
Registration Number (Optional)
Class and Semester:
Age:
Male or Female:
Personal & Social Aspects
1. Out of the following, who can be a better ideal English teacher?

a. Man b. Woman c. Both Man & Woman (Gender doesn’t matter.)
2. An Ideal English teacher, to your mind, belongs to the age group of ________________.
a. 20-30 years b. 31-40 years c. 41-50 years d. 51-60 years e. 61- years
f. Above 70 g. Age doesn’t matter
3. To what extent an ideal English teacher’s dress sense influence you to make an opinion about
his/her personality as a teacher?
a. Not important b. Slightly important c. Somewhat important d. Very important
e. The most important
4. To what extent an ideal English teacher’s looks/physical features influence you to make an
opinion about his/her personality as a teacher?
5. How important is it for an ideal English teacher to be emotionally sensitive?

Page 23 of 26
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
6. How important is it for an ideal English teacher to be flexible?

7. To what extent an ideal English teacher’s interactions with his/her colleagues influence you
to make an opinion about his/her personality as a teacher?
8. To what extent an ideal English teacher’s interactions with his/her students outside the
classroom influence you to make an opinion about his/her personality as a teacher?
9. To what extent an ideal English teacher’s active presence on social media sites like Facebook,
Twitter, and Instagram influence you to make an opinion about his/her personality as
a teacher?
10. How important is it for you to know about the family and social background of an Ideal
English teacher?
11. To what extent a teacher’s brand consciousness (for e.g. while using products like pen, mobile
phone, shoes, clothes, etc.) influence you to make an opinion about his/her personality as
a teacher?
12. How important is it for an ideal English teacher to be available for his/her students outside
the classroom/university?
Professional Aspects
13. How does an ideal English teacher teach English?

a. English as a Language b. English as a Subject c. English as a Skill
d. English through Literature e. __________________ (any other)
14. What should be the attitude of an ideal English teacher towards the mother tongue? He/
she should ___________ use the mother tongue to teach English.
A. Always B. Usually C. Sometimes D. Rarely E. Never
15. Classroom environment can be best classified as ____________when an ideal English tea
cher teaches.
A. Teacher Centric B. Student Centric C. Syllabus Centric D. Teaching Aids like
projector, board, chalk, etc. Centric E. Any other (______________Centric)
Page 24 of 26
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
16. An ideal English would like to conduct tests________________.

A. Daily B. Weekly c. Fortnightly d. Monthly e. Quarterly f. Annually
g. Not regularly h. Whenever the teacher feels like i. Never
17. How should an Ideal English teacher take the University examination process (which
includes invigilation duties and evaluation of answer scripts also)?
A. Very Strictly; abide by all rules in letter
B. Seriously, but may not follow all rules strictly; Uses his/her discretion sensibly and legally
(abiding rules in spirit)
C. Leniently; does not follow all rules; doesn’t mind taking illegal decisions off and on
D. Carelessly; not bothered about rules at all; highly illegal, unprofessional, and unethical
approach.
18. An ideal English teacher does _________________marking.

A. Strict B. Lenient C. Neither Strict nor lenient (objective) D. Sometimes
Strict and Sometimes Lenient; depends upon his/her mood
19. How important is it for an ideal English teacher to use technology (slides, edocuments,
smart classroom materials, etc.) in the lecture?
20. How important is it for an ideal English teacher to build strong studentteacher
relationship?
21. How important is it for an ideal English teacher to use his/her physical gestures (Not
words), i.e. non-verbal communication while communicating and teaching?
22. How important are Listening skills for an ideal English teacher?
23. How important are Reading skills for an ideal English teacher?
24. To what extent is it important for an ideal English teacher to have a doctorate degree?
25. To what extent is it important for an ideal English teacher to have teaching experience
in the past?
Page 25 of 26
https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623
26. How important is it for an ideal English teacher to show that he/she cares about his/her
students?
27. How important is it for an ideal English teacher to have high expectations from all
students?
a. Not important b. Slightly important c. Somewhat important d. Very
important
28. How important is it for an ideal English teacher to have a very high level of fluency?
important
29. How important is it for an ideal English teacher to have knowledge about other subjects
than English?
important
30. How important is it for an ideal English teacher to be punctual?

important
Page 26 of 26

University Students Perceptions of An Ideal English Teacher Before and During The COVID 19 Pandemic A Study

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

University Students Perceptions of An Ideal English Teacher Before and During The COVID 19 Pandemic A Study

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Cogent Arts & Humanities

ISSN: (Print) (Online) Journal homepage: https://www.tandfonline.com/loi/oaah20

University students’ perceptions of an ideal

Sakul Kundra, Nakul Kundra & Awadhesh Kumar Shirotriya

To link to this article: https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2023.2245623

© 2023 The Author(s). Published by Informa

Published online: 17 Aug 2023.

Submit your article to this journal

View related articles

View Crossmark data

Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at

LITERATURE, LINGUISTICS & CRITICISM | RESEARCH ARTICLE

Subjects: Languages of Asia; Language & Linguistics; Literature

Keywords: professional; social; personal; characteristics; teaching

ABOUT THE AUTHORS

2. Background to the survey study

3. Objectives of the study

5. Review of literature: An ideal second language teacher

5.1. Personal and social aspects

5.2. Professional aspects

6. Methodology of the study

6.1. Research method

6.5. Procedure of data collection

6.6. Procedure of data analysis

6.7. Ethical approval

6.8. Limitation of the study

7. Results and observations

जाति न पूछो साधु की, पूछ लीजिये ज्ञान।

Table 2. Teacher’s gender

Male (Man) 2.38 2.5

Table 3. Teacher’s age group

20–30 years 2.35 2.5

मोल करो तलवार का, पड़ा रहन दो म्यान ॥

(Ask not a saint of his caste; rather, of his knowledge.

7.2. Observation 7.2: Emotional sensitivity and flexibility

बड़ा हुआ तो क्या हुआ, जैसे पेड़ खजूर।

(So what if you are as tall as a date palm?

Emotional 2.38 5 27.38 21.3 41.66 33.8 25 31.3 3.57 8.8

7.3. Observation 7.3: Interactions, relationships, availability and expectations

पोथी पढ़ि पढ़ि जग मुआ, पंडित भया न कोय |

(Although the world reads a lot, not everyone becomes a scholar.

Judge not the servant (of the Lord) by his wealth

7.5. Observation 7.5: Technology

Presence 57.14 52.5 19.04 20 16.66 20 5.95 6.3 1.19 1.2

Use of Technology 0 11.3 19.04 15 52.38 37.5 25 27.5 3.57 8.8

7.6. Observation 7.6: Communication

काल करे सो आज कर, आज करे सो अब

(Do tomorrow’s work today and today’s work now.

Table 10. Teaching

English as a Language 1.19 16.3

Table 11. Mother tongue

Table 12. Classroom environment

Teacher Centric 7.14 6.3

7.8. Observation 7.8: Examination and evaluation

Table 13. Tests

Daily 4.76 1.2

Table 14. Attitude towards examination process

Students’ Responses in Before COVID-19 During COVID-19

Very Strictly (Abiding Rules in 5.95 28.7

Table 15. Marking

Students’ Responses in Before COVID-19 During COVID-19

Strictly 5.95 8.8

9. Suggestions for future research