ENGLISHதமிழ்বাংলাമലയാളംગુજરાતીहिंदीमराठीBUSINESSबिज़नेस Newsletters

Sections

Wednesday, Sep 27, 2023

EPAPER TODAY’S PAPER
JOURNALISM OF COURAGE

Home Cities India Explained Opinion Entertainment Sports Politics Lifestyle Tech Education Investigations Research Videos Audio

Mini Latest Join WhatsApp Asian Premium UPSC Express et Health

TRENDING
Crosswords News Channel Games Stories Special al. Specials
ADVERTISEMENT

NewsExplainedExplained LawBefore women's quota in Parliament and state Assemblies, the issue of delimitation:
What is it, why is it needed
Premium

Also read in: தமிழ்

Before women’s quota in Parliament

and state Assemblies, the issue of
delimitation: What is it, why is it
needed
It might be several years before reservation for women becomes applicable — mainly
because it has been made contingent on the delimitation exercise. What is delimitation,
and how does it work?

Written by Amitabh Sinha , Damini Nath +1 More

New Delhi | Updated: September 22, 2023 11:41 IST

Follow Us
The Bill was presented by Union Law Minister Arjun Ram Meghwal in Lok Sabha. (PTI)

Listen to this article

Before women’s quota in Parliament and state Assemblies, the issue of delimitation: What is it,
why is it needed
x

00:00
1x 1.5x 1.8x
The Nari Shakti Vandan Adhiniyam — The Constitution (One Hundred and Twenty-Eighth
Amendment) Bill, 2023, which provides for 33% reservation for women in Lok Sabha and state
Assemblies — was passed by Lok Sabha on Wednesday, and will likely be cleared by Rajya Sabha
as well in Parliament’s ongoing Special Session.

However, it might be several years before the reservation becomes applicable — mainly because it
has been made contingent on the delimitation exercise. Home Minister Amit Shah told Lok
Sabha that the “delimitation process” to decide which constituency is to be reserved for women will
be “transparent”, and will be carried out by a delimitation commission.

What does the women’s reservation Bill say about the implementation of the quota?

The Bill says the provisions of the new law shall come into effect “after an exercise of
delimitation” undertaken “after the relevant figures for the first Census” carried out “after the
commencement” of this law is “published”.

In other words, the implementation of the reservation provision is not immediate, and is contingent
on two processes — a delimitation exercise, and a Census. Delimitation is the process of redrawing
Parliamentary and Assembly constituencies based on the latest population data.

Under the provisions of the Bill, the 2021 Census — whenever it is actually carried out — will
become the basis for the delimitation exercise that would result in an increase, and redefining of
boundaries, of Parliamentary and Assembly constituencies.

Of these increased numbers of Parliamentary and Assembly constituencies, 33% would be reserved
for women, whenever the next elections are due.

Since the 2024 elections are now only months away, the 2029 election is the earliest that women’s
reservation could take effect in Lok Sabha — provided the Census is carried out and its findings are
published, and the delimitation exercise is completed before that.

ADVERTISEMENT
Why is delimitation needed, and how is it carried out?

The boundaries of Lok Sabha and Assembly constituencies must be redrawn to ensure equitable
representation — so that the vote of every person carries similar weight.

Lok Sabha constituencies have to be allotted to every state in a manner that the ratio of the number
of constituencies and the population of the state is broadly similar. A similar approach is adopted
for state Assemblies as well.

Explained | A look at women representation in parliaments of 10 democracies

As populations change, there is a need to readjust the number and boundaries of the constituencies.

ADVERTISEMENT
Need for delimitation :
Apart from population figures, delimitation also aims at a fair division of geographical areas into
seats to guard against allegations of gerrymandering, which means redrawing seat boundaries in a
way that no political party has an unfair advantage over another.

It is a constitutional requirement to carry out delimitation of constituencies after every Census.

Article 82 of the Constitution (“Readjustment after each census”) mandates the “readjustment” in
the allocation of seats to every state in Lok Sabha, and the division of every state into
constituencies “upon completion of each Census”.

Articles 81, 170, 330, and 332, which deal with the composition and reservation of seats in Lok
Sabha and state Assemblies, also refer to this “readjustment”.

The delimitation exercise is conducted by an independent delimitation commission. Its decisions

are considered final, unchallengeable in any court, to prevent indefinite delays in elections.

When was the last delimitation exercise carried out?

While the Census has been carried out seven times since Independence, delimitation has happened
only four times — in 1952, 1963, 1973, and 2002. The last delimitation exercise, in 2002, only
involved itself with redrawing the boundaries of constituencies. It did not result in the increase in
the number of constituencies. This means that the number of Lok Sabha constituencies has not
changed since 1976.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Constitution has been amended suitably — the 42nd Amendment Act in 1976, 84th
Amendment Act in 2001, and 87th Amendment Act in 2003 — to allow for deviations from the
original provisions.

As per the current provisions in the Constitution, the next delimitation exercise should take place
on the basis of the first Census carried out after 2026, that is 25 years after the 84th Amendment. In
normal course, this would have meant that delimitation would happen after the 2031 Census.
However, the Census of 2021 could not be carried out due to the Covid-19 pandemic.

ADVERTISEMENT

If the house-listing exercise, the first phase of the Census, is carried out next year, the actual
population enumeration can take place in 2025. The publication of the first results usually takes at
least one or two years. This means that delimitation need not wait for the 2031 Census, it can
happen on the basis of the delayed 2021 Census as well.

If everything progresses smoothly, and swiftly, the 2029 general elections could be held with an
increased number of Lok Sabha seats.

ADVERTISEMENT
What makes delimitation a political hot potato?

Delimitation results in a change in the total number of Parliamentary and Assembly seats. The
delimitation following the 1951 Census increased Lok Sabha seats from 489 to 494, which further
increased to 522 after the 1961 Census, and finally to 543 after the 1971 Census.

In the 1970s, the impending delimitation exercise based on the 1971 Census sparked concerns. The
Constitution mandates that states receive seats based on a population ratio, which unintentionally
implied that states (mostly in North India) with lower population control efforts may claim a larger
share of Lok Sabha seats. And the southern states that promoted family planning faced the
possibility of having their seats reduced.

In Opinion | Christophe Jaffrelot, Kalaiyarasan A write: Why delimitation could deepen

India’s North-South faultline

The impact of delimitation on inter-state seat distribution is a strong reason for political tussles and
controversies.

Is that why the strength of Lok Sabha has remained frozen at 543 since the 1970s?

Yes. In 1976, to address political concerns, Indira Gandhi’s government brought the 42nd
Amendment. This Bill suspended the redrawing of seat boundaries and seat allocation until 2001,
and justified it as part of the effort to promote family planning.

MOST READ

Watch this Space: Chandrayaan-3 sleeps as US Space Force punches a hole in atmosphere
1
India vs Australia, 3rd ODI Highlights: Glenn Maxwell’s takes 4 as visitors beat Rohit Sharma’s
2 men by 66 runs to avoid clean sweep

See More

The freeze on the number of seats in Parliament and Assemblies was extended in 2001 by the
NDA-I government under Atal Bihari Vajpayee through the Constitution (Ninety-First Amendment)
Bill, 2000, which was enacted as the Constitution (Eighty-Fourth Amendment) Act, 2002.

The “Statement of Objects and Reasons” for the Amendment brought by the Vajpayee government
read: “There have been consistent demands, both for and against undertaking the exercise of fresh
delimitation. In consideration of the progress of family planning programs in different parts of the
country, the Government, as part of the National Population Policy strategy, recently decided to
extend the current freeze on undertaking fresh delimitation until the year 2026 as a motivational
measure to enable the State Governments to pursue the population stabilization agenda.”

ALSO READ
 Humans of Bombay Age of consent Debate over anti- Delhi HC protects
vs People of India: increased from 13 to smoking ads on OTT Anil Kapoor’s
What is copyright 16 years in Japan: platforms: How personality rights:
infringement and w... Here's why Indian films and TV What they are, how
sa... ha...

The year 2026 was chosen because, according to the National Population Policy, that was when the
government expected population growth to level off. In other words, the assumption was that if
population policies worked as planned, by 2026, there should be a roughly equal number of births
and deaths in India.

© The Indian Express (P) Ltd

First published on: 21-09-2023 at 07:07 IST