Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Foreword
SK Kaluskar
Headquarters
Jaypee Brothers Medical Publishers (P) Ltd.
4838/24, Ansari Road, Daryaganj
New Delhi 110 002, India
Phone: +91-11-43574357
Fax: +91-11-43574314
Email: jaypee@jaypeebrothers.com
Overseas Offices
J.P. Medical Ltd. Jaypee-Highlights Medical Publishers Inc.
83, Victoria Street, London City of Knowledge, Bld. 237, Clayton
SW1H 0HW (UK) Panama City, Panama
Phone: +44-2031708910 Phone: +507-301-0496
Fax: +02-03-0086180 Fax: +507-301-0499
Email: info@jpmedpub.com Email: cservice@jphmedical.com
Jaypee Brothers Medical Publishers (P) Ltd. Jaypee Brothers Medical Publishers (P) Ltd.
17/1-B, Babar Road, Block-B Shorakhute, Kathmandu
Shaymali, Mohammadpur Nepal
Dhaka-1207, Bangladesh Phone: +00977-9841528578
Mobile: +08801912003485 Email: jaypee.nepal@gmail.com
Email: jaypeedhaka@gmail.com
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any means
without the prior permission of the publisher.
This book has been published in good faith that the contents provided by the author
contained herein are original, and is intended for educational purposes only. While every
effort is made to ensure accuracy of information, the publisher and the author specifically dis-
claim any damage, liability, or loss incurred, directly or indirectly, from the use or application
of any of the contents of this work. If not specifically stated, all figures and tables are courtesy
of the author. Where appropriate, the readers should consult with a specialist or contact the
manufacturer of the drug or device.
The quest for developing new technologies by bioengineers has been continuing
and open-ended since early and mid-19th century in the field of ENT and
Head & Neck Surgery. As the various diagnostic tools were designed, hand-in-
hand on the desire of the surgeons to treat underlying pathologies became more
intense.
Among many discoveries of the new technologies by late 19th and early 20th
centuries to treat various conditions in the field of ENT, one of the most important
innovations of treating the cells by “cold application” was seens; but, unfortunately,
it went unnoticed by most of ENT surgeons. Very few surgeons really expressed
any interest, if any, in the science of treating a cell with freezing temperature!
I am indeed delighted to learn that Dr KK Desarda took special interest in this
somewhat forgotten modality to treat so many common conditions for the benefit
of our patients. Following the first-hand experience and training in England, Dr
Desarda showed complete dedication and passion to treat his patients with this
approach of cryosurgery; and, as a result, he gained vast experience in treating
patients with various pathologies in ENT and Head & Neck Surgery.
The book in ENT and Head & Neck Surgery is scrupulously researched and
very well written in a detailed, concise and easy-to-understand format for the
novice and advanced surgeons practicing ENT surgery.
The book is comprehensive, unfolding the history of cryosurgery to the results
of cryosurgery in an organized fashion. The history of cryosurgery is particularly
attention grabbing.
The chapter based on the Principles of Cryosurgery is particularly well elucidated.
Dr Desarda highlights the details of pathophysiological considerations in an
undemanding manner. His wealth of experience in this field is well documented
in Cryosurgery: Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology and he emphasizes
on the importance of meticulous, atraumatic details of cryosurgical techniques
in different pathologies. The minimally invasive nature of the modality is well
illustrated including certain applications in the field of Rhinology and Head &
Neck pathologies.
Throughout the book, there are important tips and quips for the surgeons.
Cryosurgery: Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
The advent of the book is a notable milestone in the various modalities available
for the ENT surgeons to treat their patients. He has highlighted the importance
of this modality in terms of minimally invasive and reduced morbidity for the
patients in ENT and Head & Neck Surgery.
viii
Preface
KK Desarda
x
Acknowledgments
1. Introduction 1
2. Historical Overview 3
First Use of Refrigerants 4
Liquid Air and Liquid Oxygen 4
Carbonic Acid Snow 4
Liquid Nitrogen 5
3. Cryopathophysiological Considerations 7
Cryobiology 7
Cryomechanism 7
Cryohistology 9
Cryoimmunology 10
4. Principles of Cryosurgery 11
5. Cryosurgery Considerations in Otorhinolaryngology 12
Instruments 12
Cryosurgery Indications 14
Technique and Procedure 16
7. Cryosurgery—Results 50
Photo Gallery—Cryosurgery Results 52
Justification 58
8. Cryosurgery—Conclusion 59
Bibliography 61
Index 65
xiv
1
C HA P T E R
Introduction
INTRODUCTION
For centuries surgeons have searched for a technique which eliminates pain
and bleeding in surgical procedures and reduces postoperative morbidity.
Recent experience suggests that cryosurgery produces localized destruction of
tissue with little or no discomfort and bleeding during or after surgery.
The use of freezing temperatures for the therapeutic destruction of
tissue began in England in 1845 to 51 when James Arnott described the use
of iced salt solutions (about 20°C) to freeze advanced cancers in accessible
sites, producing reduction in tumor size and amelioration of pain. Improved
freezing techniques were possible early in the 1890s when solidified carbon
dioxide came into use and later when liquid nitrogen and nitrous oxide became
available. Nevertheless, cryotherapy was a minor technique, used only for the
accessible lesions of skin and mucosa.
With the development of modern cryosurgical apparatus by Cooper in
1961, a resurgence of interest in cryosurgery was initiated and techniques
for diverse clinical conditions, including visceral cancer, evolved, after the
initial widespread clinical trials matured in the 1970s, some applications of
the technique fell into disuse while others became standard treatment. Late
in the 1980s, further improvements in apparatus and imaging techniques
have permitted increased clinical use of cryosurgery in wide spectrum of
otorhinolaryngology including head and neck neoplasm.
Cryosurgery, sometimes referred to as cryotherapy or cryoablation, is a
surgical technique in which freezing is used to destroy undesirable tissues.
Although the prefix “cryo” (from the Greek word “kruos” for cold) usually
refers to temperatures below 120°C.
The controlled destruction of tissue by freezing is today widely practiced
in medicine. Terms for it include cryotherapy, cryocautery, cryocongelation
and cryogenic surgery, but cryosurgery (literally, cold handiwork) seems most
appropriate. Cryosurgery is a cheap, easy, and safe treatment suitable for both
hospital-and office-based practice. Its major advantage is excellent cosmetic
results with minimal scarring.
Cryosurgery is an important minimally invasive surgical technique. It can
be potentially applied to any procedure in which scalpels are used to remove
Cryosurgery: Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
2
2
C HA P T E R
Historical Overview
4
Historical Overview
When the gas was allowed to escape, rapid expansion caused a fall in
temperature (the Joule–Thompson effect) and a fine snow was formed. The
snow was easily compressed into various shapes, known as pencils, suitable
for different treatments. Pusey’s first reported case was the treatment of a
large black hairy nevus on a young girl’s face. Impressive before-and-after
photographs showed the successful depigmentation of the lesion.
This was one of the first demonstrations of the extraordinary sensitivity
of melanocytes to cold. He successfully treated other nevi, warts and lupus
erythematosus. Pusey stated of carbon dioxide snow that ‘we have found a
destructive application whose action can be accurately gauged and is therefore
controllable’. He recognized the low scarring potential of cryosurgery although
he attributed this to regeneration of residual epidermal cells rather than to
collagen’s resistance to cold.
Hall-Edwards, of Birmingham, first described his carbon dioxide collection
model in The Lancet in 1911. Hall-Edward’s monograph, written later in 1913,
detailed the uses of carbon dioxide and methods of collection is contribution
to cryosurgery was all the more remarkable because he was a respected
radiotherapist in charge of much of the Midlands.
He would have been well aware of the place of cryosurgery in relation
to X-ray use. He detailed many conditions in which treatment was effective
but was particularly struck by its efficacy in rodent ulcers. At the same time
Cranston-Low, a physician in the Edinburgh skin department, was likewise
promoting the use of carbon dioxide snow. He observed that ‘thrombosis,
direct injury to tissues, and the inflammatory exudate probably all act together’
to produce the effects of freezing.
Solid carbon dioxide applied directly to the skin cannot get the surface
temperature below –79°C. This is insufficient for deeper freezing of tissue
necessary for treatment of malignancies, when a temperature of –50°C at a
tissue depth of 3 mm is required.
Nevertheless it proved very successful for a wide variety of benign skin
conditions and remained popular until the 1960s. Carbon dioxide slush,
a mixture of carbon dioxide and acetone, was used extensively for acne. As
the use of carbon dioxide snow became more widespread so did the range of
conditions treated. De Quervain reported the successful use of carbonic snow
for bladder papillomas and bladder cancers in 1917.
LIQUID NITROGEN
Allington is generally thought to have been first to use liquid nitrogen, in
1950. He recognized that the properties of liquid nitrogen were very similar
5
Cryosurgery: Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
to those of liquid air and oxygen. After the Second World War, liquid nitrogen
became freely available and was preferable to liquid oxygen with its explosive
potential. He used a cotton swab for treating various benign lesions but poor
heat transfer between swab and skin meant this method was insufficient for
tumor treatment.
The contribution of Dr Irving S Cooper to cryosurgery was immense. An
American neurosurgeon based in New York, in 1913 he designed a liquid
nitrogen probe that was capable of achieving temperatures of -196°C. With it
he treated Parkinson’s disease and other movement disorders by freezing the
thalamus, in addition to previously inoperable brain tumors.
Although Cooper was controversial in his lifetime because of his
showmanship, his work led to an explosion of interest in liquid nitrogen and
its eventual acceptance as a standard treatment in many specialties. More
general use of cryosurgery was facilitated by the development of devices
suitable for office-based practice.
Torre developed a liquid nitrogen spray in 1965 and Zacarian a hand-held
device, the Kryospray, in 1967. Zacarian popularized the use of this equipment.
Zacarian’s spray allowed one-handed operation with trigger type control, and
interchangeable tips permitted variations in spray diameter. Zacarian also
developed copper probes that allowed tissue-freezing to depths of up to 7 mm.
His contributions to cryosurgery equipment, understanding of the science of
the cryolesion and the published work on cryosurgery was very great.
Amoils developed a liquid nitrogen probe that achieved cooling by
expansion. He performed cataract extraction (cryoextraction) successfully but
cooling was slow and temperatures were not low enough for tumor work. This
system is still widely used in gynecology and ophthalmology.
The use of liquid nitrogen spread through different specialties. Rand
performed a transsphenoidal hypophysectomy with liquid nitrogen, Gage
treated oral cancers and Cahan performed cryosurgery of the uterus with a
liquid nitrogen probe.
The use of liquid nitrogen in Great Britain took off when Zacarian donated
the first hand-held liquid nitrogen spray to the Oxford dermatology department
in the 1970s. This center became the focus of cryosurgical research in Britain.
6
3
C HA P T E R
Cryopathophysiological
Considerations
CRYOBIOLOGY
The past 50 years have seen great advances in knowledge of the biological
effects of freezing. Almost all research has concerned the effects of liquid
nitrogen. The development of temperature probes that can be inserted into
skin has allowed measurement of tissue temperatures during freezing.
An accurate picture of the shape and depth of iceball formation with
different lengths of freeze has been built up, allowing development of guidelines
for freezing times (best established for cutaneous lesions). For malignant
lesions freezing times are longer than for benign lesions since destruction of
all malignant cells is vital.
Tissue temperatures must be below –50°C for adequate treatment of
tumors. A 30-second spot freeze, counted 30 seconds after an iceball formation,
is capable of achieving a tissue temperature of –50°C in the center of the iceball
and is usually the minimum time necessary for tumor work.
Other research has concentrated on determining the sensitivity of
individual cell types to freezing. Melanocytes are most sensitive, hence the
depigmentation of skin often seen after cutaneous cryosurgery. Collagen is
the most resilient tissue, and indeed preservation of the normal structure
of collagen bundles is observed on electron microscopy even after the deep
freezes necessary for tumor work. This explains why there is so little scarring.
Cartilage necrosis is extremely rare, so cryosurgery is particularly suitable in
otorhinolaryngological lesions.
Cryogens/Temperature (Degree C)
Liquid/20 (Cotton-wool bud)
Nitrogen/180 (Spray)/196 (Probe)
Carbon dioxide snow/78
Nitrous oxide/89 (Cryogun).
CRYOMECHANISM
Mechanism of Cell Death
Liquid nitrogen, which boils at –196°C (–320.8°F), is the most effective
cryogen for clinical use. It is particularly useful in the treatment of malignant
lesions. Temperatures of –25°C to –50°C (–13°F to –58°F) can be achieved
Cryosurgery: Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
CRYOHISTOLOGY
Recognizable morphological changes can be seen immediately after freezing
and are easily recognized within 30 minutes after a return to normal ambient
temperature.The earliest changes consists of an area of an uniformly altered cells
sharply demarcated from the surrounding normal tissue, showing pyknotic
nuclei, edematous, coarsely granular and some times vacuolated cytoplasm
with slight disruption of the reticulin framework. Immediate fixation of the
frozen margin shows the familiar demarcating line, with typical ice crystal
spaces in the periphery of the lesions.Initially, there is no clear intermediate
zone but within 30 minutes, there is a distinct band, between 10 and 30 cells
broad,which separates the injured from the normal area.
Electron microscopy has added to our knowledge of the effects of very low
temperatures other than to confirm the light microscope findings and to allow a
more certain identification of small intranuclear ice crystals. It has also confirmed
the dramatic demarcation between totally injured and surviving cells. There are
nonspecific changes that affect the various cell membranes, and particularly the
plasma and nuclear membranes, and it has been suggested that the integrity of the
plasma membrane is the limiting factoring cell survival.
Repeated freez-thaw cycles produce a lesion with histological changes such
as nuclear pyknosis and chromatin clumping observed in a single freez lesion,
but in a more exaggerated fashion. Despite this “local homogenization” there
is a striking preservation of cellular detail at electron microscope level.
9
Cryosurgery: Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
CRYOIMMUNOLOGY
Recent reports suggest that within a cryolesion tumor, destruction releases
either tissue proteins which acquire new antigenic properties or pre-existing
but unavailable antigens. The result is the creation of an autoimmune response
to the target tissue that is directly related to the freezing process.This release of
antigenic substance probably occurs during the relatively slow thawing period
rather than the preceding rapid freez and as such, differs from the effect of
other forms of tissue injury such as irradiation in which the potential antigenic
substance is simultaneously destroyed.
The first report of this antigenic response was made by Gonder and Soanes
who demonstrated tissue specific autoantibodies following cryocoagulation
which is clinically significant immune response against cryosurgically treated
tumors. On the other hand, should this phenomenon be substantiated its
potential application to cancer therapy would be a most exciting prospect.
Liquid gas circulated through closed system has been basis of many cryosurgical
units. Instruments were designed in which cooling process relied on “Joule-
Thompson” effect, which states that, when a compressed gas is allowed to
expand rapidly, a fall in temperature results. Cryoprobes work on the principle
of Joule-Thompson effect.
10
4
C HA P T E R
Principles of Cryosurgery
13
Cryosurgery: Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
CRYOSURGERY INDICATIONS
Otology
1. Aural cysts, dermoids, fibroma, keloids, papillomas.
2. Aural hematomas, hemangiomas, nevus warts.
3. Glomus tumor.
4. Meniere’s disease (selective cryofreezing).
5. Basal cell and squamous cell carcinoma of ear.
Oral Cavity
1. Tonsillitis and tonsil remnants, granular pharyngitis.
2. Epulis and papillomas, ranulas. Retension and mucous cysts, etc.
3. Palatal and cheek ulcers, papillary hyperplasia, vascular malformations.
4. Oral submucous fibrosis, hyperkeratosis and leukoplakia.
5. Cheek hemangiomas, lymphangiomas, leukoplakia.
6. Premalignant lesions.
7. Glossopharyngeal neuralgia.
Oropharyngolaryngeal Lesions
1. Premalignants and benign lesions of oropharynx.
2. Base tongue, pharyngeal and oral cavity tumors.
3. Cheek, tongue and tongue base lesions.
4. Postirradiated recurrences in oropharyngeal malignancy.
5. Granulomatous and hyperplastic lesions.
Rhinology
1. Vasomotor rhinitis, and chronic rhinitis.
2. Chronic hypertrophic turbinates.
3. Epistaxis and familial hemorrhagic telangiectasia.
4. Allergic rhinitis, noninfective rhinitis, and nasal polyposis.
5. Allergic polyposis–Ethmoidal.
6. Angiofibroma, hemangiomas, fibromas.
7. Papillomas, basal cell carcinoma of nose and face.
8. Post FESS recurrences.
Special Indications
1. Transnasal hypophysectomy.
2. Transnasal endoscopic vidian nerve cryofreezing.
3. Endoscopic cryofreezing of posterior epistaxsis.
4. Cryopalliation for head and neck malignancies.
5. Transtympanic cryofreezing of membranous labyrinth for Meniere’s disease.
14
Cryosurgery Considerations in Otorhinolaryngology
Cryosurgery Advantages
1. Its office procedure.
2. No scar formation.
3. No primary bleeding (pre-and postcryo).
4. Palliation of painful neoplasms.
5. Well-accepted by elderly and debilitated patients.
6. No unpleasant odor of burning tissue (As in SMD).
7. Absence of scarring as associated with deep cautery.
8. Postcryo recovery is smooth.
9. No major complications encountered.
10. Most cost-effective as compared to laser or radiofrequency therapy.
Cryosurgery Disadvantages
1. Margins of the tumor cannot be made out.
2. Tissue not available for histopathology.
3. If biopsy is required, it must be done precryofreezing.
4. Depigmentation and loss of hair for skin lesions.
Cryosurgery Complications
1. No major complications are seen.
2. Infections (postcryo) rarely seen.
3. Bleeding during procedure if premature cryotip is withdrawn from tissue.
4. Intense headache is experienced.
5. Some times vasovagal attack is observed (xylocaine-reactions).
6. Hypopigmentation of skin.
7. Delayed healing.
Cryosurgery Morbidity
1. Pain for temporary period, relieved by analgesics.
2. Nasal obstruction and rhinorrhea lasting for one week.
3. Dental (incisors) paresthesia lasting for a month.
4. Healing takes two to three weeks.
5. Hospitalization for one day only.
Cryosurgery Economics
1. Low cost of equipment.
2. Low operating costs.
3. Minimal treatment time.
4. It is a day-procedure (office procedure).
5. Can be assisted with endoscopes.
6. Can be repeated any number of times if required.
15
Cryosurgery: Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
Cryosurgery–Investigations
1. Preoperative investigations are mandatory.
2. Routine lab work-up as hemogram, coagulation profile, BSL, urea
creatinine, etc.
3. Radiology and CT or MRI as indicated.
4. Medical and anesthetic fitness.
5. Briefing and consent for the procedures.
6. Preoperative antibiotics, anti-inflammatory and antihistaminics drugs are
given.
7. Xylocaine sensitivity test is must for all patients.
Precautions in Cryosurgery
1. Gas cylinders should not be stored at temperature above room temperature
(18–30°C) or near radiators, furnaces, or other heat supply.
2. Use only nitrous oxide gas cylinder.
3. Use presterilized cryoprobes (immersed in cidex tray).
4. Freezing-thaw cycles should be complete for required time duration.
5. Patients are warned not to blow nose too hard to avoid bleeding.
6. Nasal douches with normal saline are advised after one week to keep the
nasal cavity clean.
7. Patients should continue antibiotic therapy for full one week.
8. Patients are advised to keep the nasal splint for full 7 days to avoid synechiae
formation.
16
Cryosurgery Considerations in Otorhinolaryngology
4. If spray is to be used, mask off surrounding area with piece of plastic sheet,
or apply white petroleum, Styrofoam cups or X-ray film to prevent freezing
of underlying or adjacent tissue.
5. Large tumors are debulked as much as possible, prior to freezing to produce
a flat surface for easy contact freezing and to reduce the amount of tissue to
be frozen.
6. Select suitable probe needle for example, 10 or 20 mm diameter or spray
attachment depending on desirability.
Methods of Treatment
The dose of liquid nitrogen and the choice of delivery method depend on the
size, tissue type and depth of the lesion. The area of the body on which the
lesion is located and the required depth of freeze also should be considered.
Also the additional factors should be considered which include the thickness
of the tissue, the water content of the tissue and local blood flow.
Cryoprobes
While the open spray technique can be used for the most easily accessible
lesions, a cryoprobe attached to the liquid nitrogen spray gun can provide
added versatility, depending on the site and type of the lesion. In this regard
various sizes and types of cryoprobes are available. The cryoprobe is applied
directly to the lesions. A gel interface medium often is used between the probe
and the skin surface. These are frequently used in the treatment of smaller
facial lesions, where scatter of liquid nitrogen is undesirable. Probes also are
useful in the management of vascular lesions where its pressure can be used
to remove blood from the tissues thus allowing more adequate treatment. The
tissue must be frozen to a temperature of –20°C to –30°C.
17
Cryosurgery: Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
A B
Figures 5.6A and B: Instrument showing freezing tips; (A) Nitrous oxide cryojet;
(B) Nitrous oxide cryocan
10. The procedure is always repeated on both sides in allergic and vasomotor
rhinitis cases to achieve complete relief from the symptoms.
11. The most important step in cryoprocedure is not to withdraw cryoprobe
prematurely so as to avoid catastrophic bleeding from the lesion. Probe is
released only after complete defrost.
12. No major dressings are required apart from simple sterile tulle gras or
soframycin soaked dressing, or presterile avalon pack.
13. Simple micropore dressing is given which will absorb the excessive nasal
secretions.
19
6
C HA P T E R
Clinical Applications in
Otorhinolaryngology
CRYOFREEZING IN OTOLOGY
Cryofreezing is very effective in lesions of external ear, particularly the pinna
and some part of external auditory canal, such as keloids, hemangioma,
papillomas, basal cell and squamous cell carcinoma. The postoperative results
are excellent and without tissue distortion. It does not cause any deformity.
The minimum two or three cryo-thaw cycles are required to complete the
procedure. All otological procedures are done under local anesthesia (Figs 6.1
to 6.10) .
however, other variants can be very difficult to distinguish from benign lesions
such as intradermal nevus, sebaceomas, fibrous papules, early acne scars, and
hypertrophic scarring.
21
Cryosurgery: Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
22
Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
23
Cryosurgery: Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
24
Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
Adenoidectomy
Since the adenoid is not accessible for cryoprobe application. A special
adenoid probe is required for the procedure. This can be done effectively but
since it is very time consuming and is less reliable than a conventional adeno-
tonsillectomy. Cryoadenoidectomy is unlikely ever to replace the conventional
curettage technique. Now special adenoid debriders are available, but its very
costly for general hospital patients. We feel the standard good old technique
of adenoid curettage is still the best technique used all over world. We do not
recommended cryosurgery for this indication.
25
Cryosurgery: Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
Glossopharyngeal Neuralgias
In 1946 Wilson and McAlpine described the operation for glossopharyngeal
neuralgias by dividing the nerve in the tonsillar fossa. It is difficult to identify
the nerve because of fibrosis following tonsillectomy. It is much easier and
equally effective to destroy the nerve by the application of cryosurgical probe
to the lower half of the tonsil fossa. The actual exposure of the nerve through
the muscular fibers is unnecessary.
The cryoprobe of oval shape is applied to the anticipated course of the nerve
in lower pole of the tonsil. Two freez–thaw cycles of five minutes duration are
usually necessary. In cases of recurrence a second application may be required
Although, results are excellent, but unpredictable.
Leukoplakia
Oral leukoplakia was predominantly seen in elderly age group. Addiction to
tobacco was observed in majority of patients (80.8%). Clinically commonest
site of involvement was buccal mucosa (67.33%), followed by labial mucosa
(13.86%). Majority of patients (57.35%) were having homogenous type of
leukoplakia, followed by verrucous variety (25%). 26 to 48% cases were
also having oral submucous fibrosis. Histologically various combinations of
hyperkeratosis, hyperorthokeratosis and acanthosis were observed in 77.93%
of cases. Dysplastic lesions were reported in 17.65% cases. In 80% of dysplastic
lesions, band-like infiltrate of mononuclear cells in subepithelial zone was seen.
Malignant transformation was noticed in 2.94% cases. Excellent therapeutic
results were obtained by cryosurgery. In resistant cases good results were
observed with high dosage of vitamin A.
Cryosurgery is an ideal form of treatment for areas of leukoplakia in the
mouth and buccal cavity. The procedure is done on OPD basis under local
anesthetic infiltration or spray. Areas of leukoplakia are treated in parts rather
than attempting to freez a large surface area at one attempt. The flat cryoprobe
of nitrous oxide is applied to the lesion and two to three freez-thaw cycles of
five minutes are used. Freezing of deeper layers is not necessary. It is painless
26
Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
with minimal inflammatory reaction and subsides in two to three days with
excellent slough. The healing is excellent without distortion of mucosa. It is
advisable to excise the leukoplakic patch for frozen section if malignancy is
suspected.
Oral Ulcerations
Cryosurgery is successfully used for many oral conditions. Cryoprobe have
been used alone or associated with other surgical methods in various types
of oral lesions, such as pyogenic granuloma, angioma, actinic cheilitis,
keratoacanthoma, fibroma, HPV lesions in HIV and non-HIV patients,
hypertrophic lichen planus, leukoplakia and erythroplakia, verrucous
carcinoma, mucous cysts, and papillary hyperplasia of the palate, among others.
All procedures of oral cavity are performed under 10% xylocaine spray or
2% xylocaine with 1:200000 adrenaline infiltration. The lesions are infiltrated
all around the tissue and then cryofreez-thaw cycles are repeated for 3 to 5
minutes. The results are excellent without any distortion of oral mucosa. Our
experience and review of literature have shown that cryosurgery is a very
useful technique for treatment of oral lesions. The tissue healing is fast (within
a week).
The oral mucosa because of its characteristics of humidity and smoothness,
is an ideal site for this technique. It shows a very good esthetic result and
it may be either the first choice or an alternative option to conventional
surgery. Cryosurgery is a very safe, easy to perform, and relatively inexpensive
technique for treating various oral lesions in an outpatient clinic.
Lichen Planus
Lichen Planus: This condition presents as a white lace-like pattern on the
inside of the cheeks. It can be confused with many other conditions and
evaluation by a physician is mandatory to make sure other serious problems
are not present. Often the condition is caused by a reaction to medications.
Beta blockers and oral hypoglycemics are the most common offending
medications. Lichen planus can also be associated with other conditions such
as Hepatitis C. Treatment is with oral prednisone (5 mg/5 cc) rinses, mixed
(1:1) with kopectate to allow the medication to stick to the oral mucosa. The
cryofreez-thaw cycles are applied for the lesions. The results are excellent and
the mucosa appears normal after a week without ant scarning.
Hemangiomas
The oral or pharyngeal hemangioma has an older age at diagnosis than lesions
from other sites. In adults, the mucosal hemangioma most often arises from
the frequently traumatized mucosal sites: the lip mucosa (63% of oral cases),
the buccal mucosa (14% of cases) and the lateral borders of the tongue (14%
of cases), but it may occur at any oral or pharyngeal location. In population
studies there is a strong (2:1) male predilection, although there is minimal
gender predilection in hospital-based studies. Congenital and neonatal lesions
do occur, especially in the lips and parotid glands.
The mucosal hemangioma is typically a soft, moderately well-circumscribed,
painless mass which is red or blue in coloration. The more superficial ones are
often lobulated and will blanch under finger pressure. Deeper lesions tend to
be dome-shaped with normal or blue surface coloration; they seldom blanch.
A lesion with a thrill or bruit, or with an obviously warmer surface, is most
likely a special vascular malformation, called arteriovenous hemangioma
(arteriovenous aneurysm, A-V shunt, arteriovenous malformation), with
direct flow of blood from the venous to the arterial system, bypassing the
capillary beds.
The lesion is usually less than 2 cm in greatest dimension, but may be so
extensive as to encompass much of the oral/pharyngeal tissues. Congenital
lesions tend to keep pace with body growth, while adult-onset lesions tend to
slowly enlarge over a period of months or years. The preoperative embolization
must be done before cryofreezing therapy is applied. The postoperative results
are excellent. Most congenital capillary hemangiomas will spontaneously
regress or disappear by the fifth or sixth years of life.
Lymphangiomas
These lesions are usually present at birth and occur most commonly in the
mouth, neck, axilla, etc. Surgical excision is always difficult because these
cystic lesions frequently invest and mingle with nerves, blood vessels and
muscles. They can be large and multiple in nature.
The aspirations and injecting sclerosing fluids are far from satisfactory.
Cryosurgery is probably the best answer to this problem. The 10% xylocaine
spray is used for surface anesthesia. The flat cryoprobes lubricated with K-Y
jelly are applied to the localized lymphangiomatous lesions and 2 to 3 freez-
thaw cycle are repeated for 3 to 5 minutes. The results are very gratifying with
no morbidity. The recurrences are treated by repeat cryoapplications.
28
Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
29
Cryosurgery: Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
30
Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
31
Cryosurgery: Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
32
Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
33
Cryosurgery: Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
34
Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
HEMORRHAGIC TELANGIECTASIA
Hereditary hemorrhagic telangiectasia (HHT) or Rendu-Osler-Weber disease
is a genetic disorder with a dominant autosomic transmission. Its prevalence
is estimated in one in 5 to 8,000 individuals. Two different mutations have
been described involving endoglin and ALK-1 genes, resulting in HHT type
1 and 2 respectively. It is characterized by the occurrence of spontaneous
and recurrent episodes of epistaxis. Telangiectasia shows the presence of
arteriovenous malformations mainly affecting nasal mucous membrane
involving septum, turbinates and lateral nasal wall, tongue and oral mucosa
which are responsible for the clinical manifestations of intractable bleed.
This condition can be treated under local 10% xylocaine spray or under
general anesthesia. Familial hemorrhagic telangiectasia (Osler disease) can be
treated by cryoapplications for 3 to 5 minutes at each sites covering the bleeding
zone on the septum,turbinates and lateral wall of the nose. The cryoprobe size
should be 3 to 6 mm and freez-thaw cycles of 3 to 5 minutes are used. Most of
the time this treatment will control the bleeding.
The results are extremely satisfactory. Great care is taken to ensure that
the cryoprobe is not withdrawn until the reheat mechanism has thawed the
tip. The avulsion of iceball by premature withdrawal may cause catastrophic
hemorrhage. In cases of recurrence, the septo-dermography procedure is
advisable. Bleeding from the choana is treated by curved nasal cryoprobes.
There is no contraindication to repeat cryoprocedures in this condition.
Postcryofreezing, the nasal and oral mucosa regains its normal physiological
integrity without distortion. In treating small angiomas, over the septum or
lateral nasal wall, or turbinates and oral mucosa cryoprobes of suitable size
(2 to 3 mm) are used. The larger angiomata in the anterior nasal passages
are occasionally the cause of profuse epistaxis. The bleeding surfaces of these
lesions may be frozen with extremely good results. The rhinosporidiosis is
another bleeding disorder which can be effectively treated by cryosurgery with
two or three repeat cycles.
36
Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
NASAL-POLYPOSIS
Nasal polypi are avascular structures with a narrow pedicle and are therefore
vulnerable to freezing. The cryoprobe of 3 to 5 mm size are used to freez the
poypi which will go in cryonecrosis. Gross polypi can be effectively frozen only
in stages and thus will need several repeat procedures. The most important of
these are ethmoidal polypi which frequently recur after FESS surgery, even
if the debrider is used. Cryonecrosis technique is preferable when freezing
localized polypoidal bed or tags. The procedure is performed under local
anesthesia with general cryoprobes. The pedicles should be given two freez-
thaw cycles for 3 to 5 minutes. The rilastic septal splints are kept in the nasal
cavity for a week to prevent adhesions or synechiae. The healing following
cryofreezing is excellent.
HYPERTROPHIC RHINITIS
The cryosurgical flat probe used to reduce the bulk of turbinates in cases of
hypertrophic rhinitis, either allergic or nonspecific types. The turbinate is
infiltrated with 2% xylocaine solution from anterior to posterior ends. A flat
cryoprobe is applied to the turbinate for 5 minutes each on either sides and
2 to 3 freez-thaw cycles are used. During the procedure intense headache is
experienced but it could be relieved by simple analgesics. Tissue ischemia and
necrosis takes place in about 7 days time and the turbinate will shrunk in its
size which will improve the nasal airways. The results are extremely good.
Our results show that the cryoturbinectomy is the best method of treatment
because it most effectively maintains satisfactory nasal physiologic integrity
without damaging nasal mucosa or underlying nerves.
procedure (vidian nerve cryosurgery) is based on the fact that the autonomic
nerve supply to the nasal cavity is through sympathetic and parasympathetic
fibers, carried by the vidian nerve.
The vasomotor instability is manifested mainly by rhinorrhea, sneezing,
nasal obstruction and headache which is attributed to the overactivity of
sympathetic and parasympathetic of autonomic system. The target of vidian
nerve is always the superior turbinate which acts as a pointer to sphenopalatine
foramen, which is frozen for three to five minutes by cryogen.
All patients were instructed that they will have excessive lacrimation
and nasal obstruction for first 24 to 48 hrs. This is because of excessive
overactivity of the seromucinous glands. The healing takes place within two
to three weeks with minimal fibrosis, less scarring, than with either linear
cautery or submucosal diathermy. Results are extremely good with regard to
improvement of airway, rhinorrhea, sneezing and nasal obstruction. All three
components of VMR are best treated by cryofreezing with encouraging results.
Complete relief is obtained after six weeks. Although, results are encouraging,
reduction of rhinorrhea occurs after about three weeks but the procedure may
offer relief for months only rather than years, as the nerves can regenerate and
hence repeat cryofreezing is recommended for chronic VMR cases.
Verrucous Vulgaris
Verrucous vulgaris is a wart which is on the inside of the nose. This is a skin
growth which is caused by a virus. In this case, it may have been implanted in
the nose by nose picking. The ideal treatment is cryofreezing with two rapid
thaw cycles for 2 to 3 minutes. The complete resolution of the lesion is seen in
six weeks. No postoperative scarring is seen.
40
Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
43
Cryosurgery: Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
44
Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
46
Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
MENIERE’S DISEASE
The rational of cryosurgery in Meniere’s disease is to create a periotic-
endolymphatic shunt, allowing endolymph to seep into the perilymphatic
fluid space as the endolymphatic pressures are raised.
The cryoprobe is applied either to thinned bone over the surface of the
promontory or thinned bone overlying the horizontal semicircular canal and
membranous labyrinth is thus frozen. Long-term results are as variable as
other forms of treatment for Meniere’s disease.
The postsurgical rate of decline in semicircular canal function was found to
be directly related to the temperature and exposure time employed. For a given
exposure time, decreasing cryosurgical temperatures provided loss of function
in fewer days. When temperature was held constant, increases in duration of
cryosurgical application produced a more rapid decline in semicircular canal
function.
48
Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology
CRYOSURGERY—POSTOPERATIVE CARE
Immediately following cryofreezing, patients will experience intense headache
and watering from eyes. The simple analgesics will relieve the pain. All patients
undergoing nasal cryofreezing are instructed not to blow their nose too hard
and too frequently, since intense freezing will lead to excessive nasal discharge.
Next 3 to 4 days nasal cavity will remain more blocked than before cryofreez.
The block will be cleared after the Escher is formed which comes out on its own
by gentle blowing or it can be removed by nasal forceps or suction cannulae
after two weeks.
Patients are prescribed analgesics, antibiotics, and anti-inflammatory agents
for full two weeks. Nasal obstruction immediately following cryofreezing is
relieved by steroidal spray (Flixonase nasal spray). Escher is formed on 5th
or 7th day which is end result of cryoischemia and necrosis. After the Escher
is released the nasal cavity is cleaned and Betnovate cream is applied to nasal
mucosa. The healing is fast and without any tissue distortion. All patients are
seen in follow-up clinic in 2 weeks, 4 weeks, 6 weeks. The complete recovery is
seen after six weeks.
49
7
C HA P T E R
Cryosurgery—Results
INTRODUCTION
Applications of cryofreezing to the inferior turbinate and transnasal
cryodegeneration of the vidian nerve using endoscope were evaluated. The
study consisted of 180 patients with chronic vasomotor rhinitis and 102
patients of allergic rhinitis. All were refractory to conservative treatment,
including allergic desensitization. The cryosurgery was repeated once a week
for 3 weeks. After the third cryoapplication, the area that was endoscopically
estimated to be the sphenopalatine foramen was frozen over the mucous
membrane by an extrafine pointed cryoprobe. The subjective results 3 months
after the operation ware promising, and no major complications were noted.
The cryoapplications using endoscope is a minor surgical procedure with
high efficacy and minimal postoperative morbidity. The results in chronic
vasomotor rhinitis and allergic rhinitis were extremely gratifying and patient
satisfaction. More cases and a longer follow-up are necessary to provide long-
term results.
Our results of KEM study infer that cryosurgery may be prescribed as an
effective method of treatment in patients of chronic vasomotor rhinitis and
allergic rhinitis (Tables 7.1 to 7.3). The results were extremely promising
(72%) and repeat cryo was required for (28%) cases. The recurrence after
FESS surgery responded very well with cryofreezing (30%) which required
few repeat sittings. The hemangiomatous polyps, telangiectasia hemorrhagica
and papillomas were treated with cryofreezing for two to five minutes and
results were very satisfactory (Figs 7.1 to 7.16). Benign tumors of nasal cavity
also responded effectively and patients were comfortable after cryofreezing.
Most of the cases healed well without tissue damage and scarring. Cryohealing
takes 7 to 10 days no postoperative complications seen as bleeding, infections,
and distortion of normal tissue. Recurrences seen in hemangiomas and,
papillomas needed repeat cryofreezing. Tissue destruction is essentially well-
circumscribed and without scarring. Its inherent anesthetic and hemostatic
properties make it suitable for OPD procedures.
Benign, premalignant and malignant lesions in the oral cavity were treated
by cryosurgery, extremely good results have been obtained in the treatment of
small to moderate, superficially situated angiomas, simple cysts, papillomas,
pyogenic granuloma, keratoacanthoma, etc. Cryotherapy has also been found
Cryosurgery—Results
JUSTIFICATION
The potential benefits certainly justify its place as a valuable therapeutic agent.
Cryosurgery appears to be more effective than current standard treatment
options. The complication rate is also lower in our series. It is also a promising
modality in patients who are radiation therapy failures. Hence we strongly
recommend this therapy in clinical practice of otolaryngology and oncology.
58
8
C HA P T E R
Cryosurgery—Conclusion
22. Das K, Benzil DL, Rovit RL. A Cooper is (1922-1985): A pioneer in functional
neurosurgery. J Neurosurg. 1998;89:865-73.
23. Dawber R, Colver G, Jackson A. Cutaneous cryosurgery: Principles and Practice.
London: Martin Dunitz. 1997.
24. Dawber RPR, Colver G, Jackson A. Historic and scientific basis of cryosurgery.
In: Cutaneous Cryosurgery. Principles and Practice. London: Martin Dunitz.
1997.pp.15-26.
25. Dawber RPR. Cold kills! Clin Exp Dermatol. 1988;13:137-50.
26. Dennison AR, Paraskevopoulos JA, Kerrigan DD, et al. New thoughts on the
aetiology of haemorrhoids and the development of non-operative methods for
their management. Minerva Chir. 1996;51:209-16.
27. Edwards JH. The therapeutic effects of carbon dioxide snow: Methods of
collecting and application. Lancet. 1911;ii:87-90.
28. Gage AA. History of cryosurgery. Semin Surg Oncol. 1998;14:99-109.
29. Gill IS, Novick AC. Renal cryosurgery. Urology. 1999;54:215-9.
30. Gold J. Liquid air and carbonic acid snow: Therapeutic results obtained by
dermatologists. NY Med J. 1910;92:1276-7.
31. Grimmett R. Liquid nitrogen therapy. Histologic observations. Arch Dermatol.
1961;83:563-7.
32. Hall-Edwards J. Carbon dioxide snow: Its therapeutic uses. London: Simpkin,
Marshall, Hamilton, Kent. 1913.
33. Henderson RL. Cryosurgical treatment in haemangiomas. Arch Otolaryng. 1971;
93:511-13.
34. Holden HB, McKelvie P. Cryosurgery in head and neck neoplasia. Br J Surg.
1972;59:702.
35. Holden HB. J Laryng. 1972;86:821.
36. House WF. Arch. otolaryng, 84,616, Cryosurgical treatment of Menire’s disease.
1966.
37. Hunsaker R, Schwartz J, Keasy B, et al. Dry ice cryoamputation: A 12 year
experience. J Vasc Surg. 1985;2:812-16.
38. Irvine H, Turnacliffe D. Liquid oxygen in dermatology. Arch Dermatol Syphilol.
1929;19:270-80.
39. Kuflik EG, Gage AA. History. In: Kuflik EG, Gage AA (Eds). Cryosurgical
Treatment for Skin Cancer. New York: Igaku-Shoin. 1990.pp.1-13.
40. Maiwand MO. The role of cryosurgery in palliation of tracheobronchial
carcinoma. Eur J Cardio-Thorac Surg. 1999;15:764-8.
41. Marren P, Dawber RPR, Wojnarowska F. Failure of cryosurgery to eradicate
vulval intraepithelial neoplasia: A pilot study. J Eur Acad Dermatol Venerol.
1993;2:247-51.
42. Meijer S, Rahusen FD, Van der Plas LG. Palliative cryosurgery for rectal
carcinoma. Int J Colorect Dis. 1999;14:177-80.
43. Pictet R. Mémoire sur la liquéfaction de l’oxygène. Am Chemie Physique. 1878;13:
145-227.
62
Bibliography
44. Poswillo DE. A comparative study of SMD and Cryosurgery. Br J Oral Surg.
1971.
45. Pusey W. The use of carbon dioxide snow in the treatment of naevi and other
lesions of the skin. JAMA. 1935;49:1354-6.
46. Sako Marchette FC, Hayes RL. Evaluation of cryosurgery in intraoral leukoplakia.
J Cryosurg. 1969;2:239-43.
47. Saliken JC, McKinnon G, Gray RR, et al. Liver cryosurgery with curative intent:
Can we realize the promise? Can Assoc Radiologists J. 1999;50:295-7.
48. Shepherd JP, Dawber RPR. Wound healing and scarring after cryosurgery.
Cryobiology. 1984;21:157-69.
49. Smith FWR, Work WP. Cryosurgical technique in Angiofibromas. Laryngoscope.
1964;84:1071-80.
50. White AC. Liquid air: Its application in medicine and surgery. Med Rec. 1899;56:
109-12.
51. White AC. Possibilities of liquid air to the physician. JAMA. 1901;36:426-9.
52. Whitehouse H. Liquid air in dermatology: Its indications and limitations. JAMA.
1907;49:371-7.
53. Wilson JW, Ayers SW, Luikart R. Dichlorotetrafluorethane for surgical planning.
Arch Dermatol. 1955;71:253.
54. Zacarian S. Cryogenics: The cryolesion and the pathogenesis of cryonecrosis.
In: Zacarian SA (Ed). Cryosurgery for Skin Cancer and Cutaneous Disorders. St
Louis: Mosby. 1985.pp.1-30.
63
Index
C E
Cancer of tongue 29f Endoscopic cryofreezing of posterior
Carbonic acid snow 4 epistaxis 14
Carcinoma Epistaxis 14, 35, 51
in situ and malignant conditions 44 Epulis 14, 51
of anterior commissure and vocal Extensive papilloma larynx 46f
cords 47f
of vocal cord 47f F
Cervical esophagus 44 Familial hemorrhagic telangiectasia 14
Cheek Fibromas 14
fibroma 35f Freer’s septal elevators 12
hemangiomas 14 Freezing tips 18f
Chronic
allergic rhinitis 37 G
hypertrophic turbinates 14 Glomus
rhinitis 14, 41f jugulare 24f
vasomotor rhinitis 38 tumors 49
Cidex tray for sterilization of cryoprobes 12 tumor 14
Complete regression of tongue Glossopharyngeal neuralgia 14, 26
hemangioma 57f Granular pharyngitis 14, 51
Cryobiology 7 Granulomatous and hyperplastic lesions 14
Cryofreeze spot freeze 17
Cryofreezing 56f H
for hemangioma of tonsil 54f Hemangioma 14, 28
in laryngopharynx 43 of auricle 21f
in otology 20 of ear lobule 23f
of fungal ulcers of tongue 29f of septum 42f
of hemangioma 56f of tongue 51
of septum 40f of tonsil 54, 55f
of tongue 31f tongue-cryofreezing 55f
Cryosurgery: Clinical Applications in Otorhinolaryngology