You are on page 1of 18

CHAPTER 1

Introduction to Sport Organizations


and Governance

Governing bodies are an important part structure, which in turn is impacted by the
of the sport industry. Any given governing marketplace.
body is structured in a way to achieve its From the beginning, humankind has
stated mission within the environment in sought ways to make decisions for the group.
which it works. There is inherent challenge That is, it looks for better ways to govern in
in this process because the governing body order to resolve disputes, control disruptive
must maintain a level of consistency and behaviors, and achieve goals that advance
stability over time as well as be responsive the welfare of group and society as a whole.
to changes in the marketplace. Knowledge In this sense, sport governing bodies exist
about how a governing body is organized to make group decisions within a particular
will help the sport manager understand why segment of the sport industry. When ana-
the governing body operates in a particular lyzing governance systems, the sport man-
manner and why some bodies are more ef- ager can study a governing body from two
fective than others. perspectives. From the micro approach, a
Organizational theory is an area of governing body is itself an organization
study that seeks to understand the struc- and is set up in a particular way to achieve
ture and design of organizations. Schol- goals. For instance, the internal workings of
ars analyze the “patterns” and “regularities” the Boys and Girls Clubs of America “home
that emerge in order to better understand office” can be analyzed. From the macro ap-
both their causes and consequences (Slack proach, the governing body may be thought
& Parent, 2006). The process of organiz- of as the tip of the iceberg. The governing
ing is essentially the same for all types of body oversees all the individual organiza-
organizations. Once the mission and goals tions within its jurisdiction. In this case,
have been formulated, sport managers how the home office interacts with all the
must develop a systematic plan to bring community Boys and Girls clubs can be
together the necessary human and physical studied. The aim of this chapter is to in-
resources (Montana & Charnov, 2000). To troduce the sport industry and outline the
a large extent, a sport governing body’s abil- component parts of a sport organization.
ity to govern effectively is determined by its Next, an overview of how governing bod-
4 SPORT GOVERNANCE AND POLICY DEVELOPMENT

ies acquire legal authority and jurisdiction dustry”. Similarly, a “sport industry” exists
is presented. Finally, governance is defined that can be divided into a multitude of seg-
and contrasted with management and lead- ments: youth sport, interscholastic sport,
ership in sport management. intercollegiate sport, Olympic sport, pro-
fessional sport, sport manufacturing, sport
retailing, sport consulting, sport marketing,
Learning Objectives sport merchandising, facility management,
and others. Each segment is composed of
Upon completion of this chapter, the a variety of individual organizations. For
reader should be able to: instance, consider participation in a single
sport, such as track and field. There are a
• Describe the sport industry. number of organizations to provide gov-
• Define key terms, including organiza- ernance and input, including high schools,
tion, organizing, organizational con- state high school athletic and activity asso-
text, organizational design, organiza- ciations, multisport (i.e., AAU), and single
tional structure, organizational chart, sport (i.e., USATF) governing bodies, col-
organizational behavior, and organiza- legiate athletic associations, collegiate re-
tional culture. cruiting services, sporting goods manufac-
• List and explain the structural elements turers and retailers, and sport media outlets
of organizational design, including (i.e., Track & Field News) to name only a
complexity, formalization, centraliza- few. Now, include all kinds of sports and all
tion, specialization, standardization, types of sport products and services across
departmentalization, and size. the various segments, and you can see the
• Explain the relationship between mis- expansive nature of the sport industry.
sion, strategy, and structure. Though difficult to measure, scholars
• Discuss how governing bodies acquire agree the sport industry is growing at an
legal authority and jurisdiction. exponential rate. Within the United States
• Define governance and explain the alone, the gross national sport product is
component parts of good governance. projected to increase from $157 billion in
• Distinguish between governance, man- 2005 to $236 billion by 2015. This tremen-
agement, and leadership in sport orga- dous growth is attributed to increased dis-
nizations. cretionary income, heightened awareness of
• Discuss why management is needed in the relationship between an active lifestyle
an organization. and good health, and a greater number of
• Describe the differences between lead- opportunities for all to participate in sport.
ers and managers. Some scholars have argued sport is an in-
• Discuss the various types of leaders and tegral part of the entertainment industry.
outline the various types of leadership Whether sport is a freestanding industry
theories. or segment of the entertainment industry,
it continues to expand as a global multibil-
lion-dollar industry.
What is the Sport Industry?

An industry is any grouping of busi- What is an Organization?


nesses that share a common method of
generating revenue such as the “automobile An organization is the entity that allows
industry”, “cattle industry”, or “fashion in- for a group of two or more people to work
Introduction to Sport Organizations and Governance 5

together more effectively than they might structural elements in a governing body
work alone in order to achieve goals. A (i.e., complexity, formalization, etc.). The
governing body is an organization with five preferred design will depend largely on the
essential elements: social identity, involve- stated mission as well as the organizational
ment in sport industry, goal-directed focus, context. The organizational structure refers
consciously structured activity system, and to how jobs are broken down and assigned
identifiable boundaries (Slack & Parent, to members, communication and report-
2006). In other words, a governing body is a ing relationships among individuals, and
discernable entity apart from its individual the coordination and control mechanisms
members that is set up in a way to achieve used within the governing body. According
identified goals within a specific jurisdic- to Miller (1987), organizational structure
tion in the sport industry. The third section is important to study because it “influences
of this book will describe the governance the flow of interaction and the context and
system of various sport organizations (see nature of human interactions. It channels
Figure 1.1) and discusses present challenges collaboration, specific modes of coordina-
and those that may be faced in the future. tion, allocated power and responsibility,
Fundamentally, organizing involves an- and prescribes levels of formality and com-
alyzing, identifying, and defining the work plexity” (p. 7). In other words, the organiza-
to be performed. If this process is done tional structure shapes how sport managers
properly, it will result in some logical order- interact with one another, how decisions are
ing of work and a manner for individuals made and tasks completed, and whether the
to cooperate efficiently and effectively to atmosphere feels casual and friendly or for-
achieve objectives (Montana & Charnov, mal and reserved.
2000). When thinking about organizing in The visual representation of how a
relation to governing bodies, a sport man- governing body is structured is referred to
ager should consider several factors. Unity as the organization chart (see Figure 1.2).
of purpose is an agreement about the work The organization chart may reflect many
to be performed. Division of labor entails aspects, such as the levels of management,
how tasks are partitioned and what author- supervisory relationships, major subunits,
ity will be given to responsible individuals. division of work, and communication chan-
Staffing requires decisions about the type, nels (Montana & Charnov, 2000). It should
number, and experience of individuals who be noted the formal chart might not accu-
will complete the work. Finally, organiza- rately reflect the important relationships
tional framework is the structure that will that exist in governing bodies. In fact, these
allow for effective cooperation among in- “informal” relationships may significantly
dividuals (e.g., chain of command, flow of influence what and how tasks are performed
information, etc.). to achieve stated goals.
The organizational context refers to
the “setting which influences the (govern- Organizational behavior and
ing body’s) structural dimensions” (Daft, organizational culture
2003, p. 17). Determinants, also known in Daft (2007) defines organizational be-
the literature as contingencies or impera- havior as the study of how individuals and
tives, which influence the organizational small groups function within the organiza-
structure, include age, size, strategy, tech- tion and the characteristics of the environ-
nology, and sociopolitical and economic ment in which people work. Researchers
factors found in the external environment. who study organizational behavior are con-
Organizational design is the pattern of cerned with such issues as leadership traits
6 SPORT GOVERNANCE AND POLICY DEVELOPMENT

Sports Industry

Amateur Sports Professional Sports Sport Services


Youth Sports National Basketball Association Athletic Foundations

Basketball Women’s National Basketball Arena and Stadium


Association Operators
Baseball
Continental Basketball Cable Sports
Bowling
Association Network Sports
Cheerleading
United States Basketball League Race Tracks - Auto and
Field Hockey Trucks
Major League Baseball
Football Race Tracks - Horses
Minor League Baseball
Golf Race Tracks - Greyhounds
National Hockey League
Gymnastics Sport Agency/Player/Coach
National Football League -
LaCrosse European Representations
Soccer Arena Football League Sport Media
Softball Major League Soccer Sport Sponsorship
Agencies
Swimming Major Indoor Soccer League
Sport Event Agencies
Wrestling National Hot Rod Association
Sport Marketing Agencies
Interscholastic Sports Motor Sports:
Sport Facility Management
High School Associations NASCAR
Sport Commissions
Intercollegiate Sports IRL
Sport Fundraisers
Collegiate Conferences F1
Sport Museums
United States Olympic NSRA
Committee Sport Libraries
Track and Field
National Governing Bodies for Sport Hall of Fame
Beach Volleyball
Olympic Sports Sport Architects
Bench Tennis
Special Olympics Sports Facility Development
Golf:
Paralympics Consultants
PGA
Senior Olympics Sports Facility Concessions
LPGA and Food
State Games
Tennis: Sports Ticket Services
Military Sports
APT
Recreational Sports
WTA
Campus Recreation
Professional Bowling
Community Recreation
Association
Professional Figure Skating
Professional Rodeo

Figure 1.1
Categories of Sport Organizations
Introduction to Sport Organizations and Governance 7

Member State
Associations
General
Committee
National Council Appeal

Board of All Related


Directors Subcommittees

Executive Director NIAAA


Certified Athletic
Administrators
Support Staff Program

17 Sports Rules
and Activity General
Special Publications Educational
Committees Committeees
Mtgs/Events Ct/Fld Diagram Services
Baseball Annual Mtg
Debate Topic Forensic Quart. NFHS Coach Ed
Basketball AD Advisory
HOF Induction HS Sports Reebk Citizenship Curr
Field Hockey Citizenship
Legal Mtg IAA Magazine Rules Exams/Int
Football Equity
Nat. HS Act. Wk Line-Doug Debate Rules Posters
Gymnastics HOF Screening
Conf. AD NFHS Annual Rpt Sports Trans/PP
Ice Hockey National Records
NFHS Sum Mtg NFHS Brochure Sportsmanship
Lacrosse G/B NFHS Coach Ed
NFHS Win Mtg NFHS Coaches Q Materials
Music Sports Med Adv
NFHS Summit NFHS Handbook
Soccer Prof. Dev. NFHS New
Softball Conferences NFHS Official Q Professional
Speech Special
State Music Conf NFHS State Manual Organizations
Spirit Committees
Stud. Leadership NFHS Catalog NFCA
Swimming/Diving Hall of Fame
Rules Pub 17 Sports NFMA
Track and Field Selection
Speech/Debate Bks NFOA
Volleyball Videos Sports Med Handbk NFSA
Water Polo Misc. Videos NFSDA
Wrestling Staff Committee
Music Videos
Sports Rules
Speech/Deb Vid Rules Exams
Review
Sports Videos Resource Ctr Legal
Interpreters Mtg Rules/Question Resource Nat. Iss
Citizenship Pro
Ath Sanctions
Other Sevices
Advertising Particip. Survey
Off. Equip. Ctr.
NFHS Website Rules Interp Mtg
Cor. Partner Pro.
Rules Interpret Teleconf. Critical
Auth. Mark Pro

Figure 1.2
National Federation of State High School Associations (NFHS)
8 SPORT GOVERNANCE AND POLICY DEVELOPMENT

and styles, team building, job satisfaction, talized. Vertical differentiation refers to the
communication, and motivation. In the number of levels in the organization and
sport management literature, scholars have is represented by the “hierarchy of author-
focused primarily on topics such as leader- ity.” A tall structure is characterized by (a)
ship traits and approaches, level of job sat- greater levels of hierarchy and (b) relatively
isfaction, and workplace motivations (Slack narrow span of control. Conversely, a flat
& Parent, 2006). structure is characterized by (a) fewer levels
Organizational culture refers to the of hierarchy and (b) relatively wide span of
shared philosophies, values, beliefs, and control. Spatial differentiation may be verti-
behavior patterns that form the organiza- cal or horizontal. Vertical spatial differen-
tion’s core identity. As people interact with tiation occurs when different levels of the
the governing body, they become familiar organization are dispersed geographically.
with the “manifestations” of the organiza- Horizontal spatial differentiation is when
tional culture. These manifestations may the different functions (or departments) of
include the organization’s formal rules and the organization take place in different loca-
practices, dress norms, and co-worker sto- tions (Slack & Parent, 2006).
ries as well as the informal codes of behav- As differentiation increases in an orga-
ior, rituals, reward and promotion system, nization, so does the complexity. In other
tasks, pay system, jargon, and jokes under- words, complexity increases when an orga-
stood only by insiders. Sport managers, by nization has many departments, multiple
their actions and non-actions, send signals levels of authority, and physical separation
about what they value. Regardless of what between members. Poor communication,
may be written in an organization’s formal coordination, and supervision are a few of
documents, how individuals behave in the the problems organizations face when they
workplace is a candid representation of the become too complex.
organizational culture. Formalization is a means to control the
amount of discretion individuals or groups
Structural elements of have when performing job functions (Slack
organizational design & Parent, 2006). Written documents, such
Organizational design refers to how as job descriptions, codes of conduct, and
structural elements are arranged to create policies and procedure manuals, direct and
the governing body. There are several struc- control staff member behavior (Daft, 2003).
tural elements to be considered, including These documents complement the organi-
complexity, formalization, centralization, zational chart by describing the tasks, re-
specialization, standardization, departmen- sponsibilities, and decision authority within
talization, and size. No two governing bod- a governing body. It should be mentioned,
ies are exactly the same, because the orga- however, that formalization may not be the
nizational design reflects the organization’s same across all hierarchical levels or depart-
mission and environment. ments with an organization.
Complexity is the extent to which a Centralization is concerned with who
sport organization is horizontally, verti- makes decisions and at what level. Mitzberg
cally, or spatially (geographically) differen- (1979) writes, “When all power for decision
tiated. Sport organizations are horizontally making rests at a single point in the orga-
differentiated when work is broken down nization—ultimately in the hands of a sin-
into narrowly defined tasks, when profes- gle individual—we shall call the structure
sionals or trained specialists are employed, centralized; to the extent that the power is
and when the organization is departmen- dispersed among many individuals we shall
Introduction to Sport Organizations and Governance 9

call the structure decentralized” (p. 181). cialized knowledge about product or servic-
Generally speaking, in a centralized govern- es); (c) market (i.e., specialized knowledge
ing body, decisions are made by a relatively about clientele; (d) division (i.e., organiza-
small number of people at the top of the hi- tional outputs such as product or service for
erarchy. In a decentralized governing body, single customer); (e) customer (i.e., targets
decisions are made by a greater number of for organizational outputs); (f ) geographic
people at lower levels in the organization. area or territories (i.e., physical location);
Work specialization is the extent to and (g) matrix (i.e., multiple approaches to
which jobs are divided into separate activi- emphasize cross-functional teams).
ties. Another term for this is division of la- Size is another important factor in-
bor. For example, the production of one pair fluencing the structure of an organization.
of Nike shoes involves 34 operations and There are a number of possible ways to mea-
approximately 170 workers. Some authors sure size: total assets, market share, number
have argued that division of labor maxi- of clients, number of employees, number
mizes productivity by increasing workers’ of members, and net profits. While schol-
skills, saving time lost when changing tasks, ars debate the impact size has on structure,
and by creating laborsaving inventions and the majority of studies recognize the two
machinery (Daft, 2003). concepts are related. As Daft (2003) writes,
One of the primary methods governing “The overall size of an organization has
bodies use to coordinate interdependent been shown in many research surveys to be
tasks is standardization. As sport organi- closely associated with the type of structure
zations have become more complex, new adopted” (p. 10).
oversight systems that specify roles, plan While not technically a structural ele-
work, and monitor activities have been in- ment of organizational design, an impor-
troduced. Specifically, standardization re- tant aspect of organizational structure is
fers to the extent to which work activities the distinction between line departments
in different areas are performed in a uni- and staff departments. A line department
form manner and the extent to which such performs activities most closely associated
uniformities are documented. Uniformity with the organization’s mission or purpose.
may be analyzed in terms of technical pro- In a sport goods company, the line depart-
cedures, administrative procedures, work- ment makes and sells the product. Staff de-
place arrangements, equipment and tools, partments include those departments that
among others. provide specialized skills to support line
Another fundamental characteristic of departments. These departments have an
organizational structure is departmentaliza- advisory or auxiliary relationship with line
tion. The goal of departmentalization is to departments. For example, ordinarily facil-
group people into manageable work units to ity maintenance is considered a staff func-
achieve their objectives in the most efficient tion in a sport goods manufacturing compa-
and effective manner possible (Montana & ny. The organization is not in the business
Charnov, 2000). This process involves plac- of providing maintenance. However, in an
ing individual positions within departments arena or stadium, facility maintenance is a
as well as locating entire departments with- critical operation. Poor maintenance may
in the overall organization (Daft, 2003). result in a decrease in attendance; thus, it is
According to the management litera- considered a line department function.
ture, departments may be coordinated based
on (a) function (i.e., similar skills, expertise,
and resources used); (b) product (i.e., spe-
10 SPORT GOVERNANCE AND POLICY DEVELOPMENT

Structure follows strategy to complete specific job tasks (Drucker,


As previously mentioned, no two gov- 1999). These analyses occur within the con-
erning bodies are exactly the same because text of the larger environment. The general
the organizational design reflects the or- environment includes the legal, political,
ganization’s mission and environment. To technological, economic, and social context
state this in a slightly different way, mission that affect all organizations. The task envi-
defines strategy and strategy defines struc- ronment includes external factors such as
ture within a particular environment. Every customers, competitors, and suppliers that
organization has a set of assumptions about interact directly with a specific organiza-
its business type, products, and services of- tion. The internal environment includes
fered to customers. It also has a declaration internal factors such as mission statement,
of intent, which is the mission statement, to policies and procedures, and personnel over
guide its method of operation. For example, which the organization has a large degree of
NASCAR aims to organize and promote control.
stock car racing on an international level.
Strategy converts the theory of business
into performance. Thus, NASCAR has a Legal Authority and
strategic plan that outlines how it will con- Jurisdiction
duct all business operations during the next
three to five years to accomplish the mission. There are many different types of orga-
In order for the organization to achieve its nizations that combine to create the sport
strategy in an unpredictable environment, industry. Businesses that provide sport
it must be structured in an appropriate way. products and services may be classified as
Therefore, within the NASCAR organiza- being in the public, private (for-profit), and
tion, different departments, such as mar- nonprofit sectors. These businesses take dif-
keting and promotion, media relations, and ferent legal forms: sole proprietorship, part-
technology and development, are set up to be nership, and corporation. Typically, govern-
responsible for aspects of the strategic plan. ing bodies are a corporation. A corporation
This specialization allows NASCAR to re- is any business entity recognized as distinct
spond to changes in the environment. Since from the people who own it (i.e., not a sole
strategy is dynamic, changing in response to proprietorship or partnership). To be classi-
marketplace, it may require the sport agency fied as a corporation, a business must be in-
be “reorganized” from time to time so that its corporated according to the laws of a partic-
structure supports the new strategy. ular state, province or national government.
Decisions about structure come from This includes filing the requisite documents
an analysis of activities, decisions, and re- (e.g., articles of incorporation) and paying a
lations. Activities analysis considers what fee. In some cases, these businesses are called
work has to be performed, what kinds of associations, organizations, or limited liabil-
work belong together, and the emphasis ity companies. Business law (i.e., taxation,
each task should be given within the overall rights, restrictions, etc.) varies from state to
organization. Decisions analysis determines state; therefore, the prospective corporation
what decisions are needed to obtain the de- will file documents in a state whose laws are
sired performance to achieve goals and at most favorable to its business interests. Once
what level in the organization the decisions registered, the corporation has artificial “per-
should be made. Relations analysis reviews sonhood” until such time as the corporation
with whom individuals in an organization is dissolved. Hence, the corporation may ex-
must work and the nature of contribution ist beyond the lifetime of any of its agents.
Introduction to Sport Organizations and Governance 11

Corporations can be either for-profit erning documents (available at www.ncaa.


companies or nonprofit entities. In for- org) specifies its authority and jurisdiction
profit companies the “owners” are called as well as membership requirements, sanc-
stockholders or shareholders. In nonprofit tioning, and appeals processes.
entities, the owners are called members. Typically, the board delegates, either
Revenue generated that exceeds operating formally or informally, decision-making
expenses is distributed to shareholders in authority to elected officers to operate the
a for-profit corporation. For instance, the corporation on a day-to-day basis (Colley,
NFL and its teams, such as the Indianapo- Doyle, Logan, & Stettinius, 2003). The
lis Colts, are registered as for-profit corpo- number of officers, also known as senior
rations. This revenue is reinvested in the or- management, depends on the organiza-
ganization in a nonprofit corporation. For tion and may include chief executive officer
example, Boys and Girls Clubs of America (CEO), chief financial officer (CFO), presi-
and its local chapters are registered as not- dent, vice-presidents, secretary, and others.
for-profit entities. Tax exempt nonprofit For example, Myles Brand is the president
businesses are often called a “501(c)3 cor- of the NCAA. Interestingly, there is a fine
porations” in reference to the section of the line between the board delegating enough
IRS Code that outlines tax exemptions. It and too much decision-making authority to
may be of interest to know that the U.S. senior management. When senior manage-
Congress is reviewing the NCAA’s non- ment develops agendas, collects informa-
profit status given the revenue the govern- tion, and prepares background information
ing body generates and how it is distributed without significant guidance from or refer-
to member institutions. ence to the board, there is a shift in control.
The board of directors (sometimes The board may become a “rubber stamp”
called executive committee or management for decisions made elsewhere, or the board
council) is responsible for governing the af- might fight back by blocking decisions put
fairs of a corporation. The board’s power forth by senior management (Friedman &
is derived from the shareholders (or mem- Phillips, 2004). In any event, the board is
bers) they represent and is articulated in the the legitimate “leader” in the corporation
corporation’s governing documents: articles and must retain its ability to make decisions
of incorporation, constitution and bylaws, to guide the organization.
and shareholder (member) agreements. The
articles of incorporation specify the nature
of the corporation, such as the corporate What is Governance?
name, purpose, registered office, authorized
capitol, duration, and board of directors. Governance refers to how governing
Constitution and bylaws govern the routine bodies are directed and controlled. The
internal affairs of the corporation (e.g., core governance mechanism (e.g., formal docu-
principles and values, committee structure, ments, organizational structure) specifies
meeting procedure, financial operations, how rights, authority, and responsibility are
etc.). Stakeholder (member) agreements distributed among the participants in order
can very depending on the history, size, and to monitor performance and achieve goals.
type of business the corporation seeks to The test of effective governance is the de-
operate. For instance, NCAA Division I gree to which any organization is achieving
institutions (members) elect the executive its stated purpose.
committee (board). As the governing body On a larger scale, governance describes
of intercollegiate athletics, the NCAA’s gov- methods a governing body uses to ensure its
12 SPORT GOVERNANCE AND POLICY DEVELOPMENT

constituents follow established protocol. impede the work of governance as much as


At the macro level, there is a loosely cou- it works to promote it. The challenge is to
pled organizational structure that oversees design a governance structure capable of
and maintains accountability. For instance, a proactive approach to determining mis-
the International Olympic Committee sion, strategy, and policy and be responsive
oversees international sport federations to the external and internal environment
(e.g., International Association of Athlet- as well as the needs and aspirations of
ics Federations), national sport governing members (Friedman & Phillips, 2004).
bodies (e.g., USA Track & Field), national
Olympic committees (e.g., United States What is good governance?
Olympic Committee), and local Olym- Good governance has eight character-
pic organizing committees (e.g., Chicago istics: participatory, responsive, equitable
2016). A proper governance strategy im- and inclusive, and consensus oriented. It is
plements a system to monitor and record also transparent, accountable, effective and
what is happening within the governing efficient, and follows the rule of law (UN-
body’s jurisdiction, take steps to ensure ESCAP, 2006). To facilitate participation,
compliance with established policies and either direct or through legitimate repre-
procedures, and provides corrective action sentatives, members need to be informed
in the event rules have been misconstrued and organized. Further, the governing body
or ignored. must be responsive, that is, to serve all mem-
There is a dichotomy between a gov- bers within a reasonable timeframe. To be
erning body’s role as an advocate within equitable and inclusive, members must feel
the sport industry and its requirement to they have a stake in the governing body and
regulate members (Friedman & Phillips, have the opportunity to maintain, if not
2004). In other words, the governing body improve, their status. Since there are many
must make decisions to promote sport, viewpoints on how sport should be oper-
but in order to promote sport, the govern- ated, mediation is needed to reach consen-
ing body must make decisions about what sus on what is “good” for the sport and how
members can and cannot do. For example, it might be achieved.
Major League Baseball wants players to Good governance also requires efficien-
hit home runs. This is good for baseball cy and effectiveness. This means processes
because the result, among other things, is must be developed to produce results that
increased attendance, media coverage, and meet member needs in a way that makes
merchandise sales. As such, Major League good use of human and physical resources.
Baseball allows cities to build ballparks When information is freely available and
with varying dimensions (within certain accessible to affected members, then the
limits) to make it easier for ballplayers to governing body is said to be transparent.
hit home runs. Similarly, Major League Following the rule of law involves applying
Baseball does not allow ballplayers to use rules in an impartial manner during deci-
performance-enhancing substances to sion making and enforcement. In general,
increase home run production. Thus, to a governing body is accountable to those
advocate for a sport in the industry, gov- affected by its decisions or actions. Ac-
erning bodies must regulate its members’ countability cannot be enforced without
behavior. transparency and rule of law.
There is no perfect organizational
structure associated with good gover-
nance. In fact, organizational structure can
Introduction to Sport Organizations and Governance 13

Governance and Management: plish tasks. Leading (directing) comes in


What’s the Difference? the form of guidance and support. Since
the marketplace is constantly changing, the
A governing body is an organization board must be prepared to provide input or
designed to achieve a specific mission. Gov- change strategy when needed. Controlling is
ernance is the means to coordinate and the means to ensure planned performance is
control the organization’s actions and re- achieved. The authority and jurisdiction to
sources. Management involves translating perform these functions come from the for-
the system of governance into performance. mal documents.
Both governance and management involve Management involves converting the
four functions: planning, organizing, lead- system of governance into day-to-day op-
ing (or directing), and controlling (POLC) erations. Senior management, working with
human and physical resources to achieve or- the board, develops an operational plan to
ganizational objectives. This is the same re- achieve the identified mission and goals
gardless of the type of industry, level within within a specified time period. Using the or-
the industry, or sort of organization. ganizational structure, senior management
Management scholars (Mosley, Pietri, organizes by delegating specific responsibil-
& Megginson, 1996; Rodenz, 2006; Wil- ity and authority to staff members to carry
liams, 2007) have defined the four manage- out operations. Leading is the ability to
rial functions as follows: influence others to work toward achieving
Planning is the management function personal and professional goals. Controlling
of choosing an organization’s mission and is the documentation system to ensure tasks
objectives and then determining the courses are completed according to policy in a time-
of action needed to achieve them. ly fashion. The authority and jurisdiction
Organizing is the management func- to perform these functions comes from the
tion of determining resources and activi- board. In small organizations, the board and
ties required to achieve the organization’s senior management are one and the same.
objectives, combining these into a formal In this case, senior management determines
structure, assigning responsibility for them, the governance system as well as the system
and delegating authority to carry out as- to translate this into day-to-day operations.
signments.
Leading (sometimes called directing)
is the management function of influencing Management—Why is it
employees to accomplish objectives, which Needed by Organizations?
involves the leader’s qualities, styles, and
power as well as the leadership activities of There are three key reasons why or-
communication, motivation, and discipline. ganizations need management: to estab-
Controlling is the management function lish objectives, to maintain balance among
of devising ways of ensuring that planned stakeholders, and to achieve efficiency and
performance is actually achieved. effectiveness. The initial task for manage-
In governance, the board of directors ment is to develop objectives for the organi-
plan by outlining the mission statement and zation. The objectives become the organiza-
goals and a strategic plan to achieve them. tional energy currency. Once the objectives
The board organizes by structuring the or- are established, the organization’s human,
ganization to implement a specific strategy financial, and physical resources attempt to
and delegating the authority and responsi- accomplish them. Generally, top manage-
bility senior management needs to accom- ment establishes overall objectives for such
14 SPORT GOVERNANCE AND POLICY DEVELOPMENT

areas as profitability, market share, growth, Leadership


or new product development. Lower-level
objectives are commonly determined by all Attila the Hun, Napoleon, Marshall,
of the employees. Eisenhower, Patton, and Rommel believed
In working to achieve objectives, man- that, under the right circumstances, every
agers need to maintain balance among the soldier in his army had the potential to be
conflicting objectives of the stakeholders. a general and lead the army in his absence.
The stakeholders are all those having a stake Whether you hold that belief or not, the
in the organization’s success, including em- plain fact is that “natural” leaders do not just
ployees, owners, customers, government happen, nor does anyone have a divine right
authorities, and creditors. Management to lead or rule.
holds in trust and must balance the interest You do indeed have a marshal’s baton
of many different groups including commu- in your own knapsack. Recognizing your
nity leaders, creditors, customers, employ- leadership potential is the first step toward
ees, government needs and demands, public leading others. The second is being able to
(consumer groups, environmentalists, and manage yourself before trying to manage
civil rights advocates) stockholders, suppli- others. Finally, a third, as noted by Bennis
ers, trade associations, and union leaders. (1989), is self-expression, and the key to
Further, management performs the self-expression is understanding one’s self
function of stewardship on behalf of the and the world, and the key to understand-
owners who are seeking a satisfactory re- ing is learning—from one’s own life and ex-
turn on investment (ROI). The ROI may perience.
be profits (as in a business) or service (as in Bennis based his bestseller On Becom-
local, state, or federal governments). Finally, ing a Leader (1994) on the assumption that
management must also consider the inter- leaders are people who are able to express
ests of its employees who seek good pay, themselves fully. “ . . . they know who they
safe and comfortable working conditions, are, what their strengths and weaknesses
fair and equitable treatment, the greatest are, and how to fully deploy their strengths
possible job security, and more time off. and compensate for their weaknesses.” Fur-
The last reason for management is ther, “ . . . they know what they want, why
achieving effectiveness and efficiency. The they want it, and how to communicate what
concept of effectiveness relates to the ability they want to others, in order to gain their
of management to set and achieve proper cooperation and support” (p. 37).
objectives. The other side of the manage- Finally, Norman Lear’s success was
ment performance coin is efficiency. Effi- based on four very simple yet complex steps:
ciency is management’s ability to get things (a) becoming self-expressive, (b) listening to
done, achieving higher outputs relative to the inner voice, (c) learning from the right
inputs. In the case of managing a sport re- mentors, and (d) giving oneself over to a
tail store, this would include such resources guiding vision (Bennis, 1994).
as employees, food, and time. The store
manager, who achieves the same sales vol-
ume with another store, while having only Leadership and the Facility
15 percent of the payroll and inventory and Event Manager
costs, would be considered more efficient in
using resources. Leadership has been defined by many
and many continue to redefine it. For the
purposes of this chapter, leadership will be
Introduction to Sport Organizations and Governance 15

defined as a set of qualities that causes peo- have enough confidence in yourself to ac-
ple to follow. Leadership requires at least cept responsibility for failure?
two parties; a leader and a follower. Many One of the realities about placing the
experts have argued over what exactly needs of others above your own is that you
causes a group to follow one person and not cannot blame other people. If you are the
another, but the decision to follow a leader type of person who looks outward for an
seems to come down to few common traits excuse instead of inward for a reason, you
(See Table 1.1). will have a hard time earning the trust of
Leaders have the ability to inspire peo- others. An absence of trust makes eliciting
ple to go beyond what they think they are their cooperation more difficult, which,
capable of doing, making it possible for a in turn, makes it more difficult for you to
group to attain a goal that was previously lead, even if you have been given the title
thought unattainable. Leaders carry their of leader.
followers along by (a) inspiring their trust, On the other hand, the leader receives
(b) acting consistently, and (c) motivating most of the accolades and rewards when
them by words and deeds. things go well. No matter how hard your
Leadership boils down to a willing- followers worked, no matter how modest
ness to accept responsibility, and the ability you are, no matter how much you attempt
to develop three skills that can be acquired to deflect credit to your entire team, yours
through practice—elicit the cooperation of is the name that people will remember.
others, listen well, and place the needs of oth- That is the great benefit of being the leader.
ers above your own needs. When you prop- Can you handle the limelight of success?
erly put these skills together, people begin to
turn to you when they need direction. The Basic Ingredients of Leadership
Leaders come in every size, shape, and
Responsibility and Accountability disposition. Yet they share some of the fol-
Leadership begins with the willingness lowing ingredients (Bennis, 1994):
to embrace responsibility. You cannot be a
leader if you are afraid of responsibility and • guiding vision,
accountability. With responsibility comes • passion,
the concept of accountability. If you cannot • integrity (i.e., self-knowledge, candor,
answer yes to the following question, you and maturity),
are not ready to become a leader. Do you • trust (i.e., constancy, congruity, reliabil-
ity, and integrity),
Table 1.1 • curiosity, and
Ten Characteristics of a True Leader • daring.

The following are the 10 characteristics of Key Leadership Abilities


a true leader: The trick to becoming a leader is to be
• eager
• cheerful
able to elicit cooperation, to listen to the
• honest needs of others, and to put other people’s
• resourceful needs ahead of your own with great con-
• persuasive sistency. After you decide that you can and
• cooperative
• altruistic
want to embrace responsibility, leadership
• courageous requires that you be able to do three things
• supportive very well (also see Table 1.2):
• assertive
16 SPORT GOVERNANCE AND POLICY DEVELOPMENT

• Elicit the cooperation of others. You to you—stretch, don’t strain and be re-
must be able to get others to buy into alistic about expectations),
your vision of the future and the right • leaders have what I think of as the
way to get there. Gretzky Factor (a certain “touch”),
• Listen well. You have to be able to gath- • leaders see the long view,
er many kinds of information from oth- • leaders understand stakeholder sym-
ers in order to lead; doing so requires metry, and
that you hone your listening skills. The • leaders create strategic alliances and
old adage, “listen and hear before you partnerships.
speak,” is very important when dealing
with people. Building Leadership Tools
• Place the needs of others above your John F. Kennedy once said, “Leadership
own needs. Leadership requires that and learning are indispensable to each oth-
you be willing to sacrifice for a greater er.” Learning about the job, the employees,
good. and yourself is very important to a leader
and his/her leadership ability. There are a
Characteristics of Leaders Coping number of leadership traits that need to be
with Change developed by the leader. The remainder of
There are 10 characteristics for coping this section will discuss these traits:
with change and creating learning organiza-
tions (Bennis, 1994): • Learning to use what you have. Intel-
ligence is critical to leadership because
• leaders manage the dream, synthesizing information is often nec-
• leaders embrace error, essary in order to create a vision.
• leaders encourage reflective backtalk, • Responding to situations flexibly. Gath-
• leaders encourage dissent, ering new information and adjusting a
• leaders possess the Nobel Factor (opti- response to a particular situation re-
mism, faith, and hope), quires intelligence. Instead of respond-
• leaders understand the Pygmalion ef- ing in a knee-jerk way, an intelligent
fect in management (if you expect great person responds flexibly based on cir-
things, your colleagues will give them cumstances and needs.
• Taking advantage of fortuitous circum-
stances. You not only have to be smart
enough to adapt to new information
Table 1.2 with flexibility, but you also have to
Ten Ways to Master Leadership Skills
have the courage to seize opportunities
The following are the ten ways to master
when they present themselves.
leadership skills: • Making sense of ambiguous or contra-
• prepare dictory messages. A good leader listens
• volunteer to all the information and then sorts
• keep an open mind
through it. You test contradictory mes-
• give speeches
• develop discipline sages by asking for more information
• meet deadlines in order to find the truth.
• stay in touch • Ranking the importance of different el-
• listen ements.
• cooperate
• do things for others • Finding similarities in apparently dif-
ferent situations. One of the normal
Introduction to Sport Organizations and Governance 17

characteristics of intelligence is a tal- Manager Leader


ent for analogies. Analogous intelli- ↓ ↓
gence in leaders is the ability to draw
Administers Innovates
on prior experience, no matter how Copy Original
tenuous the connection is, to find a Maintains Develops
similarity that you can use to solve a Focuses on systems Focuses on
problem. & structure people
Short-range view Long-range
• Drawing distinctions between seem- perspective
ingly similar situations. You can find Relies on control Inspires trust
differences among situations just as Asks how and when Asks what and why
often as you can find similarities and a Eye always on the Eye on the horizon
bottom line
good leader learns to recognize when Imitates Originates
A is not like B and emphasize the dif- Accepts status quo Challenges status
ferences over what the two have in quo
common. Classic good soldier His own person
Does things right Does the right thing
• Putting concepts together in new Wear square hats Wear sombreros
ways. Along with analogies, one of the Learn through Learn through
components of intelligence is the abil- training education
ity to synthesize new knowledge by Deductive Inductive
Firm Tentative
putting together time-tested concepts
Static Dynamic
in new ways. Memorizing Understanding
• Coming up with novel ideas. Facts Ideas
Narrow Broad
Surface Deep
Direction Initiative
Leadership versus Left brain Whole brain
Management Common sense Imagination
Rules Risk
Leadership is based on a person’s Rigid Flexible
Reactive Active
ability to influence others to work to-
ward achieving personal and organiza-
tional goals. Leadership is often defined
Types of Leaders
as a process of influencing individual
and group activities toward goal setting
A leader has to work effectively with
and achievement. However, manage-
many people including superiors, peers,
ment involves much more. While leader-
subordinates, and outside groups. However,
ship is a part of management, manage-
the qualities of leadership are seen especially
ment also includes performing the other
in a manger’s relationship with subordinates
functions—planning, organizing, and
(Mosley, Megginsen, & Pietri, 2005).
controlling. Keep in mind that effective
Leaders are often classified by their ap-
managers must be effective leaders and
proach (i.e., autocratic, democratic or partic-
the successful leader is one who succeeds
ipative, or laissez-faire) or their orientation
in getting others to follow.
toward getting the job done (i.e., task- or
A leader is not a manager and a man-
production-oriented or people-oriented or
ager is not a leader. There are enormous
employee-centered). These approaches have
differences between leaders and managers
been defined by a variety of scholars (Mos-
including:
ley et al., 1996; Mosley et al., 2005; Rodenz,
2006; Williams, 2007) as follows:
18 SPORT GOVERNANCE AND POLICY DEVELOPMENT

Autocratic leaders are often called au- exercise self-direction and self-control to
thoritarian leaders who make most deci- achieve company objectives.
sions themselves instead of allowing their Theory Z is a theory of leadership that
followers to participate in making them. emphasizes long-range planning, consensus
They are also characterized as “pushers” or decision making, and strong mutual work-
“drill instructors.” er-employer loyalty.
Democratic or participative leaders Leadership grid® is a leadership model
involve their followers in groups who are that focuses on task (production) and em-
heavily involved in the decision process. ployee (people) orientations of managers as
Laissez-faire leaders are often called well as combinations of concerns between
free-rein leaders who are “loose” or permis- the two extremes.
sive and let followers do what they wish. Contingency-situational theories are
Task-oriented or production-oriented leadership theories (i.e., Tannenbaum and
leaders focus on getting the job done. They Schmidt’s leadership continuum, and Hersey
emphasize planning, scheduling, and pro- and Blanchard’s life-cycle theory) prescrib-
cessing work and they exercise close control ing that the style to be used is contingent on
such factors as the situation, the people, the
of quality.
tasks, the organization, and other environ-
People-oriented or employee-centered mental variables.
leaders focus on the welfare and feelings of Leadership continuum is a range of
followers, have confidence in themselves, behavior associated with leadership styles
and have a strong need to develop and em- from democratic to authoritarian.
power their team members. Life-cycle theory is a theory that the
leader’s style should reflect the maturity
level of employees and that draws heavily on
Leadership Theories previous leadership research.
Servant-leaders are leaders who serve
There are six key leadership theories the people he leads, which implies that they
that all future managers need to be aware are an end in themselves rather than a means
to an organizational purpose or bottom line.
of as they develop their leadership skills.
The servant leader devotes him-/herself to
These theories are behavioral, contingency- serving the needs of organization mem-
situational, servant-leaders, traitist, transac- bers, focuses on meeting the needs of those
tional leaders, and transformational leaders. they lead, develops employees to bring out
These theories are defined below: the best in them, coaches others and en-
Behavioral theories are a group of theo- courages their self-expression, facilitates
ries of leadership that emphasize favorable personal growth in all who work with them,
treatment of employees rather than their and listens and builds a sense of commu-
output or performance. The leading theo- nity. Servant leaders are felt to be effective
ries in this area are McGregor’s theory X because the needs of followers are so looked
and Y, Ouchi’s theory Z, Likert’s four man- after that they reach their full potential and
agement systems, and Blake and Mouton’s hence perform at their best.
Traitist theories are theories of leader-
management grid.
ship that claim leaders possess certain traits
Theory X suggests that workers dislike or characteristics (i.e., supervisory ability,
work and must be coerced, controlled, and need for occupational achievement, intelli-
directed in order to achieve company objec- gence, decisiveness, self-assurance, and ini-
tives. tiative) that cause them to rise above their
Theory Y indicates that workers accept followers.
work as natural, seek responsibility, and will
Introduction to Sport Organizations and Governance 19

Transactional leaders are leaders who include complexity, formalization, central-


identify desired performance standards, ization, specialization, standardization,
recognize what types of rewards employees departmentalization, and size. Governing
want, and take actions that make receiving bodies acquire legal authority and jurisdic-
these rewards contingent upon achieving tion through its governing documents.
performance standards. Management involves four functions:
Transformational leaders are leaders planning, organizing, leading, and control-
who provide charismatic leadership, indi- ling. Management is important because it
vidualized consideration, and intellectual establishes objectives for the organization,
stimulation. maintains a balance among stockholders,
and achieves efficiency and effectiveness
within the organization. Managers imple-
Summary ment the plans and leaders develop and sell
the plans. There are three generally accept-
Sport is a global, rapidly growing in- ed approaches to leadership—autocratic,
dustry. The sport industry is composed of democratic or participative, or laissez-faire.
organizations that are involved in sport. A Some would say there is a fourth approach
large number of different types of organi- known as orientation toward complet-
zations make up the sport industry, includ- ing a task—task- or production-oriented,
ing amateur sports, professional sports, or people-oriented or employee centered.
sporting goods manufacturers, sport goods There are six key leadership theories that
retailers, public assembly facilities, sport all managers need to understand including
management consultants, sport agencies, behavioral theories (i.e., theory X, theory
etc. Whether it is a freestanding industry Y, theory Z, and leadership grid), contin-
or segment of the entertainment industry, gency-situational theories (i.e., leadership
sport is a multibillion-dollar business. continuum and life-cycle theory), servant-
Governing bodies are an important part leaders, traitist theories, transactional lead-
of the sport industry. Any given governing ers, and transformational leaders.
body is structured in a way to achieve its
stated mission within the environment in References
which it works. The aim of this chapter was
to introduce the sport industry and outline Colley, J. L., Doyle, J. L., Logan, G. W., & Stettinius,
W. (2003). Corporate governance. New York:
the component parts of a sport organiza-
McGraw-Hill.
tion. An organization is when two or more Daft, R. L. (2003). Management (6th ed.). Cincinnati,
people interact to achieve a common goal. OH: South-Western.
Every organization is impacted by the gen- Daft, R. L. (2007). Organizational theory and design
eral, task, and internal environments. Orga- (9th ed.). Cincinnati, OH: South-Western.
Drucker, P. F. (1999). Management challenges for
nization behavior is the study of individuals the 21st century. New York: HarperCollins
and small groups within the organization Publishers.
and the characteristics of the environment Friedman, A., & Phillips, M. (2004). Balancing
in which the people work. Organizational strategy and accountability: A model for
the governance of professional associations.
culture refers to the shared philosophies, Nonprofit Management and Leadership, 15(2),
values, beliefs, and behavior patterns that 187-204.
form the organization’s core identity. Orga- Miller, G. A. (1987). Meta-analysis and the culture
nizational theory is the study of the design of free hypothesis. Organization Studies, 4, 309-
325.
and structure of organizations. The struc- Mitzberg, H. (1979). The structuring of organizations.
tural elements of organizational design Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
20 SPORT GOVERNANCE AND POLICY DEVELOPMENT

Montana, P. J., & Charnov, B. H. (2000). Management Slack, T., & Parent, M. M. (2006). Understanding sport
(3rd ed.). Hauppauge, NY: Barron’s Educational organizations: The application of organization
Series. theory (2nd ed.). Champaign, IL: Human
Mosley, D. C., Megginson, L. C., & Pietri, P. H. Kinetics.
(2005). Supervisory management: The art of United Nationals Economic and Social Commission
inspiring, empowering, and developing (6th ed.). for Asia and the Pacific. (2006). What is good
Cincinnati, OH: South-Western. governance? Retrieved September 1, 2006, from
Mosley, D. C., Pietri, P. H., & Megginson, L. C. http://www.unescap.org/pdd/prs projectactivities
(1996). Management: Leadership in action (5th /ongoing/gg/governance.asp
ed.). New York: HarperCollins Publishers. Williams, C. (2007). Management (4th ed.).
Rodenz, E. (2006). Management fundamentals. Cincinnati, OH: South-Western
Cincinnati, OH: South-Western.

NOTES

You might also like