Il
Books for
Emperors
he legend recounts that in the year Ab 1900 the Emperor Otto Ill, then an unbelievably rich
young man of about twenty, ordered the opening of the tomb of Charlemagne at Aachen. His great predecessor had died in
814, nearly two hundred years earlier. It is said that they found the body of Charlemagne almost intact and fully clothed,
seated on a chair, holding a sceptre and with a gold chain about his neck, and on his lap (the story claims) there was a splendid
illuminated manuscript, Otto Il removed these treasures, together
with one of Charlemagne’ teeth a4 a relic. The fact that a manu:
script wasamong the symbols of state is important in the history of
books, This was not a missionary text but part of the regalia of the
Christian emperor.
‘The manuscript from Charlemagne’'s tomb was carefully pre
served. It is traditionally identified with the so-called Vienna,
Coronation Gespels now in the Vienna Schatzkammer (PL. 33). It
Js a big square volume decorated with rather blotchy vibrant
impressionistic paintings in heavy colours, totally unlike the intsi-
ly controlled mathematical designs of the Gospel Books we
the western islands. The miniatures look more like wall
yaintings and the vellum leaves are stained in purple, The style
drives from Byzantine art and th
imately from classical antiq
tity, In faet, the Vi
“Demetrius presbyter’ in gold capitals in the outer margin of the
first page of the Gospel of St Luke, and it is not impossible that
there wore artists from Byzantium iteelf at the court of
Charlemagne. At last three other manuscripts were painted in this
Greek style in western Furope inthe late eighth or early ninth cen-
tury. They are the Xanten Gospels in. Brussels (Bibliotheque
Royale, ms. 15723), a Gospel Book in Brescia (Biblioteca Civica,
Queriniana cod. E:l.9) and the Aachen Gospels which is still in
the cathedral treasury in Charlemagne’s capital (Domnschate-
ana Gospels includes the Greek name
kammer; Pt. 45). The books were perhaps all decorated in
Aachen, or at least at the imperial court which (in its primitive
Frankish way) followed Charlemagne on his endless. journeys
around the royal residences over much of Europe. When the
emperor travelled, he was followed by imperial wagons of gold
treasure, archives, and manuscripts
Charlemagne’ empire was vast and it eventually extended from,
the pleasant villas and orange groves of southern Europe, where
‘lasical learning and literacy had never completely disappeared, so
the enormous wastelands of northern Germany, where wolves
roamed the forests and where Roman culture was symbolized only
boy the ruins of abandoned garrisons. Without doubt, Charlemagne |
himself was a quite exceptionally brilliant man, He was literate and
culure
is favourite reading (we are told) was St Augustine's
City of God, he understood some Greek; he was on intimate terms
with popes and saints; he gathored around him the most cultured
men of Europe, including Peter of Pisa, Paul the Deacon, Theedull
the
sainthood in 1165, At the same time Charlemagne was primarily a
rman of the north, His capital Aachen is in Germany today, He was
a descendant of the Frankish tribesmen who ruled by extravagant
Alisplays of miliary arms and of personal wealth, by appaling
goth, and the great Alcuin; he himself was admitted ta
double-deating and thuggery, and who regarded a kingdom as the
private property of 4 ruler who could use it entirely aceordingto-whim, The ancient tribal leaders had held together their precar
ious kingdoms by military retinues whom they rewarded seth gold
and seth the spoils of war. Charlemagne, for all his elegant clas
nner parties, was above all a Germanic military leader at his
access in warfare is literally legendary
farlemagne’s cwn ancestors acquired the Meri
wn king
dom by ouumanneustiny 19. From the early seventh cen
mp
tury they had been officials in the houshold af the Frankish ki
The family became mayors of the royal palace, and effective poiver
was setzedl hy Charles Martel in the 720s, fn 751 his som Pepin the
Short managed to gst himself anointed king by. $1 Be an in
754. after skillal diplomatic appeals,
ope Stephen IL etussed the
Alps and at the abbey of St Denis erowned Pepin and consecrated
hrm ane his two sons, Chaeles (the future Charlemagne, then aged
shout ten) and Carloman, Pepin died in 768 and Carloman in 774,
Jeaving Charlemagne as sale king of the Franks,
One of the first really great manuser
alee! Maurteamnus
Charlemagae’s
Bible, a huge b
Bibliothéque Municipale in. Amiens (as, 6-7, 94 44-12) an the
lumes now divided hetwoen the
Bibliothisgue Nationale i Paris (ms, lt, 14474). He way made at
i 4
Abbey. near An
«during the abbacy of Mauntramnus
(772-41), I is monumental volume intended for display at
‘of the greatest cighth-cntury monasteries, and it i sometimes
suggested that a preject of this size and expense would have need
1 the patronage of the royal treasury. The Mauriramos Whe
comprises the Old Testament only, and it if the Old ‘Testament
that contains the politically: appropriate themes of the eleetion of
of authority by
kings, maintenan the anointing of kings
by patriarchs to confer legitimacy on their titles, and the vision of
fection of Gd. These
tribal society invincible under the special pr
were favourite subjects for the Carolin
an propagandists of the
King David's seizure of power aver the Israelites mast hive
been comforting to Charlemagne. There is nio doubt that be
lentiied himself with the Old Testament king
wl_psalrist
Charlemagne’s companions had! a kind of private joke among
themselves in which they pretended! to be their heroes fron class
gilbert.
eet w
cal antiquity: Alcuin was “Placcus’ (that is, Horac
abbot of S-Rigutirwas:‘Eonsee’ Charleneagysc
‘Julius’, but Charlemagne himself, to his friewls, was. “King
David!
became known, One enchantin
the nickname
Aleuin called him David in publi
carly Carolingian manuseript is a
little Paaltor written out at the anlor af Charlomagose himself fer
presentation to Pope Hhidrian 1 (773-95). The book is now in
Viera (Osterreichische Nationalbibliothek, Cod 1861, pt. 34) ft
te lecication (Fol. 4, written inv yok and
saying that the psalms are the golden words of King Davie andl that
Charl
politeness in Chi
ne is his golden successor, There is as much politics as
lemagne choosing this value for the papacy, of6
at least, at ho fad onder I (for there Ww no
ving i kaa
‘evidence that it actually left Germany), and Charlemagne ruthless:
|y manipulated papal support for himself, his kingdom, and (after
feter's on Christinas Day 800) for the new
by
the scribe Dagulf (fol. 48). The name appears in several contempa:
his coronation in St
Holy Roman Empire. The Baker for Pope Hadrian i 5
rary documents; in a letter of Alcuin written between 789 and 796
he i called "Dagalfus serinarius’, which means a kind of archivist
He was in the royal household. The book beautifally decorated
with majestic initials and headings in gold and silver, often on pur
pple grounds (the imperial colour, deliberately chosen), ani the
script by Dagulf an elegant minuscule
This introduces a fundamental theine bs Carolinglan hook pri
duction the refortn of handwriting an! the adoption of minuscule
script, Historians of manuscripts: love to argue endlessly over
‘exactly how and why this eecurred, There had been many kinds of
script ned for writing books in Merovingian France, derived from
various forms of Roman writing, Sometimes these were so bizarre
that one can localize cighth-century manuscripts fairly closely from
the use of + local script such as the ‘Corbie a/b" senpt or the
“Laxeuil minuscule’, which were employed in particule monas
teries and thelr surrounding regions, ny keeping with
Clarlemagne’s carefully planned campaign to reform education,
grammar, and hurgy
fa new ani very simple script was intro:
duced with extreme efficiency and in all parts of the Carolingian
luqninions. It is known ay Caralinglan (or Caroline) minuscule. It
fs small and very rourd and has tall yertial ascenders and descen:
dlers, and was compact and no doubt quick tw write and cary to
road, and it was phenomenally successful, Vitwally all Carolingian
manuscripts were written ia this famous minuscule
At the risk of anticipating chapter 8, »
‘an glance ahead and
fowesce that the majority of manuscripts of clasical texts that were
rediscovered by the humanists in the fifteenth century” were
Carolingian in date and therefore in this writing. The humanists
wrongly convinced themselves that these represented original
Reman manuscripts, They began to imitate Carolingian minuscule,
abundoning the Gothie seript of the period. At that time (and we
are stll looking ahead by seven hundred years) the art of printing
vas introduced into Haly, ad the frst Halian printers abo adopted
this nest round writing: i was called ‘Roman’ type, Prin
ing had
the remarkable effect of stabilizing letter forms and they have
remained substantially unchanged ever since, We still use
Charl
nagne’s script It bs probably the most ong-lasting achieve
ot of Carolingian ciilization, Through a mistake in the dating of
‘eighth: and ninth-century manuscripts, Carolingian minuscule is
used (for example) fot the printing of this book.
The manuscript usually regarded as the first to contain the new
Carolingian minuscule writing is the Gorlescale Evangelistary, ax it
is called, a Gospel Book which is now Paris, B.N., ms. nowy. 364,
Tat, 1203 (re. 47). ML was commissioned by Charlemagne and his
16 to
ame, Bone Aptis
akan Pa 5,0
‘or, psy i Aac ,
ce
rath grat
tiga aah he
pel ental th
Mey et aa
Inthe hcl
17 Or
ot 1056
The aque er howequeen Hildegard on 7 October 781 and completed on yo April
73, Te was written by the seribe Godescale and (a the dedication
verses explain) commemorates Charlemagne’s fourteenth anniver
sary as king of the Franks and the optisa of his son Pepin by Pops
Hidrian in Rome, One suspects Charlemagne was especially protal
‘of this baptism: the manuscript incliaes a miniature of the
Fountain of Life which may reflect the haptitery of the Lateran
church in Rome, and thus this ria
Godessale Ev
Dagulf Paaher. They hoth belamg toa whole group of closely relat
centered Carolingian art. The
listary i illuminated in the same style a¥ the
ced ceremonial manuscripts usually known as the Ada’ group of
books because one of thera (now Trier, Stadibliothek, Col. 22)
includes a dedication
Ada, the servant of God, who ig sid to
have been Charlmagne’s sister. Some leaves of” Ada's bok socen
tobe inthe hand of Godescale aso, Other manuscripts in thie style
include the Si-Rigquier Gospels (Abbeville, Bliotheque
Municipale, ms. 4) which was apparently given by Charlemagne to
Angilbert, abbot of St-Riguier (790-814), the so-called Golden
Gospels of Charlemagne from the abbey of St-Martin-des- Champs
ly Paris (bliothéaque cle "Arsenal, Paris, 1m. 599), the Harley
Golden Gospels (B.L., Harley ts 2788), the Lorsch Gospels
(civided between the Vatican Library, ws. Pal lat 52
1. 36
and the brary in Alba Julia in Romania), and the StMédard
Gonpels Paris, BLN., mis. lat_ 869) which was wise by Louis the
Plous in 827 to Angilbert, abbot of St-Médard in Soissons
These are all extremely grand manuscripts, Some of dhe inter
laced initials refleet Celtic styles, but the whole appearance of
these books is Mediterranean, with medallions fike Roman coins
and with classical pediments andl marbled columns. Most of thera
are at least in part written in gold script on a purple-coloured
ground, a device which (as Charlemagne’s scztbes certainly knew)
wont back to imperial antiquity, It ix a very distinctive feature
Suetonius mentions « poem by Nero which had heen written ia
have hall « Ho
in is prologue to the
‘geld; the emperor Maxieninam (235-8) fe
written in gold en purple vellum; St Jere
Book of Job eritcizes those wh lke
old or ailver on purple leaves, It isa practice which probably sur
niient hooks writen out in
vived into Charlemagae's time theoygh is use in) Constantinople
One cat understand how important it was to Charlemagne, who
.was rebuilding his dominions ox the model of classical antiquity, to
propagate the image of the cultured emperor, and displays of
beoks were (and are) amang the accepted trappings of the cul:
tured, Manuscripts written in gold on purple had a promotional
value in symbolizing imperial culture. That is une reason why
these spectacular manuscripts were made for distribution by
(Charlemagne's family to communities in his Christian empire, asi
was call
There may be a cruder, more harharian, reason too. These
beoks are heavy in gold. This was really quite a new development
in Frankish manuscript production. Charlemagne’. aks. look
2 ie le
a LIBER
DEDIVERSSO\WE
LINNEESEMRESEN
'SIONIBSSVSOEM
CARIVSTRANSEBE
REEAAVTENTIERE
TRIAREHIDEALONT
Abe. at igeapensive. ‘The odescale Evangelistary
Iegin with the word “gold” (Aurea purpureis pinguntur =.)
Those in the Dagull Psalter start “Aurea daviticos ...: the text is
ot nly, goklen but the volume isto be interpreted ax comprising
‘geld. Ik was the ancient Germanic custom for tribal leaders to
foward thei retinues in gold. Charlemagne regularly summoned
Ii secular armies and in return for military serve he gave lady
Bed boty. The soldiers und
et
were rewarded for spiritual servic
primitive sense, a Frankish pi
were gold
Charlemagne him scems 16 have add a personal interest in
manuscripts, if one can judge from remarks by his biographer
Enhard, who mentions a great quantity of books that he had ea:
Heated n in tibeary, oF tron the observation that be liked o read
ood this, But the cohorts of rel
monks of Corbie, Larsch, and other imperil abbeys
ye way. ty the most
ed gold, ane books
SiAngustine, hisories, ani tales of the ancients, One fragmentary
Tray catalogue survives from about 790 and it was at one time
supposed that it might recor part of the holdings of Corie Abbey
Werlin, Sunsbiblionick Preacher Kulturbeite, ss. Dice
BSmnt.o6, fol Hi i
demonstrated that it i very probably a list of the texts
2181). However, the late Professor Bernhy
gto the private library of the evurt of Charlemagne, It is
Vnpressive roll-cll of clasical works, i books by
Status, Terence, Juvenal, Tibullus, Herace, Claudia,
Servius, Cicero, and Ssllust, The Tibullusis expecially tan
j a8 the earliest known surviving manuscript is no older
File tcatises on La
an eghers — and one «an imagine Chatlemagne reading
grammar — works by. Donatus,
furtively gleaing hooks of tiquet
grammatical manuscript probably from the court srip
‘of around the year Soe (Brusels, Bibliothéque Royale, ms
recording that the lord King Charles commanded 419 be
cL from the original hook hy Peter the Archdeacem (nt
“We are told Charlemagne was so anxious to lear to, write
sept wi g materials under his pillow. fis rather
10 catch these glimpses ofthe great king trying Wo keep up
eral renewal that he had initiated, and perhaps he was
10 practise the new minuscule in the middle of the night
eof 789 commanding liturgical reform ordered that only
Sif the work bs 4 Gospel Rook, Patter, or Misa,
el be ofthe pert age for writing diligently
‘of Chatlemagne’s promotion of education and hook learn
‘the importation of the work's most dstinguished
Erte his era, One of those eae Alcuin (-735-Mo4), whe
‘horn at York in England and who was related 10 St
PNCIPIT
‘ EPISTOLA
2
at ee
. XPMiacares
ice:
Pores
carr
ANTE pa
Pe ieee!
P Retin pean idefiteome — '
quar fixeeu Benen termine chanted Bexsectoem
caurnern quidlertneres filaarivncur
Se ee
none marmucrum thinepidedinerr pe
eed ee pie aco
mal Pe cerelcane
oe ae
ca eee
dif Hlectiivocxar ifs Greens cisbir expe
Fo prrodmmubuCuobireurc
Ffderor! See e eee
sete Grin fGen
sti filed ve ven Hamer
|, [ite ano ephemeris Aaqu
malate pres fri
imuat neepere dT uensierelicad uor; Der dermensse ¥,
fren Pulao maakt |
Fprerndaecoou firmadot act ie frmat con
Stee och firth emenetiennte
39 Awe
Malibe) Pat Ge Munum,
i sh cin, et ace
ce the grat conte ate pr
taacrph ble ih bore
anu, eiten
rckling at th aes
Mavi re, Top
loge Flew the Roma ”io
Willibcord, th
cathedral school in York when, during an embassy to Ray i 785,
the met Charlemagne, sho temptes him with two great abbacies
and persuaded hin to come tw France. For upwards of te
missionary bishop, He was already head of the
Alewin thew directed and inspired the revival of classical culture
around the figure of Charlemagne. In 796 he retired to Tours,
where he became abbot of St Martin's Abbey, and set in motion
there a campaign of manascript production which lasted f
the ninth century and made Tours the wo
for Carolingian minuscule seript (HL. y
The making of 0
ninth century slipped effectively from the court seriptorium i
the great royal monasteries such as Chelles and St-Den
Paris, and Hleury, Rheims, Tours, Lorsch, St Médarel at Soissons,
and clewhere, The finest manuscripts were expensive and richly
ld centre for Bibles ane
nuseripts in the Frankish empire in the
decorated, The best-known centre for book production in the
carly ninth century is Rheims, where manuscripts of really impeti-
al quality were mate ithe time of Ebbo, who had been
CCharlemagne's librasian and ocho sea appointed archbishop. of
Rheims in 816. The most extraordinary of the surviving Rheims
manuscripts is the famous Utrecht Puaker which 6 dust
‘throughout with incredibly lively, vigorous, sketchy Httledrassings
(71-40). The:style seems to point straight back tthe esi
Byzantine art-which the: court artots at Amchon intenaduced fi
Charlermgne’s vin books. One early ninth-contury mari
fromthe any of SDs can be prt dc Fo a a
fea htc, Pari Ns I 2195 3 omy “
Camisdoror's commersary on the Bans made at S-Di
style associated with Abbot Fardulphas (79-86), One of is big
inal includes several in ers an a suprisingly sete
rate sketch ofthe heal of an fan 41-2), Meshes
arias knew about ivary but net many had sen clephants. Thi
iuminator probably know the elephant which wis presented ta
Charlemagne by caliph Haroun-al-Rashid inthe year No2,‘The ees
phant’s same was Abulabar and it lived until $2, Therefore the
Cassiodoras manuscript cannot be earlier thay Sox. For all we
phant (v
know, Abulabsi's tusks survive in some of the magnificent
Canulingian ivory book-covers whieh decorated the grandest
Gospel Hooks (et. 44)
Charlemagne died at Aachen on 28 January 814. Among various
gous 448 Opp
Usrect, ibotheader Par, iblehegue Nationale,
ikemnern, ot Cod MS. Bn 295. deta of
henoraicainae, Ne
LN TLE Cet min Bren ho,
Te Ue Per wat ion ey. nae a
bulb wl acid ch tr
a One il nui
Cairn rit 3 Dee
tcp, len orate we) tbe tt rc of hh cary
wth ie dc ema a
ks eps hed, pera he ait
ata in i tre #6
tnd oe oe oe
oltieg al Cavin mut
Sout th ya oe ad
ect rag Cantrary ho
(Con mach al ap ae
Aer many slots a
ee yey Unc
i rps sipped backs
Fae Mega nner
uh This lpn nt Fat
io Cals al, Town,
{848 oe 48), te
tase keer ath tan
st nd execs The ae
Far dey, erry mas yeFraquests he directed that three-quarters of the gold and sikver in
Dis treasury should be distributed among the twenty-0
polit churches of the empire and (probably: the tit time that
Canyon lei this inasruction) hat his Hbrary
ould Ie sel and
proceeds given to the needy, This conirims again that it was part of
the anvibutes of a Frankish ruler to distribute treasure, and
Bers at books hint « monceary value, Chirlemagie’s copy of
‘Claudia came to Gembloux Abbey, only about 65 miles fro
Aachen. His Livy travell further into the Frankish empire and
“a probably at Cothic and ln at Tours. Charlemagne"s unig:
Tabu may han
Tiieice perhaps to Orléans, The dispersal of his Hora after 81
Fedhoes Charemagne's lack of any provision for keeping his emp:
tics his death, 1c wan src
Malet empire be subdivided among his bs, aul
sida ago ard
ary later
The cusom of commisioning teasice manus
fond ite way 10 Fleury Abbey’ on the Lescol
{4 bartarian anda poltsian
way subst
fon their deaths, unc it was aneecognizable a
some of Charlemagne’s descendants, His illegitimate son
bishop of Metz 826-55, owncil at least two Gospel Books
written entirely in gold Paris, B.N ‘1
the amazing Drago Socramentary (ms. lat. 4428) which has 41
tins. at. 94 and 9388)
huge historiatel initials of classical foliage filled with lusting hile
Figure of
dct. The nearest, bowerer, boa palace rch
book prostuction was that of Charles the Bald (et, 42, grandson of
Charlemagne and son af Louis the Pious, who, after fines warfare
wwii hall-brother
held he Kingdon’ of the western Franks
from the treaty of Verdun in 841 and finally obsained th
crown in #75, dying less than two years later, His life rellects the
same kind of desperate tribal struggle for leadership. which marked
the We find
ae duitined aspect of the’ Covollgian ty Faiily
CChailes the Bald preparing treasure manuscripts for his ecclesia
cal vasa, like an old chieftain distributing gold bullion,
The. grand mani toned re toe wa Chars
Bald include a praverchook (now inthe Munich Schatekamner)
and a Plter (now Paris, BN., ms. bt. 1152), both date to
before #69, and probably the famons Bible of Sin Paolo fuor te
‘Mura (which belongs now to the abbey of that name ia Rome, ws
1.339).
aby 14% incloes (445 by 963
ssive manuscript with 336 leaves about
num, Ie hay 24 Full-page paincingss4
at least seven of them include scenes showing biblical kings. The
figure of Solomon looks remarkably like Charles the Bald himself.
‘The manuserpt concludes with a portatt of Churley enthroned as
ing, holding in hie ltt hana golden diseinseibed with a
gram i red which has been interpreted as "Charles king [and] cae
nar, save Charles ane Richilis, this fs] king Solomon of the new
Rom Richie
fon 23 January 87
Rat this spectacal
Probably Je commemorates Charles's marriage
manuscripts ectipsed by an even richer vol
tame, made for the treasury of Charles the Bald, Hts the Cealex
Aureus (or Book of Gold
the ane iv a valid one) of St
Emmeram, now Munich, Bayerische Staatsiblinthck, Cin. 13000
(e145). This
good fortune}
a volume of pheromesal luxury, stil (by extreme
wits origins goldon hinting profusely encrusted
with jewels and pearls and gold repousst: pictures, If Charles the
Bald identified himself with Soloman, he must have known the text
(oF | Ringe 0321-2 describing Solomen's work on
temple at
Jerasalera: ‘So Solomon overlaid the house within wth pure gold
And the whole house he overlaid with gold, until he ha finished
all the tase
(Charlo the Bild on jowelstudda
(On fol, $y of the Codex Aureus 2 portrait of
oie witha a dor
ed temple
‘with angels and the hare of God above, On either sde are armed
ers and allegorical figures, representing Francia amit Gotica,
OF the page sre: gold
rich king as Charles, son of Louis,
1 Charlemagne, David (calls hin) and
book
alter page of paintings, can tables, and huge decorated initials all
brilliantly itluminated, Charles himself presumably: provided the
and on panic along the top and batten
inseriptions demtfsing thi
fh
Loman, by whase
snes with gold, ‘The manuscript has page
{gold for the artists, sho may have ben working in the abbey of
St-Denia, which the king retained as his din ponseiafon afte the
death of on 67, The Cokes Aurea iy signed by
the scribes Beringer and Luthard andl dated Ago, There fa on
of is abbots in
temporary reference t» Charley the Bald’s manuscripts kept
his treasury. Certainly the Codex Aurcus of St Faameram was
For daily use, but was a dazaling display of the King’s fica assets
[After the death Charles the Bald in 877,
his listant cousin King Areulf of Mararia who, soon aloe 89),
it on to the abbey of St Emmeram ia Regensburg, Thus i
sas finaly received a8
team into the hana
P
rare eames rom the monastery whe
royal gif
We gain some idea that rich ma
weripts ad a realizable
financial value in the nigth century from references to thefts of such
books. & Psalter written in golel writ and with a treasure binding
cconered with pearls wae given hy. Lonie the Pious (80) to the
abbey of St Hubert near Liége; the eronidle ofthe abbey reeves
tha Ue book was stolen and was soll by the thieves to a woman in
‘Tonal, ner a hundevd rales to the sovth, Lupais of Rerrgres, sit
ing tw Hincmar, archbishop of Rheims, in 858, regretted that he
had heen unable to send great manuscript of Bede and Augustine
for fear of losing i to robbers om the journey who would, he
certainly be attracted by the beanty ofthe book
“The tremendous monetary value of imperial mane
worked both ways. A ing both received manuscripts and presen
cal the. A secular ler might give 2 luxury manusenpt to
return for prayers fr his salvation, Tis would
or bath
ties, A monastery might make and offer a supreme manuscript ta
ing, a hope for patronage in return, This was certainly not
monastery
sown as 4 vory soriate exchange, nesleulably valuable
a one shed payment eb, The use of manips sek
tntie transactions undeetines for us the vale place! at hat tha
‘om books, which we an understand today looking at th 4d
sulded volumes theses, but i also roids ws that p
llr bya monastery or military protection offered by an cmp
‘or were worth evvey penay of the investinnt i a aha be
A youl example of an alliance Betwexn emperor ani monastery i
the abbey at Tours, We mentioned eather that Charlemag
auhiser Alen ho retird t the monastery ofS Martin at Te
ore-a great programme of manescript production hud been se
motion by Alen and bis successors, Fridugisus (804.
Adilhar (334-43), and Visian (843-51). These abbots were raya
appoiintnients: Adalhard had been sesieschal to Lonis the Pk,
Vivian was a count and cout oficial of Charley the ald
Manoscripts produced under royal patronage at Tours
exported fron there all over the Carolingian kingdoms, Prot
tose of then were presented to Lothair (855), hall brother
Charles the fall and king of the Nallan part of Charkamagoe’s
‘empire, These area Gospel Book Paris, BIN. ms, lat, 266) ao
Poster (BLL, Ad, 5. 47768). EAR, Rate, the historian of th
scriptorium of Tours, described the former as ‘Perfected, ‘he
pls ulns of excellence. The unsurpisied model of perfection i
script and omamint arsong the looks of Tours.” The monks we
determined to impress King Lothar.
A becter-kanwn presentation from Tours i: the famous
File of Charles the Bak, sometimes cad the Vivian Bible:
now’ has the first shelfinark in the Biblothique Nationa in
(on, at 54s 465 etal, wt. 42). ‘The manuscript was vom
sional hy the abbot te present to the king in e836. 1 ope
an unusisl miniatare i thee horizontal rows showing scenes i
the life of St Jerome, transtor of the Latin Bible. In the centre
Jerome dictating 19 2 group of scribes and at the bottom Je
disrihutes copies of his new tratsation, This probably has an alles
govical allusion to Alcuin correcting the text of the Bible and hav=
Jing copes male and dsserainated from is abbey sm Tours
worth looking closely atthe boxes from which St Jerome i shown
handing. oot mananeripts: they are typical treasure chests, with
‘wonder bands and massive metal locks. Books were equated with
Word of Geal with treasure. The respi
nto ical
ents are shown fartively hurrying away with the luxury gis, The
sociation betyverh the manuscript and secular eal i elestehin in is dedicatory verses which are illustrated with to imper-
one inscribed “David rex imperator’ and the other
‘6x Francorum’. Thus the hiblical King David is linked
‘Charles, king of the Franks. ft is important that this is repre=
‘by gol coins, ‘That is how many would have understood
cof the Bible. In the Gespels, when Christ was shown an
ol, asked whose portrait and inscription it bore, and
ical and armed soldiers Fingering their weapens. From
tadelegation of nervous monks bring in the huge Bible part
ein white cloth, and the king holds cat his right hand to
auton wo his treasury.
es the Bald ded in #77, while marching across the Alps in
seemingly endless Carolingian dynastic feuds, this time
loman, king of Bavaria and Italy and great-grandson of
1 Te was, in fact, Carloman'e aon and heir, Arnulf,
the Colex Aureus of St Emmeram and pethaps
(eho ded in 9 18) nominated
hocomes clear again, Historians grasp will
from the hibrary of Clurles the Bald, Arwuf's
I, hing of Ube Frauke ors, was the last
cernlant of Charlemagne to rule the German part of his
i great-grandfather's vast empire, When Louis the Child
issue, Conrad, duke of Franconia, was elect! king,
Rovwlae a i
This seals complicate, an indeed the thread of
from Charlemagne is remarkably fragile and one gener:
another wb great rapidity, Heney the Foster's
“Finperor Otto the Great, Now at last the tine of suc
‘ognize Figure and cll this the 'Ottonian” age. The tenth century
was certainly a great period in imperil hstory. It brought the
rarest possible revival of the golden days of Charlemagne, with
fervour of politcal snd rcligicus reform, ard iti often krown as
the Oxtonian renaissince. Italo predluced a great many illuminat-
cof manuscripts.
‘Ovio the Great was anointed king in 936 in Charlemagne’s palce
lapel at Aachen. After a turbulent rnlitary life and careful mar
tiages, he brought great portions of Germany and Italy under his
‘control, Even the pope eventually became his vassal, a shrewd polit
teal move whieh die) uch to sta
crowned emperor in Rome on 2 February 962. He lived until 973,
As Otto the Great consolidated bis position and began to merge
the state and Church into a powerful new administrtion, so the
Ottonians Looked back wistfully at the eultiva
lige imperial power. Otto was
empire of the
past, Bruno (925-65), Otto’s hreiher, was appointed royal chan-
cellor, archchuplain, and later archbishop of Cologne, and
Inspired a renewed snterest in classical texts (he had learnest Greek
from the monks of Reichenau) and in grammar, thetoric, x
try, music, astronomy, commerce, and the other refinements of
civilization, Education again became a royal priority, There is an
sccount in Ekkchanl!s chronicle of the abbey of St Gall in
Switzerlan ofa visi to that monastery in the year 972 by Otto the
Great with his son (the future Ott Hi, then aged about 17). They
spent several diys there. The boy discovered a locked! chest in the
rmonstic treasury and demanded that it he opened for him. It
proved to be full of manuscripts, Young Otto helped himself tothe
best, as the monks stood by, unable to refuse, Later (ollowing a
diplomatic request from the monastery) some of the books were
returned, but one which was never sent back was probably
‘aalter (now in the Staatliche Bibliothek in Bamberg) with paralleltexts in two versions of Latin and in Hebrew and Greek, which
hd been made for Salomo Ill, abbot of St Gall, in gag. It says
something about Ottonian court edication thit a Germanic prince
al be
In the same year that they visited St Gall, Ost the Great
arranged a marriage for his son. It was a political triumph, The
bride was Theofanu, a princess of Byzantium, Throughout the
‘whole Carolingian and Ontonian period, the Byzantine empire was
regarded as the ultimate symbol of sophistication, and for a daugh
ter of the easter imperial house to marry the heir apparent of the
German rile cotiferred imei prestige of the: went: (Hot the
poor girl felt in northem Europe, twelve hundred miles from
home, would not have been considered.) The original marrage
charter of Theofana and Otto still survives, and it displayed
ina ypecil room in the state archives: of Lower Saxony in
Wolfenbittel, This document of 14 April 972 isan ultimate impe
ral manuscript, a huge scroll written in gold in uncial and minus
cule on purple vellum and decorated with great medallions of clas
sical and mythological designs of animals infiled with ornamental
scrollwork. It is a magnificent object. At last the tribal rulers of
Europe glimpsed their own names in an inkeritance which qwent
tmack to the Ermperor Augustus,
Quo Il succeeded to the Holy Roman Empire in May 975, but
‘he lived for only another ten years. He died i Rome and is buried
in the ceypt of St Peter's. The revival of manuscript illumination in
is reign ie partly due to Eigb pointed to the arch
bishopric of Trier in 977 and was both a churchman and a member
of the imperial chancery. A contemporary account of the transl
tion of the relics of saint in Trier in the time of Egbert deseribes
the archbihop's pencesdén, ‘with cross, candles, thiribles,
Gospel Books set with gems, and erery Kind of ecclessstical beau
ty’, The archbishop owned a Gospel Lectionary, now called the
Codex Egberti (Tries, Stadtbibliotbek, Cod, 24), which is signed
by two monks Kerald and Heribert of Reichenau Abbey, the
wealthy islind monastery on Lake Constance, The book has 51
largo illustrations, by far the mast extensive cycle of pictures of the
Me of Christ in any known manuicript up to thie date. The vol
tume’s lavish binding of gold and enamels survived until the eigh
teenth century. Egbert ako almost certainly employed one of the
very greatest medieval ilaminators, the Master of the Rey
Gregerit, sha was probably working at Trier from about 98 until
atleast 996. About half a dozen surviving manuscripts were paint
co refurbished! by this artist. One of them, a Gospel Book data
be to before the death of Ott Il, was given four hundred yearn
later hy the king of France to the Sainte-Chapelle in Paris (Paris,
BIN,, ms, lat. 4851), The same artist also. painted two detached
rminiatures, one still in Trier (Pt. 48) and the other navy in the
Musée Condé at Ch
Re "
Trier Cathedral. The survivin
tilly (et. 47). from a volume of the
jsteurn Gr we 10
i hence the artist's name) which Eghert
fragment includes a poemwailing the death of Ono tin 984, and the Chantilly miniature
of a crowned emperor with his staff and arb no doubt commen
rates Hgbert’s ate patron. It shows Otta enthroned under a tiled
by claesical columns, and from either side he
receives. gifts of homage fram perscnfications of Germania
Francia, Halia, and Alamannia. It js
marvellous image
1 was under Ouse I, emperor from 98 until his early death in
002, that the Ottonian passion far books reaches! its high point
There survives in Bamberg a list of manescripts which Otto IIE was
given by Johannes Philagathos, his former tutor whort The
had made bishop of Pacenza, probubly befur
a Persius, andl other texts. This wax
We be
pening the tomb of Chatlem
copies of Orosius, two of Livy
2 good nucleus of a classical Hbrary
iH
fining a Gospel Book among the imperial regalia, Otte fl consid
cred himself doubly imperial, both through his Byzantine: mother
and his German father, He was ext
igh to be amet bliphemonsly arrogant (he was less
than five wher his father ded, and will only cleven an the death of
his mother Theofanu in 991). Unlimited wealth is not good far
Young men. In 496 be promoted Bruno, his twenty-nine-yearvokl
‘cousin, to the papacy; Bruno took the ttle of Gregory Vy the first
German pope, and then promptly crowned Otto Ill as emperor
The new pope himself ordered manuscripts to be sent to Rome
from Reichenau for the confirmation of his avn insallayon as
pope, He the monastery should deve
teste that the abbot
,
tw him a Sacramentary, an Epistolary and a Gospel Book, and they
were doubtless very splendid. When Gregory died three. years
later in 999, Quo installed ay the next po
Gerbert of Aurillac, who asumed the name of Sylvester I. Even
the popes were under the power of Otto I. tn his manuscripts the
emperor was represented almost on a level sith God hinwelf
made at about the tla of the
pe Bock rent An
inperial corenatica in 996, shows the emperor seated within a
randdorls in heaven with his arms outspread like Christin. glory
and with the emblems of the four Evangelists hovering on either
side of him. tis amazing that a monk could paint
er
Anwther Gospel Book in the John Relands University Library in
Manchester includes Ono's portrait four times on the first page of
St Matthew's Gospel (48. lat. 9
name of Otto, emperor of the Christian religion andl of the Roman
people. This lumination occurs on the page which recounts the
‘descent of Christ from David and Abraham. It too is painted by the
Master ofthe Registrum Gregori the
lst manuscript ofall s the extraordinary Gospel of
‘Otto HL in Munich (Bayerische Staatdbibliothek, Chm, 4453). tn
moder monetary terms this must he a eandiate for the most
valtable book in the world (ris, 49-59). It was made for Otta
probably at Reichenaw around 99-1061, abwook fora millennium:
It isin its original golden binding set with jewels anel with a teathHAPTER 1 century Byzantine ivory panel (et. 32). IE was a mageificent and a
oxs VO — sacred manuscript, whether open or closed, Inside it is of supreme
pmrusons imperial luxury with full-page illuminated initials, Exangelst
rrsita, 29 fall-page miniatures From ue fe of Chewt, and
dominating all these, it has-@ pair of facing paintings showing the
people of the world adoring Otto I. The worshippers resemble
the Mi
erage 10 the dnlant Chris. They are four
women bearing gold and jewels and their names are serition
above in capitals: Sclavinia, the eastern European with dark rod
hair, Germania, a fairskinnet girl with long wispy blonde hair,
Gallia, the blade-haired French gir, and the curly-headed Roma,
wha is bowing lowest of all before the ruler off the exmpine. Otto
himself is shown on the opposite page, seated disdainfully on his
majestic throne, flanked by twe priests with b
fern by tienen
identified as Heribert, chancellor af taly (d.1671), and Len, ii
bishop of Verve (d.c.1026) and by two armed soldiers, one
them perhaps Gerard, count of the Sabine, the guard ofthe opal
se (4), Otto tt fad Dui
in Rowe. His brary included (amaringly) a ifth-century am
script of Lisy’s history of Rome
probably ane of the wo copia
i he
free johannes Phil
had made sill survives. in Bamber ha the
Renovatio Inperit Romanarum, the restoration of the empire dl
the
mans. He thought himself at least as great ae. Cue
It is interesting to try to compare the Ottonian imperial man
all
Sometimes it is quite clear thatthe later illuminators were actuallyfs, Arpo and Acalpertus,
B Frontispiece illustrating the Ottorian ah
261), The the enporor Henry I had the v
rite
eh, yer Staaten
Fae B xr wl
hore remarkable is the use mate of the Codex
role bs the
1 archbishoy
BR rset} Seecribe this famowe nih-cots
{which inthe Ottoman period belonged to the abbey
GiRegerwbang (in, 45). First of al, two monks at S
4 and died in 1024. H
FF the Conlex: Aureus of St Emmeram was painted no
and it still survives: in Man
at Mass, and pthreligious solemnity and of themselves as high priests and mighty
kings. Henry It was proud 10 be depicted in a Missal; Charlemagne
vould probably have been rather frigitened
Another difference between manuscript production of the
Carolingians and of the Ottonians is that there seems to have been
to court schoo! of Mumiation under the Ottonian emperors
Charlemagne employed scribes and artists i his household, Ort
re
Henry I sent out to the monasteries, They chiefly used
Trier, and then very probably Reichenau (mts. 52, 55 amd 56), and
later Regensburg and Eehternadh, O1to ll owned some older man
scripts which had come from taly (such as bis minhentury We
‘of St Sylvester illuminated at Nonatela), but the Ottanians sect to
have commissioned
manuscripts there, Their use of monasteries
doesnt siecessarily mean that the artists were always monks, but
53 hale
Univreatoee,
‘sacha Me. The psi
shoe the wn tg pone
hoe hese, Ie te ha
mo Pea i res lite
Crivend
54 Orie
pec i 57
ey he pis i ea he
Lani rp oa ah
ewe he re re Hey
arg one th Ging oak
seh goed coats
that they worked within a monastic context. A Gospel Lectionary
now in Bremen actually illestrates this happening (Staats. ut
Universtatsbibliothiek, af, 24, fs, 1248-125; Pte 5H shoe
1 Echternadh Abbey, and busy working an the mand:
a layinan andl the other a monk, and oi
book to Heney I
scripts are two men,
the facing page they are shown presenting the
in about 1 59-40.
Honey HQ. 54) had a particular reason for: wanting: mam
scripts, Unlike other emperars, who probably built up brary
mainly because books wore treasure axl partly because they ct
Henry M1 plined ter set-up a
religious Joundstion at Bamberg avd to furnish i with manaseript
whic fe hae collected. He declared in 1003 that ashe himself tad
fo children be had chosen Christ as his heir. Hie dies not quite66
ame Christ as his kinsman, but almost, His bequest included not
‘ely ancient books (auch as the fit
tury Livy from the
of Oto Ill and Chaves the Bold's copy of Boethis on Arithm
Which hal pethaps survived, like the Codex Aureus, i the
sonastery of StEmameram) but also books from bis fathers brary
like the great Bumberg Apocalypse and an illstratedl commentary