Professional Documents
Culture Documents
KEYWORDS Congenital choanal atresia is rare congenital condition which may cause asphyxia in newborns.
Choanal atresia; Our team from Hong Kong, China, presented our endoscopic, endonasal, stentless approach to this
CHARGE syndrome; condition. In this review we also provided an overview of the evolution of various surgical techniques
Mitomycin; and accessory measures.
Vomer; © 2021 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Stents;
Nasal obstruction;
Airway obstruction;
Surgical flaps
http://doi.org/10.1016/j.otot.2021.01.006
1043-1810/© 2021 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
32 Operative Techniques in Otolaryngology, Vol 32, 2021
Recanalization surgery
Figure 2 Coronal CT of a newborn with bilateral choanal atre- The approach to choanal atresia recanalization has been
sia, with classical unfused, thick tri-layer vomer; and medialized evolving as a result of our increasing understanding of the
lateral nasal wall. developing nose and the advancement of surgical instru-
ments. There is no objective numeral definition of posterior
choanal patency. Outcome of different surgical approaches
are reported in terms of blood loss, operative time, rate
of reoperation and complication rates. Table 2 summa-
rized the contemporary surgical approaches. Transantral
approach had replaced but sometimes included in litera-
tures for the sake of completeness.
Transnasal puncture
retractors as in the case of palatoplasty. The hard palate scopic instruments, Wormald et al 14 reported a make-over
is then exposed using a median or a U-shaped incision, of this approach with the assistance of endoscope in 2016.
preserving the greater palatine neurovascular bundles. The They elevated the mucoperichondrial flaps bilaterally using
atretic segment, which arises from the posterior part of hor- transfixion incision, then develop the submucosal planes
izontal plate of palatine bone, posterior nasal spine, vomer all the way to the atresia segment lifting a pouch of pos-
and medial pterygoid plates are resected with rongeurs or terior nasal mucosa. The posterior vomer, palatine crests
cutting drills. The palate is then closed with absorbable and medial pterygoid plates are removed using Blakesley
sutures. Successful rate (patency more than a year later) forceps and 1mm diamond blur. They then make cuts on
as a single surgery is more than 80%.16 Blood loss and the blind pouch mucosa to fashion a pair of swing-door
palatal fistula are occasional complications. A major con- flaps. The flaps are secured with fibrin glue and they do
cern of this technique originates from a report by Freng not use stents. Their result is impressive with no revision
et al17 who compared 2 groups of Norwegian children with surgery necessary, though only 2 of the 17 reported cases
choanal atresia: 35 with transpalatal resection, and 20 with were neonates.
no surgery. He reported 52% occurrence of crossbite in
those with surgery (4% in nonoperated group), affected
individuals have a significant reduction of the width of
the upper dental arch and the maxilla. Contemporary sur- Endoscopic endonasal approach
geons almost never apply this technique as the first line
of surgery for children with choanal atresia. A few con- With the advancement of high definition cameras and
sider such approach when the noses are too small to admit small caliber endoscopes, endoscopic endonasal resection
endoscope and instruments.9 has now become the standard for primary choanal atresia
recanalization. With blooming of literatures since 1990s,
Trans-septal Resection this straight forward approach has shown replicability and
earned confidence from surgeons worldwide. Cedin et al20
Trans-septal approach was described in the late 80s as published a Cochrane review in 2012, endoscopic approach
an alternative to the aforementioned traditional approaches. shown a slight reduction in the absolute risk for not requir-
Trans-septal approach involves elevating mucoperichon- ing reoperation (0.75, compared to 0.84 for nonendoscopic
drial/mucoperiosteial flaps of the septum, as in septoplasty, approaches). Yet the use of endoscope allows meticulous
and tackles the atretic structures submucosally using mi- dissection in small operative fields, and leads to the evo-
croscopes and nasal speculums. Krespi et al18 utilized a lution of mucosal preservation techniques. The absolute
sublabial incision, while McIntosh et al19 adopted a Kil- risk for not requiring reoperation of endoscopic cases with
lian incision at the anteirorinferior septum extended to the flaps is down to 0.09 (compared to 0.3 for endoscopic ap-
anterior nasal floor. This approach gives a novel access to proach without flaps). Different flaps have been described.
the posterior vomer but the mucosal flap limits the access Figure 4 summarized flap designs by various authors, the
to the medial pterygoid plates. With the advance of endo- list is not exclusive.
Alice KY Siu and Jacky FW Lo 35
Intraoperative
The child is orotracheal intubated, preferably with oral-
Rae tube. In unilateral cases, the patent side gives a good
idea on the height and width of the posterior choana, thus
surgery is usually straight forward. In bilateral cases, how-
ever, perspectives are taken from the nasopharynx to es-
timate the dimension so as not to violate the skull base
which is commonly the cause of major bleeding. 120 tele-
scope viewing from the oropharynx can serve this purpose.
The noses are prepped with 0.5% oxymetazoline or 1 to
100,000 adrenaline soaked neurosurgical petties. Cuts are
made onto the atretic pouch mucosa with sharp elevators
(Duckbills or round knife), and the mucosa is reflected
using curved curettes (House curettes). In infants the “I”
incision are more feasible to construct fold-over circum-
ferential flaps. In older children, a cross over flap can be
used. The difficulty of mucosa preservation attempts is that
the mucosa often obscures the field for bone work, and
the small but continuous bleeding becomes disturbing in
infants’ small confined nasal cavities.
Bone work
After elevation of the mucosa, bone work can be started at
the posteroinferior vomer. The septum and nasal floor are
the most reliable landmarks. In unilateral case, it is possi-
ble to use backbite forceps. In bilateral cases, sharp Freer
elevators are used to make curvilinear cuts cracking the
vomer. The vomer in choanal atresia children are layered Figure 5 Endoscopic endonasal recanalization Surgery in a uni-
lateral choanal atresia case.
with a membrane sandwiched between the 2 bony plates.
(a) Preoperative picture showing right choanal atresia. (b) Lateral
Once the posteroinferior vomer plates on both sides are based mucoperiosteal flap raised. (c) Confirmation of atresia po-
removed, a posterior choanal airway is established. From sition with Transoral illumination using a 120-degree endoscope.
there the circumference can be enlarged by chipping the (d) Burring down of posteroinferior vomer with 2mm diamond
vomer superiorly, then burring the vomer alae and the me- burr. (e) Removal of vomer with Blakesley forceps. (f) Part of
dial pterygoid plates. The end of middle turbinate gives us vomer being removed. (g) Trimming and reposition of mucope-
an idea of the lateral and superior limits of the choana. riosteal flap. (h) Recanalized posterior choanae.
The sphenoid ostia are commonly used as the reference of
skull base – they certainly mark the body of the sphenoid,
breath nasally and discharge home in 2 days with normal
yet in infants there is no validated measurements taking
saline drops and a week course of empirical antibiotics.
reference from the roof of choana to the sphenoid ostium.
Many surgeons use nasal steroid sprays and proton pump
A preoperative detailed study of the CT helps the estima-
inhibitors postoperatively. 9
tion. Then it comes to the point whether CT navigation
is useful? Navigation systems are surely of value in older
children and revision cases, though in infants the operative
field would be too small to utilize the navigation-enabled Discussion: debate and controversies
instruments, and the accuracy for 0.5 mm measurements
was doubtful. Figure 5 illustrated one of our cases. Stents
Postoperative care Many articles had detailed the craft of tailor making bi-
The mucosal flaps are repositioned after the bone work, lateral nasal stents from noncuffed endotracheal tubes.13 , 24
and packed down with hemostasis petties. Often this is Postoperative stentings have been a tradition since the di-
enough to stick the flap down without fibrin glue nor nasal latation/transpalatal era. There is no consensus on how
packing. Many authors use stents and mitomycin C. In our long a pair of stents should be kept in situ, though many
unit, stents are no longer used as they do not seem to alter reported a duration of 2 to 8 weeks. Few series reported
the reoperation rates. Mitomycin C use as local applica- the stents to be removed in 24-48 hours, these nasopha-
tion to prevent re-stenosis is off-labeled, we now change ryngeal tubes serve more as a transient airway. From the
to smear the wound with a mixture of 1% momethasone 2012 Cedin et al 20 Cochrane Library review, the absolute
plus 1% gentamycin ointment, as an orthodox practice bor- risk of not requiring reoperation with or without stents
rowed from our airway surgery. The babies are left to is the same (0.81/0.81). A more recent systemic review
Alice KY Siu and Jacky FW Lo 37
by Strychowsky et al30 has a similar conclusion: stented coupled the use of bougies and stents, and averaged with
and unstented series have similar reoperation rates (65% 3.8 procedures per case. De Vincentis et al33 from Rome
in stented, 64% in un-stented patients are successful with utilized the balloons as a secondary measure to stabilized
first surgery). The stented patients had a higher complica- their results in the early postoperative periods in their en-
tion rate including alar injury, vestibular stenosis, columela doscopic endonasal stentless laser resection. They reported
tear and stent dislodgement or blockage. an 85.7% successful rate with an average dilatation of 3.5
times. Both teams used the Relieva Solo Pro Sinus Balloon
Mitomycin C Catheter by Acclarent (Menlo Park, California, USA) with
a diameter of 5-10mm (depends on age of the patients) and
Mitomycin C is an antibiotic and chemotherapy agent a length of 16 mm. The balloon catheter was inflated twice
isolated from the Streptomuces caespitosus fungus. It is for 5 min at 8 Bar using the Acclarent Balloon Inflation
used widely in different surgical fields to reduce scar, Device. Contrary to the laryngeal framework which con-
for its antiproliferative property which inhibits the forma- sists of solely cartilage, we shall evaluate the outcome of
tion of progenitor cells to myofibroblasts. When used in balloon dilatation on the bony posterior choana carefully.
choanal atresia surgery, it is applied by packing petties
soaked with 0.4mg/mL dilution at the end of the proce-
dure. The evidence of its benefit has been questionable,
Author roles
with only few cases series showing effects, all coupled
with the use of stents.1 With the possible risk of bone mar- Dr Alice KY Siu – manuscript preparation, tables and
row toxicity and oncogenicity later in life, it has largely radiology images.
fell out of favor. Dr Jacky FW Lo – manuscript advice, operative photos
and description.
How much vomer is safe to remove?
11. Fitzpatrick NS, Bartley AC, Bekhit E, et al: Skull base anatomy and 23. Önerci TM, Yücel ÖT, Ögretmenoglu O: Transnasal endoscopic
surgical safety in isolated and CHARGE-associated bilateral choanal surgery in choanal atresia. Operative Tech Otolaryngol Head Neck
atresia. Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol 115:61–64, 2018. doi:10.1016/ Surg 17:143, 2006.
j.ijporl.2018.09.009. 24. Nour YA, Foad H: Swinging door flap technique for endoscopic
12. Terzi S, Dursun E, Çeliker MA, et al: The effects of choanal atresia transeptal repair of bilateral choanal atresia. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryn-
on development of the paranasal sinuses and turbinates. Surg Radiol gol 265:1341–1347, 2008. doi:10.1007/s00405- 008- 0654- 4.
Anatomy 39:1143–1147, 2017. doi:10.1007/s00276- 017- 1842- y. 25. Tomoum MO, Askar MH, Mandour MF, et al: Stentless mirrored
13. Gujrathi CS, Daniel SJ, James AL, et al: Management of bilateral L-shaped septonasal flap versus stented flapless technique for en-
choanal atresia in the neonate: An institutional review. Int J Pediatr doscopic endonasal repair of bilateral congenital choanal atresia: a
Otorhinolaryngol 68:399–407, 2004. prospective randomised controlled study. J Laryngol Otol 132:329–
14. Wormald P-J, Zhao YC, Valdes CJ, et al. The endoscopic transsep- 335, 2018. doi:10.1017/S0022215117002614.
tal approach for choanal atresia repair. Int Forum Allergy Rhinol. 26. Stamm AC, Pignatari SS: Nasal septal cross-over flap technique:
2016;6:654-660. doi:10.1002/alr.21716. a choanal atresia micro-endoscopic surgical repair. Am J Rhinol
15. Samadi DS, Shah UK, Handler SD: Choanal atresia: A twenty-year 15:143–148, 2001.
review of medical comorbidities and surgical outcomes. Laryngo- 27. Yaniv E, Hadar T, Shvero J, et al: Endoscopic transnasal repair of
scope 113:254–258, 2003. choanal atresia. Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol 71:457–462, 2007.
16. Hengerer AS, Brickman TM, Jeyakumar A: Choanal atresia: em- 28. Pasquini E, Sciarretta V, Saggese D, et al: Endoscopic treatment of
bryologic analysis and evolution of treatment, a 30-year experience. congenital choanal atresia. Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol 67:271–276,
Laryngoscope 118:862–866, 2008. 2003.
17. Freng A: Growth in width of the dental arches after partial extirpa- 29. Holzmann D, Ruckstuhl M: Unilateral choanal atresia: Surgical tech-
tion of the mid-palatal suture in man. Scand J Plast Reconstr Surg nique and long-term results. J Laryngol Otol 116:601, 2002.
12:267–272, 1978. 30. Strychowsky JE, Kawai K, Moritz E, Rahbar R, Adil EA: To
18. Krespi YP, Husain S, Levine TM, et al: Sublabial transseptal repair stent or not to stent? A meta-analysis of endonasal congenital
of choanal atresia or stenosis. Laryngoscope 97:1402–1406, 1987. bilateral choanal atresia repair. Laryngoscope 126:218–227, 2016.
19. McIntosh WA: Trans-septal approach to unilateral posterior choanal doi:10.1002/lary.25393.
atresia. J Laryngol Otol 100:1133–1137, 1986. 31. Fawcett The development of the human maxilla, vomer, and parasep-
20. Cedin AC, Atallah AN, Andriolo RB, et al: Surgery for congeni- tal cartilages. J Anatomy Physiol 45(Pt 4):378–405, 1911.
tal choanal atresia. Cochrane Database Syst Rev CD008993, 2012. 32. Riepl R, Scheithauer M, Hoffmann TK, et al: Transnasal endoscopic
doi:10.1002/14651858.CD008993.pub2. treatment of bilateral choanal atresia in newborns using balloon di-
21. Dedo HH: Transnasal mucosal flap rotation technique for repair of latation: own results and review of literature. Int J Pediatr Otorhino-
posterior choanal atresia. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 124:674–682, laryngol 78:459–464, 2014. doi:10.1016/j.ijporl.2013.12.017.
2001. 33. De Vincentiis GC, Panatta ML, De Corso E, Marini G, Bianchi A,
22. Cedin AC, Fujita R, Cruz OLM: Endoscopic transeptal surgery for Giuliani M, et al: Endoscopic treatment of choanal atresia and use of
choanal atresia with a stentless folded-over-flap technique. Otolaryn- balloon dilation: our experience. Acta Otorhinolaryngologica Italica
gol Head Neck Surg 135:693–698, 2006. doi:10.1016/j.otohns.2006. 40:44–49, 2020. doi:10.14639/0392- 100X- 1567.
05.009.